Hi,
I have a banking app wich loink I provide hereby: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.rsi.ruralviawallet2
In the latest versions it just crashes, and after force closing and few opening and closing the app tells me that the system is modified and cannot run.
I have MAGISK 16 with magisk hide and the app checked to hide root, USB debugging deactivated as well...
Tried to use the uninstall magisk and un-SU scripts and cache clean but still crashing, So it may not have anything to do with Magisk, but since I had it installed it may have left something over there that the app is detecting as a mofied system...
Any Ideas ?
Thanks so much for your help
Make sure to also hide the Manager. I can open the app just fine if it's added to the Hide list and with the Manager hidden.
There might also be other things causing issues... Check here for more tips:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Thank you
Anyhow it's still not working, I have uninstalled all the apps that can be only runt with Root in case that was the cause, but still crashing. The Phone is unrooted now...
I will try now to Re-intall Magisk and hide everything, see if it does work :S
If anyone has a similar issue or idea, all help would me much appreciated.
Thanks again
whitenoyz said:
Thank you
Anyhow it's still not working, I have uninstalled all the apps that can be only runt with Root in case that was the cause, but still crashing. The Phone is unrooted now...
I will try now to Re-intall Magisk and hide everything, see if it does work :S
If anyone has a similar issue or idea, all help would me much appreciated.
Thanks again
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you don't have Magisk installed there are a whole bunch of stuff that may trigger the app that MagiskHide otherwise hides. Try with Magisk again...
Thank you very much for your help!!
For people that's having the same issue, I've solved it uninstalling several apps like TWRP MANAGER, ROOT EXPLORER and other apps that can only be used with root, after did a wipe cache and rebooted.
Take care with TWRP, when you install the recovery it asks to install an APK and usually almost everyone hits yes. This app is most likely detected by some apps and considered as system modification. @Didgeridoohan thank you!! ( It may be useful to put tjis in your Wiki for everyone to be warned about this so you dont receive this question again )
Reinstalled Magisk, Hid the Magisk Manager, selected the app to hide on the list and it worked!
Everything's fine now.
Thanks a lot for you kind help
bkash app
pixel 9.0 rom bkash app not working.... every rooted app unstall also twrp manager dismiss. clear the CAcHe & facory resat but result is bkash app not run
Related
Both me and my friend's Snapchats are crashing before it even opens. Only things we have in common is that both of us are using latest Android (through Custom ROMs, but they're not the same), latest TWRP and Magisk. I use AICP and he uses TeslaOS.
No, for me it works fine. Latest magisk
Sent from my ONEPLUS A3003 using Tapatalk
I am having a similar problem, as of 8/15/17 snapchat on the latest update is not working on my phone.
I have a rooted oneplus 3t with supersu and twrp, some side apps like flashify, root explorer, etc I cant seem to find the app or program that is triggering snapchat's safety feature causing it to repeatedly crash and not let you log in. I also currently do not have magisk.
from some searching it seems some people were able to solve this problem by unrooting and uninstalling magisk modules from their phone, or by using a root hide module from magisk.
Im not an expert but I plan to try the magisk root hide thing and if that doesnt work, do a full nandroid backup and re add one thing back at a time from titanium backup until I find what is causing the problem. there may also be modded snapchat apks out there that bypasses that error but I haven't checked yet. I'm still a noob at this so I would greatly appreciate any help or insight by anyone who's dealt with this problem before!
Try clearing cache/data for Snapchat. It was working fine for me yesterday, but this afternoon I randomly started getting force closes. After clearing cache/data and signing back in it works fine. I highly doubt it's a Magisk issue.
Also, Snapchat was an example, other apps, like Kung Fury: Street Rage, crash too, but only Snapchat actually gives the crash message, the others just keep closing
Hyoretsu said:
Also, Snapchat was an example, other apps, like Kung Fury: Street Rage, crash too, but only Snapchat actually gives the crash message, the others just keep closing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Snapchat has root/tampering detection. Can't help there (since I don't use Snapchat)...
Kung Fury does not have root detection (I just tested it). If a bunch of apps are crashing/force closing when you have Magisk installed (and MagiskHide active), your ROM might have an issue with WebView. Hard to know without a logcat from the crash though... If it is WebView, installing Chrome Beta and choosing it as your WebView implementation might fix it.
Didgeridoohan said:
Snapchat has root/tampering detection. Can't help there (since I don't use Snapchat)...
Kung Fury does not have root detection (I just tested it). If a bunch of apps are crashing/force closing when you have Magisk installed (and MagiskHide active), your ROM might have an issue with WebView. Hard to know without a logcat from the crash though... If it is WebView, installing Chrome Beta and choosing it as your WebView implementation might fix it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Changing WebView to Chrome Beta didn't solve it. How do I get a logcat of the crash?
Didgeridoohan said:
Snapchat has root/tampering detection. Can't help there (since I don't use Snapchat)...
Kung Fury does not have root detection (I just tested it). If a bunch of apps are crashing/force closing when you have Magisk installed (and MagiskHide active), your ROM might have an issue with WebView. Hard to know without a logcat from the crash though... If it is WebView, installing Chrome Beta and choosing it as your WebView implementation might fix it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
snap only utilizes safetynet during login.
Hello Man, i have the same problem on aicp. I have install another rom (CRdroid) and it's work like a charm. I think magisk is not fully compatible with all ROMs. Send a message to the dev of ur ROM for know it.
All apps started working after I uninstalled magisk
Hyoretsu said:
All apps started working after I uninstalled magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just re-read your first post... Does MagiskHide even work on your device? Can you pass SafetyNet or hide root from a root app (by adding it to the Hide list)?
Didgeridoohan said:
I just re-read your first post... Does MagiskHide even work on your device? Can you pass SafetyNet or hide root from a root app (by adding it to the Hide list)?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I tried, I could pass Pokémon GO's safetynet. In Snapchat case, when the problem was safetynet, it loaded but I couldn't log in, this time it simply didn't open at all, when the app tried to launch it immediately closed and showed a crash message.
Hyoretsu said:
When I tried, I could pass Pokémon GO's safetynet. In Snapchat case, when the problem was safetynet, it loaded but I couldn't log in, this time it simply didn't open at all, when the app tried to launch it immediately closed and showed a crash message.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you ever find a fix for Snapchat?
I'm using a Galaxy S8, Android 7.0, Magisk 16.6. When I try to play Pokemon go, it gives me the "OS not supported" message. The 16.3 fix didn't work back when it came out and I haven't been able to play since then. I did check the app in Magisk Hide and I activated the setting to hide Magisk Manager with a random package name, but it still doesn't work. Is there anything else I should do?
The only thing you can do that will work is to completely uninstall magisk. That should let you play pokemon go.
Pokemon also looks for a bunch of known root apps on your device, not only Magisk. And MagiskHide can't hide other apps.
Didgeridoohan said:
Pokemon also looks for a bunch of known root apps on your device, not only Magisk. And MagiskHide can't hide other apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What are those apps?
vladone97 said:
What are those apps?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are a whole bunch... Busybox installers, system cleaners, etc. There's an old list available somewhere in the Magisk PoGo thread (search), but that list might be outdated. Easiest thing is to uninstall some root apps and see if it works better.
An easier alternative, if you have the means to do it, is to use a clean spare phone/tablet for Pokemon Go, and keep your phone how you need/want it for everything else. Bluetooth data sharing is enough bandwidth to make PoGo work.
PoGo 0.115.3 not working, no login
Didgeridoohan said:
There are a whole bunch... Busybox installers, system cleaners, etc. There's an old list available somewhere in the Magisk PoGo thread (search), but that list might be outdated. Easiest thing is to uninstall some root apps and see if it works better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hello sorry for my bad english, today the new update 0.115.3 no login with magisk hide. I use a custom room with many root apps. wich is the solution? please can u say it itemized step by step?
StanGumn said:
hello sorry for my bad english, today the new update 0.115.3 no login with magisk hide. I use a custom room with many root apps. wich is the solution? please can u say it itemized step by step?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure.
Make sure you have Pokemon on the Hide list.
Hide the Magisk Manager (in the Manager settings)
Delete the MagiskManager folder on your internal storage (next time you download/install a module through the Manager the folder will be recreated).
Edit: There will likely be an update to Magisk that will hide the MagiskManager folder. But for now this is a workaround.
Didgeridoohan said:
Sure.
Make sure you have Pokemon on the Hide list.
Hide the Magisk Manager (in the Manager settings)
Delete the MagiskManager folder on your internal storage (next time you download/install a module through the Manager the folder will be recreated).
Edit: There will likely be an update to Magisk that will hide the MagiskManager folder. But for now this is a workaround.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmmm, tried all this, but still PoGo will not comply, even when I sandbox it in the work profile. (island app) The latter sounds a bit strange to me, as it should limit access to anything. (Magisk Manager gets installed, but is hidden)
To be honest, PoGo is just a test for when they start messing with Ingress as well. When it's getting to much trouble to have the app behave, it's out. They are just games, nothing to compromise my device for.
Also rename or delete every file or folder on your internal storage / sdcard that contains "magisk"
michikrug said:
Also rename or delete every file or folder on your internal storage / sdcard that contains "magisk"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any file? Not only the directory, but one that can be found somewhere on the device/external sdcard? (Like Magisk-v16.7.zip which you need to install it...)
Strange it should see it when sandboxed.
You can try, someone else said so, I did also do it and had no problem anymore so far.
But you should be right, that when its sandboxed it should not see it anyways...
michikrug said:
You can try, someone else said so, I did also do it and had no problem anymore so far.
But you should be right, that when its sandboxed it should not see it anyways...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will try to access sandbox via adb and see what I can find.
guys I own a redmi 3s and using 9.6.1.0 arvanasoft rom. Even on latest pokemon go version after hinding magisk manager and deleting magisk folder it's working just fine. But when I install other newer custom roms pokemon go gives me error like unable to find data on server or unable to authenticate pls try again later. but again when I restore back my old rom it works just fine. Pls help me how can I make pogo work on newer custom roms.
sorry for bad english
T_I said:
Hmmm, tried all this, but still PoGo will not comply, even when I sandbox it in the work profile. (island app) The latter sounds a bit strange to me, as it should limit access to anything. (Magisk Manager gets installed, but is hidden)
To be honest, PoGo is just a test for when they start messing with Ingress as well. When it's getting to much trouble to have the app behave, it's out. They are just games, nothing to compromise my device for.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Before using the hide magisk manager option, make sure magisk manager is NOT a system app. This will successfully repack magisk manager.
Then delete magisk fodler from internal storage and hide PoGO.
---------- Post added at 11:37 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:32 AM ----------
Vinayakn73 said:
guys I own a redmi 3s and using 9.6.1.0 arvanasoft rom. Even on latest pokemon go version after hinding magisk manager and deleting magisk folder it's working just fine. But when I install other newer custom roms pokemon go gives me error like unable to find data on server or unable to authenticate pls try again later. but again when I restore back my old rom it works just fine. Pls help me how can I make pogo work on newer custom roms.
sorry for bad english
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
May be other ROMs come with integrated Magisk. That was the case in mine. Convert it to user app first.
Then try magisk hide again and look for the package name in app info (It should be something random). Then continue with other steps as it is and it should work fine.
Let us know how it goes
Hi togehter,
if you use the Fake GPS Route, then uninstall via TWRP Magisk and then works PoGo (new version) perfekt, that works with my Samsung S5
I have a problem with my Samsung S7 edge, if I uninstall Magisk, then I have the problem, that the S7 go to a bootloop <--- Have anyone a idea?
Samsung S7 Edge
6.0.1
SecurePatch 01.12.2016
TWRP Recovery
If I install Magisk again, then boot the Samsung S7 without a bootloop, but then dont work PoGo
Xamel
Uninstall in the magisk app not by flashing a zip in recovery
Before I rooted my XZ premium I played pokemon go Just fine, afer Just enabling developer options (still locked bootloader and not rooted) it did not work Annymore, switching off developer options fixed pokemon go again.
Now with properly rooted Phone with magisk busybox, and whole bunch of rooted apps I am stuck as wel.... bonkers!!! !!
Could someone find a solution?
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/please-help-unable-to-play-pokemon-t3837451
Tried using magisk hide and hiding the magisk app itself but neither works. Somehow it is still detecting that my device is rooted. I don't have any other rooting on my phone.
It used to work with the Huntington bank app just fine.
Anyone else have this issue?
Having the same problem recently with Chase Mobile.
Any way to reach the dev and let him know or to help him test it with these apps?
Have the same problem with the new update of my banking app "Natixis Banxy".
They found a way to detect magisk even when everything is hidden.
Try renaming the TWRP folder on your Internal Storage to something else. Then try your Banking app again. (Only applies to TWRP users).
Thanks but I'm not using TWRP. I do use it to initially load Magisk, but I don't keep it on the phone.
Ewto16 said:
Thanks but I'm not using TWRP. I do use it to initially load Magisk, but I don't keep it on the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you remove it does the folder remain on Internal Storage?
Dirk said:
When you remove it does the folder remain on Internal Storage?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Doesn't appear to as I don't have a TWRP folder anywhere on my phone.
Bump for more thoughts and suggestions
I have been annoyed by this for so long but I finally just found a solution. If anybody is still having this issue, go into settings of magisk manager and find "Hide Magisk Manager" in the list. I stuck with the default name of "Manager" and then after that I cleared the storage for Huntington. I should also note that I have MagiskHide enabled for Huntington too but I don't know if that is needed when hiding Magisk Manager itself. After all that, fingerprint works and I can send money with Zelle again from the app.
Hello to all folks,
This is a weird one.
My banking app could see rooted state although the app was in the hide list and also the Magisk Manager was hidden too (renamed, reinstalled etc).
So I was out of options until I read this:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot
Among other useful bits and pieces it says "If an app still can detect Magisk, even if you have it on the Hide list, the Manager is repackaged and everything else from this list of tips is ok, try to uninstall the Manager and see if this helps. If that works, you might be out of luck and the only way to fully use the app in question is to regularly uninstall and then reinstall the Magisk Manager..."
I did so and here is the crazy part...
After uninstalling magisk manager app then a series of things took place:
My banking app now works ok
Root checker says root not properly applied
All apps that need root to work (TitaniumBk, Adaway, CallRecorder) see device as rooted and work flawlessly.
In other words, as like magic everything works fantastic!
Problem/Question/Worry: What will happen after I reboot?
Any ideas please?
Thank you very much!
You just made my day! Someone actually did their homework...
If you don't have the Manager installed you will end up having issues with superuser requests. Reinstalling the Manager after using the banking app is probably a good idea. Or you could probably set up a script or an app to freeze and unfreeze the Manager at the press off a button. I'll have to look into that and add to the guide.
Update:
I had to uninstall and reinstall TitaniumBk and sure enough TitaniumBk didn't get root permissions.
So I installed again Magisk Manager and updated to 8.0.0 and decided to try once more to hide Magisk Manager by renaming it to a different name than "Manager".
I noticed an important difference compared to previous endless times of hiding MM: The newly installed MM had a diferrent icon than the original one with the masked face.
And then...
...magic happened!
All banking apps didn't decect root!
Root checker could see device rooted!
Conclusions:
1. Either the MM 8.0.0 has a better hide MM feature
2.or my installation of MM 7.5.1 wasn't robust
Who knows...
Anyway this is my underatnding and I wsih there is a script to freeze/unfreeze MM with the push of button because in this battle of app developers against MM it's not always safe to assume that the "hide MM" feature will do the trick.
Thnak you again
awarexda said:
1. Either the MM 8.0.0 has a better hide MM feature
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This, most likely.
With this new Manager, the stub that is used is completely empty (which is why you're seeing the basic Android icon) and much harder to detect.
Hi
The new danish app Sundhedskortet (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=dk.digst.hc&hl=en_GB) detects root, and think i have tried everything in my own toolbox.
anyone with suggestions?
Got it working with a tip from another tread:
"You can also use "shelter" to isolate what the apps can see"
thanks to @Lu5ck
Sundhedskortet detects the hidden Magisk app. Use Island.
Tried Island and Shelter.
Fixed my issue with AL-Bank, but Sundhedskortet still detects root.
Tried uninstalling from main profile and installing directly in the work profile, but still complaining...
Feeling a bit foolish now... Forgot to actually uninstall from main profile, noticed the duplicate in my launcher, uninstalled - and now works like a charm (Shelter, but guess Island would work similarly).
ksga said:
Feeling a bit foolish now... Forgot to actually uninstall from main profile, noticed the duplicate in my launcher, uninstalled - and now works like a charm (Shelter, but guess Island would work similarly).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
EDIT: nevermind. I did a reboot and everything is working now. Thanks!
Hi - I have the same problem. Can you explain what you did step by step? I installed shelter and then installed sundhedskortet directly using Google play in my work profile but the app still detects root
Thanks!
Peter
I have tried installig shelter and island - installed Sundkedakortet on the work profile but still says root detected.
Can you tell me more specific what you did to make it work?
Im rooted with Magisk and Magisk hide is activated + Sundhedskortet is hidden.
KAngelo said:
I have tried installig shelter and island - installed Sundkedakortet on the work profile but still says root detected.
Can you tell me more specific what you did to make it work?
Im rooted with Magisk and Magisk hide is activated + Sundhedskortet is hidden.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you uninstalled from main profile? And then remember to reboot. Mine didn't work till after reboot.
Same issue. Sundhedskortet detects root, no idea how.
Using magiskhide, rename magisk and app is added in the magiskhide list.