Mic isuue Hardware or Software?? - Galaxy S I9000 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

Traded for this phone, but just noticed it has a mic issue.Very low and the other side cant hear unless your yelling, but bluetooth headset works. Wondering if its a hardware problem, or does it work after porting a ROM to it?

g0t0 said:
Traded for this phone, but just noticed it has a mic issue.Very low and the other side cant hear unless your yelling, but bluetooth headset works. Wondering if its a hardware problem, or does it work after porting a ROM to it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are using stock rom or custom rom?
if not stock, could be rom issue too.. but if stock then its a hardware issue

Related

[Q] Headphones mic fix?

hey i just got an incredible s and using it on ARHD 1.1.1 rom... I can't get my iphone headphones (with the volume controls) to work with the phone...
I have used these headphones on SGS with cm7.... so cant figure out why they wont work with IS...
the headphones buttons work... but no voice from mic... any fix for this? i love these headphones compared to others ... so need this to work!!!
thanks
... no one else has this issue ...?
danial.aw said:
... no one else has this issue ...?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
same problem - and still no fix to date...
Same.. it sucks, couldnt find a fix so far
Does yor problem with iphone headphone's mic or with any headphone's mic?
NikkyNine said:
Does yor problem with iphone headphone's mic or with any headphone's mic?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
any that we have tried so far...
NikkyNine said:
Does yor problem with iphone headphone's mic or with any headphone's mic?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought the beats headphones with mic, the mic work with Iphone but it dosn't with IS.
Any suggestion how to fix that.
------delete----
ok so apparently for me even the htc headset that came with my phone doesnt seem to want to work :S...
is this true for everyone or is my htc IS just messed up?
I used it in miui, arhd and virtuous.... is it possible that there is a hardware issue in the phone :S? any way to check?.... the mic symbol does show up on the phone though just no voice goes through?
this is a bell/virgin IS with S-off, and eng boot...
any reply back will be really helpful cuz im about to chuck my phone against the wall
... the handsfree build.prop change (from development section) works somewhat that i can hear myself talking on mic.... but no voice is going through to the other end :S....
danial.aw said:
ok so apparently for me even the htc headset that came with my phone doesnt seem to want to work :S...
is this true for everyone or is my htc IS just messed up?
I used it in miui, arhd and virtuous.... is it possible that there is a hardware issue in the phone :S? any way to check?.... the mic symbol does show up on the phone though just no voice goes through?
this is a bell/virgin IS with S-off, and eng boot...
any reply back will be really helpful cuz im about to chuck my phone against the wall
... the handsfree build.prop change (from development section) works somewhat that i can hear myself talking on mic.... but no voice is going through to the other end :S....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are not alone - have same problem and have tried multiple rom images.
thats sad.... kills the device for me nicely that a simple thing like that has a bug
Handsfree was working well with htc stock rom. It wont work on cyanogen and miui roms.
doesnt seem to want to work for me with any custom rom :S... oh well
I too have the same problem. It's a bit disappointing but overall phone is great with custom roms.
mmmm do u people (whomever) has the issue... mind telling exactly what phones u have and what carriers and stuff.... this has to be a software issue somewhere cuz it was working on stock roms...
My headset ( htc ) worked without a problem on the ORIGINAL stock rom aka. 2.2 ( or was it 2.1 ) when i updated to the OFFICIAL 2.3 rom via the built-in upgrade now feature in the phone it stopped working, so in my experience it seems to be a 2.3 problem or smthing
so it seems as if a drivers problem in gingerbread for us :S... everyones from a different country...
unless somehow the manufacturing is not as solid as i thought...
- so i seem to have gotten my htc headset working with virtuous 1.29.... I had to flash another kernel (unity v3 in my case) ... and the headset started working, has a little echoish sound ... but better than nothing
I have the same issue here : IS with Orange France
So problem started with stock rom. HTC headphone ok, iphone headphones ok, then i bought sennheiser CX880i and then i mic was not properly detected and never able to get a sound out of it.
Had the same issue with custom rom later on : Virtuous unity. So i buy another brand of headphones with mic today : Klipsch S4i ... same issue with custom rom virtous unity 1.31.
will try other kernel to see if its the same...
it is worse with this kernel as now my iphone mic is no longer recognised...

[Q] Microphone "kinda" not working (With any ROM)

Just acquired one of these phones today and seem to be having a slightly strange issue and hoping someone might know the resolution.
When on a call, the other person cannot hear me at all (they can hear nothing as-if the microphone is muted, it's not!), however if I switch to speakerphone they can hear me fine.
This is happening on any ROM, except unofficial CM10.1 where the microphone does not work at all.
In external apps the mic does not work either (so if I record a video, I get no sound).
I'm having trouble seeing this as a mic hardware issue as it works OK on speakerphone, any ideas on this?
Cheers!
tral1z said:
Just acquired one of these phones today and seem to be having a slightly strange issue and hoping someone might know the resolution.
When on a call, the other person cannot hear me at all (they can hear nothing as-if the microphone is muted, it's not!), however if I switch to speakerphone they can hear me fine.
This is happening on any ROM, except unofficial CM10.1 where the microphone does not work at all.
In external apps the mic does not work either (so if I record a video, I get no sound).
I'm having trouble seeing this as a mic hardware issue as it works OK on speakerphone, any ideas on this?
Cheers!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does this happen on stock rom as well?
Yeah I've put it back to the Samsung firmware (Carphone Warehouse UK, 2.3.6) and still doing the same thing.
Interestingly, on stock-based ROMs the Mic works on speakerphone (Still nothing anywhere else), but on CM-based or ported ROMs, the mic does not work at all!
Just to confirm, the Galaxy Mini does have just a single mic right? Haha!

need help! what is wrong with my mic? broken when on-ear call, not during speaker

no known damages at all. yes rooted, i have flashed multiple roms, so i dont think its software, i think it's a hardware problem so i'm asking if there's a way around it. Yes I have sound enhancement disabled and yes I have cleaned it with a brush
problem - when making a call on-ear, the mic doesn't work. when i put it in speaker the mic works again.
therefore i ask, does the phone using a different mic between on-ear and speaker? if the answer is yes, how can i switch which mic it uses? if the answer is no, what is wrong with the phone?
unknown00 said:
no known damages at all. yes rooted, i have flashed multiple roms, so i dont think its software, i think it's a hardware problem so i'm asking if there's a way around it. Yes I have sound enhancement disabled and yes I have cleaned it with a brush
problem - when making a call on-ear, the mic doesn't work. when i put it in speaker the mic works again.
therefore i ask, does the phone using a different mic between on-ear and speaker? if the answer is yes, how can i switch which mic it uses? if the answer is no, what is wrong with the phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If your signature is correct then you have a OnePlusOne and this is a HTC One M7 forum. The phones are different and if it is a hardware issue you will need to return it to the manufacturer for repair. I would guess that there is just one mic and I would go back to stock to see if the problem is evident there, if not then it is a software issue.

Sound problem when calling solved by custom ROM?

My friend has a problem with his galaxy s4 active. His microphone and speaker work perfectly when testing with music and audio recording. But when calling someone the speaker is dead silent and the other person can't hear him. I saw a bunch of threads where they reheat the audio IC and so on. He is running android 5.0.1. Now my question is: is this a software problem and can it be fixed by flashing CM? Thanks for any and all replies.
Edit: If you're wondering I know how to flash custom ROMs and have a lot of experience doing that.
I have the same problem, no sound when call via telephone app. Videos and music are prefect to. The best is when I use WahtsApp and call to someone everything is ok. So I think hardware is ok but something is blocking standard telephone application. I reset my phone (wipe) and reload rom but the problem wasn't gone.
I'm still looking for any solution so maybe someone can help.
Tx
Samsung headphones are not working too.
Solution:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...ute-person-t3169864/post62150085#post62150085
And post 7
ungrillao said:
Solution:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/gal...ute-person-t3169864/post62150085#post62150085
And post 7
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the reply I was thinking it is a software glitch considering sound recording still works.
Sent from my Xperia M2 using Tapatalk

External Microphone on 3.5MM audio Jack not working - Headphones worked!

Hello Guys,
I been searching alot in the forum and I can't seems to find a solution for this yet. Maybe I got too confuse after reading some threads here.
nevertheless, I just wanted to make sure that my external Microphone would work with the 3.5mm Audio input jack. I have tested the same mic with the correct cable and it works with my 1Plus5T / Samsung Note8 how ever no luck with the K20Pro.
Do I need to root the phone and use Magisk to fix this issue?
I am currently on INDIA Raphaline rom 10.3.5 I believe
please don't shot me guys.
Cheers
Jumundz said:
Hello Guys,
I been searching alot in the forum and I can't seems to find a solution for this yet. Maybe I got too confuse after reading some threads here.
nevertheless, I just wanted to make sure that my external Microphone would work with the 3.5mm Audio input jack. I have tested the same mic with the correct cable and it works with my 1Plus5T / Samsung Note8 how ever no luck with the K20Pro.
Do I need to root the phone and use Magisk to fix this issue?
I am currently on INDIA Raphaline rom 10.3.5 I believe
please don't shot me guys.
Cheers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just received my Mi 9T Pro a few days ago and was researching this. Don't have a mic yet so haven't been able to try it. I guess evidently it will work with Open Camera as there's a setting for that. But I'm trying to see if it works with Gcam mods. I found this video but it's for the Gcam stock app. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-cNyep1vADY Please let us know if you find anything.
BCE111 said:
I just received my Mi 9T Pro a few days ago and was researching this. Don't have a mic yet so haven't been able to try it. I guess evidently it will work with Open Camera as there's a setting for that. But I'm trying to see if it works with Gcam mods. I found this video but it's for the Gcam stock app. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-cNyep1vADY Please let us know if you find anything.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi there, thanks very much I wlll take a look.
Jumundz said:
Hello Guys,
I been searching alot in the forum and I can't seems to find a solution for this yet. Maybe I got too confuse after reading some threads here.
nevertheless, I just wanted to make sure that my external Microphone would work with the 3.5mm Audio input jack. I have tested the same mic with the correct cable and it works with my 1Plus5T / Samsung Note8 how ever no luck with the K20Pro.
Do I need to root the phone and use Magisk to fix this issue?
I am currently on INDIA Raphaline rom 10.3.5 I believe
please don't shot me guys.
Cheers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same issue. Headphones work but the mic does not. Looks like a defective piece. Did not have time to head to the service center yet
shiwik said:
I have the same issue. Headphones work but the mic does not. Looks like a defective piece. Did not have time to head to the service center yet
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i read through post ~ need to use magisk to patch it and it would work . I don't want to root the phone . does i am still stock here i really hope is a defective unit. I didn't have a chance to try when I am using chinese firmware
Did anyone solve this?
I just bought this phone and have the same issue.
Major75 said:
Did anyone solve this?
I just bought this phone and have the same issue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just got my Mi 9T Pro a week ago and just bought a mic the other day but haven't had a chance to try it yet. I'll let you know. I think Open Camera has a setting for external mics. Gcam has a setting that pops up when a mic is inserted, but that's the stock software. Not sure if Gcam mods do. See above for video link.
Just saw this article that says an external mic won't work. Not sure how accurate it is. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...ortant-video-feature/articleshow/70339311.cms
Same issue here. Discord with an external mic is not working, but in the miui recorder app it is. Did you try that?
I'm pretty sure its a MIUI bug since one year ago the poco f1 had exactly the same issue and it got fixed via update.
peter0010 said:
Same issue here. Discord with an external mic is not working, but in the miui recorder app it is. Did you try that?
I'm pretty sure its a MIUI bug since one year ago the poco f1 had exactly the same issue and it got fixed via update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep. I tried in the recorder app. the external mic doesn't record. complete silence on playback.
My main problem is when i'm using headphones in a call...the other person can't hear me.
Major75 said:
Yep. I tried in the recorder app. the external mic doesn't record. complete silence on playback.
My main problem is when i'm using headphones in a call...the other person can't hear me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you talkin about an actually mic? Or a headset?
I was talking about some regular headset with a microphone, if this change anything at all.
peter0010 said:
Are you talkin about an actually mic? Or a headset?
I was talking about some regular headset with a microphone, if this change anything at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry for the confusion. So my phone Mic is fine. When i plug in my headphones ( Samsung akg s8 ones with a external mic), the phone detects the headphones with external mic but the mic on the headphones doesn't work but I can hear music, voice calls through my headphones. Just the other person can't hear me through the headphone mic. Tried with the recorder app etc. The mic on the headphone doesn't work
I have tried 2 samsung headphones and 1 apple headphones. All with the same issue.
Tried all the headphones on another phone and all the headphones and mic work perfectly.
Does it need specific xiaomi mi headphones to work or something?
Major75 said:
Sorry for the confusion. So my phone Mic is fine. When i plug in my headphones ( Samsung akg s8 ones with a external mic), the phone detects the headphones with external mic but the mic on the headphones doesn't work but I can hear music, voice calls through my headphones. Just the other person can't hear me through the headphone mic. Tried with the recorder app etc. The mic on the headphone doesn't work
I have tried 2 samsung headphones and 1 apple headphones. All with the same issue.
Tried all the headphones on another phone and all the headphones and mic work perfectly.
Does it need specific xiaomi mi headphones to work or something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, definitely not. Mine is some old one from oppo find 7, I think.
Thats weird that it doesn't work for you in the recorder app though, cause for me it does. Its just voicechat applications like discord for example which don't work.. and it really annoys me.
We should definitely report it to xiaomi via the feedback section at the bottom of the settings.
edit: seems like it is a known issue already
https://forum.xda-developers.com/k20-pro/help/issue-discord-k20p-mi9tp-t3965007
peter0010 said:
No, definitely not. Mine is some old one from oppo find 7, I think.
Thats weird that it doesn't work for you in the recorder app though, cause for me it does. Its just voicechat applications like discord for example which don't work.. and it really annoys me.
We should definitely report it to xiaomi via the feedback section at the bottom of the settings.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ahh is my unit defective? Idk if i should return it.
Major75 said:
Sorry for the confusion. So my phone Mic is fine. When i plug in my headphones ( Samsung akg s8 ones with a external mic), the phone detects the headphones with external mic but the mic on the headphones doesn't work but I can hear music, voice calls through my headphones. Just the other person can't hear me through the headphone mic. Tried with the recorder app etc. The mic on the headphone doesn't work
I have tried 2 samsung headphones and 1 apple headphones. All with the same issue.
Tried all the headphones on another phone and all the headphones and mic work perfectly.
Does it need specific xiaomi mi headphones to work or something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have been hearing different views from various folks on this forum. I have the Indian version of the K20Pro and i can confirm that the mic of an external headset (earphones or headphones) does not work. I can however listen to music and also hear the opposite person talk where i receive a call. However the opposite person cannot hear me - which is indicative that the mic does not work (or there is an issue)
On the positive side though, i flashed Revolution OS and this problem seems to have been fixed. I can now use any earphones (or headphones) to take calls and the opposite person can now hear me. I am doing an entirely clean flash (fastboot) now to check if that works on the latest Indian version too.
shiwik said:
I have been hearing different views from various folks on this forum. I have the Indian version of the K20Pro and i can confirm that the mic of an external headset (earphones or headphones) does not work. I can however listen to music and also hear the opposite person talk where i receive a call. However the opposite person cannot hear me - which is indicative that the mic does not work (or there is an issue)
On the positive side though, i flashed Revolution OS and this problem seems to have been fixed. I can now use any earphones (or headphones) to take calls and the opposite person can now hear me. I am doing an entirely clean flash (fastboot) now to check if that works on the latest Indian version too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the Mi 9T global version with stock glonal MiUI 10.3.11 and I have the exact same issue as you're having. I'm going to try some xiaomi headphones and see if this fixes the issue. Thank you for your response by the way.
Major75 said:
I have the Mi 9T global version with stock glonal MiUI 10.3.11 and I have the exact same issue as you're having. I'm going to try some xiaomi headphones and see if this fixes the issue. Thank you for your response by the way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I suspect it is an issue with the global firmware. If may want to try some of the Chinese ones to see if that has solved this issue as most of the custom ROMs are based on the Chinese FW
Edit:
I have been running Custom MIUI with Chinese FW so far. Just did a clean fastboot of the indian version 10.3.5.0 and guess what - the mic works for calls!! Very strange as it definately did not work for me out of the box
shiwik said:
I suspect it is an issue with the global firmware. If may want to try some of the Chinese ones to see if that has solved this issue as most of the custom ROMs are based on the Chinese FW
Edit:
I have been running Custom MIUI with Chinese FW so far. Just did a clean fastboot of the indian version 10.3.5.0 and guess what - the mic works for calls!! Very strange as it definately did not work for me out of the box
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you do a factory reset or something? I'm not very familiar with rooting and running fastboot so i dont feel comfortable flashing any firmwares. I'm a noob. i know :laugh:
Some feedback, but probably not what you want to hear:
Had a similar problem with Signal - old headset worked fine on HTC-U11+ stock, on the K20 pro there was no microphone (callee said no sound at all) even though headset with mic was detected. A temporary solution was to partially pull out the plug which caused the K20P to show headphones only headset connected and I guess it used the phone mic.
However I purchased a Xiaomi headset which worked fine from the start, detecting headset with microphone and callee said mic quality was much better. Seems they may have pulled an Apple move and used non-standard pin connectors
Currently on 9.9.6 Xiaomi.eu ROM, K20Pro CN version (purchased in China) 8/128Gb version.
murakh said:
Some feedback, but probably not what you want to hear:
Had a similar problem with Signal - old headset worked fine on HTC-U11+ stock, on the K20 pro there was no microphone (callee said no sound at all) even though headset with mic was detected. A temporary solution was to partially pull out the plug which caused the K20P to show headphones only headset connected and I guess it used the phone mic.
However I purchased a Xiaomi headset which worked fine from the start, detecting headset with microphone and callee said mic quality was much better. Seems they may have pulled an Apple move and used non-standard pin connectors
Currently on 9.9.6 Xiaomi.eu ROM, K20Pro CN version (purchased in China) 8/128Gb version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That wouldn't explain why it is working on mine with some random OPPO headset.
peter0010 said:
That wouldn't explain why it is working on mine with some random OPPO headset.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Could you please clarify as your last post states that voice comms apps, like discord did not work?
peter0010 said:
No, definitely not. Mine is some old one from oppo find 7, I think.
Thats weird that it doesn't work for you in the recorder app though, cause for me it does. Its just voicechat applications like discord for example which don't work.. and it really annoys me.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/k20-pro/help/issue-discord-k20p-mi9tp-t3965007
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me it was Signal which was not working with the external headset mic, but then worked perfectly when I used the Xiaomi one. (not an advert, yet I really do like the Xiaomi headset (in-ear) and I am not unhappy that I purchsed it)
Also, and its been a long while since I had the Find 5, I seem to vaguely recall there was similar issues with headsets & micrphones on the early Find phones - maybe Xiaomi and Oppo use the same jack supplier?

Categories

Resources