Among the various magisk's modules, is there one that performs the same function as the xposed's module?
I would like to eliminate that space where advertising normally appears, which I block with adaway.
Magisk ≠ Xposed.
Related
Just curious to know if any moto x users have tried some of the more popular xposed modules. Is this device aosp enough to expect most, if not all, modules to work properly?
Most of them work. I'm using app settings, gravity box, Halo FloatingWindow, Xprivacy, and adaway without problems.
I use GravityBox, Greenify, Exchange Security Bypass, and AppOps. They all work great.
Hello! I know about XPOSED mod XPrivacy:
XPrivacy can prevent applications from leaking privacy sensitive data by restricting the categories of data an application can access. XPrivacy feeds applications fake data or no data at all. It can restrict several data categories, such as contacts or location. For example, if you restrict an application's access to contacts, that application will receive an empty contacts list. Similarly, restricting an application's access to your location will send a fake location to that application.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But xposed will not be available for Android N in the nearest future(
Is there any analog of this mod for magisk?
And it sounds cool if I could allow app to have access to my files, but restrict it to its virtual folder or some analog.
No.
If you can find a way to do it without Xposed, you can use Magisk to make that mod systemless. Magisk can't do something like that by itself.
Magisk - Makes system modifications systemless.
Xposed - A system modification.
I saw there are a lot of interesting modules for pogo and I cant use them because it recognizes xposed..
In addition, the systemless xposed works for me only when magisk hide is off, is there any option to use them both? Thanks
(S8 plus, oreo, magisk v18)
No, Xposed will always trigger safetynet. Magisk module was created in order to make it easy to disable and enable it
Try to use "no device check" Xposed module.
Wysłane z mojego Redmi 4X przy użyciu Tapatalka
This has been brought up quite alot, and there really is no need for me to post anything about it again. But... To clarify some more on the above posts (and give me a perfect excuse to procrastinate a bit on my paper due on friday ):
Xposed cannot currently (and likely never) be hidden. On older systems this was possible but Google changed something in a security update (november 16, maybe?) and now it can't be done.
The "No Device Check" Xposed module that @Robert342 talks about above can be used to fake a CTS profile response, but that's about it. In the past, Pokemon Go only used the Basic integrity check (so the "No Device Check" module would be useless), but nowadays it also checks for a whole host of other things, like Busybox apps, root hiding apps, etc, and if I remember correctly the Xposed installer as well.
There might be some way of getting things running with PoGo (VirtualXposed, maybe), but I've never bothered to dig deeper into that kind of stuff (and I haven't actually used Xposed since Marshmallow). Too much effort... Would be much easier to just keep an untouched device for playing the game and another for all your rooting and modding needs.
And now for some semantics: It's not Magisk's SafetyNet, it's Google's. The Magisk Manager just uses Google's APIs for making a security check against their servers so you easily can check if MagiskHide is working as it should. And you can actually have the Magisk systemless Xposed module installed and still pass SafetyNet (as @azZA_09 is hinting about above). You'll just have to deactivate it and reboot whenever you need to pass SafetyNet and then reactivate it and reboot when you're done...
It's funny how just days after this last comment, EdXposed was released.
Also, it's even more funny that I only got to discover it today, after the despair that hardware-backed remote attestation in safetynet now is.
I guess it was a good year for some people at least.. And perhaps older phones not shipping with keymaster 2 might still enjoy escaping
Hello,
my Oneplus 7+ is running stock Android 11. Magisk has been installed and since a month ago everything was working fine (even DKB TAN2go and other banking apps). Last month an update for Comdirects Photo TAN was released and it stopped working. Luckily I was not the only one to encounter it and the description from @ralphabt here solved the issue for me.
Since this morning Google Pay stopped working (of couse I only noticed when I tried to pay and had my wallet nearby). SafetyNet fails (basic and cts). If I disabled the modules that I installed for the PhotoTan fix, SafetyNet is working again.
I found the MagiskHide Props Config, which I don't have a problem installing and testing, but I was wondering if there anything else I can try before fixing an issues that is caused by a solution for another issue.
Thanks a lot!
If SafetyNet now triggers from the Riru/EdXposed stuff you'll likely have to wait for an update to those modules (or try the latest beta/alpha/canary releases). Or try LSPosed instead (seems like more people have success with that). It's a cat and mouse game...
Im still waiting for anyone to give me a valid reason to use Xposed of any sort....
I pulled it out recently after jettisoning Xposed back in Marshmallow days, and was completely unsurprised that in my attempts to avoid root detection when i was having bank app issues it just broke things harder
Your biggest issue is getting SafetyNet pass...
Getting Google Pay and banking apps is another level...
My current setup for working bank apps (my bank at least) and working Samsung Pay & Google Pay is, should you wish to have a crack:
Magisk Alpha - here (second most recent at time of posting) or here for latest:
Riru - here
Riru-Momohider - my own mod of that module attached to my post here (where i just added creation of the 4 optional config options to the installations script, to avoid manual jiggery pokery, touching 4 files in a terminal every ROM flash didnt seem like a fun thing after the 3 ROMS i tested that week i started using Riru-Momohider)
Im talking those are the only modules i use. Even a simple font replacement module will give up a system modification to most root detection apps. So no fonts, no emojis swapping, no fiddly shizz. Keep it simple.
You can get an idea of what may be setting things off via Magisk Detector here, or VD Infos here (apologies to Didge, as mentioning that may be a trigger )
And i now get to tell you that this only currently works on 2 ROM's for my device, all the others cough up the existence of root through modifications made by devs to build.prop etc
So even in the best circumstances, and with all the right magisk and riru modules, the ROM youre using can still betray you.
Isnt that fun?
Worth pointing out (so frequently am i pointing this out these days im thinking of removing the link to my GPay Magisk Module from my sig) that for like 6 months now its been unnecessary for a lot of people to
a) Use the Google Pay db fix originally sussed out by @BostonDan, or my Magisk Module that does the same thing
and
b) Enable MagiskHide for Google Pay...
Actually getting SafetyNet is rather easy - if I remove EdXposed and XPrivacyLua it is working again and Google Pay as well. I only installed (my only reason) it, as it was required to get that banking app running.
I am using different banking apps and it the past the one from german DKB was rather difficult, but with newest Magisk (23) and Magisk Hide it is working.
Has anyone found a work around to use hidemyapplist on a13?
I can't get services to hook and extended module results in bootloop