I just replied to a question in the development thread where an N4 user, running stock 4.3 suddenly lost connectivity to his 5ghz router band, nothing changed on his phone but suddenly he loses connectivity to 5ghz band?
Of course this is a well known issue, impacting hundreds of users globally since the 4.3 update, and it got me thinking that just maybe the actual code written for the Wi-Fi radio drivers in 4.3 was overly aggressive in terms of the capabilities of the radio hardware in the N4 and actually physically damaged the hardware? Code can break hardware, we all know of devices that have been permanently bricked and became coasters - all because of bad code or a flash that went wrong.
What if the radio code written in 4.3 was to maximize signal strength to remedy the complaints of poor/slow Wi-Fi on many 4.2 devices, but was too aggressive for the radio hardware in our N4's causing it to basically overload and physically die? I've read of people who had no issues with their 5ghz channel (like me) then after updating to 4.3 completely lost 5ghz connectivity, and even after downgrading to factory 4.2 stock firmware STILL had no 5ghz connectivity. In my case after downgrading to 4.2 i still had no connectivity to both of my dual band Netgear routers, nor any other 5ghz band router I tried, complete 5ghz failure - downgrading to the same 4.2 firmware that had worked flawlessly before updating to 4.3! If it was just software then downgrading to the previous 4.2 firmware should have instantly resolved the 5ghz connectivity, right? If it worked without issue before then it should work without issue again. Except for many it simply remained broken, so it stands to reason that something else changed - i.e. the physical hardware was damaged.
Maybe that's why Google quietly shot out 4 different versions of 4.3 in an attempt to hide the fact that the radio code was too aggressive for some phones hardware? They perhaps toned down the radio code's aggressive push of the hardware, which might explain why some people don't have the issue, but it was already too late for phones with lower hardware tolerances and the damage was permanent.
I'm getting a replacement device from Google tomorrow and if the 5ghz band works out of the box on the stock 4.3 firmware, I'm highly likely to immediately downgrade to 4.2 stock as I have a strong feeling that its just a matterof time before i once again lose 5ghz connectivity just like the person i mentioned at the beginning of this post.
I suspect Kit Kat to use the same drivers as 4.3 so I'm staying clear of new builds until V5.0.
Of course if people regain 5ghz connectivity on Kit Kat I will stand corrected, but I'm willing to bet they don't - if functionality that worked fine on 4.2 can't be recovered by downgrading from 4.3, it's almost certainly damaged radio hardware, and no new versions can fix that.
Scary but probably unlikely I'm sure google knows the hardware limits of the devices and tests before it releases it. I mean google is generally try to play it safe then sorry like how high they set the CPU voltages.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
THEBANDIT420 said:
Scary but probably unlikely I'm sure google knows the hardware limits of the devices and tests before it releases it. I mean google is generally try to play it safe then sorry like how high they set the CPU voltages.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Google releases their ROM's for numerous phone manufacturers, remember that ICS was the first android version that was cross compatible across all phones and tablets, the idea that it was easy to mass implement.
Consider the price of the N4 - $250 for 16gb model, about 40% of the price of a Samsung GS4! And the old saying that you get what you pay for. Junky screen compared to the SGS4 and other top price phones. Crap audio hardware compared to the fantastic sound chips Samsung uses. And most likely many other corners were cut to be able to release a 'flagship' device for less than half the price of the next major Android competitor (SGS4). It's straight forward economics, you get what you pay for. And I don't think Google realized that the tolerance levels of the N4's radio hardware were as low as I think they actually are, which is why they have been unable to resolve the issue in 4 quickly released 4.3 builds! I think they knew that the first release boosted signal strength in most other phones but didn't expect it to actually exceed the tolerances of lower end components that had to be used in the N4 which packs in all the top features of a high end phone at half the price!
I would never buy an LG flat screen TV, I'd always buy the Samsung simply because it's better quality in every way. I'm not sure why my brain didn't tell me this when I bought the N4. It was too good to be true at less than $250 for the latest Android phone? I think it was too good to be true!!
Let's watch Kit Kat roll out and watch these forums fill with p!seed people who still don't have reliable connectivity, and never will because their phone is physically broken.
Again, the acid test is to downgrade to say 4.1.2 and see if your 5ghz band works and your 2.4ghz speed flies, because it did when the phone was released back in December 2012 when it ran 4.1.1 or 4.1.2. I'm betting it won't work like it did and you still can't connect with the speed and reliability you once had. And if you can't get 5ghz connectivity on 4.3 you won't ever get it again because the hardware is cooked.
Globespy said:
Too long to quote.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Globespy said:
to long to quote
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't buy lg TVs yet you bought a phone made by lg......
You bought the n4 but yet to YOU the s4 is WAY superior to it.....
Then I guess you know what you need to do then.....
Smh
Sent from my Nexus 4 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Highly doubtful that the radio firmware is causing hardware failure. As for your example usually a phone bricks because something went wrong with the flash or an incorrect file was flashed and the file system is no longer accessible hence a black screen with no boot... or worse.. the the hardware its self isn't actually damaged.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
---------- Post added at 02:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:49 PM ----------
PJcastaldo said:
Highly doubtful that the radio firmware is causing hardware failure. As for your example usually a phone bricks because something went wrong with the flash or an incorrect file was flashed and the file system is no longer accessible hence a black screen with no boot... or worse.. the the hardware its self isn't actually damaged.
And I think and still think the N4 is a great device. Its fast looks nice. I personally think the screen looks nice.. and takes great pictures. So... maybe you should go buy a Samsung...
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
Globespy said:
[A lot of text]
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A few things.
1. It seems you fail to grasp the purpose of the Nexus program.
2. I doubt Google would release software that damaged the hardware on the latest Nexus phone. That's kind of the point of the Nexus line; development. Not only for independent developers, but also internal Google ones. If this scenario were true, it definitely wouldn't be the Nexus phone that got broken, it would be a different one.
3. Assuming that the Nexus 4 is of lower quality than the GS4 since it is half the price, citing "simple economics" as a reason is just plain ignorant. There is a lot at play here, the two devices aren't in the same situation. Samsung is trying to make money off of the hardware so they mark it up. Google is just trying to showcase Android and offer an affordable top-end phone, so they don't mark up the price. Plus, they make their money off of their services.
4. Head over to this thread and start flashing different radios. I'll bet you 3,000 Internet Dollars that one of those radios fixes your WiFi issues.
Zenety said:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So childish. I bought the N4 for thethe same reason most others did - it was sold as a flagship product for what was literally a 'steal'. I haven't had this many issues with a phone since I ditched windows and moved to Android when eclair came out. But I suppose this makes me a Mac fanboy now? Lol.
I actually have never owned a Mac - PC guy.
Johmama said:
A few things.
1. It seems you fail to grasp the purpose of the Nexus program.
2. I doubt Google would release software that damaged the hardware on the latest Nexus phone. That's kind of the point of the Nexus line; development. Not only for independent developers, but also internal Google ones. If this scenario were true, it definitely wouldn't be thethe Nexus phone that got broken, it would be a different one.
3. Assuming that the Nexus 4 is of lower quality than the GS4 since it is half the price, citing "simple economics" as a reason is just plain ignorant. There is a lot at play here, the two devices aren't in the same situation. Samsung is trying to make money off of the hardware so they mark it up. Google is just trying to showcase Android and offer an affordable top-end phone, so they don't mark up the price. Plus, they make their money off of their services.
4. Head over to this thread and start flashing different radios. I'll bet you 3,000 Internet Dollars that one of those radios fixes your WiFi issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This thread was started because of an idea, based on a problem that I've struggled with as well as friends who ate all nexus guys.
It was not to bash LG or Google - I've been around on this forum a LONG time and have bought many nexus phones and tablets, and have enjoyed them!
The last Gnex was not priced at the level the N4 released at, yet at that time Android phones had been selling as much as iPhone, I believe around that time worldwide sales surpassed them for the first time. I understand that Google has a different business model focused on selling software (actually their main business is advertising) and want to market their products at a lower price point than hardware manufacturers like HTC, Samsung etc. But when you do this you still cut corners. I'm not alone here in saying that the screen and sound hardware used in the sgs4 is just better. There's no argument. I could have bought one but I'm a nexus guy and have been for a while. I bought a sgs4 for my Gf, she loves that TW nonsense. But maybe just maybe I have a point about hardware failure given that the majority can't resolve it even going back to software that worked before!
Anyway, your recommendation of flashing different kernels may work for a few, but from looking at the hundreds of posts on numerous different sites (most notably Google's N4 support forum), it's clear that the majority are still having issues, me included which is why I just ordered a replacement phone which success today.
You see, I actually like the device - with a few tweaks here and there it can be vastly improved. Screen gamma can be fixed, sound quality too with things like viper.
If a problem that didn't exist on a previous build still exists when going back to that exact build then you tell me why? Something else has changed.
Globespy said:
If a problem that didn't exist on a previous build still exists when going back to that exact build then you tell me why? Something else has changed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you say you go back to a previous version of Android, how do you do it? Do you have a flashable zip that you flash through recovery to return to the previous version, or do you grab the factory image from Google and run flash-all.bat?
Johmama said:
When you say you go back to a previous version of Android, how do you do it? Do you have a zip that you flash through recovery to return to the previous version, or do you grab the factory image from Google and run flash-all.bat?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried EVERYTHING, but with regard to stock images I use ADB to flash the factory firmware, which as you should know basically nukes the phone and whatever used to be on it is gone forever and what you have left is a pure stock phone just as you would receive from Google if you bought a new one (like the new one I'll get from Google in a few hours, running JWR66Y), except my 5ghz radio doesn't work on any 5ghz router (both my wndr3700 & R6300, nor my neighbors dlink, Asus or Linksys routers) regardless of whether it's 4.1.1, 4.1.2, 4.2.x or 4.3.
In case you are serious about your bet earlier, I'd like to have a few more bills for fun money, so here is my money ($3K in 100's) - you can see my N4 with this actual thread showing (it's taken with a $5K camera so just zoom in) so you know I actually put my money where my mouth is.
And I know for 100% that in the case of my phone you are wrong because I've tried to fix this for over 3 months using every available option
So if you have time to sit on Skype today and you can walk me through the things you think will fix the 5ghz connectivity issues (kernels from faux, Franco, neo, semaphore, matrix and the list goes on), or maybe you think I haven't thought about build specific kernels like JSS, JWR or JLS?
I'm available all day my friend and as soon as you show me your cash then let's do it, but I can guarantee you will lose.
Heck, it's Friday so let's make it $5K (the extra bundle of $100 notes in the top of the pic) - I was thinking of new rims for my Porsche.
https://db.tt/dZz3Xpek
PS - I'm a 25 year veteran software developer for a prominent electronics firm - yeah I'm an old dude not a pot faced teen. I hope you have the chops to back up your words. And if you don't live in the US forget about it because I can't chase you down so easily when you don't pay up and vanish.
Globespy said:
I've tried EVERYTHING, but with regard to stock images I use ADB to flash the factory firmware, which as you should know basically nukes the phone and whatever used to be on it is gone forever and what you have left is a pure stock phone just as you would receive from Google if you bought a new one - except my 5ghz radio doesn't work on any 5ghz router (both my wndr3700 & R6300, nor my neighbors dlink, Asus or Linksys routers) regardless of whether it's 4.1.1, 4.1.2, 4.2.x or 4.3! The same one in getting in about 5 hours which I know will be JWR66Y.
In case you are serious about your bet earlier, I'd like to have a few more bills to for fun money, so here is my money ($3K in 100's) - you can see my N4 with this actual thread showing (it's taken with a $5K camera so just zoom in) so you know I actually put my money where my mouth is.
And I know for 100% that in the case of my phone you are wrong because I've tried to fix this for over 3 months using every available option
So if you have time to sit on Skype today and you can walk me through the things you think will fix the 5ghz connectivity issues (kernels from faux, Franco, neo, semaphore, matrix and the list goes on), or maybe you think I haven't thought about build specific kernels like JSS, JWR or JLS?
I'm available all day my friend and as soon as you show me your cash then let's do it, but I can guarantee you will lose.
Heck, it's Friday so let's make it $5K (the extra bundle of $100 notes in the top of the pic) - I was thinking of new rims for my Porsche.
https://db.tt/dZz3Xpek
PS - I'm a 25 year veteran software developer for a prominent electronics firm - yeah I'm an old dude not a pot faced teen. I hope you have the chops to back up your words. And if you don't live in the US forget about it because I can't chase you down so easily when you don't pay up and vanish.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, you're starting to get a little antagonistic here. I'm just trying to help you. In my previous post I was trying to ascertain whether or not you're flashing a new radio. When you flash back to an older version of Android, if you don't flash a new radio, it won't help your situation. So unless you run either
Code:
fastboot flash radio radio.img
or a script that has that in it, such as the flash-all.bat that comes with the factory image, you aren't really doing anything to fix your WiFi issues.
Head on over to the thread I posted previously, here, try flashing a few different radios, starting with the most recent, and see if that helps. In the same thread, someone else also had issues with 5Ghz WiFi which got fixed by flashing one of the hybrid radios. Check this post for the problem, this post for a link to the originally-posted hybrid radio that fixed that guy's problem. You don't necessarily need to use that hybrid radio, but it helped that poster; scroll down the page to read his post after he reported back.
It's not a hardware issue. I've had the same problem with certain hybrid radios like 33/84 as mentioned by the poster above. I switched to 33/54 and it started working okay. It's some software issue. It was very annoying but fixable with the right radio.
lazer155 said:
It's not a hardware issue. I've had the same problem with certain hybrid radios like 33/84 as mentioned by the poster above. I switched to 33/54 and it started working okay. It's some software issue. It was very annoying but fixable with the right radio.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I get that these methods have worked for some but not all.
Let's get real basic.
If my phone had zero 5ghz issues on say 4.2.2 (with .54 radio), and then lost 5ghz connectivity on 4.3, then I flashed a completely clean version of that previous Google factory 4.2.2 firmware (which includes the .54 radio) and my phone now shows that indeed that old radio was installed, yet i still can't get 5ghz connectivity, then its not software only. Something changed that's not software, otherwise it should work. The phone has been returned to exactly the same way it was before the 4.3 update, every shred of the 4.3 build nuked as if it never existed. Yet part of it is not functional that used to be fine? There aren't too many things it could be - software or hardware. The software didn't change, I know that is factual as its the very same Google factory stock firmware. So......?????
Johmama said:
Ok, you're starting to get a little antagonistic here. I'm just trying to help you. In my previous post I was trying to ascertain whether or not you're flashing a new radio. When you flash back to an older version of Android, if you don't flash a new radio, it won't help your situation. So unless you run either
Code:
fastboot flash radio radio.img
or a script that has that in it, such as the flash-all.bat that comes with the factory image, you aren't really doing anything to fix your WiFi issues.
Head on over to the thread I posted previously, here, try flashing a few different radios, starting with the most recent, and see if that helps. In the same thread, someone else also had issues with 5Ghz WiFi which got fixed by flashing one of the hybrid radios. Check this post for the problem, this post for a link to the originally-posted hybrid radio that fixed that guy's problem. You don't necessarily need to use that hybrid radio, but it helped that poster; scroll down the page to read his post after he reported back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
PM sent. I'm just playing with you mate. I just got tired of people on the other end of an internet connection making bets they can't or won't follow through on. I am no novice and have been around long enough to know that my issue is not fixable. Trust me I've tried everything and then some. After trying all the potential fixes, I also bought a new router (the r6300), and tried 3-5 other routers and same problem every time. That's when I threw in the towel and sent for a replacement.
But thanks for your suggestions. I still think in my case it's hardware as I've ruled out software.
So I just had a knock on the front door and have a new N4!
However, it came pre-installed with JDQ39 (4.2.2), and it connected no problem with both my routers.
Now I have a dilemma. Firstly, if this is indeed a new phone (packaging all looks like it has never been opened), then why wouldn't it come with 4.3 installed? It's been out for over 3 months. So chances are whilst it's a new phone, it was manufactured before June of this year.
I'm terrified to update it to 4.3 in case the same thing happens again and my 5ghz connection vanishes. And it seems that most people think that Kit Kat will use the same drivers as JB 4.3, so even if I wait until Kit Kat (hopefully later this month) I could end up with the same borked 5ghz band.
Maybe 4.2.2 is as good as it gets for this phone.......what to do what to do....
Globespy said:
So I just had a knock on the front door and have a new N4!
However, it came pre-installed with JDQ39 (4.2.2), and it connected no problem with both my routers.
Now I have a dilemma. Firstly, if this is indeed a new phone (packaging all looks like it has never been opened), then why wouldn't it come with 4.3 installed? It's been out for over 3 months. So chances are whilst it's a new phone, it was manufactured before June of this year.
I'm terrified to update it to 4.3 in case the same thing happens again and my 5ghz connection vanishes. And it seems that most people think that Kit Kat will use the same drivers as JB 4.3, so even if I wait until Kit Kat (hopefully later this month) I could end up with the same borked 5ghz band.
Maybe 4.2.2 is as good as it gets for this phone.......what to do what to do....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is weird that it came with 4.2.2, it's been quite some time since 4.3 came out.
Anyway, have you tried something like this? I know you said you tried a few different routers after upgrading to 4.3, but maybe you just needed to make your 5Ghz channel static. I don't know how true this is, but in that thread they said that the channel switching function isn't the greatest at detecting conflicts and switching over. Of course, even if that's true it could just be his router.
I'm sorry, I'm just having a tough time believing that it's a software issue that permanently removed 5Ghz WiFi capabilities on the hardware. I'm sure it's possible; I've seen stranger things. My gut just keeps telling me that it isn't the cause in this case. If you want to, maybe try manually flashing different radios through adb so you know nothing else is getting touched and see if one removes the 5Ghz capability; then flash back. Mainly the .84 that comes with 4.3. If not, I guess just stay on 4.2.2 until the issue is resolved. Maybe a new radio will come with KitKat that no-one will have an issue with.
Let's analyse;
first of all, I do not own the device. I have just sold my Note 2 and waiting for a good second hand Nexus 4 to show up in the local market. So I have no idea of this problem specifically. Just trying to help by looking into pieces.
- First, you should try to find anyone who used to lose 5GHz connection and than got it back. If there is a case then it is not related to hardware.
- Second you should be sure abour wiping every single code on your device. I don't know how thing are done in Nexus world but in Note 2, there is no certain ways of "deleting" every code. Maybe with a PIT file, not sure.
- I know that every chip or device or SoC manufacturer put their own non-software-controlled precautions to their "things". For example, you may choose to disable thermal throttiling of CPU by modifying a kernel but it will still cut the power once it reaches a pre-defined critical heat, regardless of the software. I am sure Wi-Fi antennas have this type of phsical/hardware protections.
- Besides; who would release a "voltage boosting software" without further testing it? (that could happen though, would not be the first time in the mobile devices' world)..
- What else, besides some un-down-gradeable driver or software, do you think, could possibly disable 5 GHz signal of antenna? Maybe it is about battery? I remember Nexus 4, first having USB OTG support but then removed both from advertisings and the sofware due to battery current limitin.. Maybe there is case like this?
- Any more investigable ideas?
Johmama said:
That is weird that it came with 4.2.2, it's been quite some time since 4.3 came out.
Anyway, have you tried something like this? I know you said you tried a few different routers after upgrading to 4.3, but maybe you just needed to make your 5Ghz channel static. I don't know how true this is, but in that thread they said that the channel switching function isn't the greatest at detecting conflicts and switching over. Of course, even if that's true it could just be his router.
I'm sorry, I'm just having a tough time believing that it's a software issue that permanently removed 5Ghz WiFi capabilities on the hardware. I'm sure it's possible; I've seen stranger things. My gut just keeps telling me that it isn't the cause in this case. If you want to, maybe try manually flashing different radios through adb so you know nothing else is getting touched and see if one removes the 5Ghz capability; then flash back. Mainly the .84 that comes with 4.3. If not, I guess just stay on 4.2.2 until the issue is resolved. Maybe a new radio will come with KitKat that no-one will have an issue with.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. Tried this with every channel on the 5ghz band, 2-digit and 3-digit channel.
_delice_doluca_ said:
Let's analyse;
first of all, I do not own the device. I have just sold my Note 2 and waiting for a good second hand Nexus 4 to show up in the local market. So I have no idea of this problem specifically. Just trying to help by looking into pieces.
- First, you should try to find anyone who used to lose 5GHz connection and than got it back. If there is a case then it is not related to hardware.
- Second you should be sure abour wiping every single code on your device. I don't know how thing are done in Nexus world but in Note 2, there is no certain ways of "deleting" every code. Maybe with a PIT file, not sure.
- I know that every chip or device or SoC manufacturer put their own non-software-controlled precautions to their "things". For example, you may choose to disable thermal throttiling of CPU by modifying a kernel but it will still cut the power once it reaches a pre-defined critical heat, regardless of the software. I am sure Wi-Fi antennas have this type of phsical/hardware protections.
- Besides; who would release a "voltage boosting software" without further testing it? (that could happen though, would not be the first time in the mobile devices' world)..
- What else, besides some un-down-gradeable driver or software, do you think, could possibly disable 5 GHz signal of antenna? Maybe it is about battery? I remember Nexus 4, first having USB OTG support but then removed both from advertisings and the sofware due to battery current limitin.. Maybe there is case like this?
- Any more investigable ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lots of great ideas. I've heard of only a few people who managed to get the 5ghz band back, although most still suffer from much slower speeds. If you run broad searches you will see that most people can't get it to work after they lose it, even downgrading the entire system to a build/radio that previously worked without issue - like me.
Using MrSkips toolkit it absolutely wipes any trace of the 4.3 ROM and any radio association, turning the phone back to how it was shipped (JDQ39). Yet still no luck. Not all hardware is created equally, just like certain CPU can overclock/undervolt the same amounts. Perhaps some radios have lower tolerances and die? It may sound strange, but not impossible.
I'm sticking with 4.2.2 until Kit Kat comes out and will wait a few weeks to see what happens. If people get 5ghz back then it's likely Google rewrote the radio code.
There have been some confusing discussions all over the internet from this forum to OnePlus' forum on what ROM and hardware variant is used where. The simple answer is that Oneplus uses different hardware for different regions and the ROM is not necessarily tied to the hardware. OnePlus is using hardware variants that will work best outside of it's designed region and putting a generic ROM over it.
To clear things up I've made a cheat sheet with the main specifications between and across all the variants. I understand that it may not be complete, but it should help a lot of people understand what they are getting with each variant. I've also attached a PDF for easy copying and pasting.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
mine is a NE2210 , but it came preloaded with NE2211 , the hardware is same and it has Oxygen OS , which is good .. but so from now onwards i will be following guides meant for NE2211\?
Dr-Hack said:
mine is a NE2210 , but it came preloaded with NE2211 , the hardware is same and it has Oxygen OS , which is good .. but so from now onwards i will be following guides meant for NE2211\?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd treat it as such, really the biggest difference is the OS. Technically all the phones are the exact same hardware (except for Ram and storage sizes) and you should be able to cross flash if a full factory rom is released.
omega552003 said:
I'd treat it as such, really the biggest difference is the OS. Technically all the phones are the exact same hardware (except for Ram and storage sizes) and you should be able to cross flash if a full factory rom is released.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is a fascinating and most helpful discussion - but I am CONFUSED. In your earlier post you wrote "The simple answer is that Oneplus uses different hardware for different regions and the ROM is not necessarily tied to the hardware." but now you say that all the phones are the exact same hardware? Which statement is correct?
Thanks for clearing up yet another confusion!
Does that mean that NE2210 has different physical hardware than NE2215, or is it just a software limitation? For e.g. if you flash NE2210 with NE2213 OOS rom the missing 4g/5g bands will not magically become enabled?
omega552003 said:
There have been some confusing discussions all over the internet from this forum to OnePlus' forum on what ROM and hardware variant is used where. The simple answer is that Oneplus uses different hardware for different regions and the ROM is not necessarily tied to the hardware. OnePlus is using hardware variants that will work best outside of it's designed region and putting a generic ROM over it.
To clear things up I've made a cheat sheet with the main specifications between and across all the variants. I understand that it may not be complete, but it should help a lot of people understand what they are getting with each variant. I've also attached a PDF for easy copying and pasting.
View attachment 5685035
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is such a useful document - thank you very much for this fine work! You must know these phones in great detail.
Can you please enlighten me... Is the OnePlus 10 Pro hardware the same for all versions, i.e. - if we flash an EU ROM onto the NE2210, will the phone have the same bands as an original NE2213 version? Will Android Auto work - even though it hasn't been preinstalled by the phone manufacturer? (This is the error message I get when I try to run Android Auto on the NE2210.)
ralphhayes said:
This is such a useful document - thank you very much for this fine work! You must know these phones in great detail.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use a NE2215 daily, but other than that I just looked it up on the internet.
ralphhayes said:
Can you please enlighten me... Is the OnePlus 10 Pro hardware the same for all versions, i.e. - if we flash an EU ROM onto the NE2210, will the phone have the same bands as an original NE2213 version? Will Android Auto work - even though it hasn't been preinstalled by the phone manufacturer? (This is the error message I get when I try to run Android Auto on the NE2210.)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think so due to the fact that people have said they have NE2213 ROM on an NE2210 phone. Also when I looked at the SIM slot of my NE2215 it has 2 sets of contacts even though it's sold as a single sim phone. Lastly I rooted my NE2215 phone by booting a rooted NE2213 boot.img.
Thank you for your comments. Fascinating comment, esp. about your discovery of the 2 sets of contacts!
I have never rooted or used Fastboot on a phone, but feel that I need to in this case. I got my NE2210 while in Europe (I upgraded from an 8T). Used it in various countries without real problems (except for phone and messaging apps - which I could not replace with the Google apps, and some Chinese bloatware, which I uninstalled or at least force-stopped). Next, I traveled to the U.S. That's when the problems began. The NE2210 would not connect to any Mobile Network (I am using Google Fi but also have an Asian SIM card - neither would connect.)
I love the camera and speed of the phone and even the Color O/S is fine.
I then realized that Android Auto does not work - "because it had not been pre-installed by the phone manufacturer."
Please let me ask you one more question: On the Internet, there are numerous instructions on how to flash the NE2113 ROM - have you seen step-by-step instructions that are complete and airtight (for a beginner)? I'll be happy to share my experiences once I have made them!
TY!
ralphhayes said:
Thank you for your comments. Fascinating comment, esp. about your discovery of the 2 sets of contacts!
I have never rooted or used Fastboot on a phone, but feel that I need to in this case. I got my NE2210 while in Europe (I upgraded from an 8T). Used it in various countries without real problems (except for phone and messaging apps - which I could not replace with the Google apps, and some Chinese bloatware, which I uninstalled or at least force-stopped). Next, I traveled to the U.S. That's when the problems began. The NE2210 would not connect to any Mobile Network (I am using Google Fi but also have an Asian SIM card - neither would connect.)
I love the camera and speed of the phone and even the Color O/S is fine.
I then realized that Android Auto does not work - "because it had not been pre-installed by the phone manufacturer."
Please let me ask you one more question: On the Internet, there are numerous instructions on how to flash the NE2113 ROM - have you seen step-by-step instructions that are complete and airtight (for a beginner)? I'll be happy to share my experiences once I have made them!
TY!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have an NE2210 that I bought off Amazon and when it came in, it was flashed with Oxygen OS NE2215 ROM. I'm currently using it with Google Fi and seems to work great in my area so you should be able to get yours to work stateside. The only thing I'm not certain of yet is if 5g band 71 is activated since it's on a NE2215 ROM or if that band will not work at all due to hardware limitations. Earlier posts in this thread seem to allude to that it does work because the hardware is the same, however I've seen other threads that indicate the US version definitely has different hardware. I can tell you that my phone has indicated 5g before but that may only be the 41 band. I'm going to install signal spy to try and confirm if I'm ever on band 71.
Edit: Oh, and my Android auto does work. However, the seller indicated that the ne2215 ROM was flashed by OnePlus themselves. Not sure if that's true or not.
RS7JR said:
I have an NE2210 that I bought off Amazon and when it came in, it was flashed with Oxygen OS NE2215 ROM. I'm currently using it with Google Fi and seems to work great in my area so you should be able to get yours to work stateside. The only thing I'm not certain of yet is if 5g band 71 is activated since it's on a NE2215 ROM or if that band will not work at all due to hardware limitations. Earlier posts in this thread seem to allude to that it does work because the hardware is the same, however I've seen other threads that indicate the US version definitely has different hardware. I can tell you that my phone has indicated 5g before but that may only be the 41 band. I'm going to install signal spy to try and confirm if I'm ever on band 71.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Am actually wondering this myself. I've seen a few posts of NE2215 devices getting better signal when cross flashed with NE2213 because 2213 has a few more 5G Bands enabled.. I would definitely be interested in this if cross flashing could open up more bands... if the hardware truly is the same.
RS7JR said:
The only thing I'm not certain of yet is if 5g band 71 is activated since it's on a NE2215 ROM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does, as T-Mobile uses B71 for NR 5G and the NE2215 is sold by them.
omega552003 said:
It does, as T-Mobile uses B71 for NR 5G and the NE2215 is sold by them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But my variant is actually a NE2210 (Chinese) which has NE2215 ROM flashed to it (supposedly from factory). Are you saying that you have proof the hardware is the same between the two and by simply flashing the NE2215 ROM on a NE2210 device will activate the use of 5g band 71?
so NE2213 supports tmobile volte and wifi calling?
Prant said:
Am actually wondering this myself. I've seen a few posts of NE2215 devices getting better signal when cross flashed with NE2213 because 2213 has a few more 5G Bands enabled.. I would definitely be interested in this if cross flashing could open up more bands... if the hardware truly is the same.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So update: Over the weekend, I've noticed my phone on 5g three different times. All three times I was on band 41. Still no luck at catching it on 71. The theory of flashing ROMs to activate bands isn't looking good so far but I'm going to keep trying.
daviddem said:
so NE2213 supports tmobile volte and wifi calling?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have both VoLTE and VoWiFi working on stock NE2215. I've heard NE2213 works just the same, but sometimes better due to having a couple extra 5G bands. But @RS7JR seems to be seeing something different with actual tests.
Prant said:
I have both VoLTE and VoWiFi working on stock NE2215. I've heard NE2213 works just the same, but sometimes better due to having a couple extra 5G bands. But @RS7JR seems to be seeing something different with actual tests.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think my tests prove that VoLTE and VoWifi don't work. I don't have t-mobile but I do have Google Fi and my WiFi calling does work which I'm pretty sure is the same as t mobile VoWifi. Not sure about VoLTE though. The only thing my tests have proven so far is that flashing ROMs from other variants doesn't unlock the use of more frequency bands in the radio. And in my particular case, specifically 5g band 71. Keep in mind, I've only had 3 opportunities to test it so take my info with a grain of salt. I'll still be doing more testing for the next couple weeks.
I just got NE2213 in the US on Tmobile and volte, wifi calling and all bands are working
daviddem said:
I just got NE2213 in the US on Tmobile and volte, wifi calling and all bands are working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is there any chance for you to try out any other carriers, Verizon or MVNOs like visible/us mobile?
jllll said:
Is there any chance for you to try out any other carriers, Verizon or MVNOs like visible/us mobile?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sorry i only have tmobile
From what I can tell, 5G is not working in Canada. I believe that, in order for 5G to work, the device has to be certified for use on Canadian carriers' 5G service, and that doesn't seem to be the case for the OnePlus 10 Pro. Otherwise, everything else seems to work perfectly. However, it's also my understanding that 5G connectivity did work on the OnePlus 9 (also the OnePlus8???), so not having it work on the OnePlus 10 Pro is very confusing. Personally, I don't care if I can't access 5G. It has no "REAL" benefit for me, so I can live with it. I'm just curious as to why the OP10P is blocked from 5G access.