So here's what happened:
I installed a new rom: Google wiz 44. A touchwiz based Android 8.0 rom. It has magisk pre-installed. In magisk, I get the systemless xposed SDK26 module. It installs fine but after reboot there is no Xposed installer APK. To fix this I also install the normal Xposed module from magisk repo. This gets me the Xposed installer APK and after a reboot it detects Xposed is installed. The problem now is I cannot uninstall Xposed framework even with the uninstaller zip. I have tried removing the sdk26 Xposed from magisk but it doesn't uninstall Xposed. Can't pass saftynet.
If you'd have read the documentation for the Xposed module, or the OP of the Systemless Xposed support thread, you'd have seen that you need to install the modified installer for that module manually.
Now, the question is what you mean by the "normal Xposed module from magisk repo". Do you mean the Unity version? Because that's also a systemless Xposed version, just by a different creator...
So now you have two systemless Xposed modules installed? That sounds like it could cause problems...
You can't use the Xposed uninstaller zip for a Magisk systemless Xposed module. It won't recognise it. Since it sounds like you've installed everything through Magisk, you can uninstall through Magisk. When you say you've tried and it doesn't work, what do you mean? Have you gone to the modules section of the Magisk Manager and pressed the trash bin icon next to the module you want to remove and then rebooted? More details, please...
And lastly, you can never pass SafetyNet with Xposed installed and active.
@benvrakas, maybe try the UNITY installer. It acts as an installer, uninstaller, and upgrader.
Flash it and pay attention to the output. It'll tell you what it's doing.
If it installs on first flash, flash it again for an uninstall. Hopefully it'll remove things successfully. Just another option.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3697756
Xposed Framework [UNITY]
Maybe this more involved method may work.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=76064855
Moto G5S Plus XT1806, FireHound v4.5 ROM, MultiROM, Tapatalk 4.9.5
removed
My Experience, A standalone Install did not pass "SafetyNet" checks, even the basic integrity check failed.
I just installed it from Magisk as a module but again the same, both the checks (basic and cts) are failing., Just wanted to post this reply to see if somebody has a suggestion so that I can also follow.
Update:
I can conclude that Xposed from magisk is the best choice right now.
Installing Xposed in anyway makes this thing called "safetyNet" fail, and you cannot use apps like Netflix and Google pay.
If you install Xposed as standalone, you have to uninstall xposed to set the safetyNet back to true. (I tried that disabling from 'xposed installer' app isn't helping)
But if you install Xposed via Magisk, it is as good as a module and you can disable Xposed whenever needed from the modules menu of magisk and reboot to use the apps mentioned above..
To put it simple, if a friend were to ask me to send money via Google pay, it is better to ask for 2 minutes to disable Xposed and reboot via magisk.. instead of saying that i have Xposed installed and i cant use the Google pay app.
sagar2208 said:
My Experience, A standalone Install did not pass "SafetyNet" checks, even the basic integrity check failed.
I just installed it from Magisk as a module but again the same, both the checks (basic and cts) are failing., Just wanted to post this reply to see if somebody has a suggestion so that I can also follow.
Update:
I can conclude that Xposed from magisk is the best choice right now.
Installing Xposed in anyway makes this thing called "safetyNet" fail, and you cannot use apps like Netflix and Google pay.
If you install Xposed as standalone, you have to uninstall xposed to set the safetyNet back to true. (I tried that disabling from 'xposed installer' app isn't helping)
But if you install Xposed via Magisk, it is as good as a module and you can disable Xposed whenever needed from the modules menu of magisk and reboot to use the apps mentioned above..
To put it simple, if a friend were to ask me to send money via Google pay, it is better to ask for 2 minutes to disable Xposed and reboot via magisk.. instead of saying that i have Xposed installed and i cant use the Google pay app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Way to go[emoji41][emoji1419]
Sent from my SM-N920T using Tapatalk
Oneplus 5
ACIP 10
Lastest magisk with magisk hide enabled
When I use the app whisper (sh. Whisper), it works fine and dandy. When I install edxposed (sandhook/yafha) it some how detects edxposed and ghosts my account, meaning I can't make posts or send DMs.
It's not detecting the edxposed manager app, because when I uninstall edxposed using the zip, it works. Even the riru module is installed and it still works.
How is this app detecting edxposed being installed and how can I hide it from the app?
I tried with the hiddencore xposed module too and it passes safetynet, Google
Pay works, but only that app detects and ceases use of the app.
ahb83 said:
... When I install edxposed (sandhook/yafha) it some how detects edxposed and ghosts my account, meaning I can't make posts or send DMs.
It's not detecting the edxposed manager app, because when I uninstall edxposed using the zip, it works. Even the riru module is installed and it still works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It probably looks for the package name, or just runs keywords to detect the xposed presence.
I suggest you to install rootcloak, you can hide specific keywords and commands from an apps list you can set, usually after that it stops detecting xposed.
Be careful it probably trips safetynet, but since it's still working for you maybe it doesn't cause any hassle.
Developers: LSPosed Developers
Homepage: GitHub
✱ Requirements:
• Magisk 21+
• Android 8.1-13
• Riru(NOT NEEDED) USE ZYGISK
Description: Riru module providing ART interception framework (natively for Android Pie) that provides consistent API -interfaces with OG Xposed, using YAHFA (or SandHook) interception environment, supports Android 8.1 ~ 11.
& Installation:
• Install Riru 23+
• Install Riru - LSPosed via Magisk Manager
• Install LSPosed Manager app (Note: No Saparate App and Zip, App Will be Installed Automatically)
• Reboot your device.
Download:
For stable release, please go to Github Release page For canary build use telegram.
Go to second post for latest version Download
Notes:I'm just sharing this from github, I'm not responsible if you bricked your device.
GPay and other banking apps working fine without any issue so this xposed alternative is worth trying and safer.
Note: If anyone facing bootloop issue, don't panic, hard reboot again and it will work.
Screenshot:
Download:
Flash zip file through magisk and then install LSPosed Manager app
Update 1 March 2021
V1.2.0
V1.3.7 Updated 15.May.2021
(Note: No Saparate App and Zip, App Will be Installed Automatically)
For Newer Version Changelogs and Downloads:
LsPosed Github
Changelog
Spoiler: See
Fix manager white screen
[*]Support split-apk modules (LSPosed will choose only one apk with xposed_init to load)
[*]Fix manager crash when launching an uninstalled module from notification
[*]Load modules with SharedMemory (it can speedup app cold launch) 2
[*]New manager icon
[*]Fix incorrect update notification in the first installation
[*]Fix some apps not showing in the scope list in some rare cases
[*]Show notification of module uninstallation
[*]Prevent modules from hooking inner methods (methods from XposedBridge's classloader)
Note:
Previously LSPosed only recognize modules from the primary user. However, this strategy is not good and leads to some problems: some modules require getting installed app lists for configuration but they cannot do so across users; some require reading themselves from the hooked apps but they cannot do so from non-primary users; some users want to configure modules differently on different users which is not feasible previously. Thus LSPosed now requires every module to be installed to the user on which the apps they want to hook are installed. Some devices restrict modules from installing onto some users. In such a case, you can install them from the manager (but it's recommended).
1: For some weird devices that prevent installing apps from the root user, please install the manager from /data/adb/lspd/manager.apk or manager.apk from the zip file manually.
2: Some modules get modules' apk path using reflection of its classloader, it's not recommended and unstable since the apk path from classloader no longer exists when using SharedMemory to load modules. Please use the documented way (from IXposedHookZygoteInit.StartupParam.modulePath) instead.
Reserved 2
Why it's safer than EdXposed?
QkiZMR said:
Why it's safer than EdXposed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't say it's safer than edxposed. I meant xposed alternatives like taichi etc.
All banking apps works, no system slowdown, i got more free ram etc.
In edxposed the hooked apps take time to open, no such issue with LSPosed.
That's why i thought it's worth trying and safer.
And +1 is safetynet passes all the time with LSPosed but, with edxposed safetynet works for some time after every reboot even with blacklisting google framework and services.
This slowdown is caused by YAHFA hook in EdXposed. On Sandhook is much better. Which hook method you use in LSposed?
And +1 is safetynet passes all the time with LSPosed but, with edxposed safetynet works for some time after every reboot even with blacklisting google framework and services
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
SafetyNet works till google patched it no matter which xposed clone you use. Before last patch SN was working fine with EdXposed. I don't needed blacklisting framework and services because EdXposed manager is doing automatically, with special option enabled. So don't say lies about EdXposed but tell us about technical differences between LSposed and EdXposed. What you change after forking EdXposed repo?
looks working good u,till now, just its annoying sometimes to have to choos which app has the module applies. a "select all" option would be welcome in a next release
How do I pass safety net? I have universal safety fix module is installed too.
Antho02 said:
looks working good u,till now, just its annoying sometimes to have to choos which app has the module applies. a "select all" option would be welcome in a next release
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is what i was confused about? ive never chosen before. I dont know which ones i need things like HiddenCoreModule to apply to? Everything?
It looks like this xposed clone works only in whitelist mode...
I'm quite amazed that this edxposed alternative is running much better than edxposed itself on my android 11, aosp rom, redmi k30 pro zoom. Really glad that I came across this!
Thanks for the great and awesome work devs!
Preparedtobereckless said:
This is what i was confused about? ive never chosen before. I dont know which ones i need things like HiddenCoreModule to apply to? Everything?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apply to System Framework.
Hidden core module do nothing, try no device check module. BTW safetynet passes for me by default.
darashikoh said:
How do I pass safety net? I have universal safety fix module is installed too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What are LSposed module we can use in A11
Im trying to ask the scope list of my modules. Firefds minminguard hiddencore and hide mock location. Anybody can help for the whitelist ??
what does mean: "select other app for each module" ?
for example for "GravitiyBox" module, which app should be enable and why?!
mrhamed said:
what does mean: "select other app for each module" ?
for example for "GravitiyBox" module, which app should be enable and why?!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Android System - android
Call - com.samsung.android.incallui
Camera - com.sec.android.app.camera
Contacts - com.samsung.android.contacts
Email - com.samsung.android.email.provider
Firefds Kit - sb.firefds.r.firefdskit
Messaging - com.samsung.android.messaging
MTP Application - com.samsung.android.MtpApplication
NFC - com.android.nfc
One UI Home - com.sec.android.app.launcher
Settings - com.android.settings
Smart Capture - com.samsung.android.app.smartcapture
Software Update - com.wssyncmldm
System UI - com.android.systemui
It also depends on what firmware you are using amd what features you've enabled in gravity box. Enable these according.
What I've enabled in miui are shown in image below.
a module based selection, what to hook seems a good approach of doing what you want and at the same time saving resources. a more advanced selectiin UI would be good. filter based on words and then select in the filtered list, select deselect all. in addition I have no idea what some modules are hooking like gravity box...this is just an example...I know I can find out however maybe the manager app can support to find out or tick what is recommended
I am trying LSposed on my OnePlus 7 Pro (GM-1917), OOS 10.3.8, Magisk 21.4, xXx 12.4.
I followed these instructions from the OP ...
• Install Riru 23+
• Install Riru - LSPosed via Magisk Manager
• Install LSPosed Manager app
• Reboot your device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got into what seems to be an infinite boot loop. I waited 3-5 minutes, but the boot loop continued.
Has anyone seen this behavior? If so, is there a workaround?
Thank you in advance.
UPDATE: I must have messed up one or more of the installation steps the first time around. I retried installing, and now LSPosed works for me with no boot loop.
OnePlus 7 Pro (GM-1917)
OOS 10.3.8
Magisk 21.4
Magisk Manager 8.0.7
xXx 12.4
Riru 23.4
LSPosed-v0.5.4.0-5135-release.zip (YAHFA)
LSPosedManager-v0.5.4.0-5175-release-signed.apk
Good work!
Onward!
HippoMan said:
I am trying LSposed on my OnePlus 7 Pro (GM-1917), OOS 10.3.8, Magisk 21.4, xXx 12.4.
I followed these instructions from the OP ...
I got into what seems to be an infinite boot loop. I waited 3-5 minutes, but the boot loop continued.
Has anyone seen this behavior? If so, is there a workaround?
Thank you in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Working fine with OnePlus 7t latest beta. There might be some other issue. LSPosed doesn't seem to cause bootloop. Share logcat.
I have a module development question. I don't know exactly where to post this question. If this is not correct place, would you please show me the correct place?
I rebuild an old xposed module and generate signed APK. I can install and use this APK on android 6 and 7 systems with standard Magisk and Xposed. And works perfectly.
But when I use this APK with android 9 and Magisk, riru and edxposed, phone can't be booted. it falls into edxposed bootloop.
When I it use it with Magisk, Zygisk and LSPosed, I can install APK, enable it on LSPosed, but does not function as expected.
When I try to install original old module from repository, it is not possible to install this APK to android 9.
This is the original old module:
LeEco Infrared Fix | Xposed Module Repository
repo.xposed.info
I had to upgrade gradle version and several other configurations to build successfully. It can be running up to android 7, not tried but probably will run up to Android 8. But it is not possible to run android 9 or later.
How can I debug the code, and understand why edxposed fall into bootloop. Are there any log file to examine?
Thanks