Database Develop

Magic v11 installation question

Hi, do i need install systemless SuperSU always in twrp before install magisk v11 if I want use new MagiskSU instead??
If I try install Magisk v11 with superSU uninstalled and phone unrooted TWRP give me error and installation fails and if I install superSU and after Magisk v11, Magisk manager say system is using SuperSU instead MagiskSU. How do I install Magisk with MagiskSU??
I have Samsung Galaxy S4 with optimized LineageOS 14.1

Read the pinned Magisk thread...
Unroot again using unSu by osm0sis (Google) before flashing magisk

Installation Instructions
If you're already rooted with MagiskSU, Magisk phh's superuser (not original), or Official Systemless SuperSU
Install/upgrade Magisk Manager from Play Store
Install/upgrade Magisk as prompted in the application
Reboot and you're done!!
If you're not rooted, or something went wrong and you need a clean start
(Recommended) Restore your boot image back to stock
Download the latest Magisk zip file
If you choose to use SuperSU (only support Android 6.0+), first flash SuperSU in systemless mode
Flash Magisk zip
Reboot, and update the stub Magisk Manager to the latest from Play Store
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I read 200 times but when I install Magisk without SuperSU (because I want MagiskSU) TWRP give me an error and install fail... read my initial post first please....
Error:
Code:
! SU image mount failed...
! Please immediately flash SuperSU now
! Installation will complete after flashing SuperSU
[B]Updater process ended with ERROR: 1
Error installing zip file 'sdcard/Download/Magisk v11.1/Magisk-v11.1.zip[/B]

dhaern said:
I read 200 times but when I install Magisk without SuperSU (because I want MagiskSU) TWRP give me an error and install fail... read my initial post first please....
Error:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You need to FULLY unflash superSU using the zip that the other person told you to google.

PartyPlease said:
You need to FULLY unflash superSU using the zip that the other person told you to google.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok I will try unflash with the zip, I was using unroot inside superSU menu but installation instructions dont say nothing about the unflash with an extrenal script

dhaern said:
Ok I will try unflash with the zip, I was using unroot inside superSU menu.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah that button doesn't work for systemless superSU. It doesn't roll back your boot.IMG like it should.
Worst case scenario, flash the stock boot.img and then flash magisk.

Thanks guys, I installed Magisk v11.1 with MagiskSU working, Magisk Hide enabled but I have CTS mismatch error now in Safetynet test. I guess I cant do nothing about this error. Optimized LineageOS 14.1 and Samsung Galaxy S4
EDIT: Finally I passed the Safetynet test (no CTS mismatch error) disabling ADB interface in developer options. Thanks for Magisk, amazing.

PartyPlease said:
Yeah that button doesn't work for systemless superSU. It doesn't roll back your boot.IMG like it should.
Worst case scenario, flash the stock boot.img and then flash magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ahh, this would explain why my boot.img was not the same after "unrooting"! thanks for clearing this up for me...

dhaern said:
Thanks guys, I installed Magisk v11.1 with MagiskSU working, Magisk Hide enabled but I have CTS mismatch error now in Safetynet test. I guess I cant do nothing about this error. Optimized LineageOS 14.1 and Samsung Galaxy S4
EDIT: Finally I passed the Safetynet test (no CTS mismatch error) disabling ADB interface in developer options. Thanks for Magisk, amazing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
By disabling ADB interface, do you mean the USB debugging part? for some reason I am still getting Safetynet error.

vicky_ag said:
By disabling ADB interface, do you mean the USB debugging part? for some reason I am still getting Safetynet error.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I said USB debugging option, when I disabled this I passed Safetynet test.

dhaern said:
Yeah I said USB debugging option, when I disabled this I passed Safetynet test.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks but doesn't seem to work for me.

dhaern said:
Yeah I said USB debugging option, when I disabled this I passed Safetynet test.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this hint; got my build "passed" now appreciate it

What settings are you guys using in Magisk? I have disabled BusyBox, enabled Magisk Hide and systemless hosts. Superuser options are Access to "Apps and ADB" and Automatic Response set to prompt

I'm still having an issue installing Magisk on my phone with RAMROM V10. It gives me an ERROR 1.
It has been suggested that I should re-flash my boot.img with TWRP following the instruction:
Place your BOOT.img on your sdcard
Reboot into TWRP recovery
Tap "Install"
In the bottom right corner tap "Install Image"
Select your BOOT.img
Select the Boot Partition, then swipe to confirm Flash
However, when I follow the step, my TWRP cannot seem to find BOOT.IMG in my SD Card (I know it is there). What did I do wrong? Can anyone help?

i think the .img thingy is only for twrp.img files. You have to use another method to place your boot image like. -> make a backup of only your boot image via twrp backup function. Then duplicate that backup folder of twrp containing only the newly just regernated files, in the twrp folder. Then replace the su-modified boot file there with your original boot file, you obviously have to rename your boot image to fit the right name. (eg. with the logo image -> logo.bin changes to logo.emmc.win -> etc;.) Then use the twrp restore function to restore your "original" boot logo.
Hierarchy folder view would be like:
TWRP->folder 1 (original folder, in case something goes wrong)-> boot file and others
->folder 2 (our modified folder)-> files

sm00th4f3 said:
i think the .img thingy is only for twrp.img files. You have to use another method to place your boot image like. -> make a backup of only your boot image via twrp backup function. Then duplicate that backup folder of twrp containing only the newly just regernated files, in the twrp folder. Then replace the su-modified boot file there with your original boot file, you obviously have to rename your boot image to fit the right name. (eg. with the logo image -> logo.bin changes to logo.emmc.win -> etc;.) Then use the twrp restore function to restore your "original" boot logo.
Hierarchy folder view would be like:
TWRP->folder 1 (original folder, in case something goes wrong)-> boot file and others
->folder 2 (our modified folder)-> files
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FIY: Flashing regular boot.img files works just fine with "Install Image" in TWRP (of course, YMMV, depending on your device).

Cannot install Magisk on Lineage 14.1 (August 3 2018 release) on hltemo

I tried to install version 16 using 2 different ways. In both cases installation went well but Magisk Manager shows "Magisk is not installed".
Method 1: I downloaded Magisk 16 and put it on internal storage. Started TWRP recovery and installed the ZIP file. All went well without any error. Restarted. Magisk Manager shows "Magisk is not installed".
Method 2: I extracted boot.img from Lineage OS zip file. Using Magisk Manager I patched the file. Started TWRP recovery and copied the patched boot.img into boot. All went well. Restarted. Magisk Manager shows "Magisk is not installed".
Any ideas?
Update: same issues with version 17.1 as well
UPDATE: Uninstalled version 17.1, repatched boot image and replaced boot image. It worked.... :good:

Where do I get boot.img? How do I patch? Please help I have Lineage OS on my LG G3 @SkylarkC
Thanks

x.shayan.x said:
Where do I get boot.img? How do I patch? Please help I have Lineage OS on my LG G3 @SkylarkC
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_Wheres_my_boot_image_for_the_Manager_to_patch

Magisk v17 Failed to Install

I attempted to go from Magisk v16 to Magisk v17 from the app, Install > Patch Boot Image File > Magisk-v17(1700).zip and I get the below .
I opened up Root Checker and it let me know that the device no longer has Root.
- Copying image to cache
- Device platform: arm64-v8a
- Existing zip found
- Extracting files
! Installation Failed
Magisk Log File
- Copying image to cache
- Device platform: arm64-v8a
- Existing zip found
- Extracting files
boot_patch.sh[73]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
MagiskBoot v17.0(17000) (by topjohnwu) - Boot Image Modification Tool
Parsing boot image: [/data/user_de/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/install/boot.img]
No boot image magic found!
boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
! Installation failed
Device Stats
Nexus 6P
Lineage 15.1
TWRP - latest
Any help would be greatly appreciated.

monteie2016 said:
I attempted to go from Magisk v16 to Magisk v17 from the app, Install > Patch Boot Image File > Magisk-v17(1700).zip and I get the below .
I opened up Root Checker and it let me know that the device no longer has Root.
- Copying image to cache
- Device platform: arm64-v8a
- Existing zip found
- Extracting files
! Installation Failed
Magisk Log File
- Copying image to cache
- Device platform: arm64-v8a
- Existing zip found
- Extracting files
boot_patch.sh[73]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
MagiskBoot v17.0(17000) (by topjohnwu) - Boot Image Modification Tool
Parsing boot image: [/data/user_de/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/install/boot.img]
No boot image magic found!
boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
! Installation failed
Device Stats
Nexus 6P
Lineage 15.1
TWRP - latest
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Happened with me also...i gues the only solution is you have to uninstall mafisk via magisk uninstaller and flash it once again via whatever recovery you are using...i am also using lineage os 15.1 but with RN4....

Happened to me as well. HTC u11, ViperU 1.8.0, Android 7.1.1, TWRP 3.2.2. Tried flashing it though TWRP got a bootloop. Had to revert back to my previous nan which luckily I made yesterday.

I attempted the same, now my galaxy s6 is in a boot loop

Look other posts in this section - you should flash latest uninstaller before Magisk v17 package. It seems that some residues from v16 prevent v17 from installing correctly.

^^^^^^^^^^

how to uninstall magisk completely without custom recoery

Hello Guys
I can not install Magisk v17.1
I delete it complete with the uninstaller
And then flashed again in TWRP, but dont work
Magisk icon is not visible and I can not manually install the Magisk Manager
Pls Help

edkmho said:
how to uninstall magisk completely without custom recoery
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had to reflash stock (OTA sideload version, in stock recovery) via adb sideload. Essential phone. Wifi is working now, didn't lose any data.

I'm also having the issue on my OnePlus 5T. I was running v16.0, and when I tried to flash the v17.1 zip in TWRP like usual, but it said zip signature verification failed. I flashed the Magisk uninstaller zip and tried again, but still had the same problem. I've lost root, but all my data is still intact and it never had boot issues.

After using uninstaller in recovery, restart into recovery to flash v17

aydinbahadir88 said:
And then flashed again in TWRP, but dont work
Magisk icon is not visible and I can not manually install the Magisk Manager
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you update from 16.0? If Yes test following:
Download the seperate MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk
Make sure that you adb is working, connect your phone to computer
Code:
adb devices
must show your phone, if not adb is not proper set
Code:
adb install MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk
if you get a error message like
the sign with the installed apk has not matsched..aborted
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the uninstaller not proper delete the old magisk manager
try
Code:
adb uninstall com.topjohnwu.magisk
the result must be an sucess
then again
Code:
adb install MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk
result must also sucess
Reboot, voiala its done....
You see the Magisk Manager

Does anyone have a working solution?

1.download magisk 17.zip from inside magisk 16
2. uninstall magisk 16 (i do from inside, not twrp)
3. instal magisk 17.zip from twrp
4. open magisk 17 and get notification for downloaded magisk 17.apk
5. download and instal it,
tested by my phone
mi5 Lineage Os 15.1

How I recovered from this on a Pixel 2 XL
I'll chime in with my experience here, as it might save someone else a lot of time if they are at my skill level with this stuff (which is only moderate, I suppose, although I do always get things to work eventually!).
As of yesterday, I had a Pixel 2 XL, rooted with Magisk, and working great. This morning, during the middle of the night, Magisk innocently asks if I want to upgrade to a new version. I was very tired (in fact, I think I was sleeping when my phone buzzed to alert me of the upgrade message) and don't even know how I responded except that it was "yes" to the upgrade part. By the time I'd fully awakened, I had a phone that waw in a boot loop. I went back to sleep, figuring I'd have better luck looking at it after a little rest.
Getting out of the boot loop was easy: I just reinstalled the August 2018 factory image for the phone. However, getting Magisk reinstalled was an adventure. I saw posts that said I should run the Magisk uninstaller, but when I did it just said that Magisk was already uninstalled. And yet, whenever I tried to apply either v16.0 or v17.1, I got errors (error codes 1, 2, and 255 at different times).
Up until this event, I'd always upgraded Magisk by installing it via TWRP. However, that was not working, so I thought I needed to try patching the boot image, something I'd never done before. Because I'd never done it before, it took me a while to understand the steps, which are actually quite simple. This is where I'm hoping I might save someone some time. Basically, my fear was not knowing which file the "boot image" was. Seasoned Android veterans might get a chuckle out of this, and that's fine, but I was looking at the file in the factory image download and basically saw only two image files: bootloader-taimen-tmz20j.img and radio-taimen-g8998-00253-1805232234.img. I was trying to figure out if either of those could be the boot image, and they both seemed pretty big to be a boot image! Finally it dawned on me that the much larger file in the directory was a zip archive (named image-taimen-ppr1.180610.009.zip). I looked inside there, and sure enough, there was a rather small file named boot.img. I was pretty sure that was the "boot image" file!
Here's what I did after that, again just hoping to help anyone who finds themselves in the same predicament I was in: Magisk is broken, root isn't working, and I can't install any of the Magisk *.zip images via TWRP.
- First, I downloaded a copy of Magisk Manager: this version is named MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk.
- Next, I ran a couple adb commands to send the Magisk Manager apk and the stock boot.img to my phone:
Code:
adb push MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk /sdcard/Download
adb push boot.img /sdcard/Download
- Next, I installed /sdcard/Download/Magisk-Manager-v5.9.1.apk by nagivating to it (I use ES File Manager) and launching it from there.
- Next I opened Magisk Manager
- Magisk Manager detects that there is a newer version available and asks if I want to upgrade
- I said yes
- I told it that I wanted to patch a boot image
- I chose /sdcard/Download/boot.img as the "unpatched" (stock) boot image
- Magisk Manager churned away for maybe half a minute and then produced a new file called patched_boot.img, saved in the same directory as boot.img.
After that, all I had to do was run these commands:
Code:
adb reboot bootloader
fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img
fastboot reboot
As soon as the phone restarted, I opened Magisk Manager again and it verified that its upgrade was successful, and root began working for me again also.
Like I said, I hope this helps someone else. If not, it's probably good for me to just write it all out anyway.
Cheers,
Sky Captain

_sky.captain_ said:
I'll chime in with my experience here, as it might save someone else a lot of time if they are at my skill level with this stuff (which is only moderate, I suppose, although I do always get things to work eventually!).
As of yesterday, I had a Pixel 2 XL, rooted with Magisk, and working great. This morning, during the middle of the night, Magisk innocently asks if I want to upgrade to a new version. I was very tired (in fact, I think I was sleeping when my phone buzzed to alert me of the upgrade message) and don't even know how I responded except that it was "yes" to the upgrade part. By the time I'd fully awakened, I had a phone that waw in a boot loop. I went back to sleep, figuring I'd have better luck looking at it after a little rest.
Getting out of the boot loop was easy: I just reinstalled the August 2018 factory image for the phone. However, getting Magisk reinstalled was an adventure. I saw posts that said I should run the Magisk uninstaller, but when I did it just said that Magisk was already uninstalled. And yet, whenever I tried to apply either v16.0 or v17.1, I got errors (error codes 1, 2, and 255 at different times).
Up until this event, I'd always upgraded Magisk by installing it via TWRP. However, that was not working, so I thought I needed to try patching the boot image, something I'd never done before. Because I'd never done it before, it took me a while to understand the steps, which are actually quite simple. This is where I'm hoping I might save someone some time. Basically, my fear was not knowing which file the "boot image" was. Seasoned Android veterans might get a chuckle out of this, and that's fine, but I was looking at the file in the factory image download and basically saw only two image files: bootloader-taimen-tmz20j.img and radio-taimen-g8998-00253-1805232234.img. I was trying to figure out if either of those could be the boot imag, and they both seemed pretty big to be a boot image! Finally it dawned on me that the much larger file in the directory was a zip archive (named image-taimen-ppr1.180610.009.zip). I looked inside there, and sure enough, there was a rather small file named boot.img. I was pretty sure that was the "boot image" file!
Here's what I did after that, again just hoping to help anyone who finds themselves in the same predicament I was in: Magisk is broken, root isn't working, and I can't install any of the Magisk *.zip images via TWRP.
- First, I downloaded a copy of Magisk Manager: this version is named MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk.
- Next, I ran a couple adb commands to send the Magisk Manager apk and the stock boot.img to my phone:
Code:
adb push MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk /sdcard/Download
adb push boot.img /sdcard/Download
- Next, I installed /sdcard/Download/Magisk-Manager-v5.9.1.apk by nagivating to it (I use ES File Manager) and launching it from there.
- Next I opened Magisk Manager
- Magisk Manager detects that there is a newer version available and asks if I want to upgrade
- I said yes
- I told it that I wanted to patch a boot image
- I chose /sdcard/Download/ as the "unpatched" (stock) boot image
- Magisk Manager churned away for maybe half a minute and then produced a new file called patched_boot.img, saved in the same directory as boot.img.
After that, all I had to do was run these commands:
Code:
adb reboot bootloader
fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img
fastboot reboot
As soon as the phone restarted, I opened Magisk Manager again and it verified that its upgrade was successful, and root began working for me again also.
Like I said, I hope this helps someone else. If not, it's probably good for me to just write it all out anyway.
Cheers,
Sky Captain
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I too have a Pixel 2XL but had a much easier upgrade experience. I downloaded the latest version of Magisk files (3 files: MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk, Magisk-uninstaller-20180901, and Magisk-v17.1 from here https://www.xda-developers.com/magisk-v17-1-android-pie-a-b-support/) and put them on my phone.
Rebooted into recovery TWRP run the Magisk-uninstaller-2018090 file, then ran Magisk-v17.1 rebooted and all worked (thanks to ALL the developers out there!!!)
I'm running rooted Pie (standard google Pie) with Rootchecker, 4.4.153-FlashKernal-Wahoo-v3.06, Greenify, AdAway, and of course Magisk 17.1.
Hope this helps.

akohle said:
After using uninstaller in recovery, restart into recovery to flash v17
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
flashed uninstaller in recovery
flashed v17
rebooted
it worked

If patch boot image is getting failed in magisk latest version v17.1 then enable storage permission for magisk app manually in Device/OS setting. Now patch boot image again, It will get patched successfully.

I
pierro78 said:
flashed uninstaller in recovery
flashed v17
rebooted
it worked
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK...im a relative newbie here...first post actually....but Im a bit stuck in a fastboot boot loop
LG G5 tmobile running fulmics
I decided to try this exact process to get my root back by updating Magisk
booted into TWRP through ADB
flashed uninstaller using TWRP
(cleared cache/dalvik)
flashed v 17.1 (not 17) using TWRP
(cleared cache/dalvik)
rebooted
now i'm stuck in fastboot bootloop….can reboot from fastboot but nothing else
any advice would be appreciated!
update: I am able to get to TWRP using reboot command and holding power and volume down. flashed uninstaller wiped cache/dalvik...rebooted into TWRP long way and then installed 17....still fastboot at startup again

Art1mis said:
If patch boot image is getting failed in magisk latest version v17.1 then enable storage permission for magisk app manually in Device/OS setting. Now patch boot image again, It will get patched successfully.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
many thanks for the tip!!
spent like an hour trying to figure out why my pixel 2 was failing to patch the boot image.
Allowed storage permissions, flashed the patched boot and now im rooted

Why magisk doesn't work with PIE Roms ?

Hi
Since PIE roms for santoni are available, some people, including me, can't root their santoni.
I don't know why.
Flash looks ok in recovery, but after reboot, Magisk Manager says that Magisk isn't installed.
I tried every solution found in forums here, but everytime, same result : "magisk isn't installed"...
So sad !
Could you guys (and girls) centralize here your solutions, step by step, from flash the rom to root it...
It would be so nice for helping desperate people...

I also tried SuperSU and am having the same problem. I've tried Magisk 17.1, 17.2 and the Canary build along with the newest SuperSU and the result is always the same. Flashes fine but Magisk Manager and SuperSU apps can't find root.
The weird thing is that Enpass always tells me that my device is rooted and that it's a security risk even though Magisk Manager can't find root.
Also, I'm positive Magisk is patching the ramdisk. The Uninstaller always finds a Magisk-patched image. I'm assuming something has to be happening during boot that's cancelling root.

Two things I don't understand :
- why some people, with same configuration, don't have root problem ?
- why, with same recovery, same flash method, root works with nougat/oreo rom, and doesn't work with pie...?
Just like that : do you think problem could come from the sd card ?
I'm using à 128 gb samsung sd-card. Maybe I should format it before trying again root ?
I'm not sure it's the problem, since I can flash all roms, but I could try...
Or flash Magisk from internal storage ?
Really desperate...

Hi,
I´m in the same situation like you.
Yesterday I made a new experience of that without solution:
- Backuped all
- Uninstalled magisk at twrp
- Installed santoni_twrp_silent 27_treble (recommended from dev to install havoc)
- Rebooted
- Formated data with factory reset
- Wiped vendor, cache, data... (everything)
- Installed havoc (version 2018-09-08)
- Rebooted
- Installed magisk at twrp
- Rebooted
Same issue like before...
If I try to install magisk on magisk manager I get the following log:
Copying image to cache
Device platform: arm64-v8a
Existing zip found
Extracting files
boot_patch.sh[73]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
MagiskBoot v17.1(17100) (by topjohnwu)
Boot Image Modification Tool
Parsing boot image: [/data/user_de/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/install/boot.img]
No boot image magic found!
boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory
boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory!
Installation failed
It seems magisk can´t install correct in cause of failing permissions to create new directories. But why?
Edit:
I think there´s an old magisk information written in device system who has to removed manually, cause magisk uninstaller is not able to do

Edit:
I think there´s an old magisk information written in device system who has to removed manually, cause magisk uninstaller is not able to do
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, but I wiped AND format data of internal storage, same results.
Do you think I should format/wipe micro-sd too ?

newbie_or_not_newbie said:
Ok, but I wiped AND format data of internal storage, same results.
Do you think I should format/wipe micro-sd too ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don´t think so. Well, if you like you can try, but I think it´s an internal problem, not an external

So,
I tried another wipe of internal storage, made a format data with recovery. Then I flashed another pie rom, then magisk. And after reboot : tada !! still not working...

try with version 16.6 of magisk

Great news, actually my magisk works on Pixys 2.1!
I installed this twrp:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RR-8WMNSQgx6QzQv5U4i-sST1Af42nrI/view
What I did:
Uninstalled old magisk, rebooted to twrp, installed magisk 17.2, rebooted, installed magisk manager 6.0 and it works.
The only thing is I didn´t rebooted until now, maybe it still works after next reboot or not...

Lemmy554 said:
Great news, actually my magisk works on Pixys 2.1!
I installed this twrp:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RR-8WMNSQgx6QzQv5U4i-sST1Af42nrI/view
What I did:
Uninstalled old magisk, rebooted to twrp, installed magisk 17.2, rebooted, installed magisk manager 6.0 and it works.
The only thing is I didn´t rebooted until now, maybe it still works after next reboot or not...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just tried this and it didn't work for me either. I tried multiple clean flashes, flashed MIUI then back to Pie and flashing things in different orders last night and nothing worked. I'm tired of messing with it. I don't know how to get logs without root. I've come to the conclusion that for now I either have Pie or root. Not both. lol

Me too. I stop trying every day a solution.
For the moment, no root for pie roms, so I keep staying with oreo roms (nice dot OS...) I can root.
Hope next builds of pie roms will accept to be rooted on our santoni...

You can try this:
1 Flash Magisk v 17.2, Reinica in fast boot mode, turn it off and turn the phone on again
2 Install Magiskmanager V6 APK, do not open and restart in recovery
3 Flash Magisk v 16.6 and ready...
It worked for me... important, do not update magisk... The root is lost again
Best regards

Thanks for your reply.
Did you have root trouble before trying your solution ?

yes, when installing Pie only. In oreo no, I tried it in havoc and pixys

Try OrangeFox recovery for flashing magisk.

hyperkin said:
Try OrangeFox recovery for flashing magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what I've been using. Also tried TWRP. Neither worked for me. The flash always looks good with no errors but when I boot the ROM Magisk says it's not installed.

I just realize to make magisk work on pie roms i realize that i need dev miui firmware not stable miui firmware the file you need is named fw_santoni_miui_HM4XGlobal_8.9.20_3219de02e5_7.1.zip i not sure why stable firmware wont work on magisk.
i used OrangeFox Recovery Project R8.1 for recovery
1. install rom PixysOS 2.1 as normal (clean flash). Note: LineageOS 16.0 also works I have tested it
2. boot up os to make sure it that everything is working
3. then reboot back to recovery
4. flash firmware zip file named fw_santoni_miui_HM4XGlobal_8.9.20_3219de02e5_7.1
5. reboot to system making sure that it still boots in os
6. reboot back to recovery
7. flash magisk 17.2 beta i think magisk 17.1 also works
8. reboot up back to system
9. installl magisk manager apk
10. done
i just uplolad screenshot just to prove it

neijzen said:
I just realize to make magisk work on pie roms i realize that i need dev miui firmware not stable miui firmware the file you need is named fw_santoni_miui_HM4XGlobal_8.9.20_3219de02e5_7.1.zip i not sure why stable firmware wont work on magisk.
i used OrangeFox Recovery Project R8.1 for recovery
1. install rom PixysOS 2.1 as normal (clean flash). Note: LineageOS 16.0 also works I have tested it
2. boot up os to make sure it that everything is working
3. then reboot back to recovery
4. flash firmware zip file named fw_santoni_miui_HM4XGlobal_8.9.20_3219de02e5_7.1
5. reboot to system making sure that it still boots in os
6. reboot back to recovery
7. flash magisk 17.2 beta i think magisk 17.1 also works
8. reboot up back to system
9. installl magisk manager apk
10. done
i just uplolad screenshot just to prove it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sounds like a plan! I'll try it out when I get home from work and let you know how it goes!

Trying asap.
Thanks

neijzen said:
I just realize to make magisk work on pie roms i realize that i need dev miui firmware not stable miui firmware the file you need is named fw_santoni_miui_HM4XGlobal_8.9.20_3219de02e5_7.1.zip i not sure why stable firmware wont work on magisk.
i used OrangeFox Recovery Project R8.1 for recovery
1. install rom PixysOS 2.1 as normal (clean flash). Note: LineageOS 16.0 also works I have tested it
2. boot up os to make sure it that everything is working
3. then reboot back to recovery
4. flash firmware zip file named fw_santoni_miui_HM4XGlobal_8.9.20_3219de02e5_7.1
5. reboot to system making sure that it still boots in os
6. reboot back to recovery
7. flash magisk 17.2 beta i think magisk 17.1 also works
8. reboot up back to system
9. installl magisk manager apk
10. done
i just uplolad screenshot just to prove it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This post right here works, thank you so much

Unable to install Magisk - getting "Unable to repack boot image!" error

Good evening lads. I've been having problems installing Magisk.
I've successfully rooted my device (a Samsung J5 2016) and installed Magisk Manager. From there, I selected "Install" and after the confirmation that I want to install Magisk v20.4(204000) I choose "Direct Install" , which is also the recommended option but get an installation error.
Here's my log:
Code:
- Target image: /dev/block/mmcblk0p16
- Device platform: armeabi-v7a
- Unpacking boot image
- Checking ramdisk status
- Stock boot image detected
- Patching ramdisk
- Repacking boot image
! Unable to repack boot image!
! Installation failed
I'm very noob at this and barely have any idea with what I'm doing, so I'm asking you, what can I do? I checked other threads but their logs was very different.
I've never had any other problem with other root apps (Lucky Patcher, Titanium Backup, Root checker etc.) and all I want to do is hide my root so I can use the Nintendo Switch app, lol.
Thanks in advance for your help.

The usual answer is, into Recovery and flash Magisk Uninstaller, then install the Magisk file in Recovery.
I can't give any guarantees, but that always used to be the way to go, if Magisk did not install with Direct Install option.
Like I say, no guarantees.
Should have said, make a Recovery Backup before attempting.
Second thoughts, another poster has just reported a problem installing 20.4 in TWRP, so maybe it's not such a good idea after all.
I don't advise.
Sorry for wrong advice.
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

if anyone is having trouble while installing magisk I have come up with solutions.​
if you have installed magisk but it never detects as it is installed the following would be solutions i have found for my self​
install magisk that is older than the one you are going to install in recovery with sideload for eg. to install magisk 25.00 from the recovery you need to install magisk 24.1 apk before that without shutting down your phone.​
the second step you need to do is you have to side-load the latest version after you have installed the older version from the recovery​
that is it simple as it is​