Database Develop

App crashed after hide on Magisk 17.1

Again I face a problem, now if I hide any application the application doesn't work or open, every time it crashed.
My device: Honor 8

This is happening with me on LG G6. Hide is enabled in options and when I want to enter Magisk Hide to enable it then Magisk crashes.

Logs?

Aid777 said:
This is happening with me on LG G6. Hide is enabled in options and when I want to enter Magisk Hide to enable it then Magisk crashes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had that problem on LG V30. I reverted to 16.0 with Manager 5.9.1, and the problem persisted. I then downgraded Manager to 5.8.3, and it's working fine again with the older version of Manager.

MechanicaIMan said:
I had that problem on LG V30. I reverted to 16.0 with Manager 5.9.1, and the problem persisted. I then downgraded Manager to 5.8.3, and it's working fine again with the older version of Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
5.9.1 seems to be 17.0 zip. I assume you meant that
5.8.3 is 16.7
When you downgrade do you just flash the zip or do you need to uninstall the 17.1 Magisk then flash this downgraded one?

I'm getting this exact same issue, I've attached logcat and magisk logs after hiding the Play Store with Magisk Hide, then attempting to open it (and having it immediately crash). Magisk 17.1, latest Magisk Manager app, Pixel 2XL, Oreo 8.1 (July patch). Apps open again after deselecting them from Magisk Hide. Was working fine on 16.4, stopped working after 17.1, and a complete Magisk uninstall/reinstall did not fix it.
Magisk Log, Logcat.

Aid777 said:
5.9.1 seems to be 17.0 zip. I assume you meant that
5.8.3 is 16.7
When you downgrade do you just flash the zip or do you need to uninstall the 17.1 Magisk then flash this downgraded one?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the problem after updating from 16.0 with 5.8.3 to 17.1 with 5.9.1, but I also tried using the newest manager with 16.0, and that didn't work either. So there must be some kind of issue with the newest version(s) of the manager. I completely uninstalled 17.1, flashed 16.0, updated manager to 5.9.1 (crashing returned), then uninstalled 5.9.1 and installed the 5.8.3 apk without changing Magisk. If you have 17.1 installed now, then you might want to try just replacing manager with an older version before you bother with completely uninstalling/downgrading Magisk. You can simply uninstall the manager app without uninstalling Magisk, but I don't know if Magisk 17 will work okay with the older versions of manager, since I haven't tried that myself and don't really know anything about Magisk.

It is the same with me

Google Play Store crashed

Same here guys with LG g6, I installed the 17.1 by direct installation (within the app) and then when I go to magisk hide, it keeps crashing!

I've had the exact same experience as @mechanicalman on my V30+ (US998).

Any solution guys.

same with me, would appreciate somebody to have a look.

Magisk Hide tickboxes in Magisk Manager make Oreo crash
Hi, same with me: Oneplus3 with stock OOS 5.0.5 (oreo), dm-verity warning at boot since when I was a superSU user.
Everything was fine with Magisk 16. Since update to 17.1 and MagiskManager 5.9.1, the Magisk Hide menu keeps crashing. I've reflashed the stock ROM, reinstalled magisk 16 and 17.1, used the magisk deinstaller. The problem seems tied with MagiskManager 5.9.1
- In the MagiskHide menu, sometimes I can check 5 to 10 apps before it crashes.
- In the MagiskHide menu, sometimes only 1 check or 1 uncheck makes the phone crash.
When MagiskHide crashes it:
- blacks out the screen for a few seconds
- then starts a reboot (a soft reboot where I am not asked my device password, which I have set to be asked during boot)
- then it eventually launches Android after a very long time (usually OOS 5.0.5 opens after 20 cycles of the animation, but after a MagiskHide crash, it can take 200 cycles (from which I stop counting))
I attached the Magisk log immediately after reboot, which doesn't say much (some lines similar to previous and following ones removed).
MagiskManager: "Preserve force encryption" is on (default), "Preserve AVB 2.0/dm-verity" is off (default), Modulues are Busybox, MM for recovery, Xposed, YouTube Vanced, rest of settings are default.
I hope that helps narrowing down the problem.

I'm coming here with this issue occurring on my LG V30+ and Magisk 17.1

Hi, I'm having the same problem as a couple of people, magisk 17.1, newest Magisk Manager, then when I try to go into the magisk hide menu, the app crashes to home screen.
I enabled core only mode to see if it was any of my modules but the problem persists.

lenovo p2 same problem of manager crashing when entering hide menu

Same problem on my Nexus 5, Dirty Unicorn with Oreo 8.1

Same problem here on the V30+. Anyone able to confirm downgrading works?
Also, what do most of y'all use hide for? I was gonna try to use it to set up chase pay for that 5% rewards. lol

Didgeridoohan said:
Logs?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk Manager v6.0.0, OOS9.0 OnePlus 6. App crashes while opening Magisk hide menu. Thanks

OnePlus7T / Magisk crashing when opened / Replace Canary to stable

I am having OnePlus7T which does not have TWRP. Magisk was installed through patched boot image while rooting many months back. At that time Canary version was recommended and I had installed that.
I have updated the ROM, Magisk Manager and Magisk in these months via OTA.
Everything works except this app, https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=in.org.npci.upiapp&hl=en. It detects even though hidden with MagisK Hide. Magisk package manager is also hidden but this app does not work. It opens, registers the user but later detects root.
Since last few days Magisk is crashing when opened for no apparent reason. Restarting the phone didn't make any difference. If I long click on the app and select Magisk Hids or Supeuser or Modules it opens but when I try to go to main Manager screen it crashes. How to resolve this? Phone is still working as intended and I have root access for apps not hidden in Magisk Hide.
How do I update Manager from Canary to Stable? Can I just download a stable Manager apk and install it on top of the Canary? Which version should be used? Will Magisk also need to be installed again? Will I lose root?
Can anyone explain the steps in detail as I am bit confused.

My Magisk also crash like this

Has Google disabled Magisk?

I installed a new ROM on my tablet and couldn't get Magisk to work, so I restored the ROM I was using previously. But Magisk wasn't working in it anymore. In researching the problem, it seems that Google has not only removed Magisk Manager from the Play Store, but also found a way to keep previously installed Magisk from granting root privileges.

lewmur said:
I installed a new ROM on my tablet and couldn't get Magisk to work, so I restored the ROM I was using previously. But Magisk wasn't working in it anymore. In researching the problem, it seems that Google has not only removed Magisk Manager from the Play Store, but also found a way to keep previously installed Magisk from granting root privileges.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't get Magisk from the playstore but from the Magisk thread.
Magisk
Magisk - The Universal Systemless Interface, to create an altered mask of the system without changing the system itself.
forum.xda-developers.com

Tulsadiver said:
You don't get Magisk from the playstore but from the Magisk thread.
Magisk
Magisk - The Universal Systemless Interface, to create an altered mask of the system without changing the system itself.
forum.xda-developers.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you read my later post you'll see that I found that out and tried it. None of the versions work with the ROM based on Android 11. I have always just installed an the latest version Magisk.zip I happen to have handy and let it install Magisk Manager. Then I'd use Magisk Manager to update Magisk. That didn't work with the Android 11 ROM either. The update failed and the older version didn't root.

[Guide][A8-12] Banking Apps while being rooted

Hide Root from Apps e.g. Banking Apps​NOTICE (24.11.22): Updated thread​Info: I'm sharing my take on how to get S-Pushtan Banking App to work with Magisk, or any other App of your Choice. (Greatly inspired by searching on the internet)
Works for:​- Android 8-12
List of apps known to work:​- S-Pushtan, Sparkasse, Sundhedskortet, Keytrade Ban
What you need:​- Magisk 25.1
- DenylistUnmount Magisk Module | Download on Github or use shamiko module
- Universal Safetynet Fix Magisk Module | Download on Github
- MagiskHidePropsConfig | Download on Github
- Airfrozen App v1.2.8 | Download on Github
- optional: Yasnac (Safetynet Checker) | Google Play
Pre-Requisites:​- Have Magisk 25.1 installed
Step by Step Guide:​0. Install Magisk via Recovery and reboot
1. Go into settings of your Magisk Manager and
- enable "Hide Magisk Manager" , type in a name you want for the hidden app.
- open the new app and enable in settings: "Zygisk", then in "Configure DenyList"
- Select any app you want hide root from (for example your banking app)
(Make sure that for every App, all processes are also choosen. If you did everything correctly the colored bar should be full)
1.1.1 Disable "Enforce DenyList"
1.2 Install DenyListUnmount or latest Shamiko Module, Universal Safetynet Fix via Magisk Manager and Reboot to activate the modules
Reboot again.
1.2.1 Check that your Safetynet Status Pass both times via Yasnac App
- If you don't pass the Check, install the MagiskHidePropsConfig Module via Magisk Manager and Reboot to activate the module
- Configure your fingerprint to your phones or a Google Pixel's and reboot again -> do Step 1.2.1
2. Install Airfrozen (grant root permission)
2.1 in Airfrozen: Select your renamed Magisk App and your Banking App (example: Sparkasse, Google Pay)
2.1.1 In Airfrozen: Settings->General->Auto freeze
Enable "Freeze on exit" and "Not Freeze foreground"; Set Freeze on locked to 1 minute;
2.1.2 Optional: If you want a open (also unfreeze) your Magisk Manager/ Banking while they are disabled to use them; longpress the apps in airfrozen und create a shortcut for easy use
2.2 Setup your Banking Apps now, while the MagiskManager is disabled and undetectable.
4. Done!
CHECKLIST:​- Magisk installed and Zygisk enabled, App is hidden
- Your Banking App is selected in Airfrozen and XPrivacyLua, and MagiskManagers Denylist
- Your Magisk App is selected in Airfrozen
- Remember the usage rules(below)
IMPORTANT RULES FOR USAGE:​1. Always freeze the Magisk App before using your banking App! Vice-Versa
2. In the case that it does get detected -> Force Close your Banking App and clear the cache.
This Method should work with most Apps right now that are detecting root
It's a trial and error situation so try your best, also give some feedback for others as to which apps work and which won't.
I hope this will help some people out there.
Stay healthy!

Thank you very much.
I can confirm this ist working with:
S-PushTAN Version: 3.4.0
Magisk Version: 23.0
Airfrozen 1.6.2 (143)
on latest ArrowOS (Android 11)

Thank you very much.
I can confirm this ist working with:
S-PushTAN Version: 3.4.0
Magisk Version: 23.0
Airfrozen 1.6.2 (143)
on latest ArrowOS (Android 11)

Ice Box is also working fine if you need an alternative.

@sm00th4f3
Thanks a lot, this method also works for these two banking apps

Still a very nice and working workaround

Nice Nice, works on my device!
Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 Pro (begonia)
Android 11 Stock, Miui 12.5.4 Global (RGGEUXM)
Magisk v23
S-Pushtan v. 3.5.1
Can't belive its working. Big Thanks!

Thanks working on rooted pixel 6 pro !! S Pushtan from Starfinance is not detecting Magisk ! Thanks for your work

After completed all the steps, app still complain.
One extra step for me is to also delete the "TWRP official app" (which I decide to randomly installed it back when I rooted my phone)
And citibank app can now open.
Redmi Note 10 pro on MIUI Global 12.5.9 (boot loader unlocked, rooted)

Wappenull said:
After completed all the steps, app still complain.
One extra step for me is to also delete the "TWRP official app" (which I decide to randomly installed it back when I rooted my phone)
And citibank app can now open.
Redmi Note 10 pro on MIUI Global 12.5.9 (boot loader unlocked, rooted)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What magisk Version do you use?

I've installed LineageOS on S8 and the S-ID-Check app complains about a rooted device. Now that Magisk Hide isn't available any more (v24.3), is there any other way to make the banking app work?

Edit: updated thread

will it cause any issue if i reboot the phone with magisk frozen ?

naveen_reloaded said:
will it cause any issue if i reboot the phone with magisk frozen ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope. You are only freezing the magisk manager app. The root itself is still in place
I have a up to date guide in the works. Stay tuned.

UPDATE: Refreshed the Guide to latest Magisk Stable and with easier instructions... Cheers!​
I am using my phone rooted again, as you can probably guess

Not working
I use the Bank Austria App...

Edit: removed list of not working apps

Not working neoBT app (Banca Transilvania Romania).

Dude here is a modified of the module this is working perfectly
https://forum.xda-developers.com/attachments/safetynet-fix-v2-3-1-mod-zip.5670155/

xerel89 said:
Dude here is a modified of the module this is working perfectly
https://forum.xda-developers.com/attachments/safetynet-fix-v2-3-1-mod-zip.5670155/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
!To everyone: Don't use this. Use the official version.

Settings App (Hidden Magisk Manager) keeps crashing

Hi there,
i used Magisk with a hidden Magisk Manager (As "Settings" in the app drawer) and i got a update notification about a new Magisk version. I updated and afterwards i read Magisk Manager is dead and isn't used anymore. When i now click on "Settings" it force closes and i can't open Magisk. What can i do now?
Device is a Oneplus 7t Pro with Stock rom.
Thanks

Try reinstalling magisk through recovery. Works for me on my Pixel 3 running LOS18. 1. Just flash the magisk zip through twrp or whatever you have.
Shouldn't be necessary to hide the magisk app. I have Gpay etc working nicely with the magisk app not hidden. Unless of course there's some other app you're running that won't work without magisk being hidden?

Okay i try to reinstall it but i think i'll wait for Android 12 to come and then start from scratch. Magisk Hide or at least hiding root is necessary for my banking app.

Same happened to me. Oneplus 8T with Android 11.