Has anybody tried the Android P DP4 GSI on the Xiaomi Mi 8/ Mi 8 SE?
Couldn't get the treble P GSI to boot on my Mi 8 SE but I managed to get the Oreo GSI running (doesn't have notch support though).
PravAndroidGeek said:
Has anybody tried the Android P DP4 GSI on the Xiaomi Mi 8/ Mi 8 SE?
Couldn't get the treble P GSI to boot on my Mi 8 SE but I managed to get the Oreo GSI running (doesn't have notch support though).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which GSI booted on your SE?
Other Mi8 SE users reported that every GSI they flashes resulted in a bootloop.
Can you also mention the last MIUI version you had when you flashed a GSI?
As for P, you tried the semi-GSI, right?
Some people said that they had to fix things themselves for the image to boot but did you try flashing Magisk or setting Selinux to permissive? There should be a "permissiver" zip on the P gsi thread if I'm not mistaken.
dm-verity and selinux could cause a bootloop.
The Marionette said:
Which GSI booted on your SE?
Other Mi8 SE users reported that every GSI they flashes resulted in a bootloop.
Can you also mention the last MIUI version you had when you flashed a GSI?
As for P, you tried the semi-GSI, right?
Some people said that they had to fix things themselves for the image to boot but did you try flashing Magisk or setting Selinux to permissive? There should be a "permissiver" zip on the P gsi thread if I'm not mistaken.
dm-verity and selinux could cause a bootloop.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got my Mi8 SE running MIUI 9 Chinese.
Unlocked the bootloader and flashed the latest Xiaomi.EU MIUI 10 ROM as a base and then tried both: GSI for phh-Treble AOSP and Resurrection Remix phh-Treble. Both worked surprisingly well, the notch being detected was the main issue. I followed this guide on xda.
Yes it was the P semi-GSI that resulted in a bootloop. Might try the permissiver zip.
PravAndroidGeek said:
Got my Mi8 SE running MIUI 9 Chinese.
Unlocked the bootloader and flashed the latest Xiaomi.EU MIUI 10 ROM as a base and then tried both: GSI for phh-Treble AOSP and Resurrection Remix phh-Treble. Both worked surprisingly well, the notch being detected was the main issue. I followed this guide on xda.
Yes it was the P semi-GSI that resulted in a bootloop. Might try the permissiver zip.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tell us how it works out [emoji846]
Skickat från min MI 8 via Tapatalk
PravAndroidGeek said:
Got my Mi8 SE running MIUI 9 Chinese.
Unlocked the bootloader and flashed the latest Xiaomi.EU MIUI 10 ROM as a base and then tried both: GSI for phh-Treble AOSP and Resurrection Remix phh-Treble. Both worked surprisingly well, the notch being detected was the main issue. I followed this guide on xda.
Yes it was the P semi-GSI that resulted in a bootloop. Might try the permissiver zip.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Been wanting to get the 8 se, but I've been waiting to hear if phh-treble and other GSIs work before buying. other than notch problems are there any other major issues? Once P is released and phh-treble is updated to android 9 the notch won't be a problem anymore due to AOSP notch support.
Running lineage GSI on SE too without issues (except some full screen apps which do not support notch). The minimum brightness is a bit high.
Ydraulikos said:
Running lineage GSI on SE too without issues (except some full screen apps which do not support notch). The minimum brightness is a bit high.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you point me to a guide to run Lineage os or RR on out SE?
I am familiar in flashing custom for many years but i am new to treble and just heard about it.
Unlock your bootloader, flash a TWRP and format your data partition. Then flash and try to boot the latest xiaomi.eu rom. If you succeed, format /data /system /cache and flash /system with an arm64 GSI for A only devices such as https://github.com/phhusson/treble_...d/lineage-v21/system-arm64-aonly-gapps-su.img
Ydraulikos said:
Unlock your bootloader, flash a TWRP and format your data partition. Then flash and try to boot the latest xiaomi.eu rom. If you succeed, format /data /system /cache and flash /system with an arm64 GSI for A only devices such as https://github.com/phhusson/treble_...d/lineage-v21/system-arm64-aonly-gapps-su.img
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok, i am running xiaomi.eu rom so thats allready done.
The img i download is allready the lineage os, what i see
And is there a completely different forum/site where just. only trebel based custom roms are stored and discussed.
Is it gapps included, because normally it has to be flashed separtly.
Can you just format and go back to any miui rom, and when wanted to trebel based, just flash img file in /system again
Sorry for all the questions
marcel112 said:
ok, i am running xiaomi.eu rom so thats allready done.
The img i download is allready the lineage os, what i see
And is there a completely different forum/site where just. only trebel based custom roms are stored and discussed.
Is it gapps included, because normally it has to be flashed separtly.
Can you just format and go back to any miui rom, and when wanted to trebel based, just flash img file in /system again
Sorry for all the questions
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gapps are included in the above link. You don't need to flash anything else. And yes you can always flash the stock rom. Just remember to erase /data when you change between MIUI & AOSP based ROMs.
Ydraulikos said:
Gapps are included in the above link. You don't need to flash anything else. And yes you can always flash the stock rom. Just remember to erase /data when you change between MIUI & AOSP based ROMs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok, so its like normal business.
Normally when i switch between custom i allways full wipe
/dalvik
/data
/cache
/system
As long as format data was once, i dont have problem..
Can you provide links for more like RR for SE?
I didnt knew there was development at all for SE on custom roms
EDIT: https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...opment/resurrection-remix-phh-treble-t3767688
this one is for RR, and if i am correct you linked me to the first in the V5 section, so the xiaomi mi 8 se is a ARM64 A-only device?
But what is the difference between gapps and vanilla
marcel112 said:
ok, so its like normal business.
Normally when i switch between custom i allways full wipe
/dalvik
/data
/cache
/system
As long as format data was once, i dont have problem..
Can you provide links for more like RR for SE?
I didnt knew there was development at all for SE on custom roms
EDIT: https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...opment/resurrection-remix-phh-treble-t3767688
this one is for RR, and if i am correct you linked me to the first in the V5 section, so the xiaomi mi 8 se is a ARM64 A-only device?
But what is the difference between gapps and vanilla
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gapps include google services, vanilla does not.
Mi 8/SE are ARM64 A-only devices. You can try flashing any treble based rom with a high chance to operate normally. With a decent treble implementation, there is no need for custom rom development. The device specific blobs are moved to a separate partition and are provided by vendor.
Ydraulikos said:
Running lineage GSI on SE too without issues (except some full screen apps which do not support notch). The minimum brightness is a bit high.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does the system detect the notch on lineage?
Ydraulikos said:
Gapps include google services, vanilla does not.
Mi 8/SE are ARM64 A-only devices. You can try flashing any treble based rom with a high chance to operate normally. With a decent treble implementation, there is no need for custom rom development. The device specific blobs are moved to a separate partition and are provided by vendor.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i did full wipe,
after that i tried to install image, but as what do i need to flash this?
system image
boot
recovery
vendor image
firmware
persist
splash
logo
etc etc?
i choose system image, but after flash ( was quick ) i get no OS?
edit: so i can flash anyone off this page, as long as i use arm64 Aonly for my Mi 8 SE?
edit 2: got it..
install is real fast, and phone is very quick
after trying treble...
i tried to go back to miui backup..
It boots fine, but i cant get past pin code?
I know 100% its the right code, does it have to do with trying treble?
PravAndroidGeek said:
Has anybody tried the Android P DP4 GSI on the Xiaomi Mi 8/ Mi 8 SE?
Couldn't get the treble P GSI to boot on my Mi 8 SE but I managed to get the Oreo GSI running (doesn't have notch support though).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MI8 is also same.
P GSI (can't boot)
RR oreo rom (all working)
- last MIUI verion : XIAOMI.EU 8.7.19 version.
jectsin said:
MI8 is also same.
P GSI (can't boot)
RR oreo rom (all working)
- last MIUI verion : XIAOMI.EU 8.7.19 version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Everything works on RR? How is the camera?
_katho_ said:
Everything works on RR? How is the camera?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
work. but bad quality
jectsin said:
work. but bad quality
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes and notch is not detected for me
marcel112 said:
yes and notch is not detected for me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Notches are "expected" on AOSP only with P and newer Android versions.
It probably can be modded but since P is around the corner, it might not be worth it.
The Marionette said:
Notches are "expected" on AOSP only with P and newer Android versions.
It probably can be modded but since P is around the corner, it might not be worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i know this is not miui forum, but i made twrp backup..
Why cant i unlock after restoring after flashing Treble based roms ?
I tried yesterday 3 trebles and full wiped, and restored nandroid of miui 10.
All looks good, but after boot up, i cant get past pincode( i know its right code 110% )
looking for pixel experience or lineage os
husseen147 said:
looking for pixel experience or lineage os
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only GSI roms at the moment.
i try to downgrade but i don't know how to install gsi rom useing me flash need to back to stock miui I'm on eu rom
husseen147 said:
i try to downgrade but i don't know how to install gsi rom useing me flash need to back to stock miui I'm on eu rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
First you need to unlock the bootloader
https://c.mi.com/thread-1857937-1-1.html
https://en.miui.com/unlock/index.html
But if you have a Xiaomi EU rom it's already done so use:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/flash-tool-guide-use-xiaomi-flash-tool.4262425/
GSI rom
https://forum.xda-developers.com/f/xiaomi-11t-pro.12447/?prefix_id=37
hey guys, today I want to try some GSI, is there any port of any android-based os? like ColorOS, OneUI or other?
any other rom from some other manufacturer is fine, which is not MIUI obv hahaha
Nippon gsi ha e a lot of os port, but all i tried didnt boot. You can try do a port by yourself with ergan tool
wetito said:
Nippon gsi ha e a lot of os port, but all i tried didnt boot. You can try do a port by yourself with ergan tool
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ahh, so nippon gsi are supported? i read on another thread on this forum that aren't
Hypo_Wolf said:
ahh, so nippon gsi are supported? i read on another thread on this forum that aren't
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no, not at all. even if nippon marks as "for MTK", it wont boot. this could be because of our soc and maybe MIUI vendor
Hypo_Wolf said:
ahh, so nippon gsi are supported? i read on another thread on this forum that aren't
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i wrote "all nippon gsi i tried DID NOT boot", but u could try to port by yourself
GitHub - erfanoabdi/ErfanGSIs: Just a tool to make GSI out of firmware from any phone
Just a tool to make GSI out of firmware from any phone - GitHub - erfanoabdi/ErfanGSIs: Just a tool to make GSI out of firmware from any phone
github.com
Has S21U any treble / GSI rom yet ?
ounila said:
Has S21U any treble / GSI rom yet ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you misunderstand the point of Trebleized devices and GSIs.
A GSI, or Generic System Image, is a system image designed to be used with any device, usually with the original kernel.
Project Treble is the idea behind "modular" software such as GSIs and GKIs (generic kernel images), where the "product specific" code is divorced from the kernel and system code and kept in its own partition.
So, to answer your question, I believe the S21U is Treble enabled, which means you can use any GSI.
thanks for reply.
I understand the subject well since i installed the GSI based roms for xiaomi phones (curtana. mojito . vayu . alioth ...) So, my real question is: Why there is no (pixel xperience . evolution. arrowOS ....) roms yet ?
ounila said:
thanks for reply.
I understand the subject well since i installed the GSI based roms for xiaomi phones (curtana. mojito . vayu . alioth ...) So, my real question is: Why there is no (pixel xperience . evolution. arrowOS ....) roms yet ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I dont understand this question. Why should be a gsi device specific thread..?
Just Google PHHUSSEN treble experimentions or click this Link. This list is almost daily updated with much of gsi roms like PE or Evo.
Look for haridhayal11's gsi project for exynos 2100, I can't remember if he posted here before but he's the one that enabled us to use GSI on S21s with good stability.