Got a new Moto X4 1900-7 two days ago (reteu channel). Unlocked and rooted with MAGISK 17. Yesterday installed LineageOS 15.1 (Android 8.1 was shown) as described here. AddonSU and MindTheGApps did not work as install from the LineageOS Recovery. So installed them via TWRP.
Today it showed there is a new update for LineageOS. It seemed a good idea to test the update channel. LineageOS downloaded, installed and I pressed the reboot button. Since then the device does not switch on anymore. Just nothing. No lights, no booting screen. Looks fairly hard bricked now.
It is a bit frightening since I made good experiences with LineageOS on Moto X Play for years. But this time it did not work as seamless. As a side note, the second sim slot was disabled. I did not find out, where and how to enable it. This would be issues to be sorted out, before I support the project again.
I appreciate all your efforts about these devices and free software! :good:
Is there a reason you are not posting (and reading) in the proper thread?
https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-x4/development/rom-lineage-os-15-1-t3802265
You will find all your answers there.
The developer specifically advised not to use the OTA updater.
Same issue here. Got a brand new Moto X4 delivered today. Verified nothing was obviously broken (tried WLAN, Cell, Dual SIM from stock). All fine.
Then I installed last night's nightly "lineage-15.1-20181017-nightly-payton-signed.zip" from within TWRP. After installing the nightly, I went with reboot recovery.
Since then, the phone appears hard-bricked as described by halori above.
No lights, no activity. Had it on charger most of the afternoon and all evening (it is 22:13 in Germany now). No signs of life. No matter how long I pressed VOLUMEDOWN+POWER. Same thing if I only press POWER. Same thing if I try charging it for 10-20 minutes, then try switching it one. Neither of the methods works.
Update:
- Similar symptoms, but different way of getting there
- Installed nightly 2018-10-17 via TWRP, *NOT* via OTA
Please post in proper thread.
jhedfors said:
Please post in proper thread.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's a 64-page monster thread. Loads of different topics are "cross-talked". On the last two pages alone there are people
asking whether particular variants can be unlocked,
asking about issues with SIM2,
asking about storage requirements,
responding to those questions and
responding to questions from the pages before.
That thread is pure chaos. Web forums got threads, subjects and all that stuff for a reason: to keep things tidy and on-topic.
No offense meant. It is just very hard to grasp how merging all sorts of topics into one massive thread helps anybody keeping an overview.
Anyways, I posted in the thread, as you asked.
This Lineage is obviously crime with this device - it is just too sensitive to anything than 100% unmodified stock.
Exactly the same here. Today's 10/23 OTA update bricked it. :-/ No lights or anything. Not even from charging. Trying to figure out what to do at this point.
If you've already bricked your device you'll need to restore to stock ( https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-x4/how-to/guide-how-to-flash-official-factory-t3808348 ) and then reinstall LOS.
From there you can apply updates without bricking your device by following this procedure: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77861941&postcount=616
As for finding specific things in the threads, there is a search function within each thread that is your friend.
DISCLAIMER:
Code:
* Your warranty is now void.
*
* I am not responsible for bricked devices, dead SD cards,
* thermonuclear war, or you getting fired because the alarm app failed.
* Please do some research if you have any concerns about features included
* before flashing it! YOU are choosing to make these modifications, and if
* you point the finger at me for messing up your device, I will laugh at you.
INTRODUCTION
This thread is mainly intended for devs (pro devs don't really belong here because they're pro and this thread is useless), for someone who need help to continue the work for Nova and fix the bugs on Pie (not many left). I'll help as long as you can speak English xD (no google translate because it can cause misunderstandings). However, don't expect me to spend the same time into this as i''ve did when i've had the phone. Yes, i no longer have the phone (it's still dead) and if you're not up to date with that, then you can read the announcement here and i've mentioned that i've got a new phone here. On top of this, i can't build anymore because i can't sign up on Google Cloud Platform anymore. I've wrote about this here at the hidden content (below as a side note).
Users can also help with doing researches, testing things and logs.
I don't know if i'll consider to continue working on it myself alone without the phone. I'd need at least to be able to build and then i'd need people to test new builds / flashable zips. At some point i might consider that because i'm missing this phone and the community xD.
SOURCES
Device: https://github.com/skinzor/android_device_huawei_hwcan/tree/lineage-16.0-last
Vendor: https://github.com/skinzor/proprietary_vendor_huawei/tree/lineage-16.0-last
Kernel: https://github.com/skinzor/android_kernel_huawei_msm8953-1/tree/lineage-16.0-last
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's two branches:
1) lineage-16.0: those ones were used when i've booted Pie the first time. Remember that i've wrote about it here? Those ones were updated from mido's ones.
2) lineage-16.0-last. those ones are the last ones and updated, which i've used in my last build. Those ones were continued from previous branch and updated from tissot ones which were / are updated by another dev (not the same dev as on mido). I recommend to continue with this branch, but it's up to you. You might not be able to get a successful or bootable build anymore with lineage-16.0 branch anyway because lineage's sources were updated since then.
I've used mido's trees as reference for lineage 14 and 15 trees too. You can figure that yourself if you check mido's trees and then Nova's ones, as i've cherry-picked the commits. Why did i use mido's trees? Because:
1) It has the same qcom chipset as Nova.
2) It is a popular phone.
3) A good dev was working on it.
4) It has official lineage support.
Now you might ask why i haven't did myself everything from scratch. Well, as a newbie dev, it would've been much harder and would've took much more time. Also, i'd say that there's no point at all to do something from scratch when it was already done unless you want to go the "hard" way, assuming you have time and want to learn more. I've still learnt a lot since i've started.
There are "universal" commits which are about fixes / improvements that can be related to e.g. the android version or the qcom chipset and those commits are usually found in many device trees, so you just cherry-pick them. A good example would be this commit: hwcan: Use mke2fs to create ext4 images.
FIXING THE BUGS OF LINEAGE 16 / PIE
I assume that you've used lineage-16.0-last branch as i've recommended. I no longer remember what bugs had my last build, but i think that the bluetooth was working, while it wasn't working in the build made from old lineage-16.0 branch. However, i remember that it had a new bug and as far as i remember, it was the RIL, but the baseband was showing up. I think i've tried to fix it and i've got it working (i remember that it was about the blobs), but i don't remember how. As of typing now, i've looked into the logcat which i still have and i've seen this:
Code:
F linker : CANNOT LINK EXECUTABLE "/vendor/bin/tftp_server": library "liboemaids_vendor.so" not found
That kind of error is self explanatory: the blob / lib is missing. After i've seen this, i've remembered that it's a new blob which got added in the original commit and which i've cherry-picked here. I didn't include that blob for a reason, but i don't remember that reason lol (it's not that i've forgot it, but i've skipped it for a reason). I remember that back then i've added the blob manually after i've seen the error, but i don't remember if that's what fixed the RIL, so you can try that and let me know.
As i've said already, i don't remember what bugs had that build besides the RIL, so you can try it and let me know.
At the introduction i've mentioned that i can help. I'll help only here on XDA in this thread because it may help other people too if they're having the same error / problem and after all, it's nice to have a thread like this in my opinion.
You can attach the log or paste it to gist github, pastebin, del.dog or any pasting website, but don't paste it in the XDA post because it just sucks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
DOWNLOADS
MEDIAFIRE | ANDROIDFILEHOST
As i've recommended to use lineage-16.0-last branch to build / continue the development, i also recommend to flash that build.
The build from lineage-16.0 branch folder doesn't boot. Back then, when i've seen that it doesn't boot and took a look at the logcat, i've tried the graphic blobs from the tree of zenfone 3 and that one was using them from nokia 7 plus (based on the commit). I had two zips in my PC and i've uploaded both. The first one created is graphic_pie_blobs_zenfone3_nokia_7_plus.zip and the second one sdm_blobs_zenfone3_nokia7_plus.zip, so you flash them in that order. As i've mentioned in that post in which i've said that i've booted Pie, there is some lag / glitches while scrolling, due the display / graphic blobs.
ENDING
As i've promised, i've pushed the tree sources and uploaded my first and last build. The reason i'm willing to help in fixing the bugs is because i'm missing this phone and this community here on XDA (as i've expected xD). It was fun and thanks to this phone and y`all for your support and kind words, i've learnt so many things in this journey. That's simply unforgettable for me.
Hopefully someone will jump on and continue the development further. I'll be here to help.
XDA:DevDB Information
[DEV][9.0] LineageOS 16, ROM for the Huawei Nova/Nova Plus
Contributors
#Henkate
Source Code: https://github.com/skinzor/android_kernel_huawei_msm8953-1/tree/lineage-16.0-last
ROM OS Version: 9.x Pie
ROM Firmware Required: Unlocked bootloader, TWRP
Version Information
Status: Testing
Created 2019-01-02
Last Updated 2019-01-05
Reserved
Reserved
Thank you for all the hard work you put into this. I would try to follow the leads, but for me this phone is dead now. I had hoped it would be something, but naw, just a hunk of something. Maybe someone can pick it up and go with it, encouraged everyone to try. If you are thinking about it Robert @#Henkate will help you. Great person, and this phone got me to know him so boom, good phone.
Maybe this should be in off topic thread, but I will post here.
Thank you for the great work that you have done. You gave us nougat, oreo, almost a pie. LineageOS 15.1 is the best firmware I have ever used. EmUi far behind. Thanks again a lot. Pie is full of bugs (I have already tried), counted a huge list of 10 items, but I think it's time to relax. You gave nova a second life and for that I am grateful to you. I found out that you are switching to another phone. Good luck in developing it, you are a good developer, the main thing is to believe in yourself!
Hi enkate... does wifi calling work on 16 ?
thanks
virusdunil said:
Hi enkate... does wifi calling work on 16 ?
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
He has no way to check. Maybe someone who has flashed it could test.
wow！thx a lot，I will try it now！
Hey Henkate !, Yesterday I installed LOS16, the last build that you compiled, botched and everything, but at the moment of continuing with the initial configuration, the screen does not give an image, the touch works, but it runs out of image: /
Alee.se said:
Hey Henkate !, Yesterday I installed LOS16, the last build that you compiled, botched and everything, but at the moment of continuing with the initial configuration, the screen does not give an image, the touch works, but it runs out of image: /
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With the first build go two files, except for the firmware, responsible for the display. Flash them after flash lineage 16 last build and everything will work
Logcats
Hey there!
Finally tried it. I flashed just the latest build and there is what I got:
After flashing only ROM, it booted, but nothing was drawn at the display. Ok, that was expect
Then I wiped system and data again, flashed the build and both of the other zips (from the first build folder)
It booted fine, RIL was working at start, wifi ok. Many other things couldn't be tested, because randomly (one time taking photos, other when scrolling settings, other when trying to test bluetooth) screen went black the blue led got lit up.
I took a logcat only with errors and it seems there is a lot to fix. Still today (just a lot later today, I have to work) I'm gonna fetch los 16 trees, but I still have no idea how to solve any of the bugs. I'll do a lot of search though.
Here is the gist I made with the logcat I took. Any help would be appreciated.
EDIT
just forgot to mention that besides RIL working, I couldn't make a call (display went black and blue led). When rebooted it, I had no signal reception at all
Vinnom said:
Hey there!
Finally tried it. I flashed just the latest build and there is what I got:
After flashing only ROM, it booted, but nothing was drawn at the display. Ok, that was expect
Then I wiped system and data again, flashed the build and both of the other zips (from the first build folder)
It booted fine, RIL was working at start, wifi ok. Many other things couldn't be tested, because randomly (one time taking photos, other when scrolling settings, other when trying to test bluetooth) screen went black the blue led got lit up.
I took a logcat only with errors and it seems there is a lot to fix. Still today (just a lot later today, I have to work) I'm gonna fetch los 16 trees, but I still have no idea how to solve any of the bugs. I'll do a lot of search though.
Here is the gist I made with the logcat I took. Any help would be appreciated.
EDIT
just forgot to mention that besides RIL working, I couldn't make a call (display went black and blue led). When rebooted it, I had no signal reception at all
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also to the list of bugs: personally, my phone did not work with a SIM card, constant crash of applications. The YouTube crash, the camera does not take a photo (camera stock), after restarting, the fingerprint disappears (it is not deleted from memory, but it can only be unlocked if you make a new fingerprint) Any heavy application will crash after a while
Thx for u work, I have a reboots after few mins the system starts
nova canL11, cant reply link to adb bugreport logs x_x
penk3 said:
Thx for u work, I have a reboots after few mins the system starts
nova canL11, cant reply link to adb bugreport logs x_x
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Disable out sim card
AssasinAkindinov said:
Disable out sim card
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ye, phone in airmode workrd normally,
AssasinAkindinov said:
Also to the list of bugs: personally, my phone did not work with a SIM card, constant crash of applications. The YouTube crash, the camera does not take a photo (camera stock), after restarting, the fingerprint disappears (it is not deleted from memory, but it can only be unlocked if you make a new fingerprint) Any heavy application will crash after a while
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
penk3 said:
Thx for u work, I have a reboots after few mins the system starts
nova canL11, cant reply link to adb bugreport logs x_x
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry guys, no mean to be rude here, but this thread is for development purposes. My point in posting was to give a logcat and receive help to try and fix the bugs I found. I know that when possible, #Henkate gonna take a look and give some directions, so work can be done. So, if you wanna test and see if the rom works for you, that's fine, but provide logs, please. It's good to have other logs and be able to compare if the bugs are the same and I think it can help development a lot (no need to flood with logs either, be reasonable).
Unbrick no screen.
To repair the phone (when there is more image) it must start in fastboot mode and then flash boot image) wait for the phone to go off or remove the battery. When it is off plug the usb cable c on your huawei nova and the phone will show that the phone is charging. Now you can reflash another rom but not lineage os 16. Sorry i use google translation
Android 9 with jdi screen
Android 9 with jdi screen
Amazing near.
As it is known, custom firmware was not friends with the jdi screens.
And here came LOS16 on Android 9. Read reviews that it is now not usable even on smartphones with "normal" screens, what can we say about JDI
But from the realization that he had bought a new phone and having a lot of time, the thought crept in to try to put a fresh custom for total disappointment in his smartphone and quiet use of the new.
However, not everything is so simple. After the first launch, the screen began to flicker well, I thought everything had arrived, now it will get dark and the sensor will fail. Cured with just one reboot. more of this did not happen.
Sim cards did not pull out (I have 2 of them), some wrote that because of them there were some problems crashing and rebooting the system (I don’t have that)
After a night out, the interface began to respond with a delay of 0.5 seconds. (It was cured by a complete reboot) ..
Quickstep launcher is often closed with an error
The camera does not remove the drain, installed from the playlist of the market works without comments.
The navigation bar disappeared after a telephone conversation, when the interlocutor first completed the call (It was decided to reboot)
Vkontakte application crashes, but I use Kate Mobile, it flies with a bang.
YouTube crashes
The sound from the conversational dynamics is quiet, I think you can fix it in the mixer_paths but this is not exactly
Waiting for the moment until the screen fails.
All right, testing 9 android is over!
Discharged the battery to 0, the phone turned off, when turned on, the painfully familiar symptom with the diagnosis "JDI", no image, the screen backlight is on.
Hope no more. I return the phone to the stock and sell it, turn to Meizu pro 7. Thank you all!
R0mi4 said:
All right, testing 9 android is over!
Discharged the battery to 0, the phone turned off, when turned on, the painfully familiar symptom with the diagnosis "JDI", no image, the screen backlight is on.
Hope no more. I return the phone to the stock and sell it, turn to Meizu pro 7. Thank you all!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ты все посты будешь переводить и сюда кидать?) (It is joke)