Related
Hello folks!
I have a weird problem with my rooted OPX 3.1.3. I'm still using this version because Xposed is not yet officially supported with the november patch (last time I checked, it was being tested).
I haven't been able to successfully hide supersu and Xposed with Chainfire's SuperSU (even tough I think it's very good!). So, instead, I'm using PHH's SuperSU 266-2 with Magisk v9 (and Xposed 86.6). As expected, I can use Android Pay (by hiding it with Magisk Hide functionality), but after a while, I lose the root access... I don't know what to do to cause the problem, I just know it happens. So, I can't give you a step-by-step to reproduce it, which makes it more difficult to diagnose.
A reboot "fix" this, but it's kind of annoying. As this happened to someone else? What could cause this kind of problem?
Thanks and let me know if you need more info!
Remove magisk manager from greenfy-like apps, close the androidpay app after using anf if possible keep magisk manager opened worked for me
My setup is SuperSU 2.78 SR4, suhide, magisk v9, rootswitch 1.3.3.2 and PoGo and Android Pay works. I used the ramdisk patch. Root is never lost.
gamer765 said:
My setup is SuperSU 2.78 SR4, suhide, magisk v9, rootswitch 1.3.3.2 and PoGo and Android Pay works. I used the ramdisk patch. Root is never lost.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Um magisk thosent do anything in that case as supersu is independent from it and su hide is the only thing doing anything in that case
Majesty00 said:
Hello folks!
I have a weird problem with my rooted OPX 3.1.3. I'm still using this version because Xposed is not yet officially supported with the november patch (last time I checked, it was being tested).
I haven't been able to successfully hide supersu and Xposed with Chainfire's SuperSU (even tough I think it's very good!). So, instead, I'm using PHH's SuperSU 266-2 with Magisk v9 (and Xposed 86.6). As expected, I can use Android Pay (by hiding it with Magisk Hide functionality), but after a while, I lose the root access... I don't know what to do to cause the problem, I just know it happens. So, I can't give you a step-by-step to reproduce it, which makes it more difficult to diagnose.
A reboot "fix" this, but it's kind of annoying. As this happened to someone else? What could cause this kind of problem?
Thanks and let me know if you need more info!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The "losing root" problem with Magisk Hide is known and under investigation. I saw someone claiming that they didn't experience it anymore after doing a complete uninstall of Magisk and starting over. Otherwise, the only solution at the moment is to reboot the device or disable Magisk Hide.
Xmaster24 said:
Um magisk thosent do anything in that case as supersu is independent from it and su hide is the only thing doing anything in that case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm giving him an alternative that works where he doesn't lose root spontaneously and need to reboot to fix.
gamer765 said:
I'm giving him an alternative that works where he doesn't lose root spontaneously and need to reboot to fix.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But magisk in your alternative those nothing it's completely inactive, he would only find magisk useful if he was using another module but not xposed as superSU plus systemless xposed always leads to SN fail
Majesty00 said:
Hello folks!
I have a weird problem with my rooted OPX 3.1.3. I'm still using this version because Xposed is not yet officially supported with the november patch (last time I checked, it was being tested).
I haven't been able to successfully hide supersu and Xposed with Chainfire's SuperSU (even tough I think it's very good!). So, instead, I'm using PHH's SuperSU 266-2 with Magisk v9 (and Xposed 86.6). As expected, I can use Android Pay (by hiding it with Magisk Hide functionality), but after a while, I lose the root access... I don't know what to do to cause the problem, I just know it happens. So, I can't give you a step-by-step to reproduce it, which makes it more difficult to diagnose.
A reboot "fix" this, but it's kind of annoying. As this happened to someone else? What could cause this kind of problem?
Thanks and let me know if you need more info!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
I have same issue. I randomly loose root and I have no idea why. I hope someone can help.
I also will try to disable the magisk hide and see if it helps.
FlintStoned- said:
+1
I have same issue. I randomly loose root and I have no idea why. I hope someone can help.
I also will try to disable the magisk hide and see if it helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am having the same problem, but am not using the Magisk hide feature. Have to reboot to restore root - very annoying!
I disabled battery optimization on magisk and super user so we'll see if these fixes it or not.
Edit: as long as magisk hide is on this doesn't seem to help. It's a bug with magisk hide apparently.
I have noticed this twice, and it seems to be related to having the phone die from low battery? This is the only common condition I can recognize with the last two times it has happened.
Revenge282 said:
I have noticed this twice, and it seems to be related to having the phone die from low battery? This is the only common condition I can recognize with the last two times it has happened.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This happens to my phone and it's not died from having low battery.
Link_of_Hyrule said:
This happens to my phone and it's not died from having low battery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I let it die last night with Magisk Hide off, so that certainly seems to be the issue. I kept root and other modules after I turned it back on.
But even with Magisk Hide on, I never experienced any issues unless the phone died. I had rebooted it a ton of times and never lost any modules. I'm convinced that it has something to do with a "ungraceful" reboot situation and how Magisk Hide must unload itself.
Maybe that's an issue as well but my phone if I pick it up after it's been sitting there and charging or a good amount of battery and try to use root it says there isn't root unless I restart.
The same issue with Magisk hide on Xiaomi Redmi Note 3 Pro
Sent from my Xiaomi Redmi Note 3 using XDA Labs
Started experiencing this on Nexus 6p stock NMF26F. Predominantly happening overnight.
tzortst said:
Started experiencing this on Nexus 6p stock NMF26F. Predominantly happening overnight.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also facing this problem on Nexus 6 (nougat 7.0.1).
In addition to this, when ROOT is lost, Magisk Log is empty.
It happens whatever the day/hour... it just seems to happen after a few hours without using the phone.
- Phone never dead due to battery empty
- android pay DISABLED
- PokemonGO not installed
- Android installed from a Factory Image (november patch NBD91P)
- Magisk V9 + phh_root_r266-2 (the only module)
- magisk hide ENABLED + magisk busybox DISABLED + systemless hosts ENABLED
- greenify installed, but neither Magisk Manager nor SuperSU in the greenified applications
lebaud07 said:
Also facing this problem on Nexus 6 (nougat 7.0.1).
In addition to this, when ROOT is lost, Magisk Log is empty.
It happens whatever the day/hour... it just seems to happen after a few hours without using the phone.
- Phone never dead due to battery empty
- android pay DISABLED
- PokemonGO not installed
- Android installed from a Factory Image (november patch NBD91P)
- Magisk V9 + phh_root_r266-2 (the only module)
- magisk hide ENABLED + magisk busybox DISABLED + systemless hosts ENABLED
- greenify installed, but neither Magisk Manager nor SuperSU in the greenified applications
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk log is empty because the Magisk Manager can't access the cache folder where it's located (no root, remember ).
It's a known bug, probably due to Magisk Hide being a little too aggressive.
I've noticed that I lose root every time I open Magisk Manager, so I've decided to hide it from to app drawer & have Greenified it in an attempt to stop it from running at all after initial boot - will report back if it works or not.
Edit: so I rebooted and haven't opened the Magisk Manager app since last boot and haven't lost root yet, so, so far so good. (15hrs 30m uptime) - will update if I do.
Edit2: haven't lost root in 2 days now, so looks like a temporary fix?
enabling Magiskhide caused me to lose root
Just upgraded from 10.2 to 11.0 on a nexus 5x using magisk manager. CTS profile match triggered now I'm screwed. How to go back or how to fix?
Just uninstall magisk, wipe your system, and reinstall your ROM. You shouldn't have to wipe user data.
mickrussom said:
Just upgraded from 10.2 to 11.0 on a nexus 5x using magisk manager. CTS profile match triggered now I'm screwed. How to go back or how to fix?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you enable magisk hide again?
It broke cts on my tablet too so going to try a few things before I do what I said in the above post.
Edit: I could not get CTS back with the new Magisk so something is broken with Magisk hide.
I had the same problem on my OnePlus 2.
I had to clear Magisk Application data, then reboot, and reactivate Magisk Hide to get it back. No need to reboot when activating Magisk Hide.
Chiyo-chan said:
I had the same problem on my OnePlus 2.
I had to clear Magisk Application data, then reboot, and reactivate Magisk Hide to get it back. No need to reboot when activating Magisk Hide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I tried that but sadly if I have to reboot for other reasons it breaks Magisk Hide unless I toggle and even that only fixes it half the time.
For me, magisk hide is still working after reboot.
I have the same problem when i reboot magisk hide break
There's currently a bug with Hide initialization that will be addressed. After a reboot toggle Hide off and on and you'll be fine.
Yeah I got it to work but hopefully the bug is fixed quickly is rather not go back to pre-10.2 days.
I had the same problem.. but before reinstalling everything I turned magisk hose off rebooted turned it on again and rebooted and it worked fine since.
Sent from my HTC6545LVW using Tapatalk
Now Magisk hide works but it's losing root again.
Link_of_Hyrule said:
Now Magisk hide works but it's losing root again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try disabling Busybox in the Manager. Other users that are loosing root on v11.1 are reporting that this helped. Sounds like a bug somewhere...
Magisk 11.1 and Magisk Manager 4.0 fixed my CTS profile issue. I was having CTS profile issues with 11.0 but after updating to 11.1, the issue disappeared. I can now play Pokemon Go on a rooted phone with limited Xposed support (using Root Switch to disable Xposed); Xposed module like Snorlax is working.
I believe topjohnwu did acknowledge that it's due to some bug in MagiskHide.
xstahsie said:
Magisk 11.1 and Magisk Manager 4.0 fixed my CTS profile issue. I was having CTS profile issues with 11.0 but after updating to 11.1, the issue disappeared. I can now play Pokemon Go on a rooted phone with limited Xposed support (using Root Switch to disable Xposed); Xposed module like Snorlax is working.
I believe topjohnwu did acknowledge that it's due to some bug in MagiskHide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which Xposed are u using
I mean standard or the systemless
I flashed the official Xposed and NOT the unofficial from topjohnwu. Being that I have a Nexus 6P w/ 6.0.1 , I flashed xposed-87-sdk23-arm64.zip. I don't think the unofficial xposed works w/ Root Switch.
Official Xposed link: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3034811
Yeah the 11.1 fixed the cts issues but still lose root occasionally. It's not as stable as the old version was hopefully the bugs get fixed.
Hi.
I've done a lot of research, and it seems it's not possible to totaly hide xposed from android system.
I'd like to avoid the "application is not compatible with your device" message on some apps on google play (like fire emble heroes). Seems it have something to do with android pay (safetynet).
There might be a solution as I was able after some research to hide root (with magisk).
I've tried suhide xposed module, magisk root hide, magisk systemless xposed install, systemless xposed install, system xposed install... Nothing seems to work.
Anybody managed to get a working xposed while making google play unaware of that?
Any help would be GREATLY appreciated (as I've been working on this problem for 2 months now, around 1-2 hours a day )
roxxxance said:
Hi.
I've done a lot of research, and it seems it's not possible to totaly hide xposed from android system.
I'd like to avoid the "application is not compatible with your device" message on some apps on google play (like fire emble heroes). Seems it have something to do with android pay (safetynet).
There might be a solution as I was able after some research to hide root (with magisk).
I've tried suhide xposed module, magisk root hide, magisk systemless xposed install, systemless xposed install, system xposed install... Nothing seems to work.
Anybody managed to get a working xposed while making google play unaware of that?
Any help would be GREATLY appreciated (as I've been working on this problem for 2 months now, around 1-2 hours a day )
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is there a way to use Xposed to remove Sean droid enforcing from the boot screen
_throwbackkk said:
Is there a way to use Xposed to remove Sean droid enforcing from the boot screen
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what?
roxxxance said:
what?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was having trouble reverting my phone to stock . do you know how to do that ?
I've been reading several threads here and in other forums as well, and I still not sure if this is possible at all, or it depends on the Xposed modules, etc.
I'm planning to do a clean install of the RR ROM, 6.0.1, try to remove all traces of root, then flash magisk and see if I can pass SafetyNet.
Does a custom kernel interfieres with that?
And if I pass it... any possibility to use Xposed (being active) and pass SafetyNet? Or at least hide it for problematic apps, like Netflix, or Mario Run?
Thanks in advance.
No, Xposed and SafetyNet is a no-go for now.
If you have a device, which ROM has security patches older than November 2016, you may try to use suhide along with Magisk and its MagiskHide, but no guarantees.
The ROM I plan to use is from september, you mean with suhide maybe SafetyNet could pass with Xposed enabled?
Thanks!
eXtremeDevil said:
I've been reading several threads here and in other forums as well, and I still not sure if this is possible at all, or it depends on the Xposed modules, etc.
I'm planning to do a clean install of the RR ROM, 6.0.1, try to remove all traces of root, then flash magisk and see if I can pass SafetyNet.
Does a custom kernel interfieres with that?
And if I pass it... any possibility to use Xposed (being active) and pass SafetyNet? Or at least hide it for problematic apps, like Netflix, or Mario Run?
Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With Xposed Safetynet gone.
But you can use no device check module to pass ctsProfile True. But you can't anything about basicintegrity.
the ctsProfile in important. This mean you can play super Mario run or use Netflix in your device. But because of the basicintegrity you can't download or update this app from play store. You can download from apkmirror site.
Netflix and super Mario run in my phone.
Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
arianat said:
With Xposed Safetynet gone.
But you can use no device check module to pass ctsProfile True. But you can't anything about basicintegrity.
the ctsProfile in important. This mean you can play super Mario run or use Netflix in your device. But because of the basicintegrity you can't download or update this app from play store. You can download from apkmirror site.
Netflix and super Mario run in my phone.
Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Let's see if I understood it correctly. Can I have custom ROM + Magisk + SuperSU + custom kernel + Xposed active and with this module I can use that kind of apps?
Thanks!
eXtremeDevil said:
Let's see if I understood it correctly. Can I have custom ROM + Magisk + SuperSU + custom kernel + Xposed active and with this module I can use that kind of apps?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. I have custom kernel on ViperU 1.7 custom Rom in HTC U11
but I think you can't use superSu with magisk. You must use one of them. Why you want superSu? Magisk has superuser
Just install Xposed and install no device check module in Xposed installer
Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
arianat said:
Yes. I have custom kernel on ViperU 1.7 custom Rom in HTC U11
but I think you can't use superSu with magisk. You must use one of them. Why you want superSu? Magisk has superuser
Just install Xposed and install no device check module in Xposed installer
Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use an older Magisk that supports SuperSU. If I need newer Magisk for this to work, or if the module doesn't work with SuperSU, please let me know.
Thanks!
Best way really is root switch, requires reboot and disables xposed bit gets the job done.
kekistaneerefugee said:
Best way really is root switch, requires reboot and disables xposed bit gets the job done.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't want to be disabling Xposed and rebooting everytime...
eXtremeDevil said:
I use an older Magisk that supports SuperSU. If I need newer Magisk for this to work, or if the module doesn't work with SuperSU, please let me know.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The module worked with superuser and superSu
I tested
Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
Great, thanks, for now I will try MagiskSU. Just flashed ROM, removed su and SN passed. But installed boeffla kernel and not anymore. Is it normal? Can I avoid that? Gonna flash Magisk 13.3 now and check.
Thanks for everything guys!
Never mind, got SN again. But after installing Xposed systemless 87 I get bootloop Any idea why? Or is it really a very long boot? I have no Xposed modules at the time, just trying to boot it.
EDIT
Thanks to liveboot, I can see a boot error: Xposed: Can't find file.
Any clues???
Try install classic. If you don’t want disable xposed for pass basicintegrity , no need to install system less. Systemless xposed not active in my phone and I installed classic.
What’s your device? Do you wipe delvik & cache?
I flashed systemless Xposed from recovery and that did the trick.
If disabled, I pass SN. With the No device check module I pass cts profile.
But, Netflix does not work with that configuration. Maybe that app has extra checks? Thanks.
Sent from my ONE A2003 using Tapatalk
eXtremeDevil said:
I flashed systemless Xposed from recovery and that did the trick.
If disabled, I pass SN. With the No device check module I pass cts profile.
But, Netflix does not work with that configuration. Maybe that app has extra checks? Thanks.
Sent from my ONE A2003 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's do you mean extra configuration?
It's must work with pass ctsProfile. Just you can't update or download from play store.
Do you downloaded last version of Netflix for your device dpi and CPU architect from apkmirror?
Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
With Xposed disabled, and SafetyNet passing at 100%, Netflix says that my device is not compatible. Even installed from Google Play.
BTW, Mario Run only works if Magisk Hide is enabled for it, I guess that's normal (with Xposed active this time)
Thanks for all the clarifications, now I have a better understanding of it all
I guess this is the cause?
https://www.reddit.com/r/netflix/comments/69l2fp/all_netflix_no_longer_available_to_android/
Can anyone confirm?
Thanks!
eXtremeDevil said:
With Xposed disabled, and SafetyNet passing at 100%, Netflix says that my device is not compatible. Even installed from Google Play.
BTW, Mario Run only works if Magisk Hide is enabled for it, I guess that's normal (with Xposed active this time)
Thanks for all the clarifications, now I have a better understanding of it all
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know why Netflix not work for you. I have Netflix in my phone and using every day.
What's your phone Android build?
Netflix must work on your phone.
I have U11 and installed viperU magisk version custom rom. Android 7.1.1 and August patch.
Custom kernel and classic PurifyOS Xposed with so much modules like xprivacy, appsetting, hush sms, no device check , location report enabler, chromepie, native clipboard, and ...
Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
I have Resurrection Remix 6.0.1 from september 2016.
Is there a log or something where I can check what is cause Netflix refusal to work?
Do you have Magisk Hide enabled for those apps?
Thanks.
EDIT
Actually, Mario Run is now giving me the code error screen
CTS profile is passing.
EDIT 2
Additional info:
Super Mario Run works fine only for two levels, then is error 804-5100.
Netflix above version 4 (5 and later) says it is incompatible with my device.
- Both appear on Play Store.
- Store version is 8.1.73, installed this afternoon and cleared data.
- Bootloader is unlocked (maybe I should try to relock?).
- I can't find device verification in Play Store settings (is not there), even tried this:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-2/help/module-fix-google-play-certification-t3602629
with no luck.
- Xposed installed with modules but disabled (from Xposed Manager).
- SafetyNet passing 100%.
- Tried both and without Magisk Hide enabled for the apps.
- Disabled superuser and enabled Magisk Core only.
- Build version: 6.0.1_r66 - MOB31E (my signature is outdated).
- I had Lucky Patcher but I uninstalled it.
- Also tried this:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/xiaomi-safetynet-fix-t3600431
Nothing works.
Maybe some other app(s) is being detected by Netflix? Maybe a log would help? Or a full bug report?
Is it the ROM version? Maybe is device specific? Should I open a thread on the device's forum? Am I missing something?
Thanks in advance!
EDIT 3
Android Pay seems to work. I don't have NFC, I only got to the add card screen, but I guess that's enough.
EDIT 4
Kernel is Boeffla.
you need root switch
Hi All,
I have an app that detects for root, i think it might be using safety net check
I'm on s7 edge with Nougat.
I was on Magisk and was able to hide the app, but recently found it, it was the reason due to many apps not running and SD card being slow..
After flashing to SuperSU Pro v.282-SR5 - everything is working great and with xposed as well!
But the problem now is, i can't hide root for one app - is it possible within SuperSU to just hide root from that one app?
thanks,
kevinwu128 said:
Hi All,
I have an app that detects for root, i think it might be using safety net check
I'm on s7 edge with Nougat.
I was on Magisk and was able to hide the app, but recently found it, it was the reason due to many apps not running and SD card being slow..
After flashing to SuperSU Pro v.282-SR5 - everything is working great and with xposed as well!
But the problem now is, i can't hide root for one app - is it possible within SuperSU to just hide root from that one app?
thanks,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/supersu/suhide-lite-t3653855
Didgeridoohan said:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/supersu/suhide-lite-t3653855
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, but I have xposed.
Any other way?
kevinwu128 said:
Thanks, but I have xposed.
Any other way?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are Xposed modules for that. But you can only partially hide Xposed (fake a cts profile match) with modules like "No device check". The only way to completely bypass an app detecting Xposed is to deactivate Xposed when you need to use the app in question.