Hi All,
CITI bank App is detecting root. No matter what I do, Magiskhide fails to hide CITI bank app. Tried all the basic troubleshooting.
1. Restored the Magisk app and unchecked CITI bank app from the list.(shield icon)
2. Rebooted and added CITI bank to list.
3. Changed magisk manager name(Hide the app)
4. Changed the Twrp folder name.
5. Cleared cache for CITI bank.
If anyone could possibly help, I'll be grateful.
Thanks in advance.
altafharsh60 said:
Hi All,
CITI bank App is detecting root. No matter what I do, Magiskhide fails to hide CITI bank app. Tried all the basic troubleshooting.
1. Restored the Magisk app and unchecked CITI bank app from the list.(shield icon)
2. Rebooted and added CITI bank to list.
3. Changed magisk manager name(Hide the app)
4. Changed the Twrp folder name.
5. Cleared cache for CITI bank.
If anyone could possibly help, I'll be grateful.
Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Were you able to solve this? I am also facing the same issue. Please let me know.
trgowtham said:
Were you able to solve this? I am also facing the same issue. Please let me know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using a web version now.
Citi Mobile
m.citibank.co.in
Works exactly same.
I know this is not a solution, but workaround until the app starts to work.
trgowtham said:
Were you able to solve this? I am also facing the same issue. Please let me know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey ,
Its working for me again.
1. Installed magisk v 22.0.apk and Magisk 22. Zip.
2. Hiding manager app
3. Installed the latest citi bank app (Version 23.5.2) but didn't open
4. Added app to magisk hide list.
Its started working.
Please uninstall busybox.
altafharsh60 said:
Please uninstall busybox.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome.. uninstalling busybox did the trick..
Citi app works perfectly now..
Now need to check if other apps are broken because of busybox..
use airfrozen and then its working
i uninstalled busybox, still no luck.. Citibank still detects root
Any idea on how to solve this?
xn0live said:
use airfrozen and then its working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
After August app update, Citibank is stuck on blue screen WITHOUT any notification!
Obviously it detects magisk root, and all hiding procedures failed (magisk 23.0 / no busybox installed).
Applying airfrozen (on magisk manager) fix the issue while root stays active.
Ta
huuur said:
After August app update, Citibank is stuck on blue screen WITHOUT any notification!
Obviously it detects magisk root, and all hiding procedures failed (magisk 23.0 / no busybox installed).
Applying airfrozen (on magisk manager) fix the issue while root stays active.
Ta
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
me too. just found this post, installed airfrozen and freezed magisk and now citibank works (busybox doesnt matter for me). however, one of the hsbc app still doesnt work even with busybox renamed and magisk freezed
huuur said:
After August app update, Citibank is stuck on blue screen WITHOUT any notification!
Obviously it detects magisk root, and all hiding procedures failed (magisk 23.0 / no busybox installed).
Applying airfrozen (on magisk manager) fix the issue while root stays active.
Ta
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you shall find an app that have the function of "App ops"
Then disable citibank from "get installed apps"
take a try I have worked in this way
wks960803 said:
you shall find an app that have the function of "App ops"
Then disable citibank from "get installed apps"
take a try I have worked in this way
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i can't seem to find Citibank on the Request install package from the App ops app.
xn0live said:
use airfrozen and then its working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You just saved my life. Thank you very much!
xn0live said:
use airfrozen and then its working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks - but easier said than done
Airfrozen cannot get root - using Poco F2 Pro, Android 11 stock, Magisk 23.0
Any idea how to overcome?
Thanks
Tiemichael said:
Thanks - but easier said than done
Airfrozen cannot get root - using Poco F2 Pro, Android 11 stock, Magisk 23.0
Any idea how to overcome?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
just open your magisk, and enable it from there...
Same issue here on SM-N910G with crDroid custom ROM. I needed to have the "Hide the Magisk app" settting enabled in conjunction with Airfrozen. Just freezing the Magisk app wasn't enough. Note: this isn't the MagiskHide setting I'm referring to; that setting was enabled the whole time.
Steps that worked for me (Magisk 23.0) was:
1. In Magisk, add Citi to the hide list first (of course)
2. In Magisk, don't use "Hide the Magisk app". I.e. the app is listed as Magisk in the app drawer.
3. Then, install Airfrozen and grant root access (I wouldn't get the grant root access prompt unless #2 above was done)
4. Now, in Magisk, enable "Hide the Magisk app" and go through that process to rename to 'settings' or whatever.
5. Now, open up Airfrozen and select "settings" (or whatever name you used in 4). Freeze it.
6. Citi app now launches and loads the login screen
Hope that helps someone
dallivadr said:
Same issue here on SM-N910G with crDroid custom ROM. I needed to have the "Hide the Magisk app" settting enabled in conjunction with Airfrozen. Just freezing the Magisk app wasn't enough. Note: this isn't the MagiskHide setting I'm referring to; that setting was enabled the whole time.
Steps that worked for me (Magisk 23.0) was:
1. In Magisk, add Citi to the hide list first (of course)
2. In Magisk, don't use "Hide the Magisk app". I.e. the app is listed as Magisk in the app drawer.
3. Then, install Airfrozen and grant root access (I wouldn't get the grant root access prompt unless #2 above was done)
4. Now, in Magisk, enable "Hide the Magisk app" and go through that process to rename to 'settings' or whatever.
5. Now, open up Airfrozen and select "settings" (or whatever name you used in 4). Freeze it.
6. Citi app now launches and loads the login screen
Hope that helps someone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! It definitely helped me!
wks960803 said:
you shall find an app that have the function of "App ops"
Then disable citibank from "get installed apps"
take a try I have worked in this way
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i didn't see any permission nameas "get installed apps" in app ops.
dallivadr said:
Same issue here on SM-N910G with crDroid custom ROM. I needed to have the "Hide the Magisk app" settting enabled in conjunction with Airfrozen. Just freezing the Magisk app wasn't enough. Note: this isn't the MagiskHide setting I'm referring to; that setting was enabled the whole time.
Steps that worked for me (Magisk 23.0) was:
1. In Magisk, add Citi to the hide list first (of course)
2. In Magisk, don't use "Hide the Magisk app". I.e. the app is listed as Magisk in the app drawer.
3. Then, install Airfrozen and grant root access (I wouldn't get the grant root access prompt unless #2 above was done)
4. Now, in Magisk, enable "Hide the Magisk app" and go through that process to rename to 'settings' or whatever.
5. Now, open up Airfrozen and select "settings" (or whatever name you used in 4). Freeze it.
6. Citi app now launches and loads the login screen
Hope that helps someone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hmm...not working for me. using MIUI here , i already disallow citibank to read my app list, and perform steps above. still detect my phone as rooted.
locolyric said:
hmm...not working for me. using MIUI here , i already disallow citibank to read my app list, and perform steps above. still detect my phone as rooted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try downgrading magisk to v22 and uninstalling busybox. I'm using it.
See images.
Related
Magisk Hide (Masking Magisk SuperUser) - 2 Problems w/ Magisk Hide being disabled after reboot or closing Magisk Manager.
If you are using Magisk Manager and Magisk Root and are experiencing difficulty with Magisk Hide (Masking Magisk's SU) not showing in the Manager's side-menu or remembering its status in settings, it occurs when a file is not automatically deleted and removed.
PROBLEM:
Open Magisk Manager, Settings >> Enable Magisk Hide, close Manager, re-open and Magisk Hide is disabled and not visible (hidden) in the left side-menu. i.e. Exit, Close, Stop, Re-Open & Reboot Reset's Magisk Hide's State to Disabled.
SOLUTION 1.
Force stopped Magisk Manager.
Backup then Delete file /data/property/persist.magisk.hide (0600).
Launch Magisk Manager.
Go to Settings >> Enable Magisk Hide.
Go back to Manager home screen. Swipe to reveal side-menu and check Magisk Hide menu is visible.
Close Magisk Manager or Force stop.
Reopen and Swipe side-menu and confirm Magisk Hide is still visible!
I hope this helps others also experiencing issues with Hiding Super User SU. Thanks Shak!
SOLUTION 2.
Another Fix someone else has also posted Dec 2017 was in regards to an error "fopen: /magisk/.core/magiskhide/hidelist failed with 2: No such file or directory"
The issue is due to Magisk Manager being unable to save the list of ticked Apps to hide from SU to /magisk/.core/hidelist.
Check the existence of the "/magisk/.core/hidelist" path.
Create the "/hidelist" directory.
CHMOD "/magisk/.core/hidelist" to 0644.
Thanks to Dunderball. :highfive:
.
Thanks a lot! I have been looking this issue up for almost a week now.
Solution 1 worked for me.
No worries mate. Appreciate the feedback.
Someone else had a similar issue for a few weeks and was unable to resolve it until upgrading to 16.4 beta. But this isn't viable for everyone due to issues w/ 16.4+.
Thanks!
monsterkrusher said:
Thanks a lot! I have been looking this issue up for almost a week now.
Solution 1 worked for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would like to add to this thread that this doesn't work anymore with the newer versions of magisk. Eget did work for me though was to delete (and backup of course) /data/adb/magisk.db and then restart
tgcGlaDius said:
I would like to add to this thread that this doesn't work anymore with the newer versions of magisk. Eget did work for me though was to delete (and backup of course) /data/adb/magisk.db and then restart
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
which version you use ?
I use version 19.4, wont work if delete magisk.db.
LineageOs 17 on a Nexus 2013 Flo
Magisk 19.3
Magisk Manager 7.3.2
safetynet always fails after a reboot.
I tried renaming magisk.db and while magisk kept working generally, m-hide still fails the safetynet test after a reboot until I toggle hide.
kevin mitnick said:
which version you use ?
I use version 19.4, wont work if delete magisk.db.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
michaelh99 said:
LineageOs 17 on a Nexus 2013 Flo
Magisk 19.3
Magisk Manager 7.3.2
safetynet always fails after a reboot.
I tried renaming magisk.db and while magisk kept working generally, m-hide still fails the safetynet test after a reboot until I toggle hide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Download The Module Of MultiFunctions From This Thread https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/module-multifunctions-bootloop-t3933386 For Getting The Ability To Use Either The Sub-Function Of Hide Keeper Or Hide Enabler.
Dreamer(3MF) said:
Download The Module Of MultiFunctions From This Thread https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/module-multifunctions-bootloop-t3933386 For Getting The Ability To Use Either The Sub-Function Of Hide Keeper Or Hide Enabler.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll have to try that sometime in the future when I've got more time to experiment. I ended up going back to stock just to have a working tablet. I only use it for maps and streaming and since Netflix wouldn't work...
How to make a bakup?
I recently rooted my new Mi A2 Lite using Magisk.
So my current banking app detected the root and now I cannot use it anymore. I tried Root Cloak and MagiskHide but both of them did not work either. It still shows the message saying my phone is rooted.
How do I debug that now. I need it to be working anyhow.
App: K-Plus; play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.kasikorn.retail.mbanking.wap
https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot
arunsharmaofficial said:
I recently rooted my new Mi A2 Lite using Magisk.
So my current banking app detected the root and now I cannot use it anymore. I tried Root Cloak and MagiskHide but both of them did not work either. It still shows the message saying my phone is rooted.
How do I debug that now. I need it to be working anyhow.
App: K-Plus; play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.kasikorn.retail.mbanking.wap
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I recently had the same problem, but with a different banking app.
What helped me in the past was to hide Magisk Manager with a random package name. It is an option in Magisk Manager itself. Unfortunately it doesn't work anymore but i could mask Magisk Manager with the Samsung app S Secure and now it's working again .
This was included in my Galaxy S7 ROM so you probably need to find the apk for the app or find a similiar working app for your phone model.
Hope this helps.
Daci54 said:
I recently had the same problem, but with a different banking app.
What helped me in the past was to hide Magisk Manager with a random package name. It is an option in Magisk Manager itself. Unfortunately it doesn't work anymore but i could mask Magisk Manager with the Samsung app S Secure and now it's working again .
This was included in my Galaxy S7 ROM so you probably need to find the apk for the app or find a similiar working app for your phone model.
Hope this helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright! Can you clarify what on how to hide Magisk with a different package name. I am still pretty new to Magisk. Thanks.
arunsharmaofficial said:
Alright! Can you clarify what on how to hide Magisk with a different package name. I am still pretty new to Magisk. Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Open Magisk Manager, go to settings and tap on Hide Magisk Manager. If your banking app doesn't work right away try a restart. If it still doesn't work try to mask Magisk Manager with S Secure or similiar apps.
The magisk hide feature does not work
nm180618 said:
The magisk hide feature does not work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does work, the steps I took were:
1) Install Banking app
2) Open it and get notified about the phone being rooted
3) Use Magisk Hide feature to hide the Banking app
4) Go to phone's app settings
5) Baking app settings
6) Clear storage data (Clearing only the cache could work too, I didn't test it)
7) Profit!
Hope that works for you.
Magisk hide doesn't seem to be working for me. Magisk says it's working and safety net passes, but I've tested multiple apps and they can see that I'm rooted. Hiding magisk with a random package name doesn't work either.
Yesterday I installed magisk and went to hide options and checked my banking app. I was amazed to see banking app allowing me to do everything without limited functionality due to "root" like before. But today banking app detected root again and limited all functions, how? There haven't been any updates for banking app yet it seemed to no longer be fooled by magisk.
Same goes for me with the K-Plus app as well. (สวัสดีคับผม) Use Magisk Hide to hide the root access but it crashes the bank app instead.
Not sure what I've missed.
Gpay and banking are still detecting root/custom rom
Magisk and manager installed.
module SaMoDXv1 installed.
Safteynet is showing green
gpay and banking apps hidden
Using hide magisk function
removed all Magisk related stuff from SD card.
Cleared cache from gpay and banking apps .
Turned off usb debugging.
What else is there?
Just installed root checker basic, it sees root. I hide magisk from it and it still sees root. Is that right?
beythas said:
Same goes for me with the K-Plus app as well. (สวัสดีคับผม) Use Magisk Hide to hide the root access but it crashes the bank app instead.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try following the 'Promon' section in https://github.com/Ingan121/UDSBypass
Hi,
I'ould like installing Fde.ai on my One plus 6 rooted with Ice Renovate 11.1 rom, but I'm not sure that installation is compatible with "Rice tweaks", a tweak app for this rom no my device.
Peraphs there is someone who does know the answer?
Tks and regards.
Roberto
What I do
Go to setting -> Magisk Hide -> disable then enable.
This way worked with me .
I used Magisk Manager v 7.2.0 (213).
Magisk v 19.3 (19300).
What worked for me is using the "Hide Magisk Manager" feature in settings. Now apps are not promoting about device being rooted and are running fine now.
Anyone solved this problem?
I still have a banking app with this problem. I tried many times but still not working.
Magisk hide dont work for this app.
nguyenlinh said:
Anyone solved this problem?
I still have a banking app with this problem. I tried many times but still not working.
Magisk hide dont work for this app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So far there are very few apps that I've seen that can not be tricked with tips from the guide linked in the second post of this thread. Give it a shot...
Can you try it?
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=vietcombank.itcenter.smartotpcorp
I Cannot run this app.
Thanks
nguyenlinh said:
Can you try it?
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=vietcombank.itcenter.smartotpcorp
I Cannot run this app.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Runs fine with the app on the Hide list and the Magisk Manager repackaged with a random name.
More:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Can someone check this for me?
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=no.apps.dnbnor&hl=en_US
Iam using MH v60 with 19.3 still nothing. Iam fighting with that about 4 months now((((
I am using oneplus 6 with latest oos magisk 19.3
Banking app like sbi anywhere, icici detecting root can't use upi.
Also adadhar app detecting root event safety net pass already done magisk hide
Can some help me there or use other versions of magisk
Please help
android_smater said:
I am using oneplus 6 with latest oos magisk 19.3
Banking app like sbi anywhere, icici detecting root can't use upi.
Also adadhar app detecting root event safety net pass already done magisk hide
Can some help me there or use other versions of magisk
Please help
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use Hide Magisk manager in settings or Core only mode.
Sent from my MI 8 using Tapatalk
Dexer125 said:
Use Hide Magisk manager in settings or Core only mode.
Sent from my MI 8 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Didn't work either. I guess will have to wait for an update. I have tried so far:
Settings > Magisk Core Only More - On
Magisk Hide - Check against the banking app
Clear app cache
Reboot
Also - Magisk v19.3, Magisk Manager v7.3.1(222)
gagan007 said:
Didn't work either. I guess will have to wait for an update. I have tried so far:
Settings > Magisk Core Only More - On
Magisk Hide - Check against the banking app
Clear app cache
Reboot
Also - Magisk v19.3, Magisk Manager v7.3.1(222)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
disable developer mode?
and you need to hide magisk manager itself.not just magisk hide.
Try executing
Code:
su -c chmod 000 /proc/net/unix
in a terminal. Several banking apps now use a very stupid and shaky root detection heuristic that is circumvented in this way.
(see https://github.com/Ingan121/UDSBypass).
A banking app on my phone (keytradebank, belgian bank) worked fine with Magisk Hide but after an update stopped working.
Disabling read access to /proc/net/unix did the trick for me!
Looked it up, this rootbeerFresh code is really brain-dead, even the presence of busybox will make isRooted() return true
No concern for false positives at all.
el_perro said:
A banking app on my phone (keytradebank, belgian bank) worked fine with Magisk Hide but after an update stopped working.
Disabling read access to /proc/net/unix did the trick for me!
Looked it up, this rootbeerFresh code is really brain-dead, even the presence of busybox will make isRooted() return true
No concern for false positives at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Remember that app says it COULD be root.
If anyone is paying attention to it yet.
Also
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magis...and_other_apps_wont_install_or_doesnt_show_up
Busybox
Some apps detect Busybox and see this as a sign of your device being compromised (rooted). Magisk should be able to hide any Busybox installed as a Magisk module. osm0sis has a great Busybox module available in the Magisk repo (install from the Magisk Manager, under "Downloads").
Figuring out if an app has dependencies, looks for "sensitive props", Busybox, etc
It can be tricky figuring out if an app is dependent on another app or process for detecting root, expects certain prop values, doesn't like Busybox or whatever is triggering a root warning within the app. Apart from trying one thing/prop at a time, finding this out could mean you have to decompile the apk to look at the source code (use search), grab a logcat when the app is detecting root, etc.
Detecting apps requiring root
There are apps that detect known apps that require root and refuse to work properly or even start if that is the case. Usual suspects include (but aren't limited to) busybox apps, Xposed installer, root hiding apps, etc.
This can be worked around by uninstalling or possibly freezing (Titanium Backup can do this, among others) the offending root app when you need to use an app detecting root apps and reinstalling/unfreezing it afterwards. Cumbersome, but it might work. There are also some Xposed modules that can hide apps from other apps, but having Xposed installed might cause other issues with tampering detection...
@mrspeccy Thank you for pointing out that workaround. Works for me too for the Keytrade app
el_perro said:
A banking app on my phone (keytradebank, belgian bank) worked fine with Magisk Hide but after an update stopped working.
Disabling read access to /proc/net/unix did the trick for me!
Looked it up, this rootbeerFresh code is really brain-dead, even the presence of busybox will make isRooted() return true
No concern for false positives at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did you do that?
su -c chmod 000 /proc/net/unix didn't work for me.
robuser007 said:
How did you do that?
su -c chmod 000 /proc/net/unix didn't work for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes, in a terminal on your phone or using 'adb shell'
be aware it's not a permanent fix, a reboot will restore the old permissions on /proc/net/unix
so you have to remove read access after every reboot.
Quite clumsy.
To make this easier on the go, I installed termux, created in the home directory a small file 'hide' with the one-liner,
Code:
su -c chmod 440 /proc/net/unix
Note: 000 works just as well, but 440 is closer to the original permission and works too.
so after a reboot i open termux terminal and type the command
Code:
. hide
gagan007 said:
Didn't work either. I guess will have to wait for an update. I have tried so far:
Settings > Magisk Core Only More - On
Magisk Hide - Check against the banking app
Clear app cache
Reboot
Also - Magisk v19.3, Magisk Manager v7.3.1(222)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks it work...
Got that app working successfully today. Hiding Magisk itself worked I guess. I locked bootloader also.
android_smater said:
I am using oneplus 6 with latest oos magisk 19.3
Banking app like sbi anywhere, icici detecting root can't use upi.
Also adadhar app detecting root event safety net pass already done magisk hide
Can some help me there or use other versions of magisk
Please help
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try these...
1. From your magisk, install these 2 modules: Riru - Core, and Riru - EdXposed (Sandbox or Yahfa is okay]
2. Reboot your device to activate both modules.
3. Install Xposed Installer APK by DVDandroid. You can get it here: https://dl-xda.xposed.info/modules/d...v33_36570c.apk
4. Reboot to activate the Xposed Installer app
5. Inside Xposed Installer app, go to downloads and install the HiddenCore Module.
6. Reboot and go back to Magisk, and hide.
7. Test to see if everything is now okay.
wittymav said:
Try these...
1. From your magisk, install these 2 modules: Riru - Core, and Riru - EdXposed (Sandbox or Yahfa is okay]
2. Reboot your device to activate both modules.
3. Install Xposed Installer APK by DVDandroid. You can get it here: https://dl-xda.xposed.info/modules/d...v33_36570c.apk
4. Reboot to activate the Xposed Installer app
5. Inside Xposed Installer app, go to downloads and install the HiddenCore Module.
6. Reboot and go back to Magisk, and hide.
7. Test to see if everything is now okay.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope! It Doesn't Work With SBI YONO Or BHIM.
My Cofidis app also keeps detecting root.
Have latest version magisk, latest version of magiskmanager and renamed it. Magisk is hidding. App is in magisk hide list.
chmod suggestion did not work
Running latest version of lineageos on my htc u11. I think the issues started when I installed the latest build (11/08).
Any suggestions to fix this?
Same issue here with this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=eu.mobeepass.nfcniceticket
Is there any way to troubleshoot what triggers the root detection?
Ps24u said:
Same issue here with this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=eu.mobeepass.nfcniceticket
Is there any way to troubleshoot what triggers the root detection?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Using my app VD INFOS you can see every detectable thing. (Root/Magisk/Xposed/Riru/and others.)
And then you can fix what needs to be fixed.
[APP][v1.10] VD Infos (Package: com.vitaodoidao.vdinfos)
(Para quem fala PORTUGUÊS, o próximo post está totalmente traduzido !) VD Infos v1.10 As we all know, Android is a super powerful and super versatile operating system. What nobody tells you is that all your personal details and confidential...
forum.xda-developers.com
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you can pass SafetyNet (cts profile) try to hide :
Magisk Manager with a random name (mandatory) ... and "Your banking app" must be hidden too along with Google Services of course !
There are currently several ways of detecting Magisk that MagiskHide can't circumvent.
If the app isn't using one of those (if it is you'll just have to wait for a possible update to Magisk), you can find some tips and tricks here:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
Magisk cannot hide:
Other known root apps (see "Detecting apps requiring root"). (Shouldn't be a problem since even with a renamed manager and magisk unflashed it still works.)
Remnants of previous root method, including any root management apps (a good way to remove most remnants of root is osm0sis unSU script). (Magisk is unflashed and app immediately works.)
Unlocked bootloader (see Unlocked bootloader). (Magisk is unflashed and bootloader unlocked, app still works. I also tried custom rom and the stock rom.)
A tripped Samsung Knox counter. (Not a samsung phone.)
Xposed (deactivate it or uninstall). It doesn't matter if it's systemless, Magisk can't hide it. (Never used.)
EdXposed. Detection of EdXposed can sometimes be worked around with newer release of EdXposed and/or features like the EdXposed Manager blacklist. (Never used.)
USB/ADB Debugging (disable under Developer options in Android settings). (Magisk unflashed and debugging on, app works.)
Developer options. (Magisk unflashed and developer options is on, app works.)
Some Magisk modules - Depending on what the module does, it may not be able to be hidden by MagiskHide. (Tried core only mode which should disable all modules, still don't work.)
Some modifications to /system. Make sure to use Magisk modules... (I'm not sure what this means :c)
From that list it looks like it's something from Magisk itself that's tripping the detection :/
Im going bald from this.
IcY~ said:
From that list it looks like it's something from Magisk itself that's tripping the detection :/
Im going bald from this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you've tested and confirmed everything else, it is very likely that the app is using a detection method that Magisk currently can't hide from.
Solution? Wait for @topjohnwu to possibly update Magisk/MagiskHide (alternatively, don't install Magisk). When? Whenever he feels like it...
Didgeridoohan said:
If you've tested and confirmed everything else, it is very likely that the app is using a detection method that Magisk currently can't hide from.
Solution? Wait for @topjohnwu to possibly update Magisk/MagiskHide (alternatively, don't install Magisk). When? Whenever he feels like it...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2406
Looks like someone posted a potential fix. Will wait for it to reach the master branch!
Have you find the workaround? I am using the same app and face same problem. This app last update gives headache
I am hidding root and edxposed using Island and installing intune inside the sandbox. Maybe the same will be with bank apps.
@kubis111
i'm happy for you, but please...this isn't your thread so do not OOT, OP problem isn't solving yet
---------- Post added at 11:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:03 AM ----------
Tomek0000 said:
I am hidding root and edxposed using Island and installing intune inside the sandbox. Maybe the same will be with bank apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can you share the apps link?
Any updates on this banking app? I've tried many TaiChi Magisk, Sudohide and Zuper module but no success.
ctsProfile all green, Rootbeer Fresh all green.
citi app also detected my rooted device( Mi 8 Pro) after update , even hide the App ..useless....
Heatexplorer said:
citi app also detected my rooted device( Mi 8 Pro) after update , even hide the App ..useless....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Had the same problem. Updated magisk manager and fixed it (even before updating my modules).
Anyone lucky on it? What about BBVA Spain app?
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you found a solution? With latest Permata and Magisk (23) the banking app still does not work...
timofonic said:
Anyone lucky on it? What about BBVA Spain app?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me work
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Found a solution, but can't publish yet. Excuse me
Spartacus500 said:
Found a solution, but can't publish yet. Excuse me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why?
hallo dare said:
Why?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So I ran the test quickly and it turns out that it works, for those who are interested, I will provide a solution, but a little later.
I managed to make it work,
Spartacus500 said:
For me work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Spartacus500 said:
For me work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No idea how. I'm worried about that Knox logo these days, but we'll..
Thanks!
IcY~ said:
My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.
I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.
Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to be just now, but to the point of solution to this,
1. Install the disable services app and disable a process called "S17"
2. Done
Hey, i have a problem since my last update for my Banking App (VR-SecureGo; Update to 20.27.0 (from 20.23.0 i think)). The problem is that Magisk is getting detected even with Magisk Hide enabled, repackaged Magisk Manager and passing SafetyNet.
I don't know what can I do to bypass this root detection. I can't downgrade version anymore because the last version isn't supported anymore.
My specifications:
Device: Pixel 2 XL
Version: Android 11
ROM: Stock (Rooted with Magisk boot.img)
Installed Magisk: v22.1
Installed Magisk Manager Version: v22.1
Installed Magisk Modules: Universal SafetyNet Fix
(EdX/LS)posed: Not installed (anymore; tried to bypass detection with LSPosed and XPrivacyLua spoof, but don't work)
Edit: Before anyone refers me to the other posts, i've already seen them and tried their solutions, but none of them work
PS: Sorry for my bad english, I'm german
Did you try freezing the hidden magisk app prior starting the banking app?
This is the only working solution i could find for DKB Tan2Go.
JMaster7 said:
Hey, i have a problem since my last update for my Banking App (VR-SecureGo; Update to 20.27.0 (from 20.23.0 i think)).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The same here of course :-(
I tried all too, only restoring the last backups (made with swift backup) did help for now.
VR SecureGo, PSD-SecureGo and PSD.Banking app are affected.
These apps did work with Magisk 22.x and Edxposed.
ratelutz said:
Did you try freezing the hidden magisk app prior starting the banking app?
This is the only working solution i could find for DKB Tan2Go.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you please explain a bit more, what you mean?
Very simple:
Configure magisk hide, hide the magisk app, freeze the hidden magisk app, start your banking app
ratelutz said:
Very simple:
Configure magisk hide, hide the magisk app, freeze the hidden magisk app, start your banking app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thx.
ratelutz said:
Very simple:
Configure magisk hide, hide the magisk app, freeze the hidden magisk app, start your banking app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, this works but a little laborious :-(
Thank you.
tramp20 said:
Yes, this works but a little laborious :-(
Thank you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, annoying if done manually.
But this can be automated with Tasker.
As i tap (start) my banking app,
Tasker:
-kills it right again
-freezes the hidden magisk app
-and restarts the banking app
jokk3l said:
Yes, annoying if done manually.
But this can be automated with Tasker.
As i tap (start) my banking app,
Tasker:
-kills it right again
-freezes the hidden magisk app
-and restarts the banking app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And the most reliable and fastest method is using logcat reader and reacting on app started event
ratelutz said:
Very simple:
Configure magisk hide, hide the magisk app, freeze the hidden magisk app, start your banking app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i have similar problem with other app
so what do you mean by (freeze the hidden magisk app)
ratelutz said:
And the most reliable and fastest method is using logcat reader and reacting on app started event
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This!
abogrhen said:
i have similar problem with other app
so what do you mean by (freeze the hidden magisk app)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk Manager app can be hidden (repacked/renamed) to make it harder to be detected.
Freezing can be done via apps like airfrozen or via shell command "pm disable-user <PACKETNAME>"
jokk3l said:
This!
Magisk Manager app can be hidden (repacked/renamed) to make it harder to be detected.
Freezing can be done via apps like airfrozen or via shell command "pm disable-user <PACKETNAME>"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The hide already done
but the freezing is new to me
i will try
Thanks. Airfroze did help me to bypass root check.
ratelutz said:
And the most reliable and fastest method is using logcat reader and reacting on app started event
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How can I do that? Freezing Magisk does work for me. The method jokk3l described is a bit buggy on my phone. I have to open the VR Banking app twice. But thank you jokk3l, that's better than doing evertyhing by hand.
Edit: YouTube helps! Thank you for posting your solutions!
Was there another update? I rooted just yesterday and can't get SecureGO to work at all.
I'm using Magisk 23.0 on Android 10.
I already renamed Magisk, activated MagiskHide and used airfrozen to freeze the renamed app, but SecureGO refuses to start
For me it works just fine with freezing Magisk.
Maybe you need to clear cache and data of securego first after you renamed and hid magisk!?
paulquappe said:
For me it works just fine with freezing Magisk.
Maybe you need to clear cache and data of securego first after you renamed and hid magisk!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tried freezing, then clearing data / reinstalling SecureGo and even then it doesn't start.. is there any way to check if other apps can "see" the root? I'm wondering whether MagiskHide even works at all..
I got same problem here but with another bank app, C6 Bank.
The way I could have it working with root is on Android 10. With Android 11 can't make it run anymore.
Hi @ all.
I had the same problem with the vr securego app. It helped to completely uninstall Magisk and reinstall it again. Then the work around works with the Magisk hide, Hide Magisk app and freeze. Many greetings
FreezyLemon said:
Tried freezing, then clearing data / reinstalling SecureGo and even then it doesn't start.. is there any way to check if other apps can "see" the root? I'm wondering whether MagiskHide even works at all..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you solve your issue with this app? Having LOS 18.1, Magisk 23.0 with MagiskHide and freezed the app by with Airfrozen but it does not work. Neither VRSecure-GO nor DKB-Tan2GO are working anymore