Flashing Patched Boot.img in ODIN Not Working - Magisk
I installed Magisk Manager 5.3.0 and opened it and clicked on Install to download Magisk 14 and to patch the boot.img file that I got from the Samsung Firmware file.
I patched the file and that completed fine with no errors.
I then copied the patched boot.img file to my computer so I could run ODIN on to flash it. Its in the proper format, "magisk.img.tar" is that I called it.
I opened ODIN 3.12 and selected the file under BL and plugged my phone in while in Download Mode.
ODIN detected my phone with the Added! msg in the log window.
ODIN is still running as I type this and all that is in the log is the following:
<ID:0/003> Added!!
<ID:0/003> Odin engine v(ID:3.1203)..
<ID:0/003> File analysis..
Theres no change on the phone screen either.
OEM Unlock is enabled as on the phone screen it says FRP Lock: Off
Phone is a Samsung Galaxy J3 Emerge (J327P) with Boost Mobile
Samsung firmware file from SAMMOBILE is J327PVPU1AQF4_J327PSPT1AQF4_BST
John877 said:
I installed Magisk Manager 5.3.0 and opened it and clicked on Install to download Magisk 14 and to patch the boot.img file that I got from the Samsung Firmware file.
I patched the file and that completed fine with no errors.
I then copied the patched boot.img file to my computer so I could run ODIN on to flash it. Its in the proper format, "magisk.img.tar" is that I called it.
I opened ODIN 3.12 and selected the file under BL and plugged my phone in while in Download Mode.
ODIN detected my phone with the Added! msg in the log window.
ODIN is still running as I type this and all that is in the log is the following:
<ID:0/003> Added!!
<ID:0/003> Odin engine v(ID:3.1203)..
<ID:0/003> File analysis..
Theres no change on the phone screen either.
OEM Unlock is enabled as on the phone screen it says FRP Lock: Off
Phone is a Samsung Galaxy J3 Emerge (J327P) with Boost Mobile
Samsung firmware file from SAMMOBILE is J327PVPU1AQF4_J327PSPT1AQF4_BST
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It has to be added in AP not BL.
I did the same and I tried to flash it in odin in AP but odin crushes!!
My phone is Galaxy S7 edge
Hani88 said:
I did the same and I tried to flash it in odin in AP but odin crushes!!
My phone is Galaxy S7 edge
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you by any chance send me the boot-image, stock, patched, tared ?
Or do you have the possibility to untar the image (or create just the boot.img) and use a "real" gnu-tar (preferred on linux).
Or give me the exact firmware, so I can try to create the image and tar it with the tar on my Fedora system ?
When doing the (internal) beta-tests I had the same issue, because of incorrect tar-headers (gnu-tar does not care about it). That should be fixed in MagiskManager, but Odin seems to be extremely nitpicking about the tar-header.
It might also be a problem with signed (or better not signed) bot-image, but I guess this would lead to another error.
jenslody said:
Can you by any chance send me the boot-image, stock, patched, tared ?
Or do you have the possibility to untar the image (or create just the boot.img) and use a "real" gnu-tar (preferred on linux).
Or give me the exact firmware, so I can try to create the image and tar it with the tar on my Fedora system ?
When doing the (internal) beta-tests I had the same issue, because of incorrect tar-headers (gnu-tar does not care about it). That should be fixed in MagiskManager, but Odin seems to be extremely nitpicking about the tar-header.
It might also be a problem with signed (or better not signed) bot-image, but I guess this would lead to another error.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well for me I only know how to extract the boot.img file from the AP file using winrar and patching it using magisk then renaming to .img.tar
I don't know anything about gnu-tar linux
Hani88 said:
Well for me I only know how to extract the boot.img file from the AP file using winrar and patching it using magisk then renaming to .img.tar
I don't know anything about gnu-tar linux
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you give me the exact version of your rom, so I can download it and send you a patched image for testing ? Or send me the boot.img either patched, stock or patched and tared ?
Hani88 said:
Well for me I only know how to extract the boot.img file from the AP file using winrar and patching it using magisk then renaming to .img.tar
I don't know anything about gnu-tar linux
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, if that's what you did, no wonder why it's failing and Odin is stuck on analyzing the image—it's not in the proper format, you shouldn't rename it, you need to tar the boot.img file.
jenslody said:
Can you give me the exact version of your rom, so I can download it and send you a patched image for testing ? Or send me the boot.img either patched, stock or patched and tared ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is
GF935FXXS1DQHM
I downloaded it from samfirm
I can send you the boot.img tomorrow because my laptop is not with me
---------- Post added at 06:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:50 PM ----------
白い熊 said:
Well, if that's what you did, no wonder why it's failing and Odin is stuck on analyzing the image—it's not in the proper format, you shouldn't rename it, you need to tar the boot.img file.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now I understand because inside it also there is not "meta inf " folder. How to tar it ?
Hani88 said:
It is
GF935FXXS1DQHM
I downloaded it from samfirm
I can send you the boot.img tomorrow because my laptop is not with me
---------- Post added at 06:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:50 PM ----------
Now I understand because inside it also there is not "meta inf " folder. How to tar it ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In MagiskManager's settings chose the .img.tar output format. The patched image should be named "patched_boot.img.tar", if it's just "patched_boot.img" you can not directly flash it!
jenslody said:
In MagiskManager's settings chose the .img.tar output format. The patched image should be named "patched_boot.img.tar", if it's just "patched_boot.img" you can not directly flash it!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But in odin in AP I am not able to import img file
Hani88 said:
But in odin in AP I am not able to import img file
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's why you have to chose the correct patch-format in MagiskManager's settings before patching the stock boot.img .
In the settings click/touch "Patch Boot Output Format" and chose ".img.tar", then in the main menu click/touch "Install", then again "Install", then "Patch Boot Image File", chose the stock-image and wait until it is patched.
This should create a file named "patched_boot.img.tar" in the MagiskManager-folder of your internal storage.
This should be flashable.
Changing just the ending of any file does not change the format and can not work therefore.
jenslody said:
That's why you have to chose the correct patch-format in MagiskManager's settings before patching the stock boot.img .
In the settings click/touch "Patch Boot Output Format" and chose ".img.tar", then in the main menu click/touch "Install", then again "Install", then "Patch Boot Image File", chose the stock-image and wait until it is patched.
This should create a file named "patched_boot.img.tar" in the MagiskManager-folder of your internal storage.
This should be flashable.
Changing just the ending of any file does not change the format and can not work therefore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the explanation.. I will do it tomorrow
Flashing a patched boot image will trip the knox counter right ? Of course mine is tripped but I want to know that
@jenslody I have just tried flashing the patched boot.img file in ODIN under the AP/PDA field and depending on ODIN version it either crashes or is stuck at file analysis. I have named the file "magisk" to keep the filename short. Therefore the full filename is magisk.img.tar. It was created using the patcher in magisk manager with the output setting of img.tar. I prefer to flash it in ODIN as I would like to keep the stock recovery for the sake of future updates.
How I obtained the boot.img file is from opening the stock firmware image from SAMMOBILE and extracting the AP file and grabbing the boot.img. I also grabbed the recovery.img this way just to have it. I dont have access to any other way of extracting the files as I dont have or use linux personally so its my windows 10 computer only.
As you offered the other guy above I am including my stock extracted boot.img file as well as my exact firmware version on SAMMOBILE.
The exact firmware filename is: J327PVPU1AQF4_J327PSPT1AQF4_BST
Its the Samsung Galaxy J3 Emerge (2017) from Boost Mobile (J327P) with Baseband version ending in QF4. Its on Android 6.0.1.
I was unable to attach the boot.img file here cause its too big (11.7mb) and the upload failed when I tried to ZIP it instead cause the limit there is 20mb. So here it is on DropBox instead.
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/s/azyeqrx7rtvjvik/boot.img
Once again the is extracted directly from the firmware file with winrar with no magisk patching.
John877 said:
@jenslody I have just tried flashing the patched boot.img file in ODIN under the AP/PDA field and depending on ODIN version it either crashes or is stuck at file analysis. I have named the file "magisk" to keep the filename short. Therefore the full filename is magisk.img.tar. It was created using the patcher in magisk manager with the output setting of img.tar. I prefer to flash it in ODIN as I would like to keep the stock recovery for the sake of future updates.
How I obtained the boot.img file is from opening the stock firmware image from SAMMOBILE and extracting the AP file and grabbing the boot.img. I also grabbed the recovery.img this way just to have it. I dont have access to any other way of extracting the files as I dont have or use linux personally so its my windows 10 computer only.
As you offered the other guy above I am including my stock extracted boot.img file as well as my exact firmware version on SAMMOBILE.
The exact firmware filename is: J327PVPU1AQF4_J327PSPT1AQF4_BST
Its the Samsung Galaxy J3 Emerge (2017) from Boost Mobile (J327P) with Baseband version ending in QF4. Its on Android 6.0.1.
I was unable to attach the boot.img file here cause its too big (11.7mb) and the upload failed when I tried to ZIP it instead cause the limit there is 20mb. So here it is on DropBox instead.
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/s/azyeqrx7rtvjvik/boot.img
Once again the is extracted directly from the firmware file with winrar with no magisk patching.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This should work, unless your ODIN-version stumbles about other things than mine.
Nevertheless, I uploaded a patched version of your boot.img to my server: https://rpm.jenslody.de/magisk/J327PVPU1AQF4_patched_boot.img.tar .
It's tared with the tar from my Fedora-system, but the (tar-header related) fixes @topjohnwu made to the java-tar he uses in MagiskManager made the created image flashable on my J5 (latest stock).
I also added a tared image with md5-checksum for you to test: https://rpm.jenslody.de/magisk/J327PVPU1AQF4_patched_boot.img.tar.md5
jenslody said:
This should work, unless your ODIN-version stumbles about other things than mine.
Nevertheless, I uploaded a patched version of your boot.img to my server: https://rpm.jenslody.de/magisk/J327PVPU1AQF4_patched_boot.img.tar .
It's tared with the tar from my Fedora-system, but the (tar-header related) fixes @topjohnwu made to the java-tar he uses in MagiskManager made the created image flashable on my J5 (latest stock).
I also added a tared image with md5-checksum for you to test: https://rpm.jenslody.de/magisk/J327PVPU1AQF4_patched_boot.img.tar.md5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
@jenslody, just for me to understand—you get the patched version via Magisk Manager, then untar it, then tar it again with a custom built tar?
Where are the patches you mention?
I think I realized my mistake. I extracted the boot.img file from the AP file of the firmware then not realizing it has to be inside a tar archive file I just renamed the boot.img file boot.img.tar instead. I feel like kind of an idiot right now.
Would it be sufficient to just use 7zip to create a tar archive with the boot.img file inside it?
Also would this be how to flash the recovery.img file too if I flash TWRP and want to go back to the stock recovery?
白い熊 said:
@jenslody, just for me to understand—you get the patched version via Magisk Manager, then untar it, then tar it again with a custom built tar?
Where are the patches you mention?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used the stock boot for J3, patched it through MagiskManager (one as *.img, one as *.img.tar), renamed the patched_boot.img to boot.img (taht's what Odin expects inside the tar, used Fedora's tar (I'm on Fedora 26) to create a tar archive from it and just for testing added a md5-checksum to one version of it.
MagiskManager is the 5.30 released with/for Magisk 14.4, bot patched. The fixes I mention were made by @topjohnwu in the (internal) beta-testing for 14.4.
To be clear:
the released Magisk with MagiskManager create img.tar-files that work for my J5 with the Odin-version I use (Odin3 v3.10.7) without any tweaking.
My self-tared versions are for testing purposes, to see if other Odin versions are more nitpicking than mine (about tar-headers). The included boot.img is exactly (binary) the same.
John877 said:
I think I realized my mistake. I extracted the boot.img file from the AP file of the firmware then not realizing it has to be inside a tar archive file I just renamed the boot.img file boot.img.tar instead. I feel like kind of an idiot right now.
Would it be sufficient to just use 7zip to create a tar archive with the boot.img file inside it?
Also would this be how to flash the recovery.img file too if I flash TWRP and want to go back to the stock recovery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same question here.. and you are not the only one who's feeling like an idiot now
---------- Post added at 09:23 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:02 AM ----------
jenslody said:
Can you by any chance send me the boot-image, stock, patched, tared ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
here is it thanks for helping
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B9_cANW46As_Y2Jwa0xsR1p2UkE
John877 said:
I think I realized my mistake. I extracted the boot.img file from the AP file of the firmware then not realizing it has to be inside a tar archive file I just renamed the boot.img file boot.img.tar instead. I feel like kind of an idiot right now. [emoji14]
Would it be sufficient to just use 7zip to create a tar archive with the boot.img file inside it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's unnecessary, you should just select .img.tar as the output format in Magisk Manager's settings. Then you can use the .img file you've extracted from the stock firmware. Magisk Manager will patch the .img file and create a patched .img.tar
This you should be able to flash with Odin.
白い熊 said:
It's unnecessary, you should just select .img.tar as the output format in Magisk Manager's settings. Then you can use the .img file you've extracted from the stock firmware. Magisk Manager will patch the .img file and create a patched .img.tar
This you should be able to flash with Odin.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I extracted the boot.img file from the firmware it was boot.img. When I patched it from magisk manager, it was boot.img still even though I chose output format img.tar.
Related
Where do radio and kernel come from flashing img's?
I know how to fastboot flash .img files and understand it includes the radio and kernel components. I'm rooted and have TWRP recovery. But which .img file contains the radio and which the kernel? I ask because I'll be going from the latest T-Mo rom (LYZ28J) to Project Fi having just received my sim. If I flash just the system.img from LYV48E (Fi rom) will I have the correct kernel and radio or will I have to flash boot.img also or something else? Since kernels and radios can be flashed separately I'm just not sure where everything comes from. I would appreciate some clarity.
Groid said: I know how to fastboot flash .img files and understand it includes the radio and kernel components. I'm rooted and have TWRP recovery. But which .img file contains the radio and which the kernel? I ask because I'll be going from the latest T-Mo rom (LYZ28J) to Project Fi having just received my sim. If I flash just the system.img from LYV48E (Fi rom) will I have the correct kernel and radio or will I have to flash boot.img also or something else? Since kernels and radios can be flashed separately I'm just not sure where everything comes from. I would appreciate some clarity. Click to expand... Click to collapse have you ever unzipped a factory.img .tar file to see what files it contains?
Groid said: I know how to fastboot flash .img files and understand it includes the radio and kernel components. I'm rooted and have TWRP recovery. But which .img file contains the radio and which the kernel? I ask because I'll be going from the latest T-Mo rom (LYZ28J) to Project Fi having just received my sim. If I flash just the system.img from LYV48E (Fi rom) will I have the correct kernel and radio or will I have to flash boot.img also or something else? Since kernels and radios can be flashed separately I'm just not sure where everything comes from. I would appreciate some clarity. Click to expand... Click to collapse simms22 said: have you ever unzipped a factory.img .tar file to see what files it contains? Click to expand... Click to collapse If I were a betting man, I'd be backing the horse called "Wish I'd done that before posting"
Tiptonian said: If I were a betting man, I'd be backing the horse called "Wish I'd done that before posting" Click to expand... Click to collapse Hahaa. Unzip and you shall receive. LMAO
simms22 said: have you ever unzipped a factory.img .tar file to see what files it contains? Click to expand... Click to collapse Not sure what you mean by this. I have the system, boot, recovery, and userdata .img files. I don't know which one has the kernel or which one has the radio. You imply I can unzip, for example, system.img to see what files are there, but I cannot unzip it or any of the .img files. My main question still is unanswered which is which .img files do I need to (m)fastboot flash to insure I have the correct (stock) kernel and radio for the Project Fi rom? I may just flash them all, flash TWRP, re-root and start clean, but I wanted to consider the option of keeping data. Any helpful answers?
Tiptonian said: If I were a betting man, I'd be backing the horse called "Wish I'd done that before posting" Click to expand... Click to collapse prdog1 said: Hahaa. Unzip and you shall receive. LMAO Click to expand... Click to collapse So glad my post was such a source of amusement for you. Sorry I didn't make it clear I know how download factory images, unzip the .tgz file to get the .tar file. Unzip the .tar file to get to the .zip file. Unzip the .zip file to get the boot, recovery, system, and userdata .img files. But no one actually tried to answer my question.
Groid said: So glad my post was such a source of amusement for you. Sorry I didn't make it clear I know how download factory images, unzip the .tgz file to get the .tar file. Unzip the .tar file to get to the .zip file. Unzip the .zip file to get the boot, recovery, system, and userdata .img files. But no one actually tried to answer my question. Click to expand... Click to collapse kernel is boot.img, radio is radio.img
Thank you for your reply. I suspected boot.img is the kernel but wanted to make sure. I notice that the radio-shamu-. . .02.78.02.img and boot-shamu. . .71.10.img are in the shamu-lvy48e folder in the .tar file with the flash batch files. The enclosed .zip file has the system, boot, userdata, recovery, and cache .img files along with the text file specifying the bootloader (kernel) and baseband (radio). I now understand that the boot.img is the kernel which is the same version my current one in LYZ28J, so I need not flash it. The radio is different based on the android-info.txt file. So, the last piece of the puzzle for me is will I get the updated radio by flashing the system.img or must I separately flash the radio-shamu -. . .-02.78.02.img?
Groid said: Thank you for your reply. I suspected boot.img is the kernel but wanted to make sure. I notice that the radio-shamu-. . .02.78.02.img and boot-shamu. . .71.10.img are in the shamu-lvy42e folder in the .tar file with the flash batch files. The enclosed .zip file has the system, boot, userdata, recovery, and cache .img files along with the text file specifying the bootloader (kernel) and baseband (radio). I now understand that the boot.img is the kernel which is the same version my current one in LYZ28J, so I need not flash it. The radio is different based on the android-info.txt file. So, the last piece of the puzzle for me is will I get the updated radio by flashing the system.img or must I separately flash the radio-shamu -. . .-02.78.02.img? Click to expand... Click to collapse youll get the updated radio in the factory.img, but you can always flash the radio itsrlf via fastboot(fastboot flash radio radioname.img).
Groid said: Thank you for your reply. I suspected boot.img is the kernel but wanted to make sure. I notice that the radio-shamu-. . .02.78.02.img and boot-shamu. . .71.10.img are in the shamu-lvy48e folder in the .tar file with the flash batch files. The enclosed .zip file has the system, boot, userdata, recovery, and cache .img files along with the text file specifying the bootloader (kernel) and baseband (radio). I now understand that the boot.img is the kernel which is the same version my current one in LYZ28J, so I need not flash it. The radio is different based on the android-info.txt file. So, the last piece of the puzzle for me is will I get the updated radio by flashing the system.img or must I separately flash the radio-shamu -. . .-02.78.02.img? Click to expand... Click to collapse If have updated SDK will get everything in flash-all.bat. If not and have to do all separate they are all separate. Bootloader, radio, boot, system, cache, userdata. There is no radio in system.img. It is the radio. img. On first unzip get bootloader, radio, flash-all and the folder for the rest of the images. If want radio fastboot flash radio (radio.img).
Thank you for answering my question about whether or not the radio gets updated by flashing system.img. Unfortunately, I cannot get ADB to work properly. I initially seem to have it working with the ADB devices statement from the command prompt, it returns the serial #, but when I try to execute the batch file ADB seems to be disconnected. At least I have experience with (m)fastboot and will just flash the radio and system .imgs since the bootloader is the same. I'll keep TWRP recovery, format cache, update supersu for root and I should be good to go.
Groid said: Thank you for answering my question about whether or not the radio gets updated by flashing system.img. Unfortunately, I cannot get ADB to work properly. I initially seem to have it working with the ADB devices statement from the command prompt, it returns the serial #, but when I try to execute the batch file ADB seems to be disconnected. At least I have experience with (m)fastboot and will just flash the radio and system .imgs since the bootloader is the same. I'll keep TWRP recovery, format cache, update supersu for root and I should be good to go. Click to expand... Click to collapse well, adb doesnt work in the bootloader, and its only fastboot that can flash those files..
Thanks, I was responding to using adb to sideload with the flash(all).bat. Fastboot works fine for me so I don't really miss using adb commands.
Twrp help :(
I have a g800f rooted I need to install the twrp 2.8.0.0 bootloader recovery without a pc. I have the tar.md5 file but I need the twrp .img file for this phone..where can I get the twrp.img file for this phone? it will help me out a lot . I'd appreciate the help. I've Google but I only find the tar file. which I got from the cyan gen mod cm12
change tar.md5 to tar, and open it. there's a recovery.img
How do I change to tar? do I convert it or just change the file name?
Change filename...
Flash magisk via boot.img but boot.img is boot.img.lz4
I want to flash magisk and keep stock recovery i need to modify the boot.img but it is boot.img.lz4 and when i try to patch that with magisk manager it says failed . Need help!:angel: Nevermind fixed it: Download modified 7 zip to extract lz4 files https://github.com/mcmilk/7-zip-zstd/releases OG Thread: https://forum.xda-developers.com/galaxy-s8+/how-to/guide-how-to-flash-crap-using-odin-t3748555
i managed to unzip the boot.img.lz4 then ran boot.img via magisk manager on phone I compressed the patched_boot.img to patched_boot.img.lz4 I can not find a way to convert .img.lz4 to tar.md5 to inject via odin? I tried flashing patched_boot.img not compressed with lz4 however it just hangs renaming patched_boot.img to boot.img before converting img to tar.md5 and that returns a failed I'm running a virgin n950f UEX on most recent FW (OTA) I have the same fw ---------- Post added at 04:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:06 PM ---------- never mind fixed it Forgot to turn on OEM unlock! Magisk v16.7 was detected anyway
extract boot.img from boot.img.lz4 Thanks a lot ! Worked for my SM-J701F Firmware . Great job
Extracting with 7zip or WinRAR fails. Is better to try: https://github.com/lz4/lz4/releases
KunkerLV said: I want to flash magisk and keep stock recovery i need to modify the boot.img but it is boot.img.lz4 and when i try to patch that with magisk manager it says failed . Need help! Nevermind fixed it: Download modified 7 zip to extract lz4 files https://github.com/mcmilk/7-zip-zstd/releases OG Thread: https://forum.xda-developers.com/galaxy-s8+/how-to/guide-how-to-flash-crap-using-odin-t3748555 Click to expand... Click to collapse Thank you very much. The modified 7z worked.
is it still working? Using https://github.com/lz4/lz4/releases I get error : access denied with -d arg...
twrp s10
Hi, I rooted my s10 with magisk but cannot flash twrp parched with odin because the file is .img and odin accepts file tar. What do I Havel to do?
Guide to Extract Boot image file and flash via Odin Tool First, download the preferred Samsung Stock ROM for your device model. Extract the firmware zip file on your computer within a folder. Now, the boot image file named as AP_xxx (similar kind of) file. Recently, Samsung firmware files use a new compression type called .lz4 extension. You may see something like boot.img.lz4 file name. Extract the boot.img.lz4 file via 7Zip to .tar extension and now you will see the boot.img.tar file. Download 7Zip - github (dot) com (slash) mcmilk (slash) 7-Zip-zstd (slash) releases Now, open the Odin tool and connect your device to the PC via a USB cable. Click on the ‘AP’ button and select the boot.img.tar file from your computer. Click on the ‘Start’ button. That’s it. Wait for flashing to complete and reboot your handset. Hope this guide will be helpful to you. If you’re facing any issue, you can ask your queries in the comments below.
How To Guide How to root SM-X200
Hello guys. I failed several times rooting this device and finally managed to root. You need to extract AP tar and then replace the boot.img with a magisk patched one. You then need to re tar the file using 7zip and flash as normal. AP CSC HOME CSC and BL
If there's enough demand I'll write a proper guide. Also if soft bricked you need to press both volume buttons and plug in usb at right point on restart.
jameswalker457 said: Hello guys. I failed several times rooting this device and finally managed to root. You need to extract AP tar and then replace the boot.img with a magisk patched one. You then need to re tar the file using 7zip and flash as normal. AP CSC HOME CSC and BL Click to expand... Click to collapse
Thanks @jameswalker457 Which one did you use CSC_HOME or CSC? When I run with CSC, I get a 'fail' in ODIN However, it does run with CSC_HOME, BL and the patched AP - but it doesn't actually root the device. Greatful for your help. Thanks
Used BL AP (with patched boot.img) CSC and HOME_CSC in the userdata
kevinsims said: Thanks @jameswalker457 Which one did you use CSC_HOME or CSC? When I run with CSC, I get a 'fail' in ODIN However, it does run with CSC_HOME, BL and the patched AP - but it doesn't actually root the device. Greatful for your help. Thanks Click to expand... Click to collapse See above. Missed the quotation
I'm not sure why we need a third thread for this: SM-X200 root failed... It's now a bricked tablet after a boot loop, I think should wait to magisk get an update. It won't power on or charge I think. I have two days trying to power on in several times and many key conbinations. No Samsung logo or something. Can I do... forum.xda-developers.com The best way to root samsung tab a8 2021 pls Android 11 I got fast as f boot loop solution below btw An 4 gamers I got fps/ping boost solution below to forum.xda-developers.com I still do not have root. What I did: 1. unlocked bootloader 2. install magisk manager 24.3 3. Download X200XXU1AVC1 from Samfw 4. unzip the firmware 5. Untar the AP tar file 6. Extract boot.img, send to device, and patch with magisk 24.3. Patched boot is magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img 7. Replace boot.img with the newly patched one (renamed to boot.img) 8. Create a tar file from the AP folder using " tar -C AP_folder -cvf AP_patched.tar ." 9. "adb reboot bootloader" to download mode 10. open Odin v3.14.1 and add BL, HOME_CSC, and the AP_patched.tar 9. Flash via Odin, exit download mode, enter stock recovery, factory reset For some reason I can't get from download mode to recovery w/o first booting the fresh android. No boot loop, but no root either.
These are the file names I got from Samfw: AP_X200XXU1AVC1_CL23784803_QB49828201_REV00_user_low_ship_MULTI_CERT_meta_OS11.tar.md5 BL_X200XXU1AVC1_CL23784803_QB49828201_REV00_user_low_ship_MULTI_CERT.tar.md5 HOME_CSC_OMC_XAR_X200XAR1AVC1_CL23784803_QB49838021_REV00_user_low_ship_MULTI_CERT.tar.md5 The md5sum of the files: AP stock: fa97e5cee1deaf26175b27d26df94266 AP patched: 006b12f713fc3caa127bc5cba01ae4b9 BL: 2172ca468462a46917d78e94157aed54 HOME_CSC: 5ede57b9ffe8059f3166dd5de6ef8721
The tar file worried me. It had file names like ./boot.img instead of boot.img. So I created a new file, with the patched boot.img, this way: cd AP_folder tar -cvf ../AP_patched.tar * Then flashed that. Took longer than the previous tar. On reboot, it asks me to press PWR to accept boot loader unlocked. Then a splash screen saying: unapproved software, then a few boot loops. I got to recovery, factory reset, the tablet does the LONG boot, does the initial setup thing. Install Magisk Manager, and root! Google Play still works. Whoopee! I can now wait for a working TWRP.
jameswalker457 said: Hello guys. I failed several times rooting this device and finally managed to root. You need to extract AP tar and then replace the boot.img with a magisk patched one. You then need to re tar the file using 7zip and flash as normal. AP CSC HOME CSC and BL Click to expand... Click to collapse Hello, I have a problem/doubt. I have the files AP, BP... etc I use 7zip to extract the boot.img ..... if I unzip all the AP XXX.tar.md5 the 7zip warns me that there is data after the file, it warns me of an error and at the end it stops in the fota . ...when I replace the boot.img in the AP folder by the one corresponding to the patched with Magisk and use the 7zip again to create the .tar the file does not work with ODIN...I do not know what step or mistake I make. Regards PS: I'm extracting the files instead of unzipping the .tar.md5 to see if that's the problem .... PS: Root! Thanks Jameswalker457 Cheers! .... Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)
IkeGolden said: Hello, I have a problem/doubt. I have the files AP, BP... etc I use 7zip to extract the boot.img ..... if I unzip all the AP XXX.tar.md5 the 7zip warns me that there is data after the file, it warns me of an error and at the end it stops in the fota . ...when I replace the boot.img in the AP folder by the one corresponding to the patched with Magisk and use the 7zip again to create the .tar the file does not work with ODIN...I do not know what step or mistake I make. Regards PS: I'm extracting the files instead of unzipping the .tar.md5 to see if that's the problem .... PS: Root! Thanks Jameswalker457 Cheers! .... Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version) Click to expand... Click to collapse > if I unzip all the AP XXX.tar.md5 That is because a .tar.md5 is a tar file with an md5 concatenated to it. > use the 7zip again to create the .tar the file does not The proper tool to create .tar files is "tar". >PS: I'm extracting the files instead of unzipping the .tar.md5 to see if that's the problem .... Care to be more specific on how you did that? >PS: Root! Thanks Jameswalker457 Cheers! .... Good news.
Have root my SM-X205 (LTE) for 1 Feb Patch level but no go with latest May update. Getting constant boot loop (exactly same process, magisk boot.bin etc) so rolled back to Feb for now.
lufee84 said: Have root my SM-X205 (LTE) for 1 Feb Patch level but no go with latest May update. Getting constant boot loop (exactly same process, magisk boot.bin etc) so rolled back to Feb for now. Click to expand... Click to collapse What firmware version worked, and which failed? X200XXU1AVC1 worked for me.
Yes, X205XXU1AVC1 works. No luck with latest X205XXS1AVE1 (May Patch).
garyemiller said: I'm not sure why we need a third thread for this: SM-X200 root failed... It's now a bricked tablet after a boot loop, I think should wait to magisk get an update. It won't power on or charge I think. I have two days trying to power on in several times and many key conbinations. No Samsung logo or something. Can I do... forum.xda-developers.com The best way to root samsung tab a8 2021 pls Android 11 I got fast as f boot loop solution below btw An 4 gamers I got fps/ping boost solution below to forum.xda-developers.com I still do not have root. What I did: 1. unlocked bootloader 2. install magisk manager 24.3 3. Download X200XXU1AVC1 from Samfw 4. unzip the firmware 5. Untar the AP tar file 6. Extract boot.img, send to device, and patch with magisk 24.3. Patched boot is magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img 7. Replace boot.img with the newly patched one (renamed to boot.img) 8. Create a tar file from the AP folder using " tar -C AP_folder -cvf AP_patched.tar ." 9. "adb reboot bootloader" to download mode 10. open Odin v3.14.1 and add BL, HOME_CSC, and the AP_patched.tar 9. Flash via Odin, exit download mode, enter stock recovery, factory reset For some reason I can't get from download mode to recovery w/o first booting the fresh android. No boot loop, but no root either. Click to expand... Click to collapse Not sure if this helps but i read an article that says you should patch the whole AP tar file rather than extract just the boot.img. Maybe because it patches the recovery and super etc img files too? I havet tried this yet as I cant even get my bootloader unlocked
dan.langridge88 said: Not sure if this helps but i read an article that says you should patch the whole AP tar file rather than extract just the boot.img. Maybe because it patches the recovery and super etc img files too? I havet tried this yet as I cant even get my bootloader unlocked Click to expand... Click to collapse Dunno where you read that, don't care. This works (as above): 1. unlocked bootloader 2. install magisk manager 24.3 3. Download X200XXU1AVC1 from Samfw 4. unzip the firmware 5. Untar the AP tar file 6. Extract boot.img, send to device, and patch with magisk 24.3. Patched boot is magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img 7. Replace boot.img with the newly patched one (renamed to boot.img) 8. Create a tar file from the AP folder using " cd AP_folder" " tar -cvf AP_patched.tar ." 9. "adb reboot bootloader" to download mode 10. open Odin v3.14.1 and add BL, HOME_CSC, and the AP_patched.tar 9. Flash via Odin, exit download mode, enter stock recovery, factory reset Note the fixed "tar" command. Do not use "tar -C".
garyemiller said: Dunno where you read that, don't care. This works (as above): 1. unlocked bootloader 2. install magisk manager 24.3 3. Download X200XXU1AVC1 from Samfw 4. unzip the firmware 5. Untar the AP tar file 6. Extract boot.img, send to device, and patch with magisk 24.3. Patched boot is magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img 7. Replace boot.img with the newly patched one (renamed to boot.img) 8. Create a tar file from the AP folder using " cd AP_folder" " tar -cvf AP_patched.tar ." 9. "adb reboot bootloader" to download mode 10. open Odin v3.14.1 and add BL, HOME_CSC, and the AP_patched.tar 9. Flash via Odin, exit download mode, enter stock recovery, factory reset Note the fixed "tar" command. Do not use "tar -C". Click to expand... Click to collapse OK, I've un-tarred the AP tar.md5 and patched the old boot-img file on the device, renamed it and replaced the original boot.img in the AP "folder". Steps 8 & 9 are a little confusing for me, if you could expand on those. Can I use 7zip to re-tar? Those look like DOS commands in step 8.
Ar-Pharazon said: OK, I've un-tarred the AP tar.md5 and patched the old boot-img file on the device, renamed it and replaced the original boot.img in the AP "folder". Steps 8 & 9 are a little confusing for me, if you could expand on those. Can I use 7zip to re-tar? Those look like DOS commands in step 8. Click to expand... Click to collapse Slightly expanded: 1. unlocked bootloader 2. install magisk manager 24.3 on the tablet 3. Download X200XXU1AVC1 firmware from Samfw onto PC 4. unzip the X200XXU1AVC1 firmware zip file 5. Make a directory for the AP tar contents "mkdir AP" 6. Untar the AP tar file into directory AP, all on one line: "tar -xvf AP_X200XXU1AVC1_CL23784803_QB49828201_REV00_user_low_ship_MULTI_CERT_meta_OS11.tar.md5 -C AP" 7. Change the current directoy to the AP directory: "cd AP" 8. Using adb send boot.img, to the tablet,. 9. Patch boot.img with magisk 24.3. Patched boot is magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img 10. Using adb copy magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img from the tablet and into the AP directory. 11. Rename magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img to boot.img: "mv magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img boot.img" 12 Create a tar file from the AP directory Note the space and period(".") after ".tar": " tar -cvf AP_patched.tar ." 13. Use adb on PC to enter download mode on tablet: "adb reboot bootloader" 14. open Odin v3.14.1 and add BL, HOME_CSC, and the AP_patched.tar as files to be flashed. 15. Flash via Odin, exit download mode, enter stock recovery, factory reset How about that?
garyemiller said: Slightly expanded: 1. unlocked bootloader 2. install magisk manager 24.3 on the tablet 3. Download X200XXU1AVC1 firmware from Samfw onto PC 4. unzip the X200XXU1AVC1 firmware zip file 5. Make a directory for the AP tar contents "mkdir AP" 6. Untar the AP tar file into directory AP, all on one line: "tar -xvf AP_X200XXU1AVC1_CL23784803_QB49828201_REV00_user_low_ship_MULTI_CERT_meta_OS11.tar.md5 -C AP" 7. Change the current directoy to the AP directory: "cd AP" 8. Using adb send boot.img, to the tablet,. 9. Patch boot.img with magisk 24.3. Patched boot is magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img 10. Using adb copy magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img from the tablet and into the AP directory. 11. Rename magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img to boot.img: "mv magisk_patched-24300-9Iez2.img boot.img" 12 Create a tar file from the AP directory Note the space and period(".") after ".tar": " tar -cvf AP_patched.tar ." 13. Use adb on PC to enter download mode on tablet: "adb reboot bootloader" 14. open Odin v3.14.1 and add BL, HOME_CSC, and the AP_patched.tar as files to be flashed. 15. Flash via Odin, exit download mode, enter stock recovery, factory reset How about that? Click to expand... Click to collapse I'm guessing those are Linux commands? In any event, I made 7zip re-tar the AP folder with the patched boot.img, but it ends in .tar.tar Is this an issue, or should/can it be renamed .tar.md5 like the original?
Ar-Pharazon said: I'm guessing those are Linux commands? In any event, I made 7zip re-tar the AP folder with the patched boot.img, but it ends in .tar.tar Is this an issue, or should/can it be renamed .tar.md5 like the original? Click to expand... Click to collapse I do them on Linux, but they can also work on WinBlows. Since I do not use M$ products, I can only say I've seen those commands work on WinBlows, but can't say how to set that up. I also can't help you with 7zip, it can run on Linux, but never use it myself. People have problems when they don't use "real" tar, so don't. Save yourself the pain. You do not need to convert the .tar to a .tar.md5. Odin will use either file type. A .tar.md5 file is a .tar file with its md5 hash appended. Odin can use the file to verify the .tar integrity, but that is optional.