Downgrade Magisk from 17.1 to 16.7 - Magisk

So I've the following Problem. I updated Magisk from 16.7 to 17.1/17.3 (tried both) and also the Manager from 5.3.8 to 6.1.something. I simply can't for the heck of it downgrade it again to 16.7. I've one and only one issue with 17.1+, my phone won't detect any SIM, the only fix I've at hand is to use the stock update.zip from my ZTE Blade L7 to revert it and get my SIM to work, boot into recovery and apply update from SD card. So atm it's either, have root but no SIM or have no root but a working SIM. I tried the following:
- Install magisk16.7.zip from stockrecovery, gives me zip autentification error.
- Flash the magisk16.7.zip via fastboot, gives me the target didn't report max downloadsize error. I've OEM unlocked and USB debugging enabled, also, flashing the patched_boot.img via fastboot works everytime.
- Rename the magisk16.7.zip to magisk16.7.apk and install it, gives me a parsing error.
- Access the apk from within the magisk16.7.zip and extract and run it. It showes me the Magisk Icon and it seems to be about to install normally like any other app but it stops and says "magisk Manager not installed".
I don't have access to costum recoveries like twrp etc, because the ZTE Blade L7 isn't supported anywhere. With such costum recoveries I could disable the zip verfication check I guess. Also rooting it with other methods won't work either, for example kingroot.
Also what's weird is, when I uninstall magisk manager 6.1. for another attempt and install the older 5.3.8 wich I had with magisk 16.7, the manager gives me no other option but to update to 6.1 again, it won't let me install 16.7 wich I have on my SD and when I update the manager to 6.1, then I only have the option to install magisk 17.1 or 17.3 as zip. I can't patch the stock boot.img beforehand. It's realy confusing. Also I'm not 100% certain but is it correct that you've to use the corresponding manager for the right magisk version? So, magisk manager 5.3.8 for magisk 16.7, mm 6.1. for m 17.1+ and so on?
Magisk is cool and good, it's the only way of rooting my ZTE Blade L7 it seems, I hope topjonwu fixes this SIM detection bug soon or somebody gives me a simple method to downgrade.
update:
I'm still trying to find a solution. It seems the reason behind the SIM issue is that when I flash the patched boot.img my IMEI gets messed up. I tried to find some way to restore/edit the IMEI, but to no success. Also another method would be to install a costum ROM like lineageos, but this doesn't work for my ZTE Blade L7 aswell. This entire thing is sure a hard nut to crack, I already put too many hours into this. Please somebody help me, I can't be the only one with this SIM error when using Magisk 17.1/17.3
second update:
Installed the brand new magisk 18 today, SIM error persists. Checked the IMEI, weirdly, IMEI for SIM1 is not aviable but SIM2 got it correct, yet when I try to select any SIM in settings they're both greyed out (I put the SIM in the corresponding slot). What I noticed aswell was, when magisk is installed and mobile starts anew, my SIM gets detected and works normally, but if I reboot only once it's bugged again and no matter how often I reboot it won't detect it again. Also, I installed cwm, flashed the costum recovery for zte blade (zte blade L7 isn't supported and this was the only similiar sounding option) from within the cwm rom manager while beeing rooted, bootet into recovery from cwm rom manager but to no success, I still have the stock recovery. Intention was to install magisk16.7.zip from a costum recovery. I'm going nuts with this! Please, I just want a rooted mobile that works. Just an info for other zte Blade L7 owners, you get into recovery from:
power key + volume up > zte logo shows onscreen tap power key once > android guy on screen hold power key + tap volume up once.
To make my SIM work again I installed the stock zte update.zip from recovery. Somebody please help, if you search for "magisk no SIM" you'll find some results regarding this problem but there isn't any solution.
third update:
So I've given up for now. It's too complicated, I don't have that much time and I realy need this mobile to make calls/use the 3G for internet. It's my only stable internet connection. I'm too afraid to damage this mobile irepeairable. It seems when I flash the patched_boot.img with magisk 17 and higher something's gets done wrong with the modem/baseband settings. You can erase modemst1.bin and modemst2.bin via fastboot and do such things, but that can make things much worse. Can't backup and restore efs partition, can't install costum recoveries, can't flash modem.bin files, yet alone find the right .bin. This sucks. Magisk is the only method to root a ZTE Blade L7 it seems. Or compile a twrp recovery your own, but that's way over my head. Mods can you please rename the thread title to "Magisk 17.1 and higher no functioning SIM, how to downgrade to 16.7?" Since the v.18 came out recently. Thank you topjonwu and xda board.

Related

Bootloop - New fi Moto x4

I've just gotten my new fi Motorola x4 running Android 8.1.0 today. I've unlocked the boot loader via Motorola and I've rooted the device via Magisk. Since I had the Xposed framework on my old phone and loved some of the modules I wanted it on my new phone. Downloaded the Xposed Installed from the playstore, gave it root access with Magisk and attempted to install the framework. Phone is now stuck in a bootloop and it's been alternating between the androidone and motorola screens for about 45 minutes.
I tried to flash xposed-uninstaller-20180117-arm64.zip but got an error that it couldn't mount /system. Another page on the net had me holding down the power button and then spamming it ten times to tell Xposed no to load but that didn't seem to do anything at all. I created a disabled file as suggested on some sites but that did nothing to stop the bootloop:
touch /data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/conf/disabled
I actually had to make the /conf directory manually since it wasn't there. Wiped the cache with no better results. Factory reset did nothing to improve the situation and I was unsuccessful with sideloading the Xposed disabler found here:
https://android.gadgethacks.com/how-to/xposed-101-temporarily-disable-xposed-fix-bootloop-0179446/
It's hard for me to grasp how a completely empty barebones android phone which has only been rooted using Magisk with no other actions taken or software installed can be be stuck in a bootloop trying to perform a standard install using the Xposed installer. Not sure you can find a cleaner environment than the one on my phone.
Anyway if anyone has thought I'd love to hear them. I can boot to TWRP without issue and my phone is visible to both fastboot and adb.
Thank you!
Laugh this is just getting worse. I uninstalled Magisk and now the phone boots straight into recovery whenever I restart it. I'd flash a stock rom but I can't find one. I think I'm in trouble...
Reinstalled Magisk and it at least tries to boot up again but it just loops.
Arsenal420 said:
I've just gotten my new fi Motorola x4 running Android 8.1.0 today. I've unlocked the boot loader via Motorola and I've rooted the device via Magisk. Since I had the Xposed framework on my old phone and loved some of the modules I wanted it on my new phone. Downloaded the Xposed Installed from the playstore, gave it root access with Magisk and attempted to install the framework. Phone is now stuck in a bootloop and it's been alternating between the androidone and motorola screens for about 45 minutes.
I tried to flash xposed-uninstaller-20180117-arm64.zip but got an error that it couldn't mount /system. Another page on the net had me holding down the power button and then spamming it ten times to tell Xposed no to load but that didn't seem to do anything at all. I created a disabled file as suggested on some sites but that did nothing to stop the bootloop:
touch /data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/conf/disabled
I actually had to make the /conf directory manually since it wasn't there. Wiped the cache with no better results. Factory reset did nothing to improve the situation and I was unsuccessful with sideloading the Xposed disabler found here:
https://android.gadgethacks.com/how-to/xposed-101-temporarily-disable-xposed-fix-bootloop-0179446/
It's hard for me to grasp how a completely empty barebones android phone which has only been rooted using Magisk with no other actions taken or software installed can be be stuck in a bootloop trying to perform a standard install using the Xposed installer. Not sure you can find a cleaner environment than the one on my phone.
Anyway if anyone has thought I'd love to hear them. I can boot to TWRP without issue and my phone is visible to both fastboot and adb.
Thank you!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://magiskroot.net/uninstall-magisk-module-twrp/
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=72542167&postcount=242
In summary:
Step 1: Download the flasheable zip file from the Magisk module uninstaller from the following link to the PC
Step 2: Send the zip file to the SD card of the phones or to the internal memory using MTP (most of the recovery of TWRP is compatible with this method)
Step 3: Now, touch the Install button and choose the Zip file of the uninstaller of the Magisk module that you want to update.
Step 4: After the completion of the installation. Go back to the TWRP home page.
Step 5: Tap the advanced option from the TWRP homepage. Choose the terminal option now.
Step 6: Type uninmod in the terminal box and touch the input button.
Step 7: Now, you can see the list of Modules and you have to type the Number you want to uninstall (Check the screenshot below)
Step 8: Finally, the magisk module will be completely uninstalled.
Arsenal420 said:
. Downloaded the Xposed Installed from the playstore,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What xposed installer in playstore, playstore is not where xposed is gotten from...at all. The closest thing to it that I found is an asian trick your friends app.
Nergal di Cuthah said:
What xposed installer in playstore, playstore is not where xposed is gotten from...at all. The closest thing to it that I found is an asian trick your friends app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are right I got the apk from here:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3034811
Do you have anything additional to offer?
Arsenal420 said:
You are right I got the apk from here:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3034811
Do you have anything additional to offer?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok good, I got scared for you a bit there, my post was not meant to be mean spirited but maybe you read it as such. As far as the bootloop i'm afraid i'll be no help.

Keep root after update with Magisk and no TWRP

If you already have root with Magisk, and don't have TWRP on your otherwise stock ROM, it is easy to retain root after upgrade. I have done this the past 4 updates.
1) Install the update through system updates. Don't reboot.
2) Open Magisk Manager and select "Install to Inactive Slot (After OTA)." Press Magisk Reboot button to reboot.
If for some reason you don't get the choice in Magisk to install to inactive slot the first time, then do this:
1) Install the update through system updates. Don't reboot.
2) Open Magisk Manager and install Magisk. Don't reboot
3) Open Magisk Manager again and this time select "Install to Inactive Slot (After OTA)." Press Reboot button to reboot.
don't you have to restore first the stock boot image in Magisk, before downloading/installing the OTA?
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/tutorials.md
I haven"t done the procedure yet, but I"m gonna have to update soon before Q drops, I wanna stay in Pie
Nope. I just updated to android 10 (A6013_41_191214) using the same method, so that makes 5 updates. I am really glad I found this method that is so simple since I always used to dread updating and regaining root. Now it adds about 10 seconds to the process.
I did have to use the three-step process since I had not updated Magisk in a while and it wants to be on the latest version before it allows you to install to inactive slot. Unlike previous updates, I had to re-choose Nova as the default launcher.
This helped me after I hard bricked my phone trying to root android 10. Thanks!
H10N3 said:
This helped me after I hard bricked my phone trying to root android 10. Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem. When I said "I used to dread updating and regaining root" it was because i had bricked my phone trying to re-root after an update, too, so I was always on edge when doing it until I found this easy method.
It works for me from 10 oos to oos10.3
I did that, I'm now stuck on Bootloader warning screen, even after rebooting :/
Phone can't boot in fastboot, PC can't detect device anymore.
Edit: Managed to boot in fastboot mode (vol +/-/power), had to use MsmDownloadTool to unbrick.
Hi can anybody give me a hint how to procede?
- I was on 8.1 Oreo with my 1043 PL2
- did select System Update --> Android 10 (V4.16B)
- in magisk I selected "Install to Inactive Slot (After OTA)." + reboot
I just got a loop of white android one screens,
every third cycle "Android Recovery" is offering a selection of "Try again" or "Factory data reset".
Did I lose unlocked Boot loader?
Would some more retries help?
If I use "factory data reset" do I keep magisk - or would it be non rooted system?
Any hint to go to an android 10 rooted device is apreciated (preferrably with my data).
I id a TWRP BU of 8.1 system before update.
Would also a switch back to other "sltot" with 8.1 be possible?
cheers
lino
EDIT (29mar21):
since no answer,
- I selected "delete Data partition"
- Phone deleted all my data I had no BU (pictures, Download folder)
- installed MagiskManager, and at least I stayed rooted.
- now I have to setup may phone from scratch :'(
EDIT2: and I did not even realise that I that I stumbled in wrong thread (I was searching for Nokia 6.1 ... anyway)
woo that was close.
ok so, sorry, reviving from the future, hello!
for some reason, I followed this on a Nord. Bootloop.
A/B partitions!
fastboot --set-active=a
Is there a update guide for Magisk using LOS 19.1? This method does not work for LOS, only for OOS. It will give you a bootloop. I have been flashing Magisk's zip file under LOS recovery, but there should be another way to update Magisk without all that hassle. Magisk's direct install will not work.

Magisk v22.0 Patch Image - Magisk in Recover - Xiaomi Mi 9T (davinci) not being installed

Hopefully someone can help me out here:
I'm on Mi 9T (davinici) with xiaomi.eu-cROM 12.1.2 (Stable) and OrangeFox Beta R11.0 Recovery. Bootloader is obviously unlocked.
I followed the guide for Magisk v22.0 and installed the apk first, opened it and it says
"Ramdisk No"
Alright, so I have to patch the recovery.img.
In Orangefox Recovery I open the Terminal and extract recovery.img with
Code:
dd if=/dev/block/bootdevice/by-name/recovery of=/sdcard/recovery.img
Reboot to system and I chose "Install" in Magisk, "Recovery Mode" is already selected, click "Next" and I select the newly created file "recovery.img". Magisk does it's thing and I have "magisk_patched_cOdEy.img" in my Download folder which I pull with adb.
I reboot to fastboot mode and
Code:
fastboot flash recovery magisk_patched_cOdEy.img
which works w/o problems and reboot again.
But when I open Magisk it still says it's not installed.
So, I check the guide under Magisk in Recovery, where it gets really confusing, but from what I got is that I need to start the phone with recovery button combo (Power+VolUp for Mi 9T) pushed and release at splash screen so Magisk is activated. I try this multiple times since it's really hard with the timing (milliseconds too long it kicks me into fastboot mode. idk why).
Can someone figure out what went wrong/what I did wrong? Never had problems with earlier Magisk versions.
Follow up question: There's some warning about going back to stock recovery will brick your phone in installation. Does that include installing OrangeFox again? I'm 95% sure it doesn't, but would be nice to know before I do it.
Some Xiaomi devices have their bootloaders set up so that it will accept an initramfs that was manually added to the boot image. Therefore, on these devices you'll need to patch the boot image even though there's no ramdisk. Try that.
Didgeridoohan said:
Some Xiaomi devices have their bootloaders set up so that it will accept an initramfs that was manually added to the boot image. Therefore, on these devices you'll need to patch the boot image even though there's no ramdisk. Try that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can I reinstall OrangeFox or TWRP recovery then?
I'll report back, when I tried it.
edit: So this actually works and I was able to enter TWRP recovery again after flashing.
edit 2: Now WiFi is not working anymore. fml.
edit 3: For anyone stumbling over this thread. Nothing worked, I had to do a compelte wipe and then flash Magisk "the old way", by renaming the .apk into a .zip and flashing it in recovery. That did the trick without any probems and I'm rooted now after quite a hassle.
yeah, I stumbled upon it. And I'm having the same/a very similar issue. I was very happy with Magisk up to v22 when the problems began.
I'm still at DerpFest based on Android 9.0 (from 2019 ) and TWRP-3.4.0.0.I had Magisk running since it was 19.4, upgraded it multiple times already. So didn't think much about updating to 22. Then, it said the same: no ramdisk. Pitty. OK, so I went ahead and let Magisk patch the TWRP.img I still got on my phone and flashed the patched TWRP onto recovery. Upon booting, Magisk is there, but no wifi, no sound, no light sensor, ... LTE works, though .
Anyways, I just want to get my old setup back, so I thought, I just flash the original TWRP again. According to the Magisk documentation, if I don't press any button, it should boot to Android without Magisk. Well, it always boots into Android+Magisk disregarding that. If I flash the original TWRP.img back, I always end up in TWRP. So, the order is: boot.img -> magisk-modified-recovery.img -> (boot.img?) -> system. How can I get the behaviour Magisk advertises?
And yes, I tried uninstalling Magisk (via uninstall.zip meythod), which said it would uninstall, but actually didn't. I also flashed different boot images (a backup I had in TWRP, the original boot.img I've found in the DerpFest zip...) to no avail.
So, Immortal68, which of the many wipes one can do did result in the old behaviour? And: now that you have Magisk22, does it say "Ramdisk: yes" again?

After rooting G9+ & installing an unofficial LineageOS 18.1, root was lost & need help getting it back

I decided to upgrade to the G9+ after finding a LineageOS ROM for the phone. Root via TWRP & Magisk worked without a hitch. Then I installed the LineageOS 18.1 ROM from here: https://www.getdroidtips.com/lineage-os-18-1-moto-g9-plus/
Next I went to install GApps via the Aroma setup, but found that TWRP was gone. There was some limited recovery from the ROM installation which didn't seem to be of any use, so I reflashed TWRP & then Magisk, but I didn't get root back.
The phone now has a working version of LineageOS, but I can't even get the Google crap I need.
When I try to flash something via TWRP I get an error saying there was a "Zip signature verification failure", so I can't even get back to stock ROM to try again. (I guess this error is related to not having root.)
(I installed TWRP & Magisk on another G9+ with stock ROM and everything seems as expected. The phone is rooted. I just want to get rid off all the Google software I can.)
Anyone got an idea how I can get root back?
------
And any reason why "ADB devices" doesn't list the attached phone? "Fastboot devices" works fine.
Have u tested lineage, is
everything working fine?
UsmanQ said:
Have u tested lineage, is
everything working fine?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Everything seems to be there, seems normal. Except root.
doktorspin said:
Everything seems to be there, seems normal. Except root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
doktorspin said:
Everything seems to be there, seems normal. Except root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have u tried superoot or something else instead of magisk?
Sapper Morton said:
The ROM that you're using is not meant to be daily driven, Erfan compiled that for experimental purposes, but that aside, there's a few things that you should take in consideration when using Lineage; It's not meant to be used with TWRP, that's why they ship their own recovery (Lineage Recovery). It's still possible to flash custom files with it (That doesn't match their original signature), you just need to skip a warning.
For Magisk, download the latest stable build from here: Download
(The .apk has the flashing script built-in, so just rename that to .zip).
One major difference from TWRP, is that Lineage Recovery doesn't support decrypting userdata, so the files must be flashed using ADB or USB OTG.
Use ADB Sideload as follows:adb sideload magisk.zip
As for me, I didn't unlocked my device yet, so if you could confirm me something: I need to know if I will lose my DRM certification, used for Netflix, Disney+, Prime Video and such.
Download Castro from Play Store, go to the DRM tab, and check the Widevine status, tell me if it remains L1, or if it downgraded to L3. That's what's holding me back from testing, or even compiling for this device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the response.
1. I'm using the Github Magisk 23.
2. Lineage Recovery is gone. I reflashed TWRP.
3. Attempting to use "ADB sideload Magisk-v23.0.zip" ADB responds "cannot read 'Magisk-v23.0.zip'"
4. I haven't got Play Store on the phone as I can't flash the aroma package (1.7GB) via TWRP.
UsmanQ said:
Have u tried superoot or something else instead of magisk?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know anything about the other methods for getting root. I've always used Magisk.
(I'm working under the idea that as TWRP + Magisk works fine on one phone, they aren't the problem.)
Sapper Morton said:
The idea is to rollback to Lineage Recovery, you can even flash only the boot.img that it's inside the ROM flashable file, instead of reflashing the whole thing again. It's probably in payload.bin format, so you'll need a payload firmware extractor (Easily found on GitHub), in case you choose the first option.
• Aroma is not supported on Lineage Recovery, so I would recommend something smaller, like OpenGapps nano or stock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
<rant>
What sort of idiots build in a crap recovery when one has obviously already installed a functional recovery, needed in the process of gaining root and installing LineasgeOS? This unnecessary included recovery wasn't in previous versions of LOS I've used.
Yes, this is an unpleasant surprise and I'm ticked off. I'm an end user who wants a relatively de-Googled phone, but now to maybe get a functional recovery I have to extract stuff from a payload file, but to do that I have to install more crud so that I can run the tool that does the extracting.
And I need Aroma to be able to select what I must have from Google. My partner needs their voice tech. I could dump almost everything else and use Pico. </rant> Sorry.
Is there no way to wipe the slate clean, get rid of this Lineage, and start again?
(I don't understand how installing their recovery could ruin the functionality of another recovery.)
Sapper Morton said:
Download Castro from Play Store, go to the DRM tab, and check the Widevine status, tell me if it remains L1, or if it downgraded to L3. That's what's holding me back from testing, or even compiling for this device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On the second G9+ which I rooted but left the stock ROM, I installed Castro and it indicates L3.
doktorspin said:
I decided to upgrade to the G9+ after finding a LineageOS ROM for the phone. Root via TWRP & Magisk worked without a hitch. Then I installed the LineageOS 18.1 ROM from here: https://www.getdroidtips.com/lineage-os-18-1-moto-g9-plus/
Next I went to install GApps via the Aroma setup, but found that TWRP was gone. There was some limited recovery from the ROM installation which didn't seem to be of any use, so I reflashed TWRP & then Magisk, but I didn't get root back.
The phone now has a working version of LineageOS, but I can't even get the Google crap I need.
When I try to flash something via TWRP I get an error saying there was a "Zip signature verification failure", so I can't even get back to stock ROM to try again. (I guess this error is related to not having root.)
(I installed TWRP & Magisk on another G9+ with stock ROM and everything seems as expected. The phone is rooted. I just want to get rid off all the Google software I can.)
Anyone got an idea how I can get root back?
------
And any reason why "ADB devices" doesn't list the attached phone? "Fastboot devices" works fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
take a look at this group of telegram, here they can help you to return
Lolinet [English Only]
Our website: MIRRORS.LOLINET.COM Our channel: https://t.me/lolinetnews Please speak in English
t.me
Lineage is working fine, some details that will be fixed when releasing the new kernel
There is a method to root with magisk by patching the ramdisk its a way better rooting method then with twrp in fact magisk dev recommends this way of rooting if you have not tried this here is a magisk official link https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/install.html
Hope This helped you bro
The ROM in the O.P. works.​
Folks, I actually made a number of mistakes in this process.
The major one was to muff the fastboot command for flashing TWRP. I had followed instructions which said to boot TWRP, which didn't install TWRP, just loaded it into phone memory. But...
The ROM cited in the O.P. doesn't seem to have any problems that I have noticed in my usage, which is basically as a hand computer, not as a phone.
LineageOS now overwrites recovery with its own recovery, which is pretty moronic, because the user has already had to install a recovery to root the device.
But fortunately, if you have your ADB/fastboot apps handy with TWRP in the same folder it's an easy fix.
You should already have this stuff, but use the following software:
sebastian3367HD has provided TWRP for G9+ users onsight here. I'll assume it's called "twrp.img".
Magisk-v23 here -- put it somewhere easy on your phone.
Also get GApps 11. I used core NikGapps here, select latest date, then the version of GApps you want. (The core version 82MB just gives you Play Store & support software.) Put it the same place on the phone you put Magisk.
Assuming you've flashed the O.P. LineageOS ROM, which overwrites trusty TWRP, put your phone in fastboot mode, either using
1. power button + volume down
until you get the droid image on its back, or get there with your phone on, sending
2. adb reboot bootloader
via the windows command shell.
You're now in fastboot mode. You can now flash TWRP back onto the phone. Note that the phone has two slots of memory, so that the phone can hold two operating systems. If you send
fastboot flash recovery twrp.img
it will be flashed to the current slot, either A or B. To be safe you should flash both:
fastboot flash recovery_a twrp.img
fastboot flash recovery_b twrp.img
That gives you the safety of having TWRP in both slots. (Incidentally, TWRP allows you to changes slots.) (Also remember if you reflash LineageOS you'll have to put TWRP back on if you want a decent recovery program.)
Use TRWP to Reboot to Recovery.
Now install Magisk using TWRP:
Spoiler: (You know this)
a) choose Install
b) if the bottom right button says Install Zip press it and it will change to Install Image
c) if you put Magisk on your external SD card Select Storage to choose the SD
d) find and select Magisk-v23.0.apk, then
e) swipe to flash.
Then install GApps, basically the same as for Magisk.
Reboot to System. You should be rooted now and should have Play Store (and whatever else you opted for).
M.Akram said:
There is a method to root with magisk by patching the ramdisk its a way better rooting method then with twrp in fact magisk dev recommends this way of rooting if you have not tried this here is a magisk official link https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/install.html
Hope This helped you bro
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the info. My problem was simple to fix, using the right commands!
I haven't installed that rom because afaik the source tree isn't available anywhere which seems kind of fishy, if anyone knows where they are please let us know

Rooting Moto G6 with PPS29-118-15-11. What versions of noverity, twrp, magisk to use?

Hello forum, I have been trying to root my motorola G6..
After much struggle, getting stuck in a boot loop and other issues I finally have restored stock roms and now have build PPS29-118-15-11 installed. So at least the phone works again My bootloader is unlocked.
But I still want to root it.
I think I understand the procedure well enough, but I am unsure of the correct/best versions I need for the ROMS/boot, Magisk, and TWRP.
ROMS/boot:
I found a youtube with instructions for updating Android v9
But I haven't tried it as this recommends a boot img:
OPS27.104-15-10_no-verity_boot.img
OPS27.104-15-10_no-verity_boot.img | by dejello for Moto G6
Download GApps, Roms, Kernels, Themes, Firmware, and more. Free file hosting for all Android developers.
androidfilehost.com
I am reluctant to use the above as it looks to be a downgrade from my current version 29-118-15-11.
Also, I thought that the filename prefix "O" indicated oreo instead of "P" for pie? So would this be a version 8 file?
TWRP:
Similarly, I am not sure if I am using the right, or best TWRP version. I currently have twrp-v3.2.3-ali.img
I flash this (with fastboot) and it works but shortly after I encounter the "no command" error (when booting to recovery) and I have to redo it. I am NOT overwriting it with a stock recovery.img.
I have also run into the "encryption password" problem, where I am unable to provide one to decrypt the data partition. So I can't backup the data with twrp (something I really would like to do).
Magisk
I have Magisk-23-0.zip
But I saw a post from brunogroa that recommends installing Magisk 19 and updating it to 23 later. Is this something that is required or can I just install v23?
So, I am looking for the correct versions for ROM, Magisk and TWRP to use, given that I have installed PPS29-118-15-11
Any assistance will be greatly appreciated.
Well I finally have it I think. I noticed a comment in
[GUIDE][ROOT][Moto G6][ALI] TWRP, Root, and Magisk installation guide. by djello
"(you may not need a modified boot image for Magisk)"
When using PIE instead of OREO.
Being an optimist, I gave it a try and it worked... I installed Magisk and was able to verify root access using the Root Checker Basic App. Kept stock boot img.
This is probably not too amazing for the old hands but us newbies need a break every now and them
So in the end, all I had to do was:
(0) Unlock bootloader
(1) Install stock PPS29-118-15-11
Done earlier with another version of twrp.
Install TWRP 3.5.2
(2) fastboot flash recovery twrp-3.5.2_9-0-ali.img
(3) Use twrp to install Magisk
adb push Magisk-v23-0.zip /tmp
Boot phone into recovery and use twrp to install Magisk
(4) Boot the phone into System and verify Magisk is there and use Root Checker App to confirm I am now rooted.
Issues:
I noticed that a security update for
PPS29-118-15-11-5 failed to apply.
The phone boots into recovery mode and asks for the decrypt password. I don't know the password to decrypt data and how to proceed from here.
I suspect that if I flash the stock recovery img the security update might work. If anyone knows please comment ; I will research this also and maybe just try it.
pdpantages said:
Well I finally have it I think. I noticed a comment in
[GUIDE][ROOT][Moto G6][ALI] TWRP, Root, and Magisk installation guide. by djello
"(you may not need a modified boot image for Magisk)"
When using PIE instead of OREO.
Being an optimist, I gave it a try and it worked... I installed Magisk and was able to verify root access using the Root Checker Basic App. Kept stock boot img.
This is probably not too amazing for the old hands but us newbies need a break every now and them
So in the end, all I had to do was:
(0) Unlock bootloader
(1) Install stock PPS29-118-15-11
Done earlier with another version of twrp.
Install TWRP 3.5.2
(2) fastboot flash recovery twrp-3.5.2_9-0-ali.img
(3) Use twrp to install Magisk
adb push Magisk-v23-0.zip /tmp
Boot phone into recovery and use twrp to install Magisk
(4) Boot the phone into System and verify Magisk is there and use Root Checker App to confirm I am now rooted.
Issues:
I noticed that a security update for
PPS29-118-15-11-5 failed to apply.
The phone boots into recovery mode and asks for the decrypt password. I don't know the password to decrypt data and how to proceed from here.
I suspect that if I flash the stock recovery img the security update might work. If anyone knows please comment ; I will research this also and maybe just try it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am stuck in a similar position.
SOLVED IT!!! Followed all of the steps that you posted except I installed Magisk with the patch method because I couldn't get the zip file to push onto the device. Kept getting a read only error, maybe because it wasn't rooted?
Anyway, I am rooted now!!!

Categories

Resources