Database Develop

Commuter vs Dualpro

Which case is better?
Looking for the better front face protection, and more grip on the back.

Bump?
Really trying to decide.

I can't speak for the Commuter for the G2, but I've handled the DualPro and the Commuter for the Galaxy Nexus, which seems similar in design to the G2 version.
The DualPro doesn't have the plastic outer shell going up to the too and bottom edges, and the silicone seems thinner than that used by the Commuter. It's also thinner in the back area, so means the whole case is smaller than the Commuter appears to be. What I don't like is that there's very little front protection, due to an extremely thin rim and having a low lip over the front.
The Commuter appears more protective due to having more silicone on all sides of the case, plus the thicker plastic that almost reaches the rim on all four edges. But it's definitely not a slender case. It also covers all the buttons, which is good for protection but also hides the power button LED. It also has flaps for the USB and headphone poets, which the DualPro does not. It is also less matte than the DualPro, which means the plastic is slippery, more so than the soft-touch type plastic on the DualPro. It also has a taller rim, when I look at it in-box, which is also thicker than the DualPro's.
It's really up to you to decide if more silicone with a slightly more slippery back is better than less face protection but a better grip (due to matte plastic plus a thinner overall case).

I have the dualpro for the G2 and the commuter for the note 2. The dualpro is thin but I feel would survive a light drop. The commuter would probably survive a toss or throw.
However, I like to maintain some of the original slim feel to my phone. The commuter negates that, the dualpro is perfect for that.
Sent from my SGH-T889 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

Just compared the DualPro to the Spigen Slim Armor.
The DualPro has a VERY thin lip, but it's taller (by 1mm) than the Spigen, which has a lip about 3/4 as thick as the Commuter. The DualPro also has a thinner back than either the Commuter for the G2 I played with in store or the Spigen. The silicone is thinner on all sides, and is a softer, stickier rubber than either of the other two. But the plastic on the Commuter and the Spigen is not the soft-touch, rubber-coated type of the DualPro. That is a thin, but grippy case. It's also shorter than either the Commuter or Spigen.
But it's still bulkier than the QuickWindow case, and feels about as protective - which means it wouldn't be good for more than 20-30cm falls. The Commuter is the thickest and widest of the three, but has the most protection with its firm, thick silicone and port covers, plus a sturdy plastic shell and tall lip. The Spigen is shorter, thinner, but has little face protection due to its short lip. But the very firm TPU feels like it can handle a few bumps, as did similar TPU cases for my iPod Touch. Plus it has an okay grip, if not as good as the Incipio Dualpro. The DualPro is the thinnest two-part silicone case with a plastic frame I know of. It covers the corners and sides better than the official QuickWindow case, while being almost the same size. That is, IMO, also its weakness. It doesn't seem much better then the Feather, which has a thicker plastic shell that's the same width as the soft silicone here, and which also covers part of the top and bottom.
Still, nothing beats trying the cases yourself and seeing if one suits you better than the others.

I only have experience with the DualPro, and I love it. That said, I have been pretty lucky in caring for this phone. I did drop it once in a parking lot, luckily, it landed on one of the corners. That corner of the case is now slightly scuffed, but the phone was fine. I don't remember if it landed face down or not. I do worry about bigger drops, but I also don't want the phone to be too unwieldy. I'm happy with the DualPro.

I have the black Dual Pro and have been very happy with the case. I definitely like that it does not add much bulk. Also that the camera lens no is recessed. With knock-knock the phone is usually facing up. As mentioned in another post the matte finish gives the case a better grip.
I have 3 kids, 2.5, 5 and 9 years old so I need to protect the phone. I let them all use the phone for games, camera or internet. So far its been dropped a few time in the house on tile, carpet and hardwood floors with no damage to phone or case.
Overall I give the case a 4 out of 5 stars. Maybe 5 stars if the headphone jack and USB port had covers.
I might have gotten the commuter case but Otterbox didn't have a version for Verizon's G2

I had an Otterbox Commuter for my Galaxy SIII and I have an Incipio DualPro for my LG G2. The Incipio case feels better and in the conditions I use my phone there would be a negligible difference in protection.
I like the Incipio better.
Sent from my Verizon LG G2 using Tapatalk

Now that I have a black Incipio DualPro case on my LG G2, I think it's just about the perfect case for this phone. It strikes a perfect balance between low profile and protection. Its low-key good looks make it a great all-around case. I may never use my matte black Diztronic case again.
Sent from my Verizon LG G2 using Tapatalk

liteon163 said:
Now that I have a black Incipio DualPro case on my LG G2, I think it's just about the perfect case for this phone. It strikes a perfect balance between low profile and protection. Its low-key good looks make it a great all-around case. I may never use my matte black Diztronic case again.
Sent from my Verizon LG G2 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Funny, I went from DualPro t0 the Diztronic, and have stayed on the Diz a bit longer (plus I got if for under $9). Love them both, the DualPro does seem to add a bit more protection, thought. Definitely cannot go wrong with it.

Yeah
slainte_0317 said:
Funny, I went from DualPro t0 the Diztronic, and have stayed on the Diz a bit longer (plus I got if for under $9). Love them both, the DualPro does seem to add a bit more protection, thought. Definitely cannot go wrong with it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree

Supcase Unicorn Beetle rugged case w/holster

This isn't a review. Just a first impression/initial thoughts.
I handle otterbox cases of all variety everyday. This unicorn beetle feels just as good, quality wise. Its mostly comparable to the defender series however. Both have built in screen protection, port covers. Both utilize a tongue in groove like method of securing the plastic 'inner' to the rugged rubber 'outer'
Overall it feels very secure and robust, but not quite as bulky as a defender in my opinion.
The orzly glass screen protector on my g4 (edge to edge) does not interfere with the 'front' cover of the case. I have removed the built in plastic protector, so i cannot comment on how it feels etc.
I should also note that i have the plastic back on while in this case. I have not and will not attempt installation with the leather back. This case seems to meet and exceed my needs for when rugged protection is required. My typical day to day is case-less, alternating between plastic and leather backs.
The holster seems to be robust. Made with thick plastic and a 360 degree rotating belt clasp. Almost identical to the defenders holster.
Please excuse the purple tint from my m7 camera.

Do you feel like the holster would snap eventually? How did you remove the screen protector? The screen protector is a major drawback to me.

The holster feels very sturdy. However it is plastic after all and im sure it will break under certain conditions. Im at work right now so ill take some photos of the defender series holster for the g3 and post a comparison in this thread later in the evening. The screen protector was attached to the 'front' with an adhesive. It was easy to pop it out. As i mentioned in my original post, my edge to edge tempered glass protector does not interfere with the fitment of this case.

I removed the screen cover the case had built in, and all I did was push it out and pull on it. The glue used is like a double sided tape, so get as much off when removing the screen and peel the rest. DO NOT USE GOO OFF, you'll mess up the case, trust me. Removing the sticky residue is the hardest part honestly.
Sent from my LG-H811 using Tapatalk

[review] Gmyle Book Case Vintage wallet/folio case

This is my review of the Gmyle Book Case Vintage wallet/folio case
This folio/wallet case is made of PU leather but the material looks and feels like leather. The bookcase design is original and adds a nice touch to the phone. The spine of the case has some nice gold patterns that remind of old book designs.
Inside the case, you will find 3 card slots and one id slot on the left, as well as a pocket for cash. The plastic case holding the phone is black and is made of flexible plastic. I’m not sure if this is the same material as that used in the Galaxy S5 case, which a lot of users criticized for falling apart after a few days. The phone sits pretty tightly in the plastic sleeve. However, the sleeve is so flexible that I’m not sure whether the phone would effectively remain attached to it in case of a fall. Cutouts allow easy access to all the ports and the S-pen is easy to pull.
The case adds some bulk to the phone. When the wallet is closed, the total thickness is 0.75”. However, the case seems to provide a higher level of protection than bumpers and other slim cases. In particular, the thick PU material adds some cushion, which may be able to absorb some energy during a fall. The back of the case is pre-folded to allow the case to act as a stand maintaining the phone in a comfortable landscape viewing position. One limitation of the bookcase design is the lack of a cutout on the front cover, which prevents the use of the phone for a call with the case closed. The thickness of the case in the closed position may also make this case incompatible with car docks/holders.
Summary: Overall, this is a great wallet case at this price level. If you're more interested in an authentic leather case and you don't mind paying extra, I recommend the Davis Case (reviewed here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/note5/accessories/review-daviscase-wallet-folio-bookcase-t3198304)
Pros:
- original design that will make your Note 5 stand out of the crowd
- nice texture and color for PU material
- cheap
Cons:
- no easy phone call with the case closed
- no auto awake/sleep feature
- may require the need for a screen protector to prevent the cards located in the card slots from rubbing against the screen

Review of: Note 5 Tough Case by Artech 21

Note 5 Tough Case -- Artech 21 [Little Rock Series] Military-Grade Ultra Protective [Shockproof] [Drop Proof ] Heavy Duty Rugged Case with Built-in Screen Protector For Samsung Galaxy Note 5-White
This case comes as a 2 piece clamshell, top part containing the built in screen protector and the bottom having a rigid back and flexible sides that secure it to the top piece. The top half is a secured in place screen protector made of a clear and rigid plastic sheet with a cutout for the action button. The phone is snapped into this portion first where it makes a snug and secure fitment. The bottom half is thicker and possesses the bulk of the padding, seen in the honeycomb ridges and thick sidewalls. This half receives the top where it snugs into the flexible sidewalls.
The power and headphone jacks are covered with flaps, speaker and S-Pen openings are unobstructed and the volume and power buttons are firm but still responsive. The sides of the case are beveled above and below and are textured with a crosshatch design which makes it easy to pick up from a flat surface and have a secure grip. The rear of the case is branded with the company logo and an industrial design. The area around the camera is not very beveled which provides poor access to the Heart Rate Monitor. Wireless charging is functional through the case, tested on 2 OEM and 1 Samsung branded charger pads
In comparing this product with a direct competitor and king of the hill, Otterbox Defender, a few differences stand out. While both items have similar port cover designs, the hinge side on the Otterbox is to the front of the case where the silicone has the greatest flexibility and the Artech case is hinged toward the rear of the case where the silicone has greater stability. In my opinion the silicone on the Artech case will not stretch out around the port covers as easily as the Otterbox could. The Otterbox has a more accessible design around the Heart Rate Monitor than the Artech case does. The shape and texture of the silicone on the Artech case makes it appear slimmer and feel more secure than the Defender.
The biggest negative to the Artech case in my opinion in comparison to the Otterbox case; is the lack of a holster. A device this size in a thick case isn’t as convenient in a pocket. This is a personal preference however, I know many people that do not use a holster. It would be nice if a holster for the Artech was available as an add-on item.
The greatest perk to the Artech case is it is 25% of the price of the Otterbox. A second or third one could be purchased as a backups and still come out under the cost of one Defender.
I did receive this case from the vendor at a discount for the purposes of reviewing the product.
* I'll add pictures later as I have them on a different device

Cheap knockoff of this case:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B013D..._rd_t=36701&pf_rd_p=2068141862&pf_rd_i=mobile

nevermind

Chuckd610 said:
Cheap knockoff of this case:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B013D..._rd_t=36701&pf_rd_p=2068141862&pf_rd_i=mobile
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
first of all , our product is not cheap at all . We are better than the Chinese Copycat
2nd , we do try to take advantage from UAG , But not the Chinese Supcase
3rd , Do you mind to try out out product before you said something very offensive ?

Artech21-Offical said:
first of all , our product is not cheap at all . We are better than the Chinese Copycat
2nd , we do try to take advantage from UAG , But not the Chinese Supcase
3rd , Do you mind to try out out product before you said something very offensive ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah

Otterbox vs UAG

I just got a OnePlus 8T+ 5G today ( T-Mobile ) and need to get a case. For my last two phones, I have used UAG and I have been happy with them. Reading the specs, it seems like Otterbox has testing above and beyond what UAG does (milspec) so I am considering that option too, but the back of the Otterbox cases feels a bit smoother and less grippy than UAG.
Two options I am considering:
Sites-ob_us-Site
OtterBox cases, power, screen protection, and accessories protect and empower your digital world.
www.otterbox.com
Monarch Series Cases | Urban Armor Gear
The UAG Monarch Series protective cases are the most rugged and durable on the market. They offer military drop-test protection for all your Apple, Samsung, Huawei, Motorola, Google, Microsoft, HP, and LG products.
www.urbanarmorgear.com
Only $10 price difference, so that isn't a factor. My main concern is protecting the phone. The UAG seems to provide good protection and feels a bit more grippy than the Otterbox, but I know Otterbox is a known solid design.
Any thoughts on those two?

I have both. I'm kind of a case hoarder, trying to find the perfect case. I drop my phone often because my hands randomly spasm.
Which case is better comes down to 1 question: will you be using anything other than your phone in the case?
The OtterBox + glass screen protector did well. The UAG + screen protector didn't do nearly as well. It broke more often, faster.
If you're sticking anything additional in, like a thin metal plate for sticking to magnetic holders like you put in your car, it will be too thick for either case. I rather like using a lanyard and found this thin pad that sits behind a phone and had a strap coming out the charging hole of your case with a small keychain loop....even that's too thick. The metal sheet or my thin pad causes the screen protector to protrude too far out from the case. 1 drop and they'll break.
Bare phone, either will work very well.
If I had to pick between them protection wise, the OtterBox probably has it.
If you have your heart set on the UAG, I have a better suggestion: get the Poetic Affinity case. It's less than half the price and better IMO than the UAG.
Poetic Affinity Series Designed for OnePlus 8T Case, Rugged Lightweight Military Grade Hybrid Protective Bumper Cover, Clear : Amazon.ca: Electronics
Poetic Affinity Series Designed for OnePlus 8T Case, Rugged Lightweight Military Grade Hybrid Protective Bumper Cover, Clear : Amazon.ca: Electronics
www.amazon.ca
A case very similar to the OtterBox but maybe with BETTER protection is the Spigen Tough Armor. It has these yellow foam pads inside, and is similar to hold. It's technically 2 pieces but in the real world it appears very very similar to OtterBox if not better.
Amazon.com: Spigen Tough Armor Designed for Oneplus 8T Case (2020) - Black: Electronics
Buy Spigen Tough Armor Designed for Oneplus 8T Case (2020) - Black: Basic Cases - Amazon.com ✓ FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases
www.amazon.com
Virtually every single case has the same flaw though: there is a very bad soft spot in the case...every case....over the ring mode selector slider (silent\vibrate\ring). Some cases it's not quite as bad than others. But it's been present on every case I've tried except 2. And those cases fixed the issue by sandwiching the phone in between 2 hard pieces:
One was a heavy as hell all metal case that's a MONSTER in size and weight, and most people will hate, but does an incredible job protecting the phone. And it uses any old 3rd party glass screen protector. Your floor will be dented by falls, not your phone! (this is currently my case).
Amazon.com: Feitenn Oneplus 8T Metal Case, Oneplus 8T Case Heavy Duty, Hard Cover Armor Military Bumper Shockproof Defenderr Protective Soft Rubber Men Gift Outdoor with Screen Protector for Oneplus 8T - Black
Amazon.com: Feitenn Oneplus 8T Metal Case, Oneplus 8T Case Heavy Duty, Hard Cover Armor Military Bumper Shockproof Defenderr Protective Soft Rubber Men Gift Outdoor with Screen Protector for Oneplus 8T - Black
www.amazon.com
The other is the Supcase Unicorn Beetle Pro... an all plastic case that doesn't let you use a glass screen protector, you have to use their built in thin film screen protector that SUCKS and makes the case useless. It doesn't have the so called soft spot. But the lack of glass screen protector kills it for me.
It does come with a not so great belt holster though if anyone wants that.
Amazon.com: SUPCASE Unicorn Beetle Pro Series Case Designed for OnePlus 8T (2020), Full-Body Rugged Holster Case with Built-in Screen Protector for OnePlus 8T 5G (Tilt)
Buy SUPCASE Unicorn Beetle Pro Series Case Designed for OnePlus 8T (2020), Full-Body Rugged Holster Case with Built-in Screen Protector for OnePlus 8T 5G (Tilt): Holsters - Amazon.com ✓ FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases
www.amazon.com

cookiemonster79 said:
I just got a OnePlus 8T+ 5G today ( T-Mobile ) and need to get a case. For my last two phones, I have used UAG and I have been happy with them. Reading the specs, it seems like Otterbox has testing above and beyond what UAG does (milspec) so I am considering that option too, but the back of the Otterbox cases feels a bit smoother and less grippy than UAG.
Two options I am considering:
Sites-ob_us-Site
OtterBox cases, power, screen protection, and accessories protect and empower your digital world.
www.otterbox.com
Monarch Series Cases | Urban Armor Gear
The UAG Monarch Series protective cases are the most rugged and durable on the market. They offer military drop-test protection for all your Apple, Samsung, Huawei, Motorola, Google, Microsoft, HP, and LG products.
www.urbanarmorgear.com
Only $10 price difference, so that isn't a factor. My main concern is protecting the phone. The UAG seems to provide good protection and feels a bit more grippy than the Otterbox, but I know Otterbox is a known solid design.
Any thoughts on those two?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The UAG is available on Amazon
However the case doesnt really protect the screen the lips are not raise enough.
Its too Flush
I choose the Poetic Affinity instead not only its cheaper
the lips in the front actually protect the screen

hoodred said:
The UAG is available on Amazon
However the case doesnt really protect the screen the lips are not raise enough.
Its too Flush
I choose the Poetic Affinity instead not only its cheaper
the lips in the front actually protect the screen
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Idk what case you're talking about but I have the uag case on my 8t and the edges stick up above the sides of the screen where if I lay it down screen first the screen doesn't touch the surface

rcummings100 said:
If you have your heart set on the UAG, I have a better suggestion: get the Poetic Affinity case. It's less than half the price and better IMO than the UAG.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If the Poetic Affinity for the 8t is anything like the one on the 3t, that thing can take a beating

IMO i have had multiple (4) phones (samsung, oneplus and pixel) and I have used uag with a dbrand skin underneath and it's always been an awesome mix for looks for me

spart0n said:
Idk what case you're talking about but I have the uag case on my 8t and the edges stick up above the sides of the screen where if I lay it down screen first the screen doesn't touch the surface
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not as high as Poetic.
UAG Lips raised only top,bottom and about 1/5 on the sides.
Poetic all edges top, bottom and both sides lips are raised.

hoodred said:
The UAG is available on Amazon
However the case doesnt really protect the screen the lips are not raise enough.
Its too Flush
I choose the Poetic Affinity instead not only its cheaper
the lips in the front actually protect the screen
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey, I'm thinking of taking affinity or uag, depending on this following question: do poetic cases get yellow over time?
*I found something on google that says that uag plasma cases stay pure transparent, but nothing useful about poetic

cutade said:
Hey, I'm thinking of taking affinity or uag, depending on this following question: do poetic cases get yellow over time?
*I found something on google that says that uag plasma cases stay pure transparent, but nothing useful about poetic
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've still got an old note 8 still in the uag case from day 1 and it hasn't changed color at all.

cookiemonster79 said:
I just got a OnePlus 8T+ 5G today ( T-Mobile ) and need to get a case. For my last two phones, I have used UAG and I have been happy with them. Reading the specs, it seems like Otterbox has testing above and beyond what UAG does (milspec) so I am considering that option too, but the back of the Otterbox cases feels a bit smoother and less grippy than UAG.
Two options I am considering:
Sites-ob_us-Site
OtterBox cases, power, screen protection, and accessories protect and empower your digital world.
www.otterbox.com
Monarch Series Cases | Urban Armor Gear
The UAG Monarch Series protective cases are the most rugged and durable on the market. They offer military drop-test protection for all your Apple, Samsung, Huawei, Motorola, Google, Microsoft, HP, and LG products.
www.urbanarmorgear.com
Only $10 price difference, so that isn't a factor. My main concern is protecting the phone. The UAG seems to provide good protection and feels a bit more grippy than the Otterbox, but I know Otterbox is a known solid design.
Any thoughts on those two?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Over the past 8 year I’ve had 5 otterbox defenders. They all served well. My biggest issue with them is there is always going to be a thin section that always breaks over time. That all truly depends on how much it drops and how hard it drops. Some of them come with their own screen protection which can be convenient but also annoying. They don’t bind to the screen so it can cause unresponsive touches. Otterboxes do come with port covers to protect from dust.
I tried out UAG 2.5 years ago and it outlasted all of my otter boxes. And it’s still going strong. It barely even has a scratch on it. It’s been accidentally ran over by a Ford 150 too lol. Nothing is breaking on it. Nothing is warped. It’s taken harder falls than all my otterboxes and it is still perfectly intact. UAG does not come dust covers. I will point out that the dust covers fall apart and they damage your phone chargers because they always push on them. Dust covers can also damage your ports because it’s pushing your chargers on the side of them. I’ve had 2 charge ports go bad because of that. Newer phones now are waterproof/water resistant so it won’t hurt your phone just to wash the dust out. So to be honest dust covers are not necessary and are more inconvenient now.
My personal preference is a UAG + Zagg screen protector. Zaggs have a lifetime warranty. You buy one and it’s good for the remainder of the phone’s life or if you buy another phone that is compatible to it. Iphone 11 and 12s use the same protector size.
I dropped using otterboxes when I discovered UAGs. They are the toughest phone cases I’ve ever had. I even had Specks that were more durable than my otterboxes. Otterboxes cost more and seem to be a lot less durable from my experience.

rcummings100 said:
Virtually every single case has the same flaw though: there is a very bad soft spot in the case...every case....over the ring mode selector slider (silent\vibrate\ring). Some cases it's not quite as bad than others. But it's been present on every case I've tried except 2. And those cases fixed the issue by sandwiching the phone in between 2 hard pieces:
One was a heavy as hell all metal case that's a MONSTER in size and weight, and most people will hate, but does an incredible job protecting the phone. And it uses any old 3rd party glass screen protector. Your floor will be dented by falls, not your phone! (this is currently my case).
Amazon.com: Feitenn Oneplus 8T Metal Case, Oneplus 8T Case Heavy Duty, Hard Cover Armor Military Bumper Shockproof Defenderr Protective Soft Rubber Men Gift Outdoor with Screen Protector for Oneplus 8T - Black
Amazon.com: Feitenn Oneplus 8T Metal Case, Oneplus 8T Case Heavy Duty, Hard Cover Armor Military Bumper Shockproof Defenderr Protective Soft Rubber Men Gift Outdoor with Screen Protector for Oneplus 8T - Black
www.amazon.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm currently on a search for a rugged case and came across your post. Are you still using the metal case? If so, do you mind giving us a quick recap of how it's holding up after all these months? and would you recommend it over other cases?
Thanks!

gravewormx said:
I'm currently on a search for a rugged case and came across your post. Are you still using the metal case? If so, do you mind giving us a quick recap of how it's holding up after all these months? and would you recommend it over other cases?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
don't do metal unless you want signal issues!
I recommend: https://www.supcase.com/products/oneplus-8t-unicorn-beetle-pro-full-body-case-black