I used Xposed a lot 10 years ago, but I don't remember much of that time. Is it still worth it? Do Xposed and the modules still work nicely with Android 9 and 10 ?
I am thinking about it, because I want to change the scroll behavior of Android, using an Xposed module. And maybe, to look around for other Xposed modules...
Magisk does not have many modules that interest me.
tomxyz said:
I used Xposed a lot 10 years ago, but I don't remember much of that time. Is it still worth it? Do Xposed and the modules still work nicely with Android 9 and 10 ?
I am thinking about it, because I want to change the scroll behavior of Android, using an Xposed module. And maybe, to look around for other Xposed modules...
Magisk does not have many modules that interest me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Using xposed is a personal choice.
I am using a samsung S8 on android 9 using about 12 modules.
Rovo's version of xposed only works up to android 8 ( oreo ).
For 8 and up you will have to use Edxposed.
Edxposed will require magisk to be installed.
Edxposed will require 3 components
Riru core - download through magisk
Riru Edxposed - download through magisk
Edxposed manager
XDA thread for edxposed
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/development/official-edxposed-successor-xposed-t4070199
As to what modules that work It a bit hard to say you will have to try them out. Early modules may not work properly since they haven't been updated to newer android versions.
All modules are downloaded from the xposed repository ( using edxposed manager or website ).
XDA thread for edxposed modules
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/06-nov-2019-list-xposed-modules-android-t3998427
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/list-xposed-modules-android-pie-ed-t3892768
Is VirtualXposed on the table by any chance?
I'm having noting but problems
I personally think the effort to get it running smoothly isn't worth it when Android 11 has exposed a few of the features that xposed granted users in the past. Also there are apps on the playstore and other sites that fill the gap to some degree.
One big one for me in the past was xposed edge, now I use edge gestures from the playstore, and it doesn't even require root let alone xposed.
Related
I'm on Pie. Xposed and Xtoast no longer works on Pie. XToast is Toast Notification personalization app. (Duration, Style, Height, Color)
So anyone have suggestion XToast like module for Magisk?
I only needed for disable toast notifications for specific apps.
Thanks.
No... That's quite outside the scope for what Magisk can do with it's module, but it happens to be exactly what Xposed is for. So, if you don't have Xposed you'd have to find some other means of achieving the same (or similar) goal. But not with Magisk.
Think of Magisk like a file injector, where you just mount new files into the system (without touching it), and Xposed as a code injector, where the running code is altered on the go. Two quite different things...
You can of course make a Magisk module that mounts a modified apk over the stock one, where you have disabled toast notifications for that particular app, but that would be extremely cumbersome and not really feasible.
I get it. Thanks ?
emreceleke said:
I get it. Thanks ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have EdXposed and XToast functioning on S7 with custom ROM.
Nir.Hendin said:
I have EdXposed and XToast functioning on S7 with custom ROM.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
android version? rom name? edxposed version?
Hi
I have Android 9.0 Pie,
BlackDiamond N8 v2
EdXposedInstaller_v2.2.5-release
Riru_-_Core-v19.5(27)
Riru_-_EdXposed-v0.4.5.1_beta(4463)_(YAHFA)(4463)
Functions as well on Android 10.0 Q with FloydQ v7 for S7
Later versions of Riru requires dev mods of the Xposed modules and as Xtoast is no longer maintained you must stay on a lower version of Riru for it to function.
I love it as well, but had to giv Xposed up to get som apps to function. :-(
Thanks...all good things must come to an end except one....
removed
I preferred Magisk, because it is very stable while does not depend to system.
pol-der said:
Hi All,
Hope you are fine. I have some questions mates. Now i had installed Xposed Framework before Magisk and it is still installed. I realized (from Downloads) Magisk has Xposed Framework module.
Should i uninstall Xposed Framework from phone and install from Magisk?
If yes, why?
If i use Xposed Framework standalone (without Magisk), what is advantages and disadvantages?
Thank you so much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If your current version is working then there is no real reason to change. I have rovo's version 89 and magisk separate on my s8 with no issues. Basically it boils down to personal preference. I like to keep root and exposed separate in case of issues with one or the other. In any case if there are issues with exposed then it will happen on any version that you install.
As I've said it's all a matter of personal preference.
removed
magisk does not have xposed module ?
Well before Magisk was in our lives, the Xposed framework was where all the mods and magic happened.
Ed Xposed Developers Solohsu, givien2u, riru core developer Rikka released beta version that supports Android 10 also now, so It may now be compatible with Android 10, but there are still some bugs to be worked out — So this thread is all in one place for find the modules
For Pie Supported modules Refer the thread - https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/list-xposed-modules-android-pie-ed-t3892768
IMP Note For Android 10 - Need to download a separate beta version of the EdXposed module instead of using the one from the Magisk Manager app. Not sure why latest beta not added in Magisk repo.
Riru Core
Riru Edxposed
Xposed Installer
Users can try and comment supported modules in comments section.I will regularly update the thread so this list which makes it lot easier for all the xposed Android 10 users.
WORKING MODULES:
App Locale 2
afwall+
Dark Tricks
Exi for swiftkey
Fingerprint pay
Gravity Box
instaprefs (initial release)
lataclysm
MinMinGuard
SudoHide
Tweeks (initial release)
WaTweaker
XPrivacyLua
UNCONFIRMED MODULES
100M+ memory saver
Always Correct
Android App theme engine
App settings*
ART Deoptimiser
Blur System UI*
Boot Manager
Buttered toast
Complete Action Plus
CustomShare
Enhanced Toast
Fingerprint quick actions
Flat style keyboard
Flat Style Module
FM Radio Without Headphones
Force Fast Scroll
Force touch detector
FSCB
G3 TweakToolbox
Google Offline Voice
HTC One Tweaker
Installer Opt
InstantFaceUnlock
KT2
L Tweaks
Lockscreen clock mods
Neo power menu*
Net strength
Network Speed Indicator for OnePlus
No Keyboard Auto Popup
No Lock Home
No More Google Play Services
Notify Clean
Prevent Running*
Remember IME
RootToolsNeo
ScreenOff Animation
Swipe Back2
WhatsApp Extensions
WhatsApp theme engine
X Halo Floating Windows
XGram
Xposed Additions
Xposed Groot
Xposed macro expand
XQS Backgrounds
Xstana
Xvoice changer
At the time of writing this thread, Gravitybox only supported for Q
Imp Note for Oneplus users who are trying to root and stuck at bootloop/fastboot message after android 10 update
Oneplus has blocked fastboot boot command so there is a details guide available in the thread - https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-6/how-to/how-to-flash-twrp-magisk-android-10-t3988213
My module (Dark Tricks) works on Android Q too.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/modules/mod-dark-tricks-t3750586/amp/
I have these modules working well on my pixel 3 with November updates.
0455 beta YAHFA +Riru-core 19.5 + latest custom magisk
CustoMIUIzer (For MIUI) (some mods doesn't work but 95% of them are working)
Sudohide 1.28 (or you can try 1.28.3 modded version by Mikanoshi)
Keyboard animation tweak
unclutter IG
These are working fine on my Xiaomi Mi 9T MIUI 11 based on Android 10 rom
with official Magisk 20.1 and Modded Sandhook (tried Yahfa also working) 4471 by Dark_Eyes_
Even these modules are compatible to android 10, they may have failed at Safetynet check !!
So carefully if you're using google pay...
Kris
Confirm this modules is work on Android 10
Exi for swiftkey
SudoHide
i'm using riru core 19.5, edxposed v0.4.6.0 yahfa, edxposed installer 2.2.5:
xprivacylua, greenify, gravitybox does NOT work
afwall+ works
It is supposed to use edxposed manager with latest exposed build?
Build 0455 YAHFA here, gravitybox works
anonxlg said:
i'm using riru core 19.5, edxposed v0.4.6.0 yahfa, edxposed installer 2.2.5:
xprivacylua, greenify, gravitybox does NOT work
afwall+ works
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
xprivacylua don't work
10.0.0 (QQ1A.191205.011, Dec 2019), riru core 19.5, edxposed v0.4.6.0 yahfa or sandhook, edxposed installer 2.2.5
bush911 said:
It is supposed to use edxposed manager with latest exposed build?
Build 0455 YAHFA here, gravitybox works
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
bush911 said:
It is supposed to use edxposed manager with latest exposed build?
Build 0455 YAHFA here, gravitybox works
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
not sure what you mean but:
v0.4.6.0_beta
@solohsu solohsu released this Oct 21, 2019 · 7 commits to master since this release
Changelogs
Add support for Android 10
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also tried installing xprivacylua and it wouldn't install (it downloads and then it just stops)
njtony said:
xprivacylua don't work
10.0.0 (QQ1A.191205.011, Dec 2019), riru core 19.5, edxposed v0.4.6.0 yahfa or sandhook, edxposed installer 2.2.5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
XPrivacyLua works for many people on Android 10.
M66B said:
XPrivacyLua works for many people on Android 10.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
XPrivacyLua is works now
edxposed v0.4.6.0 yahfa does not work
edxposed v0.4.5.5 yahfa works fine
Modules List Update
Alltrans, MinMinGuard, HiddenCore, and Xposed Edge confirmed working on Q.
Soumy1234 said:
Alltrans, MinMinGuard, HiddenCore, and Xposed Edge confirmed working on Q.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What version of min min? And what versions of the edxposed zips?
CounterC said:
What version of min min? And what versions of the edxposed zips?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Latest version of MinMin (2.1.1) and Edxposed 0.4.6.1 (4491) from Canary tab of Edxposed Manager.
Soumy1234 said:
Latest version of MinMin (2.1.1) and Edxposed 0.4.6.1 (4491) from Canary tab of Edxposed Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what went wrong here?
CounterC said:
what went wrong here?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you install the Riru Core Magisk Module?
Hi guys. I'm about to get this phone soon so coming from s9 plus (rootedwith xposed framework on android 8.0) I was wondering what's the status on this phone as far as xposed framework is concerned?
I don't see much people talking about it for this phone.
A few modules are a must have for me to the point of losing OTA or not having the latest OS doesn't bother me.
Modules I use:
Chromepie
Chrome selection patch
Exi for swiftkey
Undo
Wifi password
Gesture Navigation
Xposed edge pro
Text Aide.
omar.abbas said:
Hi guys. I'm about to get this phone soon so coming from s9 plus (rootedwith xposed framework on android 8.0) I was wondering what's the status on this phone as far as xposed framework is concerned?
I don't see much people talking about it for this phone.
A few modules are a must have for me to the point of losing OTA or not having the latest OS doesn't bother me.
Modules I use:
Chromepie
Chrome selection patch
Exi for swiftkey
Undo
Wifi password
Gesture Navigation
Xposed edge pro
Text Aide.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I recently gave EdXposed a try and it worked just fine. I only wanted it for gravity box and most of the functionality there worked without issues.
I can't speak for the rest of the modules but this phone is almost entirely AOSP so most should work.
gilsol said:
I recently gave EdXposed a try and it worked just fine. I only wanted it for gravity box and most of the functionality there worked without issues.
I can't speak for the rest of the modules but this phone is almost entirely AOSP so most should work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you use magisk to install it as a magisk module?
When I search for edxposed on magisk I see two versions I'm wondering which one to go with.
omar.abbas said:
Did you use magisk to install it as a magisk module?
When I search for edxposed on magisk I see two versions I'm wondering which one to go with.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's a dedicated thread for this from the magisk module info page. First install Riru core and then one of the 2 Riru edexposed modules. They differ in implementation. I used Sandhook method.
Xprivacy Lua doesn't seem to be working on Android 11 AOSP based custom ROM.
Installed using LSposed.
App ops also doesn't seem to be working.
Any workaround?
Sjain11 said:
Xprivacy Lua doesn't seem to be working on Android 11 AOSP based custom ROM.
Installed using LSposed.
App ops also doesn't seem to be working.
Any workaround?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you explain more as to what is not working.
Device and what rom your using may help.
How have you setup lsposed. If you are going to set restriction in xpl for all apps have you selected all apps in lsposed.
What app ops are you using as wasn't aware it an exposed module.
spawnlives said:
Can you explain more as to what is not working.
Device and what rom your using may help.
How have you setup lsposed. If ypu are going to set restriction in xpl for all apps have you selected all apps in lsposed.
What app ops are you using as wasn't aware it an exposed module.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow thanks. Selecting all apps in LSposed worked.
Hi, I just had the same problem and found this thread and resolved the issue, thanks!
Question: Is there a way to default so that new apps are automatically selected when installed?
markd89 said:
Hi, I just had the same problem and found this thread and resolved the issue, thanks!
Question: Is there a way to default so that new apps are automatically selected when installed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On LSposed no.
Any new app will have to be enabled in LSposed for xprivacylua to work.
I don't think that option will be included any time soon, if at all.
spawnlives said:
On LSposed no.
Any new app will have to be enabled in LSposed for xprivacylua to work.
I don't think that option will be included any time soon, if at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think that's an important capablilty, otherwise things will leak on first run.
I tried installed Edxposed but get this issue please install riru from magisk manager
The comments on that issue say Edxposed is not longer supported ant to use LSPosed, Taichi or Dreamland instead. Does Taichi or Dreamland allow for new apps to default to be restricted?
Thanks again!
markd89 said:
I think that's an important capablilty, otherwise things will leak on first run.
I tried installed Edxposed but get this issue please install riru from magisk manager
The comments on that issue say Edxposed is not longer supported ant to use LSPosed, Taichi or Dreamland instead. Does Taichi or Dreamland allow for new apps to default to be restricted?
Thanks again!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want to use Edxposed you will have to downgrade Rui core module ( in magisk ) to version under 25. I think the latest working version was 25.5.5 ( from memory ).
As for Taichi, Dreamland and other Xposed like frameworks i don't know never used them.
I have be using Xposed since the Jellybean ( android 4 ) and have only install rovo's version ( up to android 8 ), then started using Edxposed ( currently on now ). The only reason i'm not using Lsposed at the moment is laziness on my part because of the extra steps involved.
Note: not all modules will require every app in Lsposed to be activated it will depend on what the module does.
@spawnlives thank you!
I got Edxposed working with Riru 25.4.4 https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/releases/tag/v25.4.4
To use XprivacyLua on Android 11 - Which one should I get ?
Edxposed or Lsposed ?
JazonX said:
To use XprivacyLua on Android 11 - Which one should I get ?
Edxposed or Lsposed ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Depends on magisk version
I am using stable magisk with latest versions of riu and lsposed.
Lsposed with modules you have to select what apps to restrict.
Big thanks to @Fif_ for automatic selecting modules.
Edxpoesd has two modes but you have to downgrade riu module for it it work.
With regards to expricavylua working fine on stable magisk /latest versions of riu/lsposed on S9 running lineage 18.1 (A11).
spawnlives said:
Depends on magisk version
I am using stable magisk with latest versions of riu and lsposed.
Lsposed with modules you have to select what apps to restrict.
Big thanks to @Fif_ for automatic selecting modules.
Edxpoesd has two modes but you have to downgrade riu module for it it work.
With regards to expricavylua working fine on stable magisk /latest versions of riu/lsposed on S9 running lineage 18.1 (A11).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For reference the post about automatically adding newly installed apps to LSPosed scopes is here:
LSPosed Xposed Framework [8.1-13.0]. Simple Magisk Module
Developers: LSPosed Developers Homepage: GitHub ✱ Requirements: • Magisk 21+ • Android 8.1-13 • Riru(NOT NEEDED) USE ZYGISK Description: Riru module providing ART interception framework (natively for Android Pie) that provides consistent API...
forum.xda-developers.com
markd89 said:
@spawnlives thank you!
I got Edxposed working with Riru 25.4.4 https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/releases/tag/v25.4.4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
JazonX said:
To use XprivacyLua on Android 11 - Which one should I get ?
Edxposed or Lsposed ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
spawnlives said:
Depends on magisk version
I am using stable magisk with latest versions of riu and lsposed.
Lsposed with modules you have to select what apps to restrict.
Big thanks to @Fif_ for automatic selecting modules.
Edxpoesd has two modes but you have to downgrade riu module for it it work.
With regards to expricavylua working fine on stable magisk /latest versions of riu/lsposed on S9 running lineage 18.1 (A11).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As stated in post #8 EdXposed is also working with stable Magisk v23.0, but only using Riru 25.4.4 and lower. Advantage for me is that I don't have to add new apps to the scope like in Lsposed. Even with Fif's Automate flow, I would forget to reboot