Database Develop

f2fs is not so good for /system

Hi, just reporting my findings on F2FS,
To use system partition in F2FS you need to convert rom, adjust scripts, etc.. so i was trying to find if it worth the hassle
Let's take in consideration two things:
1. F2FS have consistently better write speeds than EXT4 , but the same cant be said for read speeds.
2. EXT4 can become laggy when not trimmed, F2FS is always trimmed,
F2FS makes sense for /data and /cache partition but not for /system... /system partition have almost no changes so its 99% trimmed and usually read only
i used this app https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=vog.com.aiv to benchmark bootup time in seconds
CM11 2305 nightly, /data and /cache in F2FS , only change is /system partition format (less is better)
ext4
32,06
28,55
28,01
28,13
27,08
27,77
f2fs
27,44
28,65
40,91
36,95
28,29
27,46
28,41

thanks for showing, but i still prefer using f2fs on system because some files in /system get called all time(i.e framework-res.apk),but its not that difference, our nand is already fast.

Even if it is not so good, it is still a step in the right direction.
I will probably try it at some point.

DZeros said:
Even if it is not so good, it is still a step in the right direction.
I will probably try it at some point.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
F2fs is good, I'm using it, but Just for partitions with lots of writing operations only, simple as that.
And the big plus is that i don't need to worry with compatible roms and updates, just flash any rom updates, without any conversion, and flash kernel after..
Enviado de meu Nexus 4 usando Tapatalk

opssemnik said:
thanks for showing, but i still prefer using f2fs on system because some files in /system get called all time(i.e framework-res.apk),but its not that difference, our nand is already fast.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Read times for /system are not faster in f2fs, but it's up to you
Enviado de meu Nexus 4 usando Tapatalk

Thank you for pin pointing this out. A lot of people still believe F2FS will make their phones fly for some reason. I've tested a phone with F2FS next to another running EXT4 and there was no real world performance boost or anything of that sort. F2FS got higher benchmark scores. That's it. Its no a placebo effect but in real world performance it makes no difference.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

So, i'm on full F2FS. And i agree with your post. Is there anything i must do to use system as EXT4 or just flash not-f2fs-rom ?

This would explain why there is now a longer than normal delay every single time when I hit the home button that is not noticeable when system is ext4. When on ext4 system this delay was hardly noticeable and with f2fs it seems like there is lag but as soon as it does go home I can then open the app drawer immediately with no lag whatsoever. If it was normally slow or laggy to go home then it took an equal amount of time to open app drawer as the lag existed everywhere, here it is only on the home button.

okanb3 said:
So, i'm on full F2FS. And i agree with your post. Is there anything i must do to use system as EXT4 or just flash not-f2fs-rom ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
flash any rom, and then flash one of those jolinard f2fs kernels with filename ending in auto.. they work with any partition layout!

diogo.sena said:
flash any rom, and then flash one of those jolinard f2fs kernels with filename ending in auto.. they work with any partition layout!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There must be another way, with this method,the rom doesnt boot.

ashishv said:
There must be another way, with this method,the rom doesnt boot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What rom and what kernel exactly did you use?

diogo.sena said:
What rom and what kernel exactly did you use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I flashed velocity rom, rebooted into recovery again and flashed franko kernel 208 f2fs. The phone didnt get past boot logo.
Then i formatted system, flashed velocity ext4 again, this time without installing kernel. Surprisingly, the rom booted, but the phone was asking password to decrypt storage, ehich left it unusable. So i tried to go back to f2fs rom by formatting system and lashing f2fs velocity, but here again the phone didnt boot past the boot screeen. Finally i had to flash formatpartitions.zip , followed by flashing f2fs velocity, and finally the rom booted. BTW my phone was off for 2 days because of this lol.:laugh:

ashishv said:
I flashed velocity rom, rebooted into recovery again and flashed franko kernel 208 f2fs. The phone didnt get past boot logo.
Then i formatted system, flashed velocity ext4 again, this time without installing kernel. Surprisingly, the rom booted, but the phone was asking password to decrypt storage, ehich left it unusable. So i tried to go back to f2fs rom by formatting system and lashing f2fs velocity, but here again the phone didnt boot past the boot screeen. Finally i had to flash formatpartitions.zip , followed by flashing f2fs velocity, and finally the rom booted. BTW my phone was off for 2 days because of this lol.:laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, at least you solve it, but next time, try to use twrp from multirom thread instead of flashing fromatpartitions.zip, there's a feature to change back and forth between ext4 and f2fs for any desired partition, and use franco from this link
http://mirror.lnx.im/android/mako/franco/
( i used semaphore auto version, but it should work the same way for franco )

diogo.sena said:
Well, at least you solve it, but next time, try to use twrp from multirom thread instead of flashing fromatpartitions.zip, there's a feature to change back and forth between ext4 and f2fs for any desired partition, and use franco from this link
http://mirror.lnx.im/android/mako/franco/
( i used semaphore auto version, but it should work the same way for franco )
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Twrp with ext4/f2fs format option for mako
http://d-h.st/g59
Multirom app, which will install the recovery without fastboot.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.tassadar.multirommgr

[Q] [TITAN 1086] Encryption Unsuccessful

Hey guys,
normally I don't cry, but now the time has come to do so, I think. I've updated the bootloader and installed the newest TWRP.
The problem is whenever I flash a rom, no matter which, it tells me that the encryption was unsuccessful. I've tried to reformat the DATA partition and SYSTEM and everything else. Made several wipes, but nothing seems to help.
I hope, that you have any hints for me. I'm afraid that I'm totally helpless right now.
Thanks in advance.
Daniel

CarthyMcDan said:
Hey guys,
normally I don't cry, but now the time has come to do so, I think. I've updated the bootloader and installed the newest TWRP.
The problem is whenever I flash a rom, no matter which, it tells me that the encryption was unsuccessful. I've tried to reformat the DATA partition and SYSTEM and everything else. Made several wipes, but nothing seems to help.
I hope, that you have any hints for me. I'm afraid that I'm totally helpless right now.
Thanks in advance.
Daniel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1. Execute "fastboot -w"
2. Start TWRP
3. Reformat your data as EXT4 and then format it again as F2FS
3. Reformat your cache as EXT4
4. Flash/Boot ROM you've chosen.

LuK1337 said:
1. Execute "fastboot -w"
2. Start TWRP
3. Reformat your data as EXT4 and then format it again as F2FS
3. Reformat your cache as EXT4
4. Flash/Boot ROM you've chosen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What can I say. You're my hero. Thanks a lot, you're a good lad. :good:
Cheers

Successfully Revert back to OOS 3.2.8 (MM) from Open Beta 8 (N)

I installed the N beta and have to say it was not working for me as I had a few bugs with it. There is a way to easily revert back to MM.
Boot into TWRP.
Go to advanced wipe and select everything including system. (This will delete everything including os from your phone)
Reboot and go into twrp again.
Flash 3.2.8 and SuperSu (optional)
Thats it. No need for any special build as OP said.

Thx for that Info. Have you been on F2fs or on ext4?

In my case I guess i can´t got beta 8 installed and twrp ask for pin did you think if i wipe data and flash 3.2.6 i manage to revert?

Blubber120 said:
Thx for that Info. Have you been on F2fs or on ext4?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i was on ext4. to get on f2fs you have to hard reset your device after flashing beta.

Crash said:
In my case I guess i can´t got beta 8 installed and twrp ask for pin did you think if i wipe data and flash 3.2.6 i manage to revert?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you have enabled pin on bootup. You can try disabling it and then you should be able to get to recovery.

Thx. I am afraid, if on f2fs, it wouldnt be that easy, but good to know that it works if we stayed on ext4

Blubber120 said:
Thx. I am afraid, if on f2fs, it wouldnt be that easy, but good to know that it works if we stayed on ext4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you can clean reflash the open beta 8 instead of 3.2.8 which would take you back to ext4 then you can flash 3.2.8.

what is the file system by default in op3 and will installing open beta 8 change file system to f2fs or to ext4?? thanks

Ext4 is default. Whether ob8 changes it or not, i got no aim.

bonham1988 said:
I installed the N beta and have to say it was not working for me as I had a few bugs with it. There is a way to easily revert back to MM.
Boot into TWRP.
Go to advanced wipe and select everything including system. (This will delete everything including os from your phone)
Reboot and go into twrp again.
Flash 3.2.8 and SuperSu (optional)
Thats it. No need for any special build as OP said.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for sharing :good:
Very useful info.

Correct me if I am wrong, but this method to revert back to 3.2.8 will only work only if you have flashed open beta 8 with official twrp as the partition will remain to EXT4.
If you have flashed the update through stock or modded twrp recovery then your system partition will become F2FS so this method to revert back to 3.2.8 will not work as it need EXT4 system partition.

daninantro said:
Correct me if I am wrong, but this method to revert back to 3.2.8 will only work only if you have flashed open beta 8 with official twrp as the partition will remain to EXT4.
If you have flashed the update through stock or modded twrp recovery then your system partition will become F2FS so this method to revert back to 3.2.8 will not work as it need EXT4 system partition.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm on the latest twrp by eng.stk, twrp-3.0.2-1.28

bonham1988 said:
I'm on the latest twrp by eng.stk, twrp-3.0.2-1.28
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So I am guessing your system partition is ext4 and f2fs , right? Coz, after a clean flash the system will become f2fs partition (thats what I read)
EDIT: Oh, You need to do hard reset for f2fs..
Also, did you read another thread? the users who did a remote session with OP said that u need some certificate file to downgrade to official OTA. something related to encryption

daninantro said:
So I am guessing your system partition is ext4 and f2fs , right? Coz, after a clean flash the system will become f2fs partition (thats what I read)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No it remains on ext4 even after a clean flash. You have do a hard reset to change it to f2fs.

I wonder what happens if file system is changed to f2fs. Should we change the partition to ext4 in twrp before installing OOS 3.2.8?

bonham1988 said:
I installed the N beta and have to say it was not working for me as I had a few bugs with it. There is a way to easily revert back to MM.
Boot into TWRP.
Go to advanced wipe and select everything including system. (This will delete everything including os from your phone)
Reboot and go into twrp again.
Flash 3.2.8 and SuperSu (optional)
Thats it. No need for any special build as OP said.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Buddy,
"wipe everything", that includes internal storage.. I read that it's not a good ideea to wipe internal storage.
But, thanks for info.

When you say wipe everything do you also mean internal storage? I really don't want to wipe that if it isn't absolutely necessary.

I am on Arter's CM13 Rom with modified kernel and with cache, system and data, all on f2fs.
What all do i have to keep on f2fs and what on ext4 to install Beta8.
After that i can follow all the steps with modified recovery, right? Or do i have to flash 3.5.5 or Beta7 first?

GaugeX said:
I am on Arter's CM13 Rom with modified kernel and with cache, system and data, all on f2fs.
What all do i have to keep on f2fs and what on ext4 to install Beta8.
After that i can follow all the steps with modified recovery, right? Or do i have to flash 3.5.5 or Beta7 first?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know that the OP3T only uses F2FS for the DATA partition.
All other partitions are EXT4.
So I guess they will probably keep it that way on Nougat.
The beta 8 kernel might actually support F2FS for the other partitions, but without the source code I think you can only try.
Personally I am running Nougat Beta 8 as mentioned with DATA only on F2FS.

it might be a silly question, but now reading a lot about ext4 and F2FS everything I am totally messed up. Below are the confusions/queries-
1. How can I come to know I am on which files system, ext4 or f2fs ? (if I have twrp installed)
2. can it be changed from on to other, if yes, how?
3. Two latest builds - stock 3.2.8 and beta 8 are on ext4 and f2fs respectively, is it correct?
4. If I am on beta8 (flashed via modded twrp), how can I downgrade to stock 3.2.8 ?

OP3T (OxygenOS 3.5.X) default file-system for Cache, Data (userdata) and System

After installing custom recovery and rooting my (OP3T) in DiskInfo (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.kuder.diskinfo) I noticed that the file-system for System is ext4 (same for Cache), but at the same time Data (userdata) is still in f2fs (see the print screen)?
During the TWRP installation and root I did not format or re-flashed the ROM (I am still on OxygenOS 3.5.3. as it was after OTA update from OxygenOS 3.5.3.).
So I am thinking its either the custom recovery installation that caused file-system change or it is so by default.
Could you please check your OP3T and see what DiskInfo (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.kuder.diskinfo) reports in regard of file-system.

jemeljsh said:
After installing custom recovery and rooting my (OP3T) in DiskInfo (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.kuder.diskinfo) I noticed that the file-system for System is ext4 (same for Cache), but at the same time Data (userdata) is still in f2fs (see the print screen)?
During the TWRP installation and root I did not format or re-flashed the ROM (I am still on OxygenOS 3.5.3. as it was after OTA update from OxygenOS 3.5.3.).
So I am thinking its either the custom recovery installation that caused file-system change or it is so by default.
Could you please check your OP3T and see what DiskInfo (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.kuder.diskinfo) reports in regard of file-system.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pure stock updated to latest, just had the device a few hours and love it.

LMcR92 said:
Pure stock updated to latest, just had the device a few hours and love it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Everything's the same, except in your case we cant see "Internal Storage - System" and its file-system. Probably because yours is without root.

jemeljsh said:
Seems the same, except in your case we cant see Internal Storage - System. Probably because yours is without root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm planning on getting root and kernel on ASAP.

LMcR92 said:
I'm planning on getting root and kernel on ASAP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any news?

Userdata (the main storage) is f2fs, modem and sde23 are vfat, rest is ext4. From what I know, this is supposed to be so.
I have TWRP installed and phone is rooted.

Mine are all EXT4.
Running stock 3.5.3
TWRP, Rooted, running tyranus kernel, and xposed.
Everything seems perfect so I'm not sure why mines different.
I'll back everything up and format data in TWRP
OK I'm good now

(Guide) Convert EXT4 to F2FS on lavendar

Hi,
I made this guideline for those who want to convert filesystem from EXT3 / EXT4 to F2FS on lavendar, for amazing speed & performance.
I already had MIUI EU beta working on my phone.
Note: Internal data storage will be wiped. Make sure to have a backup.
Steps:
1. Install Orange Fox Recovery (latest one)
2. Reboot to recovery
3. Go to Manage Partition
4. Select "Cache" and click orange tick button, then choose F2FS as the file
system and proceed.
5. Again, select "Data" and click orange tick button, then choose F2FS as the file
system and proceed.
6. Reboot to Recovery again.
7. Install a custom kernel which support F2FS (i.e Evira)
8. Install Universal F2FS support patch file. (otherwise causing boot loop)
9. Reboot
Enjoy the speed.>>>>>>>>>>>

Hi! Filesystem F2FS keeps always even if you make full wipes + format data? For example, if i do the process but later i want to change my device's ROM, system will still have F2FS after wipes and format data? Sorry i've never changed my device's Kernel so i don't know if the system keep the new kernel (and the F2FS support patch file mentioned in this post) after a wipe + format data or they have to be re-flashed. Thank you in advance.

Did as instructed. got a boot loop : (
Are you sure that fstab flags are properly set? I don't see 'nofail' option or maybe there's some other option that substitutes?
I use miui eu 9.8.9
I reformatted back to EXT4 and it boots again.
If you are not so sure (neither am I, I will go research mount command options) then I recommend 3 separate zips
One that's F2FS only for cache and data
One that's all EXT4 for cache and data in case someone needed to revert without reflashing rom
And one that's F2FS cache and EXT4 data because migrating data partition can be a lengthy process for some people. But formatting cache is always easy.

Plast0000 said:
Did as instructed. got a boot loop : (
Are you sure that fstab flags are properly set? I don't see 'nofail' option or maybe there's some other option that substitutes?
I use miui eu 9.8.9
I reformatted back to EXT4 and it boots again.
If you are not so sure (neither am I, I will go research mount command options) then I recommend 3 separate zips
One that's F2FS only for cache and data
One that's all EXT4 for cache and data in case someone needed to revert without reflashing rom
And one that's F2FS cache and EXT4 data because migrating data partition can be a lengthy process for some people. But formatting cache is always easy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the same problem, to solve it do the partitions process, flash first evira, reboot to recovery again and flash the patch. It worked for me and booted succesfully into the rom. I use xiaomi eu 9.8.9 too.

jalzate94 said:
I had the same problem, to solve it do the partitions process, flash first evira, reboot to recovery again and flash the patch. It worked for me and booted succesfully into the rom. I use xiaomi eu 9.8.9 too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So I do it like this?
1- change partition fs
2- reboot into recovery
3- flash evira
4- reboot into recovery
5- flash fstab.zip
6- reboot into rom

Is there actually any benefit at all in using F2FS on Lavender since the flash type is not one of ones supported by F2FS?
Sent from my Note 5 / 5 Plus using XDA Labs

gardiol said:
Is there actually any benefit at all in using F2FS on Lavender since the flash type is not one of ones supported by F2FS?
Sent from my Note 5 / 5 Plus using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean when you say that its flash type is not supported by F2FS?
also see these posts:
https://forums.oneplus.com/threads/...o-perfomance-after-formatting-to-f2fs.441177/
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2697069

Plast0000 said:
What do you mean when you say that its flash type is not supported by F2FS?
also see these posts:
https://forums.oneplus.com/threads/...o-perfomance-after-formatting-to-f2fs.441177/
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2697069
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
See, F2FS works on NAND flash memories.... Lavender ilis NOT a NAND flash, so there is no advantage in using it. At least this is the rationale if I am not wrong.
As speed goes, F2FS is no benefit as your link said, but also for the wear and tear there is not much benefit
Sent from my Note 5 / 5 Plus using XDA Labs

gardiol said:
See, F2FS works on NAND flash memories.... Lavender ilis NOT a NAND flash, so there is no advantage in using it. At least this is the rationale if I am not wrong.
As speed goes, F2FS is no benefit as your link said, but also for the wear and tear there is not much benefit
Sent from my Note 5 / 5 Plus using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm? according to mi website and wikipedia it uses eMMC 5.1 which is a NAND storage. why wouldn't it work?
As for my link they all agree that F2FS is a bit slower for read but hellalot faster for write. overall gain is considerable.

Plast0000 said:
Hmm? according to mi website and wikipedia it uses eMMC 5.1 which is a NAND storage. why wouldn't it work?
As for my link they all agree that F2FS is a bit slower for read but hellalot faster for write. overall gain is considerable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
... Well, my info is wrong then... In this case it would be useful
Sent from my Note 5 / 5 Plus using XDA Labs

White_Lion said:
Hi! Filesystem F2FS keeps always even if you make full wipes + format data? For example, if i do the process but later i want to change my device's ROM, system will still have F2FS after wipes and format data? Sorry i've never changed my device's Kernel so i don't know if the system keep the new kernel (and the F2FS support patch file mentioned in this post) after a wipe + format data or they have to be re-flashed. Thank you in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, the data partition will be converted back to ext4 everytime you do "format data".
Not formatting your data could keep the f2fs status, but it's risky to not formatting data when changing ROM in lavender due to it's strict encryption issue.
Plast0000 said:
Did as instructed. got a boot loop : (
Are you sure that fstab flags are properly set? I don't see 'nofail' option or maybe there's some other option that substitutes?
I use miui eu 9.8.9
I reformatted back to EXT4 and it boots again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Miui.eu ROMs doesn't fully support F2FS. The rom does, but the kernel doesn't.
You need to make sure both the ROM and kernel has F2FS support.
if one of them don't, you'll get bootloop.
Plast0000 said:
So I do it like this?
1- change partition fs
2- reboot into recovery
3- flash evira
4- reboot into recovery
5- flash fstab.zip
6- reboot into rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been on F2FS since.. April I think, and I've installed and tried so many roms without any problem.
here's what I normally do and it works all the time:
- Make sure data & cache are ext4
- format data
- reboot recovery,
- wipe cache, dalvik, system, data, internal,
- flash firmware
- flash ROM
- flash gapps (optional)
- flash magisk
- flash kernel that has f2fs support (optional, if the rom's kernel doesn't support F2FS)
- reboot system
————————————————————————
it's necessary to install the rom in EXT4 because automatic encryption doesn't work in f2fs partition (I think... based on my experience). granted, you can do the encryption manually from settings, but it's require to have 80%++ battery and the more stuff you have in your internal, the longer it'd take to manually encrypt the device. automatic encryption is just easier to do. You can leave your internal decrypted as well, but you won't be able to use your fingerprint or any screen lock methods. That's just how redmi 7 family works.
————————————————————————
- once you get into system, reboot to recovery once again
- convert cache & data to f2fs
- flash magisk
- flash universal f2fs patch
- reboot
now your /data and /cache are in f2fs.
If you're already on a rom and kernel that support f2fs, you can just do the later half of this tutorial without the need to reinstall rom and everything, but you'd lose all your data. good luck!

What's the benefit of changing cache into F2FS?

begging
Seeking flash tutorial videos

Thanks
thx for guide.

Which custom rom that support f2fs?