Related
Hi all,
So I've just flashed Oxygen OS 4.0.1 for the OnePlus3T, flashed SuperSU 2.79, downloaded Magisk from playstore, installed it, uninstalled SuperSU app. Root is working fine
Two green ticks, installed and properly rooted, but the SafteyNet failes. I read that you need to enable Magisk hide, so I do, and it tells me to reboot, so again I do, but the option keeps resetting/.
Anyone else having this issue/ has a solution?
There's been several users with OnePlus devices having problems with Magisk Hide. Might be a device specific issue that's not user solvable at the moment...
Edit: New info added to OP after my answer... Magisk Hide does not work with SuperSU.
Didgeridoohan said:
There's been several users with OnePlus devices having problems with Magisk Hide. Might be a device specific issue that's not user solvable at the moment...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's a shame ./. I'll ask reddit
Thanks
I'm using phh's superuser and Magisk hide is working for me on the open beta and people seem to say that the current beta and the release versions are virtually the same, so it might be an issue with how SuperSU is handled.
afaik Magisk Hide needs phh's root, not SuperSU
Snappiestjack said:
Hi all,
So I've just flashed Oxygen OS 4.0.1 for the OnePlus3T, flashed SuperSU 2.79, downloaded Magisk from playstore, installed it, uninstalled SuperSU app. Root is working fine
Two green ticks, installed and properly rooted, but the SafteyNet failes. I read that you need to enable Magisk hide, so I do, and it tells me to reboot, so again I do, but the option keeps resetting/.
Anyone else having this issue/ has a solution?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok... I believe you've added some information since my first answer...
Magisk Hide does NOT work with SuperSU. You have to use topjohnwu's phh's superuser that's provided with Magisk.
Didgeridoohan said:
There's been several users with OnePlus devices having problems with Magisk Hide. Might be a device specific issue that's not user solvable at the moment...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, nope, nope. It's a problem with USERS who use magisk hide options. In THREAD is info about supersu + magisk hide = NOT WORKING. This is only fault of wrong su binaries, so it's not device specific issue.
And for this issue - probably flash a unsu script. It will (probably) delete all of supersu files, then in magisk manager or twrp flash modded phh binaries for magisk and then, finally install ph manager from google play. That is config to be able to use magisk hide.
ENJOY.
mucha.k1994 said:
Nope, nope, nope. It's a problem with USERS who use magisk hide options. In THREAD is info about supersu + magisk hide = NOT WORKING. This is only fault of wrong su binaries, so it's not device specific issue.
And for this issue - probably flash a unsu script. It will (probably) delete all of supersu files, then in magisk manager or twrp flash modded phh binaries for magisk and then, finally install ph manager from google play. That is config to be able to use magisk hide.
ENJOY.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I know... OP edited with SuperSU info after my answer. I edited my post as well. Thanks for the reminder.
Not going to quote everyone, but YES! Removing SuperSU and using phh SU works just fine!
Thanks all.
Hi, thanks for reading.
I've used Magisk 17.3 with all my bank apps perfectly, with Magisk hide and Magisk manager hidden.
After update to 18.0 and update manager to 6.1, the bank apps start detecting root status, and stop working.
So, I've flashed back to 17.3 and old manager 6.0.1, and everything's back to working normally.
My system:
Poco F1
LineageOS 16.0 built 27/11/2018
The apps are from Thai's banks:
SCB EASY: detected root, still working
TMB Touch: detected root, stop working
KTB Next: detected root, working partially
If you'd want any log or anything, please also tell me how to get them.
Adios2nd said:
Hi, thanks for reading.
I've used Magisk 17.3 with all my bank apps perfectly, with Magisk hide and Magisk manager hidden.
After update to 18.0 and update manager to 6.1, the bank apps start detecting root status, and stop working.
So, I've flashed back to 17.3 and old manager 6.0.1, and everything's back to working normally.
My system:
Poco F1
LineageOS 16.0 built 27/11/2018
The apps are from Thai's banks:
SCB EASY: detected root, still working
TMB Touch: detected root, stop working
KTB Next: detected root, working partially
If you'd want any log or anything, please also tell me how to get them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1.restore magisk manager with original package.
2.disable hide app.
3.reboot.
4.rehide msgisk manager.
5.rehide app.
6.reboot.
it work for nexus 6p.
Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
Can confirm that this works, thanks.
For me, it started getting detected on 17.x even before updating to 18, right after the banking app (Sparkasse) was updated.
LG G6.
hsiehboss said:
1.restore magisk manager with original package.
2.disable hide app.
3.reboot.
4.rehide msgisk manager.
5.rehide app.
6.reboot.
it work for nexus 6p.
Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This didn't work for me. I had to downgrade back to 17.1 to get my banking app working again. Appears that the root detection prevention is a regression in this latest version.
-- SSS
hsiehboss said:
1.restore magisk manager with original package.
2.disable hide app.
3.reboot.
4.rehide msgisk manager.
5.rehide app.
6.reboot.
it work for nexus 6p.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This doesn't work for me.
Did all of these...still got detected.
I have the same problem. Magisk says: ctsProfile: False and Google Pay don't work. Also my Banking App detects root.
I flashed today the latest Los 15 build and the crt false error is till there after flashing magisk 18. The same error is also with 17.4...
Tell me if I'm wrong but I believe we have two different reports: the original report where root is detected, and the ctsProfile/basicIntegrity failing. The second one is a regression fixed by rebooting device (however, it is annoying to reboot 10 times a day because suddenly SafetyNet fails for no reason).
I am using Magisk Hide Props module, and after 18.0 update Santander App detects root, even with Magisk Manager says I pass safetynet
It's happened with my bank app as it detected root & saftynet false and have to downgrade to ver.17.2
Sent from my SM-C900F using Tapatalk
See in install app delete old magisk manager, after install magisk 18.0 new magisk manager rename to manager.
I have same problem. After install v18 magisk, same bank app can detect the system is rooted. Downgrade to v17.2, all bank app become normal.
Same here since Magisk 18 my BankApp (Intesa Sanpaolo) start and says that there is a safety problem and it close, if I choose Magiskhide it doesn't start at all.
SafetyNet check spin without an end.
With Magisk 17.1 and 17.3 no problem at all.
Same problem here, after upgrading to Magisk 18 claiming to better hide root in the history, apps now suddenly detect root.
This affects also the Safety Net check and Google Pay... so far, Root Hiding in 18.0 seems COMPLETELY broken.
A solution would be great.
Later... after downgrading to Magisk 17.2, MagiskHide is working for me again and Safetynet checks succeed. The dev is aware of the problem, an issue is open on the Magisk Github (#907)
After uninstalling and reinstalling my bankapp now works without any problem and doesn't detect root even if is not under Magisk hide
I can confirm the v18 update breaks something and BOTH safety net checks fail. So all apps detect you are rooted, especially bank apps and Get Pay. Downgrading back to v17 restored everything to normal.
The only thing I could think of is the installation method. I did the direct install rather than installing the zip via recovery. Not sure if it makes a difference but I will wait for next release.
I am on a Pixel 2 with Android Pie updated to the Aug 2018 release.
---------- Post added at 12:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:43 PM ----------
Harlock1978 said:
After uninstalling and reinstalling my bankapp now works without any problem and doesn't detect root even if is not under Magisk hide
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did not uninstall but tried clearing bank app data and cache and the problem persisted. Magisk still showing all red for safetyNet. Just sharing testing feedback.
@Djtrip83 Did you try just toggling MagiskHide off and on once after updating to v18? Sometimes MagiskHide simply needs a restart after an update...
I did that too. Toggled Hide on and off for all apps. Repackaged Magisk. Turned off USB debugging. Removed modules installed. Tried everything I thought would work. Even restored hosts in case Ad Away affected something on /system.
The only thing I did not do was remove root apps and re-install them to re-grant permissions after the Magisk update. And I wonder now if uninstalling Magisk completely and make a brand new clean install with v18 would work rather than upgrading.
I was at a loss so I downgraded. Sorry I don't have a log to share. However, v17 works fine.
Djtrip83 said:
I did that too. Toggled Hide on and off for all apps. Repackaged Magisk. Turned off USB debugging. Removed modules installed. Tried everything I thought would work. Even restored hosts in case Ad Away affected something on /system.
The only thing I did not do was remove root apps and re-install them to re-grant permissions after the Magisk update. And I wonder now if uninstalling Magisk completely and make a brand new clean install with v18 would work rather than upgrading.
I was at a loss so I downgraded. Sorry I don't have a log to share. However, v17 works fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We might be misunderstanding each other, but what I'm talking about is simply to go to the Manager settings and change the toggle for MagiskHide to off and then on. No need to do anything to the Hide list or anything else... Did you do that? As I said, that's sometimes something you the to do after an update, but it's rare.
I noticed something strange, on my phone and I'm trying different ways to solve it, but it just does not "work".
I have 2 x Magisk icons in my phone and I cannot remove them, so that I only have 1 x Magisk.
Here's some background,...
My phone: OnePlus 6 [OP6], with stock Oxygen OS 9.0.9 [OOS 9.0.9] Android and running custom kernel [Omega].
I had been running a ROM [xXx NoLimits] which is a Magisk Module.
For last 11+ months, I have had no issues with my phone, no issues with Magisk, and no issues with root really.
I updated to Magisk v20.0 (but it seems it was the Beta / Canary channel) and also,
I had used the "Hide Magisk Manager" feature, for 1 specific app. to work.
Just this week, I noticed some issues with my phone or that I had 'lost' root
This happens rarely, and I just reinstall Magisk, but it resolves itself.
So, I went looking and saw an odd thing: 2 x Magisk icons.
Since then, I have tried:
- Magisk Uninstaller [Magisk-uninstaller-20191011.zip]
- Flashed unpatched BOOT.img file, Flashed TWRP. Then, rebooted to TWRP.
- Flashed Magisk, flashed the custom kernel.
Still, I saw 2 x Magisk icons.
I could see 1 Magisk was on STABLE channel, while other was on CANARY channel.
This was strange.
So, I changed the CANARY to STABLE, etc. etc...
Anyway, too many combinations of uninstalling and removing root, reinstall Magisk, etc... and I still don't know how to really uninstall Magisk and start from ZERO again.
I have lost Magisk's association to my Magisk modules too.
Can anyone help or advise?
Sounds like you just have two Managers installed. Uninstall them both (like you would with any other app) and install the apk manually again.
https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_There_are_two_Magisk_Managers
I think I resolved my issue now...
I uninstalled Magisk using the official Magisk Uninstaller.
I also uninstalled the 2 x Magisk apps in my launcher, using this .APK ---> "Uninstalled SystemApps" ( https://github.com/nicolaserlonghi/UninstallSystemApps )
Then, I had to go through re-installing the BOOT.img, Magisk and most importantly, the ROM (which itself was a Magisk module).
Slowly, it populated the Magisk module list and 'SuperUser' lists, and I think I got the phone back into how I had it.
Didgeridoohan said:
Sounds like you just have two Managers installed. Uninstall them both (like you would with any other app) and install the apk manually again.
https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_There_are_two_Magisk_Managers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, exactly.
Thanks for this tip, but I reached this conclusion anyway...
and used another .apk (Unsinstall SystemApps) to remove the Magisk Manager (which was the result of using "Magisk Manager Hide",
but then I must have mixed up Stable & Canary builds of Magisk on the phone, etc.)
Didgeridoohan said:
Sounds like you just have two Managers installed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
One thing weird though is, quite a few modules that were previously installed are missing from the Magisk "modules" section.
When I 're-install' them, they still don't show in the "modules" section.
For Example:
Vanced, Advanced Charging Controller, etc... all have been installed, but not showing up in Magisk.
I just had a weird situation of 2 different Magisk installs (at first it seemed like 2 x Managers), but it could be 2 different Magisk builds:
stable and canary
I don't know how to explain it, but maybe the Magisk Uninstaller doesn't work properly on Canary builds?
Anyway, my issue now is modules don't get listed in the Magisk Manager.
No, you did not have two different Magisk builds installed at the same time. Can't happen...
And without more to go on (logs, etc) it's gonna be real hard to help with the module issue.
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you can pass SafetyNet (cts profile) try to hide :
Magisk Manager with a random name (mandatory) ... and "Your banking app" must be hidden too along with Google Services of course !
There are currently several ways of detecting Magisk that MagiskHide can't circumvent.
If the app isn't using one of those (if it is you'll just have to wait for a possible update to Magisk), you can find some tips and tricks here:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Magisk cannot hide:
Other known root apps (see "Detecting apps requiring root"). (Shouldn't be a problem since even with a renamed manager and magisk unflashed it still works.)
Remnants of previous root method, including any root management apps (a good way to remove most remnants of root is osm0sis unSU script). (Magisk is unflashed and app immediately works.)
Unlocked bootloader (see Unlocked bootloader). (Magisk is unflashed and bootloader unlocked, app still works. I also tried custom rom and the stock rom.)
A tripped Samsung Knox counter. (Not a samsung phone.)
Xposed (deactivate it or uninstall). It doesn't matter if it's systemless, Magisk can't hide it. (Never used.)
EdXposed. Detection of EdXposed can sometimes be worked around with newer release of EdXposed and/or features like the EdXposed Manager blacklist. (Never used.)
USB/ADB Debugging (disable under Developer options in Android settings). (Magisk unflashed and debugging on, app works.)
Developer options. (Magisk unflashed and developer options is on, app works.)
Some Magisk modules - Depending on what the module does, it may not be able to be hidden by MagiskHide. (Tried core only mode which should disable all modules, still don't work.)
Some modifications to /system. Make sure to use Magisk modules... (I'm not sure what this means :c)
From that list it looks like it's something from Magisk itself that's tripping the detection :/
Im going bald from this.
IcY~ said:
From that list it looks like it's something from Magisk itself that's tripping the detection :/
Im going bald from this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you've tested and confirmed everything else, it is very likely that the app is using a detection method that Magisk currently can't hide from.
Solution? Wait for @topjohnwu to possibly update Magisk/MagiskHide (alternatively, don't install Magisk). When? Whenever he feels like it...
Didgeridoohan said:
If you've tested and confirmed everything else, it is very likely that the app is using a detection method that Magisk currently can't hide from.
Solution? Wait for @topjohnwu to possibly update Magisk/MagiskHide (alternatively, don't install Magisk). When? Whenever he feels like it...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2406
Looks like someone posted a potential fix. Will wait for it to reach the master branch!
Have you find the workaround? I am using the same app and face same problem. This app last update gives headache
I am hidding root and edxposed using Island and installing intune inside the sandbox. Maybe the same will be with bank apps.
@kubis111
i'm happy for you, but please...this isn't your thread so do not OOT, OP problem isn't solving yet
---------- Post added at 11:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:03 AM ----------
Tomek0000 said:
I am hidding root and edxposed using Island and installing intune inside the sandbox. Maybe the same will be with bank apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can you share the apps link?
Any updates on this banking app? I've tried many TaiChi Magisk, Sudohide and Zuper module but no success.
ctsProfile all green, Rootbeer Fresh all green.
citi app also detected my rooted device( Mi 8 Pro) after update , even hide the App ..useless....
Heatexplorer said:
citi app also detected my rooted device( Mi 8 Pro) after update , even hide the App ..useless....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Had the same problem. Updated magisk manager and fixed it (even before updating my modules).
Anyone lucky on it? What about BBVA Spain app?
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you found a solution? With latest Permata and Magisk (23) the banking app still does not work...
timofonic said:
Anyone lucky on it? What about BBVA Spain app?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me work
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Found a solution, but can't publish yet. Excuse me
Spartacus500 said:
Found a solution, but can't publish yet. Excuse me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why?
hallo dare said:
Why?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So I ran the test quickly and it turns out that it works, for those who are interested, I will provide a solution, but a little later.
I managed to make it work,
Spartacus500 said:
For me work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Spartacus500 said:
For me work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No idea how. I'm worried about that Knox logo these days, but we'll..
Thanks!
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to be just now, but to the point of solution to this,
1. Install the disable services app and disable a process called "S17"
2. Done
I am having OnePlus7T which does not have TWRP. Magisk was installed through patched boot image while rooting many months back. At that time Canary version was recommended and I had installed that.
I have updated the ROM, Magisk Manager and Magisk in these months via OTA.
Everything works except this app, https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=in.org.npci.upiapp&hl=en. It detects even though hidden with MagisK Hide. Magisk package manager is also hidden but this app does not work. It opens, registers the user but later detects root.
Since last few days Magisk is crashing when opened for no apparent reason. Restarting the phone didn't make any difference. If I long click on the app and select Magisk Hids or Supeuser or Modules it opens but when I try to go to main Manager screen it crashes. How to resolve this? Phone is still working as intended and I have root access for apps not hidden in Magisk Hide.
How do I update Manager from Canary to Stable? Can I just download a stable Manager apk and install it on top of the Canary? Which version should be used? Will Magisk also need to be installed again? Will I lose root?
Can anyone explain the steps in detail as I am bit confused.
My Magisk also crash like this