Database Develop

Losing root after some time, Magisk v11 + MagiskSU

pretty much title.
sometimes i lose root twice a day, sometime 3day without lose, reboot/reflash magisk fix it

Same here
Enviado de meu LG-D295 usando Tapatalk

Just experienced the same issue. After installing some modules and rebooting

I am experiencing the same thing.. but when or how I don't know... I just take reboot and again root will be back. Might be some other app like clean master or auto killing apps kills magisk services???

I had the issue too, but it stopped when I disabled MagiskHide. That of course is only a solution if you don't actually need it.
Not being an expert, I never found a way to debug the issue or contribute otherwise.

I can confirme. Also when MagiskHide is on, I experience random reboots, which is bigger problem. Any fix for it?

Karls0 said:
I can confirme. Also when MagiskHide is on, I experience random reboots, which is bigger problem. Any fix for it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just a thought: have you added any system apps/processes to the Hide list?

No, i didn't. I don't use android pay, and i don't think that hiding root may be necessary for any other system app. When I turn MagishHide I have maybe 1 min before reboot. All was fine first few hours after installation, before first root losing.
If it will help, I'm on AOSP 6.0 custom ROM. My device is i9505. What's interesting it happens only if mobile data is on. Wi-fi doesn't do any troubles.

I will throw my experience into this thread as well. I am running Magisk 11.1 with DarkRom on my Nexus 5. Everything seems to work very smooth outside of randomly loosing root. I don't have to reflash, just reboot and it comes back. I do have MagiskHide enable for Android Pay. I also have the AppSystemizer model installed to covert Action Launcher 3 to systems. No random reboots, but loosing root is annoying. I may try to disable MagiskHide and see if that solves the root drop issue. Android Pay is handy though.

Ok Folks my 2 cents in regards to this trouble, i have did some work in reproducing this Magisk Root Loss.
say i have few apps like 1) SafetyNet Sample: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.scottyab.safetynet.sample&hl=en & 2) RootChekerPro app and both these apps are hided them from root using MagiskHide.
So when i launch Magisk Manager app and checked safetynet Status and then opened app1 (safetynet Sample) ran the test and then immediately did Forcestop the Magisk manager app and launched back Magisk Manager app boom the root is lost and did a reboot everything is back fine again.

I've been trying to find the cause of this issue for a couple of weeks. This is what works for me so far
1. Open Magisk Manager when root is working (either immediately after rebooting or after disabling Magisk Hide).
2. Does Magisk BusyBox and Magisk Hide.
3. Reboot
4. Enable Magisk Hide, but keep Magisk BusyBox disabled.
5. Reboot
Check if root disappears anymore.

I think Magisk Hide is causing the issue, disabled the Magisk Hide and the root stays.

It may also be releated with GApps package - it could explain why some people have this issue with losing root/stability but others no. You can try with smaller package (picko/nano).

Magisk 11.5 seems to fix the issue for me

craigacgomez said:
Magisk 11.5 seems to fix the issue for me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, it's just randomly occurring.
I was having the same problem with 11.1 and flashed the 11.5. It doesn't fixed.
Then flashed the ROM and 11.1 again the root is still there.
I don't know what exactly triggers the root to hide but there is something going on.

works on first flash of 11.1, then the next reboot breaks it again. uninstalling and reinstalling magisk fixes it again until the next reboot

I switch on MagiskHide only when I need it. So far it's quite good option, doesn't require any reboots.

did more testing, I don't lose root at all when I have MagiskHide disabled. Deleting /magisk/.core/magiskhide in recovery returns root.

Mostly a "me too" post. Issue still occurs on 11.6.

I tried replacing MagiskSU with SuperSU. But still the issue remains.

[Magisk v17.3] help needed.

Hi!
So this is my first post on xda, so please be nice
I rooted my Samsung s8 sm g950f with ambasadii, and running magisk.
When I first flashed the rom everything went ok. The first time I entered the Magisk Manager app there was a note that said that I can update the manager app to v18.1. When opened the app got a message that the app was unsupported by magisk manager. So I flashed the rom again and just didn't updated the manager app. That's one problem, here is the next one.
When I enter my banking they use a 2 step verification system. I have to go to the phone and enter a code that verifies the login. Now since I've rooted the phone I can't use it, is there any solution to this problem? The banking app does not support either a rooted phone. One of the reasons I rooted with magisk is the Magisk Hide. But I don't think it is working for me . The verification goes through the sim card.
Let me know if you need some more info to help me solve this problem!
PS: I am new to rooting
Thanks!

Welcome to XDA, Magisk and root world.
Quick tips:
Every time before trying the problematic app again, under Android settings/app, stop it and clean its cache and data. Even better to unistall it, reboot, install it again from play store. Even better before reboot go to recovery mode and wipe cache, dalvik (only those!).
Hide Magisk Manager (=repack it with a random name). You do that on Magisk Manager settings menu. After that its visible name will be only Manager (on your app drawer).
read everything here, special attention to SafetyNet and hiding other rooting tests apps may use:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage
install MagiskHide Props Config module and use its improve hiding settings: (available for download on the Dowload menu of Magisk Manager)
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/module-magiskhide-props-config-t3789228
Try updating Magisk/Manager to 18.1/7.0 (last stables):
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445
Do backups and try updating to last Canary builds. Read last posts on its thread:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337
Maybe the module ShellHide works better than standard Magisk Hide on your device, I don't know. Read thread:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-shellhide-t3855616
For general Magisk support, usually better search and ask for help on official support thread:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382

How To Remove Multiple Magisk (In Android 9.x Phone) ??

I noticed something strange, on my phone and I'm trying different ways to solve it, but it just does not "work".
I have 2 x Magisk icons in my phone and I cannot remove them, so that I only have 1 x Magisk.
Here's some background,...
My phone: OnePlus 6 [OP6], with stock Oxygen OS 9.0.9 [OOS 9.0.9] Android and running custom kernel [Omega].
I had been running a ROM [xXx NoLimits] which is a Magisk Module.
For last 11+ months, I have had no issues with my phone, no issues with Magisk, and no issues with root really.
I updated to Magisk v20.0 (but it seems it was the Beta / Canary channel) and also,
I had used the "Hide Magisk Manager" feature, for 1 specific app. to work.
Just this week, I noticed some issues with my phone or that I had 'lost' root
This happens rarely, and I just reinstall Magisk, but it resolves itself.
So, I went looking and saw an odd thing: 2 x Magisk icons.
Since then, I have tried:
- Magisk Uninstaller [Magisk-uninstaller-20191011.zip]
- Flashed unpatched BOOT.img file, Flashed TWRP. Then, rebooted to TWRP.
- Flashed Magisk, flashed the custom kernel.
Still, I saw 2 x Magisk icons.
I could see 1 Magisk was on STABLE channel, while other was on CANARY channel.
This was strange.
So, I changed the CANARY to STABLE, etc. etc...
Anyway, too many combinations of uninstalling and removing root, reinstall Magisk, etc... and I still don't know how to really uninstall Magisk and start from ZERO again.
I have lost Magisk's association to my Magisk modules too.
Can anyone help or advise?

Sounds like you just have two Managers installed. Uninstall them both (like you would with any other app) and install the apk manually again.
https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_There_are_two_Magisk_Managers

I think I resolved my issue now...
I uninstalled Magisk using the official Magisk Uninstaller.
I also uninstalled the 2 x Magisk apps in my launcher, using this .APK ---> "Uninstalled SystemApps" ( https://github.com/nicolaserlonghi/UninstallSystemApps )
Then, I had to go through re-installing the BOOT.img, Magisk and most importantly, the ROM (which itself was a Magisk module).
Slowly, it populated the Magisk module list and 'SuperUser' lists, and I think I got the phone back into how I had it.

Didgeridoohan said:
Sounds like you just have two Managers installed. Uninstall them both (like you would with any other app) and install the apk manually again.
https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_There_are_two_Magisk_Managers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, exactly.
Thanks for this tip, but I reached this conclusion anyway...
and used another .apk (Unsinstall SystemApps) to remove the Magisk Manager (which was the result of using "Magisk Manager Hide",
but then I must have mixed up Stable & Canary builds of Magisk on the phone, etc.)

Didgeridoohan said:
Sounds like you just have two Managers installed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
One thing weird though is, quite a few modules that were previously installed are missing from the Magisk "modules" section.
When I 're-install' them, they still don't show in the "modules" section.
For Example:
Vanced, Advanced Charging Controller, etc... all have been installed, but not showing up in Magisk.
I just had a weird situation of 2 different Magisk installs (at first it seemed like 2 x Managers), but it could be 2 different Magisk builds:
stable and canary
I don't know how to explain it, but maybe the Magisk Uninstaller doesn't work properly on Canary builds?
Anyway, my issue now is modules don't get listed in the Magisk Manager.

No, you did not have two different Magisk builds installed at the same time. Can't happen...
And without more to go on (logs, etc) it's gonna be real hard to help with the module issue.

[HELP] Hide Magisk Manager (Repackage) upgrades the version over the internet

I have my Samsung A30 (SM-A305F) rooted with magisk canery (87de0e7a) by flashing patched boot img via odin. Now, If i try to hide magisk with random package , it demands internet connection and install the latest version (9348c5ba). BUT i don't want to upgrade as the updated version has weird bug of rejecting SU automatically (with a very brief pop-up). I then need to ---> uninstall the repackaged app ---> Reboot ---> install 87de0e7a version ---> then it become functional again. I don't have TWRP installed. Re-flashing new patched boot requires wiping data. i don't want to do factory reset
Now I want to hide magisk as PUBG MOBILE might be crashing due to root detection. Please help me achieve solution:
(1) hide magisk manager without updating
(2) update magisk manager without that BUG of rejecting SU automatically

1 - Hide the Manager and let it update fully, no way around that. Then replace /data/user_de/0/com.H3.nuhw6UY.GoCgl/dyn/current.apk with the apk of whatever Manager version it is you want to use (and don't forget to set the same permissions and owner).
Edit: replace the package name above with the one your Manager uses.
2 - Seems to be a similar issue reported here: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2944
If there's anything to be done about it, it will be eventually.
If you can get some proper logs showing the su rejection and add to the above linked issue that would be great.

Note: i previously managed to hide it successfully when there was no newer version. It would just download the same version from the internet and repackage itself with random package name. But some days ago, i restored original manager and now i can't get it to hide.

Didgeridoohan said:
1 - Hide the Manager and let it update fully, no way around that. Then replace /data/user_de/0/com.H3.nuhw6UY.GoCgl/dyn/current.apk with the apk of whatever Manager version it is you want to use (and don't forget to set the same permissions).
2 - Seems to be a similar issue reported here: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2944
If there's anything to be done about it, it will be eventually.
If you can get some proper logs showing the su rejection and add to the above linked issue that would be great.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for replying. I followed our steps (com.mkhirsnpiw.z.kkt was used instead of com.H3.nuhw6UY.GoCgl). But it again says the same thing, "Upgrade to full magisk to finish the setup. Download and install?". Clicking ok upgrades it again

Shihabus Sakib Rad said:
Thanks for replying. I followed our steps (com.mkhirsnpiw.z.kkt was used instead of com.H3.nuhw6UY.GoCgl). But it again says the same thing, "Upgrade to full magisk to finish the setup. Download and install?". Clicking ok upgrades it again
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you place the new current.apk file in the same directory and give it the proper permissions (same owner and permission 600)? I just tested and had no issues downgrading the hidden Manager to 285 this way.

Didgeridoohan said:
Did you place the new current.apk file in the same directory and give it the proper permissions (same owner and permission 600)? I just tested and had no issues downgrading the hidden Manager to 285 this way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes with MiXplorer.
When Manager updated itself , i tried to update the magisk ( not the manager). But it bricked my phone as it won't start. i had to flash stock firmware via odin. It happened what i feared about. Now, i will try to patch boot img with new version.

UPDATE: I patched and flashed boot img using canary 290. after rebooting , this time there was not that Bug of rejecting SU automatically. Root was functional. But when it asked to do additional setups, it was stuck on setup operation forever and when i tried to hide manager, it showed "hiding magisk manager failed". so i uninstalled canary 290 and installed 7.5.1 (267) . This time additional setup was completed and rebooted automatically. But there was some problem with su access. so i uninstalled 7.5.1 (267) and installed canary 290. Root is now functional and it does not ask for additional setup anymore. (meaning setup was complete?). But still shows "hiding magisk manager failed" when try to hide manager. I don't know what is the problem . I was using canary 284 without any problem. PUBG mobile was runnig without problem. Now I am tired......

About hiding the Manager failing:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_Cant_hide_the_Magisk_Manager

Didgeridoohan said:
About hiding the Manager failing:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_Cant_hide_the_Magisk_Manager
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Disabling Play Protect Worked !!!! Thank you Sir :angel:

Greenify for magisk bootloop

I need small help. I got bootloop on my Xiaomi mi note 10 lite. Something like year ago I had rooted it (after couple days of trying a lot of metods) and I after that I started to use it. By time I have been using few Magisk modules and now I wanted to try some battery savers. I had install GPU Turbo boost and I reeboted my phone. After that I had install Greenify magisk module and reeboted again. Then my phone hangs on bootloop that always finish with Mi recovery 3.0. I can go into fastboot but I dont have TWRP installed. I had enter safe mode but I dont know can I go into settings/apps/magisk and clear data (or uninstall whole magisk) without causing more problems. Is there a way to remove the module somehow without removing magisk?

You need to enter twrp and select the module causing the card machine to be deleted in the twrp advanced options, file management and data / ADB / modules directory

https://lanzoui.com/b03c2iqbi Password: han
This is the self-help brick rescue module generator made by our domestic great God. After you choose to set it, click OK to automatically brush it into the mask manager! However, you cannot select a language! You can translate screenshots by yourself! The general description of the function is to find that the card machine module regrets trying the boot mode several times. If it still fails to boot after reaching the number set above, all modules will be automatically disabled to achieve the boot effect

ruffpl said:
I need small help. I got bootloop on my Xiaomi mi note 10 lite. Something like year ago I had rooted it (after couple days of trying a lot of metods) and I after that I started to use it. By time I have been using few Magisk modules and now I wanted to try some battery savers. I had install GPU Turbo boost and I reeboted my phone. After that I had install Greenify magisk module and reeboted again. Then my phone hangs on bootloop that always finish with Mi recovery 3.0. I can go into fastboot but I dont have TWRP installed. I had enter safe mode but I dont know can I go into settings/apps/magisk and clear data (or uninstall whole magisk) without causing more problems. Is there a way to remove the module somehow without removing magisk?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Module Issues:Magisk and MagiskHide Installation and Troubleshooting guide
www.didgeridoohan.com
Check from the section "Disabling/uninstalling modules manually". Maybe this will help

Thanks all for help I got it working. I read that all I need to do is just restart phone from safe mode and when phone will boot magisk will be disabled and it worked . I had open magisk app,removed module, flashed magisk boot image and its ok for now. Only problem that still exists is with some modules - when I want to install zip file I got extract error.

Safe mode has side effects. It's better to uninstall and install! After putting on the mask, brush in the automatic brick rescue module provided by me, and you can do it at will

If you don't understand, open the application, click the three vertical bar options on the right and directly click to confirm the default!