anyone able to fully test the turbo and moto voice in a car environment please? maybe with windows open also.
i would like to confirm if the turbo can handle all the touchless functions while the car has the windows open.
On the note3, it is unable to differentiate voice from car engine/wind noise and thus continues to listen until it times out and thus recognises nothing useful at all., totally useless in the car.
Im hoping the turbo mics are able to block out the wind and engine noise and such.
if it all works, im hoping to root the phone and add custom commands so nearly everything can be performed without touching the phone.
I'll give moto voice a few stress tests. I'll post back with results.
Sent from my XT1254
For me.. Moto voice has a tendency to pick up road sound....I'll be done talking and it'll keep listening..Microphone seems uber sensitive..
Sent from my XT1254 using XDA Free mobile app
ccheww said:
I'll give moto voice a few stress tests. I'll post back with results.
Sent from my XT1254
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nice thanks. its one of the main reasons to moving over to a turbo from a note3, for me anyways.
dano1282 said:
For me.. Moto voice has a tendency to pick up road sound....I'll be done talking and it'll keep listening..Microphone seems uber sensitive..
Sent from my XT1254 using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really? cos thats what my note3 in doing now, makes the google now voice service useless unless your in a car that is silent.
So, Is this with the windows down? so it cant separate wind noise or car engine noise?
Windows up or down.. doesn't make a difference..
thats a shame, hopefully someone finds a work around.. thx!
sonhy said:
thats a shame, hopefully someone finds a work around.. thx!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll report some better findings. I use Moto voice in my car all the time for placing phone calls and short text messages. I also use the voice recognition of Swype for longer texts/email replies.
Generally I'm in a Mazda 3 which is a bit quieter than the cargo van i also drive. In the car with the windows up, it always recognizes the wake up phrase and as long as there isn't a commercial vehicle next to me, it also recognizes my commands. When Moto voice doesn't recognize the commands, it punts the voice data over to Google Now which can usually finish the job. In the cargo van, i usually have to loudly speak the wake up phrase, and it almost always needs Google Now to finish the task.
I find the voice controls and recognition much better than on S4/5 and can easily use it without worry or frustration in a car.
Got my turbo on Sunday. I picked it over a note 4 because of the touch less control. After spending a few days with it and constantly trying to use the touch less feature. I must say it sucks. Its pretty good at picking up the wake line. But after that its a hit or miss. I have to turn off my radio every time when I have to use touch less because it won't stop listen with the ratio running. Overall I don't think the touch less control is ready for prime. I'm at the verge of turning this feature off completely.
phibo said:
Got my turbo on Sunday. I picked it over a note 4 because of the touch less control. After spending a few days with it and constantly trying to use the touch less feature. I must say it sucks. Its pretty good at picking up the wake line. But after that its a hit or miss. I have to turn off my radio every time when I have to use touch less because it won't stop listen with the ratio running. Overall I don't think the touch less control is ready for prime. I'm at the verge of turning this feature off completely.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wouldn't expect it to work with the radio on, it is listening for human voice after all. Once you unlock it, any words (yours, your passenger, or the radio) start to get analyzed. It does ignore music without lyrics and auto noise.
I've had really good experiences with the voice. Of course it will pick up the radio. It's kind of silly to think it could pick out your voice from all kinds of ambient noise. I usually just kill/mute the radio while I use the voice. It's only for a few seconds anyways.
If there is a lot of road noise or there is a strong crosswind that I can hear in the cabin of the car, Moto Voice will tell me it's a little noisy and I will need to speak up. But as long as I speak a little louder and clearer, it works really well. I just need to get another car dock that fits the Turbo. My old Moto X dock is too small.
X
Thanks for the replies everyone, now im back on the fence again
i do know the the tubro wouldnt have the ability to isolate different voices so definitely would lower/ mute the radio.
If voice control is something you REALLY want, I can say that my Moto 360 lets me voice control my Turbo while in my Mazda Miata, with the top down, at 75 mph.
Since this topic is in the "accessories" category, I figured I could mention this!
Related
I am really trying to like this phone even after the mango update..
But I can not understand a few things..
The Volume on this phone is crap There is no way in hell it will ever wake me up using the alarm, My droid I was able to set whatever I wanted to any ringtone or alarm ( my own music) and I was able to make the volume loud enough to actually hear it..
Microphone input why can we not use the microphone anywhere there is a input field? why can we only long press the windows logo or use it for sms? evidently it is built into the OS just fine for voice to txt why not use it across the whole os on any text input field?
No flash?
GPS navigation is piss poor unless you dump 35$ on the Garmin suite.. believe me i have tried every trial and free app this week and they all do not compare to Google maps free on the android..
Also again SOUND unless you drive with NO fan on in the car, no music, and windows rolled up and on a quiet street you will not hear the GPS telling you where to turn.
Battery life:
wow all you have to do is send a few messages and browse the web for less then 5 minutes and you are at a 1/4 power loss ...
Think it is time to head back over to android land where i was able to use the microphone for a lot more voice input...
was able to set ringtone to music I liked and was ABLE TO HEAR IT
was able to HEAR MY alarm clock
was able to HEAR the gps software that was superior and FREE
You could have saved yourself a lot of time, stress and possibly money by reading the posts in this forum which have discussed the points you mentioned about dozens of times.
I feel your pain, I bought a HD7 on launch day and sold it a week later. There weren't any reviews available back then but now, almost a year after launch, all the issues in your post at widely known.
When did you get your HD7?
re: Volume - I've never had an issue with this
re: Nav - GPS Tuner.com's "Turn By Turn" is great and cheap ($5.49 Aussie - Less everywhere else in the world)
re: Battery life - I find it the same as every power hungry smartphone I've owned... I'm used to charging once a day
A lot of the other issues you state will likely be resolved soon... But most you list are WP7 issues rather than HD7 issues...
Perhaps android is more suitable...
Hey everyone, I just recently made the switch to the Moto X and I love it. One of my favorite features is definitely touchless control. Unless I'm mistaken it's only supposed to respond to my voice yet after several attempts to train it to my voice it will still respond to other people's voice and even sometimes to ambient noise such as the TV.
Strange thing is a coworker of mine also has a Moto X, (it responds to his voice almost every time) yet his voice won't respond to me. Anyone else getting this issue? It's certainly not make or break but it's kinda annoying.
Sent from my XT1053 using Tapatalk
MakoVince said:
Hey everyone, I just recently made the switch to the Moto X and I love it. One of my favorite features is definitely touchless control. Unless I'm mistaken it's only supposed to respond to my voice yet after several attempts to train it to my voice it will still respond to other people's voice and even sometimes to ambient noise such as the TV.
Strange thing is a coworker of mine also has a Moto X, (it responds to his voice almost every time) yet his voice won't respond to me. Anyone else getting this issue? It's certainly not make or break but it's kinda annoying.
Sent from my XT1053 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does it do it very often? Did you train the phone in a quiet room? Mine does it every once in a while but not often at all. I trained it with no ambient noise. Very rarely will someone else make it wake up but I read if you train it in a loud room or once with a lot of ambient noise, you may have a problem.
My Moto X at first was perfect.. then i wiped it clean after i upgraded to 4.4 and re-trained my voice. and then it started picking up everyone elses voices and recognizing them as commands as well. I locked myself in the closet and retrained my voice a couple of times. now it's perfect once again. give that a try!
aldouse said:
My Moto X at first was perfect.. then i wiped it clean after i upgraded to 4.4 and re-trained my voice. and then it started picking up everyone elses voices and recognizing them as commands as well. I locked myself in the closet and retrained my voice a couple of times. now it's perfect once again. give that a try!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did this and it's really better here.
Sent from my Moto X using Tapatalk
I'm currently using a Nexus 5 and I find the voice dictation terrible when I'm in the freeway with wind noise is the background (windows closed). It stops listening half way through sentences or even after the first word sometimes. Its happened multiple times where I give up because it absolutely can't translate what I'm saying or just stops working halfway through the sentence.
Is the new Moto X any better at blocking out ambient noises since it has more microphones? Anyone with any experience with both of these phones for a comparison?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Free mobile app
I tried it couples times on my girl's Moto X while I was driving with the radio music on to ask what's the song on radio or navigation
it works pretty decent that it recognize what it has to do without lowering down the volume on the radio
the phone were sitting in cup holders(passenger side, I put mine on the driver's side)
I don't remember if the windows were opened though
the voice recognition of voice input comes from google itself, I dont know how much it would affect compared to the simple function
Hope this helps
Well the Moto X is way better thah nexus 5. The moto x has the noise cancelling tech and it works pretty well. U will surely find an improvement in recognition.
If you activate it then it's very accurate but if you use the one where it announces texts or calls, it struggles for me.
I turned off the Moto Voice and went with just OK Google, and the performance is so much better. All you lose us the ability to speak to your phone while it's off (which barely worked 50% of the time) and the pointless voice commands like "check my Verizon bill".
Has anyone experienced this? Seems to happen often where Moto Voice will activate and ask for commands.
wrecklesswun said:
Has anyone experienced this? Seems to happen often where Moto Voice will activate and ask for commands.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've seen in on disconnecting from car bluetooth.
Once or twice.
Sent from my XT1095
Any way to lessen? or what causes this to happen?
I've had this happen 3-4 times since I got it on Thursday, so they definitely need to tweak the software to be a little more accurate.
Re-record your voice launch phrase in a very quiet environment.
Restola said:
Re-record your voice launch phrase in a very quiet environment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, this is the answer. My first turbo never randomly activated with my very basic phrase (Okay Turbo). My second one did it all the time and it became very frustrating, until I re-recorded it.
rgerrans said:
I've seen in on disconnecting from car bluetooth.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found the cause of mine. I use Tasker and had it doing a Media Stop Key emulation which seems to be what was triggering it.
I too had the moto voice randomly activating. I just picked a more complex phase and that did the trick.
it seems shutting down Google now solves alot
I had moto voice pop up while at the movie theater during Interstellar last night. Had my phone on silent and everything, but it made the loud ding noise anyway. It must have thought someone in the movie said "OK Google." This is the only time I've had it come up without my voice command, but just a heads up to movie-goers.
My activation phrase is Hey Turbo Turbo, it seems to trigger repeatedly when in the car, usually with the radio on, sometimes with it off. It gotten so bad I had to disable voice activations.
For me in the car, moto maxx wake up like if I said my phrase "ok moto maxx" even watching my tv too..
Definitely it's a bug
Sent from my XT1225 using XDA Free mobile app
Use "OK Google Now"
No problems!
So I love using my launch phrase. And the percentage of 'correctness' is amazing. But whenever I do it anywhere except somewhere that's dead silent, it just keeps listening. For like...30 seconds. Even if I said two words. I find this quite annoying. Any fix for this? Anyone else experiencing this?
smokeydriver said:
So I love using my launch phrase. And the percentage of 'correctness' is amazing. But whenever I do it anywhere except somewhere that's dead silent, it just keeps listening. For like...30 seconds. Even if I said two words. I find this quite annoying. Any fix for this? Anyone else experiencing this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is because the phone is still listening for the sounds around you, it doesn't differentiate between a dog or your voice, it just hears sounds, so as long as they environment is noisy, the voice commands wouldn't work properly.
There is no fix for this because it's not a bug, it works as intended but if any other sources are making noises, the phone won't distinguish your voice properly; the only thing you can do is to speak louder or try to be close to your phone when using your voice.
:good:
Galaxo60 said:
This is because the phone is still listening for the sounds around you, it doesn't differentiate between a dog or your voice, it just hears sounds, so as long as they environment is noisy, the voice commands wouldn't work properly.
There is no fix for this because it's not a bug, it works as intended but if any other sources are making noises, the phone won't distinguish your voice properly; the only thing you can do is to speak louder or try to be close to your phone when using your voice.
:good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand exactly what you are saying. But, on my old GNex (and on this phone) if I use Google's voice detection services it works without these incredibly long delays. The only reason i prefer this service is that this service reacts to my command without having to touch my phone first.
smokeydriver said:
I understand exactly what you are saying. But, on my old GNex (and on this phone) if I use Google's voice detection services it works without these incredibly long delays. The only reason i prefer this service is that this service reacts to my command without having to touch my phone first.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think this is the most interesting thing, of course Google has many advantages with its own implementation, but the fact to have the always listening function on the phone is priceless.