Related
Hi,
As written in the title, after the new update (18.1) magisk no longer hides the fact that my phone is rooted from my banking app.
Ive done everything I could think of in order to fix it but it still doesnt works...
Does anybody else is having the same issue, know how to fix it or know an another app that can hide root from apps?
Thank you in advance
try zygisk in settings
I used the app Island (from Oasis Feng) and cloned the banking app. It no longer detected Magisk.
Hi, my original plan was keeping my OP7 root-free because I need that banking app - which has an incredibly good root detection.
Long story short, a few days later and went back to my old habits... Magisk, Kernel, you name it. And the banking app stopped working again.
I do pass the safetynet test, have repackaged Magisk Manager. Google Pay is working like a charme. But Fidor bank seems to be better than Google, at least in this regard. I tried logging traffic using adguard, the app does not connect to anything, no dns requests as well.
Most of the times the app won't start at all, sometimes the first screen flashes for a very short period, and sometimes chrome opens with a webpage from the bank telling me my device is modified. How the **** do they know?
Maybe you guys may have a hint in what direction I could continue poking, because carrying a second phone just for banking is a little bit overkill...
h0l said:
Hi, my original plan was keeping my OP7 root-free because I need that banking app - which has an incredibly good root detection.
Long story short, a few days later and went back to my old habits... Magisk, Kernel, you name it. And the banking app stopped working again.
I do pass the safetynet test, have repackaged Magisk Manager. Google Pay is working like a charme. But Fidor bank seems to be better than Google, at least in this regard. I tried logging traffic using adguard, the app does not connect to anything, no dns requests as well.
Most of the times the app won't start at all, sometimes the first screen flashes for a very short period, and sometimes chrome opens with a webpage from the bank telling me my device is modified. How the **** do they know?
Maybe you guys may have a hint in what direction I could continue poking, because carrying a second phone just for banking is a little bit overkill...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you clear data of the banking app after Repackaging Magisk & adding it to Magisk Hide? I assume you did it.
Sent from my OnePlus6T using XDA Labs
DarkSJ1998 said:
Did you clear data of the banking app after Repackaging Magisk & adding it to Magisk Hide? I assume you did it.
Sent from my OnePlus6T using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did. And rebooted. And reinstalled. And combinations of those.
A short screenrecord of what is happening as soon as I try to open the app can be found here (youtube link)
I have the exact same Problem
Everything works: Netflix, other banking apps, etc.. Just Fidor. I do not really know how their detection works, but I assume it's not just a root detection.
The weird thing is, it worked flawlessly 2 years ago Now it's just annoying..
Waited a few versions oft Magisk now, however nothing changes.
You're not alone
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Same problem here ... since the new fidor version v3.14 is out, no way to getting it to work. Downgrade to 3.12 is futile, it forces the update to 3.14 immediately.
As an amendment to my post above (where you'll find pretty much all you need to hide from almost any app), I've successfully tested and hidden root from Fidor v3.14.0.1.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=79997227&postcount=98
Thank you, the issue seems to have been addressed there. But as far as I can see, the canary version does not have the optional modules, correct? So I think, unfortunately I will have to wait for an adapted release of the regular magisk.
rpc75 said:
But as far as I can see, the canary version does not have the optional modules, correct?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have no idea what that means... Magisk modules works just fine on the Canary releases.
Didgeridoohan said:
As an amendment to my post above (where you'll find pretty much all you need to hide from almost any app), I've successfully tested and hidden root from Fidor v3.14.0.1.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=79997227&postcount=98
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for sharing!
I have successfully installed the canary Magisk, have Magisk hide enabled, safetynet pass etc.
All bank apps work after adding them to the hide list, for example trying "Kontist" w/o hide gave error, with hide it works.
However, Fidor (3.14.0.1) is still not working for me :/
The app stays open for 1-2 seconds on the canary build, quite a bit longer than on stable version (instant close), clean cache + clean app data, still no luck.
So Fidor must use another detection method that the other bank apps don't have.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
dagoban said:
Thanks for sharing!
I have successfully installed the canary Magisk, have Magisk hide enabled, safetynet pass etc.
All bank apps work after adding them to the hide list, for example trying "Kontist" w/o hide gave error, with hide it works.
However, Fidor (3.14.0.1) is still not working for me :/
The app stays open for 1-2 seconds on the canary build, quite a bit longer than on stable version (instant close), clean cache + clean app data, still no luck.
So Fidor must use another detection method that the other bank apps don't have.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Similar Problem, my bank brought out a new app, that is detecting the root/custom rom somehow. The app closes and shows me security bull**** about root, jailbreak, custom roms. I don't know how everything should be hidden, SafetyNet checks out but this app can detect it. No idea how.
alike03 said:
Similar Problem, my bank brought out a new app, that is detecting the root/custom rom somehow. The app closes and shows me security bull**** about root, jailbreak, custom roms. I don't know how everything should be hidden, SafetyNet checks out but this app can detect it. No idea how.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check the link, one post before yours...
Didgeridoohan said:
Check the link, one post before yours...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I was already going through that one.
Turns out the Banking app was detecting the Original Magisk Package.
Hiding Magisk Manager itself fixed my problem. Thanks for the link.
Didgeridoohan said:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Still did not get Fidor to work. Crashes after the initial first 2-3 seconds. If I uninstall Magisk it works again. Disabling modules, delete files from sd-card, etc. didn't change a thing.
This also seem not to be the problem, since it works after uninstalling Magisk.
Fidor is hidden from Magisk, Magisk is repacked with other name.
Mind giving specific instructions on what you did to make Fidor work on your device?
Thyrador said:
Mind giving specific instructions on what you did to make Fidor work on your device?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's all right there in the link provided. I'm not doing anything that's not described there... Of course, there's a whole lot of things there that I didn't do.
Here's my setup:
Android Pie.
Magisk v19.4 (19307), with hidden Manager.
The app on the Hide list.
My internal storage is full of Magisk files and I never bother to disable any modules (all of the ones I have installed can be hidden without issue). I also have OEM Unlocking disabled, but that's just by chance and not something I've done because of an app detecting it...
Didgeridoohan said:
It's all right there in the link provided. I'm not doing anything that's not described there... Of course, there's a whole lot of things there that I didn't do.
Here's my setup:
Android Pie.
Magisk v19.4 (19307), with hidden Manager.
The app on the Hide list.
My internal storage is full of Magisk files and I never bother to disable any modules (all of the ones I have installed can be hidden without issue). I also have OEM Unlocking disabled, but that's just by chance and not something I've done because of an app detecting it...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So basically same setup. Still doesn't work with latest Fidor Release.
Thyrador said:
So basically same setup. Still doesn't work with latest Fidor Release.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you say "basically", what's the difference?
Didgeridoohan said:
When you say "basically", what's the difference?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the question. Even if I do a complete fresh install without anything else beside Magisk and Fidor: as soon as Magisk is running (hidden manager & Fidor, SafetyNet Pass and certified in PlayStore), Fidor stops working.
Thyrador said:
That's the question. Even if I do a complete fresh install without anything else beside Magisk and Fidor: as soon as Magisk is running (hidden manager & Fidor, SafetyNet Pass and certified in PlayStore), Fidor stops working.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're going to have to start digging deeper then...
On my phone xiaomi A1 rooted it works on the wife's phone xiaomi note 5 pro rooted it used to work fine but for some reason it has suddenly detected root and won't work now. I have checked all the settings to do with hiding are still selected as before, strange thing is it has worked briefly for a few seconds but then stopped again.
Please can people tell me if they have had this happen and how they fixed it please.
What checks is it doing to detect root does anyone know?
Thanks
hycraig said:
On my phone xiaomi A1 rooted it works on the wife's phone xiaomi note 5 pro rooted it used to work fine but for some reason it has suddenly detected root and won't work now. I have checked all the settings to do with hiding are still selected as before, strange thing is it has worked briefly for a few seconds but then stopped again.
Please can people tell me if they have had this happen and how they fixed it please.
What checks is it doing to detect root does anyone know?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try updating magisk.
Try to disable xposed modules.
Try to disable all modules.
See if it works now.
Then one by one reenable them.
Sent from my SM-G985F using Tapatalk
vash_h said:
Try updating magisk.
Try to disable xposed modules.
Try to disable all modules.
See if it works now.
Then one by one reenable them.
Sent from my SM-G985F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your reply magisk is up to date and I don't have any modules just magisk on its own. I do find it strange how it just stopped working after many months of being used regularly.
hycraig said:
Thanks for your reply magisk is up to date and I don't have any modules just magisk on its own. I do find it strange how it just stopped working after many months of being used regularly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Credits Google
Now safetynet fails after March update
You need to change device props to pixel or lock bootloader
hycraig said:
Thanks for your reply magisk is up to date and I don't have any modules just magisk on its own. I do find it strange how it just stopped working after many months of being used regularly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Biggest_Noob said:
Credits Google
Now safetynet fails after March update
You need to change device props to pixel or lock bootloader
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My safteynet passes fine on both my devices
Thanks
somehow they manage to detect root even if magisk manager is running under custom package name and magisk hide is enabled.
Last version that is still running is 13.1.1 (apk available on apkmirror).
h4lli said:
somehow they manage to detect root even if magisk manager is running under custom package name and magisk hide is enabled.
Last version that is still running is 13.1.1 (apk available on apkmirror).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks @h4lli i couldn't see sky go version 13.1.1 for uk
so i got Sky Go UK 12.4.14 from apkmirror and can confirm is working fine
yeah still doesnt work, latest sky go app 20, latest magisk, still detects, anyone able to reverse the sky app to see what methods its using?
Fyi - any version other than the latest (20.6.1) at the moment forces an upgrade to 20.6.1, which then detects root.
Safety net is passing both basic and cts with Eval type basic. I'm on latest canary (20425).
I've tried :-
Uninstalling all apps that skygo could look for (titanium, openvpn etc.)
Using a work profile (shelter and island)
Disabling oem unlocking
Disabling usb/adb debugging
Disabling developer options
Deleting all files and folders that have magisk, twrp or titanium in them.
Basically everything here https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
So, I think it's basically no go for sky go at the moment. Happy to be corrected if someone has it working.
Beardy
beardymarrow said:
Fyi - any version other than the latest (20.6.1) at the moment forces an upgrade to 20.6.1, which then detects root.
Safety net is passing both basic and cts with Eval type basic. I'm on latest canary (20425).
I've tried :-
Uninstalling all apps that skygo could look for (titanium, openvpn etc.)
Using a work profile (shelter and island)
Disabling oem unlocking
Disabling usb/adb debugging
Disabling developer options
Deleting all files and folders that have magisk, twrp or titanium in them.
Basically everything here https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
So, I think it's basically no go for sky go at the moment. Happy to be corrected if someone has it working.
Beardy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah still can't get it working. Damn it.
Hast everyone a sollution for running the sky Go App on rooted phones?
Skygo doesnt Work... hast anyone a sollution?
eula1977 said:
Skygo doesnt Work... hast anyone a sollution?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried this? It worked for me
SkyGo app detected root!
Hi everyone i have a problema using SkyGo app on my device because It detects the root. I renamed magisk , used magisk Hide , tried magiskhide props config , tried to delete cache and re-install SkyGo app but nothing worked...any solution...
forum.xda-developers.com
Hi everyone,
I'm just hitting my head against the wall with this applciation...
I'm running OP6 with evolution X 4.5.
This app refuses to let me uses it saying that "There's an error, Check if usb debugging is activated. Check if you're rooted or if a custom rom is installed"
I've tried magisk hide, also hidding some google services, usb debugging isn't activated,...
It's the only app I knoiw so far that can detect root on my phone.
Can anyone help me find a workaround please?
thanks.
Same here...
I am using MicroG without Safetynet support and I think that is the issue, unfortunately.
Payconiq by bancontact / rooted device
Hello
I have the same problem with OP6 rooted ... magisk hide activated but when run the payconiq Bancontact app " There is an error " not possible to run the app.
Anybody for a solution ?
veronesi.n said:
Hi everyone,
I'm just hitting my head against the wall with this applciation...
I'm running OP6 with evolution X 4.5.
This app refuses to let me uses it saying that "There's an error, Check if usb debugging is activated. Check if you're rooted or if a custom rom is installed"
I've tried magisk hide, also hidding some google services, usb debugging isn't activated,...
It's the only app I knoiw so far that can detect root on my phone.
Can anyone help me find a workaround please?
thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used to use an old apk of the app but now it doesn't let me use it and forces me to upgrade to last version.
My wife's app is working well but she has a lg g7 thinq unrooted.
So if someone can help, it would be very much appreciated as every other app is working well, safety net is passed, and this app is my only way to pay contactless because my banking app doesn't have a payement option in it.
I'm using it without issues. I hide it and just turn off USB debugging when I'm using it.
Just to make sure, did you just enable Magisk Hide in the options and nothing else?
Or did you also - after enabling - go into the Magisk Hide option that now appeared in the menu and placed a checkmark after all programs for which you want to hide Magisk from, in this case Payconiq ?
Clear Payconiq cache and data, reboot and setup Payconiq.
I have the same problem.
Magic hide is enabled. USB debugging is disabled.
In the Magic hide menu, the Payconiq app has a checkmark. All my other banking apps work fine.
Phone = Samsung J7 (2016)
Does someone have a solution?
Thanks
What's your problem with this app Can't you run it Can someone show what message is showing For me, this application is not available in my country, so I downloaded it from outside. I have Magisk 21000 root and Magisk manager 8.0.2 (307) (11) and it works for me and nothing is screaming about root etc :highfive:
It is the "Payconiq by Bancontact" app.
It worked on my phone without root. Since my phone is rooted, it doesn't work any more.
My phone is rooted with Magisk 20.4 (20400) and Manager 8.0.2 (307)
When I use the app: I receive this message. I hope this can help...
Date: 12 Oct 2020 15:23:47 GMT+02:00
Device: samsung SM-J710F
App version: 5.5.3
OS version: 8.1.0
App token: /
Failure code: ERROR_SDK_INTEGRITY (81)
Hello,
Problem solved.
Thanks to Spartacus500 .
I ’ve seen there is an other version of Magisk. I didn’t even know there was an update. :silly:
I did the following thinks:
In Magisk Hide menu, uncheck Payconiq app.
Stopped Payconiq app and Cleared data.
In Magisk Hide, place checkmark at payconiq app.
Installed Magisk 21.0 (21000) Beta.
Reboot.
Run Payconiq app, and it works fine
Hope it stay this way :fingers-crossed:
Veke123 said:
Hello,
Problem solved.
Thanks to Spartacus500 .
I ’ve seen there is an other version of Magisk. I didn’t even know there was an update. :silly:
I did the following thinks:
In Magisk Hide menu, uncheck Payconiq app.
Stopped Payconiq app and Cleared data.
In Magisk Hide, place checkmark at payconiq app.
Installed Magisk 21.0 (21000) Beta.
Reboot.
Run Payconiq app, and it works fine
Hope it stay this way :fingers-crossed:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which version of the app did you use?
Is it 5.5.3?
Can you share the apk?
I tried 5.8.3, 5.5.3 and 5.3.3 but there are all stuck at the start.
I am passing all checks on rootbeerfresh (root checker).
flotheking said:
Which version of the app did you use?
Is it 5.5.3?
Can you share the apk?
I tried 5.8.3, 5.5.3 and 5.3.3 but there are all stuck at the start.
I am passing all checks on rootbeerfresh (root checker).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use the "Payconiq By Bancontact" app. I don't know which version it was that worked before, but after an update I can not run it anymore on a rooted phone.
I will send you the apk of the "Payconiq by Bancontact" app. Hope you can find a solution.
I tried the other app (Payconiq) version 4.3.5.3 (latest) and it seems to be working.
flotheking said:
I tried the other app (Payconiq) version 4.3.5.3 (latest) and it seems to be working.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sorry for bumping an old thread but what are you using now?
In my case I'm still using the old Payconiq and I don't know what I'm going to do when it gets finally phased out.
Well, I'll just pay in another way I guess.
seeschloss said:
In my case I'm still using the old Payconiq and I don't know what I'm going to do when it gets finally phased out.
Well, I'll just pay in another way I guess.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thx for responding, what version are you using?
5.14.1 Payconiq app works for me Magisk hide root
Spartacus500 said:
5.14.1 Payconiq app works for me Magisk hide root
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sadly not working for me, when i hide app in magisk, launching gets aborted without error message
got it working again
latest magisk, latest riru, lsposed, gravitybox all installed without issues to payconiq
payconiq app hidden in magisk, magisk manager isn't hidden
the thing that got it working again was disabling magisk module G-visual mod, same for magisk module fullscreen immersive gestures. Apparently payconiq app doesn't like keyboard spacing to be changed ????
i'm quite happy that i found it, but if anyone could explain i'd very gratefull
Hello,
Can I also ask a question, please? How can payconiq detect that someone is using a custom-rom? I also get a message that I am using a Custom-rom and that it is not possible to install. However, I have not installed MAGISK and my phone is not rooted.
Thanks
Andi
Bergfex2 said:
Hello,
Can I also ask a question, please? How can payconiq detect that someone is using a custom-rom? I also get a message that I am using a Custom-rom and that it is not possible to install. However, I have not installed MAGISK and my phone is not rooted.
Thanks
Andi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Could be detecting your unlocked bootloader, various prop values, etc. For a list of props that are common detectors, and that MagiskHide changes (which of course is removed in the next stable release) you can check here:
https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Repo/MagiskHidePropsConf#setreset-magiskhide-sensitive-props
I got a new banking app today that detects root, its https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=no.vipps.bankid
no problem with the Swedish bankid or other Norwegian banking apps. google pay/wallet works.
I tried blocking it in magisk block list. then with Shamiko, I'm afraid to test too many thing since google wallet is working now.
Try this modified USNF module. The issue you may be having is the new Play Integrity API.
I tried the previous version and now this one, still the same. I'm in no hurry to fix it, all other stuff work and the old bankid solution works 2 more years I think (hope)
I'm in your exact same position.
I have the MagiskHide module and used the DenyList, I also tried Shamiko, no luck for this app.
I tried the modified USNF module and no luck either.
I have several other apps where the above methods to avoid detection are working without problems, but not this one.
In the same boat as you guys. Also tried the modified magisk delta project with the old magisk hide, no luck.
Where is this?
SafetyNet is good, all other banking-and wallet-apps is working. RootBeer is not detecting root.
Oneplus 7t pro, stock latest stable rom. Magisk delta. Hide root from all apps. Renamed magisk app.
same problem here. tried everything i could find and no luck. might be a DRM problem? because 1 other issue i cant fix is apps like Netflix and prime video which are currently unusable because of DRM.
My app was updated today, and immidiatly after the update I tried activating/logging in, and to my surprise it worked. There is a one hour grace/waiting period to activate, and I'm currently waiting for that.
If it is not working after the wait, I will update this post. So if no update, it is working.
See my previous post in this thread about my setup.
jale said:
My app was updated today, and immidiatly after the update I tried activating/logging in, and to my surprise it worked. There is a one hour grace/waiting period to activate, and I'm currently waiting for that.
If it is not working after the wait, I will update this post. So if no update, it is working.
See my previous post in this thread about my setup.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
same for me. so its probably okay for everyone for now. disable auto update on it now hahaha and lets hope it stays that way.
Can confirm, it works now without any change to Magisk or other modules.
I waited the 1h period and after that I was able to activate it and use it to login.
I am using Shamiko and a modified USNF module, but probably are not required.
Great to know that it's working now. But, for next time i can give u guyz some more option to keep in mind:
**renaming/deleting the "twrp/fox" folder of the recovery, deleting all files related to magisk or xposed. Also, hiding developer mode option by "devoptshide" from lsposed. **