Related
It seems that Leedroid Rom support HTC Camera with panoramic and HDR mode.. (tnx Lee )i'm asking to m(g)ods if its possibile to extract the apk and relative dependencies to have a working Camera on other roms too ( specially ARHD,lol ) Why? Because Panoramic mode in HTC Camera is fantastic! its the best. no rivals. photos are 90% merged correctly and the result is always awesome!
--------------------------------------------------------------------
EDIT:
i've taken the files and the lib from Lee Rom and make a flashable zip..tried,and:
HDR works;
PANO works first time,then it gets stuck, and killing camera from task manager cause FC all applications who use camera until reboot.
I have to find some other files in the framework that have camera dependencies..its a good start btw
For those who wanna try,i've uploaded a restore zip that will put back original ARHD files.
http://www.mediafire.com/?9bkc6z61kr9zhq6
http://www.mediafire.com/?xqdxcl2xjwlc3ui
Currently uploading the camera app for you.
Here it is:
HTCCamera.apk
It is from Sense 3.0.
Cool
Sent from my PC36100 using xda premium
Ditti4 said:
Currently uploading the camera app for you.
Here it is:
HTCCamera.apk
It is from Sense 3.0.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks, but the app won't install
20mark said:
thanks, but the app won't install
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hm, it should work without any app, because you have Android Revolution running which includes Sense 3.0 by stock.
And my camera app is also from this.
Are you sure there is no support for panorama and HDR?
Have you looked under Effects in the Menu?
20mark said:
It seems that Leedroid Rom support HTC Camera with panoramic and HDR mode.. (tnx Lee )i'm asking to m(g)ods if its possibile to extract the apk and relative dependencies to have a working Camera on other roms too ( specially ARHD,lol ) Why? Because Panoramic mode in HTC Camera is fantastic! its the best. no rivals. photos are 90% merged correctly and the result is always awesome!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+10000000
i realy want it specially work on ARHD 6.1.can anypne do thaht?
Ditti4 said:
Currently uploading the camera app for you.
Here it is:
HTCCamera.apk
It is from Sense 3.0.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The HDR all right but Panorama style will be FC.
triaqu said:
The HDR all right but Panorama style will be FC.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which ROM are you on?
Ditti4 said:
Which ROM are you on?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
stock 3.06.405.1
Same here. Same ROM, but won't install...
triaqu said:
stock 3.06.405.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But it should be included in it, 'cause you are on Sense 3.0.
i've taken the files and the lib from Lee Rom and make a flashable zip..tried,and:
HDR works;
PANO works first time,then it gets stuck, and killing camera from task manager cause FC all applications who use camera until reboot.
I have to find some other files in the framework that have camera dependencies..its a good start btw
For those who wanna try,i've uploaded a restore zip that will put back original ARHD files.
http://www.mediafire.com/?9bkc6z61kr9zhq6
http://www.mediafire.com/?xqdxcl2xjwlc3ui
20mark said:
i've taken the files and the lib from Lee Rom and make a flashable zip..tried,and:
HDR works;
PANO works first time,then it gets stuck, and killing camera from task manager cause FC all applications who use camera until reboot.
I have to find some other files in the framework that have camera dependencies..its a good start btw
For those who wanna try,i've uploaded a restore zip that will put back original ARHD files.
http://www.mediafire.com/?9bkc6z61kr9zhq6
http://www.mediafire.com/?xqdxcl2xjwlc3ui
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
now the question is : why panorama works only one time ?
nice sharing italiano
famonaco said:
now the question is : why panorama works only one time ?
nice sharing italiano
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ty
I think there's a problem with sensor..when i press shoot button and move around the line in the middle of the screen just freeze ..i think there must be some other lib to include for the sensor work properly..
And i'm wondering if HDR is working too. I can't discover any major changes in the quality of the shots taken. Or am i missing something (of have to do something extra, like wipe cache)?
From what i understand of photography, to make a HDR picture, either you have a sensor with a a larger bit depth, that is then compressed to the standard 8bit + color maping,
or you take 2+ fotos at a different exposure, "blend" them to get the most of shadows and highlights making for a greater bit depth, and then compress to the standard 8bit + color mapping.
daedric said:
From what i understand of photography, to make a HDR picture, either you have a sensor with a a larger bit depth, that is then compressed to the standard 8bit + color maping,
or you take 2+ fotos at a different exposure, "blend" them to get the most of shadows and highlights making for a greater bit depth, and then compress to the standard 8bit + color mapping.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes,but in this case its a "artificial" HDR effect. when photo is taken the software creates a duplicate with different exposure and then blends photo toghether.so you will have HDR effect. btw i can see that pano and hdr doesn't work in this thread too..but in that case only camera apk provided. My flash file takes out some other system files used in the past by seo (credits to him) to port sense 3 camera with HDR&PANO to 2.5 based roms. I thought it would work btw there is someone who is on leedroid rom that can confirm if lee'camera is working good?
20mark said:
yes,but in this case its a "artificial" HDR effect. when photo is taken the software creates a duplicate with different exposure and then blends photo toghether.so you will have HDR effect. btw i can see that pano and hdr doesn't work in this thread too..but in that case only camera apk provided. My flash file takes out some other system files used in the past by seo (credits to him) to port sense 3 camera with HDR&PANO to 2.5 based roms. I thought it would work btw there is someone who is on leedroid rom that can confirm if lee'camera is working good?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
have the same problem , camera crash after first pano mode
i tried it
see ya
famonaco said:
have the same problem , camera crash after first pano mode
i tried it
see ya
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The leaked dhd build with sense 3.0 myt have those effects, try pushing that camera.apk or try leedroids think his is working
Sent from my HTC Desire HD using Tapatalk
shaky153 said:
The leaked dhd build with sense 3.0 myt have those effects, try pushing that camera.apk or try leedroids think his is working
Sent from my HTC Desire HD using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nope mate sense.30 leaked rom haven't those effects and leedroid camera have a panorama issue
see ya
Features:
HDR
Fully Working Manual Mode (Exposure Time, Focus, White Balance, ISO) without losing the Scene mode
Square Mode (Only works on some ROMs)
Full Size Panorama
Slow Motion Video Recording (Set video quality to SD or HD & need good light conditions).
Audio Focus Mode in Video Recording
Camera Torch capture
Quick Snap Mode
Age Stamp in Photo (Front Camera)
Mirror Front Camera
Burst Shoot Count One Time = 100
LED Color Notification
Flash the attached zip through TWRP.
Work on AEX?
no button to change to front camera ?
Alfian Firmansyah said:
Work on AEX?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes
I have it in the bottom right. Try force stopping the app and deleting data. If that doesn't help try reflashing. Mod should work on all roms.
pavaosk said:
I have it in the bottom right. Try force stopping the app and deleting data. If that doesn't help try reflashing. Mod should work on all roms.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is there any comparison with Google camera? What about your experience?
edall said:
Is there any comparison with Google camera? What about your experience?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's nothing like Google Camera for REDMI 4x
edall said:
Is there any comparison with Google camera? What about your experience?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MIUI Camera has a lot more features but Google Camera gives better photo results when properly configured, however Google Camera needs more time to take the photo (assuming you're using HDR+).
Alfian Firmansyah said:
Work on AEX?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Works on all roms.
Is there any posibility to get exposure time more than 1/2sec? 6-32sec probably good
pavaosk said:
MIUI Camera has a lot more features but Google Camera gives better photo results when properly configured, however Google Camera needs more time to take the photo (assuming you're using HDR+).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The time has greatly reduced in the latest version
tnx bro
i tested this camera on pixel rom v4 and it worked
Please add a fingerprint shutter in the new update like miui rom
Faldi
Thx OP!!! This is the cam app i need! Work well on latest RR ROM!
Suggestions
If can setup pictures saved in SD card Will be perfect.
Using latest RR Remix, installed the app amd it works, however in selfie mode it doesn't show my age?
does it support 720 p slowmo
Hey Guys, i just flashed this mod and it doesn't work
I'm on the newest MIUI GLobal 9.1.1.0 Stable
I'm using Redmi 4x 4/64 if it's matter
I've tried twice still not working
any clues ?
mojikey said:
tnx bro
i tested this camera on pixel rom v4 and it worked
Please add a fingerprint shutter in the new update like miui rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can You Please Send Me The Link Of Pixel V04 Rom
Not working :/
I'm using LineageOS 14.1-20180110-UNOFFICIAL-santoni and it crashes when I try to take a panoramic photo and can't enable HDR.
I found the settings of google camera that give the best HDR+, portraits on Nougat/Oreo Exynos devices. Compared to stock camera, GCam gives better saturation levels and detailed images. HDR+ parameters don’t hugely matter what you choose, and is all personal preference. A higher amount (very high in my case) will take a longer time to process.
New settings attached below. Clean Install is always recommended.
Mod8.3b_IDan_v3.2.9_Exynos.apk
3.2.9 Features
-Fixed black level back camera for Samsung Galaxy A8/A8+
-Attempt to fix OIS
3.2.7 Features
- Fixed black level front
- Enabled OIS by default
- Added saturation options in Advanced HDR+ settings
3.2 Features
- Dark Theme for settings.
- Now you can select the path where to save the photos (doesn't work on sd card but probably can work with some xposed mod).
- Removed all the snapdragon toggles. The app will know when apply that settings.
- Removed custom denoise param and other settings
- Now the app will restart every time you go back from settings to the viewfinder. This means that you don't need anymore to restart the app to apply settings
- Now there are three gestures in the viewfinder:
1. double tap on the black area it will pop the exposure menu directly
2. long-press on gallery and it will open samsung gallery instead of google photos
3. long press on the switch camera and after the restart the viewfinder brightness will be set to maximum
- some minor changes
Gcam Tool v2..32
-Prevent flipping of front camera photos
-Choose which photos you want to move
-Select custom source and destination folders
-Batch move multiple files
-Option to delete the sub folder created by Google Camera
Download
Thanks to:
miniuser123
Arnova8G2
IDan1109
Lens blur is not biggy right? Waiting for the portrait mode
coolguy said:
Lens blur is not biggy right? Waiting for the portrait mode
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me its pretty good.
msohail_7 said:
For me its pretty good.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
found it, tnx
msohail_7 said:
For me its pretty good.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice.. I couldn't get that movement correctly to slide it to get lens blur
But it seems to be a old version without the original portrait-mode. They are working on it and posted versions that are working for snapdragon but not for the exynos right now.
msohail_7 said:
For me its pretty good.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also I thought protrait is only via rear camera, how did you do with front camera?
coolguy said:
Also I thought protrait is only via rear camera, how did you do with front camera?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lens blur is still better than live focus.
coolguy said:
Nice.. I couldn't get that movement correctly to slide it to get lens blur
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found it better than stock one which most of the time fails to capture.
msohail_7 said:
I found it better than stock one which most of the time fails to capture.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You mean the slide up to get blur? It always says too fast for me.
msohail_7 said:
I found a version of google camera that has HDR+ and Lens Blur working on Note 8 Exynos version.
Download Link
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Working on Snapdragon too. I downloaded and the Blur works front and rear cameras.
Thanks
msohail_7 said:
I found a version of google camera that has HDR+ and Lens Blur working on Note 8 Exynos version.
Download Link
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
is this the latest link? looks like an old link?
coolguy said:
You mean the slide up to get blur? It always says too fast for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it most of the time works for me compared to stock one.
juliospinoza said:
Working on Snapdragon too. I downloaded and the Blur works front and rear cameras.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Great to hear that. How do you think its compared to stock like live focus, photo quality...
chacho_2me said:
is this the latest link? looks like an old link?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats the only version i found working.
It won't let me install it.
Corrupted installer. Have downloaded it 3 times.
msohail_7 said:
Lens blur is still better than live focus.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not at all, Live Focus is infinitely better than lens blur. Lens Blur can't detect edges for ****. The problem with Live Focus is it requires adequate lighting for good processing. Lower light tends to do about as well as lens blur, for me at least.
Also Live Focus is fantastic as generating a gradual bokeh across the ground or a wall, it's way more natural. Lens Blur can't do anything like that.
ryan770 said:
Not at all, Live Focus is infinitely better than lens blur. Lens Blur can't detect edges for ****. The problem with Live Focus is it requires adequate lighting for good processing. Lower light tends to do about as well as lens blur, for me at least.
Also Live Focus is fantastic as generating a gradual bokeh across the ground or a wall, it's way more natural. Lens Blur can't do anything like that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree that but lens blur and live focus are totally different in work. Lens blur is a good replacement for devices like S8, S7 etc.
There's a new version that supports Portrait mode, and is working on Snapdragon variants... I've tried, but can't find any setting to work.
https://www.xda-developers.com/google-camera-mod-portrait-mode-lens-blur-4k-video/
msohail_7 said:
Great to hear that. How do you think its compared to stock like live focus, photo quality...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me, the Google app is more natural than Samsung. The Samsung looks more artificial. Check by yourself. I installed the app as in OP. No problems at all.
https://www.apkmirror.com/apk/google-inc/camera/camera-7-0-009-259843690-release/
Enjoy the new camera app.
I could install the app with luckypatcher. New iu feels fresh and nice. But it looks like a portrait mode on a frontal camera doesn't work properly, it blurs everything.
UPD: the portrait mode works, it needs Ratio 4:3 to be set.
Selfies with portrait mode on front camera are blury...i reverted back to 6.3
n1kolaa said:
Selfies with portrait mode on front camera are blury...i reverted back to 6.3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Like mentioned above, you have to set the ratio for the front camera to 4:3 then the portrait selfies will work as they should At least it does for me.
Interesting...Interesting...
bejunk said:
Like mentioned above, you have to set the ratio for the front camera to 4:3 then the portrait selfies will work as they should At least it does for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a straight upgrade/update on my 3a (though it does warn that it's a "dogfood" AKA pre-beta APK). That means that- so far - there is no reason it can't install on any Pixel.
PGHammer said:
It's a straight upgrade/update on my 3a (though it does warn that it's a "dogfood" AKA pre-beta APK). That means that- so far - there is no reason it can't install on any Pixel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah right. I don't know why above user needed lucky patcher for this. But ok.
One Possibility
bejunk said:
Yeah right. I don't know why above user needed lucky patcher for this. But ok.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe he's running either Pie or a Pie-based AOSP ROM? (Despite 10/Q being available, some folks have refused to move.)
(Yes; 10 is available to every Pixel phone; not merely some of them - however, there are still holdouts.)
bejunk said:
Like mentioned above, you have to set the ratio for the front camera to 4:3 then the portrait selfies will work as they should At least it does for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
for me didnt worked sow your post
It is now on the PlayStore - as Camera 7.2. If you have an earlier version installed (unmodded, of course), update. For me (Pixel 3a), the biggest gain is still NightSight; if I needed the AstroPhotography mode, the same improvements that show up in NightSight would be useful there, too. My biggest quibble is the same one that was present with the previous Camera app; motion is on by default.. (Where I'm curious is WHY it's on by default - the default with other OEM/ODM camera apps is to shoot stills.) Because of the NightSight improvements, it's a worthwhile update for the Pixel 3a and earlier - especially if you take low-light shots - and given the time of year, you likely will.
So, anybody using Cstark's PXv4.x camera mod on the Pixel 3a? Are there major improvements?
Does this install alone or does it replace stock cam?
Tomar777 said:
So, anybody using Cstark's PXv4.x camera mod on the Pixel 3a? Are there major improvements?
Does this install alone or does it replace stock cam?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use it, works great, no issues found, but i did not made many pictures..
It installs as a new package, so you can use booth (or deactivate Google Camera wo you'll only have one in your app drawer)
PRO:
- set portrait zoom to 1.5 instead of 3.0
- Astrography mode switch
- many more settings to try out
CONS:
- Selecting Google Lens does not work, but you can use it easily from the app in the Playstore.
Just install it and try it for yourself, if you don't like it, you can uninstall it in a breeze.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/google-camera-mods/gcam-google-pixel-1-2-3-t3875663?&cf=1
Tomar777 said:
So, anybody using Cstark's PXv4.x camera mod on the Pixel 3a? Are there major improvements?
Does this install alone or does it replace stock cam?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
These camera apps will install as a second camera. They do not replace the stock camera app and they can both be installed at the same time (just like any other 3rd party camera app). You can select the PX Camera to act as the default camera, but the OEM camera is available in the apps draw.
I'm running Camera PX 4.1 (version 7.2.014) right now. It adds a bunch of extra settings that are definitely helpful. One of the best features is bringing back Smart Burst mode (where the camera takes a series of high quality images while you hold the shutter button down). This was taken away by Google when they introduced the dumb video feature which only provides one high quality image and the rest are really low quality.
It probably won't make a noticeable difference in picture quality for normal pictures, but might in night or astro mode.
The only "downside" or feature not working in PX 4.1 is the "Google Lens" function. Selecting that mode doesn't actually do anything. I have to use the OEM camera right now if I want to use Google Lens. Hopefully that bug is fixed in the next version. Everything else works as expected.
Wow...
Gcam apk for my Pixel device???
*Do we need to root to use this?
Thanks
Hi guys.
Pixel 3a with December 2019 updated on Android 10.
No Rooting done.
I also have a MiA3 with gcam apk installed.
The selfie on MiA3 with gcam come off better than on my P 3A.
Why is that? They have better dynamic range and details as well(on zooming).
Xebeck said:
Hi guys.
Pixel 3a with December 2019 updated on Android 10.
No Rooting done.
I also have a MiA3 with gcam apk installed.
The selfie on MiA3 with gcam come off better than on my P 3A.
Why is that? They have better dynamic range and details as well(on zooming).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Little off topic, but i thought the same about my nokia 7 plus with GCam.
Thing is the fixed focus on the pixel front cam. You need to hold the phone more far away to get nice selfies.
Try the modded version mentioned in this topic. i think Cstark made improvements to the front cam too
Tomar777 said:
Little off topic, but i thought the same about my nokia 7 plus with GCam.
Thing is the fixed focus on the pixel front cam. You need to hold the phone more far away to get nice selfies.
Try the modded version mentioned in this topic. i think Cstark made improvements to the front cam too
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
.
Thanks for replying.
But I had Pixel 3 before 3A(switched due to atrocious battery life), and even in that I felt that the selfie camera was ok.
The situation with my 3a is similar to my friends iPhone 11, great back camera but ok front one.
Oh well....
---------- Post added at 12:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:10 PM ----------
sic0048 said:
These camera apps will install as a second camera. They do not replace the stock camera app and they can both be installed at the same time (just like any other 3rd party camera app). You can select the PX Camera to act as the default camera, but the OEM camera is available in the apps draw.
I'm running Camera PX 4.1 (version 7.2.014) right now. It adds a bunch of extra settings that are definitely helpful. One of the best features is bringing back Smart Burst mode (where the camera takes a series of high quality images while you hold the shutter button down). This was taken away by Google when they introduced the dumb video feature which only provides one high quality image and the rest are really low quality.
It probably won't make a noticeable difference in picture quality for normal pictures, but might in night or astro mode.
The only "downside" or feature not working in PX 4.1 is the "Google Lens" function. Selecting that mode doesn't actually do anything. I have to use the OEM camera right now if I want to use Google Lens. Hopefully that bug is fixed in the next version. Everything else works as expected.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
.
Can you please share all the settings for the one by cstark?
Xebeck said:
.
Can you please share all the settings for the one by cstark?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nothing special really......
I have "4k Smart Burst", "Restore Smart Burst" turned on and "Super Res Xoom Always On". Portrait Zoom set to 1.5x. "AI AWB for HDR+ Enhanced" turned On and "AI AWB for Night Sight" turned on.
I don't do anything with Lib patcher. I figure the stock settings are about as good as they are going to get.
I am just sharing this Gcam MOD. All credits to the original developer of the MOD.
Download Link of the latest version:
https://www.celsoazevedo.com/files/android/google-camera/dev-the_dise/f/dl0/
Download Link of all other versions:
https://www.celsoazevedo.com/files/android/google-camera/dev-the_dise/
Changelog:
•2021-04-25
Based on GCam 8.2.204.
- First release;
- Removed OTA Updates.
Bugs:
- Time-lapse with large zoom;
- Crash Slow-Mo 1/8x.
This version was tested on Xiaomi Mi A2 (Android 11).
Portrait mode not working.
Astrophotography not working
blazessdd said:
Astrophotography not working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://www.celsoazevedo.com/files/android/google-camera/f/changelog786/
Tripod + astrophotography . Great on mi a2 . Picture has been taken at full dark . The results are impressive compared to the stock camera
Axel85 said:
Tripod + astrophotography . Great on mi a2 . Picture has been taken at full dark . The results are impressive compared to the stock camera
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Beautiful pic, bro. Thanks for the info. :good::highfive:
I don't know you guys, but the stock cam takes better photo in low light 32s exposure the parrot GCam espose for about 10 senconds top
blazessdd said:
I don't know you guys, but the stock cam takes better photo in low light 32s exposure the parrot GCam espose for about 10 senconds top
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree. I took this one with 8s 1600ISO on the regular camera lens and this was easier to get than a gcam version. Also with manual controls a lot is possible.
cyrill2211 said:
I agree. I took this one with 8s 1600ISO on the regular camera lens and this was easier to get than a gcam version. Also with manual controls a lot is possible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you do the full manual even on custom rom with miui camera?
Axel85 said:
Tripod + astrophotography . Great on mi a2 . Picture has been taken at full dark . The results are impressive compared to the stock camera
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
First of all, which ROM are you on and can you please share the EXIF data of the photo? Thanks.
priyambubai said:
First of all, which ROM are you on and can you please share the EXIF data of the photo? Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I m on havoc os 2.8 pie . About the exif , do I have to upload the original picture? Because this one is from google photo s unlimited backup , so it's resized . I also noticed that , as said in a previous post , gcam can only expose the sensor for 10 seconds in night sight mode , instead of 32 with the original xiaomi s app , so maybe this one could be actually better
Face Retouching (Skin smoothing) not working in Portrait mode.
Please suggest some settings without losing Portrait mode..
Some new versions from The_Dise :
https://www.celsoazevedo.com/files/a...e_dise/#apk881
As from V3.3 it is not exclusively Android 10 but now also supports Android 9 Pie !
Testing V3.4 now.
Portrait mode on the back camera won't work for me. It just considers them burst shots. It doesn't even attempt to process the photo to add blur.
Force close on Havoc OS 3.0
Does someone have facing problems trying to use this GCAM, it opens and force close.
danielfilho83 said:
Does someone have facing problems trying to use this GCAM, it opens and force close.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use SELinux magisk module
jerryshaw12 said:
Use SELinux magisk module
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you provide us a link please?
The_Dise v3.11 is out meanwhile:
https://www.celsoazevedo.com/files/android/google-camera/dev-the_dise/#apk1308
Is this the_dise official thread? Could be there a front flash light mode?
Anyone know why in astrophotography with an exposure of 30 sec activated on settings , the phones countdown from 6 minutes and 30 seconds and then crash about a minute after? While waiting everything looks to work as expected