Hey everyone.
I love Samsung and I love iPhone. Spent years playing about with roms on previous galaxy devices and just as much jail breaking iPhones so I'm not a real Apple boff just here to ask a question designed to bring down the edge over my iPhone 6.
I love the look of the edge and I've been thinking of trading in my iPhone 6 or one but I'm hearing so much about problems with screen, battery and other little niggly problems so I'm beginning to question would the trade be worth it?
Just looking for user experience preferably from someone who has both devices. I'm attracted to the edge specs and possible great battery life. I love my iPhone so need to feel the trade will make my smartphone experience even better! Thanks
Sent from my iPhone 6 using Tapatalk
That is a 100% subjective question. No one can answer that except you...
There are always pro and con.
Agreed, it is subjective. My battery life has been good, but I wouldn't say awesome. Compared to my HTC M7 it's roughly the same. I can get through the day and not have to charge until bed.
The plusses for me, screen is awesome, camera is great, phone is really fast.
Cons, no root, yet, if at all, but I knew that coming in and am ok with that.
Your milage may vary, and hope my input helps.
Sent from my SM-G925V using XDA Free mobile app
I came from an HTC One M7 which was the best smartphone i had ever bought to that point. Now using the Galaxy S6 Edge this is my new favorite smartphone ever and I have had most of the flagships over the years. I had an iPhone for a short while as well and the camera on this thing is amazing, I had zero issues with screen or any other defects, and battery life has been really solid for me as well. And the speaker is super loud
Related
Alright Nexus One boys, I have a decision to make.
I currently own the Samsung Vibrant. Great phone but here are some problems I have with it:
- The feel of it. I absolutely hate the plasticky feel of it
- Samsung support - need I say more?
- Believe or not the display. the sAMOLED is nice, but the brightness is just too much on my eyes
Someone is offering a NEW nexus one for t-mobile to trade for my Vibrant.
I know the nexus one has a nice build, and the crazy development for it, but is this a good deal. I don't know of the battery life for the phone or anything. I know you are all pretty biased, but please help me make the best decision I can. Should I do it?!?
My brother has a Vibrant and its nice don't get me wrong, but we have conpared it with my Nexus and I win mist of the time. Nexus has a better build quality and the development on it is far greater than Samsung.
I would make the trade in my opinion. Good luck.
-------------------------------------
Sent via the XDA Tapatalk App
I had a Vibrant, and I loved the screen, but I hated Sammy's botched software and the long wait for Froyo, so I traded for a Nexus One. The only thing I miss is the screen(well I could do with out that silly trackball), but it sounds like that may not be as big of an issue for you. I don't regret trading, so I'd say go for it.
I bought a n1 and plan on selling my Samsung Captivate because of these reasons:
1) Non-functional GPS on the captivate/vibrant - it MAY work sometimes, but you cant depend on it
2) LAG FEST - even with lag fixes (voodoo, oclf, etc), it still does not feel as snappy as other android phones
3) slow development - yes, the phones are new, but it really is taking off slowly.
The super AMOLED screen is nice (especially in the sun), but it SUCKS battery.
Only thing Im worried about is the not-as-responsive touch screen on the nexus one
hmm, it seems I might end up going for this trade.
The only thing that is of concern to me now is the battery life. It wasn't great, my vibrant did get me home after a 8 hour day with 70% battery life left.
I know battery has been a problem on the Nexus - how much juice are you guys getting out of it, and is it good enough?
A little background on my phone history. Started with the iPhone 4 as my first real smart phone, then moved to the Galaxy S2, then back to the iPhone 4S, then I made the jump back to Android and got the HTC One X which was my favorite device until a spilled beer ended its life. I quickly moved on and got the iPhone 5 on an upgrade, noticed how stale the design and operating system was. So that finally led my to trade the iPhone 5 for the Galaxy Note 2 and haven't looked back since.
The HTC One initially impressed me with its "unibody" aluminum design and the 1080p screen. It's a given that the Note 2 isn't satisfying me in terms of build quality since my 2 favorite phones I have had hardware wise have been the HTC One X and iPhone 5. But the Note 2 has a fantastic screen, and its size has really grown on me. Yes the Note 2 in terms of PPI isn't as great as the iPhone 5 or HTC One X, but in all honesty, I really struggle noticing a difference in that department since the contrast of the screen is quite nice.
The two things that are making me question this purchase is the screen size and battery life. I went back to hold my dead One X the other day and immediately missed the hardware and build quality, which is impressive since it is made out of plastic. However, the difference in screen size of the Note II's 5.5" screen to the One X's 4.7" screen is quite a jump. And I have gotten very used to the battery life of the Note, easily getting 6+ hours of screen on time still 20% left.
So there are my concerns; I'm curious if anyone else has any thoughts and opinions on these two phones and what they would ultimately decide one.
I recently got rid of my note 2 and am getting the one.
It all depends on what matters to you on the phone.
^^^^^ Aren't you the only person who can answer that question satisfactorily? ... Unless people know EXACTLY what you want from a phone, thy won't know which one is the right one for the job
Personally I've always had HTC except for a couple of very unpleasant and fortunately short-lived episodes with an iPhone and an LG thing, so I'd be in no position to advise on a choice. As for screen size and batery life .. I never got less that 8 hours from my One-X, and I couldn't get a note to work for me when I held it in in one hand and tried to swipe/gesture with my thumb. The One-X size was perfect for me so the One is my ideal choice for a replacement.
Thank you for your thread op . This is the one I'd like to know..... Going to get my first high end phone so I'm thinking not to screw up as it happened with my galaxy tab...
A good advice will be Helpful.
Tapatalked with galaxy tab and SwiftKey Flow
The one, has a slow motion camera. Take that into consideration.
Sent from my LG-LS840 using xda app-developers app
Just about to do the same thing... hopefully i can resell my note 2 for almost the same amount as a One.
Threevo said:
The one, has a slow motion camera. Take that into consideration.
Sent from my LG-LS840 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well note has that too
I would keep the Note 2 just because of the big screen and the SPen. All new phones will have better processors and better screens. So its just a question of money how often you want to switch your phone.
I wont replace my Note 2 for a phone with a smaler screen and no pen. I do not want to give up the two things.
radiotrib said:
^^^^^ Aren't you the only person who can answer that question satisfactorily? ... Unless people know EXACTLY what you want from a phone, thy won't know which one is the right one for the job
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indeed - There's so many arguments for and against one or the other (please pardon the pun ) that it's just a matter a personal preference. I'd wait until the One gets to a store near you and compare them side by side for yourself. Then you should know. :good:
Never
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
I first want to say that over the years i've had the resource of XDA to let me get the most out of my phones and really appreciate everyone on the site. I'm a huge phone nerd and have owned the following to give some perspective.
HTC EVO 4g
HTC EVO 3D
Samsung Galaxy 2 (Epic 4g Touch)
Samsung Galaxy Nexus
HTC EVO 4g LTE
Samsung Galaxy S3
Apple Iphone 5
and so Ive been on both sides of the HTC v. Samsung war and even tried the iphone(2 weeks and couldnt stand it)each time I try a HTC I come rushing back to the galaxy series. Now that I have the S4 and decided not to even try the One. I decided to write a quick review after the inital 24 hour period.
Got the phone at BB simply due to the amount they were giving me for the S3($250), got the phone and right out of the gate did a factory reset, set the phone up and disabled/removed all the bloatware I could(granted not that much). The build quality is something that is not given its fair due because it still is plastic, but it is a solid high quality phone and rivals any phone ive held.
The screen is hands down the best ive seen including the LCD used in the HTC's and the Iphone. With all the new features and sensors the phone does almost anything you can think of like waking up when the sensors realize you are reaching for the phone! Also another cool thing is controlling my Direct TV or TV with my phone!
The sound quality is much improved over the S3 and I bring this up mainly in terms of bluetooth streaming, bringing back all the gestures the music player is VERY nice.
The 4.2.2 menus do take a little to get used to and this is coming from a touchwiz user for years, but make the experience much more streamlined once you get familiar.
Nothing I have thrown at the phone yet has even slowed it down, from syncing all of my accounts, playing music and browsing the phone all at the same time the phone just keeps chugging along. Which even makes the S3 look slow.
Now on to what has reall impressed me so far and thats the battery life, I charged the phone fully while powered off once i got the phone and trying to run the battery down to allow me to do another full charge has proved to be a chore. With HEAVY wifi, screen time and app use and standby overnight im still at 36% battery!!
All in all i know its only the first day of owning the phone, but i couldnt be any happier or impressed. The hard part is waiting for accesories to come out.
But for anyone on the fence or not sure I would say take the plunge you won't be disappointed, and you will have the best phone out!
Good stuff. Yes, I agree. Some of the gesture features are actually quite awesome....and I've never been a big fan of gestures. But the wake up by reaching towards the phone feature is awesome. I used it twice (unfortunately) last night when I woke up in the middle of the night and wanted to know what time it was.
And yes, the battery life is fantastic. On the first couple of charges, I averaged about 4 hours of screen on time and that's also accounting for me being in a weak 3g area and leaving my mobile data on (for testing purposes).
I also want to add(it won't let me edit my original post) is that i usually always HAVE TERRIBLE service at work and since ive had this phone can actually make and receive calls and texts. And while around town data has been MUCH improved, streaming pandora is no longer something I could only dream of but a reality(with the high quality audio enabled). Browsing the web has been much quicker.
If anyone has questions feel free to ask.
i dont have the phone yet...im still debating if its much of an upgrade frkm the s3....but i do wanna know if it has the feature where u can be on the phone and can browse the net at the same time (s3 has this feature)...tia...
Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2
Thanks for the review. I have the note 2 so I'm debating to get the s4 or wait for note 3. Any dislikes on the s4?
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda premium
musclehead84 said:
Thanks for the review. I have the note 2 so I'm debating to get the s4 or wait for note 3. Any dislikes on the s4?
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nothing yet, though I'm coming from the E4GT so of course it seems a lot better.
It does not have this for 3g, but i have been able to do so while on wifi and have read it is capable while on LTE.
The s3 did do this while on 3g, this might be the only thing ive noticed that the s3 has the ability to do but not the s4.
No i have no dislikes so far for the s4, i think the 5in screen on the s4 is perfect. Ive messed around with the note2 and just not my cup of tea...but in regards to the s4 it has better specs than the note2 while still having a big screen.
musclehead84 said:
Thanks for the review. I have the note 2 so I'm debating to get the s4 or wait for note 3. Any dislikes on the s4?
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok.....I'll bite.
#1 --> Price is too high. Note 2 premiered at this price but is larger and has a digitizer (Phablet). Way overpriced in my opinion compared to other new devices (at least on Sprint).
Coming from the S3, I find the build for the S4 very cheap feeling. It has a bit of a "hollow" sound to it. Also do not like the body style compared to the S3. It is boxier, more like the iphone5 with the chrome ring around it, and doesn't feel as good in my hand. When putting it to my ear it digs in a bit and not comfortable. I would rather see the power button back on top and not stick out so much. Last thing for now is how the camera sticks out (unlike the S3) and the phone sits right down on it.
Once I get a good case for it a lot of these gripes will disappear for me. However, for the cost of the device I was hoping for more.
There are far more positives than negatives but you didn't ask for those.
Do I think it is a worthwhile upgrade from the S3? Only if you have an upgrade to burn or upgrade every time a new phone comes out. Otherwise, an S3 with the right custom rom and tweaks gives a pretty good experience.
My $0.02.
Op.. you said that BB gave you $250 for the S3? How does that work if you don't mind me asking. Do they offer some type of trade in deal or was your contact up? I still have a year to go but the HTC one and the S4 seem very interesting
Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2
musclehead84 said:
Thanks for the review. I have the note 2 so I'm debating to get the s4 or wait for note 3. Any dislikes on the s4?
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My only dislike is how slippery the battery cover is. Coming from the E4GT I got used to the textured battery cover. Its nothing a good case wouldn't fix
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda premium
http://www.bestbuytradein.com/bb/QuoteCalculator.cfm?category=mobile-phones
Find your phone on there and print the value off(just in case they try to hassel you) but take the phone in with the charger and anything you have like box or anything(just to ensure you get the highest value)
if you are not out of contract you might want to swap an old phone on your line so the One is not tied to the account. but my S3 was on my line and I didnt have an issue, but they put the value of the phone on a giftcard and then use that gift card towards the s4.
They buy back alot of stuff, i had a couple ps3 games and what not, but just find the value and go to a store.
Hi there, bought a galaxy note 3 a couple months back - then bought 4 nexus 5s.. sold 3 which covered the cost of the 4th one.
In short I pretty much got a nexus 5 for free thanks to google's lack of stock.
Coming from the note 3, the nexus 5 felt very nice to use, even with the same internals the N5 felt significantly faster. Not sure whether its due to kitkat optimizations or the lack of bloatwiz.
Been using it for a week so Ive pretty much got my thoughts straight. Build quality is supurb, love the feel in hand, and the thing looks so damn sexy.The screen is lovely, one of the best Ive seen. Camera is okay, dissapointing compared to some of the other flagships but hey, who cares its a smartphone. most of the photos taken will be compressed to use on facebook/instagram. Speaker is also pissweak.. Sound that comes out is quite good, just lacking any sort of volume.
However, the biggest problem for me atleast is the battery life, coming from a note 3 I was used to whacking the thing on charge after a heavies day of use with it still at 50%. With the N5 I can barely get through a whole day.
So here comes my topic: If only the screen was enlarged to phablet territory, and the battery was then boosted (thanks to the bigger chassis) this would be the perfect phone. The camera and speaker failiage I have learnt to live with, but the battery life was sub par (dont get me wrong, its not terrible as far as other phones go.. On par with apples offerings) Imagine a 5.5-6 inch nexus with a bigger battery keeping the same design language. Wowy!
Thoughts?
P.S
Going to keep using the N5 until cyanogen comes out for the note 3.. Touchwiz was too annoying for me.
Riimez said:
Hi there, bought a galaxy note 3 a couple months back - then bought 4 nexus 5s.. sold 3 which covered the cost of the 4th one.
In short I pretty much got a nexus 5 for free thanks to google's lack of stock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow. Are you proud of doing that? Because of ppl like you the stock is even shorter. People like you get a special place in hell. Hope CM hurries with the Note.
To the topic. Not really a phablet. 5 inch are the max. The N5s battery lasts me more than through one day so no need for a bigger battery here.
Accidentally thanked you...
TobiS87 said:
Wow. Are you proud of doing that? Because of ppl like you the stock is even shorter. People like you get a special place in hell. Hope CM hurries with the Note.
To the topic. Not really a phablet. 5 inch are the max. The N5s battery lasts me more than through one day so no need for a bigger battery here.
Accidentally thanked you...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha.. Selling them straight away - gives people a chance who missed out on the initial order batch to buy them.. For a small premium of course.
I would have bought one anyway, which means the number of people owning a nexus 5 is the same whether I bought 3 or not
Riimez said:
Haha.. Selling them straight away - gives people a chance who missed out on the initial order batch to buy them.. For a small premium of course.
I would have bought one anyway, which means the number of people owning a nexus 5 is the same whether I bought 3 or not
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wouldn't have missed out if you didn't buy 4, maybe those 3 people went to order behind you hut couldn't because you got three lol
Sent from my SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
its a bit like the sneaker phenomenon, ppl wait in line to buy shoes then more ppl wait in line cuz they realized they can sell it to make a profit. prices of products become inflated. some products get extremely inflated as in the case of the iphone 5s gold.
Firstly I think you need to edit your title, it's a bit misleading.
But I would not classify the Nexus 5 as having sub par battery life, its got decent battery when compared with devices in its class.
Comparing it's battery life to a bigger device with a significantly bigger battery isn't really a fair comparison.
Riimez said:
Hi there, bought a galaxy note 3 a couple months back - then bought 4 nexus 5s.. sold 3 which covered the cost of the 4th one.
In short I pretty much got a nexus 5 for free thanks to google's lack of stock.
Coming from the note 3, the nexus 5 felt very nice to use, even with the same internals the N5 felt significantly faster. Not sure whether its due to kitkat optimizations or the lack of bloatwiz.
Been using it for a week so Ive pretty much got my thoughts straight. Build quality is supurb, love the feel in hand, and the thing looks so damn sexy.The screen is lovely, one of the best Ive seen. Camera is okay, dissapointing compared to some of the other flagships but hey, who cares its a smartphone. most of the photos taken will be compressed to use on facebook/instagram. Speaker is also pissweak.. Sound that comes out is quite good, just lacking any sort of volume.
However, the biggest problem for me atleast is the battery life, coming from a note 3 I was used to whacking the thing on charge after a heavies day of use with it still at 50%. With the N5 I can barely get through a whole day.
So here comes my topic: If only the screen was enlarged to phablet territory, and the battery was then boosted (thanks to the bigger chassis) this would be the perfect phone. The camera and speaker failiage I have learnt to live with, but the battery life was sub par (dont get me wrong, its not terrible as far as other phones go.. On par with apples offerings) Imagine a 5.5-6 inch nexus with a bigger battery keeping the same design language. Wowy!
Thoughts?
P.S
Going to keep using the N5 until cyanogen comes out for the note 3.. Touchwiz was too annoying for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Screw you ! Blasted hungry animal.... If you had $1600 floating around you could afford to buy just one outright....
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
I feel into the pot of the Isheep and bought an Iphone 6 PLUS....
what a pile of over inflated (price and design) rubbish iphones especially the new inflated Plus, its just like a iphone 5 that's eaten all the pies and is so yawnful I cant stop nodding off using it.
Basically I seriously need help choosing another smartphone other than Apple, I think the news of the apple smartwatch just tipped me over the edge with just how over priced dirge apple products are.
I quite fancy the look of the Note 4 or Nexus 6, but my options are endless as i have the crappiest phone worth the most...weird
I feel u about how over hyped iPhone are. Quite honestly though once u jailbreak them they aren't half bad. I almost miss my 6 plus. That I was using before I got my note edge.
There are soooo many different things to consider before recommending. If a big screen is a must then the note 4 should be the best choice. Already got the lollipop update and all around good running phone with good battery life. Nexus 6 is cool but the battery life isn't near as good on it from what I hear. If size isn't your thing u can't go wrong with the new m9 HTC when it hits the shelves. The galaxy s6 looks good but the non upgradable storage is a thing to consider.
Sent from my SM-N915P using XDA Free mobile app
sand1303 said:
I feel u about how over hyped iPhone are. Quite honestly though once u jailbreak them they aren't half bad. I almost miss my 6 plus. That I was using before I got my note edge.
There are soooo many different things to consider before recommending. If a big screen is a must then the note 4 should be the best choice. Already got the lollipop update and all around good running phone with good battery life. Nexus 6 is cool but the battery life isn't near as good on it from what I hear. If size isn't your thing u can't go wrong with the new m9 HTC when it hits the shelves. The galaxy s6 looks good but the non upgradable storage is a thing to consider.
Sent from my SM-N915P using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the reply, what possible benefit can jailbreaking help ?
You can check out this thread for some ideas already in discussion:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1620179
Personally I like the iPhone 6 Plus. It's got a nice form factor, and price isn't really all that much more than buying a retail Samsung (less than the Edge actually) or some other devices.
Jailbroken it's pretty nice.
Keep in mind you're on an Android / WinPho forum. Most people here hate iOS and iOS is flat out not supported here. If you're making the switch to Android I'd recommend my current phone, the OnePlus One. It is about half the price and the specs are just as good. Certainly there are other options as well as shown in the thread I linked.
What this fine gentleman said ^^^^
Ask in the link above, you'll get far more exposure to your question and likely more opinions.
Many won't see your question here.
I'll close this thread and good luck in your search. :good:
Thanks,
Darth
Forum Moderator