Well banned for bad language... i can understand that my bad but before i was banned @Didgeridoohan so kindly said "Wait or use v11.1" the thing is i wiped phone completely and flashed a stock ro with odin.. flashed TWRP then installed magisk 11.1 and pph's magisk su and it still fails safteynet.... so if anyone has any suggestions on how to fix it im all ears "i apologize for my language previously i agree that it was uncalled for but i was kind of triggered after it breaking my phone..."
Ok... Here's the last one you get for free:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
Related
I'm right now I'm at a point where I hate stock and these custom roms are great, but hate being held back by the Play store no longer allowing me to download/update Netflix which is used often.
Previously I had installed
KatKiss - Nougatella #023,
SuperSU
Gapps - Stock
I suppose I could have just installed netflix through the apk but I figured that would only be a temp solution.
So my first steps were to wipe and go back to stock.
I then proceeded to add CWM recovery back (Also tried with TWRP)
I wiped
I then ran an uninstall SuperSU zip (which may or may not have been needed but seemed safer to try.
I installed KatKiss
Then Magisk
Then Gapps - Stock
This will cause lots of crashing right from the start of the setup wizard... the the app/stopped don't ever stop. A lot of google related stuff as soon as I conect to Wifi.
I started over.
This time I installed Gapps - Mini instead.
No longer crashes the set up wizard. Everything seems stable.
At this point I have access to the tablet through KatKiss.
When I run Magisk Manager, the safetynet check never finished. Just spins.
If I hide the PlayStore from root and try to find Netflix it won't be there.
However, if I now install Gapps-Stock through recovery at this point... I can then go back to the Play Store and find Netflix. It will be there.
However, I still can't pass SecureNet check. It just spins.
I first thought to myself... Thats ok. I don't need it, Netflix was really the issue I needed addressing and I have that.
So I started putting apps back on my tablet to find... apps were crashing more. Facebook for example will never work. Just crashes on startup.
So something just isn't right and I don't really know what I'm doing. In the past I always just followed easy to follow guides.
Note: I believe I have better luck with KatKiss build #021. 023 gave me more issues with this process so I had 021 on hand.
You really should go with the gapps version recommended by the dev of your rom and that would be pico gapps in this case. If you flash a different gapps package you're on your own for trouble shooting fc'ing apps and system UI and such...
I have no idea if this rom works with Magisk and would be tickled to find out, but I don;t have the time for it right now. On other devices there were problems when the rom was pre-rooted or for some the build-in busybox did not work and they had to flash a different version. There could also be a problem if the boot image has been modded for SuperSU and idk if it has been on this rom.
Try this first:
If you flashed any other than pico gapps version you really should format /data before reflashing the rom. That done:
format /system, wipe /cache and Dalvik, then flash the rom and pico gapps, then flash unsu by osmosis followed by the Magisk flash. Then install Magisk Manager and try to pass Safetynet with both Busybox enabled and disabled.
Let me know how it goes
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=63615067
Edit: couldn't help myself - had to try it :cyclops:
So I tried a quick and dirty switch from SuperSU rooted Katshmallow v33 to the same rom with Magisk. No reflash, just wiped cache and Dalvik, flashed unsu and then Magisk. Root works fine but it does not pass Safetynet check, Netflix app does not show in Playstore, device is uncertified in Play.
The failed check says: CTS profile mismatch and I believe that is the problem with the Busybox version that comes with Magisk. Read something somewhere about replacing it with a different one which solved the problem for some folks...
I'll dig some more later....
Thanks for the info. I didn't realize the importance of using Gapps-Pico in this case. I just figured they were recommending a light-weight Gapps opposed to a larger one... So I always went with "stock" and never had an issue.
I'll keep that in mind for debugging future issues.
I'm not sure how important formatting /system was... I always left that one alone, but I was formatting /data /cache and Dalvik
That CTS profile stuff all seems beyond my knowledge at the moment. I guess let me know what you find when you do.
Thanks again
No issues? I thought you had "lots of crashing".. ??
So you want me to do all the leg work, yes? Sorry man, it's you who wants Netflix :silly:
I dirty flashed the rom, ran unsu, then flashed Magisk and osmosis' Busybox but Safetynet check still fails for me...
Don't have time to do a clean install just now, but that would be the next step...
I like Magisk as systemless root and I got it working for my purposes.
As for Netflix - I don't use it much on the tablet and I just squirreled away the 4.16.1 version. Just in case I accidentally update it to the newer ones....
Sorry if that was unclear. I meant I never had any issues using Gapp Stock before this whole Rooted/Netflix thing came up last week. Now it is what it is.
And yeah, I didn't mean for it to be like I was asking anything of you. I'm not. You just seemed like the type who would be tinkering with this kind of stuff. If not, no worries.
Information/guidance is what I'm after. Not leg work.
I'm sure I just need to be patient really. Since a lot of people use Netflix I'm sure this will get a lot more attention in the near future.
Thanks again.
Hi
I'm using a Samsung Galaxy S4
I rooted the stock Samsung rom with SuperSU prior to install Magisk
At first I couldn't install 13.3 I had to install 12.0 because of some unknown reason installing 13.3 I got the error image mount failed same with all previous 13. versions however now 13.3 is now installed and SuperSU isn't installed.
When I run the SafetyNet Check in Magisk it reports:
ctsProfile: false
basicIntegrity: false
I want to be able to use apps like Android pay and such
Can someone please help me with getting this to work
Thanks!
Magisk v12.0 can't pass SafetyNet without workarounds like Universal SafetyNet fix module (and since the last update to SafetyNet a few days ago I've no idea if that works either).
You can't use Magisk to pass SafetyNet with SuperSU installed.
Here's some reading for you:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
Pro tip: Try using the search function and browse the stickied threads before posting. There are very few things that hasn't been covered already in one way or another...
Didgeridoohan said:
Magisk v12.0 can't pass SafetyNet without workarounds like Universal SafetyNet fix module (and since the last update to SafetyNet a few days ago I've no idea if that works either).
You can't use Magisk to pass SafetyNet with SuperSU installed.
Here's some reading for you:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
Pro tip: Try using the search function and browse the stickied threads before posting. There are very few things that hasn't been covered already in one way or another...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've got 13.3 installed and SuperSU isn't installed plus I've already read a lot on this subject and most of my searches did nothing for me that's why I thought I would make a thread to see if anyone could help me.
AyanamiRei0 said:
I've got 13.3 installed and SuperSU isn't installed plus I've already read a lot on this subject and most of my searches did nothing for me that's why I thought I would make a thread to see if anyone could help me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That was not very clear from your first post...
If you haven't already, start by reading through the link I posted. You wan't post #4.
Didgeridoohan said:
That was not very clear from your first post...
If you haven't already, start by reading through the link I posted. You wan't post #4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting trying to start magiskhide manually does nothing.
You could have remnants of Su on your phone. Even if you use the full uninstall method you can have leftovers. Tried a complete fresh reinstall?
phuhcue said:
You could have remnants of Su on your phone. Even if you use the full uninstall method you can have leftovers. Tried a complete fresh reinstall?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh it's working fine now installing Lineage OS and then install Magisk and it works perfectly.
With me my experiments with magisk in the past left some files in my data partition behind which makes safetynet fail.
I found them by going into twrp recovery, starting and adb shell and then executing find . | grep -i magisk
the two files i found were:
data/data/com.google.android.gms/files/backup_diff_script/com.topjohnwu.magisk
data/property/persist.magisk.hide
i deleted them with rm and safety net worked again.
So I can confirm that for my phone, unlocked bootloader, custom modem and custom recovery does not matter at all. But if your filesystem still contains traces of magisk, is a nono for google safetynet, pretty silly this road they are taking here.
safety net
i have the same problem on galaxy note 3 with magisk 15.3 on my galaxy s7 everything is ok but in note 3 i have safety net false...
can anyone help me?
spanpana said:
i have the same problem on galaxy note 3 with magisk 15.3 on my galaxy s7 everything is ok but in note 3 i have safety net false...
can anyone help me?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Old device... If the kernel version is lower than 3.8 it'll likely not have support for mount namespace and MagiskHide won't work. A custom kernel or ROM might work...
Didgeridoohan said:
Old device... If the kernel version is lower than 3.8 it'll likely not have support for mount namespace and MagiskHide won't work. A custom kernel or ROM might work...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank's for your reply...!
i have custom rom resurection remix v.5.8.2 but i didnt change the kernel can you explain me how to do that please because i don't know...?
spanpana said:
thank's for your reply...!
i have custom rom resurection remix v.5.8.2 but i didnt change the kernel can you explain me how to do that please because i don't know...?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check your kernel version first (usually found in Settings - About Phone). If it's less than 3.8, ask for help in your device's forum for if there's any custom kernels or ROMs available with an updated kernel.
Didgeridoohan said:
Check your kernel version first (usually found in Settings - About Phone). If it's less than 3.8, ask for help in your device's forum for if there's any custom kernels or ROMs available with an updated kernel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok my friend thank you very much...!:laugh::good:
Didgeridoohan said:
Old device... If the kernel version is lower than 3.8 it'll likely not have support for mount namespace and MagiskHide won't work. A custom kernel or ROM might work...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's interesting. I get the same message on my old phone (running the 3.4.113 kernel), but I'm unable to even open Mario Run if MagiskHide is disabled. But when it's enabled, the game runs just fine. Is that normal? I thought Mario Run made use of SafetyNet... I'm using microG + DroidGuard Helper. I've tried running Android Pay, but I get this error message. But I'm not even sure if Android Pay is supposed to work since I'm using microG... What other apps use SafetyNet so I can try them?
Thanks.
robotsrules said:
That's interesting. I get the same message on my old phone (running the 3.4.113 kernel), but I'm unable to even open Mario Run if MagiskHide is disabled. But when it's enabled, the game runs just fine. Is that normal? I thought Mario Run made use of SafetyNet... I'm using microG + DroidGuard Helper. I've tried running Android Pay, but I get this error message. But I'm not even sure if Android Pay is supposed to work since I'm using microG... What other apps use SafetyNet so I can try them?
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MagiskHide can't do it's thing to hide itself on such an old kernel, but it can still hide sensitive prop values. That's why Mario Run works... IIRC it looks for ro.debuggable, on of the props changed to "safe" values by MagiskHide.
Didgeridoohan said:
MagiskHide can't do it's thing to hide itself on such an old kernel, but it can still hide sensitive prop values. That's why Mario Run works... IIRC it looks for ro.debuggable, on of the props changed to "safe" values by MagiskHide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh, I get it now... Thanks
So there are many apps telling me that I cannot use them due to my phone being rooted. I use magisk hide and I have the app itself hidden, yet all apps still tell me that I'm rooted. I ran a safety net test and my phone did not lass with the error "response payload validation failed". I have the magisk hide props config module, but I have no clue how to use it once I'm in the menu in the terminal. Does anybody know a solution for this? Thanks.
Sounds like your device can't get a proper response from the Google servers. Might be something wrong with your Play services. But, that you can't hide root from other apps also suggests that there's something up with MagiskHide on your device.
But, it's very hard to say anything at all since we know so little about your setup. Take a look here for things to try and what to check for when troubleshooting:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide
Lastly, MagiskHide Props Config won't help unless you already have a working MagiskHide setup.
I just cannot pass safety net whatsoever on magisk on my Moto X XT1053!
I'll start saying I have been on xda for years now and this is my first post, all you guys have helped me so much through the years so I have told myself recently I really need to start posting and being more active on XDA, you guys are way more brilliant than am but I'm slowly learning through the years. My obsession with unlocking and rooting started in 2013 with the Moto X xt1058 at&t unlocked bootloader on that one with sunshine fro Jcase and I was saddened when the phone messed up on me and had to retire it, now recently I found two developer editions an XT1053 and XT1060 , I'm running CM13 on the XT1060 so of course using Super SU on that one, but on the XT1053 the T-Mobile variant my main primary phone I am on stock lollipop 5.1 and unlocked bootloader and rooted running TWRP 2.8.7.0 and everything is great but drives me crazy because I cannot pass the Safety Net Test EVER, I flashed BusyBox ndk from osmosis and before I started I unSU and SuMounted and I uninstalled BusyBox app but I've tried everything, I thought it was because there were remnants of the BusyBox by stericson left in the system/xbin and that maybe that was throwing it off , I really want to stick with Magisk but it's driving me crazy that I cannot figure this out and pass the safety net I've searched the help manual from top to bottom front to back and all the threads and I can't figure it out
@jmac052002
Some basic info is needed:
Does both CTS and basic integrity fail?
Does MagiskHide work at all (test by adding a root app)?
Does your device conform to the basic requirements for MagiskHide to work?
Also, whenever trying to figure things out, it's good to provide logs:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHelp
I just cannot pass safety net whatsoever on magisk 19.0 on my Moto X XT1053!
Hey thanks for quick reply I am sorry I meant to give you that info earlier it fails both and one of the things I had forgotten was about the kernel in the basic requirements I have a 3.4.42, and I haven't posted 10 posts so it won't let me post outside links, I've always known to make questions relevant and not waste people's time is a big part of XDA so I wanted to respect that by not breaking these rules so that's why I have just began finally posting, if I can get the logs to you in another way I have them.
jmac052002 said:
Hey thanks for quick reply I am sorry I meant to give you that info earlier it fails both and one of the things I had forgotten was about the kernel in the basic requirements I have a 3.4.42, and I haven't posted 10 posts so it won't let me post outside links, I've always known to make questions relevant and not waste people's time is a big part of XDA so I wanted to respect that by not breaking these rules so that's why I have just began finally posting, if I can get the logs to you in another way I have them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No need to post anything just yet. Take a look in the log and look for this:
Your kernel doesn't support mount namespace
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you see that there's no point in continuing the troubleshooting, because MagiskHide won't work on your device.
I just cannot pass safety net whatsoever on magisk 19.0 on my Moto X XT1053!
I checked the logs thouroughly and it never states Your kernel doesn't support mount namespace anywhere, so I think that's good news as far as the kernel goes...right?
I'm on the OP6 on latest 9.0.5 and have no issues.
Running stock as well as with nolimits mod. Franco kernel works well too
Do a clean wipe, format data, use latest Bluspark twro 9.96
You shouldn't have any issues
jmac052002 said:
I checked the logs thouroughly and it never states Your kernel doesn't support mount namespace anywhere, so I think that's good news as far as the kernel goes...right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Possibly. You still haven't said anything about testing MagiskHide in general, and we'll need those logs (make sure they're from the Canary debug build).
Cannot pass Safety Net at all on Magisk 19.0 on Moto X XT1053
Sorry about that when I test it on root checker, it comes back that my phone is rooted and I checked my 3c Toolbox pro and it granted it superuser permissions so I'm assuming Magisk hide is not working, I work nights so I had to sleep but I am gonna install the canary bleeding edge and provide logs if it's still not working thanks for all your help so far
Updating on my situation, I realized my phone does indeed pass the safety et check, I forgot to hide the safety net checker. Issue is apps still I have root. I'm using the nintendo apps as a base tester.
Hello? Anyone got any ideas on what to do? Just checking back in.
Hello, so i'm very new and my english is very bad. I'm having trouble to know how to install magisk on my samsung tab e sm t560. I don't know it's extremly complicated and I don't get it. I mean, in the installation process there is written that twrp is needed. So if I go to that post, there is written that root is needed. But how to I root? Isn't Magisk a root? And there isn't a TWRP for my device. I hope you can help me. I've searched for some hours and I've found absolutly nothing.
Thanks
Hello, I hope you can help me with this.
Yesterday I updated to the latest version of the custom rom I'm using (EvolutionX) and I had to flash the zip file manually through recovery since it didn't install automatically.
After that, magisk stopped working correctly, the root of my banking applications is not hidden, as you can see in the images, I have everything hidden and activated correctly (I think), I would appreciate it if you help me with this since the same thing happened to me a long time ago , and not finding a solution I had to do a hard reset and install a new rom.
The bank app says: "this device does not meet the minimum security requirements for this application"
(Sorry for my english, helpe pls)
alesky0903 said:
Hello, I hope you can help me with this.
Yesterday I updated to the latest version of the custom rom I'm using (EvolutionX) and I had to flash the zip file manually through recovery since it didn't install automatically.
After that, magisk stopped working correctly, the root of my banking applications is not hidden, as you can see in the images, I have everything hidden and activated correctly (I think), I would appreciate it if you help me with this since the same thing happened to me a long time ago , and not finding a solution I had to do a hard reset and install a new rom.
The bank app says: "this device does not meet the minimum security requirements for this application"
(Sorry for my english, helpe pls)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, try updating the safety net fix module and also try this
Try Universal SafetyNet Fix 2.4.0 Mod by Displex
remove that old module and install te new one 2.4.0 mod