Related
Since I upgraded from Magisk v9 to v10, every time I reboot my phone, I get a notification from phh's Superuser that says "Install Superuser" "The su binary is out of date." When I tap the notification, it just opens the Superuser app and doesn't ask me to update anything. Root still works normally, though. This is happening on a Nexus 5X running stock build NMF26F with no modifications other than Magisk itself, and no modules except for Superuser. The same thing happens whether Magisk Hide is on or off. I tried completely uninstalling and reinstalling Magisk, which didn't fix it either. What could be causing it, and how can I fix it?
EDIT: Solved: Magisk 10.2 includes a new version of the su binary that fixes this issue.
josephcsible said:
Since I upgraded from Magisk v9 to v10, every time I reboot my phone, I get a notification from phh's Superuser that says "Install Superuser" "The su binary is out of date." When I tap the notification, it just opens the Superuser app and doesn't ask me to update anything. Root still works normally, though. This is happening on a Nexus 5X running stock build NMF26F with no modifications other than Magisk itself, and no modules except for Superuser. The same thing happens whether Magisk Hide is on or off. I tried completely uninstalling and reinstalling Magisk, which didn't fix it either. What could be causing it, and how can I fix it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is because the su binary included in Magisk is a modified one & the official phh root manager detect that it is not equal to the lastest official su binary... just ignore that notification.
This happens on Magisk 9 as well I wish there was a way to turn it off but it's not really a big deal I guess.
Deic said:
This is because the su binary included in Magisk is a modified one & the official phh root manager detect that it is not equal to the lastest official su binary... just ignore that notification.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep, I did some poking around and confirmed that. (It's also entirely because of the new Superuser module, not the new Magisk). I guess as a workaround for now, I can block the Superuser app from sending notifications. The good news is this, though:
topjohnwu said:
Right now you still have to install the phh Superuser application, however the root management should move to Magisk Manager soon, please stay tuned.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This will take care of it. I'm not sure why he didn't wait to change the su version code until that was done, though, as that would have avoided this problem.
EDIT: And I also now see this listed as a known issue in the main Magisk post.
I am having the same issue, except none of my apps can see root.
kiefferbp said:
I am having the same issue, except none of my apps can see root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not at all the same issue then. You should post about it in another thread.
josephcsible said:
It's not at all the same issue then. You should post about it in another thread.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry if I sounded like one of those noobs that posts unrelated things in a random thread. I originally thought it was somewhat related since Magisk Manager said root was properly installed, but no other app recognized it.
I managed to fix that by un-installing and re-installing the phh superuser module. I am now just in the same boat as you, and I'll patiently wait for a fix.
kiefferbp said:
Sorry if I sounded like one of those noobs that posts unrelated things in a random thread. I originally thought it was somewhat related since Magisk Manager said root was properly installed, but no other app recognized it.
I managed to fix that by un-installing and re-installing the phh superuser module. I am now just in the same boat as you, and I'll patiently wait for a fix.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can confirm. On Nexus 5x 7.1.1 with no other modifications, but lost root after I updated to v10. However, after an uninstall and reinstall I was back in business. One note though, the installation through magisk manager failed, and I had to manually flash the zip in recovery.
Fixed with Magisk 10.2.
josephcsible said:
Fixed with Magisk 10.2.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk 10.2 here .. not fixed
warriorvibhu said:
Magisk 10.2 here .. not fixed
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Make sure it automatically updated you to the topjohnwu r2 version of Superuser. If it didn't, do it manually from https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-phh-s-superuser-android-pay-t3435921. If that doesn't fix the problem, then your problem isn't this problem.
josephcsible said:
Make sure it automatically updated you to the topjohnwu r2 version of Superuser. If it didn't, do it manually from https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-phh-s-superuser-android-pay-t3435921. If that doesn't fix the problem, then your problem isn't this problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup all that done .. still have the same notification ..
I have the same problem.
1) i have tryed to flash magisk 10.2 by recovery but after flashing the s7 edge goes in bootloop (tyed with SuperSu disabled and without binary installed). So i had to flash the unistaller.
2) I even tryed enabled the chainfire SuperSu just for trying to flash the magisk+phh by magisk manager. Out of date. I think it cames cause magisk try to load the chainfire supersu binary and not the SU binary magisk has.
Help me please.
P.s. i have tryed with a clean boot image charged.
I had the same issue, and also noticed that su wasn't working in ADB. It looked like some permissions were wrong on the /magisk/phh directory. I solved it by uninstalling the phh superuser module from in Magisk Manager, then reflashing phh-superuser-topjohnwu-r2.zip in recovery.
Noxious Ninja said:
I had the same issue, and also noticed that su wasn't working in ADB. It looked like some permissions were wrong on the /magisk/phh directory. I solved it by uninstalling the phh superuser module from in Magisk Manager, then reflashing phh-superuser-topjohnwu-r2.zip in recovery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tryed, no well news!
Did y have SuperSu binary installed during flashing?
Mr.Fearless said:
Tryed, no well news!
Did y have SuperSu binary installed during flashing?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I haven't had SuperSU on here at all.
Noxious Ninja said:
No, I haven't had SuperSU on here at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've just tryed deleting all the root binary files. Nothing, After flashing magisk 10.2 by recovery the phone goes to bootloop.
Thread closed at OP's request.
Hi, my Halifax banking app stopped working after last update. Before last update there was no problems, but few days ago Halifax detects root again.
After last Halifax update I uninstalled app, rebooted phone and installed it again. After that I added it to Magisk Hide and rebooted again. Unfortunately it still detects root. I even tried to Repack/Hide magisk Manager itself but it also failed.
I also installed very old (22.1) version of Halifax app and it's working fine but as I said it's quite outdated. Anyway this problem is related only to latest versions of Halifax app.
What version are you using? I have 39.03 and magiskhide is working perfectly fine
NeophyteGS2 said:
What version are you using? I have 39.03 and magiskhide is working perfectly fine
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That strange, v38 and V39 not working for me but v22 is working. Do You have Xposed installed?
Edit:
Just tested on another phone without Xposed, root is still detected. Also this phone is passing SafetyNet and Arriva app is working so Magisk Hide is working but not for Halifax.
That is strange, are you using a custom rom? I only have magisk installed and using a stock ROM on an S8
No, both phones (LG H870 and H340n) on stock rom. H340n is almost clean, only Magisk, no Xposed and other mods because I've been using it for payments.
Very weird, I've uninstalled mine and reinstalled and logged in fine
To make some test I even uninstalled all apps which using root and still nothing.
Ok, I found something. Tested all possible configurations of MagiskHide and other apps. The only way to make Halifax app working is disabling root in Magisk settings. After that it's working. Funny thing is that when I have Halifax on MagiskHide list it's not working even when root access is disabled.
Freezing or uninstalling Magisk Manager not working as well so it's not a problem with Manager detection.
And the funniest thing; I installed 22.1, configured and then updated to 37 --> 38 --> 39 and its working. Now I can open 39.3 without any problem. This is stupid!
I just installed a fresh stock android 9.0 to my pixel2 with TWRP and Magisk. Then I had same issue with root detection when I run the Halifax App. I cleared the halifax data and uninstalled. Then reinstalled halifax from google play. Added it to Magisk Hide then bingo it worked no root detection.
kolothuk said:
I just installed a fresh stock android 9.0 to my pixel2 with TWRP and Magisk. Then I had same issue with root detection when I run the Halifax App. I cleared the halifax data and uninstalled. Then reinstalled halifax from google play. Added it to Magisk Hide then bingo it worked no root detection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Reboot phone and then check. Mine is working until first reboot.
Chamelleon said:
Reboot phone and then check. Mine is working until first reboot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rebooted a few times. Still works fine. No root detection.
Ok, so I have no idea what's wrong with my phones. I have 2 LG phones and both acts the same.
we may have your solution here, I think someone with Halifax also confirmed it
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77321403&postcount=93
This works!
alpsayin said:
we may have your solution here, I think someone with Halifax also confirmed it
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77321403&postcount=93
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can confirm. Just added trusteer.com to my Adblock app blacklist and the app is no longer detecting root.
alpsayin said:
we may have your solution here, I think someone with Halifax also confirmed it
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77321403&postcount=93
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Finally it's working for me as well. Although I had to remove Xposed because every time I was opening keyboard to type anything in Halifax app it crashed.
Have the same problem. Magisk Root Hide is not working after lastest update of UBI Banking app. I think these apps have in-built code for root check
AKD111095 said:
Have the same problem. Magisk Root Hide is not working after lastest update of UBI Banking app. I think these apps have in-built code for root check
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Chceck AdAway trick https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=77321403&postcount=93.
I am using the DnB online banking app. The new version of the app, released a few days ago, detects magisk root with hide turned on. Safetynett is also intact. Thought it may be of interest; I will be using the older version for now.
Link to app page:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=no.apps.dnbnor
caniko2 said:
I am using the DnB online banking app. The new version of the app, released a few days ago, detects magisk root with hide turned on. Safetynett is also intact. Thought it may be of interest; I will be using the older version for now.
Link to app page:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=no.apps.dnbnor
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same issue with Santander Wallet. But SafetyNet is intact and I am able to use GPay.
Please share if you find a solution elsewhere.
Any solution to this?
My banking app checks if ADB debugging is enabled, but it still says "root detected". If I disable ADB debugging, it works fine
Sent from my MI 5 using Tapatalk
Same thing with the Barclays banking app. It was working fine until a few days ago with Magisk Hide. Now, the app sends a superuser request and no matter what you choose (grant or deny), it detects the phone is rooted and gives a message that it doesn't support rooted devices. Also, the app hasn't updated since January 4th, so something else must have changed.
Edit. Using this method worked for me https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/santander-app-custom-rom-root-device-t3794753/post77321403#post77321403
I use two apps which are detecting root in my OnePlus 6 with OOS Beta 11 and Magisk 18:
VR-SecureGo
Die TK-App
Same problem
Well, I am not using a "Banking" app. But can say that an install of the Marlboro app.!!!
Install was ok. However, when starting app, it said that my phone was rooted! Then it stated that it can not be used on my devise and shut down. Will not actually restart now!
Devise - Samsung Galaxy S5, On Lineage 15.1 latest build, as well as Unofficial 16.0 build. With or with out SmartPack Kernel.
Both using the Latest Magisk 8.1!
(Yes, no Exposed used) just a few modules...
P. S. I can say, in 7.0-7.3 this was NOT an issue.
My only, other issue with 8.0 an 8.1.... Extremely hard to use the 2nd Partition (formatted - Ext4) Using Link2SD Plus! Can say didn't not have this on on prior Versions.
Still trying to fix this, but nothing yet (working many hours this past week) and nothing to stick... Yet!
Tanx for letting me blow off some steam on this...
Anyone that's having issues with root detecting apps could give the new MagiskHide implementation a try (it's been rewritten from scratch). Would be interesting to know if there's any improvement... Currently only found in the Canary builds (as of now at build 18108), but will of course find it's way to a stable release eventually. Having more users test the new implementation before a stable release is of course always nice though...
I tried beta manager, same thing. Unable to pay with Google pay.
Tesco pay+ now detects root as of today. It is enabled in Magisk Hide. App last updated 31st Jan but it was working fine last weekend - Google changed detection possibly?
if you have warez apps (lucky patcher, freedom, creehack, aptoide, acmarket, gameguardian etc) installed it may detect and uses 'root detected' as a generic message
My phone is One Plus 5T with bootloader unlocked and using the BETA latest OxygenOS.
Nothing was updated and from one day to another my google pay does not work anymore. Tried to add the card again, and it told me about "my phone is altered in some ways"
Before magisk was doing the job. Looks like we need to wait for some updates. I am amazed about the only few entries I found in internet about that.
caniko2 said:
I am using the DnB online banking app. The new version of the app, released a few days ago, detects magisk root with hide turned on. Safetynett is also intact. Thought it may be of interest; I will be using the older version for now.
Link to app page:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=no.apps.dnbnor
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got DNB running with magisk Canary , use magisk hide and and systemles hosts in magisk settings .
stian230 said:
I got DNB running with magisk Canary , use magisk hide and and systemles hosts in magisk settings .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does it still work for you? I keep getting phone is rooted with latest Canary build.
SLAiNTRAX said:
Does it still work for you? I keep getting phone is rooted with latest Canary build.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It works for me ?. Running magisk canary and DNB app .
fleischbanane said:
I use two apps which are detecting root in my OnePlus 6 with OOS Beta 11 and Magisk 18:
VR-SecureGo
Die TK-App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
VR SecureGo works for me with this instruction:
https://www.android-hilfe.de/forum/...trotz-magisk.901517-page-2.html#post-11532359
pollonhokairos said:
VR SecureGo works for me with this instruction:
https://www.android-hilfe.de/forum/...trotz-magisk.901517-page-2.html#post-11532359
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much. With Magisk 19 I have zero issues!
Salty Wagyu said:
Tesco pay+ now detects root as of today. It is enabled in Magisk Hide. App last updated 31st Jan but it was working fine last weekend - Google changed detection possibly?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've similar issue, OnePlus 6, latest stock ROM, latest Magisk (v19.2), it detects the root... Can someone suggest me something to resolve this?
Has anyone else than Stian got DNB to work? I am using magisk 19.3 and it's not working.
As the title states ...v4a is it compatible with pie? Im rooted running a custom rom rooted with magisk. Installed v4a thru magisk manager it installs but i get the install driver /re-install driver message everytime. Is it an workaround to get it working?
recepo1 said:
As the title states ...v4a is it compatible with pie? Im rooted running a custom rom rooted with magisk. Installed v4a thru magisk manager it installs but i get the install driver /re-install driver message everytime. Is it an workaround to get it working?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
working fine here. maybe a root/magisk issue.
bober10113 said:
working fine here. maybe a root/magisk issue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What rom are you on and which version of magisk are you running?
recepo1 said:
What rom are you on and which version of magisk are you running?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
infinity rom.
magisk v18 and also newer test canary builds.
but prety sure its an issue where you don't wait 3 minutes after rebooting before doing actions that require root.
and not sure to which extent you tried to make magisk work with various files and mods but maybe you should just factory wipe and try and get magisk working before anything else. also mayke sure busybox is installed. and dont forget that 3 minute rule after a reboot.
bober10113 said:
infinity rom.
magisk v18 and also newer test canary builds.
but prety sure its an issue where you don't wait 3 minutes after rebooting before doing actions that require root.
and not sure to which extent you tried to make magisk work with various files and mods but maybe you should just factory wipe and try and get magisk working before anything else. also mayke sure busybox is installed. and dont forget that 3 minute rule after a reboot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks im sure it maybe an magisk issue im running 17.3 because i kept losing root on v18. I acquire root with v4a but it freezes and then keeps telling me to reinstall driver after reboot. I will try the 3 minute rule though..thank you. You installed v4a directly thru magisk or flashed a different version?
recepo1 said:
Thanks im sure it maybe an magisk issue im running 17.3 because i kept losing root on v18. I acquire root with v4a but it freezes and then keeps telling me to reinstall driver after reboot. I will try the 3 minute rule though..thank you. You installed v4a directly thru magisk or flashed a different version?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
v3.3 on magisk dated of jan. 16th.
use aroma option. it will reboot on its own from magisk console and the just follow the automated steps in recovery
bober10113 said:
v3.3 on magisk dated of jan. 16th.
use aroma option. it will reboot on its own from magisk console and the just follow the automated steps in recovery
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you appreciate your help i will give it a try
I have tried everything for hours to get viper4android to work with no avail until now. Go to the xda download page and select the beta version. Boom. It works. I know you might have long forgot this or already figured it out but I had to share
old legacy magisk module has been working for months and months.
On my phone xiaomi A1 rooted it works on the wife's phone xiaomi note 5 pro rooted it used to work fine but for some reason it has suddenly detected root and won't work now. I have checked all the settings to do with hiding are still selected as before, strange thing is it has worked briefly for a few seconds but then stopped again.
Please can people tell me if they have had this happen and how they fixed it please.
What checks is it doing to detect root does anyone know?
Thanks
hycraig said:
On my phone xiaomi A1 rooted it works on the wife's phone xiaomi note 5 pro rooted it used to work fine but for some reason it has suddenly detected root and won't work now. I have checked all the settings to do with hiding are still selected as before, strange thing is it has worked briefly for a few seconds but then stopped again.
Please can people tell me if they have had this happen and how they fixed it please.
What checks is it doing to detect root does anyone know?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try updating magisk.
Try to disable xposed modules.
Try to disable all modules.
See if it works now.
Then one by one reenable them.
Sent from my SM-G985F using Tapatalk
vash_h said:
Try updating magisk.
Try to disable xposed modules.
Try to disable all modules.
See if it works now.
Then one by one reenable them.
Sent from my SM-G985F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your reply magisk is up to date and I don't have any modules just magisk on its own. I do find it strange how it just stopped working after many months of being used regularly.
hycraig said:
Thanks for your reply magisk is up to date and I don't have any modules just magisk on its own. I do find it strange how it just stopped working after many months of being used regularly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Credits Google
Now safetynet fails after March update
You need to change device props to pixel or lock bootloader
hycraig said:
Thanks for your reply magisk is up to date and I don't have any modules just magisk on its own. I do find it strange how it just stopped working after many months of being used regularly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Biggest_Noob said:
Credits Google
Now safetynet fails after March update
You need to change device props to pixel or lock bootloader
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My safteynet passes fine on both my devices
Thanks
somehow they manage to detect root even if magisk manager is running under custom package name and magisk hide is enabled.
Last version that is still running is 13.1.1 (apk available on apkmirror).
h4lli said:
somehow they manage to detect root even if magisk manager is running under custom package name and magisk hide is enabled.
Last version that is still running is 13.1.1 (apk available on apkmirror).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks @h4lli i couldn't see sky go version 13.1.1 for uk
so i got Sky Go UK 12.4.14 from apkmirror and can confirm is working fine
yeah still doesnt work, latest sky go app 20, latest magisk, still detects, anyone able to reverse the sky app to see what methods its using?
Fyi - any version other than the latest (20.6.1) at the moment forces an upgrade to 20.6.1, which then detects root.
Safety net is passing both basic and cts with Eval type basic. I'm on latest canary (20425).
I've tried :-
Uninstalling all apps that skygo could look for (titanium, openvpn etc.)
Using a work profile (shelter and island)
Disabling oem unlocking
Disabling usb/adb debugging
Disabling developer options
Deleting all files and folders that have magisk, twrp or titanium in them.
Basically everything here https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
So, I think it's basically no go for sky go at the moment. Happy to be corrected if someone has it working.
Beardy
beardymarrow said:
Fyi - any version other than the latest (20.6.1) at the moment forces an upgrade to 20.6.1, which then detects root.
Safety net is passing both basic and cts with Eval type basic. I'm on latest canary (20425).
I've tried :-
Uninstalling all apps that skygo could look for (titanium, openvpn etc.)
Using a work profile (shelter and island)
Disabling oem unlocking
Disabling usb/adb debugging
Disabling developer options
Deleting all files and folders that have magisk, twrp or titanium in them.
Basically everything here https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
So, I think it's basically no go for sky go at the moment. Happy to be corrected if someone has it working.
Beardy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah still can't get it working. Damn it.
Hast everyone a sollution for running the sky Go App on rooted phones?
Skygo doesnt Work... hast anyone a sollution?
eula1977 said:
Skygo doesnt Work... hast anyone a sollution?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried this? It worked for me
SkyGo app detected root!
Hi everyone i have a problema using SkyGo app on my device because It detects the root. I renamed magisk , used magisk Hide , tried magiskhide props config , tried to delete cache and re-install SkyGo app but nothing worked...any solution...
forum.xda-developers.com