Hi everyone! I recently bought a LG G6 H872, which still has 10e installed. After crawling the forums for a bit, here's the sequence of things I wanted to do to it:
1.) Update to 8.0 Oreo via OTA.
2.) Unlock bootloader
3.) Root and TWRP using this: https://forum.xda-developers.com/tmobile-g6/how-to/root-h872-to-including-11g-t3775518
4.) Magisk
Is the latest Oreo update the 20a version that is mentioned in the thread or should I manually update it to something older. I saw that there was anti-rollback so I don't want to update too far. Also, if there is ever another OTA, how does one update the rooted phone?
Edit: I wrote up some steps if it helps you on this post: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77513501&postcount=4
I do not believe there is currently a way to root the T-Mobile versions.
patruns said:
I do not believe there is currently a way to root the T-Mobile versions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is not correct, see: https://forum.xda-developers.com/tmobile-g6/how-to/root-h872-to-including-11g-t3775518
For future people who come across this thread, here are the steps I took to root this phone:
1.) Factory reset and then update device via OTA incrementally until 20a (which is Android Oreo 8.0)
2.) unlock bootloader: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EpaW0-8-QKY
3.) root device: https://forum.xda-developers.com/tmobile-g6/how-to/root-h872-to-including-11g-t3775518
Note: there is a video tutorial here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-z4CWLikPcI&t=821s. The first steps of flashing the laf partition are very useful to watch before attempting
4.) Factory reset in TWRP
5.) Reset after encryption error, then wipe with TWRP. May give mount error.
6.) Boot into Android Oreo. Device is not yet rooted at this point.
6.) Flash MAGISK via TWRP (SD card or ADB push) ]. Ignore the mount error. Reboot.
7.) Device is rooted! :good:
That's interesting
Without getting into an issue those steps look slightly different in order than the original process.
Or I'm a dumbass and somehow got it out of order. Seems ok now though.
Hello there!
I want to ask if it's the same to do the steps with 20e ?
Curious as well if this works with the latest update.
thendless said:
Curious as well if this works with the latest update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is an already rooted version of the latest update. I've downloaded but haven't flashed it yet, but the op is good and I've never had an issue with his work.
https://r.tapatalk.com/shareLink?ur...share_tid=3875515&share_fid=3793&share_type=t
Sent from my LG-H872 using Tapatalk
I succeeded in completing the process.
Permanent unlock from Tom via app.
Unlocked bootloader.
Twrp installed to recovery, can boot to recovery via low volume/power button combo.
Magisk installed.
20a working nicely.
I'm getting requests from Tmo to update from 20a to 20d. Is this recommended? Will twrp, root, unlock, etc. be lost?
I am glad to see that the bootloader gets unlocked easily. @alliance1975 how did you go from Unlocked bootloader step to Twrp installed step? That is the big one I think.
There is a good TWRP available, but we can't install it because the phone lacks fastboot commands. Is there a way to install TWRP? Or is it really that the only method is the rather risky runningnak3d method?
interestor said:
I am glad to see that the bootloader gets unlocked easily. @alliance1975 how did you go from Unlocked bootloader step to Twrp installed step? That is the big one I think.
There is a good TWRP available, but we can't install it because the phone lacks fastboot commands. Is there a way to install TWRP? Or is it really that the only method is the rather risky runningnak3d method?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used the procedure summarized in step 3. I agree it is risky, well, the riskiest root & twrp I've ever tried. I neglected to say I only read instructions, the dev who actually came up with the plan deserves all the credit.
When I try to oem unlock nothing happens. What can I do? I have followed all other instructions.
Follow steps from this https://forum.xda-developers.com/tmobile-g6/how-to/unlock-bootloader-tmo-t3578099
Yeah I got my bootloader unlocked
alliance1975 said:
I succeeded in completing the process.
Permanent unlock from Tom via app.
Unlocked bootloader.
Twrp installed to recovery, can boot to recovery via low volume/power button combo.
Magisk installed.
20a working nicely.
I'm getting requests from Tmo to update from 20a to 20d. Is this recommended? Will twrp, root, unlock, etc. be lost?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any info on this? Will updating from 20a mess up the phone (root, etc...)?
Related
Hello all,
With news that the Z3 and Z3 compact are starting to get Lollipop today I am sure a lot of people are going to be coming to the boards asking this exact question. So I wanted to start a thread that can help people find the answer quickly. (I'll update the OP as useful info comes in.)
I am currently on a D5803 running 4.4.4, with a locked bootloader and am rooted. I used This how-to to get where I am.
What is the best way to upgrade to Lollipop for me?
Is there a way to keep root? A pre-rooted FTF file?
Will all DRM features remain?
Will I need to reinstall anything? Recovery? Busy Box? SU?
Does this upgrade require a full wipe?
Thanks for any help
If anyone wants to check if their bootloader is locked:
Dial *#*#7378423#*#* . Then go to -> "Service Info" -> "Configuration". If there is:
Bootloader unlock allowed - Yes << this means that your Bootloader is Locked
Bootloader Unlocked - Yes << this means that your bootloader is unlocked
just wonder...
i definitly want to root my Z3C.
Should i root with KK 4.4 or wait for Lollipop(and root later) !?
TheTomcraft said:
just wonder...
i definitly want to root my Z3C.
Should i root with KK 4.4 or wait for Lollipop(and root later) !?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You root on KK then you can update to Lollipop and keep root.
The problem seems to be getting recovery working, or keeping it working. Can anyone comment on whether they've tried the below:
1) Flash pre-rooted D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Customized_NCB rooted.zip containing Lollipop 5.0.2 in TWRP
2) Flash Z3C-lockeddualrecovery2.8.3-RELEASE.flashable.zip in TWRP
3) Flash UPDATE-SuperSU-v2.46.zip in TWRP
4) Flash the stock D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Baltic_Generic.ftf and exclude system (and data/cache from the wipe section to keep settings)?
In the other recovery threats NUT seems to think his recovery should still work?
Sean09 said:
The problem seems to be getting recovery working, or keeping it working. Can anyone comment on whether they've tried the below:
1) Flash pre-rooted D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Customized_NCB rooted.zip containing Lollipop 5.0.2 in TWRP
2) Flash Z3C-lockeddualrecovery2.8.3-RELEASE.flashable.zip in TWRP
3) Flash UPDATE-SuperSU-v2.46.zip in TWRP
4) Flash the stock D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Baltic_Generic.ftf and exclude system (and data/cache from the wipe section to keep settings)?
In the other recovery threats NUT seems to think his recovery should still work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Recovery isn't working, but I'm happy with just root for now, which works great.
I didn't flash the stock after SuperSU, don't see any reason to and works for me.
frason said:
Recovery isn't working, but I'm happy with just root for now, which works great.
I didn't flash the stock after SuperSU, don't see any reason to and works for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
could you please write what exactly you did to achieve this. Step by step guide would be awesome. Thanks!
gruev said:
could you please write what exactly you did to achieve this. Step by step guide would be awesome. Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Flashed "D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Customized_NCB rooted.zip" in TWRP.
Without rebooting, flashed "UPDATE-SuperSU-v2.46.zip" in TWRP.
Done, working root.
q.
frason said:
Flashed "D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Customized_NCB rooted.zip" in TWRP.
Without rebooting, flashed "UPDATE-SuperSU-v2.46.zip" in TWRP.
Done, working root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you wipe? or flash over?
newbie2006 said:
Did you wipe? or flash over?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wiped it (had too much crap on the phone anyway, so worth it), restored what I wanted with Titanium Backup when done.
---------- Post added at 10:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:19 PM ----------
I also tried with flashing lockeddualrecovery but recovery doesn't work. So need to wait for an update on that one I guess.
Any ideas about what could go bad if I don't wipe data?
Also, do you still have drm?
I succesfully flashed lolipop with this method without data wipe. I still have root and DRM keys. The only thing I lost was data of some app's with external data linked to SD card with Link2SD. And some root app's started to claim about busybox not installed properly. Besides that everything works like a charm
frason said:
Flashed "D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Customized_NCB rooted.zip" in TWRP.
Without rebooting, flashed "UPDATE-SuperSU-v2.46.zip" in TWRP.
Done, working root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you flash those do you have system read and write as well? Do we need to worry about the RICDefeat in doing all this for the upgrade? Is RICDefeat integrated into that?
1.Flash the tft of lollipop
2.Get the zip of XZDualRecovery 2.8.3 Advanced Stock Kernel from http://nut.xperia-files.com/ and supersu from http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1538053
3.Flash the boot.img in AndroPlusKernel with cable on flashtool
4.Reboot in recovery
5.Flash XZDualRecovery 2.8.3 Advanced Stock and supersu
6.Enjoy
Sorry，it should be with UB
about not working recovery
Dont know it thats issue, but I have same clue.
On KitKat after applying all steps to root 4.4.4 rom recovery was working until I changed busybox.
Oryginaly busybox was in version 1.20.2-jb - with that recovery was working.
I need some other tools and updated busbox to version 1.22.1 and recovery wasnt working (starting recovery end up with bootloop, but could start to system).
Returning back to recovery 1.20.2-jb fixed problem.
frason said:
Recovery isn't working, but I'm happy with just root for now, which works great.
I didn't flash the stock after SuperSU, don't see any reason to and works for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sean09 said:
The problem seems to be getting recovery working, or keeping it working. Can anyone comment on whether they've tried the below:
1) Flash pre-rooted D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Customized_NCB rooted.zip containing Lollipop 5.0.2 in TWRP
2) Flash Z3C-lockeddualrecovery2.8.3-RELEASE.flashable.zip in TWRP
3) Flash UPDATE-SuperSU-v2.46.zip in TWRP
4) Flash the stock D5803_23.1.A.0.690_Baltic_Generic.ftf and exclude system (and data/cache from the wipe section to keep settings)?
In the other recovery threats NUT seems to think his recovery should still work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was hoping by adding step 4, it would be possible the encrypt device. Sadly it still creates a bootloop.
in my case I received the notification update via OTA, have Kit Kat with root if I update, will i lose root?
skaarax said:
in my case I received the notification update via OTA, have Kit Kat with root if I update, will i lose root?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I want to know about this too.
And what is a safe process for us (locked bootloader, rooted 4.4) to upgrade to 5.02 or 5.1 in the future.
I heard that unlocking bootloader will causes the camera not working properly (at least the auto mode would be messed up)
Does TWRP requiring unlocking bootloader?
Thanks guys.
I'm resurrecting this thread as I've got the same question as previous posters and I've not been able to find an answer elsewhere on the forum.
Basically, I've got a phone with a Bootloader which can't be unlocked. I upgraded/rooted it last year. It's still on KitKat. Is there any way I can upgrade it to Lollipop or Marshmallow without going through the downgrade/flash pre-rooted ROM procedure, without losing root? In other words, can I make use of TWRP which I installed in order to flash the rooted ROM last time? If so, how? (I'm not keen on using KingRoot unless somebody can convince me that handing over my IMEI info is safe.)
Thanks in advance.
Just flash a pre-rooted 5.1 zip made with prf creator whilst still on root+recovery KK. That's how I updated my M2 from rooted 4.4.4 KK to rooted 5.1 lollipop whilst retaining my locked bootloader. No sure if it's working for mm yet though this way
Hi all:
After upgrading my unlocked-but-still-rooted Turbo to Motorola stock Marshmallow, my Android Pay no longer works; I get the message about Android not be able to verify etc. From what I understand, SafetyNet now checks for unlocked bootloaders, not just root. Also, from what I understand, Sultanxda found a workaround by modifying the Android kernel, which they have working on the OP3.
Does anyone know if anyone is working on this for the original Turbo, and/or could someone kindly point me in the right direction?
Thanks in advance.
Workaround info: https://www.xda-developers.com/sult...otloader-check-on-latest-cm13-builds-for-op3/
phraxen said:
Hi all:
After upgrading my unlocked-but-still-rooted Turbo to Motorola stock Marshmallow, my Android Pay no longer works; I get the message about Android not be able to verify etc. From what I understand, SafetyNet now checks for unlocked bootloaders, not just root. Also, from what I understand, Sultanxda found a workaround by modifying the Android kernel, which they have working on the OP3.
Does anyone know if anyone is working on this for the original Turbo, and/or could someone kindly point me in the right direction?
Thanks in advance.
Workaround info: https://www.xda-developers.com/sult...otloader-check-on-latest-cm13-builds-for-op3/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Some of the CM-based ROMs floating around address this issue, but there is no way to use stock marshmallow with an unlocked bootloader and pass safetynet. So if you want android pay, your options are to stay on SU4TL-49 or install one of the CM-based ROMs that have implemented a workaround.
I got around this issue by using my credit card company's app instead of Android Pay. It allows me to do wireless payments everywhere Android Pay is accepted, but it only checks for root. It does not use safetynet.
Too late for you now, but recently someone in this forum updated to Marshmallow radio, but did NOT flash the Marshmallow bootloader. They were already using custom ROM. Others using that ROM who flashed Marshmallow bootloader no longer pass safetynet, but that person does. The conclusions is an unlocked Marshmallow bootloader or newer is what Safetynet looks for?
And yes, I've flashed both Marshmallow bootloader and radios over both my daily XT1225. I could only test the theory by breaking out my new-in-box third Quark, which have for emergency back-up -- and is which still probably on Kitkat.
While I previously had the older Google Wallet, Android Pay for me is not as important as controlling my own phone as I please. My phones will always be rooted. And in the Moto Quark, unlocking the bootloader is necessary for permanent root, whereas it's not necessary in some other phones -- like LG. But whatever needs to be done to root my phones, I will. And if Android Pay is not possible, so be it. I always carry my wallet when I go out somewhere. Pulling out my phone, pulling out my wallet, what's the difference?
phraxen said:
Hi all:
After upgrading my unlocked-but-still-rooted Turbo to Motorola stock Marshmallow, my Android Pay no longer works; I get the message about Android not be able to verify etc. From what I understand, SafetyNet now checks for unlocked bootloaders, not just root. Also, from what I understand, Sultanxda found a workaround by modifying the Android kernel, which they have working on the OP3.
Does anyone know if anyone is working on this for the original Turbo, and/or could someone kindly point me in the right direction?
Thanks in advance.
Workaround info: https://www.xda-developers.com/sult...otloader-check-on-latest-cm13-builds-for-op3/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So actually there is a way to get safetynet working again. All you have to do is flash the SU4TL-49 bootloader and wipe cache. I'll be posting the bootloader separately when I get a chance, but if you don't want to wait that long, download the full firmware package here: https://mega.nz/#!i84inDgI!IM_A_IpLlKfGpC90S2DPB6g9t8rVkhO8heE4o_WpdMI, extract bootloader.img and flash using fastboot.
fastboot flash motoboot bootloader.img
fastboot erase cache
EDIT: Here is a flashable zip that will flash the bootloader for you for those who are so inclined. Make sure to wipe cache and dalvik/art cache in TWRP afterwards: https://mega.nz/#!6logEaIQ!q8qPJw65Upt38Hxiu1JyxErmwbgL7CBzuGzzPC0C9pQ
EDIT 2: And here is the bootloader.img taken from the SU4TL-49 package if fastboot is your weapon of choice: https://mega.nz/#!iogRGIrQ!ixpZGw1cR90jLxe9r8EAt76SGNoSqVqSv1iu0v14QCc
TheSt33v said:
So actually there is a way to get safetynet working again. All you have to do is flash the SU4TL-49 bootloader and wipe cache. I'll be posting the bootloader separately when I get a chance, but if you don't want to wait that long, download the full firmware package here: https://mega.nz/#!i84inDgI!IM_A_IpLlKfGpC90S2DPB6g9t8rVkhO8heE4o_WpdMI, extract bootloader.img and flash using fastboot.
fastboot flash motoboot bootloader.img
Remember to wipe cache afterwards.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm confused... isn't that downgrading the bootloader?
ChazzMatt said:
I'm confused... isn't that downgrading the bootloader?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it is. And as long as your bootloader is unlocked, no harm no foul. I thought that downgrading the bootloader was the one thing that you couldn't do even if it was unlocked, but I just did it and I'm passing safetynet now, so I guess I was wrong.
If anyone wants proof I'm on the SU4TL-49 bootloader, I can take a picture when I get home. I don't know of a way to get a picture of the bootloader screen using only my phone.
TheSt33v said:
Yes it is. And as long as your bootloader is unlocked, no harm no foul. I thought that downgrading the bootloader was the one thing that you couldn't do even if it was unlocked, but I just did it and I'm passing safetynet now, so I guess I was wrong.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Learn something new everyday. Wow.
You just can't downgrade a locked bootloader, eh?
Thank you!
When I get home will try Lollipop bootloader on my XT1225.
The custom ROM guys will love this, then.
ChazzMatt said:
Learn something new everyday. Wow.
You just can't downgrade a locked bootloader, eh?
Thank you!
When I get home will try Lollipop bootloader on my XT1225.
The custom ROM guys will love this, then.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I seem to remember trying this a long time ago using TWRP, and TWRP was unable to flash the older bootloader. It works fine through fastboot though. I'm going to do some more investigation when I'm not at work to see if I can get TWRP to do this. That would be easier for most people.
Also, I thought the latest iSu already got around this issue. That's what BHB's command line patch thing is for. But it will certainly make things easier!
TheSt33v said:
I seem to remember trying this a long time ago using TWRP, and TWRP was unable to flash the older bootloader. It works fine through fastboot though. I'm going to do some more investigation when I'm not at work to see if I can get TWRP to do this. That would be easier for most people.
Also, I thought the latest iSu already got around this issue. That's what BHB's command line patch thing is for. But it will certainly make things easier!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was on the latest bootloader and just flashed the .47 bootloader because of major radio issues. I flashed from TWRP and have been doing it since the .49 update.
gumbi2647 said:
I was on the latest bootloader and just flashed the .47 bootloader because of major radio issues. I flashed from TWRP and have been doing it since the .49 update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting. I've noticed that TWRP randomly has issues with flashing things on my phone for some reason, and a reboot often fixes the issue. Maybe I just got unlucky that one time, but if that's the case, I'll have a flashable SU4TL-49 bootloader up a few minutes after I get home.
TheSt33v said:
Interesting. I've noticed that TWRP randomly has issues with flashing things on my phone for some reason, and a reboot often fixes the issue. Maybe I just got unlucky that one time, but if that's the case, I'll have a flashable SU4TL-49 bootloader up a few minutes after I get home.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
IF you can flash through TWRP, then clearing caches is no problem in TWRP. IF we must use ADB, please include instructions to also clear caches that way, in any write-up -- if that's what you mean?
Or you do you mean flash bootloader in ADB, then immediately boot into TWRP and clear caches -- before booting back to system?
ChazzMatt said:
IF you can flash through TWRP, then clearing caches is no problem in TWRP. IF we must use ADB, please include instructions to also clear caches that way, in any write-up -- if that's what you mean?
Or you do you mean flash bootloader in ADB, then immediately boot into TWRP and clear caches -- before booting back to system?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ADB is not involved. Only fastboot.
The way I did it on my phone (XT1254 unrooted, unlocked, 100% stock MM) exactly was this:
1. Make note of BL version on bootloader screen.
2. fastboot flash motoboot bootloader.img using the SU4TL-49 bootloader.
3. Reboot bootloader
4. Confirm that the BL version has changed (it did)
5. Reboot to system.
6. Tried safetynet (failed)
7. Reboot to stock MM recovery menu
8. Wipe cache, reboot to system
9. Tried safetynet (passed), added a bunch of cards in Android Pay without issue
I'm assuming that wiping cache using other methods will be just as effective, but I don't know that for sure.
TheSt33v said:
ADB is not involved. Only fastboot.
The way I did it on my phone (unrooted, unlocked, 100% stock MM) exactly was this:
1. Make note of BL version on bootloader screen.
2. fastboot flash motoboot bootloader.img using the SU4TL-49 bootloader.
3. Reboot bootloader
4. Confirm that that BL version has changed (it did)
5. Reboot to system.
6. Tried safetynet (failed)
7. Reboot to stock MM recovery menu
8. Wipe cache, reboot to system
9. Test safetynet (passed)
I'm assuming that wiping cache using other methods will be just as effective, but I don't know that for sure.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which version of TWRP are you using? I heard the 04 update has some issues. I have been on 03 forever.
gumbi2647 said:
Which version of TWRP are you using? I heard the 04 update has some issues. I have been on 03 forever.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
04, so that could be it.
I post this around XDA, new bootloader add a new prop line
it add
[ro.boot.flash.locked]: [0]
And I patch that with this
https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=745425885120696423
with will change that to
[ro.boot.flash.locked]: [1]
Just use adb command
Code:
getprop | grep ro.boot.flash.locked
to check.
and then cts will not fail so is not really need to downgrade for now, There is the chance that Moto will change the boot.img so it can't boot on old bootloader, that did not happens yet on quark but others Moto device is need latest bootloader with latest ROM.
But then again may never be a update from Moto to this device.
So as long Moto did not make another patch flash this in TWRP and test with latest bootloader
https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=745425885120696423
of course that will not fix any other CTS fail like xposed or ROOT
So let me know if that helps if not it may be somethings else that can also be patched.
TheSt33v said:
So actually there is a way to get safetynet working again. All you have to do is flash the SU4TL-49 bootloader and wipe cache. I'll be posting the bootloader separately when I get a chance, but if you don't want to wait that long, download the full firmware package here: https://mega.nz/#!i84inDgI!IM_A_IpLlKfGpC90S2DPB6g9t8rVkhO8heE4o_WpdMI, extract bootloader.img and flash using fastboot.
fastboot flash motoboot bootloader.img
fastboot erase cache
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this. I'll give it a shot and let you know how it turns out.
bhb27;70506510So as long Moto did not make another patch flash this in TWRP and test with latest bootloader
[url said:
https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=745425885120696423[/url]
of course that will not fix any other CTS fail like xposed or ROOT
So let me know if that helps if not it may be somethings else that can also be patched.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! Flashing that works just fine. So now we have 2 options.
bhb27 said:
I post this around XDA, new bootloader add a new prop line
it add
[ro.boot.flash.locked]: [0]
And I patch that with this
https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=745425885120696423
with will change that to
[ro.boot.flash.locked]: [1]
Just use adb command
Code:
getprop | grep ro.boot.flash.locked
to check.
and then cts will not fail so is not really need to downgrade for now, There is the chance that Moto will change the boot.img so it can't boot on old bootloader, that did not happens yet on quark but others Moto device is need latest bootloader with latest ROM.
But then again may never be a update from Moto to this device.
So as long Moto did not make another patch flash this in TWRP and test with latest bootloader
https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=745425885120696423
of course that will not fix any other CTS fail like xposed or ROOT
So let me know if that helps if not it may be somethings else that can also be patched.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That worked for me. I was able to add a debit card without getting the error.
Thanks to you and TheSt33v.
ChazzMatt said:
IF you can flash through TWRP, then clearing caches is no problem in TWRP. IF we must use ADB, please include instructions to also clear caches that way, in any write-up -- if that's what you mean?
Or you do you mean flash bootloader in ADB, then immediately boot into TWRP and clear caches -- before booting back to system?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried this using TWRP and if so did everything go well
Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk
joekitch said:
Have you tried this using TWRP and if so did everything go well
Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have not personally tried it yet. Someone else can answer if they have?
I was wondering what sort of changes take place when you root the G5s Plus. I got several patch updates so far. Will the latest update stay once I root the device? I just want to root the device for now, not install any custom roms.
I received an OTA with an unlocked bootloader so I don't see any reason why you wouldn't with root. This only works with the stock recovery though, if you have TWRP installed I don't think it will work.
William1020000 said:
I received an OTA with an unlocked bootloader so I don't see any reason why you wouldn't with root. This only works with the stock recovery though, if you have TWRP installed I don't think it will work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rooting involves 3 steps. Unlock bootloader, install TWRP, and install Magisk patch. Just unlocked bootloader doesn't mean phone is rooted.
androidman2018 said:
Rooting involves 3 steps. Unlock bootloader, install TWRP, and install Magisk patch. Just unlocked bootloader doesn't mean phone is rooted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unlikely that the OTA will install if you have TWRP and Magisk... I wonder if we can still use Flashfire to flash the OTA and keep recovery and root?
Hi,
Can someone concisely give the most up to date instructions on how to root the P20 Pro
Confused because some people talk about debranding first? Is this necessary if you, like me, just have a generic non-network branded phone?
Also.. Does rooting require twrp?
A bit unclear on if I should use the offical or unofficial twrp methods.
And if so does twrp prevent OTA updates? I was lead to believe that any OTA updates would simply wipe any root and you just have to go through the steps again, but would twrp prevent an OTA update in the first place?
What are the best instructions to root the P20 Pro to keep the OTA updates going (even if you need to reroot after each update).
Thanks heaps in getting through the confusion!
Here you have manual to root in simple 4 steps. You need adb and fastboot on your computer, bootloader unlock code and Magisk from link in post
https://forum.xda-developers.com/hu...de-how-to-root-debrand-remove-retail-t3788326
Does any of the steps,
1/ unlocking the bootloader
2/ debranding
3/ installing TWRP
3/ rooting
Wipe the device?.. I'm assuming yes?
Also. What's the point of debranding?..
I think I'm on a generic P20 Pro that wasn't bought from a carrier - so is that step necessary for me.
Thanks heaps again for the advice - coming over from the Samsung world and maybe I'm so used to the rooting methods there
Also do any of those steps prevent OTA updates?
Or is there somehow to still use OTA updates but simply need to reapply root on every occasion there is ah update?
dgoncalves81 said:
Also do any of those steps prevent OTA updates?
Or is there somehow to still use OTA updates but simply need to reapply root on every occasion there is ah update?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unlocking the bootloader will wipe your device. The other steps won't.
You need to have TWRP installed in order to be able to flash Magisk (for Root), and no you don't have to rebrand if you don't want to. You'll still be able to receive and download OTAs but if TWRP remains installed on your phone it won't be able to install unless you change back to the stock recovery. However there is methods to update with TWRP and you'll be able to get and install updates quicker than waiting for them to be pushed to you phone. That's the main reason people rebrand because generic European models are getting updates the fastest.
What's your device model and current firmware version from 'About Phone' in settings?
..
danifilth4king said:
Unlocking the bootloader will wipe your device. The other steps won't.
You need to have TWRP installed in order to be able to flash Magisk (for Root), and no you don't have to rebrand if you don't want to. You'll still be able to receive and download OTAs but if TWRP remains installed on your phone it won't be able to install unless you change back to the stock recovery. However there is methods to update with TWRP and you'll be able to get and install updates quicker than waiting for them to be pushed to you phone. That's the main reason people rebrand because generic European models are getting updates the fastest.
What's your device model and current firmware version from 'About Phone' in settings?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks heaps for the advice - makes sense now!
I'm using the model CLT-L29 on C636 which I think is the Asia Pacific model.. And incidentally just received a OTA upgrade to the 128 firmware
.. So in order to receive OTA updates you simply have to change back to the stock recovery after using TWRP to install magisk and root?
But I imagine every time the OTA update occurs it wipes root?.. Which would mean reinstalling TWRP to regain root and doing the whole process again every time?
dgoncalves81 said:
Thanks heaps for the advice - makes sense now!
I'm using the model CLT-L29 on C636 which I think is the Asia Pacific model.. And incidentally just received a OTA upgrade to the 128 firmware
.. So in order to receive OTA updates you simply have to change back to the stock recovery after using TWRP to install magisk and root?
But I imagine every time the OTA update occurs it wipes root?.. Which would mean reinstalling TWRP to regain root and doing the whole process again every time?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep you got it in one lol
The other option so that you don't have to flash TWRP then back to stock recovery each time is when you receive an OTA is download the same firmware (Full-OTA version) from Firmware Finder - you would just need the update.zip - then using Huawei update extractor you can extract the ramdisk.img Then copy the ramdisk.img to your phone, use Magisk manager to patch it then copy it back to your PC and flash it via fastboot. But I think this is more work than flashing between TWRP & stock recoveries haha
I’m sure this is very simple and I’m just not getting it…
got new moto x4 XT1900-1 from b&h
unlocked boot loader with motorola code
using windows fast boot was able to follow the "How to : Moto X4 Root & TWRP Recovery" bu Munchy on youtube to install twrp using payton 3.2.1-1
then installed Magish 17.1 which seems to be what actually rooted the phone as per confirmation by Root Check app shows 8.1.0
now I am getting constant ota notices of a security update OPWS28.3.2 and I download it and it fails which is apparently normal for a rooted phone.
Can I disable the root and update???…can this be done by turning off magic…or uninstalling it…or is this done by tarp?
I believe I should back up the recover image using twrp…then what?…find and boot to a stock image?
???
any info appreciated
tia
PS…I just tried the "topjohnwu Update OTA tutorial for v17" method in tips and tricks on here and it also said update failed???
jojojones said:
I’m sure this is very simple and I’m just not getting it…
got new moto x4 XT1900-1 from b&h
unlocked boot loader with motorola code
using windows fast boot was able to follow the "How to : Moto X4 Root & TWRP Recovery" bu Munchy on youtube to install twrp using payton 3.2.1-1
then installed Magish 17.1 which seems to be what actually rooted the phone as per confirmation by Root Check app shows 8.1.0
now I am getting constant ota notices of a security update OPWS28.3.2 and I download it and it fails which is apparently normal for a rooted phone.
Can I disable the root and update???…can this be done by turning off magic…or uninstalling it…or is this done by tarp?
I believe I should back up the recover image using twrp…then what?…find and boot to a stock image?
???
any info appreciated
tia
PS…I just tried the "topjohnwu Update OTA tutorial for v17" method in tips and tricks on here and it also said update failed???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What I did (might be an easier way but this was fast and easy):
1) Uninstall/remove Magisk.
2) Re-flash firmware over current system but don't do 'fastboot erase userdata'
3) Boot into your system and take all the OTA's
4) Re-install Magisk via TWRP
Took about 10 minutes. Longest part was waiting for OTA's to install.
Sorry...I'm new to all this. How do I reflash firmware?....use twrp app that is installed?
Magisk 17 supposedly has the ability to do this.
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/tips.md
If you try this, please let us know. I have been waiting for an update to test this function.
jhedfors said:
Magisk 17 supposedly has the ability to do this.
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/tips.md
If you try this, please let us know. I have been waiting for an update to test this function.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did not work for me. Nothing has so far.
jojojones said:
Sorry...I'm new to all this. How do I reflash firmware?....use twrp app that is installed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use this guide:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-x4/how-to/guide-how-to-flash-official-factory-t3808348
Remove command "fastboot erase userdata" from script flash-all.bat/flash-all.sh.
jhedfors said:
Magisk 17 supposedly has the ability to do this.
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/tips.md
If you try this, please let us know. I have been waiting for an update to test this function.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried this, and it didn't work. Ended up having to boot into TWRP, uninstall Magisk, and then reboot. Haven't bothered trying to update since I attempted that.
jhedfors said:
Magisk 17 supposedly has the ability to do this.
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/tips.md
If you try this, please let us know. I have been waiting for an update to test this function.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I spent a little while trying to apply OTA with magisk. The only way I was able to do it was to flash the stock firmware like everyone says. I could only find 8.0, so I had to flash the firmware, install 3 OTA's, then reinstall twrp/magisk.
The only thing I didn't try was installing magisk without twrp, which I believe is supported but I'm not sure. I think that might be the secret sauce to fixing it, but I'm not sure, and I haven't wanted to reflash and go through the whole process again.
tjololo12 said:
I spent a little while trying to apply OTA with magisk. The only way I was able to do it was to flash the stock firmware like everyone says. I could only find 8.0, so I had to flash the firmware, install 3 OTA's, then reinstall twrp/magisk.
The only thing I didn't try was installing magisk without twrp, which I believe is supported but I'm not sure. I think that might be the secret sauce to fixing it, but I'm not sure, and I haven't wanted to reflash and go through the whole process again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you have the xt1900-1 retus you can flash the android one firmware which is 8.1 (currently on the Aug 2018 security patch).
ptn107 said:
If you have the xt1900-1 retus you can flash the android one firmware which is 8.1 (currently on the Aug 2018 security patch).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the android one variant. Do you know where I can get the firmware? There's a new security patch and I'd like to try installing it with stock bootloader + magisk (installed from a temporary twrp boot) to see if that works with the OTA. I'd like to get the method working since android 9 is coming at some point.
tjololo12 said:
I have the android one variant. Do you know where I can get the firmware? There's a new security patch and I'd like to try installing it with stock bootloader + magisk (installed from a temporary twrp boot) to see if that works with the OTA. I'd like to get the method working since android 9 is coming at some point.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
September 2018 OTA for Android One (Oreo 8.1):
Blur_Version.28.251.17.payton_fi.google_fi.en.US
Click to "Download" and save as ZIP file.
Only way how to apply OTA update with magisk rooted X4 is flash ROM using fastboot (august 2018 ROM is on AFH), remove command 'fastboot erase userdata' from script 'flash-all.bat', install september OTA from adb sideload/SD card and root again.
Comby_sk said:
September 2018 OTA for Android One (Oreo 8.1):
Blur_Version.28.251.17.payton_fi.google_fi.en.US
Click to "Download" and save as ZIP file.
Only way how to apply OTA update with magisk rooted X4 is flash ROM using fastboot (august 2018 ROM is on AFH), remove command 'fastboot erase userdata' from script 'flash-all.bat', install september OTA from adb sideload/SD card and root again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, the rom is exactly what I was looking for, I just wasn't sure which one to use. I'd hate to install the wrong rom and mess something up.
EDIT: I did get a chance to try it and you're correct, there is no way to install an OTA to this device without fully reflashing the stock rom, taking the OTA, then installing Magisk. I tried the following steps:
1. Flash ROM given from androidfilehost
2. Reboot, wait for OTA notification
3. Boot to bootloader
4. use fastboot to temporarily boot twrp
5. flash magisk 17.1 zipfile
6. reboot to system, verify that magisk/root is installed
7. Uninstall magisk using magisk manager "Restore Images" as given in the tips.md file
8. Take OTA
the OTA still failed, so even though TWRP wasn't installed and it was still the stock recovery, I was unable to install the OTA. Shame, it'd be nice if we could get this to work, but oh well.