I was looking for some cases on ebay/amazon/google and I stumbled upon the Icon Guardian Case:
*sorry can't post link due to my "status"
Has anyone had experience with this type of case. Its looks ackward but I like the enlarged corners, it reminds me of the ballistic series in a way. Might give this a shot until a true rugged case hits the market.
I found it on amazon and it has good reviews so far: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B008TX9268/ref=cm_sw_r_an_am_ap_am_us?ie=UTF8
Sent from my ASUS Transformer Pad TF700T using XDA Premium HD app
it looks sick. wish I knew about it before getting the bodyglove
What's so bad about the body glove?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Mwinggg said:
What's so bad about the body glove?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The body glove is not bad, what Dioscorus meant was he paid $25 for the body glove and he could have bough a similar case on Amazon in the 'Icon Guardian ' that has a similar or perhaps superior function with aesthetics at half the cost.
Where can I buy this in Canada ??? Can't find it on ebay.ca or amazon.ca
THS1989 said:
Where can I buy this in Canada ??? Can't find it on ebay.ca or amazon.ca
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias=aps&field-keywords=samsung+note+2+guardian
You can purchase it and have it shipped to Canada. There store page shows that they ship to canada at almost double the shipping price though.
Heres their page:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aag/detail...eID=ATVPDKIKX0DER&seller=A1QGIDACEIIO9M#rates
Has anyone gotten this yet?
Looks pretty nice - I tried the samsung flip, but it offers NO protection.
sonicthoughts said:
Looks pretty nice - I tried the samsung flip, but it offers NO protection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, the flip offers 100% more screen side protection than this case. Side note, you thought the flip would offer anything more than that? It's pretty obvious when looking at it that it won't.
I decided I liked the front screen protection from the flip so much I purchased this to get The Best of Both Worlds
Back to the Ionic case... is it me, or does it look like polka dots?
I ordered it earlier this week, should have it next week. I'll review it once I get a couple of weeks under my belt.
My case arrived today and I'm impressed to say the least. It won't replace an Aegis or Ballistic, but will definitely hold you over and for some be just enough. I took a lot of pics and I'm going to upload shortly.
Sent from my ASUS Transformer Pad TF700T using XDA Premium HD app
ok all, basically this is a very nice case that is worth much more than the ~$15 (including shipping in the US) that it actually costs. It fits really nicely and actually feels excellent. Very little bulk is added from this two piece case, while at the same time it adds pretty good protection around all areas except for the screen of course. it is raised around the screen edges, so that you can place the phone face down and not have it touching a flat surface...hopefully good for the dreaded face smack down.
my only semi-negative i could find is that the upper and lower edges on the front face side are not very tight. this is because the outer piece provides sturdiness around the entire device except for the upper and lower edge. the side edges of the inner gel piece are held sturdy due to the hard ridge of the outer cover.
nevertheless, i don't believe this is a big issue unless it becomes really weak and flimsy after prolonged use & wear (stay tuned). Despite that weakness, I also don't believe you will find yourself playing with it and even noticing that much. The case feels excellent in hand, sturdy, and gives you the feeling that it is protected.
As stated, very little bulk is added. In fact, it actually feels thinner than my Trident Aegis that fits on my GS2 Epic Touch. It feels just as sturdy as the Aegis, again except for that which is mentioned of the top and bottom edge. The Aegis eliminates this problem by extending the outer hard ridge up to the same area as it does with the sides. If the Ionic Guardian had this it would be on par with the Aegis (mind you that Trident has a newer design for the Aegis GN2 model, so I'm speaking about the previous model design). Also, there are no dust covers for the 3.5mm jack or the micro usb port. I'd like to see this on this design, but again that is something that Trident gets right and I don't know of other companies really doing the same other than Otterbox.
The case has corners that are very similar to the Ballistic SG design and is basically a copy cat, IMHO. I have never owned a Ballistic so I can't say if it is as sturdy or provides the same amount of protection. I also noticed that the upcoming Ballistic SG also doesn't have the outer case extending over the top and bottom sides or the inner gel. It also looks like they have shrunk the corners a bit as they don't look as pronounced. This may mean that the Ionic Guardian may just be a prototype of sorts of the upcoming Ballistic SG and therefore give you a very close idea of how that case will be. That all being said, I'm wondering how much protection the corners really add to this device. I'm not even tempted to test it out, which is a downside in and of itself, as with my Aegis for the GS2 I found myself bouncing it on stuff all the time with no thought of damage.
Also, remember this is a 2-Piece design. Both the gel and the hard outer shell make up a nice case, but the gel as a stand alone is thin and doesn't give you that confident feeling that you have from the gel from the Trident Aegis or other upper end combo style cases. The outer shell does feel sturdy and may be only a tad bit thinner than the Trident shell.
Overall, I give the Ionic Guardian Case a much deserved 8 out of 10. I'm only taking points away due to the designers not using the outer shell to add support for the gel's upper and bottom edges, and also that the gel itself could be .5mm thicker. That being said, this case is excellent for the price and IMHO it is high value protective case for the GN2, maybe the best available right now. I think the Otterbox Commuter, Trident Aegis, and Ballistic SG are all likely superior...but maybe not by much.
The other phone in the pics is my GS2 Epic Touch in a Trident Aegis Case.
check out the pics:
I also purchased this case and was a bit hesitant at first about the "polka dot" appearance. But once I got the case and put it on the Note II, all hesitations disappeared! Imho the side rockers are much easier to push with this case on. I must say, I can tell very little if any difference between the quality of this case compared to something like the Ballistic Shell Gel case I have on the gs3. Like mentioned above, the very top and bottom rubber is a bit flimsy, but really there isn't much device real estate available to firm it up much more. All ports and S-pen are easily accessed. For the $ of this case, I don't think you could go wrong. I bought it as a temporary case till the Ballistic or Otter comes out, but honestly I don't know if I want to fork out triple the green backs when this case seems to fit my needs just right.
If you're looking for something that doesn't add a lot of bulk, adds some nice grip and protection, check out this case. It's cheap and worthy in my opinion
I returned my Seidio because the soft rubber is not on very tight at the top and bottom edge. Looks like this one has the same problem. Going to try this $10 that has a hard shell that covers the sides, top, and bottom. Hopefully it will eliminate the short coming of the Sedio and Iconic. Also hopefully the rubber in this case won't be a lint magnet:
I've owned the Ionic Guardian Case for around 2 weeks now and I have had the Ballistic SG case for a week.
Here's the comparison:
Ionic Guardian Case
Pros:
-Great bang for buck
-Slim
-Good Build Quality
-Cut outs match almost perfectly
-Reinforced Corners
-Lay Flat feature
-Little pods in the back provide better grip
-Easy to remove
Cons:
-Silicon is somewhat frail, should be a tad thicker for better protection
-No port covers
-Silicon is not tight enough especially at the top and bottom
-Top and Bottom protection is almost non existent with the thinness of the silicon, phone will get damaged if dropped directly on its bottom surface or top surface.
Ballistic SG
Pros:
-Moderately Slim
-Good Build Quality
-Reinforced Corners
-Lay Flat feature
-Easy to remove
-Good side protection
-Very good drop protection if dropped on the back
Cons:
-Silicon is not "dense" enough especially compared to other models ex: iphone 5
--No port covers
-Silicon is not tight enough especially at the top and bottom
-Top and Bottom protection is almost non existent with the thinness of the silicon, phone will get damaged if dropped directly on its bottom surface or top surface
If you haven't noticed the Ionic is almost an exact duplicate of the SG case, here's how they compare to each other.
Build Quality: Ballistic wins but a small margin. It has a stronger silicon and thicker polycarbonate shell
Corner Protection: Ballistics corners are more dense and has less give.
Flat Screen Drop Protection: Ballistic would probably win due to its thicker corners and slightly higher edges on the front screen.
Back Screen Protection: Ballistic would win with its superior polycarbonate shell
Top Drop Protection: Neither because quite frankly, they both suck and would shatter on impact
Bottom Drop Protection: see above
Basically the Ionic is a poor man's Ballistic SG case. I bought my Ionic for $13 and my Ballistic for $26. If I had to choose again I would probably just buy the Ionic due to its moderate protection but if you have that extra money to fork over, they get the ballistic for slightly better build and protection. Overall I am disappointed that both cases couldn't deliver on the protection from the top and bottom, but other than that I feel safer than if the phone was naked.
Heres a breakdown of the pics:
1-7: Ballistic 1) Front 2) Back 3) Lay-Flat feature 4) Corner 5) Unimpressive bottom lip 6) Unimpressive top lip 7) Sides
8-14: Ionic 1) Front 2) Back 3) Lay-Flat feature 4) Corner 5) Unimpressive bottom lip 6) Unimpressive top lip 7) Sides
15-20: Comparison of 1) Fronts 2) Backs 3) Corners 4) Top 5) Bottom 6) Sides
Enjoy and Thank me if you found this helpful.
Related
Hey guys,
Currently in South America and have not posted a video in a couple of days since I can’t seem to find a decent internet connection to upload, anyways I wanted to take some time to write an overview of all cases I’ve tried out and separate them into groups.
Hard Shell Cases
Incipio Feather – $24.99 – The only complete hard shell case featuring a soft touch coated polycarbonate which snaps onto your device with ease. Protects the majority of the device save for the top and bottom which are slightly exposed. Although a little pricey, it keeps the slim form factor of the device and is comfortable to use. Will provide minimal drop protection and good scratch protection.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwQP5IpLQC8
*Note* - i9020 model only
SGP Valencia - $37.99/$39.99 - Hard shell case covered in premium genuine leather, feels wonderful in hand and adds a lot of cushioning against impacts. The front flap design protects screen when not in use but can be cumbersome otherwise, device fits in snug but the case does add some bulk. Will provide good drop and scratch protection.
Video Review- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Avlt6hz-1r0
*Note* - i9020 model and Sprint 4G compatible
PDAir Aluminum Metal Case - $27.99 - Aluminum case with neoprene lining on the inside to provide padding to Nexus S. Choice of materials is top notch, case is a little thick but still manageable, looks good but hinge mechanism could be improved.
Video Review- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eg-L-_pyy5g
*Note* - i9020 model only (no word on 4G model compatibility)
Silicone, TPU and Rubber Cases
Rearth Ringke - $16.99 – A silicone case coated in a high quality polymer which repels dust and lint as well as providing a smooth finish. Flexible but still rigid, the case fits tightly and keeps a thin form factor. Cutouts and buttons are all easily accessible. Great value for money and a good option for anyone. Will provide minimal drop protection and good scratch protection.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yo9swPPpDVU
*Note* - i9020 model only
SGP Ultra Silke - $19.99 – Featuring a form factor similar to that of the Ringke, SGP’s Ultra Silke only varies in terms of material. Made from high quality silicone, the Silke does not feel as great as the Ringke but still does an admirable job. Silicone is smooth and does not attract dust, best of all, the package includes what I believe to be the highest quality screen protector on the market, definitely a good buy. Will provide minimal drop protection and good scratch protection.
Video Review- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMQz2rN_bSM
*Note* - i9020 and Sprint 4G compatible.
Proporta Mizu Shell - approx. 32$ – Another case that resembles the form factor of the Ringke and Silke, made fully of TPU, the Mizu Shell wraps around the device tightly, preventing dust/debris from entering. Although almost twice the price of the Ringke, the Mizu shell is still a fantastic case and will offer above average protection, cushioning your device if you were to drop out. The only negative on the case is the fingerprints/oils that show up on the back after extended usage.
Video Review- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vw-DUqeQi-k
*Note* - i9020 compatible, no word on others
Hybrid Cases
Case-Mate Pop - $34.99 – Comprised of a hard, glossy plastic wrapped around silicone rubber, the Pop seems to be the most popular case on the market, little pricey though. Feel and grip on the case are superb, while the plastic tends to scratch up a little, you won’t be disappointed with the overall protection as this is the slimmest of the hybrid cases and still manages to provide a tight fit, good drop and scratch protection.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4auzR3OVB8
*Note* - i9020 model and Sprint 4G compatible.
Seidio Innocase Active X - $29.99 – A two piece case made up of a soft inner silicone layer encased by a soft touch plastic spine. Not a fan of the quality of the silicone as it tends to pick up dust and lint and is somewhat stretchy, however the spine remedies that by holding it tightly in place. Adds some thickness but provides good protection. Decent choice overall.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqYkfu93hmo
*Note* - i9020 and Sprint 4G compatible.
Trident Cyclops – $34.95 – Best protection available for your device, no questions asked. Two piece plastic case with a built in screen protector is wrapped by a silicone bumper that adds grip and even more added drop protection around the corners. Only downside is the bulk and thickness of the case, if you can handle it you’ll be pleased.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MenxwxVixGM
*Note* - i9020 and Sprint 4G compatible.
Skins/Screen Shields
BodyGuardz - $24.95 – Thin, clear membranes that cover your device, providing only scratch protection. The beauty of this is it adds virtually no bulk but your device is still protected from dirt, debris and scratches. Pack comes with 2 sets (2 screen shield, 2 backs) so good value for me, available in both Dry Apply and Wet Apply models.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r71OlL22fYU
*Note* - i9020 and Sprint 4G compatible.
Gelaskins - $14.95 – Made from 3M Printing material, Gelaskins follow the same idea as BodyGuardz but add uniqueness and design in the form of the printed artwork. A little thicker than BodyGuardz but still keeps a thin form factor. Can be removed and reused at a later date.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96d_Ti-zbGU
*Note* - i9020 only
SGP Ultra Optics - $15.99 – High quality screen shield offering an anti-fingerprint coating without affecting screen quality. Extremely easy to apply and adds a smooth feel when using the display. Only downside is the slightly squeak heard when using it, nothing major. 2 in a pack so you can save a spare.
Video Review - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDOswgrYuP0
*Note* - i9020 and Sprint 4G compatible
Overall, my favorites are the Case-Mate Pop and Rearth Ringke for cases, and I always use the SGP Ultra Optics as my screen protector. I switch between a lot of them though, depending on what I'm doing. However up to now I haven't found a case that is terrible, so by choosing any of the ones above you most likely won't be disappointed.
Edit- After trying out the Proporta Mizu Shell, I've decided to add it onto my Top 3 cases - it is relatively slim, stylish and adds good protection.
thanks for review, i was on the hunt for a case and this will help me choose one
Wow, nice write up. I am using the 6 dollar one from amazon right now, but will be checking some of those out.
Glad to help guys!
It's been mentioned in a couple of videos that the trident cyclops leaves a noticeable gap between the protector and the phone due to the curved screen. The trident aegis with a good stick on screen protector might be a better recommendation. Plus, it's 5 dollars cheaper. I'll post a review once mine arrives.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
The Case-Mate Pop works on the NS4G. I have one on my sprint phone now. I really like it so far.
crasch said:
The Case-Mate Pop works on the NS4G. I have one on my sprint phone now. I really like it so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is the power button/volume easy to press in it? What is the extra bulk like? I'm in SD also, did you pick it up at Fry's? I saw that they sell them there.
crasch said:
The Case-Mate Pop works on the NS4G. I have one on my sprint phone now. I really like it so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for letting me know, I'm going by what I've read on forums + manufacturers.
Does the silicone on the Pop case start to get nasty after a week or so? I had one for my Thunderbolt and it started to peel/crack. Got it replaced twice and finally my money back.
A good cheap silicone case for the Nexus S is the Amzer Jelly case. Usually doesn't go for more than $8-$10. Resists dust pretty well, but like all silicone cases there is noticeable flimsiness on the sides. Dust does get inside the case and on the tiny crevices on the bezel of the phone. The texture of the case makes it very good for holding while the smooth backing allows it to slide in and out of a pocket easily. The buttons are responsive and give a click sound when being pressed. I combine this with a Zagg shield for the screen protection. All in all, a good cheap purchase till I can find a better case (which is probably the Trident one that I ordered).
mbh87 said:
Does the silicone on the Pop case start to get nasty after a week or so? I had one for my Thunderbolt and it started to peel/crack. Got it replaced twice and finally my money back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The silicone on the lip does tend to wear off a little but it's nothing major, it's just a minor cosmetic issue.
Ploone said:
The silicone on the lip does tend to wear off a little but it's nothing major, it's just a minor cosmetic issue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gonna have to pass then. At $35, it shouldnt have that issue. Its a well known issue too.
any one has any idea whether the barely there case by case mate is gonna be available any time soon. im a fan of those.
Went to Fry's to buy the Case Mate Pop! today at lunch. The case is awesome! Fits great, power button is very responsive and overall much better than the Sprint Black TPU case.
I hope the silicon doesn't peel/crack and get nasty like mentioned! If it does though I will continue getting replacements as the case is awesome!
lembowski said:
Went to Fry's to buy the Case Mate Pop! today at lunch. The case is awesome! Fits great, power button is very responsive and overall much better than the Sprint Black TPU case.
I hope the silicon doesn't peel/crack and get nasty like mentioned! If it does though I will continue getting replacements as the case is awesome!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It will, pretty quickly too.
sagarpruthi said:
any one has any idea whether the barely there case by case mate is gonna be available any time soon. im a fan of those.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
According to my contact over there they have no plans to release one (although I did ask back in March), I hope I'm wrong though!
Ploone said:
According to my contact over there they have no plans to release one (although I did ask back in March), I hope I'm wrong though!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the info man.. I hope they release it though.
I think i have found an alternative to the Otterbox Defender Series. It's the Seidio Convert (use to be the Rugged series)
Basically it's a Seidio Active X on top of a Seidio Surface with a holster. 3 layers of protection. I ordered mine from ebay for 50$. I can't post link yet so make a search on google for Seidio Convert Nexus S and you'll find it.
genexxa72 said:
I think i have found an alternative to the Otterbox Defender Series. It's the Seidio Convert (use to be the Rugged series)
Basically it's a Seidio Active X on top of a Seidio Surface with a holster. 3 layers of protection. I ordered mine from ebay for 50$. I can't post link yet so make a search on google for Seidio Convert Nexus S and you'll find it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I prefer the Trident Cyclops to the Active X personally, however the Cyclops has no holster/belt clip.
Ploone said:
I prefer the Trident Cyclops to the Active X personally, however the Cyclops has no holster/belt clip.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can purchase a holster from Trident separately for $10 with free shipping.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
Can anyone provide an Aegis vs Commuter review/comparison, as these are supposedly two of the best and most promoted cases for this device and offer very similar options. In the past I have had both the Trident Aegis, Trident Kraken, and Otterbox Defender, for my Epic Touch and preferred the Trident. But now, Trident seems to have changed the design and I'd like to see what people who have had both think of them.
Dude just search!!
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda premium
shook187 said:
Dude just search!!
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've just been reporting these threads. This is terrible already.
Best way I can describe the Aegis is its like a 2 layer TPU case (hardplasic shell covered on corners with black rubber silicone); it offers a little more protection then a TPU since the inside also has rubber for cushion. Despite this tho, the case isn't made for drops or falls from a decent height like 5ft+. In addition the case doesn't offer much screen protection; there isn't much raised edges (you can prob put it facedown but at your own risk) and any drops/falls on its face is certain to hurt the screen unless you have a screen protector or extremely lucky. Usability is very nice, feels awesome in hand and keeps the thin form factor of the Note 2. Buttons (covered by rubber) are super responsive which surprised me bc other like cases they are hard to press but not this case.
Overall its a stylish case with a little protection (but not much) so keep that in mind; should be fine for daily use just don't drop it esp on its face (I do think it could survive a fall from 7ft+ but not on its face tho)
As far as the Commuter, I am getting it this week and will give a review.
I like the commuter but if the buttons are hard like on the GS3 I'm not interested.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using xda premium
Here are a bunch of pictures comparing the two cases. Hopefully they offer some needed perspectives.
After using both cases, I can give some feedback. The Otterbox definitely adds significantly more protection. I wouldn't even put them in the same class of case in that respect. You can see in the picture of the screen in the commuter case that the lip around the edge is 3x - 4x more than the Trident. This is nice for lying it flat on a table which I do constantly. Theoretically it might protect better on a screen first drop as well.
In the pictures of the cases overlapped, you can see the Otterbox has a much larger silicone layer on all sides and corners. The polycarbonate shell also wraps much further around the top and bottom and is much thicker in general. This adds nice protection to both ends of the case. Dust flaps on the Commuter are more of a sealed design. They are a tad small, but at least they lock into the hard outer shell so aren't in danger of becoming floppy.
The cut out for the s-pen is larger on the Otterbox. It makes grabbing that out much easier. There is no dust cover over the speaker on the Commuter like there is on the Aegis. All microphones and speakers line up great on both cases though.
The Commuter adds more weight and is quite a bit larger in the hand. The added thickness in both layers, the silicone and polycarbonate, are noticeable when you hold it. This makes the phone feel much better protected. Perhaps the major draw back on the Commuter's shell is that its quite slick. For those that hate slippery cases you might be concerned about this aspect. If I had it on a table, I could probably slide it across fairly easy by giving it a push to someone sitting a few chairs away, just to give an idea of what I mean. I'm considering getting a FlyGrip, more for the kickstand ability than the added grip. The slippery feeling on the Commuter doesn't bother me. I will say I prefer the feel of the Aegis though. Its a very nice feeling case.
When it comes down to it, these two cases really are in different categories. It depends on your needs and what your preferences are if you're trying to decide which one is better. The Aegis is a very nice feeling, great functioning slim design case. It adds a slight amount of protection above a typical tpu, but I wouldn't put it in the realm of full drop protection. The Commuter adds substantial protection. I'm sure its less than a defender class case, but I feel pretty secure with its ability to survive the average drop. I also like the added height on the ridge around the screen as compared to the Trident. The Otterbox does add some bulk and weight over a slim design like the Trident, but this is the entry fee into more protection really. The Commuter is about is slim as you could expect for the level of protection it provides.
As usual, feel free to ask any questions about the two cases or how they compare to each other. You can also request specific pictures and I will try to provide them.
shook187 said:
Dude just search!!
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did search, lol. Their aren't posts comparing the new model aegis with the current otterbox commuter for the Note 2. This is what I'm specifically asking about. I'm not a newbie posting for the fun of it.
Sent from my SPH-L900 using XDA Premium HD app
Wolf's Rain said:
Here are a bunch of pictures comparing the two cases. Hopefully they offer some needed perspectives.
After using both cases, I can give some feedback. The Otterbox definitely adds significantly more protection. I wouldn't even put them in the same class of case in that respect. You can see in the picture of the screen in the commuter case that the lip around the edge is 3x - 4x more than the Trident. This is nice for lying it flat on a table which I do constantly. Theoretically it might protect better on a screen first drop as well.
In the pictures of the cases overlapped, you can see the Otterbox has a much larger silicone layer on all sides and corners. The polycarbonate shell also wraps much further around the top and bottom and is much thicker in general. This adds nice protection to both ends of the case. Dust flaps on the Commuter are more of a sealed design. They are a tad small, but at least they lock into the hard outer shell so aren't in danger of becoming floppy.
The cut out for the s-pen is larger on the Otterbox. It makes grabbing that out much easier. There is no dust cover over the speaker on the Commuter like there is on the Aegis. All microphones and speakers line up great on both cases though.
The Commuter adds more weight and is quite a bit larger in the hand. The added thickness in both layers, the silicone and polycarbonate, are noticeable when you hold it. This makes the phone feel much better protected. Perhaps the major draw back on the Commuter's shell is that its quite slick. For those that hate slippery cases you might be concerned about this aspect. If I had it on a table, I could probably slide it across fairly easy by giving it a push to someone sitting a few chairs away, just to give an idea of what I mean. I'm considering getting a FlyGrip, more for the kickstand ability than the added grip. The slippery feeling on the Commuter doesn't bother me. I will say I prefer the feel of the Aegis though. Its a very nice feeling case.
When it comes down to it, these two cases really are in different categories. It depends on your needs and what your preferences are if you're trying to decide which one is better. The Aegis is a very nice feeling, great functioning slim design case. It adds a slight amount of protection above a typical tpu, but I wouldn't put it in the realm of full drop protection. The Commuter adds substantial protection. I'm sure its less than a defender class case, but I feel pretty secure with its ability to survive the average drop. I also like the added height on the ridge around the screen as compared to the Trident. The Otterbox does add some bulk and weight over a slim design like the Trident, but this is the entry fee into more protection really. The Commuter is about is slim as you could expect for the level of protection it provides.
As usual, feel free to ask any questions about the two cases or how they compare to each other. You can also request specific pictures and I will try to provide them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much for this well written post, exactly the information I was looking for. Unfortunately the design change of the Aegis is so different from that of the Epic Touch that I'll be passing on it. I really like their previous 2 layer design.
For me it now boils down to the Commuter and it's quality protection although limited style and slippery feel, or the Incipio DualPro Shine with it's presumably less protective dual layer design and more stylish look and feel.
Thanks again for the review!
Sent from my SPH-L900 using XDA Premium HD app
I got a case for my droid2 at the verizon store when I bought my phone. No name that I know of. It was rubbery and had superb grip. I think I could lay it on the roof of my car and drive around with it and it would remain there.
It definitely would never slide off a table or slip out of my hand.
I want this for my note 2. Or at least some type of non-slippery grip.
My wife has the UAG for her S3 and while I like it... it seems slippery as hell. It's marginally better than the phone itself IMO. I really like the design for the note 2 but am hesitant for the above reason.
I'm leaning toward the Trident AEGIS now. I've watched an hour of different reviews on youtube and read countless threads here on the case and nobody really mentions the grip in any detail.
Does this seem like it would fit the bill for me? Can anyone who has or has had one comment on this aspect?
Thanks.
mokumegane said:
I got a case for my droid2 at the verizon store when I bought my phone. No name that I know of. It was rubbery and had superb grip. I think I could lay it on the roof of my car and drive around with it and it would remain there.
It definitely would never slide off a table or slip out of my hand.
I want this for my note 2. Or at least some type of non-slippery grip.
My wife has the UAG for her S3 and while I like it... it seems slippery as hell. It's marginally better than the phone itself IMO. I really like the design for the note 2 but am hesitant for the above reason.
I'm leaning toward the Trident AEGIS now. I've watched an hour of different reviews on youtube and read countless threads here on the case and nobody really mentions the grip in any detail.
Does this seem like it would fit the bill for me? Can anyone who has or has had one comment on this aspect?
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Aegis seems like a great case. I have the UAG Navigator, and I love it. I have pretty big hands so it's not slippery for me. I agree it is smooth, but I think once you get used to how to hold it, it's very easy to keep in the hands. The plus is, even if you drop it from the "slipping" as you refer, nothing will happen to it because it is just that well protected. I also ordered the Case-Mate Tough based on the great reviews here. It's the thinnest case of the three while still providing very good protection. It also has that nice rubbery feel from what I've read/noted. The only reason I wouldn't go for the Aegis is because it looks more like a toy case. I feel like if they had complete solid colors or at least a black and white combo, it would look really good. Good luck with deciding
So, I assume you have read my official review HERE and comparison review to UAG/Tough/Pop posted in HERE? For your reference, you can also take a look at my UAG review HERE and also Case-Mate Tough review HERE
I'm very picky about cases as well in terms of case friction on a surface and slippery grips, and have reflected that in my write-ups and pictures in the links above. With all that said, if you are looking for a case that will stay dead on surface flat without wobbling, UAG will be your best bet. I know you compared it to UAG S3 case, but that one was different. S3 case had thin rubber ridges around corners making a feet/standoff, while GN2 case has 4 "torx" screw heads evenly spaced and making a cool standoff and a decent grip with a surface. That case will not side. I actually had it in my car a few days ago on top of the middle cup console (with top closed) which is very slippery, and it stayed on while I took a lot of turns. Tough case has a very nice textured grip in your hand, and will not slide like crazy on the surface, but the grip of those UAG torx-head softer rubber feet will have a better grip. Regarding Aegis - you have a back of the case which is not perfectly flat and your grip comes from Trident symbol in the middle of the case. It has a very good hand grip, no doubt about it, but in terms of surface grip - I wouldn't put it at the top of the list.
I would say the best surface grip probably going to come from a flat back TPU case (although stay away from popular Mercury case on Amazon - that one has a shiny sparkly finish and it slides like a soap bar across glass table) - but you also will NOT get the best protection from those TPU cases since most of them designed "slim". Silicon skin cases will be grippy, but they pull around edges and need external plastic shell to hold it down and that plastic shell will either be flat/smooth (thus slippery) or have a kickstand and some textured design (those wobbly when you put it down).
Thanks for the replies.
@opasha - I've never had the UAG for the Note2 in hand so thanks for the info. I've only held/used my wifes on her S3. I suppose there are comparisons out there of those two but I never thought to look for that...but instead just assumed it would be as smooth and slippery.
@vectron - I have seen the majority of your posts on the subject. I know you specifically mention the grip in hand but wasn't totally sure if you meant ergonomically or frictionwise. You may have went into more detail on the subject and if so I might have missed it. I will revisit your writes ups but thanks for addressing it in depth in your reply.
I'm not so much concerned about a flat surface but only mentioned it to illustrate how my droid2 case was. I literally think it would remain on my car roof if I drove around the block a few times. Oddly, my wife had the same exact case (though pink) for her droid2 at the time yet it was not at all as grippy.
It would be nice if it didn't shoot off my desk or table if accidentally knocked but I'm mainly worried about it it slipping out of my hand. I often only have one available as it is so handling a(n expensive) large slick phone is what I'm trying to alleviate with a slightly tacky (or something) case.
I did mean ergonomically, but I also mention in my reviews the grip with a surface since it always bothers me when case slides around Plus, some of the pictures worth thousand words, so yes - check out those links with reviews
The grip on the Aegis is excellent on hand and when laid flat on the screen. If laid on its back then it does slip. I've owned both UAG and Otterbox Commuter but the Aegis has the better grip.
Sent from a galaxy note 2 far far away...
Since I've bought a few different cases, I thought I'd do a roundup of them.
Nillkin Super Frosted Shield Matte:
Minimal case, but with a slight lip around the glass and camera bump protection. Full 360 degree coverage with tight cutouts and good buttons. A very tight, accurate fit; it won't bounce off if you drop it.
Covered with a bump pattern to make it grippy. Hard plastic that will likely crack on dropping.
For: people wanting to reduce the slipperiness of the phone, make the bump look less dumb, and protect from scratches and light drops.
Spigen Liquid Air:
Light by Spigen's chonky boi standards, this gives protection not far off their Rugged Armour series without the goofy carbon fibre accents. Looks good and fits great. Large protection lip around the screen and sufficient camera cover. Tasteful design. Not as grippy as you'd think, but better than just the phone.
For: serial phone-droppers who don't want to make their giant phone any more gigantic. A good compromise case.
Official "sandstone" bumper case:
More rugged than the Super Frosted Shield, but with openings for the rockers, buttons, and top and bottom.
Extremely grippy texture and a tight fit. Good screen lip protection and camera cover. Aesthetically a bit weird; a bit "HTC Desire era" with the big gaps all around. Tasteful OnePlus logo.
Colour and texture of an asteroid space station wall; really needs to have "REMEMBER THE CANT" spray painted on it.
For: official case fans who don't mind paying twice what it's worth (unless you find it on eBay). Daredevils. People who like to click the proper buttons.
All three are good, but if you spend the RRP on the official case, you should go get your face paint on and get to the circus, because you're a clown.
Good write-up ?. Though I tried a couple of cases - both military types and transparent types - I couldn't find any of them good. I still use the official transparent case that came with the phone. I couldn't find any better than this case.
For military types I hate them because of the thick bumper sides that eliminates the bezel-less nature of the phone. Yes the military types meant for that kinda protection but I don't like those cases. For the transparent ones none of them gives that extra bumper for the screen and back camera glass like the official Twitter m transparent case. All of them were sh*ts.
For my old Lenovo Z2 Plus, there were a vast variety of colored back covers with extra screen and back camera bumper protection. I had more than 20 cases in different types and colors. My MiA1 also has more than 10 different cases. Note that these weren't just cheap quality cases with some printed graphics, these were all in plain solid colors. I don't know why case manufacturers of 7T never make such kind of cases.
Two months ago I was planning to make a custom made plastic-printed case with the help of my friend, he has a 3d printer with him. I even made a 3d model of the phone and case in my PC. But due to the pandemic I had to stop the process. Not sure if I can do the further developments.
Sent from my OnePlus7T using XDA Labs
I’ve never understood why “military grade” is considered a selling point. Have these people never met someone who was in the military? Everything’s made by the lowest bidder!
I agree with the lack of case options. I don’t think the OnePlus 7T sold all that well or something, it’s disappointing.
I got my 7T used and it came with three official cases. I'll add to your list, if you don't mind.
Karbon Protective Case:
This case is just like the Sandstone in that the buttons, slider and top/bottom are exposed. The feel is interestingly rubbery, but a bit slippery. It is very thin and almost looks like a skin until you look closer. Not that it is that thin, but fits so well. It's so thin it adds nearly no weight. The OnePlus logo is far more pronounced than the Sandstone, and really pops being so silvery-white. It makes me wish the Sandstone had a silver/white logo, it's that good.
Sandstone Protective Case:
Basically everything you said. The grip is incredible and you will be hard-pressed to drop your phone unless you're being careless. An improvement over the 5T Sandstone as the texture is slightly better. My go-to case, really.
Red Silicone Bumper Case:
This thing is pure red. Wow, that red! It is noticeably more bulky than the Karbon and Sandstone. There is no lip for the camera bump because it's bulky enough to clear it. So the back is smooth all the way, no table wobble. The inside of the case is a nice suade. It actually is an awesome premium touch, and you feel good to know your phone is safe from even case scratches, lol. Covers all buttons, makes the slider a bit more difficult to reach (but not too much), and covers all the way around the top and bottom, leaving ample holes for the microphone, charging port and bottom speaker. There is an ample lip all the way around. The feel is similar to the Karbon but more grippy. Softer feeling. The logo is understated and just recessed in the silicone.
All of these cases feel very premium (to me) and the fit is so perfect I think they're worth the investment. Especially if they last as long as my Sandstone from the 5T I used since launch.
Update: I've been using the official Sandstone case as my daily driver for nearly four months now. I've had a bunch of drops from pocket height onto concrete without any damage to the phone, and the case texture hides the dings very well.
Would recommend again.
I find most cases get slippery on the sides.
I had speck in the past but it was OK any others that you recommend thanks
From what I've seen so far:
1. Spigen Liquid Air - Seems to have some good grip potential, especially with ridges on the sides. However, the gap around the camera bump is an interesting design choice...
2. Samsung OEM Matte Black Silicone Case - Seems to have a decent grip on the matte finish and very minimal.
3. Pitaka Air or MagEZ Case - While I haven't used them myself, I've heard good things about the grip/feel of the Ipitaka cases.
I'm personally going to try the PItaka MagEZ case when it becomes available (Aug 21st) since I like the idea of having embedded metal so I don't have to stick a scosche metal piece on the back of the case.
Also, just a heads up. According to some initial reviews on the new speck 'grip' cases, they're using a more plastic-feeling material for grips instead of rubberized and people are not happy about it. (I previously used them as well)
I switch phones often, but one thing that remains constant is my Pitaka MagEZ cases. Have purchased well over 10 of them at this point. Wouldn't choose any other thin case
PseudoChris said:
From what I've seen so far:
1. Spigen Liquid Air - Seems to have some good grip potential, especially with ridges on the sides. However, the gap around the camera bump is an interesting design choice...
2. Samsung OEM Matte Black Silicone Case - Seems to have a decent grip on the matte finish and very minimal.
3. Pitaka Air or MagEZ Case - While I haven't used them myself, I've heard good things about the grip/feel of the Ipitaka cases.
I'm personally going to try the PItaka MagEZ case when it becomes available (Aug 21st) since I like the idea of having embedded metal so I don't have to stick a scosche metal piece on the back of the case.
Also, just a heads up. According to some initial reviews on the new speck 'grip' cases, they're using a more plastic-feeling material for grips instead of rubberized and people are not happy about it. (I previously used them as well)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does the pitika have a lip to protect the screen? Thanks
magichoward said:
Does the pitika have a lip to protect the screen? Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The "Air" series cases generally don't rise above the screen.
They do have a thicker "Pro" series option with a raised lip to protect the screen, bumpers on the corners, etc.
Samsung OEM silicon. Can confirm it has excellent grip
seoulbrova said:
Samsung OEM silicon. Can confirm it has excellent grip
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The cloth one does as well since there's a slim silicone band along the edge.
zedwards said:
The cloth one does as well since there's a slim silicone band along the edge.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes I've seen the one the only concern I've read it's a little difficult to remove the spen.. Your thoughts.
I will never choose Pitaka again.
Edges are rough and the upper part could have covered more
But I especially won't because it damaged my Note 10+ because of a defect in the inside of the case that made a grain of sand sized hole in the back of my phone.
Been using the Zizo Bolt on my Note 10+ for over 6 months. Excellent grip, usability and protection.
Kick stand doubles as a grip; either fully retract/extend it to keep from losing it's pins, if not secured in either position they can work their way out in your pocket! No issues with this case otherwise.
The one for the 20 seems to come with a temper glass screen protector; that may not work so well.
That's not present on the one for the 10.
Presumably you can use it without and substitute one one your choice?
Damn the 20's cam has a big bullseye on it... no likey. Buying a good case for the 10+ was very hard early on, no doubt the 20 U will be harder to protect
https://www.zizowireless.com/produc...axy-note-20-ultra-case?variant=32315584282672
magichoward said:
I find most cases get slippery on the sides.
I had speck in the past but it was OK any others that you recommend thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://www.amazon.com/JJNUSA-Handmade-Leather-Samsung-Galaxy/dp/B08DXWJSQ1?ref_=ast_sto_dp
you know i never thought trying to find a case was going to leave me so hard pressed. note i do not mind the camera bump one bit. but they could have rounded out the camera hump a bit more. not the corners, but where the surface meets the edges and also they could have slanted the sides a bit more angled. who knows they did pull it off pretty good.
still on the camera bump.
note: with JJNUSA leather case you will be covering the mic on the camera bump. if that is a problem for you look elsewhere for a case.
i have received 200 in incentives to order goodies when i got my phone pre ordered and used it to order a few cases.
cases i ordered:
samsung rugged: bulky, heavy, don't like the texture on the back and flimsy kickstands that shoot off when used
samsung leather case: upgrade from last years, 2g lighter. seamless, but warps at the bottom. good cam protection.
samsun silicon: unsure if food grade safe. and slippery as glass
-other cases-
spigen Rugged Armor: oddly best all tpu case with carbon fiber accents. the back is slippery if trying to reach across the screen. side bumpers have one way slip grip and flimsy. camera is well protected. pen cut out too deep corner exposed but covered. top /bottom bumper good but top may block ear piece. 2g heavier then jjnusa leather
...now my official review of the JJNUSA Handmade Leather Case...
NOTE i used amazon prime
don't let the first pic they have on amazon throw you off, but what bothers me is the video they added to the product and it is of the s20 ultra; the camera lens is so scratched. i am still baffled how they did that. then again we will see in due time, because i can not stand the samsung leather case(which got me hooked on leather cases oddly) it is too slippery. the jjnusa case has tpu sides and saddle leather on back with plastic on the inside that the phone rests on. but i will say the leather on the back is so soft i think it sorta makes up for the lack of suede like the official samsung case has. then again the leather is so thick its' edges pop out the mold a teensy-weensy bit, but i doubt with proper use and not picking at it it will survive for a long time. with the 5% off coupon i also got another 1 usd off(who knows if it was the amazon prime). so for 19.95 it is a steal. most other leather cases are $30+. a steal; why may you say? hold on let me get to the rest of it. if we all remember the lg g4 leather back it was a looker. that was it, because it scratched easily and punctured easily. then we go onto the samsung leather case that scratches easily with minimal show. further more i can not say what that will mean over long term usage with this case from jjnusa. treat it lightly and it should be fine. now back to the leather on the jjnusa case. the leather reminds me of the type you get on a saddle and does not separate from itself. that is a plus. but a minus if the antiquing they use comes off very very easily?, and it does(con or not?) i had a cane that had antiquing and it turned my hands black, but after it leveled out it was fine. you know they always slap so much on to fill in the design that almost certainly more then half they put on will rub off. i have rubbed off some already. hence it would not rub off like wow, i had to use my nail. no way does it show like scratches on the samsung leather case. either way the extra antiquing will no matter what fade away over time and settle down to where it should be. i still think it will look good. at the same time the leather is much more scratch resistant then the latter. and the design and the look really grew on me. now on to the sides. the power button and volume are labeled with symbols and i like it even though i will never look at it. what else i like is that they are tpu like the rest of the sides. the tactile of the buttons are sturdy then again not too stiff not too mushy. then there is a bonus or an achilles heal; you move down the same side as the buttons and find a wrist strap punch out so you can add a wrist strap. have not tested it, seems like it should be worthy of use and not fearing. the bonus is removing the phone from the case, it does not shoot out like it does with the samsung leather case does. still it holds it in better. this is where i tell you that the jjnusa case has way better screen protection that leaves a better feel in the hand. the samsung leather case has a squidgy spongy top and bottom. the bottom is already warped and i never used it; i just put it on a few times and took it off. also a fail for the bottom bumper is the difficulty to remove the spen without nails. the jjnusa case is cut out just right and since it is thinner and more stiffer in a good way you can press your thumb or finger and hear that satisfying click to eject it. with that said the top and bottom bumper are raised higher then the samsung to protect the screen. the samsung case is more flush and flimsy.
i am a happy camper and if it fairs well i will update to 5 stars from 4, but i am really thinking at the price to slap down for another. as we all know leather cases do not last as long as other types
the reason i gave it 4 stars is i never really heard of JJNUSA till i saw them on etsy.com and since they where based in china i thought meh. then i thought to ebay's third party cases and said but leather? does not smell much like leather, oddly that is how saddles with the same type of leather smells. or it could be the antiquing they used and the shipping package. it was not shipped in a box or cheap plastic, it was in a cloth sleeve in a sealed padded envelope. JJNUSA do claim Oregon origins... yeah right etsy.com says ships from china.
i have played around with plenty of cases and phones in cases so it's not like i only have really had the note 20 ultra... just do not get one of them ultra thin all tpu cases. i have one for my lg g4 and only really protects the sides and back. busted the screen.