Related
From various threads, I see that the wiimote with or without the wii classic controller works well.
That's the only widely available controller I've seen. Some people have been pimping the Phonejoy modified PSX controller, but those are custom made. The datel retro wii controller has also come up, but Nintendo has all but driven these out of the market, and for our limited bt range, tethering Nintendo's Wii Classic controller to a Wiimote may be a better option anyway.
I'm specifically curious about the PS3 controller, but some googling suggests it's a no-go with Android for the foreseeable future. Too bad, as I may pick up a PS3 at some point, but probably will never own a Wii.
Any other game controllers tested working? Any of them look more versatile or otherwise better than the Wiimote + Wii Classic combo?
Has anyone using the Wiimote or other controllers found them useful aside from gaming?
the datel retro controller seems to be the way to go imo.
boogerboy72 said:
the datel retro controller seems to be the way to go imo.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
IDK, looking around a little more, I found there's a newer generation (still a year old) Nintendo offering, the Classic Controller Pro:
http://www.amazon.com/Wii-Classic-C...UTF8&coliid=INNONUR2I65HQ&colid=3L10NYSDYJ11Z
It stacks the L/R buttons, adds grips, and spaces the analog sticks better. Given the NC's limited range, it might be a pro rather than a con that it tethers to a bluetooth radio (the wiimote). At $15, even if you need to buy a wiimote you could come in under the $40 price tag on the datel retro.
ETA: Actually, a knock-off wiimote should be fine for our purposes, right? So you could have wiimote+CC Pro for $25-30 from Amazon.
wow, havent seen that before, thats deff way to go.
There is also the Msi bgp100 gamepad. But personally I have a datel and love it. Not to much use besides gaming though.
I like the datel because its 1 controller instead of 2, having the wiimote and a classic controller just seems bulkie. But, yes, it would give you an extra foot of 2 of range if needed. Fyi the datel is the only stand alone wireless on the market. All the other aftermarket wireless wiimotes have to plug an adapter into the back of the wiimote.
im using a fake wiimote and it works fine...going to get the classic controller to extend the range a bit
check out deal extreme for some good deals...shipping does take forever from china though...
I too would have liked to see the PS3 Controller work. As I think it really would have been the ultimate controller as far as everything goes.
However it doesn't, so I purchased a kid's wiimote (just a smaller wiimote for extra portability) and a offbrand classic controller from gamestop for like $10. All in all was under 40, and it really helps with range issues.
That said, it's not much bulkier of a setup than the Datel wireless controller... If you're planning on taking the nook color somewhere to play games for a few hours, you can easily use an old backpack or wal-mart plastic bag to carry it all =\.
Just bought a knockoff Wiimote and Nunchuck off of Amazon, and a Wii Classic Controller Pro, all for $29! Here are the links to the two items:
Wii Classic Pro
Wiimote and Nunchuck
I'll update yall as to how they work as soon as I get them, cant wait to get playin some N64!
Well, I was trying not to spend any more money on the NC this month, but I broke down and grabbed the CCP for $15 while my Amazon Prime trial lasts. I'll look around locally for a knock-off or used wiimote, but otherwise I can get one from Amazon for $10 shipped.
I have not tried to use an emulator. However, this might be of interest to you.
N64oid a Nintendo 64 emulator is free for 1-2 weeks. In fact, Nesoid, Snesoid, Gensoid, N64oid, Ataroid, Gearoid and Gameboid are all free at the moment.
http://www.engadget.com/2011/05/29/android-markets-most-popular-emulators-disappear-without-a-trac/
https://slideme.org/user/yongzh
Explore3 said:
I have not tried to use an emulator. However, this might be of interest to you.
N64oid a Nintendo 64 emulator is free for 1-2 weeks. In fact, Nesoid, Snesoid, Gensoid, N64oid, Ataroid, Gearoid and Gameboid are all free at the moment.
http://www.engadget.com/2011/05/29/android-markets-most-popular-emulators-disappear-without-a-trac/
https://slideme.org/user/yongzh
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep, saw that in pulse, and had to jump on it! That's actually why I ended up getting the controllers, can't wait to try them out.
Sent from my NookColor using Tapatalk
I haven't seen the Wii Controller itself, but I have seen 3rd party Nubchucks and Classic Controllers at 5 Below stores in the US... (It's like a Dollar store, but with the upper limit at 5 dollars per item...)
Taosaur said:
Given the NC's limited range, it might be a pro rather than a con that it tethers to a bluetooth radio (the wiimote).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I thought that, then I bought a Datel Retro. With newer versions of CM7 I have the Retro working from 10 feet away.
psiphi said:
I haven't seen the Wii Controller itself, but I have seen 3rd party Nubchucks and Classic Controllers at 5 Below stores in the US... (It's like a Dollar store, but with the upper limit at 5 dollars per item...)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I checked the dollar store, but no love. I might be making a field trip near the cheap mall tomorrow, so I'll poke my head in Wally World and the like.
poofyhairguy said:
I thought that, then I bought a Datel Retro. With newer versions of CM7 I have the Retro working from 10 feet away.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've seen good results with the wiimote, too, but that's nuts. I wonder why the game controllers do so much better than other devices?
There's a new USBhost kernel for CM7 in the dev forum that should open the door to ps3 and xbox controllers...
Just got in my Wiimote and Classic controller, and they pair and work great! Only thing it, I cant seem to get any diagonal directions working... Does anyone else use Fpse and have some advice for setting up the controls for a Classic controller?? Thanks in advance!
Diagonals seem to be working for me in SNesoid, but I can't get the CCPro to work in Gensoid. It recognized the buttons for keymapping, but the games didn't respond
Anyone see a Datel Retro for sale anywhere?
paleh0rse said:
Anyone see a Datel Retro for sale anywhere?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here looking to buy one, seems out of stock every place i've look...
paleh0rse said:
There's a new USBhost kernel for CM7 in the dev forum that should open the door to ps3 and xbox controllers...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd love a working 360 controller on the NC. Even if it's just to see my wifes face when she sees me goofing around on it.
Alright. I'm looking for a good deal on a controller. For the most part I enjoy on screen controls, but I find it very difficult with emulators. It's almost impossible to play Super Mario World or Tecmo Bowl with on screen controls.
So these are my questions:
1. Do I need to be rooted no matter what? If so, no problem. I'll do it.
2. Is the PS3 controller the only way to go or are there cheaper options?
Thanks in advance.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
I have a Moga bluetooth controller. Certainly not the cheapest but it works well. Its also one of the only controllers made that gets official game dev support.
Thanks. That looks pretty good. Looks like I can get it for about $30 on ebay.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda premium
The Moga is cool but pricey and the software causes input lag.
I haven't used my moga in a few weeks from being busy. Honestly, the PS3 sixaxis controller is the only one that just works.
I also use my 360 controller but that requires a USB wireless dongle on top of the controller price. It works good but I don't like the big wireless dongle.
Each has their advantages. PS3 works the best and the cheapest option. The 360 wireless dongle runs off USB which works if Bluetooth sucks or doesn't have good Bluetooth Sixaxis support. I got my Moga for free during their Christmas promo and glad I didn't pay for it.
I haven't really been able to fully enjoy my moga from their bad software support creating bad lag. The only option is to use the Moga driver app which is 3rd party and doesn't enable the second stick. I tested this on several devices. I would be pissed if I paid $50 for this.
Controller is uncomfortable for long periods and the joysticks suck... they get slippery and hard to keep them extended using your thumb for extended periods (like moving right).
The moga is cool paired with the phone for quick plays but the Sixaxis would be the better buy for a tablet.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
I must be looking in the wrong places for a ps3 controller. Everywhere I look they're like $50.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
mjs2011 said:
Alright. I'm looking for a good deal on a controller. For the most part I enjoy on screen controls, but I find it very difficult with emulators. It's almost impossible to play Super Mario World or Tecmo Bowl with on screen controls.
So these are my questions:
1. Do I need to be rooted no matter what? If so, no problem. I'll do it.
2. Is the PS3 controller the only way to go or are there cheaper options?
Thanks in advance.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For it to work wirelessly, yes you need to be rooted for the sexaxis app to work correctly. The other option is to connect the controller via the OTG cable to the tablet, and it will work as a normal gamepad.
The PS3 is the best controller I have found to use for it. Just make sure to get a real PS3 controller; the fakes are either rubbish or don't work with SixAxis correctly.
mjs2011 said:
I must be looking in the wrong places for a ps3 controller. Everywhere I look they're like $50.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The real ones are that price, true. There are a lot of fake PS3 controllers out there, I've run into a few myself. If you see one for below $40, it's fake. Just go with the real thing from a good retailer or get it directly from a Sony store, as the fakes are getting more and more difficult to spot.
Thanks guys. Yeah, I might consider getting an OTG cable and trying out my XBOX360 controller first, and if that doesn't work out, then I'll dish out some cash for a wired PS3 controller.
I was rooted but I'm really trying to keep it unrooted at this point.
I went the 360 wired route for awhile, but got really tired of the wires. Got the PS3 controller off Amazon Prime for $40 shipped new. Worth it with the Sixasis Controller app. No cables, recognized as a native controller in alot of games, and you can program it for any game. And it is so much nicer to be wireless
dsManning said:
I went the 360 wired route for awhile, but got really tired of the wires. Got the PS3 controller off Amazon Prime for $40 shipped new. Worth it with the Sixasis Controller app. No cables, recognized as a native controller in alot of games, and you can program it for any game. And it is so much nicer to be wireless
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did the XBOX 360 controller work well with game emulators? That's still my biggest concern.
mjs2011 said:
Did the XBOX 360 controller work well with game emulators? That's still my biggest concern.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not on all. Some emulators don't even look for a controller or other input method when they start. The bonus of the Sixasis Controller app is that you can take a screenshot of any game and load that up in the Sixaxis Controller app. You can then map out the entire controller to physical locations on your screen. So when you tap "X" on the controller, it thinks you tapped on the screen wherever you assigned the "X" button.
All you have to do once you make a map is save it with a name, and before you open that game in your emulator, select that map from the Sixaxis app. BOOM, your own controller scheme.
Hurry!
SixAxis DualShock 3
I have the moga gamepad and am not a fan. I was really expecting button presses like the PS3 controller and it's not even close. The moga buttons are super clicky. I like the PS3 controller, but it's not as portable as I'd like. There is another company that's making an android gamepad called evolution controllers that I think I will give a try when there product drops
edit: Just checked evolutions site and they are up for order it guess. $80 bucks though which is completely over priced IMHO
I bought two of these
http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&id=110928097710
Cheap and work great. I play fifa, nfs, nes, snes, max Payne..
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Alright, so I'm breaking down and getting an official Sony PS3 controller today. Is there a good tutorial that you would recommend on pairing it to the N7? I heard that you have to take screenshots and configure buttons in accordance with them or something like that?
I wish someone would make a case with a d-pad and some buttons integrated. It's like my dream product. *sigh*
I've got a Retrolink NES controller -> USB adapter that works great on Android (used on my Thrive and now on my Nexus 7).
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000PDOTXG/ref=wms_ohs_product?ie=UTF8&psc=1
and a Mayflash dual-SNES one that doesn't work on Android:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002IXZ5DE/ref=wms_ohs_product?ie=UTF8&psc=1
I recommend the official PS3 controller + rooted + Sixaxis app + some sort of mount.
nyko playpad mini
I own a nyko playpad mini. It's a paperweight.
The software has never been updated and it's completely not working for touch controls.
Basically a lemon.
http://www.gioteck.com/support/playstation-3-support/controllers-ps3-support-2/sc-1/
Been looking @ Bluetooth controllers with stick offset, l like using xbox controller with USB adapter but want to go all wireless.looking at this controller for ps3 with offset stick,any other suggestions would be great.
..
Does the PS2 controller work?
We have lot of fake PS3 controller available in India so if i bought SixAxix Contoller app,
what if the fake controller isn't compatible???
Will there be chance for a Fake PS3 controller for being non-compatible??
Anybody using a fake controller and still got them compatible with Our awesome Note2!! :fingers-crossed:
Will you guys suggest me to go for an original one??
I was unaware of the extent of counterfeit controllers when I was purchasing a couple a few years back. You wont be superficially be able to differentiate between the two. Only on close inspection you could tell them apart.
So, it happened that both the controllers I bought were fake. And at that time the Sixaxis App did not support fake controllers and so I couldnt do anything with them.
But a few updates back they have started supporting few of the fake controllers (there are many types,different companies and ICs).
TL;DR Yes, fake controllers work. But I would any day prefer the original.
Bunny2rock said:
We have lot of fake PS3 controller available in India so if i bought SixAxix Contoller app,
what if the fake controller isn't compatible???
Will there be chance for a Fake PS3 controller for being non-compatible??
Anybody using a fake controller and still got them compatible with Our awesome Note2!! :fingers-crossed:
Will you guys suggest me to go for an original one??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It really shouldn't make a difference at all.
As long as you change the Mac / bluetooth address of any controller then it will communicate properly (it should anyway).
I know the Sixaxis app in the Play Store said that only official controllers would work when I bought the app, but that was over 2 years ago. I'm assuming that's changed though, based on the previous replys in this thread. Either way, if given the option I'd much rather pay the extra money and get an official controller. If you already have a knock off, then let us know how it goes for you.
If you see a new in box PS3 controller on ebay for under $30, then it's a knock off. Like previously stated, some of the knock off controllers look almost identical. Most on ebay that are a knock off will say so in the description, but I've seen some that don't say whether they are or not. You just have to base your decision on the appearance and/or price.
SwiftKey'ed from my White Sprint Note 2 using XDA Premium
Nice to hear from you guys!! One last question will all the fake PS3 Controller work with Sixaxis app???
Brands like Amigo, Red, and replica of PS3 controllers?
Did anyone bought them and is using it on Our Note2
Sadly due to how android works wiimotes are a no-go. However will Xbox or ps3 controllers work? Are there any you can clamp onto the tablet?
Goggles2114 said:
Sadly due to how android works wiimotes are a no-go. However will Xbox or ps3 controllers work? Are there any you can clamp onto the tablet?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ps3 doesn't work wireless.
best option is a cheap blue tooth controller from game stop. those work just fine.
gamepad
check these out i have two they work great and they cost half the cost of a xbox or ps controller
it wouldnt let me post a link but google green throttle controllers..
whiles its on the pricey side @ $68.90 for just the controller, or $88.90 for the pro bundle (controller plus all accessories). I got the recently released Phonejoy and been doing great with it.....for emulators and Dead Trigger 1, it doesnt seem to want to work for other games that have moga support (The makers of phonejoy said that if a game uses moga then the controller would work), though that could just be the nook lol.
Hurry MOGA Mobile Gaming System for Android 2.3+ is $12 on clearance at Toys R Us! Ask to scan if not listed as a clearance item.
I'm on kitkat 11 4.4.4. Had the hardest time finding a controller that works with 4.4. Had to order a USB coupler and a csr4 BT adapter. Total on Amazon was $20. Haven't tried the ps3 controller but there are issues with the wiimote. It connects but my emulators won't accept it. On the other hand, I have this USB to gamepad converter. Works perfectly with my ps1 and GameCube controllers. I'd rather lose the wires but it's not a big deal.
Let's chat about the Samsung Gamepad ($79.99)
http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/cell-phones-accessories/EI-GP20HNBESTA
You can get a $30 discount on the Gamepad when buying with the Gear VR from Samsung. Enter coupon code STAVR1 at checkout to receive $30 off Samsung Gamepad with purchase of Samsung Gear VR Innovator Edition.
So anyone with the Gamepad, is it really necessary? I didn't order one with my Gear VR and wondering if it will actually be much use.
I was considering the samsung gamepad for a while.... But it seems like it might have some compatibility issues with emulators, and it seems lacking a bit in terms of button placement / d-pad.
I was going to get a PS3 controller with clips, but the Note 4 didn't work with it, at least not reliably. So I sent that back.
I settled on the the Moga Hero Power instead, its $35 on amazon, I picked mine up for ~40 at target. It has two modes, legacy and current mode so it is pretty much 100% compatibile with everything, and it doubles as a phone charger in a pinch. I have really enjoyed mine; using it with PPSSPP and other games and emulators, 100% no issues. Its a little bit clicky and loud compared to some console controllers, but it feels extremely accurate.
cbutters said:
I settled on the the Moga Hero Power instead, its $35 on amazon, I picked mine up for ~40 at target. It has two modes, legacy and current mode so it is pretty much 100% compatibile with everything, and it doubles as a phone charger in a pinch. I have really enjoyed mine; using it with PPSSPP and other games and emulators, 100% no issues. Its a little bit clicky and loud compared to some console controllers, but it feels extremely accurate.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for sharing this. I would roll over to Target but I don't want to miss delivery of the Gear VR . . . oh well.
Are the MOGA controllers confirmed working with the Gear VR? Someone with their unit already should test the compatibility.
m3ha said:
Are the MOGA controllers confirmed working with the Gear VR? Someone with their unit already should test the compatibility.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly. Hopefully, the Samsung gamepad isn't the only one that works with the VR
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N910A using XDA Free mobile app
MOGA
So far it seems moga pocket does not work for vr content.
Moga works ... sort of.
dunndada said:
So far it seems moga pocket does not work for vr content.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have ordered a samsung gamepad from ebay for 40 bucks, waiting to see what the difference is. As for the Moga, I have the new Pro model and in its stock for I've heard it does not work. But since I am rooted I use the Moga VK
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=ca.sandstorm.mogaime.gui
With this app and the rooted function of selecting a keyboard to be the gamepad I have had good results with the Gear VR. So far the only app that I have found trouble with is the BLUEVR (underwater swimming) the controller works for forward, backward, left, right but the four buttons YXBA don't respond. May just need to be re-mapped but it works. Also with the moga and this app I can play all of my emulators and other non supported games. The Moga universal driver works also but I have better luck with the VK app. I will post an update to give feedback on the samsung controller.
FYI, stick to a stock ROM, I went to a custom superstockrom and now the VR wont work.
I have the Samsung gamepad and the buttons are unresponsive, the left "joypad" clicks and doesn't move smoothly, and I have to switch it off and on again, sometimes 10+ times to get the bluetooth to connect with my phone. And I've never been able to get it to connect while in VR. I always have to switch it on and get it to connect from the bluetooth screen first. If I switch the controller on while in VR I get a "Bluetooth connected" / "Bluetooth disconnected" message every 5 seconds.
I gotta say, it's the worst Samsung device I've ever owned.
Still, I CAN play games it with.
I use my ps3 controller with sixaxis and if works perfectly
Moga pro w/ ab
Ps3 controller using sixaxis as well and works great with vr
UPDATE
Received my samsung controller today and personally I dislike the form factor compared to the Moga or even the PS3. The left thumb stick is stick and grinds a bit, as do the other but the left is the worst. The buttons feel like cheap clicker style buttons, With all of that the controller is nice in function with the VR, I may have been due to a bad button map on the Moga but the VR is more responsive to the samsung controller, also something to be said for the built in storage space in the VR case, the Samsung controller fits perfect. So at this point I would say its a toss up. Either way you go you are going to have some sort of issues be it feel or compatibility. Maybe once the Innovator comes off the box it will have better support for other controls. Hope this helped some.
I bought a samsung gamepad when I got my tab pro 8.4 and hated it.
I got this from ebay and in my opinion it's much much better and works well with vr.
http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&id=281489880129&alt=web
Sent from my SM-T320 using XDA Free mobile app
Any chance you have a name for this controller, no shipping to US on that sale. I would be interested to try it for that price.
I bought a Red Samurai controller from Gamestop for $13 and it works fine.
jarazmek said:
Any chance you have a name for this controller, no shipping to US on that sale. I would be interested to try it for that price.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a terios T-3 I tried it with the new games released yesterday and works perfectly.
Sent from my SM-N910F using XDA Free mobile app
My Gamepad experience
OK, I was a bit peeved at having to buy the bundled Gamepad version of the Gear VR as the solo version was out of stock. However, now I have it I am glad I did go for the version with the Gamepad.
Firstly there a few games that you can only play with the Gamepad, "Dread Halls" for example and secondly navigating the menu system is more comfortable with it. The controls needed for the VR games are quite simplistic, so the Gamepad works well. You also get the bonus of using the Gamepad with about 45 fully compatible phone games on the Samsung Console Store and it works with many others elsewhere.
Considering the Gamepad in the UK costs about £60 you are getting it for half that price with the bundle.
So all in all it's hard not to recommend.
.
http://www.gamestop.com/android/accessories/gamestick-controller/109153
Works Perfectly.
I've been using my PS4 controller over BT. Works pretty well.
I am satisfied with the Samsung Gamepad, I use the emulator PPSSPP with it.