Related
I decided to go and pay for SMS Commander because I like the concept of the application and that we will have free updates. Well the latest update for SMS Commander allows it to work with "Addons." And the addon it is referring to is now an application called SMSC Record, that will only work if you have SMS Commander first. SMSC Record is simply 2 new commands added to the system that allows it to record sound from the phone remotely. Which would be fine if it was simply just an optional download, but if you want it you have to pay another $1.00. It seems like this should just have been included in the SMS Commander update and this whole addon idea seems like just another way for the developer to make more money off his popular app and sly around the free update system.
Am I wrong for being mad about this? If he's going to make you pay more money for each new option to the program doesn't that just defeat the update system.
All depends on how many add-ons he has and if any of the updates come with free new features. Think of it as upgrading from xp to vista Microsoft makes you pay more money for more (or less ) features with the new OS
sms commander
well if developers are gonna be updating there apps with addons and charging 99 cents for every single update/addon then here i said it i will be downloading the cracked app or wait for another developer to say you know what ima make this app for free so he dont get a dime anymore example wifi awake app theirs 3 new apps that are free with the intention of the charge app not to get any money so hopefully someone will come up with a sms commander app soon for free or atleast the updates for free/addons.
Nice to hear people encourage developers to put a lot of time in developing useful applications for just 1$...
sigh...
If you don't like it, don't buy it... if you think a dollar is too much then i wonder how you make a living.
Most of my work is open-source and done in my own time ( after my daily work as a c# developer ) and most of the time it keeps me busy till late in the night. Luckily there are still people supporting my open-source work and randomly donating some money instead of going crazy about one dollar...
rogro82 said:
If you don't like it, don't buy it... if you think a dollar is too much then i wonder how you make a living.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you.
I think you guys are missing the point of his post. He is not complaining that the ass-on is a dollar but that he has to pay for an add-on to an app that he already purchased for $2.99 or whatever SMS Commander costs.
It's an issue of Microtransactions that I do not agree with at all. Charging your customers nockles and dimes for minor updates doesn't seem like much but it can snowball into developers intentionally leaving out content of an app to charge you for it later when they need or want mor money, which is what this SMS Commander situation looks like.
Yes, and that's where the public votes with it's wallet. A dev who uses this tactic, right or wrong, will be told by the buyers (and more importantly, non-buyers) that this process is unacceptable. If he can't sell his app using his current model, he'll have to work on another model, or cede the app's functionality to some other dev who will do the customers a better job.
The original poster asked if s/he was wrong being mad. I think so. This is part of the beauty of a somewhat-free Market.
I'm a huge fan of this app... I had the free trial which was buggy and not very good compared to the new version. I decided to go ahead and buy it when paid apps were released because I figured it must be quite an improvement if he was charging money for it. Although the UI stayed very similar, the additional commands are awesome! At first, I was also confused about the add-ons but after I decided to download SMSC Record, I actually really liked it. It could be its own app. I talked to the developer and he actually has plans to release many more free updates; he just thought that SMSC Record warranted charging an extra dollar and I have to say he's probably right.
The dev also told me that he already has these updates ready; however, he's going to wait until google works out its bugs on downloading updates before people get frustrated by not being able to download updates(the initial reason why I contacted him).
I'm going to have to agree with those who say that if you don't want the add-on, then don't buy it...you'll have your chance to get more free updates for this app for sure.
u cry for a buck? how much ur G1 cost you? x_x
he's not crying for a buck hes crying for being charged for an add ons/updates imagine getting charged for updates that gives your apps new features.. i don't think it is right either but i'm not complaining
Works great!
Press and hold each profile to change settings
It's on the market
Locale also does this . its on the market too
I find locale works really well especially when using location within the situation aswell. Class app!
Don't Update "Power Manager" !
I understand how hard is it for a developer to make a decent application. I remember the hours (coding and debuging) I've spent on some crappy school projects in C++. However, that dosen't permit the dev to deceive us. The dev of Power Manager has add few features to the latest update and when you download it, you'll realize that your copy becomes a trial and it'll work for 3 days
Shame on you !
yeah, i almost install but whew. i still have it with no trial. if you want it. message me.
these days i backup all apps before updating just in case- did it with this but read the comments first anyway...so anyway i didn't update it either.....its not like i can buy the paid app anyway!! Does he realise that those of us not in USA can't buy it and are then shut out of using his app until such time as google decides to allow us to purchase apps!!!
When I install new Apps I always do "cp -r app app2" in sd-directory.
I even can't buy paid apps, because I dont see them and I also dont support it.
Someone should place a rapidshare link of the free .apk-version at the market comments to protect users from such embarrassment.
MacFloid said:
When I install new Apps I always do "cp -r app app2" in sd-directory.
I even can't buy paid apps, because I dont see them and I also dont support it.
Someone should place a rapidshare link of the free .apk-version at the market comments to protect users from such embarrassment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I still need to learn all these commands and locations.
I'm assuming that cp -r app app2 means that you're copying the app folder to a folder named app2? Isn't "app" in the phone's memory?
are you kidding?
because the software WAS free to use, doesn't mean you, or anybody else but the autor owns it. You don't have the right to distribute it. If an app costs money or not doesn't change the rights to the software. distributing apps that used to be free is not allowed, because it is not public domain, just because it is free.
I am embarrased about the attitude some here have just because a dev decides to now charge for his work, where he was previously not able to (due to the market not supporting it).
I even can't buy paid apps, because I dont see them and I also dont support it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you dont support what? people producing useful apps? people charging for their work? may I ask whats your age? and your profession? I am pretty sure you don't work for a software development house, do you?
let me repeat that: while a dev can provide his software FREE OF CHARGE for as long as he wants, that doesn't make him lose the rights to his work! so stop asking for links to software that used to be free, because this still violates the rights of the owner.
if you want to use an app that costs money, buy it.
oh...and for those that cant wait the few weeks ... well ... I do understand the frustration that causes, but your rant is against selling android software per se. and come on...USD 0.99 is too much? if this is too much, then the app can't be that important to you.
how much time do you think the developer spent creating the app?
xyrcncp said:
I still need to learn all these commands and locations.
I'm assuming that cp -r app app2 means that you're copying the app folder to a folder named app2? Isn't "app" in the phone's memory?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, you're right. I have all apps running from my Ext2 sd-card. So there's enough space to copy the App folder several times.
I think you can also save all apps to sd card with ASTRO (Market).
don't think i'm breaking any rules with this, as it's free...
but heres the version before the update. enjoy.
http://rapidshare.com/files/206078555/com.acme.android.powermanager.apk.html
i will reupload if needed.
also have the free slide-locker version before the annoying new one if anyone wants that?
btw, for the European users that want to buy apps, you can use SAM app market:
https://slideme.org/
they don't offer Power Manager as of yet, but I bought Advanced Taskmanager there due to not beeing able to do so from Android market yet
How pathetic.
People ***** and moan about getting better apps, but are too cheap to pay 0.99 cents for one they use.
Truly, truly patheticc.
Henchman said:
How pathetic.
People ***** and moan about getting better apps, but are too cheap to pay 0.99 cents for one they use.
Truly, truly patheticc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
not really =/
people are *****ing and moaning about an app that was advertised as a free app being suddenly converted to an annoying trial app without any warning.
the creator could have at least published a new app instead of trying to wipe out the free version.
i'm all for paid apps (although i'm in the Uk so i can't d/l them) but the way the Power Manager developer went about releasing was all wrong, and is going to make a lot less money because of it.
i would be glad to get the free side locker
Meltus said:
not really =/
people are *****ing and moaning about an app that was advertised as a free app being suddenly converted to an annoying trial app without any warning.
the creator could have at least published a new app instead of trying to wipe out the free version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I still don't get why you think he should have done that.
again: just because he offered the app free of charge for a period of time doesn't mean it is public domain. You guys make it sound like you OWN the app because it used to be free. maybe you should have read the license you clicked away when you opened the market app, hm?
its 100% his decision. he could also just pull the software and demand that it won't be distributed at all anymore, if he so desires.
there is a HUGE difference between not charging for something and owning the app.
There's a little difference I try to tell you:
The developer made an update which turns the app from free to trial.
So it's not like he makes a new better "power manager plus" or whatever and let the actual Power Manager for free... no, he makes the free power manager to power manager trial and offers a NEW app called "Power Manager" (wtf?), which costs money (doesn't absolutely matter how much).
Because "Power Manager Trial" is related to the old "Power Manager" (free) you are forced to do the update. You couldn't do the update, if it would cost 0.99$. No, he makes the update free for everybody and turned it to trial. It's a trap! This is a cheating way to market his app as good as possible and I DO NOT SUPPORT THIS!
That was the bad way... the good way is:
Let the app under the same name for free and don't develop on it anymore. Make a new app called "appname PLUS" (or whatever) and request money for it. The developer would be likeable for me and I would like to pay for it. It's so harmonic I would even pay for it without having new features.
I absolutely agree with the thread's name 'Don't Update "Power Manager"'.
Now the devs won't frighten me again and I hope everybody understands, why I don't pay for an app, when a dev tries to cheat on all the users, which were lovely using the (free) app.
Fair play at the Android Market!
I'm with Meltus and MacFloid on this 100% The old app should've remained free, and all development stopped on it, rather than a bait-and-switch. Now granted, it tells you that it is now a trial app, and you are not forced to update, but that does not make it any less disappointing. I'm all for paid apps, but keep the free apps free, and if you want to make money off that app, release a new, more advanced version, and charge for that... but don't trick your supporters into thinking the app is free, and then quickly throw in a trial period, possibly without them even realizing it. I wasn't happy with the way the dev for "Task Manager for Root Users" handled it either, but even that wasn't as bad as the dev for Power Manager. At least I noticed the trial period warning before I hit update...
-John
BTW... anyone happen to have an .apk of the old, free "Task Manager for Root Users" handy?
I agree that the way this was done was underhanded. This morning, when I first saw the update, the only new comment in the description was "3/6 UPDATE****." There was no mention of the change. It was a blatant trick to force his >250,000 downloads to pay him 99 cents in three days or else. I almost clicked update, until I noticed every comment had one star. Now that I checked it again (three hours later), he changed the description to say it's changing to a three day trial. I understand that it is his right to do this, but the fact remains that his original goal was to fool us into clicking update by not telling us it's a trial version. I will not support this dev because of his methods. How do I know that the $0.99 one won't eventually expire and I'll have to buy a $2.50 version now that I know his business tactics. There are plenty of other ways to convert your free app to a paid one. Task Manager for example. He simply removed the free version from the market and released Advanced Task Manager. He didn't try to forcibly remove the free one from my phone. I can respect this and I supported that dev by buying his app. He also could have left the free one alone and made a paid one with new features. I can think of a few new features off the top of my head. For example, DxTop allows apps to have widgets built in to them. He could make a widget pack built in to his new Power Manager. Options for power graphs and various toggle switches to be put right on the home screen. If something like this was added in I would reconsider buying it. My advice to this dev is either completely pull the free/trial version from the market and hope people have a short memory, or completely restore your free version and give the paid one some new innovation. You could even release updates to the free one that do nothing but add a one time pop up that advertise all the new features added to Power Manager Pro. That was the method that got me to pay for Discover Pro.
However I don't agree with people asking for the apk files of the free task manager and slide to unlock programs. Those programs were legitimacy pulled from the market and replaced with superior versions. You still should support the devs that put forth the effort and not blindly lash out at every dev that decides to start charging for their software.
Hi I am paying for someone to make an app for me. It would be like the last.fm app where you can stream the music from the site, but it's for soundclick.com not last.fm. I would like to be able to sign into my account, view my favorite bands, rate/comment songs, Download songs to my sdcard right from the app, upload songs (for band accounts), and basically a fully functionally app that lets me use all the features on soundclick. I will pay $10 for someone to make the app. I will pay you via paypal, after the app is completed and being used on my G1.
An application like that would take a long time to create and cost way more then $10 to produce.
10 dollars? haha no comment
Lol, if you want an app like that you would have to pay way more than 10$. That app sounds really complex. I think you undervalue the amount of skill and work it takes to actually program an app. It's actually pretty hard ( I am a beginning coder myself ). Offering 10$ for something like that is almost an insult.
hmmm, but I thought making apps were free, all it took was time. and at least im offering something lmao. I could just be like I want some one to make it free lol. Well so it looks like no one's going to do it?
zayg1 said:
hmmm, but I thought making apps were free, all it took was time. and at least im offering something lmao. I could just be like I want some one to make it free lol. Well so it looks like no one's going to do it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The SDK for android is free, but there's a fee to post things to the market. Not to mention that it takes a LOT of time to make. You're basically asking for months of someones time for $10.
benmyers2941 said:
The SDK for android is free, but there's a fee to post things to the market. Not to mention that it takes a LOT of time to make. You're basically asking for months of someones time for $10.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah, but i'm not asking for it to be posted in the market lol I said for me lol. Whatever they decide to do with it when it's done is up to them . But I see where you are coming from .
Something like that would cost at least a few thousand dollar's worth of programmer's time. I don't know anything about soundclick, but it's very likely that it wouldn't be possible to make an app without their consent/help.
Your best bet is to suggest that they make an app themselves.
XavinNydek said:
Something like that would cost at least a few thousand dollar's worth of programmer's time. I don't know anything about soundclick, but it's very likely that it wouldn't be possible to make an app without their consent/help.
Your best bet is to suggest that they make an app themselves.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How would I go about suggesting it to them? Because don't you think i would be hard to contact the owner and have them listen to someone asking for them to make an app for android?
zayg1 said:
How would I go about suggesting it to them? Because don't you think i would be hard to contact the owner and have them listen to someone asking for them to make an app for android?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would start at their Contact Page. Probably with the support email, then maybe business development if you don't get any response from support.
$10?!?!?
Are you out of your mind?
Make a real offer. I'm not a dev but I was thinking along these lines for Hero Mock Widgets:
Pay $500 per working mock Hero widgets plus 25% of profits gained.
Charge each widget $4.99 or $20 for the entire pack.
The demand for Hero ported to Cupcake is so large that I would make my $500 in less than a day (hell... maybe in just a couple of hours) since everyone would be purchasing the $20 widget pack. Then $5 would go to the dev for each download (say 1,000) download the first day (which wouldn't be too unrealistic given the demand) so the dev could easily make $1,500 for the work on release.
That would be a minimum offer!
$10... you won't even get an e-mail of interest for that. Even if it was going to be a free app on the Market. If anything you gave someone an idea to do it themselves, take the credit and charge what ever they want (like $0.99 for ten people like YOU that want it so badly) and he could make more than a lousey $10.
use imeem , they have an app
maek_it_happen said:
use imeem , they have an app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have imeem, but I want a soundclick one. Imeem and soundclick are completely different.
Binary100100 said:
Are you out of your mind?
Make a real offer. I'm not a dev but I was thinking along these lines for Hero Mock Widgets:
Pay $500 per working mock Hero widgets plus 25% of profits gained.
Charge each widget $4.99 or $20 for the entire pack.
The demand for Hero ported to Cupcake is so large that I would make my $500 in less than a day (hell... maybe in just a couple of hours) since everyone would be purchasing the $20 widget pack. Then $5 would go to the dev for each download (say 1,000) download the first day (which wouldn't be too unrealistic given the demand) so the dev could easily make $1,500 for the work on release.
That would be a minimum offer!
$10... you won't even get an e-mail of interest for that. Even if it was going to be a free app on the Market. If anything you gave someone an idea to do it themselves, take the credit and charge what ever they want (like $0.99 for ten people like YOU that want it so badly) and he could make more than a lousey $10.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What are you talking about??? I dont want a widget. I dont even want rights to sell the app. I just want it made so that I can use it lmao.
wait for flash player then , once flash player is integrated u should be able to use all the features of the real site
Some companies pour millions into R&D for applications, $10 would barely buy them coffee. lol. Yeah, best bet is to contact soundclick and ask them if they're developing an app for android. Or hope there a dev out there that wants it as badly as you do, and is currently creating one.
YAY 600 posts.
The $10 is hilarious but besides that it probably isn't possible. There is no public API as far as I can tell. They also you a flash music player. Meaning there is no way to make the calls to stream the music.
Either email them and request it or wait till there is a flash player in android
So to sum everything up here: zayg1, it ain't gonna happen.
If you really want someone to write it for you try http://www.rent-a-coder.com there programmers will bid down against eachother for the job, you might only have to pay someone $1k
$10? Free to make? You don't know anything. Go read a book. Sorry.
new hero clocks on the market great looking stuff
hero clocks and hero clocks donate check it out!
This needs to be bumped, it's awesome. All Analogue clocks for Hero in 4x3 and 2x2 for $1.50
Can anyone report if it works on donut?
Yes it does work fine if you are using the free ones please unistall before using hero clocks donate
Bump for new Hero SE clocks in market free!
They're selling HTC's intellectual property...
there is no second hands there not selling anyone's property.
actually it kinda is. i agree it should all be free, but the dude did put some of his work and time into it, and $1.50 isnt a lot to ask for lol. plus! he even made free versions! come on lets not be too greeedy with wanting everything free, the guy deserves at least something.
coolbho3000 said:
They're selling HTC's intellectual property...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow, didn't think of that. I 100% agree, since they're basically just selling HTC's images...Not saying that they don't deserve to be paid for putting it together, but still, that's all it is, HTC's images.
gtrplr71 said:
there is no second hands there not selling anyone's property.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This guy would definitely would lose in a lawsuit.
He is MAKING MONEY by using HTC's copyrighted images. Plain and simple. Regardless of what he included or didn't include.
MOONSSPOON said:
This guy would definitely would lose in a lawsuit.
He is MAKING MONEY by using HTC's copyrighted images. Plain and simple. Regardless of what he included or didn't include.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats very true, bot does that also mean weather widgets donate and beautiful hero widgets are also infringing on this?
beatle7777777 said:
Thats very true, bot does that also mean weather widgets donate and beautiful hero widgets are also infringing on this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Most images in those widgets are almost identical copies. They aren't exactly the same. Some images are direct rips though, I'm fairly certain. I can't imagine these would hold up too well in court either.
if htc has a problem with it they will send C&D letters, just like what Palm did with the pre theme.
I will gladly pull the apps if HTC has a problem with it,I am not in any way trying to steal from them like some of you are portraying (thanks to those that understand its alot of hard work to make the people on the market happy)Yep the images are theirs though search google for clock parts and you will see how they put their clocks together.I am the one though that brought it to the market how long has it been around now? If HTC one day decides they want to put up their clocks I will surely step aside...Seems like some here are jealous I have been the one to bring this and my themes to the market.There are a ton apps on the market infringing on copyrights that are far worse than mine I never once claimed the clocks as my own and the only reason I do a donation app is to make something for the work I do.Again they may be their images but I am the one putting it together into an app fielding questions and concerns 24-7 for it so no I dont feel like I am doing anything wrong or infringing on anyones trademarks.If anything I would bet HTC probably likes the advertising,because of the hero clocks widget a few that would have never even heard of it are gonna go get a hero now.I like how this thread started but then of course it has to go astray and people all the sudden become lawyers thanks for the advise guys.I am going to contact htc right now to see if we can work something out where everyone is happy....
I would have paid 10 times what I paid great clocks and great support!
crotalusfreak said:
I will gladly pull the apps if HTC has a problem with it,I am not in any way trying to steal from them like some of you are portraying (thanks to those that understand its alot of hard work to make the people on the market happy)Yep the images are theirs though search google for clock parts and you will see how they put their clocks together.I am the one though that brought it to the market how long has it been around now? If HTC one day decides they want to put up their clocks I will surely step aside...Seems like some here are jealous I have been the one to bring this and my themes to the market.There are a ton apps on the market infringing on copyrights that are far worse than mine I never once claimed the clocks as my own and the only reason I do a donation app is to make something for the work I do.Again they may be their images but I am the one putting it together into an app fielding questions and concerns 24-7 for it so no I dont feel like I am doing anything wrong or infringing on anyones trademarks.If anything I would bet HTC probably likes the advertising,because of the hero clocks widget a few that would have never even heard of it are gonna go get a hero now.I like how this thread started but then of course it has to go astray and people all the sudden become lawyers thanks for the advise guys.I am going to contact htc right now to see if we can work something out where everyone is happy....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i actually do work with lawyers. though theyre empployment, bankruptcy and real estate lawyers, they also sometimes to that rights type crap. and i can tell you, htc would not give a crap if you do this. it wouldnt be worth sueing you because to them your worth crap, and they would lose more money in sueing you then just lettnig this be. i say to make everyone happy just lowetr the price to $1. the less money you make from there property the better.
now say if you were making like $500 a month from this, thenn your screwed lol.
Okay look people if HTC really cared do you think we would even have this web site? Really me, chrisag92 and manup put these clocks up months ago granted they were for free but any ways that doesn't matter what I'm saying is HTC leaks alot of the roms so we are basically beta testers so that they can make improvements based on what we say if they cared that much the whole site would be shut down no just certain apps removed from the market and thats cortalus for putting up my SE clock
Thanks for the support guys I really appreciate it,I would drop the price but then it gets me .69 cents each.I know 1.50 is a little more than most themes on the market but I have added tons of clocks and its not openhome,ahome whatever home specific and I feel as if its worth the $1.05 it gets me after googles cut.I dont think alot of people realize how much google takes for posting to their market,I am not complaining or anything just an fyi for those who didnt know.But aside from that this matter is in HTC's hands now I definitely wanna make a living and provide for my wife and kids the right way so I have contacted them to see if a partnership can be made.It does mean though if they say I gotta pull them I will, I am not trying to make any enemies in the Android world especially HTC.
Not a problem r_dub I am glad to do it I think your guys' special editions are gonna be in the top 5 soon at the rate they are going.Almost 3000 downloads already!
r_dub said:
Okay look people if HTC really cared do you think we would even have this web site? Really me, chrisag92 and manup put these clocks up months ago granted they were for free but any ways that doesn't matter what I'm saying is HTC leaks alot of the roms so we are basically beta testers so that they can make improvements based on what we say if they cared that much the whole site would be shut down no just certain apps removed from the market and thats cortalus for putting up my SE clock
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 now just go on over to cyans thread or jacs thead and start this crap about property and see how long you last!
crotalusfreak said:
Thanks for the support guys I really appreciate it,I would drop the price but then it gets me .69 cents each.I know 1.50 is a little more than most themes on the market but I have added tons of clocks and its not openhome,ahome whatever home specific and I feel as if its worth the $1.05 it gets me after googles cut.I dont think alot of people realize how much google takes for posting to their market,I am not complaining or anything just an fyi for those who didnt know.But aside from that this matter is in HTC's hands now I definitely wanna make a living and provide for my wife and kids the right way so I have contacted them to see if a partnership can be made.It does mean though if they say I gotta pull them I will, I am not trying to make any enemies in the Android world especially HTC.
Not a problem r_dub I am glad to do it I think your guys' special editions are gonna be in the top 5 soon at the rate they are going.Almost 3000 downloads already!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WOW top 5 i guess people like my and chrisag92's work
gtrplr71 said:
+1 now just go on over to cyans thread or jacs thead and start this crap about property and see how long you last!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I hope that comment wasn't directed at me and yeah if this was a dev forum all of you complaining about what's belongs to who you would get flamed very quickly so i suggest take it as it is and let it be sorted out by whatever means necessary
Hi Guys,
I've made my first theme and popped it on the android market, I made the decision to charge £0.99 for it as I believe it to be worth that and I know if I saw it then I would have no qualms with paying this at all, however since releasing it around 10 hours ago, ive only had 3 downloads all of which were cancelled so im trying to work out reasons why. One possible reason I can think is that they are using the Motorola Droid, where most these don't look particularly good because of the resolution, the second is that they just plain didn't like it! I do find this rather odd though as I have included 2 screenshots.
So if here's the androlib link (http://www.androlib.com/android.application.com-nd-android-pandatheme-psimpleblack_5896-pExj.aspx) (screens dont do it much justice), I would appreciate any feedback. If anyone wants to download it for real then for today I will refund anyone from XDA developers who purchases it, just PM me your name after you have done so.
Thanks a lot for any help .
Looks pretty good to me, i take it the fuzziness is just in the screenshots? There's certainly A LOT worse on the market that have quite a few downloads, so I think you just have to give it time.
Yeah the fuzzyness is just the screens, thanks for the comment . Feel free to download if you want to take it for a spin and I'll refund your money making it free.
Anyone else got anything to add? getting a lot of views but little in the way of comments .
jgclifton said:
Anyone else got anything to add? getting a lot of views but little in the way of comments .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would suggest making the notification bar black. The white bar does not look quite right. On the other hand, I only theme AOSP ROMS, so this may not be an option for you.
I want you to know that what follows is constructive criticism in the hopes that it will help you. If I offend I apologize, and give you full permission to tell me to piss off.
When I look at the theme, it looks nice, very clean, all the graphics work, but there is nothing that grabs my attention. It seems very "flat" and I personally would refund and get a theme that would draw me in to the screen. Having said that, I think it is really great work, that with a little bit of effort could really sell. I am sorry to say that I can not tell you what it needs, but I suggest making a few mock ups in gimp (or photoshop) and asking people what they think.
Additionally, the theme looks a lot like an iphone, which may be why I do not care for the look as much another may. The idiots on the market are always looking for iphone this and that, and thus I think it could really sell given time.
Thanks, comments noted, very helpful. The black notification bar isn't an option in this sort of theme but I'll definately be looking into ways of jazzing it up for a version 2.0 .
While I love themes like this, the only issue is that every other app installed will have a regular icon. Which unfortunatly takes away from your great work..
Yeah I recognise this, i was thinking of adding extra ones for the most popular apps (facebook, twidroid etc). Maybe this is something I'll look further in to.
jgclifton said:
Yeah I recognise this, i was thinking of adding extra ones for the most popular apps (facebook, twidroid etc). Maybe this is something I'll look further in to.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is exactly what I did. There is no way to legally theme and distribute most market apps, so just make an addition icon pack and let people apply via bettercut.
By the way, I showed this to my wife, whom is a professional graphic designer, and asked her opinion. She suggested it is way too flat, and needs more contrast. I realize that you do not want to add color to accomplish this, as it defies the point of your theme, so she suggested to do away with the symmetry. Stagger some icons, give the homescreen a look that carries the eye of the viewer around it.
Thanks cloverdale, will definately take this into account in my future themes. Currently selling ok on the market place after making a few colour variations .