Related
After flashing magisk 13.2
System app away ask for root access for one time when startup
And I find the system app will ask for root access again if I change the setting of selinux
I'm getting the exact same thing on my device, left everything default and tried factory reset and it keeps happening , did you find any solution for this?
Most likely an RR bug. I deny it once and it never asks again unless I wipe Magisk manager data.
paed808 said:
Most likely an RR bug. I deny it once and it never asks again unless I wipe Magisk manager data.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
At first I was certain it was only one system app that's trying to gain root access so I wasted about an hour googling it trying to find a solution but after I wiped Magisk manager I found out it will ask for random system apps upon reboot, I couldn't find anything about this issue except this post, the weird thing that all of them is issuing setenforce 1 and on all of them list the FM radio app on their data usage for some reason.
Also I wanna avoid giving everything root access so I hope I can find a solution for this because I like RR and I don't want to switch to another rom.
~Qwerty said:
At first I was certain it was only one system app that's trying to gain root access so I wasted about an hour googling it trying to find a solution but after I wiped Magisk manager I found out it will ask for random system apps upon reboot, I couldn't find anything about this issue except this post, the weird thing that all of them is issuing setenforce 1 and on all of them list the FM radio app on their data usage for some reason.
Also I wanna avoid giving everything root access so I hope I can find a solution for this because I like RR and I don't want to switch to another rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try denying it instead of granting it. Also, I think the bug is that it's the Settings app that's doing it (because of the SELinux switch) but the OS mistakes it as another system app, maybe they share the same system stuff) Idk, I'm not a dev. Sometimes when I monitor network activity anything the kernel does is showed up as FM Radio. If this doesn't make sense, I'm tired lol.
Thanks for answering, It's driving me crazy because I'm the type of guy that has to know what causing it but I've spent too much time on this already and this seems the only post I can find on this subject,maybe I need to master my Google fu or maybe it's rare because I'm pretty sure I didn't get this on my previous flash...
Anyway, I just saw that Lineage OS has finally been released officially for the redmi note 4 so I'm gonna give it a try, but because RR is mostly based on LOS I hope I'm not gonna get the same results.
Update: I've clean flashed the latest nightly of LinageOS ,GApps and Magisk(it doesn't come bundled) and so far I'm not getting strange root requests from system apps so like you said looks like it's a RR related bug, I'll try clean flashing RR again just to see if it will fix this, if not I will probably stick with LOS.
Did any of you guys enable the "suspend actions" in RR configuration settings?
I first had this happen a couple months ago and related it to the suspend actions. Makes sense right, since your radio is trying to switch itself to 2g?
Omfg. Been looking for this post everywhere, dang and not much topic on it.. ):
zerolam said:
After flashing magisk 13.2
System app away ask for root access for one time when startup
And I find the system app will ask for root access again if I change the setting of selinux
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If u update your Magisk version now, its works or not ?
Rom said:
If u update your Magisk version now, its works or not ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No it doesn't.. I disabled the activity for the switch using my Android tools though, seems it did the trick.
What I did:
- Wipe all (clean install).
- Flash latest Official MoKee ROM (Nougat).
- Flash latest GApps.
- Flash latest Magisk.
- Reboot.
After finished the Wizard Setup and before doing anything, my phone got very laggy, open menu, open Settings, etc.
Then I clean install again like the steps above, but this time using SuperSU, and everything normal, so I stick with SuperSU for now.
My questions, what is the cause of the lags? Is it known bug in Magisk, the ROM itself (not compatible), or GApps? I also heard ResurrectionRemix had the same problem after installing Magisk, so many people revert back to SuperSU.
Thanks,
I have Resurrectionremix and Magisk 14.3
No any lag on my phone.
Tapatalk - Xiaomi Mi6
You need to list what modules you're using.
BIGWORM said:
You need to list what modules you're using.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I only flash the ROM, GApps and Magisk without any additional flashable ZIPs.
Honestly that doesn't sound like Magisk. I've ran Magisk on literally probably 20 ROMs between Angler and Pixel XL and never Magisk caused lag... Did u try a different rom? Just curious, or maybe it's some incompatibility with that specific rom and magisk
yung40oz84 said:
Honestly that doesn't sound like Magisk. I've ran Magisk on literally probably 20 ROMs between Angler and Pixel XL and never Magisk caused lag... Did u try a different rom? Just curious, or maybe it's some incompatibility with that specific rom and magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried several ROMs that based on LOS and all same, maybe it's caused by LOS base that used in those ROMs. And since you say so, probably it's not an issue in Magisk, but the ROM itself.
I'll try Magisk again later when some ROM's builds available for my device.
-
I think my questions has been answered (it's appear not issue in Magisk side) and this thread can be closed.
irfanfadilah said:
I tried several ROMs that based on LOS and all same, maybe it's caused by LOS base that used in those ROMs. And since you say so, probably it's not an issue in Magisk, but the ROM itself.
I'll try Magisk again later when some ROM's builds available for my device.
-
I think my questions has been answered (it's appear not issue in Magisk side) and this thread can be closed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ya I was gonna say cause I use all AOSP and CAF based
I had this issue with Lineage 14.1 and AEX before.
Now I don't have this issue anymore.
What I do is:
- Wipe everything
- Install ROM
- Install GApps
- Reboot and finish Setup Wizard (then I install some or all apps that I use)
- Reboot to TWRP and flash Magisk.
The first time I reboot after flashing Magisk it's still a little slower than normal. Then I reboot one more time and never faced this anymore.
Now I do this everytime I make a clean install and everytime it works.
Danilo-Sanchez said:
I had this issue with Lineage 14.1 and AEX before.
Now I don't have this issue anymore.
What I do is:
- Wipe everything
- Install ROM
- Install GApps
- Reboot and finish Setup Wizard (then I install some or all apps that I use)
- Reboot to TWRP and flash Magisk.
The first time I reboot after flashing Magisk it's still a little slower than normal. Then I reboot one more time and never faced this anymore.
Now I do this everytime I make a clean install and everytime it works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So don't flash Magisk along with the ROM?
Instead finish Wizard Setup first and back to TWRP to flash Magisk. I'll try this if the issue still persist. Many Thanks
irfanfadilah said:
So don't flash Magisk along with the ROM?
Instead finish Wizard Setup first and back to TWRP to flash Magisk. I'll try this if the issue still persist. Many Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes.
Try it and let me know if this also fix the problem for you.
Yes, Magisk is the thing that's causing lag and stutter. My Nexus 5X is also barely responding to any commands if I flash Magisk right after a ROM clean installation. If you flash only the ROM, then you can finish setting up the device without much stutter or hiccups in performance.
If, after a clean installation (or after installing Magisk - didn't try this though) you use the phone without Magisk for a bit, maybe install some apps, etc, you'll see that everything is nice and smooth.
Now, you can check the smoothness without Magisk and with Magisk installed like this:
- Without Magisk: Update 'Google App' to the latest version then try to open the side panel from the latest Pixel Launcher. You'll see that opening/closing it is nice and smooth, and scrolling up and down is also smooth.
- With Magisk installed (without using any modules): The moment the phone turns on, at first, things might seem OK. First wait for the phone to settle down after the reboot for a few minutes. Then try opening the side panel. You'll see some stutter while dragging that panel to the right, maybe not huge, but it's there. Scrolling up and down is also stuttery. At first I thought it was because of the latest version of Google App, or the new cards design, or even the images in there, but that wasn't the issue. Then I thought maybe the launcher was somehow influencing Google App's performance, but that wasn't either the issue.
AND it was like I completely forgot about SuperSU and didn't even think of trying it in order to see how things were.
I even rebased my ROM in the hope that I'd find the culprit, and still nothing. Nothing weird appeared in any logs, which was so annoying. And a few hours ago, after finishing up cleaning up my sources (for other reasons), I compiled a fresh new build, and it crossed my mind to try SuperSU, just for the hell of it, and BOOM ! No more lag and stutter. The phone is snappy and responsive again.
I'll try to contact the dude behind Magisk and see what he has to say, or leave a comment in his thread.
The thing is, those with more recent phones, like the Pixels or any other phones than are more powerful than mine, might not notice what I described above, but there should be some stutter there, no matter how small, maybe in other scenarios as well.
The thing is, Magisk kinda slowly took the place of Xposed, at least that's what it looks like to me, and I personally don't like that but that's how things are, I suppose. All those modules or at least one of them WILL cause issues sooner or later, just like on Xposed.
But in the end, yes, it's Magisk what's destroying your phone's performance and nothing else. So if you're not really in the need to have your phone pass SafetyNet, and want to have your phone snappy and lag-free, use SuperSU, at least until things get better on Magisk.
dragos281993 said:
Yes, Magisk is the thing that's causing lag and stutter. My Nexus 5X is also barely responding to any commands if I flash Magisk right after a ROM clean installation. If you flash only the ROM, then you can finish setting up the device without much stutter or hiccups in performance.
If, after a clean installation (or after installing Magisk - didn't try this though) you use the phone without Magisk for a bit, maybe install some apps, etc, you'll see that everything is nice and smooth.
Now, you can check the smoothness without Magisk and with Magisk installed like this:
- Without Magisk: Update 'Google App' to the latest version then try to open the side panel from the latest Pixel Launcher. You'll see that opening/closing it is nice and smooth, and scrolling up and down is also smooth.
- With Magisk installed (without using any modules): The moment the phone turns on, at first, things might seem OK. First wait for the phone to settle down after the reboot for a few minutes. Then try opening the side panel. You'll see some stutter while dragging that panel to the right, maybe not huge, but it's there. Scrolling up and down is also stuttery. At first I thought it was because of the latest version of Google App, or the new cards design, or even the images in there, but that wasn't the issue. Then I thought maybe the launcher was somehow influencing Google App's performance, but that wasn't either the issue.
AND it was like I completely forgot about SuperSU and didn't even think of trying it in order to see how things were.
I even rebased my ROM in the hope that I'd find the culprit, and still nothing. Nothing weird appeared in any logs, which was so annoying. And a few hours ago, after finishing up cleaning up my sources (for other reasons), I compiled a fresh new build, and it crossed my mind to try SuperSU, just for the hell of it, and BOOM ! No more lag and stutter. The phone is snappy and responsive again.
I'll try to contact the dude behind Magisk and see what he has to say, or leave a comment in his thread.
The thing is, those with more recent phones, like the Pixels or any other phones than are more powerful than mine, might not notice what I described above, but there should be some stutter there, no matter how small, maybe in other scenarios as well.
The thing is, Magisk kinda slowly took the place of Xposed, at least that's what it looks like to me, and I personally don't like that but that's how things are, I suppose. All those modules or at least one of them WILL cause issues sooner or later, just like on Xposed.
But in the end, yes, it's Magisk what's destroying your phone's performance and nothing else. So if you're not really in the need to have your phone pass SafetyNet, and want to have your phone snappy and lag-free, use SuperSU, at least until things get better on Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm glad I'm not the only one experienced this issue, that's mean it's not entirely user fault. Maybe you're right, on more high-spec phones they won't really notice the lags/stutters.
Looking forward to the news/updates regarding this issue.
irfanfadilah said:
So don't flash Magisk along with the ROM?
Instead finish Wizard Setup first and back to TWRP to flash Magisk. I'll try this if the issue still persist. Many Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't mean to necrobump, but did it work? I have an LG G4 (H815) and suffered the same issue. Like you, I only flashed magisk right after flashing the ROM (LG nougat).
Thanks
Camandros said:
I don't mean to necrobump, but did it work? I have an LG G4 (H815) and suffered the same issue. Like you, I only flashed magisk right after flashing the ROM (LG nougat).
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I haven't got the chance to try it.
Currently I'm using SuperSU to root my device.
I tried installing magisk on my currently in use ROM, i.e., a long time after flashing it, and although it got less laggy, there still was a heavy lag impact in some applications. Maybe it has less impact on lineage or on lighter ROMs? I'm using official LG nougat.
I'm using Mi 6 in Xiaomi.eu rom
YES, magisk causing laggy.
Same here
Mi5, tested on MIUI 9 and 10
Without Magisk everything was great and after flashing Magisk, the phone got laggy!
I have the same problem with my LG G6
interesting, first I thought that emmc will be broken. because the problem is the same (lag). but after i replace emmc, all back is fine. I just think emmc is broken because it is often flashing rom.
ChessPiece said:
What I did:
- Wipe all (clean install).
- Flash latest Official MoKee ROM (Nougat).
- Flash latest GApps.
- Flash latest Magisk.
- Reboot.
After finished the Wizard Setup and before doing anything, my phone got very laggy, open menu, open Settings, etc.
Then I clean install again like the steps above, but this time using SuperSU, and everything normal, so I stick with SuperSU for now.
My questions, what is the cause of the lags? Is it known bug in Magisk, the ROM itself (not compatible), or GApps? I also heard ResurrectionRemix had the same problem after installing Magisk, so many people revert back to SuperSU.
Thanks,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what magisk version 16.0 or beta? magisk can't make the phone lag but kernel or something in ROM may interrupt try to change kernel or flash the lastest Gapps
I've an OP3T, and I mostly flash 8.1 ROMs. Since V15 came out, I've been having Module issues, they work sometimes and after a reboot, they disappear and they don't work. I've tried flash Magisk over and over again, and also clean flashing different ROMs. Modules do not work, although Root works.
Modules are;
AR stickers Calib files,
IYTBP
V4A for V15
Xposed V90-Beta1
I've also tried both ways of installing the Modules, from Recovery and from the MM app. Nothing works.
thes3usa said:
I've an OP3T, and I mostly flash 8.1 ROMs. Since V15 came out, I've been having Module issues, they work sometimes and after a reboot, they disappear and they don't work. I've tried flash Magisk over and over again, and also clean flashing different ROMs. Modules do not work, although Root works.
Modules are;
AR stickers Calib files,
IYTBP
V4A for V15
Xposed V90-Beta1
I've also tried both ways of installing the Modules, from Recovery and from the MM app. Nothing works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's an issue with op3t and custom roms. Lots of them, like Omni, etc. No one has posted useful logs or proper bug reports. Just a bunch of posts like this scattered everywhere. Post it in the proper magisk development thread with all logs and relevant info and it may get solved. There are enough ppl having the issue, just not enough info.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/beta-magisk-v13-0-0980cb6-t3618589/post75212442
madbat99 said:
It's an issue with op3t and custom roms. Lots of them, like Omni, etc. No one has posted useful logs or proper bug reports. Just a bunch of posts like this scattered everywhere. Post it in the proper magisk development thread with all logs and relevant info and it may get solved. There are enough ppl having the issue, just not enough info.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/beta-magisk-v13-0-0980cb6-t3618589/post75212442
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually I've found out what the issue is. It's the OP3/T Calibration CAD Files Module, which somehow not allowing my other modules to be run on boot. Not installing it worked for other modules.
P.S: I checked my Logs before posting, they didn't show anything out of the ordinary. My modules are supposed to be working as needed, but don't work.
Can you fill me in on how to get the logs?
I did figure out the problem- since Magisk didn't actually update when I tapped to update it, the modules available to install were under the "Downloads" section (found in the drop down menu in top left), instead of the "Modules" section". Before I re-flashed this last time, there was an icon bar at the bottom of Magisk with icons to tap on.
Easy enough of a fix, but I would still like to know which logs to post and how to get them.
BUT, Magisk is not actually updating for me this time around (the app looks the same after updating as it did before and the time before this the whole theme and layout changed)... There is still that issue. I HAVE successfully gained root, though, sp I'm content for now but would like to figure out WHY it isn't actually updating when I try to update it.
I'm trying to use this app: play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=br.com.banrisul
I've added to the hiding list and enable core only mode, it still closes at startup after saying my phone is either root or running a modified system. I've tested with rootbeercheck and it doesn't detect root in any of its tests.
i.imgur.com/60Zs5IH.png
No issues opening the app here... That means Magisk is perfectly capable of hiding from it, but you might have something else in your setup that triggers it.
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Didgeridoohan said:
No issues opening the app here... That means Magisk is perfectly capable of hiding from it, but you might have something else in your setup that triggers it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
but what exactly would trigger it? The link talks mostly about methods to hide magisk, I didn't find anything about what to do if magisk is working but the check fails. I've uninstalled titaniumbackup and rootbrowser. I've disable adb and developer options, I've deleted any folder or downloaded file related to magisk or those apps.
I'm running lineageos, would that be it? How would I go about it?
Could be any number of things... Your ROM might be one of them (more details about that?). It's pretty much impossible for me to do anything else but make educated guesses. The only thing I can say with relative certainty is that it shouldn't have anything to do with Magisk (since I can hide from the app just fine when testing).
You do pass SafetyNet, right? Could be that this is one of those apps that actually use SN.
Didgeridoohan said:
Could be any number of things... Your ROM might be one of them (more details about that?). It's pretty much impossible for me to do anything else but make educated guesses. The only thing I can say with relative certainty is that it shouldn't have anything to do with Magisk (since I can hide from the app just fine when testing).
You do pass SafetyNet, right? Could be that this is one of those apps that actually use SN.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It passes both checks.
I am running lineage OS 14.1 (Android 7.1.2) on a moto g4.
My main guess is that it's detecting something about your ROM. LOS is well known enough for apps to look for certain properties of it.
Didgeridoohan said:
My main guess is that it's detecting something about your ROM. LOS is well known enough for apps to look for certain properties of it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, after searching around a bit more I found about why. I completely forgot that I had flashed supersu on my phone before flashing magisk. So I guess that's what the app was freaking out about. So I flashed a supersu removal and reflashed my ROM, now the app is working normally
Thanks for the help!
Same problem
Hello everyone
After the last update of my banking app and wallet too
Both apps stopped starting due tl root device detection
While it was working well yesterday
I just updat apps to the last version
I think these app's developers find a way to detect magisk
Of course im hiding and randomly renaming it
hammohammo said:
Hello everyone
After the last update of my banking app and wallet too
Both apps stopped starting due tl root device detection
While it was working well yesterday
I just updat apps to the last version
I think these app's developers find a way to detect magisk
Of course im hiding and randomly renaming it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What version of the application do you want?
I have the latest version installed and it does not detect root
Hello, I have the following problem, the operating system and the Greenify application worked very well on Magisk v22.1, but after updating to v23.0, there are problems, the operating system itself on the phone is slow and in the Greenify application, I am dissatisfied with this update v23.0 .
Please help what can be done about it.
My HTC U11, Stock ROM.
Greetings.
Noticed this on my Pixel 3 running stock as well. I would have to restart the phone several times to get it running.
GrandAdmiral said:
Noticed this on my Pixel 3 running stock as well. I would have to restart the phone several times to get it running.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand it turns out there is a problem with this v23.0 update, I wonder who else has a problem with it, besides us.
I'm not seeing any similar issues on v23 (and haven't on the canary releases leading up to it either). That doesn't mean there isn't a possible issue though...
Have you guys checked your modules if there's a possible culprit there?
Didgeridoohan said:
I'm not seeing any similar issues on v23 (and haven't on the canary releases leading up to it either). That doesn't mean there isn't a possible issue though...
Have you guys checked your modules if there's a possible culprit there?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I only have these modules and they were on v22.1, they did not cause any problems like this v23.0.
That the modules worked fine in earlier releases doesn't necessarily mean that they work on current/future release...
You need to do some troubleshooting if you're interested in getting to the bottom of this.
Disable modules to figure out if it's one of those. Disable MagiskHide to see if it's connected to that. Etc...
Didgeridoohan said:
That the modules worked fine in earlier releases doesn't necessarily mean that they work on current/future release...
You need to do some troubleshooting if you're interested in getting to the bottom of this.
Disable modules to figure out if it's one of those. Disable MagiskHide to see if it's connected to that. Etc...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It may be that the module may not work properly on this v23.0.
Okay, I will follow your suggestion on what to do with it, I'll check it out and let you know.
From the very beginning, MagiskHide is turned off.
MagiskHide off, module turned off, Riru, Riru - Edxposed, phone restart, phone working, fast as it was on v.22.1, probably something is wrong with these modules.
Sounds like EdXposed is causing some issues then... You might want to check the Xposed forums and/or EdXposed Github issues to see if there's some mention of similar problems there.
Didgeridoohan said:
Sounds like EdXposed is causing some issues then... You might want to check the Xposed forums and/or EdXposed Github issues to see if there's some mention of similar problems there.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will check the forums, maybe I will come across something, and if not, I will also write a post there, maybe a new update of these modules will fix something.
Thanks for your interest in the topic.