removed
I preferred Magisk, because it is very stable while does not depend to system.
pol-der said:
Hi All,
Hope you are fine. I have some questions mates. Now i had installed Xposed Framework before Magisk and it is still installed. I realized (from Downloads) Magisk has Xposed Framework module.
Should i uninstall Xposed Framework from phone and install from Magisk?
If yes, why?
If i use Xposed Framework standalone (without Magisk), what is advantages and disadvantages?
Thank you so much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If your current version is working then there is no real reason to change. I have rovo's version 89 and magisk separate on my s8 with no issues. Basically it boils down to personal preference. I like to keep root and exposed separate in case of issues with one or the other. In any case if there are issues with exposed then it will happen on any version that you install.
As I've said it's all a matter of personal preference.
removed
magisk does not have xposed module ?
Related
Hello guys. I'm tempted to install Magisk on my Zenfone 2 ZE551ML. I have the latest CM13 Nightly + Xposed and I want to ask if Magisk has any problem running alongside these two.
Another question is if I can still use the built in CM13 root.
Thanks for your answers!
Im running on CM 13 (ZenFone 2 Laser ZOOL) stable and it works fine.
The only problem is that with xposed active the safetynet check don't pass. But its just a matter of disabling xposed and rebooting when necessary.
I dont know if the differences are too significant, but hope it helps.
FHC1998 said:
Im running on CM 13 (ZenFone 2 Laser ZOOL) stable and it works fine.
The only problem is that with xposed active the safetynet check don't pass. But its just a matter of disabling xposed and rebooting when necessary.
I dont know if the differences are too significant, but hope it helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That means Magisk doesn't work with Xposed ? Or I just have to unninstall Xposed and then install again after installing Magisk ?
PedroCaseiro said:
That means Magisk doesn't work with Xposed ? Or I just have to unninstall Xposed and then install again after installing Magisk ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk itself works perfectly with Xposed installed, only Magisk Hide that doesn't hide Xposed.
So if you don't plan on using any app that checks Safety Net (Pokemon Go, Android Pay, for example) You won't have any problem.
FHC1998 said:
Magisk itself works perfectly with Xposed installed, only Magisk Hide that doesn't hide Xposed.
So if you don't plan on using any app that checks Safety Net (Pokemon Go, Android Pay, for example) You won't have any problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
and what about the built in CM13 root ?
I think the newest Magisk auto removes it when you flash it.
But I had manually removed before installing magisk on mine.
But in any case, if I remember correctly you can just remove it thru the SuperSU app before flashing Magisk.
FHC1998 said:
I think the newest Magisk auto removes it when you flash it.
But I had manually removed before installing magisk on mine.
But in any case, if I remember correctly you can just remove it thru the SuperSU app before flashing Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll try it then and hope not to **** up my phone. Thanks
Sent from my Asus ZenFone 2 using XDA Labs
PedroCaseiro said:
I'll try it then and hope not to **** up my phone. Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem. Just remember to make a nandroid backup first if you are worried.
hi everyone, i just want to know if its possible to make a port from youtube adaway and microOG (from ogyoutube) modules to Magisk i think magisk its the best hide root app snice google becomes too evil with root users (bassically, every xda member)
You can modify the Youtube apk yourself and then use Magisk to replace the stock apk. That's about it...
Magisk and Xposed are two very different modifications to your device and they're NOT interchangeable.
But im talking about modules
Code:
Didgeridoohan said:
You can modify the Youtube apk yourself and then use Magisk to replace the stock apk. That's about it...
Magisk and Xposed are two very different modifications to your device and they're NOT interchangeable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I saw a thread about magisk modules there are a lot of modules like viper and others and the developer do a systemless versión of xposed for magisk, so i think a bit about porting xposed modules itself
The word "modules" is not exclusive to Xposed....
There are certain things that you can do with Xposed that you also can do with Magisk, and vice versa. But (and I repeat), they are very different frameworks and are NOT interchangeable.
angelus_kun said:
hi everyone, i just want to know if its possible to make a port from youtube adaway and microOG (from ogyoutube) modules to Magisk i think magisk its the best hide root app snice google becomes too evil with root users (bassically, every xda member)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk = You want to stay on the stock ROM and only need root and maybe a couple of mods like build.prop additions and you don't want to modify your system partition.
Xposed = Your system is modified and you want more deeper OS level mods like custom ROM features injected into your system with the Xposed bridged framework.
Magisk as of now can't add any special custom ROM features unless you modify a whole apk and use Magisk to systemlessly replace the stock apk with the modified one. There is no injecting code into your system like Xposed.
Oh i got it, thanks
I do not use androidPay or banking apps on my phone because I think it is unwise to do anything financial on a mobile device.
My current ROM is lineageos 14.1 which updates fine with Xposed framework installed. So I don't have to deal with stock ota updates.
For someone like me, on a custom rom, that does not use androidPay or banking apps on a phone, is there any advantage to switching from regular Xposed to systemless xposed?
maybeme2 said:
... For someone like me, on a custom rom, that does not use androidPay or banking apps on a phone, is there any advantage to switching from regular Xposed to systemless xposed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you don't care very much about system/less installation of zips because you're on a custom rom, maybe the only advantage is that systemless xposed is easier to remove if you end up in a bootloop or if you have other kind of problems.
Also, disabling magisk will disable xposed (again, in case of problems).
So, I think the main benefit is this. I tested when I was on Oreo (now I'm on P beta) and yes, in case of bootloop or crashes, disabling xposed modules or systemless xposed in magisk is like a life saver sometimes.
maybeme2 said:
I do not use androidPay or banking apps on my phone because I think it is unwise to do anything financial on a mobile device.
My current ROM is lineageos 14.1 which updates fine with Xposed framework installed. So I don't have to deal with stock ota updates.
For someone like me, on a custom rom, that does not use androidPay or banking apps on a phone, is there any advantage to switching from regular Xposed to systemless xposed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Personally I don't"t think it matters. I am using s8 stock noughat 7.0 rom using rovo"s xposed ver 89 and magisk 16.4 with no issues.
From my understanding reading the op for systemless xposed it's basically Rovo"s version ported to be installed through magisk. So what ever problems you have with one version you would have with the other (app wise that is).
Either version does not pass safety net and can effect play store certification.
I am currently running about 10 exposed apps + about 13 root apps at the moment.
At the end of the day I think it would be a personal choice as to which you choose to use.
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S8 using XDA Labs
maybeme2 said:
I do not use androidPay or banking apps on my phone because I think it is unwise to do anything financial on a mobile device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pfff... Get with the times, Grandpa!
ldeveraux said:
Pfff... Get with the times, Grandpa!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what a wired desktop is for. But, you go ahead.
maybeme2 said:
That's what a wired desktop is for. But, you go ahead.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you think what a wired desktop is more secure than your android/IOS device nowdays? ALL the OSs have their own compromises and malware, specially desktop OSs.
Hi guys. I'm about to get this phone soon so coming from s9 plus (rootedwith xposed framework on android 8.0) I was wondering what's the status on this phone as far as xposed framework is concerned?
I don't see much people talking about it for this phone.
A few modules are a must have for me to the point of losing OTA or not having the latest OS doesn't bother me.
Modules I use:
Chromepie
Chrome selection patch
Exi for swiftkey
Undo
Wifi password
Gesture Navigation
Xposed edge pro
Text Aide.
omar.abbas said:
Hi guys. I'm about to get this phone soon so coming from s9 plus (rootedwith xposed framework on android 8.0) I was wondering what's the status on this phone as far as xposed framework is concerned?
I don't see much people talking about it for this phone.
A few modules are a must have for me to the point of losing OTA or not having the latest OS doesn't bother me.
Modules I use:
Chromepie
Chrome selection patch
Exi for swiftkey
Undo
Wifi password
Gesture Navigation
Xposed edge pro
Text Aide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I recently gave EdXposed a try and it worked just fine. I only wanted it for gravity box and most of the functionality there worked without issues.
I can't speak for the rest of the modules but this phone is almost entirely AOSP so most should work.
gilsol said:
I recently gave EdXposed a try and it worked just fine. I only wanted it for gravity box and most of the functionality there worked without issues.
I can't speak for the rest of the modules but this phone is almost entirely AOSP so most should work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you use magisk to install it as a magisk module?
When I search for edxposed on magisk I see two versions I'm wondering which one to go with.
omar.abbas said:
Did you use magisk to install it as a magisk module?
When I search for edxposed on magisk I see two versions I'm wondering which one to go with.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's a dedicated thread for this from the magisk module info page. First install Riru core and then one of the 2 Riru edexposed modules. They differ in implementation. I used Sandhook method.
Xprivacy Lua doesn't seem to be working on Android 11 AOSP based custom ROM.
Installed using LSposed.
App ops also doesn't seem to be working.
Any workaround?
Sjain11 said:
Xprivacy Lua doesn't seem to be working on Android 11 AOSP based custom ROM.
Installed using LSposed.
App ops also doesn't seem to be working.
Any workaround?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you explain more as to what is not working.
Device and what rom your using may help.
How have you setup lsposed. If you are going to set restriction in xpl for all apps have you selected all apps in lsposed.
What app ops are you using as wasn't aware it an exposed module.
spawnlives said:
Can you explain more as to what is not working.
Device and what rom your using may help.
How have you setup lsposed. If ypu are going to set restriction in xpl for all apps have you selected all apps in lsposed.
What app ops are you using as wasn't aware it an exposed module.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow thanks. Selecting all apps in LSposed worked.
Hi, I just had the same problem and found this thread and resolved the issue, thanks!
Question: Is there a way to default so that new apps are automatically selected when installed?
markd89 said:
Hi, I just had the same problem and found this thread and resolved the issue, thanks!
Question: Is there a way to default so that new apps are automatically selected when installed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On LSposed no.
Any new app will have to be enabled in LSposed for xprivacylua to work.
I don't think that option will be included any time soon, if at all.
spawnlives said:
On LSposed no.
Any new app will have to be enabled in LSposed for xprivacylua to work.
I don't think that option will be included any time soon, if at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think that's an important capablilty, otherwise things will leak on first run.
I tried installed Edxposed but get this issue please install riru from magisk manager
The comments on that issue say Edxposed is not longer supported ant to use LSPosed, Taichi or Dreamland instead. Does Taichi or Dreamland allow for new apps to default to be restricted?
Thanks again!
markd89 said:
I think that's an important capablilty, otherwise things will leak on first run.
I tried installed Edxposed but get this issue please install riru from magisk manager
The comments on that issue say Edxposed is not longer supported ant to use LSPosed, Taichi or Dreamland instead. Does Taichi or Dreamland allow for new apps to default to be restricted?
Thanks again!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want to use Edxposed you will have to downgrade Rui core module ( in magisk ) to version under 25. I think the latest working version was 25.5.5 ( from memory ).
As for Taichi, Dreamland and other Xposed like frameworks i don't know never used them.
I have be using Xposed since the Jellybean ( android 4 ) and have only install rovo's version ( up to android 8 ), then started using Edxposed ( currently on now ). The only reason i'm not using Lsposed at the moment is laziness on my part because of the extra steps involved.
Note: not all modules will require every app in Lsposed to be activated it will depend on what the module does.
@spawnlives thank you!
I got Edxposed working with Riru 25.4.4 https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/releases/tag/v25.4.4
To use XprivacyLua on Android 11 - Which one should I get ?
Edxposed or Lsposed ?
JazonX said:
To use XprivacyLua on Android 11 - Which one should I get ?
Edxposed or Lsposed ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Depends on magisk version
I am using stable magisk with latest versions of riu and lsposed.
Lsposed with modules you have to select what apps to restrict.
Big thanks to @Fif_ for automatic selecting modules.
Edxpoesd has two modes but you have to downgrade riu module for it it work.
With regards to expricavylua working fine on stable magisk /latest versions of riu/lsposed on S9 running lineage 18.1 (A11).
spawnlives said:
Depends on magisk version
I am using stable magisk with latest versions of riu and lsposed.
Lsposed with modules you have to select what apps to restrict.
Big thanks to @Fif_ for automatic selecting modules.
Edxpoesd has two modes but you have to downgrade riu module for it it work.
With regards to expricavylua working fine on stable magisk /latest versions of riu/lsposed on S9 running lineage 18.1 (A11).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For reference the post about automatically adding newly installed apps to LSPosed scopes is here:
LSPosed Xposed Framework [8.1-13.0]. Simple Magisk Module
Developers: LSPosed Developers Homepage: GitHub ✱ Requirements: • Magisk 21+ • Android 8.1-13 • Riru(NOT NEEDED) USE ZYGISK Description: Riru module providing ART interception framework (natively for Android Pie) that provides consistent API...
forum.xda-developers.com
markd89 said:
@spawnlives thank you!
I got Edxposed working with Riru 25.4.4 https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/releases/tag/v25.4.4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
JazonX said:
To use XprivacyLua on Android 11 - Which one should I get ?
Edxposed or Lsposed ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
spawnlives said:
Depends on magisk version
I am using stable magisk with latest versions of riu and lsposed.
Lsposed with modules you have to select what apps to restrict.
Big thanks to @Fif_ for automatic selecting modules.
Edxpoesd has two modes but you have to downgrade riu module for it it work.
With regards to expricavylua working fine on stable magisk /latest versions of riu/lsposed on S9 running lineage 18.1 (A11).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As stated in post #8 EdXposed is also working with stable Magisk v23.0, but only using Riru 25.4.4 and lower. Advantage for me is that I don't have to add new apps to the scope like in Lsposed. Even with Fif's Automate flow, I would forget to reboot