I successfully installed magisk on my samsung s8 but now the secure folder, software updates and maybe other apps don't work as they recognise my phone being rooted. I thought the point behind magisk was to hide the phone from looking rooted?
how can i fix this issue?
thanks
You tripped KNOX by flashing custom binaries. You're boned.
is there a way to root the phone without tripping KNOX?
cpu2007 said:
is there a way to root the phone without tripping KNOX?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There might be, but I don't think there's any going back for you. As far as I know you can't revert a triggered KNOX...
I installed magisk because I thought knox won't be tripped but I was wrong.
Does anyone know how I can use secure folder, software updates and banking apps now that my app is rooted? they can all recognise my app is rooted and won't work
cpu2007 said:
I installed magisk because I thought knox won't be tripped but I was wrong.
Does anyone know how I can use secure folder, software updates and banking apps now that my app is rooted? they can all recognise my app is rooted and won't work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can still hide Magisk from many apps with Magisk. You'll just have to activate Magisk Hide in the Manager settings. SafetyNet is added by default and any other app that detects root might be fooled if you add it to the Magisk Hide list.
I've said it before and I'm sure I'll say it again. The purpose of Magisk is NOT to hide root and pass SafetyNet (it's just a really nice feature); it's to make your system modifications systemless. You could use this to keep your devices ability to update through OTA, with a couple of extra steps. But, the main advantage for me (and it's the deal-breaker) is that I don't have to redo any of my system modifications after an update. These could be changing screen density, debloating system apps, systemising apps, changing prop values, etc. Before Magisk I could spend 30-45 minutes after an update just setting upp all the system tweaks the way I wanted it, only to realise a couples of days later I'd forgotten something. Now, with Magisk - flash the update, done!
Recommended reading if you're new to Magisk:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-details-dummies-to-developers-t3473486
And if you're having issues:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
I have activated Magisk Hide and selected the app (Lloyds banking app) then restarted the phone but the app can still recognize that the phone is modified.
I'll look at the other solution that are being proposed in one of the links you've sent and sew how it goes but if anyone has any advice on how to fix this, that will be great.
I have backup for my bootloader,boot,system etc - flashing that back, will it revert the knox?
Thanks
cpu2007 said:
I have backup for my bootloader,boot,system etc - flashing that back, will it revert the knox?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't do Samsung, but as I understand it: nope.
More info can probably be found in your device's forum here on XDA.
cpu2007 said:
I have activated Magisk Hide and selected the app (Lloyds banking app) then restarted the phone but the app can still recognize that the phone is modified.
I'll look at the other solution that are being proposed in one of the links you've sent and sew how it goes but if anyone has any advice on how to fix this, that will be great.
I have backup for my bootloader,boot,system etc - flashing that back, will it revert the knox?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Realise this is a very late reply, but if still had no joy with Lloyd's banking app, it will store it's root detection so will still think your phone's rooted even after Magisk Hide. Need to wipe the app data or reinstall.
Has anyone gotten Samsung Pay to work with Magisk? I've got it installed as a gear plugin and safetynet passes. However, somehow Samsung Pay still detects root, even though it's hidden in magisk hide.
Same. Then this droidx program protecting pay app
Sent from my SM-N910V using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Try the universal safteynet net module
Is your Knox tripped? Samsung Pay might check that independently of the root-status of your phone.
grymkmb said:
Is your Knox tripped? Samsung Pay might check that independently of the root-status of your phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm on an LG
I've got the same issue with galaxy tab 3
I got warranty bit warning was showing on the boot screen, so I'm pretty sure I triggered Knox. The reason I was using magisk was to prevent this issue, but I guess Google figured out how to detect its presence. I downloaded a fresh copy of the firmware, which will cause Knox to reset but it also factory resets the tablet. I will still use magisk on my new s8+ phone. I hope magisk will work more effectively to where I can use exposed and its modules. After jellybean, magisk wasn't able to allow exposed to be used because of the way Android sets up its environment to execute apps. Hopefully soon a work around will be accomplished especially since Oreo is coming to my two devices by the end of the year, I guess if not sooner.
Same problem here; Magisk works but Samsung pay won't work
Even tried freezing magisk. Though still no go must be detecting something.
hkbladelawhk said:
Has anyone gotten Samsung Pay to work with Magisk? I've got it installed as a gear plugin and safetynet passes. However, somehow Samsung Pay still detects root, even though it's hidden in magisk hide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried the same thing but couldn't make it work. I think it is due to the fact that the "System Status" is custom (or modified) since magisk modifies the "boot" partition, and that you probably installed a custom recovery to install magisk. That's why OTA also don't work without first flashing back the original boot and recovery images. I don't have an LG to verify that the "System Status" appears on those.
If it does, what could be tried is to install xposed and a module that fakes the system status (if you've got marshmallow or before)
sevenday4 said:
I got warranty bit warning was showing on the boot screen, so I'm pretty sure I triggered Knox. The reason I was using magisk was to prevent this issue, but I guess Google figured out how to detect its presence. I downloaded a fresh copy of the firmware, which will cause Knox to reset but it also factory resets the tablet. I will still use magisk on my new s8+ phone. I hope magisk will work more effectively to where I can use exposed and its modules. After jellybean, magisk wasn't able to allow exposed to be used because of the way Android sets up its environment to execute apps. Hopefully soon a work around will be accomplished especially since Oreo is coming to my two devices by the end of the year, I guess if not sooner.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, once knox is tripped there is no going back. However, installing Magisk fools the phone into thinking knox is still untriggerred (0x0). By reflashing the original firmware, what you did is restore the "boot" partition that was modified by magisk. By doing that, your phone should get back its "official status", allowing OTA. However, Knox will stay tripped. Anyway, Knox does little... and is only used by samsung softwares.
There is nothing that we can do about it because Samsung Pay checks the tripped status on kernel level so it's impossible.
Iradj said:
There is nothing that we can do about it because Samsung Pay checks the tripped status on kernel level so it's impossible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Booo!
someone please made an apps that can hide or fake the Knox status.
Iradj said:
There is nothing that we can do about it because Samsung Pay checks the tripped status on kernel level so it's impossible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is possible by disabling safetynet check at boot level before compiling the kernel
Iradj said:
There is nothing that we can do about it because Samsung Pay checks the tripped status on kernel level so it's impossible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does this apply for non-Samsung phones? I understand that Knox has a tripped flag, but on a non-Samsung phone, what exactly is "tripped"? As with everyone else, I'm pretty frustrated that I still can't use Samsung pay, even on a phone that passes safety checks and has MagiskHide.
gghose said:
Does this apply for non-Samsung phones? I understand that Knox has a tripped flag, but on a non-Samsung phone, what exactly is "tripped"? As with everyone else, I'm pretty frustrated that I still can't use Samsung pay, even on a phone that passes safety checks and has MagiskHide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Works for me on a Samsung phone, after hide I just had to rename all busybox exe's.
Doesn't work for me on a OnePlus 3T, OOS 4.1.7, rooted with Magisk 14.0. This stopped working after the Samsung Pay (Gear version) was updated right around August 21st. Maybe I'm just missing one or more binaries or apps that still must be hidden. I don't have any busybox apps installed, though I previously did, and I removed the busybox binaries where I knew to find them. Maybe it's detecting Magisk's su install, or some other binary I still need to remove. SafetyNet passes just fine, and I can use AndroidPay and CapitalOneWallet on the phone, but I can't use the SPay tab in the Gear app without getting the "rooted phone" message.
Magisk hide 14
Hi Yeti47: I have a samsung galaxy s8 sm-g950f. It is rooted wit renovate ice and magisk 14. What modules I have to check in magisk hide to make samsung pay working? Please answer me in [email protected]. Thank you so much. Bye.
Finally solved it. Busybox can be installed in /data/local, apart from /system/xbin or /system/bin. Samsung Pay will find it there. After I removed it, I was able to get Samsung Pay (Gear Version) working again on my OnePlus 3T.
Spot on fella, just got it working on OP5 with lineage ROM.
dcbii said:
Finally solved it. Busybox can be installed in /data/local, apart from /system/xbin or /system/bin. Samsung Pay will find it there. After I removed it, I was able to get Samsung Pay (Gear Version) working again on my OnePlus 3T.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Root explorer won't let me remove it from xbin. How exactly did you do it?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Is there a module to bypass/cloak a tripped Knox & root access to enable use of Pay?
I'm thinking of something like Root Cloak (When it worked with Snapchat) - except working and for the new Nougat Xposed. I'm using the Galaxy S5+ on a Resurrection Remix rom.
You could say "Well why not just use Root Cloak?" but the module says that it only supports 5.x.x & 6.x.x., whereas I am on 7.1.1. Thank you for any help
Note: My KNOX is tripped and there is no reset. I'm hoping that there is a module that will cloak this and/or at least fool Android Pay to work on my phone.
No.
Sent from this galaxy
Hi All,
I'm trying to set up my work MDM, which uses centrify. I get an error that the device does not meet requirements, and I'm sure it's related to root. Anyone have any experience with centrify and how to properly hide it root from it? I clicked on centrify in the magisk hide, but it still detects root. I think Centrify uses some component of Samsung Knox as well. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!
Tips for hiding root:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
If it uses Knox you're out of luck. Nothing Magisk can do there...
Hi xda-developers
How can I disable Knox
knox block supersu ?
Why do you want to disable knox?
If you just want to root then just root, knox will be disabled when it detects root.
Most of the time ppl root without disable knox as many apps won't run with knox triggered or disabled.
Sent from my SM-G985F using Tapatalk
I try that with supersu but fail supersu cant make cause still not work %100 for this problem