Related
Well folks, the time has come, every mid month I will start this poll, and when the month ends I will end the poll and post the results in my wiki and thread!
Since this is the first voting thread, there is going to be an introduction .
I want to have a list where people can be specific and choose one ROM, but what if you don't know what to choose? This is what will help.
Poll Has Started!
Will end January 31st, at 11:59:59PM
Any new ROMs will be added in this poll that are released before Jan 24th.
Please, don't post in here requesting advice on what ROM to get, this only a voting thread. If you want to know what ROM to get try some out and use the one you like. Then vote here for the ROM you like the most.
Mods, delete irrelavent posts please
Also,
CHO HTC is the PhamQuang ROM
Please add also PhamQuang ROM (PDAViet)
I think he changed the ROM's name to CHO HTC. You can check my list if you'd like .
Marketing study for cooked ROMs!
HI Tito! i find this thread extremely useful and informative, good idea! It would be even more interesting if cookers would disclose the number of downloads of their ROMs. This is important for everybody as a sort of "marketing study" to understand what the other members are looking for. I was very surprised in noticing that there are less than 0.2 posts per download, and most of the users just silently download the ROM and happily use it! Only when you have issues and/or specific requests - then posts shows up
For example, in my ROM we have achieved 1398 downloads up to now.
Another interesting "marketing" consideration: first users (the techno geeks alias "early adopters" ) downloaded almost only from rapidshare, but when roms stabilize it is mediashare which is mainly used (the early adopter testing validates the ROM for "real users" ) ! i am sure this is correlated with the different use of the PDA.
Sorry Tito, but my last Rom it's called Dark Red and no Dark Blue, I've changed it, how probably I make a new version!
Oh, thanks for the tip, but can you PM me when ever you guys have a change? I don't want this to be error reporting, I want people to post their feedback if they have any , like pzuccel did .
Thanks,
Tito
~~Tito~~ said:
Oh, thanks for the tip, but can you PM me when ever you guys have a change? I don't want this to be error reporting, I want people to post their feedback if they have any , like pzuccel did .
Thanks,
Tito
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
...pzuccel is pzucchel ...
LOL, I always miss that one.
BUMP . Hey people I want your feedback.
Hi,
I am brand new to the ppc and flashing scene.
I read a lot of articles about flashing cooked roms and their pros. Unfortunately I don't have that much time at the moment but I'd better like to flash my HD now rather than later so that I don't need to backup so much data.
I'll have enough time to tweak it a bit and change some registry stuff, installing programms etc but not for flashing it every two weeks.
So I ask you what ROM should I use? Should I go for an official ROM? I would use Duddys or Laurentius if they are really stable. Duddys seems to be great but I fear that I have a lmost no time to care for bugs.
Are there any bugs in Duddys? Which ond would you recommend me to use?
There are bugs in almost everything. Nothing es perfect . Its all up to you, but this isn't the place to post this , a PM would have been better. Check out the blackstone list in my sig. It has more ROMs listed(well its updated, I cant seem to update this poll. . . .). Its all up to what you like and need.
~~Tito~~ said:
BUMP . Hey people I want your feedback.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think the poll is turning out quite fair because the multi roms are getting votes from all languages so of course they will get a more weighted response. Maybe there should be a WWE category for each rom that is multi. Then you could compare like votes.
Matterhorn said:
I don't think the poll is turning out quite fair because the multi roms are getting votes from all languages so of course they will get a more weighted response. I don't know what the answer is though.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But thats only part of a rom, most people will go for a wwe rom and put in a different language, they probably voted for it because they like what the cook put inside his ROM(not just a language).
PhamQuang ROM (PDAViet) rom is my vote but its not on the poll..
Turb0wned said:
PhamQuang ROM (PDAViet) rom is my vote but its not on the poll..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CHO HTC, check in my list, he changed the name.
~~Tito~~ said:
But thats only part of a rom, most people will go for a wwe rom and put in a different language, they probably voted for it because they like what the cook put inside his ROM(not just a language).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am currently using one of the multi ROMs, so I agree that many people like them, including me. I have a statistical background so I couldn't help but open my mouth Anyway, it is all in fun and doesn't have to be statistically perfect
I vote for R3D Dark Red, it's really fast and stable, i've no problems with any application, great work my friend Roby
Voted for Dutty ... Kudos to him for giving us these wonderful roms
~~Tito~~ said:
LOL, I always miss that one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
...well, let's see the positive side: you wrote my name correctly 25% of the times
but don't worry, i complain just to keep your thread high in the list (actually, this is one of the few threads that should be sticky...especially if you would spell my name correctly...)
My favorite
[ROM][WWE][Jan 19]Slim 1.1, Barebone 1.2 [CE OS 20764][UPDATED Jan 20]
Hi
Two great rom both!
I am now on miri rom, but davideucks new rom looks great too.
what are users experince?
brodos123 said:
Hi
Two great rom both!
I am now on miri rom, but davideucks new rom looks great too.
what are users experince?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Buy another HD and flash Davideuck... and... then You can answer by yourself.
Regards,
KCJ
brodos123 said:
Hi
Two great rom both!
I am now on miri rom, but davideucks new rom looks great too.
what are users experince?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does miri ROM include HTC Dialer or Topez Dialer? I hate WM Dialer
affraid of posting
KChauJen said:
Buy another HD and flash Davideuck... and... then You can answer by yourself.
Regards,
KCJ
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am a regular user of this forum, witch is great!
But lately I when reading in the forum, I see a lot of complaining and ruud behavior when someone tries to post a question. Either people are told to search or they are on the wrong thread.
Why so ruud? noticed this is spesially senior members!!
why not try to help or point them in the right direction?
There are more replies on how"stupid" the question rather than just giving an answer or not reply at all
Just my thoughts!
sas90850 said:
Does miri ROM include HTC Dialer or Topez Dialer? I hate WM Dialer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
not sure!
I think it is the wm dialer (dont like it.) too much free space on the top.
I try both.both are fast and now I stay davideuck I like the HTC Dialer
brodos123 said:
I am a regular user of this forum, witch is great!
But lately I when reading in the forum, I see a lot of complaining and ruud behavior when someone tries to post a question. Either people are told to search or they are on the wrong thread.
Why so ruud? noticed this is spesially senior members!!
why not try to help or point them in the right direction?
There are more replies on how"stupid" the question rather than just giving an answer or not reply at all
Just my thoughts!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The reason is, ppl never bother to read the directions and rules set out in the forum, this thread is really not a contribution and does not comply with the specified layouts set out in starting a new thread. Admitably this topic does have some bearing but still its not really necassary.
Yes, you should be afraid of posting its a good thing it stops or prevents every noob starting another useless topic or the same topic over and over again.
If you actually read you would see the exact same question asked over and over and over, I guess that fact that you dont understand is proof that you dont read or search.
This is how I see it and Im a noob!
brodos123 said:
Hi
Two great rom both!
I am now on miri rom, but davideucks new rom looks great too.
what are users experince?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
Why Davideuck or Miri? Maybe you should have check ROMs coocked by Onkolog or PhamQuand. They are very good too and have similar bugs, eg. alarm doesn't work if HD is locked and sleeps, etc.
You should have try out each and make decision. Everyone has personal preferences.
Good luck bro
i'd like Karma rom.
i tried both in davideuck no touch flo but in miri there is both i thing in my opnion miri is better until now
Not working alarm from locked/sleeping state can be fixed with this tweak by enabling wakeup to full power
Try both and see witch one you like best.
dkjm said:
i tried both in davideuck no touch flo but in miri there is both i thing in my opnion miri is better until now
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In Davideuck you can have tf3d it depends wich version you chose...
I have used Miri 7.1 and now I use Davideuck V-7 with Manila. Both are great rom and it is up to you who you prefer. I always liked Davideuck so I use his rom now but thats only my choise.
If you dont like one of them flash the other one
shruff said:
The reason is, ppl never bother to read the directions and rules set out in the forum, this thread is really not a contribution and does not comply with the specified layouts set out in starting a new thread. Admitably this topic does have some bearing but still its not really necassary.
Yes, you should be afraid of posting its a good thing it stops or prevents every noob starting another useless topic or the same topic over and over again.
If you actually read you would see the exact same question asked over and over and over, I guess that fact that you dont understand is proof that you dont read or search.
This is how I see it and Im a noob!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see your point, but when I get a response to my first post to try both versions I think that is not what I asked.
I have tried a lot of roms and it takes a lot of time to test all out! It is not done in one day! to test it it takes at least 2 days.
A forum (like this) is to share knowlage and experinces between users. isnt it?
I tried davideuck but quite lag. now i will change back to miri one
I think
I use Miri Rom 21500 7.2.
I think , if I can say somthing about the differences between the Roms I had to test both first. And If I test both I know or not what I am going to use.
So it is the wrong question !!
The Question is " WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ............ ROMs " ?
That´s what all the people whants to know without testing all ROM a cupple of Day´s without safty to register everything.
seeya
bye
brodos123 said:
I see your point, but when I get a response to my first post to try both versions I think that is not what I asked.
I have tried a lot of roms and it takes a lot of time to test all out! It is not done in one day! to test it it takes at least 2 days.
A forum (like this) is to share knowlage and experinces between users. isnt it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
at least you can do it in the "general" forum not in the ROM Development forum.
you are transforming this forum in yr personal "give me an answer" forum. this is not a Q&A forum. with each answer you get you are pushing away from the first page really important stuff.
now after 13 posts what did u get? did u found somebody that used both ROMs and he can give a ready digested answer? did u really think that u can get a straight answer from such a (useless) thread? choosing a ROM is subjective. asking other's opinion instated of reading the relevant threads with user's opinion and user's reaction is pure laziness and total disregarding the forum rules.
all i (and many others) want is to be able to watch the ROM Development without being bothered by marathon chat threads that keep on growing without any benefit for the community.
KukurikU said:
at least you can do it in the "general" forum not in the ROM Development forum.
you are transforming this forum in yr personal "give me an answer" forum. this is not a Q&A forum. with each answer you get you are pushing away from the first page really important stuff.
now after 13 posts what did u get? did u found somebody that used both ROMs and he can give a ready digested answer? did u really think that u can get a straight answer from such a (useless) thread? choosing a ROM is subjective. asking other's opinion instated of reading the relevant threads with user's opinion and user's reaction is pure laziness and total disregarding the forum rules.
all i (and many others) want is to be able to watch the ROM Development without being bothered but marathon chat threads that keep on growing without any benefit for the community.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok. sorry!
But still I think people can be polite and respctful.
brodos123 said:
ok. sorry!
But still I think people can be polite and respctful.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
we all have high expectations about other ppl.
welcome to the club of the disappointed ones!
I am on onkolog's 6.5 and its pretty AWESOME. I was using miri's 7.1 before I flashed to onkolog's. It is very smooth and I dont have the DayLightSavingTime bug in Manila (going back by an hour) in his ROM. The only complaint I have in onkolog's is the Calculator which SUX, but so does every other 6.5 ROM.
EDIT: I have not tried miri's 7.2 yet, so cannot comment on it.
My dilemma is...
...I am unfortunately a perfectionist.
And both roms, Miri's and davideuck's as well, aren't perfect.
So the following is what I like from Miri's rom:
the "sandclock" that appears when WM works looks much better
the menu icon of "file explorer" looks better (fits to the otehr HQ icons)
to be continued....
and here comes my positive thoughts about davideuck's rom:
RSS HUB onboard
HTC calendar starts the week with Moday
calculator is much better (rotation, you know..)
icon bar at the upper screen is awesome! and not buggy like Miri's
grey theme is great looking with black of Manila!
the used HTC dialer is my favorite (I loost track of all the names, versions and so maybe s.o can tell me which which is...)
to be continued...
what I wish to be introduces (in any of both roms) is...
A weekly view in HTC calendar
FULL German Translation (it ist a dream! not more and not less)
link feeds with RSS HUB when opening a newfeed via link in opera ;-)
stringent use of manila submenus, hints, warnings etc.
Dear all I am opinng this thread to ask you to vote for the best 6.5 ROM so please vote and add link for your favorite 6.5 ROM
Thank you
My favourite 6.5 ROM
In no particular order, my favourite most bestest awesome roms are:
awesome Topix and Laurentius ROMS.....and PhamQuang's.....and Energy Roms are awesome. And how can you leave out Miri's awesome ROMs and Dutty's Leo and Dutty's Turbo. Onkologs ROMs are also awesome as are efsane's and hello nasty's MaryOn. Oh yeah, BlackMartini's ROMS are awesome as were DavidD's ROM's until he sold his blckstone. When i bought my blackstone, the stock Telstra ROM was just as awesome
Also, here's an awesome link to help decide on an awesome ROM:
Best WM ROMs
yung_vu said:
In no particular order, my favourite most bestest awesome roms are:
awesome Topix and Laurentius ROMS.....and PhamQuang's.....and Energy Roms are awesome. And how can you leave out Miri's awesome ROMs and Dutty's Leo and Dutty's Turbo. Onkologs ROMs are also awesome as are efsane's and hello nasty's MaryOn. Oh yeah, BlackMartini's ROMS are awesome as were DavidD's ROM's until he sold his blckstone. When i bought my blackstone, the stock Telstra ROM was just as awesome
Also, here's an awesome link to help decide on an awesome ROM:
Best WM ROMs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats, AWESOME!!!!!!!!!. Great list I'll have to keep it on File!!!!!!
You're kidding me right?
Not to sound rude or anything, but this question has been asked many times already, use the search bar or just take the time to go page by page.
Moderator, please close this thread.
"Basically your asking which rom is best for you, well only you can answer that. Best advice would be to try a few yourself and make your own conclusion" - Fallen Spartan
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=546609
"Opinionated threads are not permitted as they create neverending discussions with no solution as everyone has different opinions. Best advice would be to try a few and make your own conclusion" - Fallen Spartan
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=544029
Mods are sleeping, garbage flies in.
Time to re-thing your geographically mod -spread guys ?
mezolezo said:
Dear all I am opinng this thread to ask you to vote for the best 6.5 ROM so please vote and add link for your favorite 6.5 ROM
Thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The best is for you to read and follow forum guidelines, all you noobs never bother to use initiative I guess its just typical of this lazy generation!
After 35 posts you should know better, just look at pages 2-3-4-5 and see how many similar threads like this one (that are closed). The Angel may not have fallen yet but rest assured he shall put an end to this useless thread.
Your welcome
shruff said:
The Angel may not have fallen yet but rest assured he shall put an end to this useless thread.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I liked that
@ mezolezo - As stated previously opinionated threads are frowned upon in XDA as they create endless long threads with no resolution. Everyone has different tates, likes & dislikes, so what you like, I may not. This is why threads like this one is closed.
Also, if you had used the search function (and read the forum rules) you would have relaised that this question or similar question had been asked countless times bfore with same result
Thread closed
Dear All:
A quick look on Rhodium main page will show that there are few active rom designers in town. According to so many people, NRGZ28 leads the design of WM6.5 for Rhodium (and some other devices) because of his skills and remarkable talent at times when other rom bakers are barely able to assemble a program here and a patch there to a WM6.5 build.
Yet, NRGZ28 has gone against almost all other rom designers by keeping his rom for public and not imposing silly mean rules for download for people. Why?
This is because NRGZ28 remains a great person and a talented chef.
I invite everyone to thank NRGZ28 for his work and his gentle devotion to help others. Let this thread be about how many people like NRGZ28 for his talent and his kindness.
I also add that I had the chance to interface with NRGZ28 indirectly and I was amazed that he was cooperative on few matters so I want to thank him personally and warmly for his understanding and coopeartion.
Samer.
NRGZ28
I am a big fan of his work...have thanked him and also donated ...I really hope everyone else also shows appreciation and this thread becomes longer than his ROM threads with appreciation and donations!!!!
will a mod please close this!!
cobbs said:
will a mod please close this!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
any particular reason?
Every user has their own choice of what they like in their ROMs and find some a certain Chef's ROM better to their liking than other Chefs.
I will take your silly rule comment personally since I am one of those chefs with the silly rules.
Many chef's in this forum have their own silly rules for whatever the case may be.
For myself, I release enough stuff without any silly rules. If I want to put extra time and making something extra nice for people who are active members of the community and/or donated to me that is my choice and I do it as my way of saying thanks for being so considerate of the time I put in. More than 70% of the people I email my private ROMs about have not donated and are just active members of the community. Who do not give a thanks that you are looking for with NRG.
Another reason is because of the lack of a thanks for the type of ROMs I do not even use myself. For the same reason you stated about showing a thanks to NRG is the one of the reasons I have my own system. I am sure other chefs feel the same way too.
I can think of 4 off hand that have "silly rules" for their own reasons.
The only best design in town is what the user prefers. I am sure many people will say Tom, myself, Ark666, itje, udk and any other chef is the best design in town. So to make a comment like that is just "silly" since your tastes are not reflected by everyone else.
>Samer
All rom customizers will be happy and continue their work here as long it can be if all custom rom user has behaviour like you. Not like other users whose like critics, complaints, request this, request that, asking this and that, like a boss. fcuk!
samery said:
any particular reason?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cause it looks like you are trying to start trouble...should we have a thread about every chef and giving thanks?
Ever think some chefs page views are bigger cause there are more bugs so people are going back or they release ROMs very often to correct bugs or that is what they like to do by releasing ROMs often?
At0mAng
Hi, which one is you in the avatar? left or right?
HT© said:
Hi, which one is you in the avatar? left or right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hehe Looking at it my brain is on the left
Samer,
At0mAng is correct. Chef appreciation threads will soon degrade into fighting. I know your intentions are good, but this thread won't bring much to the community.
Thread Closed.
Dave
it's 2010! Lets start off the year by voting for our favorite ROMS! Whose will will out in the end? Lets see.
My main concerns are stability, speed and cool factor, in that order. What are yours?
My hats off to all the hard working cooks!
(P.S. Rhodium ROMS only here)
by the way, please tell me if I missed any prominent ROM series
by the way, please tell me if I missed any prominent ROM series
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
mightyrom?
is that one for the Touch Pro 2?
hmm, is possible to edit the poll to add options after it has been started?
phony said:
hmm, is possible to edit the poll to add options after it has been started?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi mightyrom thats a cdma rom mod can edit poll
I vote: Mods close this thread
The poll is not per ROM series but by chefs name, and considering most chefs create a number of different ROMs varying in build number and Sense releases, this is impossible to quantify. and as always and has been stated many many many times each person prefers a different ROM for different reasons.
It is not in the spirit of the forum to create a thread like this and I actually believe it to be not a productive thing to do, as well as a waste of server space.
osrix25 said:
I vote: Mods close this thread
The poll is not per ROM series but by chefs name, and considering most chefs create a number of different ROMs varying in build number and Sense releases, this is impossible to quantify. and as always and has been stated many many many times each person prefers a different ROM for different reasons.
It is not in the spirit of the forum to create a thread like this and I actually believe it to be not a productive thing to do, as well as a waste of server space.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1....
I totally agree
Actually, as a new tp2 user, i only wish a thread like this one existed before i had to waste 10 hours trying out various roms.
Which i still am by the way
Thanks to all the chefs
Dutty's rom?
Actually, as a new tp2 user, i only wish a thread like this one existed before i had to waste 10 hours trying out various roms.
Which i still am by the way
Thanks to all the chefs
With all due respect, won't this poll just be a test of how popular each ROM series is ? Which you could probably judge anyway by seeing how busy the ROM-specific threads are ?
I don't get it
What is the purpose of such poll... everyone has different needs, it just mesure the popularity as perfectly noted and not how good are the ROMs.
My respect to ALL cooks who spend time and energy to try to do the best. And it you really want to compare, benchmarks seem to be a more objective way to do it like it was done for the Topaz or some other phones but of course you need more time to do so.
Best
thread closed
as polls and questions on "best rom" always end in fighting.
thank you