Hi,
I'm running stock ROM with TWRP recovery.
I've managed to successfully root my Note with Magisk.
Somehow I noticed that my device loses root after a reboot and sometimes even randomly. When I go into the custom recovery and flash Magisk 14 or 14.3 everything works fine for while, till it loses root again.
Could someone shed some light on my issue, please?
Thanks in advance.
I've also themed Magisk Manager with Substratum could that be the issue?
I'm also running stock rom, losing magisk root from time to time.
When root is lost, I'm getting a notification that "new magisk V14 is available.
Reinstalling with TWRP only to lose it again a day or two later.
You all need to change your settings in magisk manager. I had the same problem. Change your update channel to Beta. This will keep magisk 14.3 installed once you flash it in recovery after setting this. :highfive:
Are you using the hide root feature?
If so then that is probably your issue.
opasha said:
You all need to change your settings in magisk manager. I had the same problem. Change your update channel to Beta. This will keep magisk 14.3 installed once you flash it in recovery after setting this. :highfive:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This worked for me, thank you!!
ALEXRUSS55 said:
This worked for me, thank you!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Welcome :highfive:
jpasint said:
Are you using the hide root feature?
If so then that is probably your issue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What issue does this cause?
I have the same issue with last magisk beta, 16.4.. have anyone found a fix?
stiffis said:
I have the same issue with last magisk beta, 16.4.. have anyone found a fix?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Flash magisk v16.4, then open magisk manager disable magisk hide, for keep your root
kenpaci said:
Flash magisk v16.4, then open magisk manager disable magisk hide, for keep your root
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Looks like that worked, thanks!
stiffis said:
Looks like that worked, thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But it losses Android pay. Anyone with other solution to keep root and hide it?
Best regards
Webgurru
webgurru said:
But it losses Android pay. Anyone with other solution to keep root and hide it?
Best regards
Webgurru
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try disabling MagiskHide and re-enable it again (try also with a reboot between disabling and enabling)
stiffis said:
Try disabling MagiskHide and re-enable it again (try also with a reboot between disabling and enabling)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If I disable it, won't secure apps that run in the background pick up root? I'm guessing I should freeze them first or something?
hshah said:
If I disable it, won't secure apps that run in the background pick up root? I'm guessing I should freeze them first or something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try closing those apps first, I think it goes ok as long you don't start the apps yourself because most off the apps checks root at startup, but I can't guarantee you anything
Something weird has happened... I've not actually changed anything but now I tend to lose root immediately after rebooting.
I'm a technical person so whilst I say nothing has changed, I know that it probably has and I just can't remember.
I need Hide, so disabling that is not an option... I have no idea where to even start debugging this
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy Note 8 using XDA Labs
hshah said:
Something weird has happened... I've not actually changed anything but now I tend to lose root immediately after rebooting.
I'm a technical person so whilst I say nothing has changed, I know that it probably has and I just can't remember.
I need Hide, so disabling that is not an option... I have no idea where to even start debugging this
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy Note 8 using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
Same thing happening to me. Lost root soon after restart. I need it hide. Any genius mind can suggest some solution?
Best regards,
Webgurru
webgurru said:
Hi,
Same thing happening to me. Lost root soon after restart. I need it hide. Any genius mind can suggest some solution?
Best regards,
Webgurru
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been posting my analysis here:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901
We have some smart guys (ie @topjohnwu @Didgeridoohan @kantjer etc) and I don't know enough to sort this so the least I can do is provide as much information as possible
hshah said:
I've been posting my analysis here:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901
We have some smart guys (ie @topjohnwu @Didgeridoohan @kantjer etc) and I don't know enough to sort this so the least I can do is provide as much information as possible
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any luck or help from this thread to resolve?
webgurru said:
Any luck or help from this thread to resolve?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only been spamming the thread with my woes since yesterday so still early days. I'm certainly not expecting an immediate fix because this has been going on for quite some time and if it was easy, we wouldn't be having this conversation.
hshah said:
Only been spamming the thread with my woes since yesterday so still early days. I'm certainly not expecting an immediate fix because this has been going on for quite some time and if it was easy, we wouldn't be having this conversation.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. In my point of view this look to be a bug in Magisk. Did you tried some older version?
Related
As the title says, I'm trying to see if magisk will work, and wanted input before I flash it.
jrk190 said:
As the title says, I'm trying to see if magisk will work, and wanted input before I flash it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It works, I currently use it for root, ViPER, and Xposed.
I actually went ahead and installed it before you replied, and I've been looking for something like it for ages. It's really well done.
Thanks for the heads up. I just converted from SuperSU to Magisk with phh SuperUser with no problems. Works great.
yes, it's work, [kingroot]
Hi, can you post the link of the guide that you used to install and get the Magisk working??? I need a newbie friendly guide to get that poke go working -.-
turron83 said:
Hi, can you post the link of the guide that you used to install and get the Magisk working??? I need a newbie friendly guide to get that poke go working -.-
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is the guide I used: http://www.androidpolice.com/2016/09/11/guide-play-pokemon-go-0-37-rooted-android-magisk/
Thanks!! i only did the first step and after the rebooting, i can get into pokemon go and play!!
Cya guys!!
turron83 said:
Thanks!! i only did the first step and after the rebooting, i can get into pokemon go and play!!
Cya guys!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The first part, you mean just unroot part?
Sent from my R1 HD using Tapatalk
Yes, installed so I could keep adblock and still play Pokemon Go with my kids. Used SuperSU full unroot and then followed the guides here on XDA for how to install it - works great
Installed following the android police tutorial. Root and xposed working. However, when I switch "Root Toggle" in Magisk Manager to the off position, it switches itself back to the on position. Anyone else getting this?
Edit:
This works, per u/Howie_The_Lord on reddit:
Quote:
It seems that this happens, when you ROM is preeroted, you need to delete the system/xbin/su with TWRP and let Magisk mount its own there.
Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemongode...0_with_magisk/
Though, now I get a screen on PoGo saying that my device is not compatible. At least I’m past the authentication.
Trying using Automagisk. It's truly a set it and forget it. http://www.androidpolice.com/2016/0...oid-pay-without-constantly-toggling-root-off/
ytsejam1138 said:
Trying using Automagisk. It's truly a set it and forget it. http://www.androidpolice.com/2016/0...oid-pay-without-constantly-toggling-root-off/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I may look into this.
edit, just tried works great on pokemon-go.
Sent from my R1 HD using Tapatalk
This works, per u/Howie_The_Lord on reddit:
It seems that this happens, when you ROM is preeroted, you need to delete the system/xbin/su with TWRP and let Magisk mount its own there.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemongodev/comments/5265m1/037_on_rooted_android_50_with_magisk/
Though, now I get a screen on PoGo saying that my device is not compatible. At least I’m past the authentication.
stevenlb said:
This works, per u/Howie_The_Lord on reddit:
Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemongodev/comments/5265m1/037_on_rooted_android_50_with_magisk/
Though, now I get a screen on PoGo saying that my device is not compatible. At least I’m past the authentication.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I never got this or any problems.
installed
Magisk-v6.zip
rebooted
installed
phh-superuser-17-magisk.zip
rebooted
went to playstore
installed
phh's SuperUser
installed
Magisk_Manager_v1.2.apk
installed
AutoMagisk v1.0.apk
works great.
So i flashed magisk on my phone 2 weeks ago and everything seemed fine and awesome but then for some reason i decided to use triangle away to reset my flash counter. After doing that i couldn't pass the safetynet test. I tried uninstalling magisk, flashing stock boot and finally flashed magisk zip file but still couldnt pass the safetynet test.
Extra info: i have a Samsung Note 4 N910H 6.0 marshmallow.
Read that disabling usb debugging mode might help but no luck.
Applied other fixes as well
Any help will be appreciated
Not one can help?
majd_90 said:
Not one can help?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No answer usually means just that...
When asking for help it's a good idea to include some kind of log. Upload a Magisk log (as an attachment). Maybe it'll show something (but don't hold your breath).
Didgeridoohan said:
No answer usually means just that...
When asking for help it's a good idea to include some kind of log. Upload a Magisk log (as an attachment). Maybe it'll show something (but don't hold your breath).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Was hoping for some kind of solution or idea to fix it ! I'll try finding the log and uploading it but i doubt it'll show any issues cause everything installed normally without an error or something
majd_90 said:
Was hoping for some kind of solution or idea to fix it ! I'll try finding the log and uploading it but i doubt it'll show any issues cause everything installed normally without an error or something
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Install from Google Play the app called "RootBeer Sample", hide it from Magisk Hide, run it and upload a screenshot and upload the Magisk log.
AFAIK Note 4 doesn't have the original flash counter; it uses Knox and you can't revert that. The last device with a flash counter was S3/mini.
Deic said:
Install from Google Play the app called "RootBeer Sample", hide it from Magisk Hide, run it and upload a screenshot and upload the Magisk log.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here you go ! I attached the screenshot and log ! Alot of Xs on the screenshot but it is rooted
Dexxxta said:
AFAIK Note 4 doesn't have the original flash counter; it uses Knox and you can't revert that. The last device with a flash counter was S3/mini.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wish i knew that ! The flash counter (which triangle away indicated) was 21 , when i reset the counter it turned into 1
majd_90 said:
Here you go ! I attached the screenshot and log ! Alot of Xs on the screenshot but it is rooted
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay, first you didn't hide RootBeer and second SafetyNet was update weeks ago. You need try Universal SafetyNet Fix module, I recommend the beta one
Deic said:
Okay, first you didn't hide RootBeer and second SafetyNet was update weeks ago. You need try Universal SafetyNet Fix module, I recommend the beta one
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ah ya i forgot ! I'll do it again if you want , And where can i get that module? From magisk manager?
Deic said:
Okay, first you didn't hide RootBeer and second SafetyNet was update weeks ago. You need try Universal SafetyNet Fix module, I recommend the beta one
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Much better
Deic said:
Okay, first you didn't hide RootBeer and second SafetyNet was update weeks ago. You need try Universal SafetyNet Fix module, I recommend the beta one
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok so i found it on xda , downloaded the beta one and added it to the modules in magisk manager , and then rebooted. Still not passing the safetynet test
majd_90 said:
Ah ya i forgot ! I'll do it again if you want , And where can i get that module? From magisk manager?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=72844209&postcount=633
@majd_90 Did you install F-Droid Privileged module like the posts say?
Deic said:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=72844209&postcount=633
@majd_90 Did you install F-Droid Privileged module like the posts say?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes i followed what the post mentioned
...
majd_90 said:
Yes i followed what the post mentioned
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you have Xposed and can share post-fs-data.log in /magisk/xiaomi-safetynet-fix folder?
Deic said:
Did you have Xposed and can share post-fs-data.log in /magisk/xiaomi-safetynet-fix folder?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No never had Xposed on this phone before !
majd_90 said:
No never had Xposed on this phone before !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can't execute /system/bin/sh... Do you can try this in terminal and post the result?
Code:
ls -la /system/bin/sh
Deic said:
Can't execute /system/bin/sh... Do you can try this in terminal and post the result?
Code:
ls -la /system/bin/sh
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here u go
Ok so safetynet just passed ! I went to the thread which had the universal safetynet fix module and looked around , i saw a link to another thread which had a lot of suggestions that might work ! So finally i enabled magisk core only mode in the settings, disabled systemless hosts and rebooted..
And vola it passed. Gonna keep monitoring it, i am afriad it might be luck it worked this time. Thanks everyone for your assistance
Good day all
Will xposed work on Note 8 (N950FD)?
Thanks in advance
I would guess that an installer for an S8+ might work since it is basically the same device. Since rooting with TWRP and SuperSU I've flashed a few things meant for S8 devices and they either work properly as is or with very minor script tweaking.
Kalm_Traveler said:
I would guess that an installer for an S8+ might work since it is basically the same device. Since rooting with TWRP and SuperSU I've flashed a few things meant for S8 devices and they either work properly as is or with very minor script tweaking.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks alot for your quick and kind reply...
Yes it worked... Issue is closed
how are you guys gaining root access?
Hdhntr23 said:
how are you guys gaining root access?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exynos models had root several days ago. I'm using SuperSU at the moment.
me7tarfeek said:
Yes it worked... Issue is closed
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
نوّرنا الله يرضى عليك.
We are here to learn, share and contribute. Otherwise, only the development section would be active (thanks to the developers) while the rest of the sections would be full of threads asking for help.
What method for root did you go with? URL for guide page?
What Xposed modules have you tried and are working? root cloak? Snapprefs?
Did you pass SafteyNet?
Thanks in advance.
Hello with xposed what stuff is actually working and is it stable at all for daily use please?
Kalm_Traveler said:
Exynos models had root several days ago. I'm using SuperSU at the moment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does Samsung Pay work?
طوني تبولة said:
نوّرنا الله يرضى عليك.
We are here to learn, share and contribute. Otherwise, only the development section would be active (thanks to the developers) while the rest of the sections would be full of threads asking for help.
What method for root did you go with? URL for guide page?
What Xposed modules have you tried and are working? root cloak? Snapprefs?
Did you pass SafteyNet?
Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure will do
I root with Magisk 14.0 with SafeNet pass
Follow this https://forum.xda-developers.com/ga...t/recovery-twrp-galaxy-note-8-exynos-t3674036
Flashed 26-07-17-xposed-v87-sdk25-Xposed-by-PurifyOS.zip
Now I use the following modules in the image
SiNJiN76 said:
Does Samsung Pay work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think it ever works with a different country device, or on a rooted phone.
me7tarfeek said:
Sure will do
I root with Magisk 14.0 with SafeNet pass
Follow this https://forum.xda-developers.com/ga...t/recovery-twrp-galaxy-note-8-exynos-t3674036
Flashed 26-07-17-xposed-v87-sdk25-Xposed-by-PurifyOS.zip
Now I use the following modules in the image
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This and Magisk exposed module—that's all to install Xposed?
Are you experiencing some instability—some apps FCing sometimes, or nothing at all?
白い熊 said:
This and Magisk exposed module—that's all to install Xposed?
Are you experiencing some instability—some apps FCing sometimes, or nothing at all?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did not install Magisk xposed module.. I used the normal stand alone xposed... It worked perfect with no issues at all. My device is N950FD....
Hdhntr23 said:
how are you guys gaining root access?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Follow this link if your device is N950F/FD....
https://forum.xda-developers.com/ga...t/recovery-twrp-galaxy-note-8-exynos-t3674036
Kalm_Traveler said:
Exynos models had root several days ago. I'm using SuperSU at the moment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is lacky patcher working with super su ?
me7tarfeek said:
I did not install Magisk xposed module.. I used the normal stand alone xposed... It worked perfect with no issues at all. My device is N950FD....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which root do you have—SuperSU or Magisk? I have Magisk, so tried with 26-07-17-xposed-systemless-v87-sdk25-by-PurifyOS.zip but that throws me into a bootloop directly?
How did you proceed chronologically?
First the Xposed apk (which one?), then flash the Purify zip? Did you wipe anything before or after, data or cache? I've read many conflicting reports, since you've done it should be possible to replicate it…
白い熊 said:
Which root do you have—SuperSU or Magisk? I have Magisk, so tried with 26-07-17-xposed-systemless-v87-sdk25-by-PurifyOS.zip but that throws me into a bootloop directly?
How did you proceed chronologically?
First the Xposed apk (which one?), then flash the Purify zip? Did you wipe anything before or after, data or cache? I've read many conflicting reports, since you've done it should be possible to replicate it…
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I flashed Magisk 14 root... Restarted the device to check root... Then Installed xposed apk (XposedInstaller_by_dvdandroid_09_09_17)... Then flashed the above xposed framework. Restarted the device to check xposed, then installed modules...
No wipe at all... The device restarted normaly with no issue..
Good luck
me7tarfeek said:
I flashed Magisk 14 root... Restarted the device to check root... Then Installed xposed apk (XposedInstaller_by_dvdandroid_09_09_17)... Then flashed the above xposed framework. Restarted the device to check xposed, then installed modules...
No wipe at all... The device restarted normaly with no issue..
Good luck
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does this break Android Pay?
vinokirk said:
Does this break Android Pay?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think so. As far as I know, root breaks Android Pay.
We do not have it here so I can not be sure...
Hey guys,
Trying to install the systemless XPosed for Nougat on my Note 8, but for some reason, after installation, it stops my 256GB Exynos Note 8 from booting up. Was able to recover it by running the Magisk uninstaller via TWRP.
Noticed that on the official XPosed thread, it states that it'll 'cause boot loop issues on stock Samsung ROM, but on the Systemless XPosed Page, it claims the SDK 24 and 25 are universal, so, what's wrong?
Any suggestions on getting systemless XPosed working on my Exynos Note 8 with Nougat? I especially want the systemless variant as it allows easy on/off whenever I'm going shopping and want to use Android Pay instead of having to uninstall all modules.
Also modules that I install are not appearing on the modules tap it's almost af if my Magisk stopped working. All I did was uninstall emojione and try to install a ios emoji app and this happened.
Yes, the SafetyNet check was successful (a reply from the server was received) and the check determined that your device does not pass SafetyNet.
Try completely uninstalling and reinstalling Magisk and the Manager.
Didgeridoohan said:
Yes, the SafetyNet check was successful (a reply from the server was received) and the check determined that your device does not pass SafetyNet.
Try completely uninstalling and reinstalling Magisk and the Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How do I uninstall it then? Nothing happened when I clicked install and it just rebooted the device... And I do not have a backup so I can't choose the option "back to stock" under uninstall
DEROLIVAN said:
How do I uninstall it then? Nothing happened when I clicked install and it just rebooted the device... And I do not have a backup so I can't choose the option "back to stock" under uninstall
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, you obviously have a faulty Magisk installation... There's an uninstaller zip in the release thread. Flash that in recovery.
Didgeridoohan said:
Well, you obviously have a faulty Magisk installation... There's an uninstaller zip in the release thread. Flash that in recovery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ty working now
Sorry I just uninstalled and installed again Magisk in my Xperia XZs, but CTSProfile & BasicIntegrity still false. Please help for solution. Thanks. ?
Garrsett said:
Sorry I just uninstalled and installed again Magisk in my Xperia XZs, but CTSProfile & BasicIntegrity still false. Please help for solution. Thanks. ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Install Xposed and intstall the module: No Device Check
pere1313 said:
Install Xposed and intstall the module: No Device Check
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you really want to pass safety net I'd highly recommend that you don't install Xposed!
leepea said:
If you really want to pass safety net I'd highly recommend that you don't install Xposed!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That depends... You can't pass SafetyNet fully, but with the No Device Check module you can make it pass the CTS profile check. So if you have any apps that only rely on that, you might be good to go.
Of course, having Xposed installed may cause other issues, but that's another story.
pere1313 said:
Install Xposed and intstall the module: No Device Check
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi! I've tried your suggestion and it works for ctsProfile, now showing true. But I still got basicIntegrity: false. Any other useful suggestion? Thanks in advance.
metafaniel said:
Hi! I've tried your suggestion and it works for ctsProfile, now showing true. But I still got basicIntegrity: false. Any other useful suggestion? Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, I still have the same problem as you, if you solve the problem, send me a message please.
Thanks.
Didgeridoohan said:
Yes, the SafetyNet check was successful (a reply from the server was received) and the check determined that your device does not pass SafetyNet.
Try completely uninstalling and reinstalling Magisk and the Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello, so I'm in the same situation, except I can't manage to get SafetyNet control to pass... I also have both statue on false, and I can't figure out how to solve it. I've searched for hours a solution, but nothing seems to work. I tried re installing it, hiding the manager... Nothing works. If anyone could help me, that would be really, really appreciated :/
I precise that Magisk and Magisk Manager are up to date, and that I have TWRP installed.
:crying:
KyaCeption said:
Hello, so I'm in the same situation, except I can't manage to get SafetyNet control to pass... I also have both statue on false, and I can't figure out how to solve it. I've searched for hours a solution, but nothing seems to work. I tried re installing it, hiding the manager... Nothing works. If anyone could help me, that would be really, really appreciated :/
I precise that Magisk and Magisk Manager are up to date, and that I have TWRP installed.
:crying:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
pere1313 said:
Hi, I still have the same problem as you, if you solve the problem, send me a message please.
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For Passing The SafetyNet, Check This Post https://forum.xda-developers.com/ap...playstore-services-data-t3789498/post76682978.
Magisk-v16.4 Is Not Suitable For Most Of Us To Use Due To Many Issues So That Flash Its Replacement Magisk-v16.3.1(ThePatchedBinary) From This Link https://androidfilehost.com/?fid=962339331458996616 Or Magisk-v16.3 (Instead Of Magisk-v16.4).
KyaCeption said:
Hello, so I'm in the same situation, except I can't manage to get SafetyNet control to pass... I also have both statue on false, and I can't figure out how to solve it. I've searched for hours a solution, but nothing seems to work. I tried re installing it, hiding the manager... Nothing works. If anyone could help me, that would be really, really appreciated :/
I precise that Magisk and Magisk Manager are up to date, and that I have TWRP installed.
:crying:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Before you keep trying things, make sure that you have the basics taken care of. There are some requirements and necessities for MagiskHide to work. Take a look here: https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Basics
And when asking for help, make sure to include device, ROM, and other necessary details. And logs... Take a look here for that: https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHelp
Hi, my original plan was keeping my OP7 root-free because I need that banking app - which has an incredibly good root detection.
Long story short, a few days later and went back to my old habits... Magisk, Kernel, you name it. And the banking app stopped working again.
I do pass the safetynet test, have repackaged Magisk Manager. Google Pay is working like a charme. But Fidor bank seems to be better than Google, at least in this regard. I tried logging traffic using adguard, the app does not connect to anything, no dns requests as well.
Most of the times the app won't start at all, sometimes the first screen flashes for a very short period, and sometimes chrome opens with a webpage from the bank telling me my device is modified. How the **** do they know?
Maybe you guys may have a hint in what direction I could continue poking, because carrying a second phone just for banking is a little bit overkill...
h0l said:
Hi, my original plan was keeping my OP7 root-free because I need that banking app - which has an incredibly good root detection.
Long story short, a few days later and went back to my old habits... Magisk, Kernel, you name it. And the banking app stopped working again.
I do pass the safetynet test, have repackaged Magisk Manager. Google Pay is working like a charme. But Fidor bank seems to be better than Google, at least in this regard. I tried logging traffic using adguard, the app does not connect to anything, no dns requests as well.
Most of the times the app won't start at all, sometimes the first screen flashes for a very short period, and sometimes chrome opens with a webpage from the bank telling me my device is modified. How the **** do they know?
Maybe you guys may have a hint in what direction I could continue poking, because carrying a second phone just for banking is a little bit overkill...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you clear data of the banking app after Repackaging Magisk & adding it to Magisk Hide? I assume you did it.
Sent from my OnePlus6T using XDA Labs
DarkSJ1998 said:
Did you clear data of the banking app after Repackaging Magisk & adding it to Magisk Hide? I assume you did it.
Sent from my OnePlus6T using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did. And rebooted. And reinstalled. And combinations of those.
A short screenrecord of what is happening as soon as I try to open the app can be found here (youtube link)
I have the exact same Problem
Everything works: Netflix, other banking apps, etc.. Just Fidor. I do not really know how their detection works, but I assume it's not just a root detection.
The weird thing is, it worked flawlessly 2 years ago Now it's just annoying..
Waited a few versions oft Magisk now, however nothing changes.
You're not alone
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Same problem here ... since the new fidor version v3.14 is out, no way to getting it to work. Downgrade to 3.12 is futile, it forces the update to 3.14 immediately.
As an amendment to my post above (where you'll find pretty much all you need to hide from almost any app), I've successfully tested and hidden root from Fidor v3.14.0.1.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=79997227&postcount=98
Thank you, the issue seems to have been addressed there. But as far as I can see, the canary version does not have the optional modules, correct? So I think, unfortunately I will have to wait for an adapted release of the regular magisk.
rpc75 said:
But as far as I can see, the canary version does not have the optional modules, correct?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have no idea what that means... Magisk modules works just fine on the Canary releases.
Didgeridoohan said:
As an amendment to my post above (where you'll find pretty much all you need to hide from almost any app), I've successfully tested and hidden root from Fidor v3.14.0.1.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=79997227&postcount=98
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for sharing!
I have successfully installed the canary Magisk, have Magisk hide enabled, safetynet pass etc.
All bank apps work after adding them to the hide list, for example trying "Kontist" w/o hide gave error, with hide it works.
However, Fidor (3.14.0.1) is still not working for me :/
The app stays open for 1-2 seconds on the canary build, quite a bit longer than on stable version (instant close), clean cache + clean app data, still no luck.
So Fidor must use another detection method that the other bank apps don't have.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
dagoban said:
Thanks for sharing!
I have successfully installed the canary Magisk, have Magisk hide enabled, safetynet pass etc.
All bank apps work after adding them to the hide list, for example trying "Kontist" w/o hide gave error, with hide it works.
However, Fidor (3.14.0.1) is still not working for me :/
The app stays open for 1-2 seconds on the canary build, quite a bit longer than on stable version (instant close), clean cache + clean app data, still no luck.
So Fidor must use another detection method that the other bank apps don't have.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Similar Problem, my bank brought out a new app, that is detecting the root/custom rom somehow. The app closes and shows me security bull**** about root, jailbreak, custom roms. I don't know how everything should be hidden, SafetyNet checks out but this app can detect it. No idea how.
alike03 said:
Similar Problem, my bank brought out a new app, that is detecting the root/custom rom somehow. The app closes and shows me security bull**** about root, jailbreak, custom roms. I don't know how everything should be hidden, SafetyNet checks out but this app can detect it. No idea how.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check the link, one post before yours...
Didgeridoohan said:
Check the link, one post before yours...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I was already going through that one.
Turns out the Banking app was detecting the Original Magisk Package.
Hiding Magisk Manager itself fixed my problem. Thanks for the link.
Didgeridoohan said:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Still did not get Fidor to work. Crashes after the initial first 2-3 seconds. If I uninstall Magisk it works again. Disabling modules, delete files from sd-card, etc. didn't change a thing.
This also seem not to be the problem, since it works after uninstalling Magisk.
Fidor is hidden from Magisk, Magisk is repacked with other name.
Mind giving specific instructions on what you did to make Fidor work on your device?
Thyrador said:
Mind giving specific instructions on what you did to make Fidor work on your device?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's all right there in the link provided. I'm not doing anything that's not described there... Of course, there's a whole lot of things there that I didn't do.
Here's my setup:
Android Pie.
Magisk v19.4 (19307), with hidden Manager.
The app on the Hide list.
My internal storage is full of Magisk files and I never bother to disable any modules (all of the ones I have installed can be hidden without issue). I also have OEM Unlocking disabled, but that's just by chance and not something I've done because of an app detecting it...
Didgeridoohan said:
It's all right there in the link provided. I'm not doing anything that's not described there... Of course, there's a whole lot of things there that I didn't do.
Here's my setup:
Android Pie.
Magisk v19.4 (19307), with hidden Manager.
The app on the Hide list.
My internal storage is full of Magisk files and I never bother to disable any modules (all of the ones I have installed can be hidden without issue). I also have OEM Unlocking disabled, but that's just by chance and not something I've done because of an app detecting it...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So basically same setup. Still doesn't work with latest Fidor Release.
Thyrador said:
So basically same setup. Still doesn't work with latest Fidor Release.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you say "basically", what's the difference?
Didgeridoohan said:
When you say "basically", what's the difference?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the question. Even if I do a complete fresh install without anything else beside Magisk and Fidor: as soon as Magisk is running (hidden manager & Fidor, SafetyNet Pass and certified in PlayStore), Fidor stops working.
Thyrador said:
That's the question. Even if I do a complete fresh install without anything else beside Magisk and Fidor: as soon as Magisk is running (hidden manager & Fidor, SafetyNet Pass and certified in PlayStore), Fidor stops working.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're going to have to start digging deeper then...