Database Develop

Magisk with CM13 and Xposed

Hello guys. I'm tempted to install Magisk on my Zenfone 2 ZE551ML. I have the latest CM13 Nightly + Xposed and I want to ask if Magisk has any problem running alongside these two.
Another question is if I can still use the built in CM13 root.
Thanks for your answers!

Im running on CM 13 (ZenFone 2 Laser ZOOL) stable and it works fine.
The only problem is that with xposed active the safetynet check don't pass. But its just a matter of disabling xposed and rebooting when necessary.
I dont know if the differences are too significant, but hope it helps.

FHC1998 said:
Im running on CM 13 (ZenFone 2 Laser ZOOL) stable and it works fine.
The only problem is that with xposed active the safetynet check don't pass. But its just a matter of disabling xposed and rebooting when necessary.
I dont know if the differences are too significant, but hope it helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That means Magisk doesn't work with Xposed ? Or I just have to unninstall Xposed and then install again after installing Magisk ?

PedroCaseiro said:
That means Magisk doesn't work with Xposed ? Or I just have to unninstall Xposed and then install again after installing Magisk ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk itself works perfectly with Xposed installed, only Magisk Hide that doesn't hide Xposed.
So if you don't plan on using any app that checks Safety Net (Pokemon Go, Android Pay, for example) You won't have any problem.

FHC1998 said:
Magisk itself works perfectly with Xposed installed, only Magisk Hide that doesn't hide Xposed.
So if you don't plan on using any app that checks Safety Net (Pokemon Go, Android Pay, for example) You won't have any problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
and what about the built in CM13 root ?

I think the newest Magisk auto removes it when you flash it.
But I had manually removed before installing magisk on mine.
But in any case, if I remember correctly you can just remove it thru the SuperSU app before flashing Magisk.

FHC1998 said:
I think the newest Magisk auto removes it when you flash it.
But I had manually removed before installing magisk on mine.
But in any case, if I remember correctly you can just remove it thru the SuperSU app before flashing Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll try it then and hope not to **** up my phone. Thanks
Sent from my Asus ZenFone 2 using XDA Labs

PedroCaseiro said:
I'll try it then and hope not to **** up my phone. Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem. Just remember to make a nandroid backup first if you are worried.

push TAN - app detecting root

The Problem:
The App detects the device is rooted and thus redirects to a browser with a message saying it can not be run on a rooted device etc.
What I've got so far:
-Magisk hide does nothing
-https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/santander-app-custom-rom-root-device-t3794753/post77321403 A could be hint to a solution
It works once the Magisk app is deleted
My Question:
How could I have Magisk installed and still have the push TAN app work?
APP:https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.starfinanz.mobile.android.pushtan&hl=de

Have you renamed magisk apk? There's an option in settings.
Sent from my M2002J9G using Tapatalk

renaming does nothing,here in germany its easy to use push tan apps,in my case and i am by the Sparkasse Leverkusen just go to your Sparkasse and say ur phone is not rooted,just old,after some minutes you can use spush tan app with every root method or magisk!!!!Cheers!!!

TheOne9373 said:
The Problem:
The App detects the device is rooted and thus redirects to a browser with a message saying it can not be run on a rooted device etc.
What I've got so far:
-Magisk hide does nothing
-https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/santander-app-custom-rom-root-device-t3794753/post77321403 A could be hint to a solution
It works once the Magisk app is deleted
My Question:
How could I have Magisk installed and still have the push TAN app work?
APP:https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.starfinanz.mobile.android.pushtan&hl=de
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have seen this post today and remebered your problem, check this out.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/guide-how-to-hide-root-bank-applications-t4172127
Enviado de meu POCOPHONE F1 usando o Tapatalk

[email protected] said:
I have seen this post today and remebered your problem, check this out.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/guide-how-to-hide-root-bank-applications-t4172127
Enviado de meu POCOPHONE F1 usando o Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does not work on this application, the problem is solved by the latest magisk manager 8.0.0 and repackaging it to a different name, hiding S-pushTAN and it works :highfive:

Spartacus500 said:
It does not work on this application, the problem is solved by the latest magisk manager 8.0.0 and repackaging it to a different name, hiding S-pushTAN and it works :highfive:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Confirmed with DKB PushTAN App

I tried it like this, but it's still not working. What magisk version are you on?

Dark_Lion64 said:
I tried it like this, but it's still not working. What magisk version are you on?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Today New version magisk manager update

pushTAN App by Sparkasse is not working with LOS 18.1 @OP6 with latest Magisk 23. Any solutions?

Hi guys
After a while of test try test try So on. I find a solution that work for the one of my devices that I use for. Its a huawei p10 lite. So first it had openkirin lineagos 16 build 6 but this Firmware have to many little Bugs like Bluetooth no connection with Mi Band Smartwatch but with soundbar no problem, then camera Bug...often it doesn't safe the createt pics and vids. Thats very argh when snapshots not safe and not Anke to reproduce, and some other. Some time goes by and now I have lineagos 18.1 for p8 lite 2017 codename prague. The p10 lite warsaw WAS-LX1A working well with it. I just had to downgrade the Stock ROM from 8.0.0C432B398 to B378 for headshot the build number error. The settings in magisk should be clear for every one...i think
So first I reboot TWRP and clear Cache and Dalvik. Reboot to System and adjust magisk (hide and repack) the repack needs a little while so just keep cool and wait. Then install the pushtan App Version 1.50. ask Google for apk. Or pm me and I send you This is the last that working for me. My different magisk version I use was 19.3 phh, 20,4 phh and one for Android 11. that is moddet for huawei p10 lite. Take a look in xda forum and you will find it. If the normal magisk for A11 running on your device then use it. On huawei we need the mod one.
So now the apk was installed you first open magisk and choose pushtan in hide Option. Then reboot to TWRP and delete Cache and Dalvik again. After that you can reboot to System...fingerscross could not be wrong in this moment hihi...now the great moment is coming. Start the app and your Facial expression would show if it work or not for me it does.
Hmmm Warum schreibe ik eigentlich english bei ner Sparkassen App xD
So good luck for you
solong
speedson

Pundy said:
pushTAN App by Sparkasse is not working with LOS 18.1 @OP6 with latest Magisk 23. Any solutions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use Magisk Canary, use Hide Magisk for "S-pushTAN", Repack Magisk with another name like "Manager" f.e. , get the App "Airfrozen" and freeze Magisk Manager with it.
After this steps you can use "S-pushTAN" without any problems.
If its still not working after that, make sure everything named "Magisk" like ZIPs or Folders are deleted.

bLack_Q said:
Use Magisk Canary, use Hide Magisk for "S-pushTAN", Repack Magisk with another name like "Manager" f.e. , get the App "Airfrozen" and freeze Magisk Manager with it.
After this steps you can use "S-pushTAN" without any problems.
If its still not working after that, make sure everything named "Magisk" like ZIPs or Folders are deleted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much! Now it works.
Renaming the App and Airfrozen is the key.

Pundy said:
Thank you very much! Now it works.
Renaming the App and Airfrozen is the key.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice, glad I could help. If you dont use "S-pushTAN" anymore you can simply unfreeze Magisk.

bLack_Q said:
Nice, glad I could help. If you dont use "S-pushTAN" anymore you can simply unfreeze Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not working with comdirect phototan.
Any suggestions?

Laptapper said:
Not working with comdirect phototan.
Any suggestions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately I have never used that app. But if I come up with something I will let you know.

Matterport Capture app - can't run because rooted, any way around this?

Matterport - Apps on Google Play
Transform your business with digital twins
play.google.com
I'm trying to use this app on my Xiaomi Mi Note 10 with xiaomi.eu latest stable rom, with magisk rooted. I've used magiskhide but it still says it cannot run due to rooted. any workarounds?
thanks!

geminihc said:
Matterport - Apps on Google Play
Transform your business with digital twins
play.google.com
I'm trying to use this app on my Xiaomi Mi Note 10 with xiaomi.eu latest stable rom, with magisk rooted. I've used magiskhide but it still says it cannot run due to rooted. any workarounds?
thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
first of all, hide magisk app itself (rebuild with random package name, its in Magisk settings). clear play store and play services data and reboot, then check again
if still not working, you can try Xposed modules like XPrivacyLua or SudoHide

thank you! that first advice worked! cantbeleve it was so simple!

geminihc said:
thank you! that first advice worked! cantbeleve it was so simple!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm glad I could help

Bumping this. Wondering if there's a work around now..
Tried as recommended but doesn't work

Comdirect photoTAN app detecting root

Since version 8.3.0 additional measures to detect root have been added, do not update as MagiskHide won't be able to prevent detection. Until a solution is found I would recommend staying on the previous version for as long as possible.
Finding out what exactly is causing the root detection is beyond my technical abilities but I would provide as much information needed to those willing to help.
---
Update: December 14th 2021 - Method no longer sufficient
---
The solution found by @pxrave appears to be working:
pxrave said:
Hey fellas I got it working and others apps detect magisk before.
Update to latest v23
Install modules riru and riru unshare
Remove data from tan app
Go to magisk hide and tick all process to hide included the isolated
Start the tan app and do the activation again.
Problem you need wait 2 days to activate because comdirect use new activation process for photo tan app.
Working fine all version 8.3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Link to the Riru Unshare module:
GitHub - vvb2060/riru-unshare
Contribute to vvb2060/riru-unshare development by creating an account on GitHub.
github.com

also stcpay yesterday is updated to 1.6 and started to detect my magisk canary (22105)

I can confirm what swour says.
on Android 9 and 11, my magisk root is recognized, magiskhide is active and the phototan app is added.

Yes this is a serious problem. I used xposed magisk and x privacy... Latest comdirect tan app detect all...

+1

+1 big issue for me

Only solution I found (for now): Go back to version 8.2.1 using a backup or any mirror, e.g. https://downloadapk.net/comdirect-photoTAN-App.html
Unfortunately you need to register again then

I have already applied the update. The easiest method is to wait few days for a magisk fix, right? I would can wait few days, no problem. I have an absolutly clean Android 8.1 build on the phone for banking. It's crazy that the bank is make it so difficult for us to use a save own build.

allrightlite said:
The easiest method is to wait few days for a magisk fix, right? I would can wait few days, no problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Perhaps that is too optimistic. I doubt that one app is of great interest

Asellus said:
one app is of great interest
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Until the new root detection is also available for other apps, it will be fixed quickly.

Conan179 said:
Until the new root detection is also available for other apps, it will be fixed quickly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, then I will easly wait. No need to reactivate hopefully.

Conan179 said:
Until the new root detection is also available for other apps, it will be fixed quickly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, of course, if other app developers find a similar way. So, congrats to the developers of the phototan app to find it.

Asellus said:
Yes, of course, if other app developers find a similar way. So, congrats to the developers of the phototan app to find it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think so, there is at least one other app that shows the same behavior.
new root dedction
i updated stc pay yesterday to 1.6 and it found my magisk canary (22105) the think i notes is the (isolated) is added to the app !!!
forum.xda-developers.com
I also noticed the (isolated) thing with me.

I tried with v23 this morning, w/o success :-(

Same here, got v23 and working safetynet-fix, no success. Downgraded photoTAN to v8.2.1 .

+1

I'm not surprised, there is nothing in the changelog that this has been fixed.

Downgrading to 8.2.0 or 8.2.1 doesn't work for me. Did you do something else than uninstalling 8.3.0 and installing 8.2.1?

muschi.muscholini said:
Downgrading to 8.2.0 or 8.2.1 doesn't work for me. Did you do something else than uninstalling 8.3.0 and installing 8.2.1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a ZTE Blade L130 with the old photo tan app, that is my rescue. But you can't activate the old one. But it's keep working.

muschi.muscholini said:
Downgrading to 8.2.0 or 8.2.1 doesn't work for me. Did you do something else than uninstalling 8.3.0 and installing 8.2.1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had to unhide the app in magisk hide and hide it again, after that it worked.

[Discussion] How to bypass detections of rooting ?

Did you have problems with some app that detects the root ?
Here is your place.
We will try to help you.
Keep attention, this is just a help thread, nothing is guaranteed.
Be patient and cordial.
If there is acceptance of the community on the subject, certainly the thread will grow.
Before posting your reply, please describe some questions:
- What is the version of Android ?
- What is the name of the app, the package of the app and where can we download the app ?
- When does exactly the app crash ?
- Are you using a custom/modded ROM or a stock ROM ?
- Which magisk modules are enabled ?
- Which xposed modules are enabled ?
Don't forget to attach some screenshots.

Some Useful Content For Bypassing Detections:
Shamiko:
https://github.com/LSPosed/LSPosed.github.io
DenylistUnmount:
https://github.com/mywalkb/DenylistUnmount
XPrivacyLua:
https://repo.xposed.info/module/eu.faircode.xlua
https://github.com/M66B/XPrivacyLua
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/app-xposed-6-0-xprivacylua-android-privacy-manager.3730663/
Universal SafetyNet Fix:
https://github.com/kdrag0n/safetynet-fix
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-module-universal-safetynet-fix-1-1-0.4217823/
InitRcHider
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/module-initrchider.4369285/
Magisk Hide Props Config:
https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Repo/MagiskHidePropsConf
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...safetynet-prop-edits-and-more-v6-1-2.3789228/
Hide My Applist:
https://github.com/Dr-TSNG/Hide-My-Applist
RootCloak:
https://repo.xposed.info/module/com.devadvance.rootcloak
https://repo.xposed.info/module/com.devadvance.rootcloak2
https://github.com/devadvance/rootcloak
https://github.com/devadvance/rootcloakplus
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...e-root-from-specific-apps-2014-01-14.2574647/
MomoHider:
https://github.com/canyie/Riru-MomoHider
RiruUnshare:
https://github.com/vvb2060/riru-unshare
XPrivacy:
https://repo.xposed.info/module/biz.bokhorst.xprivacy
https://github.com/M66B/XPrivacy
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/xprivacy-the-ultimate-yet-easy-to-use-privacy-manager.2320783/
Some Useful Content For Checking Detections:
VD Infos:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/VDInfos.4097379/
Momo:
https://t.me/magiskalpha/517
XposedDetector:
https://github.com/vvb2060/XposedDetector
MagiskDetector:
https://github.com/vvb2060/MagiskDetector
ApplistDetector:
https://github.com/Dr-TSNG/ApplistDetector
NativeDetector:
https://github.com/LSPosed/NativeDetector
YASNAC - SafetyNet Checker:
https://github.com/RikkaW/YASNAC/releases

Reserved.

It appears July patch defeated Magisk Deny List and USNF.
No Netflix install/update
No Wallet/Pay

mingkee said:
It appears July patch defeated Magisk Deny List and USNF.
No Netflix install/update
No Wallet/Pay
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi, good idea! So I use magisk 25.2, denylist, zygisk, shamiko.
i'm on LOS 19.1 on samsung galaxy tab a (sm-t 550). Hiding root works, but MOMo detects 'abnormal' circumstances (see attachment). Banking apps (S pushTan und VR securego crashes.
i renamed TWRP folder, Magisk and TitaniumBackup, freezed magisk app, I deactivated Developer options and debugging - guess I tried everything Didgeridoohan advices. cleared cache and data - the banking apps won't work. What can I do further?

abagm said:
hi, good idea! So I use magisk 25.2, denylist, zygisk, shamiko.
i'm on LOS 19.1 on samsung galaxy tab a (sm-t 550). Hiding root works, but MOMo detects 'abnormal' circumstances (see attachment). Banking apps (S pushTan und VR securego crashes.
i renamed TWRP folder, Magisk and TitaniumBackup, freezed magisk app, I deactivated Developer options and debugging - guess I tried everything Didgeridoohan advices. cleared cache and data - the banking apps won't work. What can I do further?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try NOT to use Shamiko (crashes in some/many apps), try this for an alternative

Stillhard said:
Try NOT to use Shamiko (crashes in some/many apps), try this for an alternative
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

abagm said:
okay. did so, loaded initRcHider as well - no luck. Denylist seems working, Momo does not mention magisk or zygisk or lsposed. Maybe SELinux permissive is the culprit? Seems that banking apps have got too strict - LOS 17 and pure old magisk hide did the job. Broken TEE, Seccomp???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Custom ROMs will always shown as abnormal because they are abnormal.
If they were not abnormal, they could not work.
About seliux permissive, this will always be a big red alert.

Hi @VD171
Thanks for creating this thread!
Please keep up the good work
abagm said:
Seems that banking apps have got too strict
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If banking app is too intrusive then you can simply access your online banking website through browser app and do your transactions from there
Browser app will never check if you got root or if your selinux is permissive or other things! Because it's none of its business!

lebigmac said:
Hi @VD171
Thanks for creating this thread!
Please keep up the good work
If banking app is too intrusive then you can simply access your online banking website through browser app and do your transactions from there
Browser app will never check if you got root or if your selinux is permissive or other things! Because it's none of its business!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lebigmac said:
Hi @VD171
Thanks for creating this thread!
Please keep up the good work
If banking app is too intrusive then you can simply access your online banking website through browser app and do your transactions from there
Browser app will never check if you got root or if your selinux is permissive or other things! Because it's none of its business!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're right- I can access the online banking via browser. But to do transaction, I need apps - that's why I complain 🫠

VD171 said:
Custom ROMs will always shown as abnormal because they are abnormal.
If they were not abnormal, they could not work.
About seliux permissive, this will always be a big red alert.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

lebigmac said:
Hi @VD171
Thanks for creating this thread!
Please keep up the good work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you, sir. I will help always as I can
lebigmac said:
If banking app is too intrusive then you can simply access your online banking website through browser app and do your transactions from there
Browser app will never check if you got root or if your selinux is permissive or other things! Because it's none of its business!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We need ways for distinguishing unexperienced users and users who assume full responsibility for their own use.
Apps delivers many new possibilities and services, banking through browser app isn't enough actually.

abagm said:
Thank you for this thread!
Yeah, that is true. i hoped there are ways to disguise the complaints of MOMo (for example such a thing like renaming addon.d in /system to disguise "running custom rom"). And LOS 17 did run the banking apps, so I wanted to understand the difference.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you having problem with any specific app?

VD171 said:
Thank you, sir. I will help always as I can
We need ways for distinguishing unexperienced users and users who assume full responsibility for their own use.
Apps delivers many new possibilities and services, banking through browser app isn't enough actually.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's true - doing your financial transactions through the web browser feels a little bit prehistoric to say the least but it works and you don't need to waste your precious time trying to hide your root and other customizations from some intrusive apps that shouldn't be intruding on your privacy like that in the first place
I know it's not the perfect solution but the more solutions we have to avoid this annoying safetynet 'feature' altogether the better. I am so happy that I don't need to bother with this useless safetynet 'feature'

lebigmac said:
It's true banking through browser app is a little bit prehistoric but it works and you don't need to waste your precious time trying to hide your root and other customizations from some intrusive apps that shouldn't be intruding on your privacy like that
I know it's not the perfect solution but the more solutions we have to overcome these annoying safetynet requirements the better. I am so happy that I don't need to bother with all this useless safetynet this safetynet that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any type of detection can be bypassed.
Even native methods can be bypassed, because Android app's run on java.
So, at sometime and somewhere, results are given to/from java.

VD171 said:
Are you having problem with any specific app?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

abagm said:
Yes, those banking apps BestSign (it detects root immediatly but can be used), S-PushTAN and VR-SecureGo. these three worked on rooted 'unnormal' LOS 17.1 but don't work now in 19.1. Momo said magisk and LSPosed were hidden butcomplains about that unnormal enviroment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When does exactly the app crash?
May you attach some screenshots?
I've tried all them.
All them are working fine for me.

VD171 said:
When does exactly the app crash?
May you attach some screenshots?
I've tried all them.
All them are working fine for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

---throwing in the towel - can't get it work as I wanted to. WIll return to the working version of ROM - and be proud to be outdated ...