CPU throttling down due to heat - G 2014 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

Let me come straight to the point-- Whenever I do any CPU intensive task for long like playing heavy games, CPU heats up and automatically throttles down to like 998 or 784MHz and games start lagging. Everything starts lagging. This phone heats up pretty quickly. I have no problem with handling a hot phone but I DO NOT want the CPU to throttle down. What's the use of Snapdragon 400 when it can't handle the heat?
How can I prevent it from throttling down? (anything to do with that "thermal" section in kernel adiutor?)

Are you using custom kernel?
In kernel auditor you can set the max temp to start throttling.

JD154 said:
Are you using custom kernel?
In kernel auditor you can set the max temp to start throttling.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using decipher kernel. Where is the temperature setting?

nilanko said:
I am using decipher kernel. Where is the temperature setting?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In Thermal screen you should able to set a maximum temperature to start throttling (I didn't used decipher) extended kernel allow this feature

JD154 said:
In Thermal screen you should able to set a maximum temperature to start throttling (I didn't used decipher) extended kernel allow this feature
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Decipher doesn't have this setting. Can I just turn it off? Titan heats up very quickly so CPU starts getting throttled.

nilanko said:
Decipher doesn't have this setting. Can I just turn it off? Titan heats up very quickly so CPU starts getting throttled.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can't do it because heat will damage the cpu, try changing kernel to extended kernel and try.

JD154 said:
You can't do it because heat will damage the cpu, try changing kernel to extended kernel and try.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was just playing NOVA 3 and it started lagging after a while and saw the CPU ramped down to 784MHz! This is really stupid! What's the use of quad core then?! If I can't even utilize it's potential just due to heat then what's the use? Is there no way to stop it from heating up so much? I switched off all the controls on thermal page but it did nothing. CPU still loves to ramp down.
Is extended kernel available for CM12.1? I can't find it.

nilanko said:
I was just playing NOVA 3 and it started lagging after a while and saw the CPU ramped down to 784MHz! This is really stupid! What's the use of quad core then?! If I can't even utilize it's potential just due to heat then what's the use? Is there no way to stop it from heating up so much? I switched off all the controls on thermal page but it did nothing. CPU still loves to ramp down.
Is extended kernel available for CM12.1? I can't find it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Disable data connection, location, Bluetooth and reduce brightness to the minimum while gaming.
Maybe you have a lot of background process and the cpu load is high. You can try also changing ROM to MM (some optimization and stuff).
Extended kernel is available for 6.0/7.0 AOSP/CM

JD154 said:
Disable data connection, location, Bluetooth and reduce brightness to the minimum while gaming.
Maybe you have a lot of background process and the cpu load is high. You can try also changing ROM to MM (some optimization and stuff).
Extended kernel is available for 6.0/7.0 AOSP/CM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did all that and now I can play a bit more without CPU being throttled down. I also installed halogen kernel that allows to set the temps. I set them to 100 degrees Celsius. No improvement! CPU still throttles down on reaching the default 70 degrees. This phone is totally stupid! We actually can't even use the full potential of the CPU unless we are sitting inside a refrigerator!

A very quick and easy way to fix throttling is flashing a kernel with UnderVolt support.
The only one available for Titan is Halogen Kernel
http://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-g-2014/development/kernel-halogenkernel-r1-t3133042
But be aware that some values still need optimizations, such as 1.4 and 1.5 ghz. They consume more energy than it should, making the phone more warm, but nothing compared to the stock moto values.

Related

[Q] Automatic under clocking when battery is low?

I've noticed that when the battery gets below 35%, many games start lagging. I couldn't figure out what was causing this so I had a hunch that the OS is forcing the cpu to under clock even under heavy use to conserve battery. I installed setcpu and forced the cpu to max and sure enough, the games were playing smooth and home screen transitions were smooth. I did this a few times just to confirm. So is this true? Does the stock OS force the cpu to under clock even under heavy use when the battery is low?
And just to clarify, I'm not talking about cpu throttling. I understand android devices throttle the cpu based on use.
dsmboost said:
I've noticed that when the battery gets below 35%, many games start lagging. I couldn't figure out what was causing this so I had a hunch that the OS is forcing the cpu to under clock even under heavy use to conserve battery. I installed setcpu and forced the cpu to max and sure enough, the games were playing smooth and home screen transitions were smooth. I did this a few times just to confirm. So is this true? Does the stock OS force the cpu to under clock even under heavy use when the battery is low?
And just to clarify, I'm not talking about cpu throttling. I understand android devices throttle the cpu based on use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
setCPU?
It does exactly that. Make a profile for Battery < 35 and set it to your clock speed.
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S II w/ CM9

[Q] CPU frequency throttling

hi all
im using DooMKernel for a while and when i set the maximum frequency for any speed faster than [email protected], when the cpu is on heavy load or when the phone temperature is rising above some threshold (i think it's around 45 degrees, not sure tho) - there is an automatic down throttling to stock valus (max 1.5ghz) and nothing will recover it back to modified values unless reboot or reapplying the OC via SetCPU or equivalent.
now, i know there is a 'thermal control' sort of mechanism, and i also know it probably resides both on os level and sony framework, but i wish i could disable it somehow.
i know there is a great risk of frying my XZ, but im only intend to overclock for short terms and not for a main daily usage.
a quote from DooMLoRD's post on the subject:
It has been observed that the overclocking sometimes reverts back automatically to stock settings especially after heavy CPU load and if the device heats up.
I think have found why this happens:
Android OS level
there is a binary called: /system/bin/thermald which writes lower CPU freq values to the CPU sysfs interface if the device starts heating
there is also an app "Overheat Control" which i suspect is doing something similar
Kernel level
there seems to be some sort of fail-safe in place "msm_dcvs" which resets the CPU to 918Mhz or 1026Mhz or 1512Mhz
could also be some other things i am still searching
now there are ways to circumvent these issues but given the risk of the damage associated with overclock for long time i think its in our best interest to not screw with these fail-safes...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
if someone could plz explain how to totaly disable thermal control - it would be much appreciated.
if you totally disable them your Smartphone will shutdown every time you reach....(cant remember! think it was 75°C) SoC Temp! and you will reach that kinda fast!

High CPU usage and micro shuttering

So I recently installed latest weekly RR again hoping it will be fixed of micro shuttering but nope, so here's what happening 1st cpu usage is 100% temperature are reaching 82°c, 2nd the micro shuttering is still there so I opened matlog and here's what I got I hope you guys can help me :silly: thank you very much :highfive:
https://mega.nz/#!fp0nWYga!Z9Sgco0jmB00E0TXHkbxbjIOMjMoy1QV-hk2t-x1gb8
Mataujo said:
So I recently installed latest weekly RR again hoping it will be fixed of micro shuttering but nope, so here's what happening 1st cpu usage is 100% temperature are reaching 82°c, 2nd the micro shuttering is still there so I opened matlog and here's what I got I hope you guys can help me :silly: thank you very much :highfive:
https://mega.nz/#!fp0nWYga!Z9Sgco0jmB00E0TXHkbxbjIOMjMoy1QV-hk2t-x1gb8
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check your CPU governor. If it's interactive, change it to anything else. The stuttering is caused by thermal throttling. Interactive governor has a bug that causes cpu to max out all the time.
xxBrun0xx said:
Check your CPU governor. If it's interactive, change it to anything else. The stuttering is caused by thermal throttling. Interactive governor has a bug that causes cpu to max out all the time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using the default settings, it's schedutil
This is really killing me.
I deleted the thermal files to as mentioned in the kernel thread
Core control is enabled rest is disabled.
Just see the temperatures!!!
I had the same problems and followed the recommended settings in the kernel thread.
No weird things happening when looking at a task manager. It just ran ridiculously hot all the time. Playing downloaded music through Play Music for example would send the CPU temp to ~90 degrees C.
Back to stock kernel on lineage OS and cool as a cucumber.
Mataujo said:
This is really killing me.
I deleted the thermal files to as mentioned in the kernel thread
Core control is enabled rest is disabled.
Just see the temperatures!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the opposite of what you want. Disable core control, enable msm_thermal. The phone gets warm, but never hot. Also, underclocking dragonxia kernel is VERY important.
xxBrun0xx said:
That's the opposite of what you want. Disable core control, enable msm_thermal. The phone gets warm, but never hot. Also, underclocking dragonxia kernel is VERY important.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't see any option for msm_thermal where do I find it?
xxBrun0xx said:
That's the opposite of what you want. Disable core control, enable msm_thermal. The phone gets warm, but never hot. Also, underclocking dragonxia kernel is VERY important.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually in the dragonxia kernel thread, it says to keep core control enabled.
FusionGhana on AKT app
I was experiencing similar issues on RR. Tried all different kinds of options. Thermal files removed (ofcourse that might have attributed to the hotness of the device since CPU was going crazy). Wanted to follow the instructions on another thread that talked about Insane speeds but couldn't since it talked about setting onDemand Governor and somehow my device does not have that.
Then I started playing around with the Balanced profiles using Advanced Kernel Tweaks app. I am currently on FusionGhana (i think that's the name), and my device is running smoooth. No lags, the device is cool most of the times.
Try it out, see if that works for you
psychedelicNerd said:
I was experiencing similar issues on RR. Tried all different kinds of options. Thermal files removed (ofcourse that might have attributed to the hotness of the device since CPU was going crazy). Wanted to follow the instructions on another thread that talked about Insane speeds but couldn't since it talked about setting onDemand Governor and somehow my device does not have that.
Then I started playing around with the Balanced profiles using Advanced Kernel Tweaks app. I am currently on FusionGhana (i think that's the name), and my device is running smoooth. No lags, the device is cool most of the times.
Try it out, see if that works for you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just be careful not to do this on an EAS kernel. Last I knew there was a bug with the interactive governor that forced CPU to max all cores all the time when interactive is set. Current version of Dragonxia is an EAS kernel and most of the governors in AKT are modified interactive governors.
That being said, I think using less aggressive governors is a great way to reduce the heat. This CPU is very powerful even at lower clock speeds, there's rarely much need to ramp beyond 50% utilization for any real length of time unless you're gaming.
Hmmm. didn't know about this. I am on DragonXia EAS. Not that I know what EAS stands for, but I will try moving to a non-EAS kernel and see if i get any more improvements. Thanks for the info.

[MOD] Thermal mod of T805/T800 boost performance by 150%

I have this tabled for a long time, but as i rarely used it i didn't bother with it much. From day one back in 2014 the tablet was sluggish and laggy, today is just unbearable even for browsing. So i have decided to take a look of what can i do.
I have installed the latest (10.26.2019) LineageOS-14.1-Deathly with gapps nano.
I have installed CPU Throttling Test from the play store and start testing to see what's going on. I saw that the CPU Throttle instantly (like in 10-15 sec max) from 1900mhz to 600mhz, and this is where the sluggishness comes from, the CPU is constantly throttled no matter that you are just looking at a simple web page.
I started playing with the Deathly Adiutor and under-voltage the cpu, set the max to 1400mhz and this is where it is stable as it is. At 1400mhz constant 100% CPU stress the CPU temps are around 90c (at 95 the cpu starts throttling). Anything above 1400mhz even with under voltages CPU results in throttling within 1-2 min, but even like that at 1400mhz and GPU set to be always used and at minimum of 480mhz (with setting in dev options to always use gpu for 2d composition) the performance was really much much better then the stock settings.
I have continued to play with it and noticed that if i apply pressure with my fingers on the back panel just below the camera where is the most hottest, the temps are dropping 10-15C, so i have opened it and i saw the issue.
The issue is that the metal shield radiators does not make a good contact with the thermal pad on the back panel, and thus can't dissipate the heat well. This may variety from user to user as some back panels will make better or worse contact, but its far from ideal.
Its good that i have some spare thermal pads around and i have applied them, and the result is perfect, drop in 12-17Cfrom stock setup under continues stress.
As a final result i have managed to bump the CPU from 1400mhz to 1600mhz with 1087mV voltage and at max 84C (down from around 90 at 1400mhz) at constant 100% CPU stress. The performance gains are around 100 to 150% (At around 42-47k GIPS up from 20-25k GIPS stock in CPU Throttling test). Additionally i have to say, its extremely easy to open the back cover panel.
Furthermore, i made an video to see how it runs and the settings i use.
https://youtu.be/_UJdjPDQB00
I'm attaching before and after the mod photos.
Quick followup, i have run 3D Mark benchmark and PCmark, see the screenshots below. Managed to achieve the world fastest Tab S, enjoy
Awesome.. I followed ur recommendations and set 1087mv at 1600mhz and its fasttttt
rihui said:
Awesome.. I followed ur recommendations and set 1087mv at 1600mhz and its fasttttt
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks mate. I'm glad it helps According to 3DMark, the performance now is slightly better then Galaxy Tab A 2019, it really bring new life to this tablet and its ready to rock another couple of years
how's your battery life with minimum CPU speed at 1600
Screen on & Standby time?
rihui said:
how's your battery life with minimum CPU speed at 1600
Screen on & Standby time?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its not the minimum CPU frequency that gives you the performance boost, its the maximum frequency limit at 1600mhz down from 1900mhz, as i explained, to gain the performance, you need to avoid CPU from overheating and throttle down itself to the ground. That's why the max frequency with the thermal pads and improved thermals is 300mhz below the stock 1900mhz, and without the pads my max stable frequency were 1400mhz (500mhz below stock).
The minimum frequency will only smooth out initial animations and things like that, but don't have much of an impact on the overall performance. With that said, increasing the minimum frequency ofc will eat more battery and you don't need it, you can safely set it to 650mhz (as low as it allows) and depending on your kernel governor policy should have the same or better battery life. As i said, the main gainer is preventing the CPU from overheating at 1900mhz and throttle down to 650mhz where it sits most of the time with stock settings.
In fact if you limit your max frequency to 1400 or 1600mhz depending on your stable thermal results, and set minimum to 650mhz, you will see the performance gain AND significantly increased battery life due to that CPU does not go to 1900mhz and does not eat that much power and voltage. You really need to fine tune it depending on your needs, but at stock CPU throttling down to 650mhz and staying there is an manufacturer (Samsung) failure, and if i were discovered this when i bought it, i would wanted refund, as they advertise 1900mhz CPU which almost never works at that frequency.
I tested this method on other tablets and phones, and while it happens on other devices to throttle down after 5-7 mins (not after 15 sec), i have never seen to throttle more then down to 80% of the advertised frequency, but the Tab S goes almost immediately down to 35% where it stays and cripple the device. Its really really bad engineering from Samsung.
Going to try this.
Thanks
A lot better .
What thickness of thermal pad should I buy? Probably will buy from Amazon unless I need to make a trip to Microcenter. Thanks for this suggestion @nauvho
osutx427 said:
What thickness of thermal pad should I buy? Probably will buy from Amazon unless I need to make a trip to Microcenter. Thanks for this suggestion @nauvho
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well as you can see on the picture, the CPU bed already has one black pad by Samsung by default which is around 0.2/0.3mm i think, but it does not make contact, so i put on the CPU radiator 1mm pad and on the other radiators i put 0.5mm to equalize in case my pad is too thick. Your guide should be how easy is to close the back-plate, if you need too much force you may need thinner. So i guess you can take 0.3, 0.5 and 1mm pads.
effing A
Wow
Applied the same settings that you show in the video and WOW! It's like a new tablet. I didn't even put thermal pads.
joelcool69 said:
Applied the same settings that you show in the video and WOW! It's like a new tablet. I didn't even put thermal pads.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nice
just rooted t800 with MM + trw + SU.
added some thermal pads like in the pics.
installed Deathly Adiutor ....which said that doesn't like the kernel..and doesn't let to change the cpu max speed, and the voltage page doesn't even exist
installed Kernel Adiutor from playstore with which I can lower the freq, and for 1600 it works 1-2min at 27-28000GIPS then starts to throttle
louis_alphons said:
just rooted t800 with MM + trw + SU.
added some thermal pads like in the pics.
installed Deathly Adiutor ....which said that doesn't like the kernel..and doesn't let to change the cpu max speed, and the voltage page doesn't even exist
installed Kernel Adiutor from playstore with which I can lower the freq, and for 1600 it works 1-2min at 27-28000GIPS then starts to throttle
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why are you using MM? Also, did you noticed that center pad is thicker and side ones are tinnier? what are your CPU temps? Also probably due to MM, but I'm getting around 42gpis (average) at 1.6, but you should really check your pads placement, thickness and temps, put the CPU under load note the temps before throttling down.
nauvho said:
Why are you using MM? Also, did you noticed that center pad is thicker and side ones are tinnier? what are your CPU temps? Also probably due to MM, but I'm getting around 42gpis (average) at 1.6, but you should really check your pads placement, thickness and temps, put the CPU under load note the temps before throttling down.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using MM since I don't know if it worth to upgrade; does this LineageOS work well...all features (cam, scanner, soud etc) works with it?
used 1mm pad over the cpu... 0.5 otherwise (china made); also removed the small factory pad and placed another pad patch there; the back cover heats well and I assume that the heat doesn't have where to go.
since it's not throttling at 1600MHZ (almost 100%, take a look at the pic)...from where to get more than 28GIPS?
louis_alphons said:
I'm using MM since I don't know if it worth to upgrade; does this LineageOS work well...all features (cam, scanner, soud etc) works with it?
used 1mm pad over the cpu... 0.5 otherwise (china made); also removed the small factory pad and placed another pad patch there; the back cover heats well and I assume that the heat doesn't have where to go.
since it's not throttling at 1600MHZ (almost 100%, take a look at the pic)...from where to get more than 28GIPS?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think removing the stock black pad were a good idea, I did not removed mine, my pad is next to it. Also CPU throttle app is not reliable to monitor cpu temp (at least for me) , you should do it by starting the throttle test and then switch to deathly auditor and monitor the temp and clock there or other app like CPUz or Aida. Look at the video how I monitored the temp. The CPU will start throttle at 93-95c so your temp of 81 cannot be accurate if it throttle. Didn't you said that you throttle at 1.6 in your previous post?
Regarding the performance I think it might be eigher app difference between mm and 7.1 or due to MM itself. And yes everything is working perfectly for me with lineage, camera, fingerprint, everything is fine and it is mile better then MM imo.
installed 7.1
pcmark 4330 with your mods.
so the thermal pads doesn't matter on MM.
from my testings on 7.1 the boost in pcmark comes form setting max freq 1600 + undervoltage (3000->3500), and another boost...by setting the lower freq to 1600 (3500->4300)
louis_alphons said:
installed 7.1
pcmark 4330 with your mods.
so the thermal pads doesn't matter on MM.
from my testings on 7.1 the boost in pcmark comes form setting max freq 1600 + undervoltage (3000->3500), and another boost...by setting the lower freq to 1600 (3500->4300)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice.
About the pads, they matter only if the CPU temp under load drops when you apply pressure with fingers on the back cover as i explained in my first post, but idk if this apply to all tablets or just mine. The boost comes from not throttling the CPU down and being stable at maximum possible frequency. The CPU can go up to 1900mhz and beyond (2.1 by spec), but the cooling is not enough for that frequencies.
I think that adding an 0.5-1mm copper heat pipe thru radiators or copper heat pads similar to flagship phones might push it to 1.9, will order some someday and try it.
now it will be interesting ?% it's the termal mod in this boost, which means, performing the test in PCMARK only with steps 1+2:
1. LineageOS-14.1-Deathly
2. Deathly Adiutor (which requires step 1) + CPU max freq 1600 + undervoltage at that freq + CPU min freq 1600
3. Thermal pads added inside the box.
Since I started with thermal pads...I can say that in MM it doesn't matter.
-after upgrade to 7.1 as I said..PC...MArk around 3000 (thermal pads mounted)
-after setting max freq 1600 + undervoltage I got a boost in PCMark to 3600
-in addition, with min freq 1600...got another boost..to 4300; in this turbo state..the battery drains quickly, but the interface it's fast like the wind.
PCMark doesn't use CPU at 100%, it counts also how fast cand do certain short tasks...and this matters because if CPU it's in it's low power states..it loose time to rise its freq and do the calc at full power.
louis_alphons said:
now it will be interesting ?% it's the termal mod in this boost, which means, performing the test in PCMARK only with steps 1+2:
1. LineageOS-14.1-Deathly
2. Deathly Adiutor (which requires step 1) + CPU max freq 1600 + undervoltage at that freq + CPU min freq 1600
3. Thermal pads added inside the box.
Since I started with thermal pads...I can say that in MM it doesn't matter.
-after upgrade to 7.1 as I said..PC...MArk around 3000 (thermal pads mounted)
-after setting max freq 1600 + undervoltage I got a boost in PCMark to 3600
-in addition, with min freq 1600...got another boost..to 4300; in this turbo state..the battery drains quickly, but the interface it's fast like the wind.
PCMark doesn't use CPU at 100%, it counts also how fast cand do certain short tasks...and this matters because if CPU it's in it's low power states..it loose time to rise its freq and do the calc at full power.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thermal mode does matter alot, CPU thermals is everything, the lower temps are, the higher frequency you can push the CPU, more frequency = more performance. As i said, without the thermal pads i could not get 1.6ghz to be stable, only 1.4 were stable-ish.
In stock rom, CPU governor and states are set according to the temps with the stock cooling. But if you don't change settings it wont change much. However Samsung engineers did a terrible job with those default settings, so as i explained in my first post only doing the software changes had dramatic impact on the performance because you get the CPU stable even at 1.4, but the thermal mod push it further to 1.6
The true performance benchmark is the 3DMARK (my screenshots 3 and 4 for score "ice storm unlimited" test and "Sling Shot" test) this will push your CPU and GPU to the max, PCMark is more about daily use performance and also can be used to measure battery performance between different settings.
Yes leaving CPU with minimum of 1.6 will drain battery more quickly naturally, is using more power, i leave mine at 1.2 as minimum, but minimum speed should not matter much in benchmarks if you are using the same as mine CPU governor. CPU governor basically tells the CPU how to behave, like how quickly to rise the frequency, for how long and etc.

New galaxy note 4 prevent emmc issue

Is there anything I can do on a new galaxy note 4 to prevent the emmc issue happening in the first place?
There was some talk about preventing overheating?
ghostwheel said:
There was some talk about preventing overheating?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do I need to lower the cpu ghz? Or run some kind of app or program?
Redrainz said:
Do I need to lower the cpu ghz? Or run some kind of app or program?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It might help to lower the CPU speed, but you need access to root and an app to tweak the values.
Avoid gaming which is very demanding on GPU and avoid gaming for long periods of time.
Search also in the Snapdragon forum a good kernel.
Also turn off the fast charging, this can heat too much the phone.
I created a script here. It works very good, it monitors the battery temperature AND all the CPU cores temperatures, and will automatically throttle the phone if temps are too high. You can even kill some apps if the temps are to high (not yet implemented).
The difference with Samsung DVFS or integrated temperature management of kernels is that this one monitors almost all CPU sensors and also the battery, all in complete combination, and it can be easily tweaked (rather than modding a kernel). No battery hog. You can enable USB fast charge, game, etc it will still prevent overheating.
Here is the solution to eMMC error
Hello everyone, I was pretty tired of the eMMC error, and I created a script that completely annihilate this error. This error is due to the phone heating up, and the fact that custom kernels (maybe even the original kernel) don't read the...
forum.xda-developers.com

Categories

Resources