Related
hey guys, so I want to encrypt my phone but I want to stay rooted with magisk and xposed. (Using SuperSU 2.78 SR3). Device: OnePlus One running SultanXDA's CM13.
Are there any special steps I need to take before I start the encryption process? do I need to completely unroot and remove all traces of all these before going back or will it just work?
I haven't seen this question addressed before and this would help others with the same questions.
Thanks for any advice!
Since there was no support from anyone, I decided to just remove everything (xposed, magisk and supersu) then encrypt, and finally re-add everything back. I did this just to avoid any complications and all works fine without issue.
@Nomelas what version of magisk did you use? and did you sideload them or just flash with the cache work around?
I've been at this all day with no luck
@GbizzleMcGrizzle what phone are you using? I had to completely remove everything before encrypting. Also reflashed stock system
@Nomelas Galaxy S7 (SM-G930F) it wont encrypt with magisk installed and magisk wont install after it has been encrypted.
@GbizzleMcGrizzle are you flashing through twrp? (are you decrypting when you boot into twrp)
i've tried flashing in twrp and sideloading. I don't think I can decrypt in twrp but magisk says it has a work around for not beiing able to boot /data and supposedly put in in cache and then moves it to data after boot so IDK
Any time I flash a new module in Magisk, when the phone reboots everything crashes (i.e. Google has stopped working, system UI has stopped working, clock has stopped working, etc etc)
Everything will crash and then my phone will constantly reboot. I don't know how I fixed it but I got Viper and YouTube Vanced to work, but anytime I try flashing a new module, it will break Viper and start crashing and restarting again until I hard reset or just wait it out.
Any suggestions? I know that I flashed whatever TWRP is in the 11g root tutorial but there was a new TWRP made for the LG G6. Maybe if I flashed that one or does that not have anything to do with this?
Any suggestions would be appreciated
Magisk is up to date.
roger.hernandez91 said:
Any time I flash a new module in Magisk, when the phone reboots everything crashes (i.e. Google has stopped working, system UI has stopped working, clock has stopped working, etc etc)
Everything will crash and then my phone will constantly reboot. I don't know how I fixed it but I got Viper and YouTube Vanced to work, but anytime I try flashing a new module, it will break Viper and start crashing and restarting again until I hard reset or just wait it out.
Any suggestions? I know that I flashed whatever TWRP is in the 11g root tutorial but there was a new TWRP made for the LG G6. Maybe if I flashed that one or does that not have anything to do with this?
Any suggestions would be appreciated
Magisk is up to date.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What modules are you using? I've had it happen quite a bit for me but I figured out what the issue was.
beany23 said:
What modules are you using? I've had it happen quite a bit for me but I figured out what the issue was.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It happens with any module, but I've successfully got several installed and working such as viper, Greenify, YouTube vanced, Emoji one, Google product sans font, and Magisk Google DNS
What was the issue and how'd you fix it?
roger.hernandez91 said:
It happens with any module, but I've successfully got several installed and working such as viper, Greenify, YouTube vanced, Emoji one, Google product sans font, and Magisk Google DNS
What was the issue and how'd you fix it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Easy. Uninstall magisk wipe cache 3 times then reboot recovery again then flash magisk 16.4 beta should fix your issue. Remember to download magisk 16.4 first then follow the above steps.
beany23 said:
Easy. Uninstall magisk wipe cache 3 times then reboot recovery again then flash magisk 16.4 beta should fix your issue. Remember to download magisk 16.4 first then follow the above steps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you say wipe cache 3 times, what do you mean by that? Go into recovery and wipe and keep rebooting three times?
Also, what method did you use to get into recovery each time and to flash Magisk?
roger.hernandez91 said:
When you say wipe cache 3 times, what do you mean by that? Go into recovery and wipe and keep rebooting three times?
Also, what method did you use to get into recovery each time and to flash Magisk?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, you just need to go into recovery and wipe cache 3 times back to back to back. You can use the file manager in TWRP to check the cache after wiping to see if its clear. If it is, reboot to recovery and flash Magisk. If you have anymore issues let me know.
Metabolic12 said:
No, you just need to go into recovery and wipe cache 3 times back to back to back. You can use the file manager in TWRP to check the cache after wiping to see if its clear. If it is, reboot to recovery and flash Magisk. If you have anymore issues let me know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes quick question, did you use Magisk uninstaller package from thread or just uninstall Magisk directly from the app?
Confused on how to uninstall Magisk without encrypting my device or loosing my boot or messing anything like that up
Also, wipe Dalvik cache and cache or just cache only?
Okay I guess I'm going to:
Boot into laf TWRP recovery
Flash Magisk uninstall zip
Wipe cache three times
Reboot into recovery
Flash Magisk v16.4 beta
Reboot system
Profit.... hopefully
Metabolic12 said:
No, you just need to go into recovery and wipe cache 3 times back to back to back. You can use the file manager in TWRP to check the cache after wiping to see if its clear. If it is, reboot to recovery and flash Magisk. If you have anymore issues let me know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Great well I can't uninstall Magisk from recovery
Still getting error that TWRP can't mount /system
Can anybody help?
roger.hernandez91 said:
Great well I can't uninstall Magisk from recovery
Still getting error that TWRP can't mount /system
Can anybody help?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure you can. Magisk doesn't root the system so all of the files you need to discard are in /data and /cache. You need a copy of the stock kernel in image format, if Magisk didn't make a back up. I gotta say bro, I haven't uninstalled Magisk or tried, so I don't know what's going to happen when you do this.
If your phone force encrypts after flashing the kernel, you may be screwed and have to format data and lose everything. This could possibly also brick your device beyond help. Since you can't mount your system in TWRP, if for some reason it fails encryption or DM-Verify into a bootloop, from the LAF or recocery modification, it won't boot. At least, not until you find a way to mount the system, which I think will be near impossible.
With that being said, if you decide to move forward you can either wipe data and cache or remove the files one by one. Your choice.
Well I gotta say, I've had a hell of a day fixing this thing. System partition got wiped somehow and had to fight to get my backup restored, thankfully I had one. Basically came back from the dead. Ended up wiping my entire internal storage to get TWRP to shut the hell up about decrypting, flashed new recovery again, flashed Magisk v16.4 beta, and now I'm good to go. Didn't have any of the issues mentioned above. And now I'm not having /system mounting problems or the force quits upon flashing a new mod. Everything seems good.
Appreciate y'all. You guys are awesome for taking the time to help.
roger.hernandez91 said:
Okay I guess I'm going to:
Boot into laf TWRP recovery
Flash Magisk uninstall zip
Wipe cache three times
Reboot into recovery
Flash Magisk v16.4 beta
Reboot system
Profit.... hopefully
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't do it from laf twrp flash the latest h872 recovery and do the steps u posted
beany23 said:
Don't do it from laf twrp flash the latest h872 recovery and do the steps u posted
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah man I actually did have to do it from laf recovery because it wasn't working from regular recovery. Had to flash it from both and also formatted data and I was good to go. I got it all figured out.
Backup your stock recovery per this post. If you are too lazy, I can upload my backup from .104 build (C432) to Mega.
Download twrp_bkl_0.7.img from this post and place it in same directory with your ADB.
After successful backup as precaution disable any locks like pattern/PIN/password/fingerprint, reboot to bootloader (fastboot):
Code:
adb reboot bootloader
Then flash new TWRP recovery:
Code:
fastboot flash recovery_ramdisk twrp_bkl_0.7.img
After successful flash reboot device and immediately after confirming command below unplug USB cable and HOLD and keep holding VOLUME UP button, if you won't the new recovery will be overwritten by stock and you can try again.
Code:
fastboot reboot
Tested by myself on Honor 10 8.1.0.104 (C432) with unlocked bootloader and installed already Magisk 16.4 with Magisk manager 5.7.0, Magisk ramdisk persisted after installing TWRP recovery, system boots normal.
Next step after unlocking BL, installing Magisk, installing TWRP recovery -> flashing GSI AOSP, LOS or RR. Only reason I bothered with installing TWRP was that GSI image of LOS and RR don't include opengapps, only AOSP does, so without TWRP you can't have opengapps with these two GSI ROMS.
PeterMarkoff said:
Backup your stock recovery per this post. If you are too lazy, I can upload my backup from .104 build (C432) to Mega.
Download twrp_bkl_0.7.img from this post and place it in same directory with your ADB.
After successful backup as precaution disable any locks like pattern/PIN/password/fingerprint, reboot to bootloader (fastboot):
Code:
adb reboot bootloader
Then flash new TWRP recovery:
Code:
fastboot flash recovery_ramdisk twrp_bkl_0.7.img
After successful flash reboot device and immediately after confirming command below unplug USB cable and HOLD and keep holding VOLUME UP button, if you won't the new recovery will be overwritten by stock and you can try again.
Code:
fastboot reboot
Tested by myself on Honor 10 8.1.0.104 (C432) with unlocked bootloader and installed already Magisk 16.4 with Magisk manager 5.7.0, Magisk ramdisk persisted after installing TWRP recovery, system boots normal.
Next step after unlocking BL, installing Magisk, installing TWRP recovery -> flashing GSI AOSP, LOS or RR. Only reason I bothered with installing TWRP was that GSI image of LOS and RR don't include opengapps, only AOSP does, so without TWRP you can't have opengapps with these two GSI ROMS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice work. ?
tried to install GSI RR OS, but ending in bootloop, also even after resizing system partition to maximum (TWRP / wipe / resize) opengapps still showing error 70 about insufficient space (which makes no sense, so they really seem to have wrong detection of A/B instead of A for Huawei/Honor devices), though these gzr gapps seem to install successfuly, now if I could figure out the damn bootloop
potential reasons for bootloop - previously installed magisk, wiped also system not only data/cache, installed through fastboot while TWRP there and not only stock recovery, ???
edit: i guess will try flash GSI through TWRP again, quite a waste time to wait each time like 9-10 minutes to find out it can't boot
edit 2: so even flashing through TWRP doesn't help, just stuck on android animation for 10 minutes and then it restarts (and even if you do fatory reset through huawei erecovery it doesnt change anything). maybe can try to restore everything and not wipe system before installing, just factory reset through TWRP (though I remember I read somewhere it's not reliable and it is better to do it through system, but I think that one wipe also internal storage which I wanna avoid)? back to rooted EMUI with TWRP for now, don't have time to try various combinations
edit 3: flashing over TWRP backup without wiping system doesn't help, so it seem it's gonna be magisk or replaced stock recovery i guess, otherwise no idea
BTW the lack of feedback here and trying from other users it's very depressing. they boasted million phone sales and i am the only one in the whole world trying to install TWRP and GSI ROM on this phone?
PeterMarkoff said:
BTW the lack of feedback here and trying from other users it's very depressing. they boasted million phone sales and i am the only one in the whole world trying to install TWRP and GSI ROM on this phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't be disappointed the lack of feedback from users is not many power users have got their hands on this model.
And also we are having different builds.
From the day one I am trying to rebrand my device but no success .
Once I have rebranded to EU I will try and let you know.
Did you flash open gapps nano package through twrp in gsi image?
Did it give you the same error?
tried just pico opengapps as on all phones i flash, that's the smallest, but always end up with error 70 not enough space despite resized system partition in TWRP and many GB available, the other unofficial GZR zero gapps build i mentioned seem to be flashed successful in TWRP, but in any case no luck with booting
PeterMarkoff said:
tried just pico opengapps as on all phones i flash, that's the smallest, but always end up with error 70 not enough space despite resized system partition in TWRP and many GB available, the other unofficial GZR zero gapps build i mentioned seem to be flashed successful in TWRP, but in any case no luck with booting
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you format your phone before trying GSI ?
Try formatting phone and remove some system apps and then flash gapps it will mostly solve the problem.
PeterMarkoff said:
BTW the lack of feedback here and trying from other users it's very depressing. they boasted million phone sales and i am the only one in the whole world trying to install TWRP and GSI ROM on this phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't be upset – e.g. I didn't receive my Honor 10 yet. You won't be the only one for sure, you're just the first one to do it, which is super nice for others because it motivates them to do so as well!
Just wondering: does it make a difference for TWRP wether I own the 6gb or 4gb version?
miststudent2011 said:
Did you format your phone before trying GSI ?
Try formatting phone and remove some system apps and then flash gapps it will mostly solve the problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did factory reset (data, both cache) and also wiped system partition, gapps would be the least issue, as I said that GZR should work, but my system doesn't boot, no matter how times I wipe everything through TWRP or stock recovery after flashing system.img, since they say it's normal to hang at first boot and then wipe and then it should boot, but it doesn't work for me. also of course tried to power off phone since some people said it helps to do it after flashing. what I haven't done it's fastboot -w which should be some better wipe. some people say also you should remove magisk ramdisk, though I forgot to back up original, backed up just stock recovery. and also I haven't tried to flash everything with stock recovery, though first flash I did was through fastboot anyway and not through TWRP and it didn't make difference
so last few things left to try:
- fastboot -w for total wipe of data (better than TWRP? though it should be same as Format data in TWRP which wipe everything including internal storage which I wanna avoid since backing up 15GB TWRP backup file it's kinda annoying and my system has problem to do it)
- flash with stock recovery (I have backup, no big deal)
- remove magisk ramdisk and flash with stock ramdisk (forgot to make backup, can't replace)
though I am tired of it for now, spend last night like 4 hours dealing with it until 2AM and I also need to take care of children
vollkornbaguette said:
Don't be upset – e.g. I didn't receive my Honor 10 yet. You won't be the only one for sure, you're just the first one to do it, which is super nice for others because it motivates them to do so as well!
Just wondering: does it make a difference for TWRP wether I own the 6gb or 4gb version?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think RAM has something to do with anything, but that sounds like Chinese version since EU has always 4GB and only difference is storage, so you will have different ROM
PeterMarkoff said:
(...)
so last few things left to try:
- fastboot -w for total wipe of data (better than TWRP?)
- flash with stock recovery (I have backup, no big deal)
- remove magisk ramdisk and flash with stock ramdisk (forgot to make backup, can't replace)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So I just read more about the GSI/Treble stuff and it said somewhere that modifications like Magisk probably lead to problems with the GSI flash.
Which is why I would try to get rid of the magisk ramdisk first.
I'm not an expert in this at all but maybe this helps.
---
PeterMarkoff said:
I don't think RAM has something to do with anything, but that sounds like Chinese version since EU has always 4GB and only difference is storage, so you will have different ROM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indeed I bought the chinese 6gb RAM Version (hope this won't turn out as a big mistake)
vollkornbaguette said:
So I just read more about the GSI/Treble stuff and it said somewhere that modifications like Magisk probably lead to problems with the GSI flash.
"Your device is free of any heavy modifications such as the
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah, now if someone could extract for me from 0.104 firmware for C432 that stock ramdisk, because I have some problems with mega to download it and I just need the stock ramdisk, nothing else, I have stock recovery backup but forgot to make ramdisk backup
edit: completely forgot there is option to "Completely uninstall" in Magisk manager, so tried it though even after restart with magisk manager missing i could still use root apps, so not sure how exactly this "complete uninstall" works, but anyway giving it a try after this and wiping data, installed system.img again, again wiped, rebooted and as usual loading and loading and nothing, seem can't further continue without copy of stock ramdisk to flash, tried downloading the big update from mega to extract it but it always fail for me to download, same with trying to copy my TWRP backup because for sure ain't gonna doi fastboot -w and setting up everything from scratch in case even this doesn't help, if I knew it works for sure and it will load new system which I will have to set up then no problem, but in this case...
edit 2: tried to replace magisk ramdisk with ramdisk from Honor View 10 BKL09 (same as our working TWRP) but it seem I end up after flashing it, wiping and flashing system.img in TWRP/erecovery bootloop, it's not showing android booting logo like before (but hey at least no need to wait 10 minutes to find it's fail) and either go to huawei ercovery, if I perform factory reset there then it boots to TWRP, but can't boot anywhere else besides these two
pass
I requested this image. Recovery has been established. When I enter the recovery, it requires a password to decrypt the system partition, I enter it (the same after switching on the phone), but a message is displayed that the password is incorrect. help me please.
told you in OP disable all passwords before flashing
PeterMarkoff said:
yeah, now if someone could extract for me from 0.104 firmware for C432 that stock ramdisk, because I have some problems with mega to download it and I just need the stock ramdisk, nothing else, I have stock recovery backup but forgot to make ramdisk backup
edit: completely forgot there is option to "Completely uninstall" in Magisk manager, so tried it though even after restart with magisk manager missing i could still use root apps, so not sure how exactly this "complete uninstall" works, but anyway giving it a try after this and wiping data, installed system.img again, again wiped, rebooted and as usual loading and loading and nothing, seem can't further continue without copy of stock ramdisk to flash, tried downloading the big update from mega to extract it but it always fail for me to download, same with trying to copy my TWRP backup because for sure ain't gonna doi fastboot -w and setting up everything from scratch in case even this doesn't help, if I knew it works for sure and it will load new system which I will have to set up then no problem, but in this case...
edit 2: tried to replace magisk ramdisk with ramdisk from Honor View 10 BKL09 (same as our working TWRP) but it seem I end up after flashing it, wiping and flashing system.img in TWRP/erecovery bootloop, it's not showing android booting logo like before (but hey at least no need to wait 10 minutes to find it's fail) and either go to huawei ercovery, if I perform factory reset there then it boots to TWRP, but can't boot anywhere else besides these two
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want, i have all the files of the C432 update but idk in wich .zip, folder the ramdisk is stored.
I can send on several clouds.
PeterMarkoff said:
told you in OP disable all passwords before flashing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey did you restore your device are you still struck at boot screen?
If yes try this method.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/huawei-p20/development/rebrand-huawei-p20-eml-l29-eml-l09-t3779283
How to GO back to stock emui(India) after i flash a treble rom? Do i need to backup using some tool?
PLease someone tell me
srharshajava said:
PLease someone tell me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The problem is currently we don't have full
ROM to revert to stock and if we brick our device there is no proper way to revert to stock.
Our model even doesn't have SD card support.
Just wait for some time for someone to provide proper way.
When i flash a treble rom, I have a bootloop. I returned back with eRecovery directly on the phone.
miststudent2011 said:
The problem is currently we don't have full
ROM to revert to stock and if we brick our device there is no proper way to revert to stock.
Our model even doesn't have SD card support.
Just wait for some time for someone to provide proper way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We do have a way to download full ROM.
http://pro-teammt.ru/firmware-database/?firmware_model=COL-L29C432
1. Search here for your exact model (change numbers after C432 to find ROM for your phone) and search for your rom version (B104 or B120)
2. Double click on "filelist" on the same row as FullOTA-MF
3. From filelist link menu download update.zip file (it should be really big, like 2+GB)
3. Extract UPDATE.APP file somewhere (eg. Desktop)
4. In settings of HuaweiUpdateExtractor (link: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2433454) uncheck "verify header checksum" and open UPDATE.APP
5. Extract any img (Be it ramdisk.img, ramdisk_recovery.img or system.img) file that you need from UPDATE.APP via HuaweiUpdateExtractor
You just got whoole stock rom and img files that you can flash. Tested by myself with flashing back original ramdisk, ramdisk_recovery and system.img and everything worked well.
Scroll down over this post to see anwer!
Hey there! I just got my Xiaomi Mi8 from HK Goldway at Aliexpress. It came with its bootloader already unlocked and a Global ROM flashed.
I wanted to install Magisk but failed horribly . I've already done that to several phones (my last one was a Moto X Play, and it worked without major complications). But with this one, it seems I can't get past the bootlogo.
Stock Fastboot image used:
dipper_global_images_V9.5.13.0.OEAMIFA_20180714.0000.00_8.1_global
This is what I've tried so far:
First try
Flashed TWRP for Mi8 version 0711.
Flashed Magisk.
Got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Second try
Booted (not flashed) TWRP.
Tried to install latest global weekly from this thread.
Also got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Third try
I thought that those flashable ZIP firmwares were too small for them to be a full-fledged OS. So I went and downloaded this other one. Global version.
I read somewhere that I needed to format data before flashing a new image, so I did.
Booted TWRP.
Formated data (not Wipe)
Installed that ZIP from TWRP and booted correctly.
Booted TWRP again and flashed Magisk.
Got bootloop.
Back to stock image via fastboot.
Last try
Booted TWRP.
Formatted data.
Installed MIUI via TWRP.
Without rebooting, flashed Magisk and no-verity-opt-encrypt-6.0.zip.
This got past bootlogo ("Unlocked" message changed to "powered by Android") but got stuck there. Not booting at all.
Right now I'm back to the last try, booting MIUI successfully but without Magisk nor no-verity-opt-encrypt.
I kinda have no more ideas left. I understand this is a new device but I can't understand why people claim the have been able to install Magisk and I can't! Other thoughts were, maybe they were running MIUI 10 Beta and it only works with that version? I'm unsure about that.
Can someone lend me a hand? What am I missing?
Thank you!!
EDIT: FIX!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7.
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata.
Rebooted.
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Hope this works out for everyone having this problem!
have you tried to use Magisk 16.4,
if not, try to follow this guide:
https://www.theandroidsoul.com/xiaomi-mi-8-root/
gulp79 said:
have you tried to use Magisk 16.4,
if not, try to follow this guide:
https://www.theandroidsoul.com/xiaomi-mi-8-root/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the fast reply!
I followed that guide and tried these steps:
fastboot boot mi8-twrp-3.2.2.img
Unencrypted via Pattern
Flashed Magisk v16.4 + DM verity disabler file
Reboot
But I'm still stuck at "powered by Android" bootlogo.
Normally it boots within 5 seconds but now it's taking forever. I'll wait a few minutes to see what happens.
I'm attaching some screenshots of the install process.
Padlite said:
Thank you for the fast reply!
I followed that guide and tried these steps:
fastboot boot mi8-twrp-3.2.2.img
Unencrypted via Pattern
Flashed Magisk v16.4 + DM verity disabler file
Reboot
But I'm still stuck at "powered by Android" bootlogo.
Normally it boots within 5 seconds but now it's taking forever. I'll wait a few minutes to see what happens.
I'm attaching some screenshots of the install process.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok,
but if you install Magisk 16.4, don't install also DM verity disabler.
DM verity disabler is needed if you don't want to root (see poin 14 in the linked guide).
Hope it works...
gulp79 said:
Ok,
but if you install Magisk 16.4, don't install also DM verity disabler.
DM verity disabler is needed if you don't want to root (see poin 14 in the linked guide).
Hope it works...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If I only flash Magisk 16.4, then phone shows "Powered by Android" and instantly reboots into stock recovery.
Only way to get it back booting, is performing fastboot flash boot boot.img from stock dipper_global_images_V9.5.13.0.OEAMIFA_20180714.0000.00_8.1_global image
I read somewhere about official and unofficial bootloader unlock. I didn't unlock the bootloader myself. Maybe it has something to do with it?
PS: Anyone had any luck using Magisk with MIUI 9.5.13?
Did you try with a newer magisk version ? ... 16.7 was released 15 day ago
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-v16.7.zip
It´s a good practice to use magisk_uninstaller before flash new one if you had problems.
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-uninstaller-20180719.zip
Please tell us if it´s works
Seems that also others users have this problem
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77234924&postcount=6312
punk84z said:
Did you try with a newer magisk version ? ... 16.7 was released 15 day ago
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-v16.7.zip
It´s a good practice to use magisk_uninstaller before flash new one if you had problems.
Direct link: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v16.7/Magisk-uninstaller-20180719.zip
Please tell us if it´s works
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just tried that. Uninstalling and re-installing v16.7. Although it seems now it's doing a few more steps, I'm still getting the recovery bootloop.
Install log screenshot attached.
gulp79 said:
Seems that also others users have this problem
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77234924&postcount=6312
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly that. Maybe we'll need to wait for a supported Magisk version. I'm still wondering what's the difference between our Mi8's that some can get Magisk working and some not. ?
I am running Magisk stable and tmiui 10 from Xiaomi. Eu without any problems.
I have a Mi 8 se and i install the eu rom boot the phone , reboot to twrp wipe and factory reset and installed magisk 16.4 .this is how works for me
i have the same problem too..when using china stable rom 16.7 magisk can be installed successfully tried many times...
flashing global version seems to have this issue...
tried all this steps too but no luck in global rom...
Padlite said:
Hey there! I just got my Xiaomi Mi8 from HK Goldway at Aliexpress. It came with its bootloader already unlocked and a Global ROM flashed.
I wanted to install Magisk but failed horribly . I've already done that to several phones (my last one was a Moto X Play, and it worked without major complications). But with this one, it seems I can't get past the bootlogo.
Stock Fastboot image used:
dipper_global_images_V9.5.13.0.OEAMIFA_20180714.0000.00_8.1_global
This is what I've tried so far:
First try
Flashed TWRP for Mi8 version 0711.
Flashed Magisk.
Got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Second try
Booted (not flashed) TWRP.
Tried to install latest global weekly from this thread.
Also got a bootloop.
Reflashed stock image via Fastboot.
Third try
I thought that those flashable ZIP firmwares were too small for them to be a full-fledged OS. So I went and downloaded this other one. Global version.
I read somewhere that I needed to format data before flashing a new image, so I did.
Booted TWRP.
Formated data (not Wipe)
Installed that ZIP from TWRP and booted correctly.
Booted TWRP again and flashed Magisk.
Got bootloop.
Back to stock image via fastboot.
Last try
Booted TWRP.
Formatted data.
Installed MIUI via TWRP.
Without rebooting, flashed Magisk and no-verity-opt-encrypt-6.0.zip.
This got past bootlogo ("Unlocked" message changed to "powered by Android") but got stuck there. Not booting at all.
Right now I'm back to the last try, booting MIUI successfully but without Magisk nor no-verity-opt-encrypt.
I kinda have no more ideas left. I understand this is a new device but I can't understand why people claim the have been able to install Magisk and I can't! Other thoughts were, maybe they were running MIUI 10 Beta and it only works with that version? I'm unsure about that.
Can someone lend me a hand? What am I missing?
Thank you!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i allso hade that problem
wen i got my phone it was with global rom
then i flashed twrp
didt like they said
wipe dalvik cache an cache an factory reset
flashed miui eu rom
then flashed twrp again rebooted into recovery
flashed magisk 16.4
ended up in staying on android logo
then i try format data an didt it all again
still android logo an nothing more
well then i didt what i allways didt on my other devices
i wiped dalvik cache
cache
data
system
then i flashed eu rom
an twrp again rebooted into recovery again
then flashed magisk 16.4
rebooted system an now it booted up
REMEMBER to manke a backup before flashing all off thise things otherwice u wont have the option to go back if something goes wrong
-fluffy- said:
i allso hade that problem
wen i got my phone it was with global rom
then i flashed twrp
didt like they said
wipe dalvik cache an cache an factory reset
flashed miui eu rom
then flashed twrp again rebooted into recovery
flashed magisk 16.4
ended up in staying on android logo
then i try format data an didt it all again
still android logo an nothing more
well then i didt what i allways didt on my other devices
i wiped dalvik cache
cache
data
system
then i flashed eu rom
an twrp again rebooted into recovery again
then flashed magisk 16.4
rebooted system an now it booted up
REMEMBER to manke a backup before flashing all off thise things otherwice u wont have the option to go back if something goes wrong
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well maybe the critical step is to wipe everything, including System.
Did you Format anything instead of Wipe this last try?
Also, could you please share a link from that working MIUI rom?
Thank you!
Sorry for double-posting, but I wanted to notify you I GOT IT!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata
Rebooted
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Here are some screenshots!
Padlite said:
Sorry for double-posting, but I wanted to notify you I GOT IT!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata
Rebooted
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Here are some screenshots!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is Google Assistant ("OK Google") working for you now as well?
I just flashed magisk v16.0 over the Miui 8.7.26 build and it booted without issues.
japancakes said:
Is Google Assistant ("OK Google") working for you now as well?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just checked and no. If I go to Google Settings -> Voice, Voice Match is disabled because "This feature is currently unavailable for this language". Even though it's set to English UK. Maybe there is some Magisk Module to enable it?
Thanks, followed these steps and it got magisk going on the recent global release. Only difference was i had to use fastboot erase userdata.
Padlite said:
Scroll down over this post to see anwer!
EDIT: FIX!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7.
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata.
Rebooted.
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Hope this works out for everyone having this problem!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey guys im a toal newbie to this whole flash theme but Ive purchased a mi8 and i would like to use GooglePay and so on, could someone give me a step by step tutorial , how to install all this stuff on my device ?
Padlite said:
Sorry for double-posting, but I wanted to notify you I GOT IT!
Over here, user @richardyusan helped me out with an extra step.
What I did:
Installed Magisk V16.7
Installed DM-VERITY AND FORCED ENCRYPTION DISABLER.
Performed fastboot format userdata
Rebooted
And I got my phone booting with Magisk Installed!
Even though I couldn't install any module, (every install claimed I needed Magisk v15+). I read some threads and with a Magisk Direct re-install (from its app) I got Magisk downgraded to v16 and everything worked perfectly!
Here are some screenshots!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well i didt not flash dm-verity an mine pass saftynet
Device variant: XT19121-2 James
Chipset: MSM8920
After repeated failed flashes I am on stock firmware using this guide. Phone boots and works normally right now, but I can't seem to flash any Custom ROMs on to my phone. I was using this post to flash Lineage OS 15.1, which worked successfully at first, but the WiFi wasn't working so I reflashed it. It still didn't work so I did it again, wiping Dalvik/Cache too. After the second flash attempt, my phone began to only flicker on and off. I made sure to always clean flash, factory resetting, wiping Cache and Dalvik, even formatting data, but no matter what I do it doesn't work. Also attempted other GSI images (arm, A-only) like AOSP, ResurrectionRemix and phhusson's Lineage OS 15.1 But they all failed too. I am using TWRP for James v 3.3.1 although I did also try other TWRP images like v 3.2.1 . But it makes no difference. Also used Magisk v19 like some guides suggested but whether I have Magisk or not, it doesn't work. Even made sure to push the fstab.qcom file to /vendor. Anytime a Custom ROM is flashed whether zip or GSI img it goes past the initial "bad key" or "N/A" screen and starts flickering on and off. Bootloader and TWRP works fine, but that's about it. Everytime a flash fails I go back to stock firmware (which always works) and try another ROM. I wonder why the first attempt worked but doesn't anymore even if I mirror the exact steps I took from stock. If anyone has any solutions I would be really grateful. Let me know if you need any more information.
have you taken any recent OTA updates?
mikeshutte said:
have you taken any recent OTA updates?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope. Still on the 8.0.0 version the stock firmware comes in.
tkhan7916 said:
Nope. Still on the 8.0.0 version the stock firmware comes in.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay give this a try, I'm assuming you have old root access and TWRP installed.
Download any Android 9 GSI of your liking, boot to TWRP.
Do a complete nandroid backup of the stock firmware.
Do a factory reset then wipe system partition.
Next flash your GSI that you downloaded to your system partition.
After flashing is complete of the GSI reboot to recovery.
After reboot completed flash your open Gapps zip. Then reflash Magisk.
if you get a error message when flashing g apps then you will need to use magic g apps with magisk as it will install them systemless. I have to do this on my device because the partition doesn't have enough space.
Give that a try and let me know how it goes if you have any questions feel free to ask.
---------- Post added at 10:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:59 PM ----------
tkhan7916 said:
Nope. Still on the 8.0.0 version the stock firmware comes in.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
mikeshutte said:
Okay give this a try, I'm assuming you have old root access and TWRP installed.
Download any Android 9 GSI of your liking, boot to TWRP.
Do a complete nandroid backup of the stock firmware.
Do a factory reset then wipe system partition.
Next flash your GSI that you downloaded to your system partition.
After flashing is complete of the GSI reboot to recovery.
After reboot completed flash your open Gapps zip. Then reflash Magisk.
if you get a error message when flashing g apps then you will need to use magic g apps with magisk as it will install them systemless. I have to do this on my device because the partition doesn't have enough space.
Give that a try and let me know how it goes if you have any questions feel free to ask.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also just noticed you are using the latest version of TWRP 3.3.1. I'm not sure if you originally rooted and installed TWRP with the original patched version by Cody or not, but if so make sure with the new version that you format your data partition to f2fs. As this will ensure correct mounting of the data partition.
mikeshutte said:
Okay give this a try, I'm assuming you have old root access and TWRP installed.
Download any Android 9 GSI of your liking, boot to TWRP.
Do a complete nandroid backup of the stock firmware.
Do a factory reset then wipe system partition.
Next flash your GSI that you downloaded to your system partition.
After flashing is complete of the GSI reboot to recovery.
After reboot completed flash your open Gapps zip. Then reflash Magisk.
if you get a error message when flashing g apps then you will need to use magic g apps with magisk as it will install them systemless. I have to do this on my device because the partition doesn't have enough space.
Give that a try and let me know how it goes if you have any questions feel free to ask.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Followed these steps exactly, including formatting the data partition to f2fs, and the same problem still persists. Screen just keeps turning on and off in a loop without booting into the ROM. I downloaded the Lineage OS 16.0 GSI A-only Arm version for reference.
I am having the same issue
Using XT1921-1
Latest TWRP
Have tried LOS 15, LOS 16, AOSP 8.1, AOSP 9.0
Have tried flashing in fastboot and TWRP
Have tried every combo of wipe/factory reset/format data and magisk flash possible
have tried stock recovery, have tried no verity, have tried stock boot.img
nothing works. only able to produce powered on (black and blank) screen that turns on and off for a minute before returning to bootloader
PLEASE HELP
think i might need a 8.0 GSI but cant find one anywhere
I eventually got RR to boot on the james xt-1921-3 I installed XT1921-3_JAMES_T_MPCS_8.0.0_OCPS27.91-150-5-1-3_cid21 as a base, then used boot and vendor partitions from JAMES_T_OCP27.91-51-4_cid21_subsidy-TMO_RSU_regulatory-DEFAULT_CFC and it finally worked.
tkhan7916 said:
Followed these steps exactly, including formatting the data partition to f2fs, and the same problem still persists. Screen just keeps turning on and off in a loop without booting into the ROM. I downloaded the Lineage OS 16.0 GSI A-only Arm version for reference.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Message me, I'll host a TWRP backup for the XT-1921-3 that boots RR 6.1
Download the file from this post https://forum.xda-developers.com/android/software/universal-dm-verity-forceencrypt-t3817389 , then using fastboot, flash the vendor and boot img
fastboot flash vendor vendor.img
fastboot flash boot boot.img
then boot into recovery and flash the file from that post to disable dm-verity and force encrytion, after that flash magisk, then reboot to bootloader, at command prompt-
fastboot erase userdata
fastboot erase cache
fastboot reboot
that should get you booted - profit
mrbox23 said:
Message me, I'll host a TWRP backup for the XT-1921-3 that boots RR 6.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you still have that back up by any chance and could ypu send it to me?