Hi,
I´ve problems to using my bank app Caixabank Pay (and I think others too like CaixaBankNow and CaixaBank Sign) on a new Samsung Galaxy S8 (SM-G950F) with a custom rom, while is working in a old phone Xiaomi Mi5s with same app version and same Magisk version with other custom rom.
These are my steps:
I installed the custom ROM (Havoc-OS v4.2) with the Gapps.
Download the CaixaBank Pay app (Google Play: CaixaBank Pay download) and install. The apps works without problem, so the problem isn´t Knox.
Extract `boot.img` from my custom rom, install Magisk 22.1 apk like any other app, patch the image and flash with TWRP the patched image.
Reboot, hide Magisk Manager with "Settings" name, enable MagiskHide and hide the Caixabank app process (es.lacaixa.hceicon2). The result it´s that CaixaBank app detects root and closes inmediatly I try to open .
At this point, if I flash again the original `boot.img`, as the Magisk manager was already hidden under the name of "Settings", the Caixabank app works like a charm...
I tested with this all this varians obtained same results:
Different Magisk versions 22.0, 22.1
Different roms: Havoc-OS 4.2, LineageOS 17.1, HadesRom Q 1.0, ProjectSakura-GAPPS-2.Q-20200915
Safetynet is passed with external checker but not passed with Magisk checker. I think this is normal like I saw in other posts like this or this.
Anyone can test the app, because it´s closed directly and not needed login.
There are the details of the phones:
Xiaomi Mi5s (capricorn)
Android version: 10
Rom: PixelExperience plus capricorn 10
Caixabank app version: 3.90
Magisk Root: 22.0 (22000)
Magisk App: 22.1 (22100) (18) (package name: tybwt.kjnyh)
Status: WORKING
Samsung Galaxy S8 (SM-G950F) (dreamlte)
Android version: 11
Rom: Havoc-OS 4.2
Caixabank app version: 3.90
Magisk Root: 22.0 (22000)
Magisk App: 22.1 (22100) (20) (package name: ken.s.y.br)
Status: NOT WORKING
Anyone have any idea to try...??
Tested with latest Canary (fb8000b5) (22104) and same results...
The unique difference is that Safatynet now passes correctly..
¿Does anyone have any ideas?
Pfff. es para volverse loco (it's just something to turn crazy with)...
I've used it with havoc 2.9 and mi mix 2 without problems, but does not even start with cherishos and android 10, so it depends on the custom rom...
Also as our "beloved" caixabank don't want to pay comission to Google, it does not work with google pay, so "dos piedras" = "bear with it"
New tested with new version and updated ROM, but same results:
Magisk version: 23.0
Different roms: ProjectSakura-5.R-GAPPS-20210525-1250-dreamlte-OFFICIAL
I tested with MomoHider and with Riru Unshare and same results.
Step 5 still working, If I flash the original boot.img temporaly, the apps works correctly..
Albvadi said:
New tested with new version and updated ROM, but same results:
Magisk version: 23.0
Different roms: ProjectSakura-5.R-GAPPS-20210525-1250-dreamlte-OFFICIAL
I tested with MomoHider and with Riru Unshare and same results.
Step 5 still working, If I flash the original boot.img temporaly, the apps works correctly..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The same happens to me on crdroid with android 11 on mi mix 2
Now, In my old phone, itsn´t working anymore....
The Magisk, ROM, app version and all are exactly the same. I haven´t installed nothing new in my phone, simply rebooted a few days ago... But now, it´s detecting root and force close at start...
I tested with XPrivacyLua and same results...
Albvadi said:
Now, In my old phone, itsn´t working anymore....
The Magisk, ROM, app version and all are exactly the same. I haven´t installed nothing new in my phone, simply rebooted a few days ago... But now, it´s detecting root and force close at start...
I tested with XPrivacyLua and same results...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They update frequently their tools with sophisticated root-detection strategies, so it's difficult to be rooted and keep using caixabank apps...
Related
Any version of Xposed works on Max 2? I need to use App Settings module
I've been scouring the internet for days since SDK24 and SDK25 is now officially supported.. But can't seem to find one that actually works.
I obviously went to the official thread the first time around, not working. Xpose is installed and all, but it doesn't work. Has that resource hook error. (similar to this thread)
Tried this SolarWarez Xposed, doesn't work either, both Magisk and System. It says the framework is not active.
I'm using MIUI 9 v7.9.21 from xiaomi.eu, deodexed, bootloader unlocked, Magisk 14, TWRP 3.1.1-0
Cryonics said:
Any version of Xposed works on Max 2? I need to use App Settings module
I've been scouring the internet for days since SDK24 and SDK25 is now officially supported.. But can't seem to find one that actually works.
I obviously went to the official thread the first time around, not working. Xpose is installed and all, but it doesn't work. Has that resource hook error. (similar to this thread)
Tried this SolarWarez Xposed, doesn't work either, both Magisk and System. It says the framework is not active.
I'm using MIUI 9 v7.9.21 from xiaomi.eu, deodexed, bootloader unlocked, Magisk 14, TWRP 3.1.1-0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Works for me =p
P.S: im using lineage.
Cryonics said:
Any version of Xposed works on Max 2? I need to use App Settings module
I've been scouring the internet for days since SDK24 and SDK25 is now officially supported.. But can't seem to find one that actually works.
I obviously went to the official thread the first time around, not working. Xpose is installed and all, but it doesn't work. Has that resource hook error. (similar to this thread)
Tried this SolarWarez Xposed, doesn't work either, both Magisk and System. It says the framework is not active.
I'm using MIUI 9 v7.9.21 from xiaomi.eu, deodexed, bootloader unlocked, Magisk 14, TWRP 3.1.1-0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi
Try downgrading to Magisk 13.3 or so, then use systemless by SolarWarez.
Here is the SolarWarez SDK 25 systemless xposed that works for me: SDK25 version: https://yadi.sk/d/K3dva3gG3MDHRd
The bad news: App Settings's settings dont work/ dont stick for any Nougat device.
Skyolinhelper is a barebones alternative that does work please google it
Sorry I cant help any further
unfortunately it only works with rom deodex. I put the multirom 7.9.21 and xposed works. some modules work but only partly ... i use xmiui (works in part) and one tap video download
Hello,
I used Xposed framework-[UNOFFICIAL] Xposed v88.1 for MIUI 9 [SDK24/25] by Psy_Man, arm64-sdk25 (Android 7.1).. Works perfectly on Xiaomi Max 2 with MIUI 9, version 7.10.12 EU. I use the following modules:
- Flat Style Indicator bars-works fine
- MIUI 8 tweaks-performs partially, without forced stops ....:good:
I finally managed to flash xposed-v88.2-sdk25-arm64-test4.zip from the official MIUI 9 Github thread.
I'm on latest weekly MIUI 9 xiaomi.eu rom (7.10.19), which is Android 7.1 with Magisk 14.0. Flashed via iscle's TWRP.
Download for test4 (Android 7.1), Android 7.0 would be this one
Got the downloadlink from here: http://en.miui.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=946636&highlight=xposed
I suggest you to read the description in the MI Forum thread. I haven't tested any modules yet, I only know that the framework is active for me and that it disabled SafetyNet.
EDIT:I just tried using PBMC (remap hardware buttons), but my phone just quick reboots (with google boot animation instead of xiaomi) as soon as I try to use a remapped button. Is that because of my Xposed version or is it the normal behaviour of miui devices when using these functions? I also tried it with recource apis disabled, same result.. PBMC is my #1 reason for xposed, maybe someone on a different rom or xposed version can try a basic command chain like next media for me?
I tried many many versions of Xposed now (I'm on .eu-rom with miui 9 and Android 7.1), and while I had no bootloops with most of them, not a single one worked with the only app I'm trying to get to work (PBMC). I read somewhere to try the Xposed Magisk module and I did, but it only told me in the Xposed app that "Xposed is not installed"...
Does someone have the time to test the Xposed app PBMC for me? You only have to set the basic chains which the app offers to you, then save, then turn on music, then turn off the Screen and hold up or down. For me everything I do results in a quick reboot. The developer looked at my logs and said it is a xposed problem.
dear friend,
i have problem with app banking mandiri online. the app cannot run on rooted devices with magisk. i have hidden the app with magisk hide on magisk manager but not success. any idea for my problem??
this my rom and magisk i used now.
Mi Globe MIUI 10
ROM VERSION 8.8.30 BETA DEV
ANDROID 8.1.0
MAGISK MANAGER VERSION 6.0.1
MAGISK VERSION 17.3 BETA
thanks
Groovyduck said:
dear friend,
i have problem with app banking mandiri online. the app cannot run on rooted devices with magisk. i have hidden the app with magisk hide on magisk manager but not success. any idea for my problem??
this my rom and magisk i used now.
Mi Globe MIUI 10
ROM VERSION 8.8.30 BETA DEV
ANDROID 8.1.0
MAGISK MANAGER VERSION 6.0.1
MAGISK VERSION 17.3 BETA
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
does the device show certified on google play store ?... try hide props module
altvolt74 said:
does the device show certified on google play store ?... try hide props module
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
where is this props module???
Groovyduck said:
where is this props module???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
is an magisk module ...u can get it whiting magisk module download section
Groovyduck said:
dear friend,
i have problem with app banking mandiri online. the app cannot run on rooted devices with magisk. i have hidden the app with magisk hide on magisk manager but not success. any idea for my problem??
this my rom and magisk i used now.
Mi Globe MIUI 10
ROM VERSION 8.8.30 BETA DEV
ANDROID 8.1.0
MAGISK MANAGER VERSION 6.0.1
MAGISK VERSION 17.3 BETA
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think this is related to the ROM itself, I'm running on Pie Havoc OS and can launch Mandiri Online with Magisk Hide.
maybe you tried first without magisk installed. if still failed, maybe tried to install custom rom such as xiaomi.eu if you want MIUI or Havoc if you want AOSP
thx, my friend my problem is solve. the busybox has installed in my custom rom default. i uninstall the busybox and try again to open app banking is succes.
thank's in advance
Go to settings and choose hide magisk manager.
It will random change package name of magisk and you can use banking app.
If not success I found problem before: remove universal safetynet fix module.
Some trick to get device certified: use magiskhide props config and change value to some xiaomi fingerprint in list.
Groovyduck said:
dear friend,
i have problem with app banking mandiri online. the app cannot run on rooted devices with magisk. i have hidden the app with magisk hide on magisk manager but not success. any idea for my problem??
this my rom and magisk i used now.
Mi Globe MIUI 10
ROM VERSION 8.8.30 BETA DEV
ANDROID 8.1.0
MAGISK MANAGER VERSION 6.0.1
MAGISK VERSION 17.3 BETA
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey!
I'm using a UMIDIGI One Pro with a treble 9.0 ROM (https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...ce-development/9-0-pixelexperience-p-t3833294). With stock oreo ROM everything is working fine but on android 9 I got several problems:
- I'm not able to install new Magisk modules (my phone starts in Magisk Core only mode)
- I'm unable to see super user request using Magisk 1.17.3 or 1.18 (but it is working fine with 1.17.1 so I keep using it)
- In the other hand ctsProfile is false with 1.17.1
Does anyone have an idea to fix these problems?
Thank you,
Thomas
Me too.I'm using lineageos 15.1 on mi 4S
Here are my magisk logs with latest canary version: https://hastebin.com/yizazepeta.js
Here are my details:
Google Pixel
Android Pie
Stock
Bootloader unlocked
I know thatXposed does not support Pie yet. So, I am willing to install Edxposed, instead, or any other fork of Xposed for Pie.
So, how do I install it? Do I download the stock ROM and modify it somehow?
All I really want is Xprivacy, so if anyone also knows of anything else like it for Pie and any custom ROM that includes said alternative, then please tell me what they are (alternative to Xposed and Pie ROM that includes it).
Master Melab said:
Here are my details:
Google Pixel
Android Pie
Stock
Bootloader unlocked
I know thatXposed does not support Pie yet. So, I am willing to install Edxposed, instead, or any other fork of Xposed for Pie with I believe with exposed.
So, how do I install it? Do I download the stock ROM and modify it somehow?
All I really want is Xprivacy, so if anyone also knows of anything else like it for Pie and any custom ROM that includes said alternative, then please tell me what they are (alternative to Xposed and Pie ROM that includes it).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Installation of edxposed is done through magisk.
They are not in the download section of the magisk repo and have to be installed manually in the modules menu with the + button. You will need the 2 files to flash in magisk + the exposed installer from this thread.
If it works you will need xprivacylua ( not xprvacy) which Marcel is currently working on to improve for pie with I believe edxposed.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/android-9-0-xposed-solutions-t3889513
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/modules/xprivacylua6-0-android-privacy-manager-t3730663
As for any other xposed versions for pie I have not heard of any others
Note: edxposed does not work for me on my s8 yet so I am not sure about your pixel.
I can confirm that EdXposed works on Pixel, I have it installed.
Like how @spawnlives said, the installation process is simple enough.
Just be careful what modules you install, a lot of them is not compatible yet and you could end in a bootloop and have to uninstall the modules via twrp.
I suggest you to read the list of compatible modules here.
If you're interested in a privacy module, looks like xprivacylua is already compatible with EdXposed.
spawnlives said:
Installation of edxposed is done through magisk.
They are not in the download section of the magisk repo and have to be installed manually in the modules menu with the + button. You will need the 2 files to flash in magisk + the exposed installer from this thread.
If it works you will need xprivacylua ( not xprvacy) which Marcel is currently working on to improve for pie with I believe edxposed.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/android-9-0-xposed-solutions-t3889513
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/modules/xprivacylua6-0-android-privacy-manager-t3730663
As for any other xposed versions for pie I have not heard of any others
Note: edxposed does not work for me on my s8 yet so I am not sure about your pixel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is Magisk a custom ROM?
Master Melab said:
Is Magisk a custom ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, magisk is a method to root your phone
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382
Hi,
I rooted my OnePlus 8 with Magisk and I'd like to use Magisk hide for my banking app but the SafetyNet test fails.
I did install Edexposed a few months ago to install Youtube Vanced but it's not installed anymore. Do I have to factory reset or is there another fix to my issue ? Magisk version : 20.4, Magisk Manager version : 8.0.0, build : OxygenOS 10.5.10.IN21BA
Thanks !
LucasDupuis32 said:
Hi,
I rooted my OnePlus 8 with Magisk and I'd like to use Magisk hide for my banking app but the SafetyNet test fails.
I did install Edexposed a few months ago to install Youtube Vanced but it's not installed anymore. Do I have to factory reset or is there another fix to my issue ? Magisk version : 20.4, Magisk Manager version : 8.0.0, build : OxygenOS 10.5.10.IN21BA
Thanks !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You shouldn't have used Xposed just for vanced, it has a rootless option, I don't know a way to recover CTS after installing Xposed cause it messes up basic integrity. Some people say if you install the canary version it has a fix for the basic integrity/CTS profile problem, you can look around that front. Sorry for not being able to help you further.
Enviado de meu POCOPHONE F1 usando o Tapatalk
Clear cache for Play Services. That usually helps...