Database Develop

[Q] Phone won't boot after root

Hi everyone,
When I first received my phone a few days ago, I unlocked and rooted it. But then I noticed I wasn't passing safetynet so I unrooted it.
Eversince, when I try to reroot it, it won't boot. It stays stuck on the boot animation (I waited up to 20 minutes).
If I reflash the ROM, it boots. If I reflash the ROM, wipe davlik & cache, and root, it stays stuck on the boot animation.
So my guess was that it was not ROM related, nor cache related, so it must be caused by something on my data partition. But I don't want to wipe it if I have another way to fix it.
Any idea on what might be preventing my phone from booting when I root it?
Thanks!

after root do you have flashed superSU?

RotesMeerJogger said:
after root do you have flashed superSU?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I flashed superSU to root the phone!
But when I do it, it won't boot.

Probably image got corrupted, Download the zip of the rom "oxygen os zip", clean flash it through recovery, try to root again

Daman5202 said:
Probably image got corrupted, Download the zip of the rom "oxygen os zip", clean flash it through recovery, try to root again
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I flash if without root it boots perfectly, are you sure about the image being corrupted?

gigaboss said:
When I flash if without root it boots perfectly, are you sure about the image being corrupted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As you said "it stucks on boot", many times the phone gets stuck on boot when the image is corrupted , its called soft brick. Try downloading the zip file of os, flash it through recovery. The img is probably facing some errors while booting with root access. Are you nougat user? 7.1? And are you using default recovery?

As most people have said here already, in general this should work. So which version of oxygenos are you running? And what recovery? Also, after flashing Supersu, you should not wipe caches as far as I know (forgot the source). Re-download the image, and flash it and directly after flash supersu (both in twrp) and your problem should be solved.

donny110 said:
As most people have said here already, in general this should work. So which version of oxygenos are you running? And what recovery? Also, after flashing Supersu, you should not wipe caches as far as I know (forgot the source). Re-download the image, and flash it and directly after flash supersu (both in twrp) and your problem should be solved.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK I am sorry I was not clear enough, this is exactly what I have been doing!
I have TWRP, when I only flash the 3.5.4 OOS it works perfectly. When I flash OOS 3.5.4 and superSU it doesn't boot.
So the image doesn't seem corrupted, I re-downloaded it.
Is it clearer?

gigaboss said:
OK I am sorry I was not clear enough, this is exactly what I have been doing!
I have TWRP, when I only flash the 3.5.4 OOS it works perfectly. When I flash OOS 3.5.4 and superSU it doesn't boot.
So the image doesn't seem corrupted, I re-downloaded it.
Is it clearer?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you cleared caches before the flash? And are you using the Full OOS 3.5.4? And I assume the most recent Supersu? I did exactly that 2 days ago. Using the full OOS zip that is in one of the threads here on XDA (can't link on phone right now).
Btw. It can bootloop a few times and take awhile once you flash both.. If that doesn't work I guess it's beyond my knowledge. You might want to try if the same thing happens with 3.5.3

gigaboss said:
Hi everyone,
When I first received my phone a few days ago, I unlocked and rooted it. But then I noticed I wasn't passing safetynet so I unrooted it.
Eversince, when I try to reroot it, it won't boot. It stays stuck on the boot animation (I waited up to 20 minutes).
If I reflash the ROM, it boots. If I reflash the ROM, wipe davlik & cache, and root, it stays stuck on the boot animation.
So my guess was that it was not ROM related, nor cache related, so it must be caused by something on my data partition. But I don't want to wipe it if I have another way to fix it.
Any idea on what might be preventing my phone from booting when I root it?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have my 3T yet to verify, but did you flash the zip which disables encryption and dm-verity?
EDIT: From the TWRP thread, step 10: http://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-3t/development/recovery-twrp-oneplus-3t-t3507308

Any update to this? I have the exact same problem; clean flash 3.5.4 OOS (tried it via twrp, adb sideload and MsmDownloadTool) then flash SuperSU via twrp (tried multiple SuperSU versions) and all results in sitting at the boot animation. I've let it sit for 2 hours and it never gets beyond boot animation. No matter what, I can't get SuperSU to work. However, I have no problem getting phh superuser to boot up. Any idea why SuperSU won't boot for me?

__McB__ said:
Any update to this? I have the exact same problem; clean flash 3.5.4 OOS (tried it via twrp, adb sideload and MsmDownloadTool) then flash SuperSU via twrp (tried multiple SuperSU versions) and all results in sitting at the boot animation. I've let it sit for 2 hours and it never gets beyond boot animation. No matter what, I can't get SuperSU to work. However, I have no problem getting phh superuser to boot up. Any idea why SuperSU won't boot for me?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got to the bottom of my problem (but did not solve it somehow) by formatting and trying every possibility. I lost all my data :crying:
So here is what happens:
-I start with a clean ROM, root it, install kernel, everything works fine EXCEPT for safetynet that won't pass even with root switch
-I try to install suhide 0.55, the phone won't start anymore (stays on boot animation, tried to wait all night)
AND HERE IS THE WEIRD THING.
-If I dirty flash the rom to start over, it boots, if then I flash SuperSU, it won't boot!! As if suhide was still in the data partition and preventing the phone from booting!!
So it means that if I try to install suhide once, I am not able to boot with root anymore... I need to format my data partition and start all over again.

Hmm. My issue is slightly different, I guess. I'm not even attempting suhide, just SuperSU. No matter what, I can't boot up once I flash SuperSU. Guess I'll give it another try with the new 2.79 sr2 and oos4.
Thanks!

__McB__ said:
Hmm. My issue is slightly different, I guess. I'm not even attempting suhide, just SuperSU. No matter what, I can't boot up once I flash SuperSU. Guess I'll give it another try with the new 2.79 sr2 and oos4.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you have any luck with this? I'm having the same issue. Flash the 4.0.2 update and boots fine. Flash SuperSU or phh (I've tried both!) and I just sit at the boot animation for hours until I get angry and restore nandroid to 3.5.4.

hyperblau said:
Did you have any luck with this? I'm having the same issue. Flash the 4.0.2 update and boots fine. Flash SuperSU or phh (I've tried both!) and I just sit at the boot animation for hours until I get angry and restore nandroid to 3.5.4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://build.nethunter.com/android-tools/no-verity-opt-encrypt/
I had a similar issue with my op3t after root it, I wipe data but it won't start, I just flash the zip 5.1 no verity opt encrypt and should be work fine without flashing supersu:good:

hyperblau said:
Did you have any luck with this? I'm having the same issue. Flash the 4.0.2 update and boots fine. Flash SuperSU or phh (I've tried both!) and I just sit at the boot animation for hours until I get angry and restore nandroid to 3.5.4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, never got it working. Upgraded to 4.0.2 and never looked back.

Maybe you already tried this version.. Otherwise...

Blackscreen after magisk update

Hello,
I have a problem with my 3T. I updated magisk yesterday via magisk manager from 11.2 to 11.5. After the update my screen was completely black, the funny thing is if I press my power button long enough the reboot menu pops up. I can boot into recovery, the bootanimation is working but the ROM itself isn't visible.
I tried reflashing magisk via recovery, ROM+magisk via recovery, ROM via recovery and uninstalled magisk via recovery. Nothing works, the last thing I can try is a complete factory reset.
Does anyone has maybe an idea what else I can do?
I would appreciate any form of hint

yup i had the same thing, used the brick recovery tool and was fine but when i re unlocked the bootloader i forgot it wipes internal data and lost all my pics music and titanium backups. Very annoyed to say the least.

EuEra said:
yup i had the same thing, used the brick recovery tool and was fine but when i re unlocked the bootloader i forgot it wipes internal data and lost all my pics music and titanium backups. Very annoyed to say the least.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That solved my issue, didn't realize that I really bricked my device. Sadly it wiped my data also!
Thanks for your advice!

I've experienced this about 3 times over the last 4 months, and had to restore a full backup each time. Basically afraid to do anything with Magisk at this point. This really needs to be fixed.

It's probably because the Magisk updater is interfering with the kernel.
Every time Magisk is updated, I always dirty flash my current ROM and flash the new version of Magisk over it. I can then flash a custom kernel and everything still works flawlessly.

Anova's Origin said:
It's probably because the Magisk updater is interfering with the kernel.
Every time Magisk is updated, I always dirty flash my current ROM and flash the new version of Magisk over it. I can then flash a custom kernel and everything still works flawlessly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did that when i switched from official to open beta, and everything went fine, then i installed a module, rebooted and got blackscreen again

Anova's Origin said:
It's probably because the Magisk updater is interfering with the kernel.
Every time Magisk is updated, I always dirty flash my current ROM and flash the new version of Magisk over it. I can then flash a custom kernel and everything still works flawlessly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not the kernel, the black screen has occurred twice when just installing a module with no modifications to /boot.

dre-z said:
Hello,
I have a problem with my 3T. I updated magisk yesterday via magisk manager from 11.2 to 11.5. After the update my screen was completely black, the funny thing is if I press my power button long enough the reboot menu pops up. I can boot into recovery, the bootanimation is working but the ROM itself isn't visible.
I tried reflashing magisk via recovery, ROM+magisk via recovery, ROM via recovery and uninstalled magisk via recovery. Nothing works, the last thing I can try is a complete factory reset.
Does anyone has maybe an idea what else I can do?
I would appreciate any form of hint
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Fix for me was to boot twrp, manually wipe system, data, caches etc (NOT internal storage box), then clean install the OS in twrp. Keeps your data and encryption then.

Just happened again. Ugh. Anybody manage to recover their existing data partition from this?
---------- Post added at 01:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:15 PM ----------
I think this is the fundamental issue: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/185

I've not experienced anything like this on my OP3T. I did see something similar on my Nexus 6 a couple of times, but could never quite get a grip on what caused it (I had a lot of other issues with that device ).
Is there any particular module that has been known to cause the issue (for testing)?

Didgeridoohan said:
I've not experienced anything like this on my OP3T. I did see something similar on my Nexus 6 a couple of times, but could never quite get a grip on what caused it (I had a lot of other issues with that device ).
Is there any particular module that has been known to cause the issue (for testing)?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, I've had this happen with multiple modules, including App Systemizer, ad-free YouTube, and OP3/T channel bonding enabler. Based on the file size changes in magisk.img, I legitimately think that the linked GitHub issue is the root cause. I think the only consistent repro is to flash different versions of modules while rebooting repeatedly.

Problem might be corrupted magisk.img during resize.

vemacs said:
Just happened again. Ugh. Anybody manage to recover their existing data partition from this?
---------- Post added at 01:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:15 PM ----------
I think this is the fundamental issue: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/185
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the same issue when trying to install xposed 87.1 through MagiskManager (black screen and repeated vibration).
On my J5 I just removed the battery and booted into twrp, then I uninstalled magisk with the uninstall-zip, wiped dalvik an cache, rebooted once and everything works.
I reinstalled magisk in twrp and installed xposed 87.0 through the material xposed-installer and everything works.
No data loss.

The issue on GitHub was closed with a comment saying that it's likely fixed in latest Magisk (13.1). FWIW I haven't seen it occur after running 13 beta for a while.

My op3 was bricked again today after the update. Funny thing is, this time I had not installed any module. So the problem doesn't seem to be fixed.

pls someone should help me i tried to root my android v10 infinix note8i with magisk patch boot img file using adb fastboot when i tranfer the file and reboot the phone is not booting and not gettig into recovery mode, just blank screen when a turn on pls help me out with solution

same but my problem is kind of stupid because someone rooted my phone in another way and magisk says it is installed and needs updating but it is actually not and the biggest problem is when i unroot my phone the stupid rmm locks gets enabled and boom i can't open twrp recovery because it is not an offical binary so i got stuck there i flashed a stock rom got it fixed but i still can't do it

[SOLVED!] Can't install Magisk without bootloop

Scroll down over this post to see anwer!
Hey there! I just got my Xiaomi Mi8 from HK Goldway at Aliexpress. It came with its bootloader already unlocked and a Global ROM flashed.
I wanted to install Magisk but failed horribly . I've already done that to several phones (my last one was a Moto X Play, and it worked without major complications). But with this one, it seems I can't get past the bootlogo.
Stock Fastboot image used:
dipper_global_images_V9.5.13.0.OEAMIFA_20180714.0000.00_8.1_global
This is what I've tried so far:
First try
Flashed TWRP for Mi8 version 0711.
Flashed Magisk.
Got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Second try
Booted (not flashed) TWRP.
Tried to install latest global weekly from this thread.
Also got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Third try
I thought that those flashable ZIP firmwares were too small for them to be a full-fledged OS. So I went and downloaded this other one. Global version.
I read somewhere that I needed to format data before flashing a new image, so I did.
Booted TWRP.
Formated data (not Wipe)
Installed that ZIP from TWRP and booted correctly.
Booted TWRP again and flashed Magisk.
Got bootloop.
Back to stock image via fastboot.
Last try
Booted TWRP.
Formatted data.
Installed MIUI via TWRP.
Without rebooting, flashed Magisk and no-verity-opt-encrypt-6.0.zip.
This got past bootlogo ("Unlocked" message changed to "powered by Android") but got stuck there. Not booting at all.
Right now I'm back to the last try, booting MIUI successfully but without Magisk nor no-verity-opt-encrypt.
I kinda have no more ideas left. I understand this is a new device but I can't understand why people claim the have been able to install Magisk and I can't! Other thoughts were, maybe they were running MIUI 10 Beta and it only works with that version? I'm unsure about that.
Can someone lend me a hand? What am I missing?
Thank you!!
EDIT: FIX!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7.
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata.
Rebooted.
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Hope this works out for everyone having this problem!

have you tried to use Magisk 16.4,
if not, try to follow this guide:
https://www.theandroidsoul.com/xiaomi-mi-8-root/

gulp79 said:
have you tried to use Magisk 16.4,
if not, try to follow this guide:
https://www.theandroidsoul.com/xiaomi-mi-8-root/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the fast reply!
I followed that guide and tried these steps:
fastboot boot mi8-twrp-3.2.2.img
Unencrypted via Pattern
Flashed Magisk v16.4 + DM verity disabler file
Reboot
But I'm still stuck at "powered by Android" bootlogo.
Normally it boots within 5 seconds but now it's taking forever. I'll wait a few minutes to see what happens.
I'm attaching some screenshots of the install process.

Padlite said:
Thank you for the fast reply!
I followed that guide and tried these steps:
fastboot boot mi8-twrp-3.2.2.img
Unencrypted via Pattern
Flashed Magisk v16.4 + DM verity disabler file
Reboot
But I'm still stuck at "powered by Android" bootlogo.
Normally it boots within 5 seconds but now it's taking forever. I'll wait a few minutes to see what happens.
I'm attaching some screenshots of the install process.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok,
but if you install Magisk 16.4, don't install also DM verity disabler.
DM verity disabler is needed if you don't want to root (see poin 14 in the linked guide).
Hope it works...

gulp79 said:
Ok,
but if you install Magisk 16.4, don't install also DM verity disabler.
DM verity disabler is needed if you don't want to root (see poin 14 in the linked guide).
Hope it works...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If I only flash Magisk 16.4, then phone shows "Powered by Android" and instantly reboots into stock recovery.
Only way to get it back booting, is performing fastboot flash boot boot.img from stock dipper_global_images_V9.5.13.0.OEAMIFA_20180714.0000.00_8.1_global image
I read somewhere about official and unofficial bootloader unlock. I didn't unlock the bootloader myself. Maybe it has something to do with it?
PS: Anyone had any luck using Magisk with MIUI 9.5.13?

Did you try with a newer magisk version ? ... 16.7 was released 15 day ago
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-v16.7.zip
It´s a good practice to use magisk_uninstaller before flash new one if you had problems.
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-uninstaller-20180719.zip
Please tell us if it´s works

Seems that also others users have this problem
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77234924&postcount=6312

punk84z said:
Did you try with a newer magisk version ? ... 16.7 was released 15 day ago
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-v16.7.zip
It´s a good practice to use magisk_uninstaller before flash new one if you had problems.
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-uninstaller-20180719.zip
Please tell us if it´s works
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just tried that. Uninstalling and re-installing v16.7. Although it seems now it's doing a few more steps, I'm still getting the recovery bootloop.
Install log screenshot attached.
gulp79 said:
Seems that also others users have this problem
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77234924&postcount=6312
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly that. Maybe we'll need to wait for a supported Magisk version. I'm still wondering what's the difference between our Mi8's that some can get Magisk working and some not. ?

I am running Magisk stable and tmiui 10 from Xiaomi. Eu without any problems.

I have a Mi 8 se and i install the eu rom boot the phone , reboot to twrp wipe and factory reset and installed magisk 16.4 .this is how works for me

i have the same problem too..when using china stable rom 16.7 magisk can be installed successfully tried many times...
flashing global version seems to have this issue...
tried all this steps too but no luck in global rom...

Padlite said:
Hey there! I just got my Xiaomi Mi8 from HK Goldway at Aliexpress. It came with its bootloader already unlocked and a Global ROM flashed.
I wanted to install Magisk but failed horribly . I've already done that to several phones (my last one was a Moto X Play, and it worked without major complications). But with this one, it seems I can't get past the bootlogo.
Stock Fastboot image used:
dipper_global_images_V9.5.13.0.OEAMIFA_20180714.0000.00_8.1_global
This is what I've tried so far:
First try
Flashed TWRP for Mi8 version 0711.
Flashed Magisk.
Got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Second try
Booted (not flashed) TWRP.
Tried to install latest global weekly from this thread.
Also got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Third try
I thought that those flashable ZIP firmwares were too small for them to be a full-fledged OS. So I went and downloaded this other one. Global version.
I read somewhere that I needed to format data before flashing a new image, so I did.
Booted TWRP.
Formated data (not Wipe)
Installed that ZIP from TWRP and booted correctly.
Booted TWRP again and flashed Magisk.
Got bootloop.
Back to stock image via fastboot.
Last try
Booted TWRP.
Formatted data.
Installed MIUI via TWRP.
Without rebooting, flashed Magisk and no-verity-opt-encrypt-6.0.zip.
This got past bootlogo ("Unlocked" message changed to "powered by Android") but got stuck there. Not booting at all.
Right now I'm back to the last try, booting MIUI successfully but without Magisk nor no-verity-opt-encrypt.
I kinda have no more ideas left. I understand this is a new device but I can't understand why people claim the have been able to install Magisk and I can't! Other thoughts were, maybe they were running MIUI 10 Beta and it only works with that version? I'm unsure about that.
Can someone lend me a hand? What am I missing?
Thank you!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i allso hade that problem
wen i got my phone it was with global rom
then i flashed twrp
didt like they said
wipe dalvik cache an cache an factory reset
flashed miui eu rom
then flashed twrp again rebooted into recovery
flashed magisk 16.4
ended up in staying on android logo
then i try format data an didt it all again
still android logo an nothing more
well then i didt what i allways didt on my other devices
i wiped dalvik cache
cache
data
system
then i flashed eu rom
an twrp again rebooted into recovery again
then flashed magisk 16.4
rebooted system an now it booted up
REMEMBER to manke a backup before flashing all off thise things otherwice u wont have the option to go back if something goes wrong

-fluffy- said:
i allso hade that problem
wen i got my phone it was with global rom
then i flashed twrp
didt like they said
wipe dalvik cache an cache an factory reset
flashed miui eu rom
then flashed twrp again rebooted into recovery
flashed magisk 16.4
ended up in staying on android logo
then i try format data an didt it all again
still android logo an nothing more
well then i didt what i allways didt on my other devices
i wiped dalvik cache
cache
data
system
then i flashed eu rom
an twrp again rebooted into recovery again
then flashed magisk 16.4
rebooted system an now it booted up
REMEMBER to manke a backup before flashing all off thise things otherwice u wont have the option to go back if something goes wrong
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well maybe the critical step is to wipe everything, including System.
Did you Format anything instead of Wipe this last try?
Also, could you please share a link from that working MIUI rom?
Thank you!

Sorry for double-posting, but I wanted to notify you I GOT IT!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata
Rebooted
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Here are some screenshots!

Padlite said:
Sorry for double-posting, but I wanted to notify you I GOT IT!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata
Rebooted
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Here are some screenshots!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is Google Assistant ("OK Google") working for you now as well?

I just flashed magisk v16.0 over the Miui 8.7.26 build and it booted without issues.

japancakes said:
Is Google Assistant ("OK Google") working for you now as well?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just checked and no. If I go to Google Settings -> Voice, Voice Match is disabled because "This feature is currently unavailable for this language". Even though it's set to English UK. Maybe there is some Magisk Module to enable it?

Thanks, followed these steps and it got magisk going on the recent global release. Only difference was i had to use fastboot erase userdata.
Padlite said:
Scroll down over this post to see anwer!
EDIT: FIX!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7.
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata.
Rebooted.
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Hope this works out for everyone having this problem!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Hey guys im a toal newbie to this whole flash theme but Ive purchased a mi8 and i would like to use GooglePay and so on, could someone give me a step by step tutorial , how to install all this stuff on my device ?

Padlite said:
Sorry for double-posting, but I wanted to notify you I GOT IT!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata
Rebooted
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Here are some screenshots!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well i didt not flash dm-verity an mine pass saftynet

Someone please help me before i give up (30 hours in, only bricking my phones)

I'm willing to offer money. I need help guys.
I'm on my third phone, probably spent about 30 some hours. I just can't seem to root a phone. I've tried it all.
I have a Motorola E5 Play. You have to speak to me like I'm 2. I read a guide that was supposedly designed and written for a 5 year old. It didn't work. I only bricked my phone and spent 10 hours on it.
I need one on one coaching. I need someone to help me root a phone I just don't get why this is so difficult!
Currently it doesn't even boot. I think it's a soft brick and needs to be recovered.

so it looks like I did a restore in TWRP and now the phone is booting up. okay so that's a good sign. still no root. the phone essentially bricked after I installed Magisk.

anon702 said:
so it looks like I did a restore in TWRP and now the phone is booting up. okay so that's a good sign. still no root. the phone essentially bricked after I installed Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay, first things first, have you unlocked your bootloader using the official Motorola unlocking portal?

IDrinkTooMuchCoffee said:
He wouldn't have twrp install as he said if he didn't unlock the bootloader.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indeed. My question was not whether his bootloader was unlocked, but rather an inquiry as to the method used to unlock his bootloader. You do not need Magisk 19.3 or older. My Boost E5 Play is presently rooted on Magisk v20 3-stable, on the latest firmware build OCPS27.91-140-18. Prior to patching the boot image with Magisk, it is recommended to disable force encryption manually by patching the fstab located in /vendor/etc/fstab.qcom. Magisk will fully disable dm-verity during the boot image patching.
---------- Post added at 05:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:52 PM ----------
IDrinkTooMuchCoffee said:
So patching the boot.img with magisk v20.3 works? Never had to do that other than when flashing a gsi. Good to know I guess but it's just as easy to flash v19.3 then update through magisk manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I do recall the boot loop issue you are referring to in some of those Magisk builds after v19.3. Magisk v20.3 seems to have fixed that issue. You're right -- you can simply patch with v19.3 and then update via Magisk Manager. Either way you want to do it should get the same end result -- full systemless root via Magisk.

In some cases like mine you have to use magisk 19.2. Moto did a update that messed it up using 19.3. I kept getting a bootloop and once I used 19.2 it worked flawlessly.

hi all.
I read the entire forum in the past 2 days.
i have hannah to the state of stuck boot logo with all the custom 9.0 PIE roms.
i gues i am doing something wrong. please help.
So far:
unlock bootloader
twrp pie installed
rooted magisk 19. 2
format data
clear dav/cache/system
copy rom + gapps on sd card
flash rom + gapps
clear cache/ dav
restart
BOOTLOGO stuck

Create a new post but after you rooted the phone did it boot before the custom rom?

Smurfy76 said:
Create a new post but after you rooted the phone did it boot before the custom rom?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
bootlogo stuck before and after root.
Rooted with 19.2 to 20.3 still stuck
ty

How long did you let it sit for. If it isn't rebooting maybe let it sit there like 5 mins on the splash screen. It takes awhile after rooting the first time.

Smurfy76 said:
How long did you let it sit for. If it isn't rebooting maybe let it sit there like 5 mins on the splash screen. It takes awhile after rooting the first time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
20 mins.
With 8.1 is booting under 2 minutes.

If it's booting on official it maybe the rom your using.

Smurfy76 said:
If it's booting on official it maybe the rom your using.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
maybe.
I'm looking now for a pie rom for ARM - a only

Stuck in Download mode bootloop after updating from v20.x to v21.x

Phone Model no : Samsung Galaxy S6 / SM-G920F
Security patch date: 01.10.2017
Android version: 7.0
Root status: Yes
Hey guys,
I rooted my phone several weeks ago for the first time via odin and everything went fine. I installed TWRP and Magisk and everything worked out.
Today I was trying to update Magisk from v20.x to v21.x with the inapp option, but now im stuck in a bootloop to download mode, screen says "Downloading... do not turn off target".
Even if I turn the phone off with Power + Home + Vol Down its just restarting right away and getting stuck in the same screen again.
Im still able to enter TWRP Recovery, but I dont know what to do to end the download mode problem when trying to start the phone.
I actually dont know/understand much about that stuff, so I dont know which other info I need to provide.
Is there something I could do without going through the whole flash/root process again?
should i try to delete magisk and install it again? if yes, how do i do it?
Help would be appreciated.

n00btuber said:
Phone Model no : Samsung Galaxy S6 / SM-G920F
Security patch date: 01.10.2017
Android version: 7.0
Root status: Yes
Hey guys,
I rooted my phone several weeks ago for the first time via odin and everything went fine. I installed TWRP and Magisk and everything worked out.
Today I was trying to update Magisk from v20.x to v21.x with the inapp option, but now im stuck in a bootloop to download mode, screen says "Downloading... do not turn off target".
Even if I turn the phone off with Power + Home + Vol Down its just resarting right away and getting stuck in the same screen again.
Im still able to enter TWRP Recovery, but I dont know what to do to end the downloading problem when trying to start the phone.
I actually dont know/understand much about that stuff, so I dont know which other info I need to provide.
Is there something I could do without going through the whole flash/root process again?
should i try to delete magisk and install it again? if yes, how do i do it?
Help would be appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know much about your device but if you can enter TWRP, it's not that bad. First what you can try is to download Magisk uninstaller and flash it in TWRP from USB. However, I don't know what can you do to update Magisk safely. Would be best if you can check your device forum or ask the question there

Lord Sithek said:
I don't know much about your device but if you can enter TWRP, it's not that bad. First what you can try is to download Magisk uninstaller and flash it in TWRP from USB. However, I don't know what can you do to update Magisk safely. Would be best if you can check your device forum or ask the question there
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Looked like my device forum is pretty dead, which is why I asked the question here again. Thanks for the fast respone
Its probably not possible to just install a Magisk version again and overwrite the current one, probably need to uninstall first and then install it again?
There is a Magisk Module Uninstaller and a Magisk Uninstaller. Are those different things or just the same?
How to Uninstall Magisk Module Using TWRP Recovery | MagiskRoot
Uninstall Magisk Module using TWRP Recovery or Offline whenever you stuck into bootloop. Magisk Module Uninstaller and Magisk Manager for Recovery methods.
magiskroot.net
How to Uninstall Magisk From Android [2 Easiest Method]
Are you facing issues with Magisk? You can uninstall magisk from your phone with these simple and easy steps.
magiskmanager.com
Because the 2nd guide says in the end
Keep in Mind – Whenever you use TWRP as a method to uninstall Magisk, it is imperative to flash the Magisk Module Uninstaller Zip onto your device.
Does this mean I need to do the magisk module one first?

@n00btuber Do not trust those websites. They're in no way official and are just trying to get adc revenue from Magisk's popularity. If you're really unlucky they'll also provide you with malicious zips...
Only download stuff from John's GitHub:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk

If you need to uninstall Magisk use the uninstall zips from the above linked Github repo, and if you need to uninstall modules (but those will also be removed by the Magisk uninstaller) you can do that directly from TWRP:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_Uninstalldeletedisable_modules_from_recovery
A lot of times you can just flash another Magisk version over your installed one, but there are times where you do need to uninstall first. Since you have TWRP it can't really hurt to just try flashing whatever Magisk zip you want and it it doesn't work you can just use the uninstaller first.
One other thing to try would be the Canary release, mainly to see if you're affected by any bugs that is present in the current stable release but has been fixed upstream. You'll find the Canary app in the same Github link above.

Didgeridoohan said:
@n00btuber Do not trust those websites. They're in no way official and are just trying to get adc revenue from Magisk's popularity. If you're really unlucky they'll also provide you with malicious zips...
Only download stuff from John's GitHub:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok.
Was trying to use the uninstaller from his GitHub.
Trying to flash it leads to
"Updater process ended with ERROR:1
Error installing Zip file .....
Updating partition details"
So what to do now?
Trying to just flash any Magisk version to overwrite the current one leads to the same result.

I think it says Unsupported/Unknown image format

Your TWRP might be bugged/incompatible. I'd reflash your stock boot image and then patch the file manually (you'll find the instructions for that on GitHub as well).

Didgeridoohan said:
Your TWRP might be bugged/incompatible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But TWRP worked fine when installing magisk the first time, I even tried the same zip folder I used to install it back then, but it wont work anymore.
Didgeridoohan said:
I'd reflash your stock boot image and then patch the file manually (you'll find the instructions for that on GitHub as well).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
However, whats my stock boot image and how to reflash it? Cant find a guide for that on GitHub.
Would a Factory Reset wipe all Magisk stuff and my TWRP Partition as well?

Does anyone know what is going on between Magisk and Google? It seems Google has removed Magisk Manager from the Play Store AGAIN! What's more, I downloaded and installed the apk but when I try to use it to install the latest Magisk the install fails. Tried installing the Magisk zip via TWRP, and while it doesn't show any errors, I still don't have root.

Ok I really need some more help @Didgeridoohan
Meanwhile I tried to reinstall TWRP from within TWRP. There was no error so I think it should have worked, but didnt solve the problem.
As soon as I try to boot the system it directly boots download mode and gets stuck in it. The volume buttons wont work or do anything as they are supposed in download mode.
Im still able to get into TWRP, but I still dont know what to do to stop this crashed download mode that starts over and over again.
When trying to flash the magisk uninstall it states "cannot access /data", when trying to flash a magisk installer it states "unsupported/unknown image format"
I dont care about Magisk right now though, I can root and install magisk again as soon as im able to clear the download mode problem. I was just trying this because trying to update magisk from within magisk manager has caused this download mode problem to appear.
Just tell me please how to fix that or how to factory reset my phone so it is able to boot regular again.
Thank you

n00btuber said:
Ok I really need some more help @Didgeridoohan
Meanwhile I tried to reinstall TWRP from within TWRP. There was no error so I think it should have worked, but didnt solve the problem.
As soon as I try to boot the system it directly boots download mode and gets stuck in it. The volume buttons wont work or do anything as they are supposed in download mode.
Im still able to get into TWRP, but I still dont know what to do to stop this crashed download mode that starts over and over again.
When trying to flash the magisk uninstall it states "cannot access /data", when trying to flash a magisk installer it states "unsupported/unknown image format"
I dont care about Magisk right now though, I can root and install magisk again as soon as im able to clear the download mode problem. I was just trying this because trying to update magisk from within magisk manager has caused this download mode problem to appear.
Just tell me please how to fix that or how to factory reset my phone so it is able to boot regular again.
Thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sounds to me like you need to reflash your ROM, not TWRP. According to your OP, you're running Android 7, but it doesn't say if it is stock or a custom ROM.. If it is stock, then use Frija.exe to download the ROM and then flash th AP, BL and HOME_CSC md5 files with Odin. If it is a custom ROM, use TWRP to flash the ROM and gapps. DO NOT try to flash Magisk. Right now there seems to be a problem with Google disabling Magisk. Wait till it is resolved before attempting to get root.

@n00btuber Dirty flashing your ROM is most likely the way to go, just like described above.
But @lewmur, what do you mean by "Google disabling Magisk"? If you're talking about SafetyNet there are ways around that (and it doesn't affect root)...

Didgeridoohan said:
@n00btuber Dirty flashing your ROM is most likely the way to go, just like described above.
But @lewmur, what do you mean by "Google disabling Magisk"? If you're talking about SafetyNet there are ways around that (and it doesn't affect root)...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I not talking about safety net. Look in Play Store for Magisk Manager. It is no longer there. And even if you download and install the apk, it won't install Magisk. Flashing Magisk from TWRP doesn't give root privileges. This just happened yesterday.

lewmur said:
I not talking about safety net. Look in Play Store for Magisk Manager. It is no longer there. And even if you download and install the apk, it won't install Magisk. Flashing Magisk from TWRP doesn't give root privileges. This just happened yesterday.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Magisk Manager hasn't been on the Play Store for years... Edit: reference - https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-the-magic-mask-for-android.3473445/post-72508849
Nothing of what you describe has anything to do with Google "disabling Magisk".

Didgeridoohan said:
The Magisk Manager hasn't been on the Play Store for years... Edit: reference - https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-the-magic-mask-for-android.3473445/post-72508849
Nothing of what you describe has anything to do with Google "disabling Magisk".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That 's my mistake. Play Store would put up a lot of "Magisk Manager" stuff, but I never really tried any of it because flashing Magisk would give me the Manager. But even that "stuff" no longer shows up.
Butt Magisk Manager still won't install Magisk. It will download the zip file, but when it attemps to install it, it get an error saying Unsupported/Unknown image format. If I flash it from TWRP, and then open Magisk Manager, it still says N/A under Installed for Magisk.

lewmur said:
Then why won't Magisk Manager install Magisk. It will download the zip file, but when it attemps to install it, it get an error saying Unsupported/Unknown image format. If I flash it from TWRP, and then open Magisk Manager, it still says N/A under Installed for Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That will be an incompatibility between Magisk and your device and has nothing to do with Google (blame your OEM for doing weird stuff instead).

Thanks for the help guys, had to flash the ROM, now its working again.