Pixel 4/4XL Brightness - Google Pixel 4 XL Questions & Answers

I am hearing in reviews that the brightness is not that great, barely visible in direct sun.
That was one of the only things that really bothered me on the Pixel 3. Looks like
its a repeat on the 4! Anyone know the max brightness in nits?
CC

I just found this:
The Pixel 4 XL display appears Perfectly Sharp for normal 20/20 Vision at Typical Smartphone Viewing Distances of 12 to 18 inches (30 to 46 cm). A Full Screen Peak Brightness of 444 nits. That is horrible!
CC

That's better than this POS 6T I am using now...I suppose a HBM could fix that

Its basically identical to the 3 XL. Tried then side by side at Best Buy.

uicnren said:
Its basically identical to the 3 XL. Tried then side by side at Best Buy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There was bright sunlight inside Best Buy???

Max Brightness
bitwiser said:
There was bright sunlight inside Best Buy???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From Displaymate:
The Pixel 3 XL has a 100% APL Calibrated Full Screen Brightness of 405 nits for the Calibrated Color Gamuts, which improves screen visibility in high Ambient Light. On its Home Screen the Pixel 3 XL produces 424 nits.
So it's true the max brightness is the same on the Pixel 4. Thats a deal breaker for me. And also pathetic max brightness.
It doesn't matter if you are looking at it in Best Buy in the sunlight or not, max brightness is max brightness.
Here is what the iphone 11's do, The iPhone 11 Pro also features a new 800 nits max brightness (typical); 1200 nits max brightness (HDR) display. This compares to the 625 nits max brightness (typical) display of the iPhone 11. I can tell you side by side the iphone 11 at 625 nits is way brighter than the Pixel 4. The Pro will be even more of a difference. Go to Best Buy and see for yourself. I always struggled
to see the Pixel 3XL in direct sunlight and was hoping for a brighter display this year
CC

That's barely better than the 438 nits on the Pixel 2 XL but I rarely have issues seeing the screen in directly. And I live in the sunshine state. It would be nice if it got bursts of brightness like 800+ but guess what, that would make for an even worse battery. And I'm sure the Pixel 4 XL is going to be far from a battery champ.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

EeZeEpEe said:
That's barely better than the 438 nits on the Pixel 2 XL but I rarely have issues seeing the screen in directly. And I live in the sunshine state. It would be nice if it got bursts of brightness like 800+ but guess what, that would make for an even worse battery. And I'm sure the Pixel 4 XL is going to be far from a battery champ.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
More like a battery chump!

ZeroKool76 said:
That's better than this POS 6T I am using now...I suppose a HBM could fix that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But not as good as the 7T (have both and compared side by side).

EeZeEpEe said:
That's barely better than the 438 nits on the Pixel 2 XL but I rarely have issues seeing the screen in directly. And I live in the sunshine state. It would be nice if it got bursts of brightness like 800+ but guess what, that would make for an even worse battery. And I'm sure the Pixel 4 XL is going to be far from a battery champ.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Still, it would be great if Google actually gave me the option of prioritizing screen brightness over battery life (which isn't a real concern for me, since I'm close to my charger basically 24/7).

hthiengo said:
Still, it would be great if Google actually gave me the option of prioritizing screen brightness over battery life (which isn't a real concern for me, since I'm close to my charger basically 24/7).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree with choice. Like the Pixel 4 is totally capable of 4K 60 FPS on the rear and I would thing at least 4K 30 FPS on the front yet it's saying most users just use 1080p. They kind of force that to be common with 1080p being the default size.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

There may be hope.
https://twitter.com/MishaalRahman/status/1187093806677680128?s=19

crusht said:
There may be hope.
https://twitter.com/MishaalRahman/status/1187093806677680128?s=19
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That makes sense since HDR does need a high brightness requirement.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

I haven't really tried using it in direct sunlight yet.
Sent from my Pixel 4 XL using Tapatalk

Has anyone tried the High brightness app on the pixel 4 xl yet? It might make the difference of someone purchasing the phone. I use it on the OP7 pro and it makes a huge difference.

equlizer said:
Has anyone tried the High brightness app on the pixel 4 xl yet? It might make the difference of someone purchasing the phone. I use it on the OP7 pro and it makes a huge difference.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That depends if it's a Samsung panel or not

Reuben_skelz92 said:
That depends if it's a Samsung panel or not
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's made by Samsung:
https://www.google.com/amp/s/9to5google.com/2019/10/24/pixel-4-xl-teardown-samsung-display/amp/

Related

[Q] How bright is the screen?

I like every aspect of nexus 6
but i'm a bit worried about the brightness of the screen
since AMOLED are kind of infamous for not able to use outdoor
I'm guessing the screen will be similar to Moto X 2014
Anyone who own the phone, can you please share the experience for using the phone under bright sun?
MrHardplastic said:
I like every aspect of nexus 6
but i'm a bit worried about the brightness of the screen
since AMOLED are kind of infamous for not able to use outdoor
I'm guessing the screen will be similar to Moto X 2014
Anyone who own the phone, can you please share the experience for using the phone under bright sun?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the important question. This year's AMOLED's (Galaxy S5, Note 4, Tab S) were very bright... but last year's AMOLED's (Galaxy S4).. not so much. Note 3 was fine however.
some review says moto X 2014 has poor outdoor visibility
and according to phonearena screen measurement, the moto X only has a maximum brightness of 385 nits
Now i'm seriously worried about the N6.....
I will accept anything higher than 450 nits, but 385 nits is just way too low
btw, I always never understood why maximum brightness is not part of the standard specs, it's an important factor, sometimes it's more important than pixel density or color saturation
While I will take all the brightness I can get, I have only struggled a few times with my S4 outdoors. I just don't use my phone all that much in full sunlight. Maybe check a football score during my kid's soccer game. Not exactly mission critical, but I guess it would be nice if it were easier. I certainly wouldn't give up the superior blacks the other 99.99% of the time. But given the awesome screens on the latest Samsungs, we should be able to have our cake and eat it, too.
Sent from my GT-I9505G using Tapatalk
It's about this bright [emoji295]️[emoji295]️[emoji295]️
Its brightness is 270 nits (quite dim when you go by the numbers)
While its 850+ on my z3!
I guess I won't be selling my z3 for a n6 after all!
As with most single specs, the luminance in nits only tells part of the story. I'll wait to see what the N6 screen looks like in full sun before making a final decision.
gtalum said:
As with most single specs, the luminance in nits only tells part of the story. I'll wait to see what the N6 screen looks like in full sun before making a final decision.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Very true. Amoled screen have very different reflective properties when compared to an LCD IPS screen. The outdoor viewing experience could and should actually be really good based on all the reviews.
Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk
gtalum said:
As with most single specs, the luminance in nits only tells part of the story. I'll wait to see what the N6 screen looks like in full sun before making a final decision.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
scandalousk said:
Very true. Amoled screen have very different reflective properties when compared to an LCD IPS screen. The outdoor viewing experience could and should actually be really good based on all the reviews.
Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Based on reviews the screen looks less vivid, less sharp and more dull than the Note 4. The visibility is less also; many reviewers claim the screen has great PPI but overall is not amazing. No surprises here - Samsung saves the best screens for themselves and everyone else gets rejects. For that reason I would've used an IPS display, like the iPhone 6+ (which has great visibility in sunlight, sharp and good colours).
spartanm99 said:
Based on reviews the screen looks less vivid, less sharp and more dull than the Note 4. The visibility is less also; many reviewers claim the screen has great PPI but overall is not amazing. No surprises here - Samsung saves the best screens for themselves and everyone else gets rejects. For that reason I would've used an IPS display, like the iPhone 6+ (which has great visibility in sunlight, sharp and good colours).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If that's the case then Google clearly chose the ambient display (which requires amoled) over an IPS display. The note 4 arguably has the best screen in the world and we don't don't know if Google could get their hands on the iPhone 6 display. Maybe they tried and still couldn't get it.
Google can still calibrate the display properly. We'll just have to wait and see.
Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk
scandalousk said:
If that's the case then Google clearly chose the ambient display (which requires amoled) over an IPS display. The note 4 arguably has the best screen in the world and we don't don't know if Google could get their hands on the iPhone 6 display. Maybe they tried and still couldn't get it.
Google can still calibrate the display properly. We'll just have to wait and see.
Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We can also, you know...Make calibrations ourselves as well once Custom Kernels make their rounds..
If colour reproduction is an issue we should have little to worry if we can modify it in due time.
Here's how to find out - go look at one yourself before purchase.
darkrai said:
Its brightness is 270 nits (quite dim when you go by the numbers)
While its 850+ on my z3!
I guess I won't be selling my z3 for a n6 after all!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are going to have to post a source for that, because I dont believe the Z3 has 850nit brightness at all. A quick Google search showed nothing of the sort either.
EniGmA1987 said:
You are going to have to post a source for that, because I dont believe the Z3 has 850nit brightness at all. A quick Google search showed nothing of the sort either.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://m.gsmarena.com/sony_xperia_z3-review-1140p3.php
Go to display section
As a Nexus 4 user, i really love this screen! Its screen colors are like bundis ip5 profile (screen color tuning) with even more whiter whites and superb brightness!
Google for nexus 6
Had to search a lot for nexus 6's
Dr Faustus said:
We can also, you know...Make calibrations ourselves as well once Custom Kernels make their rounds..
If colour reproduction is an issue we should have little to worry if we can modify it in due time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i am happy this was answered so i didn't have to make a post just to make sure. i know i have options for dpi and auto brighness controls on my gs2. but i have to wonder why they set it so low in the first place? was it for battery savings? is it because the reflectivity is so good that it didn't need to be higher? is it because it will burn out the organics? if the gs3, 290 nits, was good enough to see outside then i guess this one will be also. it just sucks that it is so low. and i don't know if i would want to trust a kernel that raised it.
darkrai said:
http://m.gsmarena.com/sony_xperia_z3-review-1140p3.php
Go to display section
As a Nexus 4 user, i really love this screen! Its screen colors are like bundis ip5 profile (screen color tuning) with even more whiter whites and superb brightness!
Google for nexus 6
Had to search a lot for nexus 6's
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sony smarthones have the worst display ever. turn off bravia engine (contrast and vivid) and you will love motorola 720i ;P
PhoneArena state the Nexus 6 is 270nits.
& the Nexus 5 is 485nits
Yet, I'm pretty sure we've seen both phones on Max brightness next to each other with the Nexus 6 being brighter.
In fact, every video I've seen with both the Nexus 6 & Note 4 has shown the Nexus to have the brighter screen with much better whites.
.....explain!?
chrisjcks said:
brighter screen with much better whites.
.....explain!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Much better whites? Yes I think so. Brighter? Where on earth did you see it brighter than note 4? Please share a link?
Thanks
plasmastate said:
Much better whites? Yes I think so. Brighter? Where on earth did you see it brighter than note 4? Please share a link?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Every video I've seen with both phones together.
If the Nexus 6 is supposed to only be 270nits, how is this possible?
I've also seen an image of the Nexus 5 & 6 together on Max brightness with the 6 being brighter.
Nexus 5 is 485 nits so PhoneArenas 270nits claim makes no sense at all.
Even in PhoneArenas own video, the Nexus looks brighter than the Note 4, easily visible during browsing & the video benchmark etc.
Google Nexus 6 vs Samsung Galaxy Note 4: http://youtu.be/afOEn-zm_y0
It's funny because when I was playing with the Note 4 in a Sprint store I was surprised to learn that the screen was at full brightness. It didn't seem all that bright to me.

Nexus 6's display compared to Note 4?

Is the AMOLED screen on the nexus 6 going to be the latest generation AMOLED screen?
If it's not the latest Note 4 screen, and looks something like the Note 3, then I'm not going to be a big fan of the screen... Are there any reviews on the display yet?
Chances of it matching Note 4 display are very slim. Samsung will of course keep its best panels for itself, like in the past.
Sigh, I wish note 4 had a stock Android option then...
Android police says that the 6 is even dimmer at first glance than the X. Not that it should matter in realy world readability and color accuracy, but I suspect that Note 4 would win out on quality.
floepie said:
Android police says that the 6 is even dimmer at first glance than the X. Not that it should matter in realy world readability and color accuracy, but I suspect that Note 4 would win out on quality.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Liam, of Android Police was referring to the minimum brightness level between the two devices. As far as max brightness is concern, he stated that the device was brighter than the Nexus 5 as shown in the first attachment
journeyman73 said:
Liam, of Android Police was referring to the minimum brightness level between the two devices. As far as max brightness is concern, he stated that the device was brighter than the Nexus 5 as shown in the first attachment
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is superb news! The N5 screen gets very bright IMO and am happy to see the N6 outdoes it
jbdan said:
This is superb news! The N5 screen gets very bright IMO and am happy to see the N6 outdoes it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol, that's only in the dark. It appears that the N5 gets dimmer.
Note 4 Vs Nexus 6
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=56143803&postcount=39
We are talking AMOLED vs Super AMOLED... From what I've heard, S-AMOLED keeps all of the advantages of LCD displays when it comes to the outdoors... I'm expecting the N6's display to be a tad better than the Galaxy Note 3, but definitively not on par with the Note 4...
iZack187 said:
We are talking AMOLED vs Super AMOLED... From what I've heard, S-AMOLED keeps all of the advantages of LCD displays when it comes to the outdoors... I'm expecting the N6's display to be a tad better than the Galaxy Note 3, but definitively not on par with the Note 4...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pretty sure that Super AMOLED is just a trademarked name by Samsung. Probably not much difference at all between one or the other as far as technology goes.
Super amoled is just samsung copyright. ...but is a little different they put a anti glare film between the digitizer and glass ....
Watch the Engadget hands on review. The screen appears to get very bright. He is in a well lit area too that usually washes out a screen.
There was a comparison video that showed max brightness of moto x (2014), nexus 5, nexus 6, and galaxy s5. The nexus 6 was not as bright as the galaxy s5, but brighter than the nexus 5 and moto x.
Yeah, it's plenty bright. I'm not worried about the screen at all at this point. My only concern is will I be able to get it from VZW and it still be able to unlock the bootloader. The Nexus 6 is all about the development available on top of being a super phone all in all.
I've noticed first impression articles-videos mention that the Note 4 display colors are more "punchy" (perhaps more color satured by default) but the Nexus 6 (while the handset is only marginally larger) is described as big & beautiful with superior speakers-overall performance.
This video showed up Nov 4 in case missed:
Ref: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vj4wRSx55wY
Ref: http://cdn.gottabemobile.com/wp-content/uploads/Nexus6vsNote4-2-620x412.jpg
SMARTPHONEPC said:
I've noticed first impression articles-videos mention that the Note 4 display colors are more "punchy" (perhaps more color satured by default)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well there's no point unless he sets the screen mode to Basic on the note 4
SMARTPHONEPC said:
I've noticed first impression articles-videos mention that the Note 4 display colors are more "punchy" (perhaps more color satured by default) but the Nexus 6 (while the handset is only marginally larger) is described as big & beautiful with superior speakers-overall performance.
This video showed up Nov 4 in case missed:
Ref: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vj4wRSx55wY
Ref: http://cdn.gottabemobile.com/wp-content/uploads/Nexus6vsNote4-2-620x412.jpg
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do we know if those are on Max Brightness or auto brightness?
As the Nexus 6 definitely looks brighter.
iamhacked said:
Well there's no point unless he sets the screen mode to Basic on the note 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd assume they are both on their default screen modes. Even on my Note 2, I have played with the other screen modes briefly but they seem more dull than the default standard mode.
---------- Post added at 09:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:58 PM ----------
chrisjcks said:
Do we know if those are on Max Brightness or auto brightness?
As the Nexus 6 definitely looks brighter.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In that video at http://www.gottabemobile.com/2014/11/04/nexus-6-vs-galaxy-note-4-size-comparison/ I'd assume they are both on their respective max brightness (not auto brightness).
From my long post at http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=56143803&postcount=39 I think the Nexus 6 may actually be brighter on max brightness (>400 nits) while the Note4 in direct sunlight may be worth switching to auto-brightness since according to http://www.androidbeat.com/2014/09/displaymate-praises-galaxy-note4-amoled-display-performance/ max brightness could go from 400 nits up to 750 nits:
"On the brightness side, the Galaxy Note 4’s AMOLED display can go as bright as up to 400 nits in manual mode, which is comparable to displays of the same size. Under Automatic Brightness mode though, the Note 4’s display can reach a brightness level of up to 750 nits. Even the minimum brightness levels of the display is an impressively low 2 nits.
The Reflectance score of 4.8% indicates that the Note 4’s display will be clearly visible even under direct sunlight without the need for the user to squint their eyes."
The following screenshot at 40 seconds from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Fn8OnzDO5Y indicates they were both on max brightness (auto brightness not checked on Note 4):
Ref: http://i61.tinypic.com/105bayx.jpg
Ref: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Fn8OnzDO5Y (Nexus 6 vs Note 4 comparison outdoors on max brightness-but auto brightness not checked where the Note 4 is claimed to go from max manual 400 nits to 750 nits)
Ref: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vj4wRSx55wY (Nexus 6 vs Note 4 comparison indoors with unknown brightness levels but assumed they were set to same manual max brightness)

Did you come from Nexus 6p?

I currently have a 6p and it´s not performing to full potential anymore, and i want to upgrade soon..... Did any of you go from 6p to opt3?
This phone performs 100 times better, so glad I sold the Nexus 6p to buy it.
Yes, my nexus6P died because he bootloop, I bought a oneplus3T, it was a great device, I like him.
Yes, I sold my RMA 6P because of battery issues. The OP3T is much, much faster than the 6P, it's like lightning compared to it. Battery life is also much better, I get around 6.30hrs SOT compared to the 4+on the 6P. The OP3T is let down by its screen, I find the 1080 pentile screen quite ugly and I can see it grainy compared to the 6P. I also find the 6P camera to be better especially in low light. So there are pluses and minuses to both phones.
I also jumped ship 2 days a go. So far i really love it, it looks much better and i really love the fingerprint scanner at the front..
It indeed performs much better and battery seems to be much better as well. Cameraman the won't be as good as the Nexus but it won't be a huge difference. I haven't compared them myself though. So far I'm trying some roms to see which one i like the most. The screen is just great, nice colours as well. 1080p is a plus for a mobile device, the screens are way too small to see the difference between a qhd screen. And a qhd screen consumes a lot of battery.
Sent from my du_oneplus3 using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Pollie81 said:
I also jumped ship 2 days a go. So far i really love it, it looks much better and i really love the fingerprint scanner at the front..
It indeed performs much better and battery seems to be much better as well. Cameraman the won't be as good as the Nexus but it won't be a huge difference. I haven't compared them myself though. So far I'm trying some roms to see which one i like the most. The screen is just great, nice colours as well. 1080p is a plus for a mobile device, the screens are way too small to see the difference between a qhd screen. And a qhd screen consumes a lot of battery.
Sent from my du_oneplus3 using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Modern day QHD screens don't use anymore battery than poor quality 1080 panels. It's a myth. The modern Samsung QHD panels use less power now than the poor quality 1080 panels used in the OP3. The S7 Edge can easily get over 7hours SOT and that's comparable to the OP3.
B3501 said:
Modern day QHD screens don't use anymore battery than poor quality 1080 panels. It's a myth. The modern Samsung QHD panels use less power now than the poor quality 1080 panels used in the OP3. The S7 Edge can easily get over 7hours SOT and that's comparable to the OP3.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If the screen itself consume less power its another thing. But the GPU has to work more on a QHD panel.
Migdilu said:
If the screen itself consume less power its another thing. But the GPU has to work more on a QHD panel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That affects performance then, not battery drain. As I said, the S7 Edge has similar battery drain to the 3T and that's a QHD display.
B3501 said:
That affects performance then, not battery drain. As I said, the S7 Edge has similar battery drain to the 3T and that's a QHD display.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Depends on the gpu behavior. It probably will affect battery drain because the GPU will work harder to get nice performance, it will affect performance in heavy tasks for the GPU, like heavy games. But its always affecting battery, not too much of course, but it does.
Also, I repeat, maybe the panel uses less power, that is a different thing.
I have both, but iam using oneplu3t more now borh have their profs and cons cam is no comperison on n6p much better fingerprint accuracy and placing on the back and stereo speakers goes to 6p
Speed bettery life screen is no issue here on 3t nothrotling build quality 6 gigs ram so here what ithink if the cam were good like 6p itwould be clear winner
I have both, i bought 1+ 3t recently and im using it as my daily driver, but im missing the stereo speakers and the camera performance, otherwise, the battery and phone performace is outstanding...i may return back to nexus 6p due to better development foundation
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
I'm in between selling my 6p and waiting for the 3t to ship. I'm jumping because of main board and software issues and do not want to be stuck with a dead out of warranty phone. I will miss the speakers for sure and am a little concerned about the camera. Is it isolated or across the board slow?
Sent from my LG-H820 using Tapatalk
kenhicg said:
I'm in between selling my 6p and waiting for the 3t to ship. I'm jumping because of main board and software issues and do not want to be stuck with a dead out of warranty phone. I will miss the speakers for sure and am a little concerned about the camera. Is it isolated or across the board slow?
Sent from my LG-H820 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The camera isn't slow, it just takes poorer quality photos than the 6P. It's fast when taking them though.
B3501 said:
The camera isn't slow, it just takes poorer quality photos than the 6P. It's fast when taking them though.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would have thought it would be better. How much worse is it?
Sent from my LG-H820 using Tapatalk
kenhicg said:
I would have thought it would be better. How much worse is it?
Sent from my LG-H820 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's struggles in low light and also struggles in general to focus. In bright light it's decent. The 6P is a better camera overall.
B3501 said:
It's struggles in low light and also struggles in general to focus. In bright light it's decent. The 6P is a better camera overall.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well that kind of sucks but oh well.
Sent from my LG-H820 using Tapatalk

Should I upgrade?

I have a Pixel 3 XL. Should I upgrade to the 4 XL? I love my phone, don't really care about the 90hz display, don't care about soli or face unlock. I do like the lack of the notch but my real reason would be the battery life. Has anyone went from the 3 XL to the 4 XL and noticed an improvement in battery? I know opinions are subjective but do the 200Mah increase in battery and new processer make a good impact on battery life? Any opinions or insight are greatly appreciated!
Droidvzw said:
I have a Pixel 3 XL. Should I upgrade to the 4 XL? I love my phone, don't really care about the 90hz display, don't care about soli or face unlock. I do like the lack of the notch but my real reason would be the battery life. Has anyone went from the 3 XL to the 4 XL and noticed an improvement in battery? I know opinions are subjective but do the 200Mah increase in battery and new processer make a good impact on battery life? Any opinions or insight are greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No point upgrading
Droidvzw said:
I have a Pixel 3 XL. Should I upgrade to the 4 XL? I love my phone, don't really care about the 90hz display, don't care about soli or face unlock. I do like the lack of the notch but my real reason would be the battery life. Has anyone went from the 3 XL to the 4 XL and noticed an improvement in battery? I know opinions are subjective but do the 200Mah increase in battery and new processer make a good impact on battery life? Any opinions or insight are greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did, but only because after one year, I got a REALLY good trade value for the 3XL and the 4XL was $200 off. (do not trade-in at Google) For about the first week I had it, I was jonesing for my old fingerprint sensor. Then face unlock got really good. Eerily good, like if I look at my phone on the stand or even laying flat on my desk, it unlocks. Screen is absolutely gorgeous and sharp as a tack. As for battery, I think the 4 is slightly better. With the 3 after 12 hours at work, I would be down to 20% on average, sometimes less. With the 4 that is now averaging mid-30's. Scientific.... no, but after using the 4 for 4 solid months it is never as low as the 3.. Could be the 3 was a year old... could be my 4 had 106% batttery capacity (Accubattery) when I bought it, but on measure it feels a bit. Should boil down to money. If you can sell your 3 and get a $200 deal or better off the 4 then go for it. If you are looking to just trade into Google and get boned on price, then I would wait for deep discounts when the 4a's arrive. Hope this helps.
v12xke said:
I did, but only because after one year, I got a REALLY good trade value for the 3XL and the 4XL was $200 off. (do not trade-in at Google) For about the first week I had it, I was jonesing for my old fingerprint sensor. Then face unlock got really good. Eerily good, like if I look at my phone on the stand or even laying flat on my desk, it unlocks. Screen is absolutely gorgeous and sharp as a tack. As for battery, I think the 4 is slightly better. With the 3 after 12 hours at work, I would be down to 20% on average, sometimes less. With the 4 that is now averaging mid-30's. Scientific.... no, but after using the 4 for 4 solid months it is never as low as the 3.. Could be the 3 was a year old... could be my 4 had 106% batttery capacity (Accubattery) when I bought it, but on measure it feels a bit. Should boil down to money. If you can sell your 3 and get a $200 deal or better off the 4 then go for it. If you are looking to just trade into Google and get boned on price, then I would wait for deep discounts when the 4a's arrive. Hope this helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Extremely helpful, thank you!
I get better on the 4XL but it's not a big difference. In both cases turning off AOD added 30ish minutes of screen; they really need to improve on that. I otherwise have everything on both now and then and end up around 4 to 5 hours on an average day of mixed use which is about 30 more than before with the 3XL. For me this is good enough since phones charge so quickly nowadays and I'm usually by an outlet and otherwise have a 10k brick in my messenger bag when I'm going to be flying and that sort of thing. Not that I wouldn't take more but I can work with what that.
krabman said:
I get better on the 4XL but it's not a big difference. In both cases turning off AOD added 30ish minutes of screen; they really need to improve on that. I otherwise have everything on both now and then and end up around 4 to 5 hours on an average day of mixed use which is about 30 more than before with the 3XL. For me this is good enough since phones charge so quickly nowadays and I'm usually by an outlet and otherwise have a 10k brick in my messenger bag when I'm going to be flying and that sort of thing. Not that I wouldn't take more but I can work with what that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I saw on YouTube pixel 4 xl last about 6-7 hours of screen on time!! Mixed use of mobile data and wifi.
Adaptive brightness!! I
Is it fake?
I had pixel 2 xl but unfortunately the touch screen stopped working.
I am considering buying pixel 4 xl or S20
But I am afraid not liking the camera of s20
mhd1st said:
I saw on YouTube pixel 4 xl last about 6-7 hours of screen on time!! Mixed use of mobile data and wifi.
Adaptive brightness!! I
Is it fake?
I had pixel 2 xl but unfortunately the touch screen stopped working.
I am considering buying pixel 4 xl or S20
But I am afraid not liking the camera of s20
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can get screen on of 10 hours or screen on of 2 hours, it's entirely based upon your usage which no one else will be able to match
If you can wait for Pixel 4a - Pixel 5 or take it now its helf price [emoji1750]
تم الإرسال من Pixel 4 XL باستخدام Tapatalk
I upgraded from the 3XL and never regretted it. It's the last Google flagship for a while at least, so if you find a good deal, go for it! Battery is slightly better, but the overall experience is way better in my opinion, although these things are very subjective.
PS: You don't have to put up with the notch by the way. Use the settings in Developer Options to cover it.
mhd1st said:
I saw on YouTube pixel 4 xl last about 6-7 hours of screen on time!! Mixed use of mobile data and wifi.
Adaptive brightness!! I
Is it fake?
I had pixel 2 xl but unfortunately the touch screen stopped working.
I am considering buying pixel 4 xl or S20
But I am afraid not liking the camera of s20
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've no idea if that is true or not; people have lots of different usage cases and will get different screen times. I tend to run at the bottom of the pack with every phone I own, I like to use my toys so I don't turn much of anything off and have a smartwatch and other devices constantly in use. It isn't really surprising that I dont do as well as the ordinary owner.
I've got to agree with the fellow above though, the 4XL is significantly better in use. It isn't any one thing I'd point at, everything is a little step better. If the phone had been released at mid range pricing to match it's rather modest spec it would have been the hottest phone of 19 and had rave reviews.

Pixel 5 display looks washed out?

Hi.
I've just got my Pixel 5, coming from a Pixel 2 (non-XL).
It's very much noticeable straight away and even more so side by side...Is the Pixel 5 display a lot warmer/paler/washed out?
Greys especially are a lot lighter compared to the dark greys of my Pixel 2...colours less deep (tried both phones on Natural, Boosted and Adaptive/saturated)...it's almost like the Pixel 2 has more blue in the display maybe? It's a lot cooler and easier to look at/see things.
A great example is using the Youtube Music app...well, here's a selection of pics demonstrating...
https://imgur.com/a/xujV3zJ
The difference is really obvious on the first, second and third pictures, less obvious on red screens (pic 5), but in the last couple of pics there's major differences on the reference picture on natural or boosted setting...
Yeah I dunno if I'm just being funny and noticing the differences but...yeah it just feels really disjointed every time I look at the screen...
Thanks
p.s. when I take a screenshot on both phones the colours look mostly similar when viewed on a PC so it's definitely to do with the panel...Don't know if it's standard calibration or faulty panel but yeah...really hard to look at numerous dark mode apps because they're so...not dark. Blacks look black though.
I observed the same on my Pixel 5, I 'm coming from Pixel 2 XL. I like saturated look on my Pixel 2 XL, but now I got used to Pixel 5 colors - Adaptive color profile
gargeya_369 said:
I observed the same on my Pixel 5, I 'm coming from Pixel 2 XL. I like saturated look on my Pixel 2 XL, but now I got used to Pixel 5 colors - Adaptive color profile
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your reply
It's really bad in some apps like Discord...makes it very difficult to look at especially when the brightness dips in low light.
Have you seen any other phones to compare to?
Since I've been using Android I've only used "pure google" devices...(Galaxy Nexus, Nexus 7 2012, Nexus 5, Nexus 7 2013, Pixel 2 and Pixel 5)...even my father has a Pixel 2...so yeah I have no other experience to compare it to, especially more modern phones
bleets said:
Thanks for your reply
It's really bad in some apps like Discord...makes it very difficult to look at especially when the brightness dips in low light.
Have you seen any other phones to compare to?
Since I've been using Android I've only used "pure google" devices...(Galaxy Nexus, Nexus 7 2012, Nexus 5, Nexus 7 2013, Pixel 2 and Pixel 5)...even my father has a Pixel 2...so yeah I have no other experience to compare it to, especially more modern phones
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately, I didn't get a chance to test with any other phones.
I also came from the Pixel 2 XL whose screen was ridiculously oversaturated. True, in direct comparison Pixel 5 looks "washed out" but this is much more true to life colors.
It's not the colours that bother me so much, more like the greys...
But lookibng at the XDA Pixel 5 display review, the Color temp is lower (warmer) and the Gamma is lower (lighter) which would very much explain.
6400K is just wrong for me to be honest! (and i personally prefer a higher gamma value but I'm odd like that)...
But mine being similar to the XDA review sample assumes calibration is the same across all models...I wonder!
But here with the Pixel 5’s minimum-brightness tone map curve, its 2.20 gamma power response may appear too light and washed out in dark environments.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I definitely notice that, the display gets much worse at low brightness so it needs to be cranked up a fair bit to uncomfortable levels in dark environments...
Still, I'm gonna go check out a couple of stores to see what other examples of he Pixel 5 are like...
Been going around a few stores today comparing my Pixel 5 with the display models...
The display models definitely have slightly darker blacks...
But then a difference is I have a Spigen screen protector on mine...
How much, if at all, would a tempered glass screen protector affect things? Would they make the greys look slightly lighter/washed out? Or is it differences in the panels?

Categories

Resources