Xtra app - Magisk

Hello,
I've a problem with this app and can't find out why it still detects root. (In fact apps says that it can't reach servers to authenticate)
Magisk is installed, hided, renamed, dialer is hided and so other Google apps or apps related to Colruyt group. (Makers of Xtra app). I've uninstalled all apps requiring root such as adaway.
Safetynet is passed and device is certified.
I've tried with safetypatch module.
None of what I've tested here works. Can anyone help me please?
Some other apps such as banking apps, etc that detects rooted phone don't detects that my phone is rooted with what I've done to hide etc.
Here's the link of the app: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=be.colruyt.xtra
Thanks.
I'm on OnePlus 6 with evolution ROM 4.20.2
Magisk 20.4 and magisk manager 7.5.1

I just created an account with this app five minutes ago and it never warned me about my phone being rooted
Magisk saftynet : all ko
Magisk hide : Google framework, services and store, play services and xtra

adrenochrome25 said:
I just created an account with this app five minutes ago and it never warned me about my phone being rooted
Magisk saftynet : all ko
Magisk hide : Google framework, services and store, play services and xtra
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's all I've done and more :'( . Android services library, carrier services, framework of google services, Google play services, dial services, Google dialer, Xtra app, etc...
I'm gonna try to reflash my rom, then magisk and see what's going on.
Thanks for the help

adrenochrome25 said:
I just created an account with this app five minutes ago and it never warned me about my phone being rooted
Magisk saftynet : all ko
Magisk hide : Google framework, services and store, play services and xtra
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've reinstalled my rom without magisk, then the app, added my credentials, installed magisk app to see if the apps detected it, but it didn't. So I installed magisk in TWRP. Hided Magisk, renamed it, hided play framework services, etc
And Voilà, it's working.
I think there has been some kind of mess last time I updated my rom.
Thanks for your help

Maybe the app had some kind of memory, did you try to delete app cache&app before reinstalling the whole rom.
Anyway, glad you fixed the problem

Related

Xposed + Snapchat + microG apps = problem. Need help!

Hello!
Hope I am writing this thread in correct section.
I have Xperia SP with android 4.4.4, compilation number pa_huashan-userdebug 4.4.4 KTU84P eng.nexusprime.20140928.205215 test-keys.
I have microG apps installed. They needs Xposed framework to work.
Now I want to login into Snapchat. I can't, because I have Xposed installed. If I uninstall all Xposed, Snapchat says that I need Google Play Services. I don't want to have Google Play Services, because I couldn't uninstall it last time (Last time I flashed gapps via recovery).
Does somebody have any idea?
VaZZoN
Install Google Play Services, login to SnapChat, backup with Titanium Backup, uninstall Google Play Services, then see what happens. Idk if it'll tell you that after.
Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
Oh, yeah, I didn't mention what I done.
When I uninstalled all microG apps, cleared cache via recovery, rebooted and installed Google Play Services, the Services started to crashing.
Is there any rescue or just flash new rom, flash gapps, login to snapchat, backup via Titanium backup and again flash new rom, install microG apps and then restore Snapchat?
VaZZoN said:
Hello!
Hope I am writing this thread in correct section.
I have Xperia SP with android 4.4.4, compilation number pa_huashan-userdebug 4.4.4 KTU84P eng.nexusprime.20140928.205215 test-keys.
I have microG apps installed. They needs Xposed framework to work.
Now I want to login into Snapchat. I can't, because I have Xposed installed. If I uninstall all Xposed, Snapchat says that I need Google Play Services. I don't want to have Google Play Services, because I couldn't uninstall it last time (Last time I flashed gapps via recovery).
Does somebody have any idea?
VaZZoN
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Some apps require Google play services to operate, end of story. Why don't you want Google play services installed?
Sent from my SCH-R220
mattzeller said:
Some apps require Google play services to operate, end of story. Why don't you want Google play services installed?
Sent from my SCH-R220
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I had Google Play Services installed on this rom, always after reboot I had to go to "Disable service" app, disable and re-enable location service and hope it would work. Often it wouldn't work, so I had to reboot again and do same thing. Of course, I could disable all location services, but I need GPS. And, when I enabled GPS, did what I wanted, I too had to disable and re-enable location service. For example, when I was doing something with GPS on evening, then I forgot to disable services or it hasn't worked, I always woke up with battery drained for about 30-40%. 90%-40% = 50%. Battery has 3 years, so it will be dead untill noon.
To close.
I did what Curiousn00b said. (To uninstall Google Play Services I had to reinstall rom, but it worked).
Thanks!

Any Snapchat Incompatibility?

Both me and my friend's Snapchats are crashing before it even opens. Only things we have in common is that both of us are using latest Android (through Custom ROMs, but they're not the same), latest TWRP and Magisk. I use AICP and he uses TeslaOS.
No, for me it works fine. Latest magisk
Sent from my ONEPLUS A3003 using Tapatalk
I am having a similar problem, as of 8/15/17 snapchat on the latest update is not working on my phone.
I have a rooted oneplus 3t with supersu and twrp, some side apps like flashify, root explorer, etc I cant seem to find the app or program that is triggering snapchat's safety feature causing it to repeatedly crash and not let you log in. I also currently do not have magisk.
from some searching it seems some people were able to solve this problem by unrooting and uninstalling magisk modules from their phone, or by using a root hide module from magisk.
Im not an expert but I plan to try the magisk root hide thing and if that doesnt work, do a full nandroid backup and re add one thing back at a time from titanium backup until I find what is causing the problem. there may also be modded snapchat apks out there that bypasses that error but I haven't checked yet. I'm still a noob at this so I would greatly appreciate any help or insight by anyone who's dealt with this problem before!
Try clearing cache/data for Snapchat. It was working fine for me yesterday, but this afternoon I randomly started getting force closes. After clearing cache/data and signing back in it works fine. I highly doubt it's a Magisk issue.
Also, Snapchat was an example, other apps, like Kung Fury: Street Rage, crash too, but only Snapchat actually gives the crash message, the others just keep closing
Hyoretsu said:
Also, Snapchat was an example, other apps, like Kung Fury: Street Rage, crash too, but only Snapchat actually gives the crash message, the others just keep closing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Snapchat has root/tampering detection. Can't help there (since I don't use Snapchat)...
Kung Fury does not have root detection (I just tested it). If a bunch of apps are crashing/force closing when you have Magisk installed (and MagiskHide active), your ROM might have an issue with WebView. Hard to know without a logcat from the crash though... If it is WebView, installing Chrome Beta and choosing it as your WebView implementation might fix it.
Didgeridoohan said:
Snapchat has root/tampering detection. Can't help there (since I don't use Snapchat)...
Kung Fury does not have root detection (I just tested it). If a bunch of apps are crashing/force closing when you have Magisk installed (and MagiskHide active), your ROM might have an issue with WebView. Hard to know without a logcat from the crash though... If it is WebView, installing Chrome Beta and choosing it as your WebView implementation might fix it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Changing WebView to Chrome Beta didn't solve it. How do I get a logcat of the crash?
Didgeridoohan said:
Snapchat has root/tampering detection. Can't help there (since I don't use Snapchat)...
Kung Fury does not have root detection (I just tested it). If a bunch of apps are crashing/force closing when you have Magisk installed (and MagiskHide active), your ROM might have an issue with WebView. Hard to know without a logcat from the crash though... If it is WebView, installing Chrome Beta and choosing it as your WebView implementation might fix it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
snap only utilizes safetynet during login.
Hello Man, i have the same problem on aicp. I have install another rom (CRdroid) and it's work like a charm. I think magisk is not fully compatible with all ROMs. Send a message to the dev of ur ROM for know it.
All apps started working after I uninstalled magisk
Hyoretsu said:
All apps started working after I uninstalled magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just re-read your first post... Does MagiskHide even work on your device? Can you pass SafetyNet or hide root from a root app (by adding it to the Hide list)?
Didgeridoohan said:
I just re-read your first post... Does MagiskHide even work on your device? Can you pass SafetyNet or hide root from a root app (by adding it to the Hide list)?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I tried, I could pass Pokémon GO's safetynet. In Snapchat case, when the problem was safetynet, it loaded but I couldn't log in, this time it simply didn't open at all, when the app tried to launch it immediately closed and showed a crash message.
Hyoretsu said:
When I tried, I could pass Pokémon GO's safetynet. In Snapchat case, when the problem was safetynet, it loaded but I couldn't log in, this time it simply didn't open at all, when the app tried to launch it immediately closed and showed a crash message.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you ever find a fix for Snapchat?

[HELP]i need help with youtube vanced, can't prevent the playstore to update the app

as the title says i have been having problems getting the youtube app to stop updating , i followed the instructions in the vanced post , i did the method 2 of the magisk installation (where you download the latest version from the page and install the module) placed the install via magisk module and the detach from playstore module on the download folder , all goes normal i even deleted all youtube data , and unistalled the app with titanium backup , and disabled the auto update tick box several times and it still ends up updating youtube and removing the vanced version :/
THEwed123wet said:
as the title says i have been having problems getting the youtube app to stop updating , i followed the instructions in the vanced post , i did the method 2 of the magisk installation (where you download the latest version from the page and install the module) placed the install via magisk module and the detach from playstore module on the download folder , all goes normal i even deleted all youtube data , and unistalled the app with titanium backup , and disabled the auto update tick box several times and it still ends up updating youtube and removing the vanced version :/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just disable auto update from play store...
Sent from my MI 5 using Tapatalk
but in general or only for the app? because i have been disabling it for the app always and it always ends up updating it
THEwed123wet said:
but in general or only for the app? because i have been disabling it for the app always and it always ends up updating it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For the app should be enough.
that's what i always do and it still ends up updating , even with the detach module, maybe i'll have to disable it all together :l
That's werid stopping auto update from the play store should stop all that
Sent from my SM-J327P using Tapatalk
Well, it doesn't. I'm experiencing the same.
i am using it on pie. is really frustrating the app update by itself.
SWITCH OFF AUTO UPDATE IN PLAYSTORE ARE NOT WORKING AT ALL.
detach in TB is NOT WORKING also.
but version on nougat doesn't have this issue, maybe google did something fishy on PIE?
I guess you should ask for help in the dedicated threads for Youtube Vanced instead of creating a new thread for this.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-iytbp-youtube-vanced-t3712097
locolyric said:
i am using it on pie. is really frustrating the app update by itself.
SWITCH OFF AUTO UPDATE IN PLAYSTORE ARE NOT WORKING AT ALL.
detach in TB is NOT WORKING also.
but version on nougat doesn't have this issue, maybe google did something fishy on PIE?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same in Oreo. Never had problem with Nougat.
I installed it just like the OP, it would detach but play store would attach youtube back on the update list by itself every night. When the phone is restarted the detach module in magisk will detach it again, but the next morning, play store would put it back on the list.
use service disabler
ttps://egg.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/android/1461342935/562
Disabling the auto-update from Play Store works fine for me. I've been using Vanced for months and no such issues.
MntFlg said:
use service disabler
ttps://egg.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/android/1461342935/562
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your link is dead. However, you inspired me.
Which service in Google Play Service should be disable?
calchung said:
Your link is dead. However, you inspired me.
Which service in Google Play Service should be disable?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ttps://i.imgur.com/ryqueL8.png
MntFlg said:
ttps://i.imgur.com/ryqueL8.png
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Http://i.imgur.com/ryqueL8.png
Only disable that 2 services in Youtube can detach the app from Play?? It works?
I was thinking to disable some service in Google Play Services.
MntFlg said:
ttps://i.imgur.com/ryqueL8.png
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
calchung said:
Http://i.imgur.com/ryqueL8.png
Only disable that 2 services in Youtube can detach the app from Play?? It works?
I was thinking to disable some service in Google Play Services.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tried but doesnt work. Youtube would still appear on the play store update list.
Sent from my HTC U12+ using XDA Labs
Read the part in the first post under:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/android/apps-games/app-youtube-vanced-edition-t3758757
"Explanation of the (Ad)Vanced options of the official installer:"
After thatd download the files from the 3# post:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=75772897&postcount=3
Use the Mediafire host. in the Installer folder you'll find all the necessary files.
regards
I've been trying to figure out this issue for a while.
Basically issue for me is on Google Pixel XL and now Pixel 3 XL and my friends Moto x4, all on both Android Oreo and Pie... Using Magisk repo install and uninstalling stock YouTube, and then adding enable_detach empty file in cache folder in root along with turning off "Enable auto update" in Google play store for YouTube . Usually this works for a few weeks but every now and then it ignores it and updates itself and turns on auto update without user explicitly allowing it. (Says YouTube was just updated).
I can easily fix it by uninstalling updates again but my friend doesn't know how to do this easily. I also tried to remove YouTube forcefully with titanium backup from system app and detaching months ago but that caused a lot more problems. Currently it gives option to attach to market forced despite it still showing up in market saying update (and auto update off for it)
I wanted to understand the plz and settings.sh options if using specifically Magisk method 1 (Magisk repo). Or are those only if using the other methods under magisk and/or root only option (no Magisk)?
Use the Sudohide xposed module.
This Module will prevent apps from detecting other installed apps on your device. Settings are done on per app basis.
Steps to hide VancedYT (A) from Play Store (B):
1. Select app A in the main list a new list view will be launched
2. Tick the checkbox next to app B in the newly opened list view
3. Press apply to save and back to exist
4. Restart luncher or reboot the phone.
Slow down.
Detach using titanium backup WORKS
For me I could only press "attach to playstore"
So I did. After I got button detach.
It worked and removed it

Safetynet fails after uninstalling EdXposed(Resolved)

https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/how-correctly-uninstall-edxposed-t3969655
Since twrp can't be used in pixel4, I deleted the directory written in this thread without flashing the zip, but it still fails.
I was able to pass Safetynet after deleting the data and cache of these apps.
Google Play Store
Google Play Services
Google Services Framework
Thread closed per OP request.

Problèm with banking app

hello, I'm here to ask for your help.
I have tried all the methods on this forum but I cannot get my dz.natixis.prod banking application to work
with root,
i have already tried all the methods starting with magisk hide, renaming magisk manager, blacklisting the app on edexposed, renaming the TWRP folder, deleting the data and cache from google services and play store, nothing
netflix, snapshat and revolut work very well
I manage to pass the safetynet checks, I am on the latest version of magisk, and the latest version canary yahfa from edxposed
busybox installed
luckypatcher installed.Thanks
I'm thinking that for bank app it's Better device without root.
Inviato dal mio ONEPLUS A5000 utilizzando Tapatalk
My first guess would be the app who must not be named that you have installed.
I suggest uninstalling it, mainly for all the bad things it is doing to your karma but it's also on many apps detection lists.

Categories

Resources