Related
I haven't been able to find any reviews on the XtremeGuard Spartan Tempered Glass Screen Protector.
You can find them: http://www.xtremeguard.com/LG-G2-AT-T-Version-ONLY-Screen-Protectors-p/lg0g20attxgrds.htm
I had a bad experience with their wet application screen protectors and was very dissatisfied with them. But now they have dry application ones!
Does anyone have any reviews of the tempered glass screen protector or the HI-DEF Screen Protector?
Bonus for reading! There's a sale on now!
Use code 90off1 to get 90% off of everything on the site.
You can get a tempered glass for $6 shipped or HiDef Protector for $0.70 FS.
xNotta said:
I haven't been able to find any reviews on the XtremeGuard Spartan Tempered Glass Screen Protector.
You can find them: http://www.xtremeguard.com/LG-G2-AT-T-Version-ONLY-Screen-Protectors-p/lg0g20attxgrds.htm
I had a bad experience with their wet application screen protectors and was very dissatisfied with them. But now they have dry application ones!
Does anyone have any reviews of the tempered glass screen protector or the HI-DEF Screen Protector?
Bonus for reading! There's a sale on now!
Use code 90off1 to get 90% off of everything on the site.
You can get a tempered glass for $6 shipped or HiDef Protector for $0.70 FS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Had two of these (the glass) its okay, hit and miss really. My first order had really nice tapered edges but the silicon peeled away from the phone edge itself , my second order (damn their 90% off sales) had very very slight tapering- to the point where it was sharp, but this one stuck to the edge just fine however was prone to chipping on the sides. I have it on to this day, albeit a crack or two (from drops) and the oleophobic coating doesn't last very long... But honestly for the price its pretty good for what you get. It's also very strong.
Unless they've changed it, the HD one is terrible. It goes edge to edge, but because of the curved glass it doesn't completely stick down. Mine caught on my pocket and peeled off in a matter of minutes after applying it.
The tempered glass is much better and is what I have been using since they came out in June. I posted a mini review here which was mostly positive, minus the rim of bubbles. I had to replace my device a few months ago so I ended up putting another one on. Not sure if it was cut slightly better or I got a perfect alignment, but there's only a slight amount bubbles along the left side and that's it. Much less noticeable (and not at all with my case on). I can get a picture if you want. I paid $4 for mine, but even at $6 I think it's a great deal.
Also, if you do get one, don't follow their directions for putting it on. Use the "hinge" method instead (google/youtube it)
I'd stay away. I figured with the 90% off coupon I'd try one of their ridiculously priced tempered glass protectors. When I opened it I found that it already had some dust on it but I installed it anyway. The edges never stuck and it looked like ****. I contacted them and they sent me a replacement, which upon opening I realized wasn't for the G2. Back to waiting for them to reply to email and then another 2 weeks to try for a successful replacement...
On sale, and now only $4.50 with coupon code "newyear85". I'm tempted to try, but I already have a regular screen protector perfectly installed, so don't really want to risk it...
waingro808 said:
On sale, and now only $4.50 with coupon code "newyear85". I'm tempted to try, but I already have a regular screen protector perfectly installed, so don't really want to risk it...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was in the exact same situation as you and regret my decision to remove my already-installed screen protector to try the Spartan. After my bad experience and multiple emails they eventually refunded my money.
Hey guys am looking for a tempered glass screen protector I've seen the thread about everything but am not really upto reading though 30 pages.. what's the best tempered glass protector out there with edge to edge coverage? BTW am UK and not wanting to leave my phone naked for too long thanks!
There are people saying that the current curved tempered glass edge to edge screen protectors are cracking from cases, Gear VR, and even basic installation. It sucks but I would wait for confirmation from the community that it is safe to buy and install.
It could have been a bad batch but it's not worth it to spend $15-$50 for the thing to break in the first few minutes.
lilchrissyy said:
Hey guys am looking for a tempered glass screen protector I've seen the thread about everything but am not really upto reading though 30 pages.. what's the best tempered glass protector out there with edge to edge coverage? BTW am UK and not wanting to leave my phone naked for too long thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
People are saying all the current edge glass protectors are manufactured from the same factories and just rebranded and resold as different products. They all suffer from similar fitment issues and inaccurate colors. Spigen is working on a curved glass protector for the s7e so I would wait until that comes out.
lilchrissyy said:
Hey guys am looking for a tempered glass screen protector I've seen the thread about everything but am not really upto reading though 30 pages.. what's the best tempered glass protector out there with edge to edge coverage? BTW am UK and not wanting to leave my phone naked for too long thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Until a decent one is available I highly recommend picking up a film one. I got a scratch from the lint in my pocket last night and have a film on as of 3 hours ago. No more braveness for me. For what it's worth, I picked up the film protector from T-Mobile and it's actually pretty good.
Trust me, for now, the best you'll get is www.ultimateshield.co.uk
There is no tempered one worth wasting money on.
The current "tempered" glass are actually plastic with bad fitment.
spigen are not working on a tempered glass screen for the s7 edge, they confirmed via twitter they have no plans for one at this moment
i echo ultimateshield recommendation above, full body coverage for 8.99 and no lifting issue with spigen tough armour case
clear film, no colour or orange peel effect and is invisible... perfectly cut
Well, I just got a tempered glass form ebay for the S7 Edge, absolutely awful quality, I echo that the tempered glass protectors are just absurd crap quality for the S7 Edge, the one I got just fogs up the display and washes out the picture.
i got mine from the ee store. 1 piece, i gold, sits right on top. took 2 minutes to install and looks great. sensitivity good. cost me 20. well worth it
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
It seems that all currently available on AliExpress (at least) tempered glass protection are flawed, because of:
1- Protectors that covers the body in full, and has some black areas: has actually glue only on the black non-transparent zones, but nothing on display area it self (so only display ages, upper and lower parts has glue), this makes it rubbish, because it will not stick well to the screen, one or two gaming sessions and it will end in recycle bin.
2- Fully transparent one, with full screen coverage: because 1+5 has 2.5D screen, those covers will not stick well on phone edges since tempered glass is rigid, this maybe can be used only with covers that overlap edges of the screen also.
3-Fully transparent one that don't cover all of the screen: those usually stick well, but only if they left about 5mm on each edge uncovered! I believe it is clear that such a gap ruins the protective purpose of the tempered glass, aside the ugly look due to gaps. (Again, having an edge overlapping cover could make it look better)
So it seems the only practical option for now is to use usual non glass protection unfortunately.
If I missed something or you have some suggestions please let me know..Some manufacturers claims that there protector is 4D, what means that it should solve all above issues, i didn't try those yet, anybody tested them?
I am regretting removing original 1+5 protection
As I bought and still use an Orzly tempered glass protector I concur with your analysis at this time. When I first applied the Orzly is was perfect without the issues some experienced but after 3+ weeks the sides must have lifted slightly due to my bumper case and dust particles got underneath next to the left/right buttons. Since then I've been religiously looking for an alternate that passes the case test but none so far have come to light.
I like the feel of the tempered glass so much that I've resisting going back to the film/plastic alternatives which I had always used in the past. I'm even considering going naked on the screen, relying on Gorilla Glass 5, but continue with a bumper case. Or the reverse, by using an Orzly but with no bumper case as I already have a dBrand skin applied. None of those options seem all that appealing. The one protector that seems to work with a 2.5D screen is the Galaxy 8's Whitestone Dome Glass but it's a crazy expensive $41USD and difficult to apply. I'm not sure even if a OnePlus 5 version was available I'd spend that much money.
I haven't had any luck with any tempered glass., due to point 2 which has been raised:
2- Fully transparent one, with full screen coverage: because 1+5 has 2.5D screen, those covers will not stick well on phone edges since tempered glass is rigid, this maybe can be used only with covers that overlap edges of the screen also.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
After reading all of the reviews I decided just to leave the plastic one on until someone gets their act together and offers a proper tgsp for the OP5
Sent from my OnePlus5 using XDA Labs
Agreed with OP and all of above. I had and still have the Orzly TG protector on, but dust underneath. I want to go back to the usual plastic ones, but don't know which one covers as well/much as the original one that came with the phone. Any recommendations?
Sent from my ONEPLUS A5000 using Tapatalk
Im still waiting for my Nilkin glass protector to arrive (it's almost been a month, sigh)
If this one has the same issue as the ones I've tried before it (lack of adhesive around the edges), I'm going to try and go back to using plastic screen protectors.
I don't want to use my device without one, but I also hate how these glass protectors don't fully adhere to the screen around the sides (including top and bottom)
Biuzko tempered glass screen protector from Amazon had been working perfectly for me for many weeks.
Megaflop666 said:
Biuzko tempered glass screen protector from Amazon had been working perfectly for me for many weeks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can anybody confirm this?
on yt you have a channel big ubox and there one guy test a lot of tempered glasses and cover for OP5 also the Biuzko one.
graja84 said:
on yt you have a channel big ubox and there one guy test a lot of tempered glasses and cover for OP5 also the Biuzko one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The YouTube channel you mention is also my favorite choice for screen protector info for the Oneplus 5. He always tests the protectors with various cases. His branding of the channel can get annoying but his market coverage is excellent and vast. With the plethora of tempered screen protectors its your choice for an accompanying case that often makes a big difference in your satisfaction. Here is the Big unBox - Biuzko review.
One thing I noticed is when the Big unBox applied the Official OnePlus 5 tgsp video it had lots of bubbles on the edges that he said couldn't be removed while I watched XDA's TK review and his application looked perfect with TK giving it a thumbs up. In the comment section of that review TK said all was well even after a month of usage. I was surprised as the Official tgsp has garnered horrible reviews and comments in the XDA Oneplus 5 accessories section. The most consistent criticism of the Official tgsp is that it cuts off a tiny fraction of the screen. In fact, so far my research indicates all of the "Full Adhesive", "Full coverage" tgsp cut off part of the screen. Personally I think the reason they have a black line on the edges is to hide inevitable bubbles due to the curved edge. The thicker the tempered glass the wider the side black stripes (e.g. Orzly versus Official).
Here is the criteria I'm using in selecting a replacement for my Orzly tgsp and cheap bumper case. Note that I've already installed a dBrand skin so that skews my criteria somewhat.
Tempered Glass screen protector:
- Must have full adhesive (not just top/bottom and side adhesion) and full coverage
- Would prefer, but am a tiny bit flexible on, part of the screen being cut off (limit is that not one pixel of the notification bar's clock is trimmed)
- Must have an oleophobic coating
Case:
- Needs to be as non intrusive as possible adding grip but not greatly ruining the sleekness of the phone
- Uses a minimalist design and/or clear materials so as not to obstruct viewing of the dBrand skin I've installed
- With the case on the buttons (power and volume rocker) must not be difficult to press
So far my research has me leaning towards the Official OnePlus 5 or Biuzko tgsp with a Rhinoshield Crashguard case. My one issue is that the Rhinoshield reviews always mention how difficult the volume rocker buttons are to press. Here is the video that has me leaning in that direction as is seems to best address my criteria
OnePlus 5 best case/protector setup
I'll being doing more reading and searching today hoping to find the unicorn of tgsp/case combinations. The dust under my Orzly is driving me mad but the feel and responsiveness of its surface has me rejecting a film/plastic protector alternative.
I'm using the Biuzko as well with the Tudia MERGE case no problems.
The trick is to first put OP5 in the case, THEN place the screen protector on. It fits perfectly, and you can't mess up the alignment since it falls right in. Then I just try to put pressure on the sticky parts for a few minutes.
I've had no problems for 3 weeks now.
I installed mine the same way, but I'm using the op5 carbon fiber case.
Sent from my ONEPLUS A5000 using Tapatalk
The original plastic cover was just perfect, is there is any possibility to find an équivalence ?
There's only tempered glasses on internet
akhage said:
The original plastic cover was just perfect, is there is any possibility to find an équivalence ?
There's only tempered glasses on internet
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello,
I recommend you the plastic screen protectors from GadgetShieldz. I made a review about it on another post on xda but to summarize, it's a bit difficult to apply but then it's great. The screen looks good and it's cheap ^^ highly recommend.
FYI, I was struggling with TGSP for the OP5 and I just gave up. There is no good alternative atm.
TMSxXDA said:
It seems that all currently available on AliExpress (at least) tempered glass protection are flawed, because of:
1- Protectors that covers the body in full, and has some black areas: has actually glue only on the black non-transparent zones, but nothing on display area it self (so only display ages, upper and lower parts has glue), this makes it rubbish, because it will not stick well to the screen, one or two gaming sessions and it will end in recycle bin.
2- Fully transparent one, with full screen coverage: because 1+5 has 2.5D screen, those covers will not stick well on phone edges since tempered glass is rigid, this maybe can be used only with covers that overlap edges of the screen also.
3-Fully transparent one that don't cover all of the screen: those usually stick well, but only if they left about 5mm on each edge uncovered! I believe it is clear that such a gap ruins the protective purpose of the tempered glass, aside the ugly look due to gaps. (Again, having an edge overlapping cover could make it look better)
So it seems the only practical option for now is to use usual non glass protection unfortunately.
If I missed something or you have some suggestions please let me know..Some manufacturers claims that there protector is 4D, what means that it should solve all above issues, i didn't try those yet, anybody tested them?
I am regretting removing original 1+5 protection
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this, I recently just applied it and noticed all the issues you raised.
akhage said:
The original plastic cover was just perfect, is there is any possibility to find an équivalence ?
There's only tempered glasses on internet
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Skinomi makes a wet application protector in both clear and matte. I posted pics of the matte version here. Since that post, I've experienced no scratches or orange peel effect. It's also great for no fingerprints.
You can always get the Nillkin H+ Pro, but only if you are using a spigen case or otterbox. Right now I am using the Spigen Rugged Armor with Nillkin H+ Pro and the gap between the glass and the case is around 1 mm (i would say 1.5 mm if I have to be more accurate). The Otterbox case is even better but I find it too bulky, tried it once for an hour and I did not enjoy it, but some of you may like it.
Few words about the Nillkin H+ Pro.
I know there are few variants of the Nillkin glass and I have tried all of them in the past. In my opinion the best glass is exactly the H+ Pro even tho it is a 1 dollar more expensive. The glass has zero rainbow effect or halo effect, it is 99 to 100% clear. It has amazing orleophobic coating. My Honor 8 has the same glass for 6 months now and it is flawless. I am going to change my nillkin glass with the official 3D tempered glass but only because I received the rhinoshield bumper. Otherwise I would not change my nillkin. You are going to get used to the small gap in a week or so.
Don't leave the phone without a glass.
I just applied mine, best screen protector I ever had, pure quality. Quote me on that
I love the official OnePlus screen protector, it's premium & looks good. Who ever made this thread is straight up wrong. The one he recommended is no Bueno, the glass part doesn't have enhesive. Look I am a OnePlus 5 conisuer, the screen protector is fantastic ?
I have siegen case. Can I buy the original screen protector from oneplus store with no problems? Or can I suggest me something with dust proof and oil proof ?
So I picked up the amFilm glass screen protector the other day from Amazon. Out of all the glass protectors I could find on Amazon, this had the least amount of bad reviews. Also its sold by TechMatte which I had heard of before.
Anyways, it went on pretty easily. No loss of sensitivity as far as I can tell with using my Finger or the Spen after 24 hrs of use. 2 specs of dirt did manage to get under the glass, but I've almost gotten to the point I can ignore them, and I'm pretty sure if I try to remove it to get rid of them it will make it worse.
The dot matrix on the screen can be seen in some lighting conditions, but you need to look pretty close and not really a distraction.
It seems to fit fine with my Spigen Tough Armor case. My only beef so far is the edges are starting to collect lint/dust etcs. In about a month the surrounding edges of this protector may look really bad. But only time will tell.
https://www.amazon.com/Protector-Coverage-Installation-amFilm-Tempered/dp/B074G1W2RC
I bought the same protector and installed it and only left it on the table untouched for a few days and it lifted off the screen so TechMatte sent me a new one but haven't installed it yet. I'm trying to use it with a Ringke Fusion case.
So its been a little over a week since I put on the screen protector. My only big issue so far is when I hit the down arrow, it makes a noise like its lifting up the protector. Though looks at the protector it still seems glued down so not exactly sure what is going on. Maybe how its rubbing against the protector. TechMatte is sending me another free of charge to put on to see if that helps. As for the crud around the edges, I've just got used to it now. It isn't to bad.
I have used the am film screen protector on my S8 plus and Note 8. It works better than any other I have found. There are some cases that don't work well with it - it all depends on where the case fits on the phone in relation to the glass - if it touches the glass, it is going to lift up the corner or sides at some point. Ringke Fusion and a few others that I have tried work every well. Many of the screen protectors like am film added additional glue to the edges of the screen protector and the good ones included a guide that you use when installing the glass - if the screen protector is perfectly centered on the phone's screen, it works exceptionally well.
The glass clicking was what made me noticed the TGSP lifted as I can lightly touch and the entire glass would come off. I also have the Ringke Fusion. It was TechMatte who told me about the glue only being on the edges when I wrote them about it. I never even noticed there were less than full adhesive TGSP as I have used AmFilm on both the LG G4 and the iPhone 6S Plus without issues.
Almighty1 said:
The glass clicking was what made me noticed the TGSP lifted as I can lightly touch and the entire glass would come off. I also have the Ringke Fusion. It was TechMatte who told me about the glue only being on the edges when I wrote them about it. I never even noticed there were less than full adhesive TGSP as I have used AmFilm on both the LG G4 and the iPhone 6S Plus without issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, I thought I was going to love this screen protector. Unfortunately I ended up returning it. The edges keep lifting up, getting a ton of dust underneath the protector and I'm starting to loose sensitivity.
howie411 said:
Well, I thought I was going to love this screen protector. Unfortunately I ended up returning it. The edges keep lifting up, getting a ton of dust underneath the protector and I'm starting to loose sensitivity.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I actually used the original one that lifted with a Ringke Fusion case yesterday and while it worked fine without the case, it seems like the case is sticking in between the screen and the AmFilm which is what is causing the lift. I guess they could use better adhesive.
So can someone suggest a good case for either the single or dual screen setup? Also I need screen protectors for the dual screen setup and Amazon didn't seem to have anything for the dual screen that were reasonable in price? Thanks in advance. [emoji846]
Matthew 6:31-34
New Living Translation
31*“So don’t worry about these things, saying, ‘What will we eat? What will we drink? What will we wear?’*32*These things dominate the thoughts of unbelievers, but your heavenly Father already knows all your needs.*33*Seek the Kingdom of God[a]*above all else, and live righteously, and he will give you everything you need.
34*“So don’t worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will bring its own worries. Today’s trouble is enough for today.
Sent from my LG-H932 using Tapatalk
I'm using these matt protectors for each screen
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/153992405865
I have the LG V60 from T-mobile this is what I got from Supcase on amazon, it has a built in screen protector. No need for tempered glass with this case, in my opinion. These cases won't work with it anyway, the tempered glass is too thick.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B088WMMJ78/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_P-UfFbTVXHS9X
atvcache said:
I have the LG V60 from T-mobile this is what I got from Supcase on amazon, it has a built in screen protector. No need for tempered glass with this case, in my opinion. These cases won't work with it anyway, the tempered glass is too thick.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B088WMMJ78/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_P-UfFbTVXHS9X
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't get the clicky sound from the gap between protector and phone screen? Last phone I tried that with was flat but that miniscule gap would make a "tap tap" sound, so I ripped off the built in. This was years ago tho, when I was still on Samsung before they ruined their screens
Supcase Unicorn with Zagg glass user here. No glass screen protector I have tried goes all the way to the edge of the screen.
Enough of a gap that the Supcase frame perfectly fits along the outside glass without overlap anywhere.
D-Max Armor glass is hot trash of a protector. Thinnest of the glass I've tried. Cracked in two days. LK glass didn't have good adhesive. Removed it because of the massive edge bubbles drove me crazy.
This Zagg glass works nice, but is not worth the price. This time I didnt even take the phone out of the Supcase to apply the glass.
pre4speed said:
You don't get the clicky sound from the gap between protector and phone screen? Last phone I tried that with was flat but that miniscule gap would make a "tap tap" sound, so I ripped off the built in. This was years ago tho, when I was still on Samsung before they ruined their screens
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No clicking sound at all, it fits perfect! Sorry about the delayed response
Ghostek case with supershieldz screen protector. no problems. even after dropping it a few times getting in and out of my truck.